{ "schema": 1, "kind": "completed_frozen_bba", "report_id": "das-bba-frozen-20260917-scribe", "published_scope": "Self-run DAS audio reasoning evaluation; not an official Artificial Analysis result.", "created_at": "2026-09-17T19:04:47.779745+00:00", "complete": true, "dataset": { "name": "ArtificialAnalysis/big_bench_audio", "revision": "af7bb9c25b015792583ca4da3ee27ec62cb79fe6", "metadata_sha256": "102a7de908f466f6c415042033e11dc8cfcd73e4687d3a00d0fe5b25b0517657", "manifest_sha256": "9834f2690bf3ffa729ee129b013e403d2467e3064102a9527b8a5aa2643d1a65", "selected": 1000, "per_category": 250 }, "freeze_sha256": "b668590f9c7830248b4a5c38c07476c26563495445a71b56cc96c2560d1c0781", "configuration_sha256": "ea690a80735777443cac6bae4a9273fbc63f263cfc9947e2c78c855140fbccf9", "configuration": { "label": "DAS Voice development: seat-backed Opus and local speech", "foreground": { "model": "claude-opus-4-8", "runtime": "Claude Code subscription", "thinking": "enabled", "effort": "high", "tools": false, "gateway_fallback": false, "answer_timeout_seconds": 120 }, "support": { "enabled": false }, "audio": { "input_asr": "ensemble:scribe_v1+large-v3", "output_asr": "small.en", "tts": "Piper en_US-lessac-low", "format": "PCM16 mono 24000Hz", "input_transcripts": "ElevenLabs Scribe v1 prepared on the host by bba_scribe.py, pinned to each WAV hash; the worker makes no network call" }, "source_sha256": { "bba_development.py": "ed17ede7136b939d75a4125f56ff9b09d661ca2489a7183319eea326e7bbbd06", "bba_seat.py": "8be404e4ac5ee8a0156cd1b299a4ad38ace2a53d29a0badfcd5d2ca305e726b6", "bba_gateway.py": "a675f418783a02230b9e84342e21e4429871c0f791750efa4cebc795d79d053b", "bba_local_audio.py": "92621819426a7fd3bf621313ee06139beab1fadf9ebdfa3a2094f5f3216bfa44", "bba_scoring.py": "04665da7c31d2a01f2cef29b856c99f9fed253888f9785eec36a6f2f5cc5323b", "bba_manifest.py": "6ef4262ed3de9967606a369c52a968aa947556b3570b18ba13be1075176065b7", "claude_local.py": "6298d97fa8815ba32ff5773f9b46bfa2ffd1ca8926e4384914aac6cd6597849e", "claude_stream_process.py": "90632655bf9abe5fc9cbcb9c3db9506ced631e16bc27e16069dc95f20bd77ce7" }, "image": "sha256:e28b8d4230d92dcd74fb422eed827c1806387a40903ee7b4528a72051fca9765", "transport": "Offline cascaded audio; no phone carrier or simulated streaming clock", "latency_scope": "Processing after a complete input file is available; not PSTN TTFA", "ground_truth": "Scorer only; reasoner receives only independently recognized input speech", "audio_assets": { "input_model": "ensemble:scribe_v1+large-v3", "output_model": "small.en", "sample_rate": 24000, "device": "cpu", "compute_type": "int8", "piper_voice": "en_US-lessac-low", "piper_source_rate": 16000, "input_snapshot": "edaa852ec7e145841d8ffdb056a99866b5f0a478", "output_snapshot": "d1d751a5f8271d482d14ca55d9e2deeebbae577f", "input_weights_sha256": "69f74147e3334731bc3a76048724833325d2ec74642fb52620eda87352e3d4f1", "output_weights_sha256": "62b2a45b05ee59acb4a5341b33ee35e041395d378d418a18acfe4c9e768ee37a", "piper_weights_sha256": "f7d01dde371555732c4c314111ac79672b1a5ce2fc19266ab42178fd8df7f375", "input_config_sha256": "a9306624f5ec14270a014b647e5c316b6e03a662c369758d1b90697a7b0655b9", "output_config_sha256": "666a9605530ac1f61fa8177f3702b4dacec9966749e42610839fcc32661d5fae", "input_tokenizer_sha256": "6d8cbd7cd0d8d5815e478dac67b85a26bbe77c1f5e0c6d76d1ce2abc0e5f21ca", "output_tokenizer_sha256": "929c5252409436dce1b38a75d1abbcb5e132d170d8e324e4e04ed915fa2d22df", "piper_config_sha256": "45754dfdebb3b8661c3fc564713772deec6e064feeb5b4e9594857dc7305193a", "scribe_model_id": "scribe_v1" } }, "source_sha256": { "bba_development.py": "ed17ede7136b939d75a4125f56ff9b09d661ca2489a7183319eea326e7bbbd06", "bba_seat.py": "8be404e4ac5ee8a0156cd1b299a4ad38ace2a53d29a0badfcd5d2ca305e726b6", "bba_gateway.py": "a675f418783a02230b9e84342e21e4429871c0f791750efa4cebc795d79d053b", "bba_local_audio.py": "92621819426a7fd3bf621313ee06139beab1fadf9ebdfa3a2094f5f3216bfa44", "bba_scoring.py": "04665da7c31d2a01f2cef29b856c99f9fed253888f9785eec36a6f2f5cc5323b", "bba_manifest.py": "6ef4262ed3de9967606a369c52a968aa947556b3570b18ba13be1075176065b7", "claude_local.py": "6298d97fa8815ba32ff5773f9b46bfa2ffd1ca8926e4384914aac6cd6597849e", "claude_stream_process.py": "90632655bf9abe5fc9cbcb9c3db9506ced631e16bc27e16069dc95f20bd77ce7", "bba_frozen.py": "c7f03d1bd79a8dee9f001bc7b4938ae0502499c800a68dcbdefb775c2fe49515", "voice_benchmark.py": "31475ed1a969b3052a7823433453d8721ec9eb895b2c3c6905f5977eca02a4a9", "../../scripts/run-bba-development.sh": "3303d2a7b00eadff049952dbee41c6fa1c4affd8a45849ebecd3764dad7db186" }, "extra_audio_sha256": { "input_preprocessor_config.json": "7ccc62c6f2765af1f3b46c00c9b5894426835a05021c8b9c01eecb6dfb542711", "input_vocabulary.json": "c69260f2ab26d659b7c398f9a2b2b48ed0df16c3b47d7326782fd9cba71690c1", "input_vocabulary.txt": null, "output_preprocessor_config.json": null, "output_vocabulary.json": null, "output_vocabulary.txt": "ff77588746d3a2595d32ab5b69ffd7b95ce2441ac57533cb66fc3eb575a115cf" }, "image": "sha256:e28b8d4230d92dcd74fb422eed827c1806387a40903ee7b4528a72051fca9765", "prompt": { "text": "You are solving one spoken reasoning question. Your input is automatic speech transcription: punctuation and homophones may be mistaken. Reason privately and at whatever length you need. First resolve clearly unnatural phrasing using the spoken question's context, while preserving its stated facts, quantities and logical premises; do not invent missing information. Then check your reasoning. Your FINAL VISIBLE REPLY must be exactly \"The answer is X.\" and nothing else, where X is only yes, no, valid, invalid, or the number. Put no explanation, subject, restatement, markdown or filler in that visible reply. Never place reasoning, analysis, headings, bullet points or markdown in the visible reply; that content belongs only in your private reasoning. The visible reply is one sentence of at most ten words. You have no tools or outside context.", "sha256": "f4305b4e1e8c0e300e509833d6f10f4cd0ee98e11d4c27f21298754b0ce5a162" }, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "official_leaderboard_score": false, "original": { "selected": 1000, "correct": 990, "incorrect": 5, "needs_review": 5, "missing": 0, "complete": false, "percent": null }, "reviewed": { "selected": 1000, "correct": 995, "incorrect": 5, "needs_review": 0, "missing": 0, "complete": true, "percent": 99.5 }, "cohorts": { "development": { "count": 100, "case_ids": [ 101, 330, 562, 883, 49, 295, 676, 852, 245, 346, 741, 853, 29, 291, 665, 985, 19, 262, 646, 820, 14, 373, 503, 801, 156, 399, 554, 958, 204, 415, 726, 931, 180, 269, 509, 770, 97, 427, 739, 911, 155, 405, 704, 885, 171, 381, 639, 935, 224, 334, 581, 966, 44, 478, 647, 997, 54, 361, 528, 977, 208, 271, 505, 992, 52, 358, 531, 941, 48, 309, 578, 944, 217, 366, 740, 897, 168, 332, 615, 752, 234, 349, 628, 927, 56, 419, 663, 757, 122, 294, 730, 876, 1, 460, 535, 750, 126, 397, 715, 950 ], "original": { "selected": 100, "correct": 99, "incorrect": 0, "needs_review": 1, "missing": 0, "complete": false, "percent": null }, "reviewed": { "selected": 100, "correct": 100, "incorrect": 0, "needs_review": 0, "missing": 0, "complete": true, "percent": 100.0 } }, "heldout": { "count": 900, "case_ids": [ 93, 354, 670, 971, 106, 324, 524, 851, 76, 392, 656, 767, 220, 433, 666, 969, 138, 259, 561, 754, 191, 498, 577, 764, 213, 350, 735, 921, 68, 289, 604, 894, 188, 481, 631, 777, 173, 440, 720, 766, 46, 474, 695, 793, 137, 452, 537, 861, 146, 431, 626, 782, 240, 325, 584, 902, 31, 395, 556, 957, 209, 482, 544, 936, 215, 292, 644, 809, 107, 477, 737, 956, 78, 250, 705, 771, 197, 266, 533, 829, 221, 420, 684, 879, 229, 288, 699, 759, 77, 457, 671, 751, 41, 445, 592, 974, 248, 283, 746, 984, 239, 345, 674, 753, 114, 471, 575, 896, 21, 304, 694, 825, 162, 329, 658, 968, 28, 451, 609, 854, 211, 408, 645, 951, 139, 320, 688, 842, 222, 314, 698, 881, 144, 268, 501, 874, 123, 469, 732, 926, 47, 277, 722, 866, 148, 313, 669, 798, 202, 491, 721, 794, 92, 442, 624, 814, 169, 286, 683, 900, 27, 321, 590, 979, 135, 352, 734, 788, 88, 275, 617, 910, 83, 429, 582, 778, 121, 489, 738, 806, 111, 308, 611, 995, 133, 327, 690, 928, 233, 410, 729, 914, 238, 377, 571, 815, 192, 401, 523, 949, 102, 494, 500, 919, 125, 363, 662, 796, 120, 499, 619, 948, 104, 407, 588, 987, 216, 450, 553, 999, 117, 265, 586, 781, 51, 476, 686, 939, 67, 441, 731, 967, 119, 335, 616, 758, 12, 254, 560, 953, 203, 340, 659, 887, 226, 411, 550, 795, 170, 360, 548, 963, 2, 282, 558, 846, 70, 276, 650, 933, 145, 305, 713, 994, 72, 455, 710, 779, 18, 409, 685, 890, 140, 331, 733, 813, 185, 355, 701, 828, 198, 278, 716, 821, 13, 260, 612, 991, 3, 251, 602, 786, 200, 456, 653, 848, 11, 388, 534, 763, 212, 300, 717, 768, 79, 310, 714, 833, 73, 372, 660, 836, 147, 293, 598, 996, 80, 296, 632, 892, 24, 496, 568, 884, 34, 341, 516, 772, 0, 357, 515, 816, 103, 479, 512, 873, 142, 298, 510, 869, 9, 464, 627, 938, 98, 264, 718, 964, 109, 493, 569, 856, 136, 391, 675, 877, 25, 344, 546, 835, 22, 421, 712, 840, 196, 438, 623, 905, 193, 384, 608, 862, 152, 351, 618, 961, 57, 390, 725, 915, 223, 315, 657, 901, 61, 256, 538, 865, 225, 297, 633, 906, 236, 306, 687, 850, 55, 398, 610, 819, 150, 307, 506, 983, 176, 425, 707, 824, 177, 302, 696, 787, 178, 290, 736, 872, 110, 426, 679, 849, 85, 432, 570, 827, 130, 417, 591, 802, 160, 463, 522, 847, 141, 347, 532, 893, 154, 484, 680, 955, 112, 365, 559, 790, 165, 416, 552, 923, 235, 378, 508, 942, 91, 403, 542, 826, 96, 270, 583, 965, 33, 376, 587, 784, 30, 263, 607, 924, 157, 369, 594, 839, 158, 359, 579, 889, 38, 387, 511, 972, 143, 404, 545, 837, 175, 423, 597, 925, 6, 443, 526, 978, 63, 473, 573, 807, 149, 362, 708, 761, 129, 252, 667, 898, 230, 435, 640, 918, 190, 436, 649, 954, 232, 279, 638, 804, 189, 326, 747, 982, 151, 490, 595, 895, 69, 470, 697, 776, 45, 394, 517, 932, 199, 287, 520, 945, 127, 343, 557, 830, 15, 439, 601, 769, 128, 364, 614, 903, 81, 285, 743, 783, 37, 414, 629, 981, 35, 495, 605, 868, 181, 368, 620, 823, 53, 339, 681, 867, 172, 430, 502, 756, 179, 467, 682, 986, 4, 353, 678, 810, 166, 462, 630, 916, 60, 497, 745, 864, 153, 281, 565, 803, 99, 466, 648, 789, 241, 319, 742, 912, 17, 428, 519, 822, 95, 272, 636, 976, 5, 434, 702, 934, 65, 393, 723, 930, 59, 383, 599, 875, 62, 400, 677, 834, 74, 458, 637, 831, 227, 389, 576, 907, 7, 267, 673, 908, 113, 273, 589, 990, 115, 422, 621, 792, 231, 301, 622, 797, 124, 374, 596, 998, 8, 483, 703, 917, 43, 342, 655, 808, 87, 485, 574, 844, 118, 375, 563, 765, 75, 413, 661, 952, 242, 333, 555, 904, 237, 253, 529, 973, 116, 380, 536, 993, 247, 338, 606, 760, 39, 396, 651, 845, 89, 424, 748, 899, 82, 382, 625, 922, 16, 255, 539, 755, 105, 299, 507, 888, 132, 492, 643, 988, 32, 318, 693, 762, 159, 258, 689, 841, 182, 487, 567, 940, 210, 488, 672, 878, 20, 274, 668, 975, 10, 386, 711, 870, 94, 449, 564, 800, 214, 437, 744, 863, 40, 284, 634, 838, 84, 448, 641, 960, 244, 371, 749, 791, 23, 317, 540, 937, 195, 348, 547, 880, 108, 461, 585, 929, 90, 486, 709, 860, 50, 459, 635, 886, 64, 406, 514, 805, 249, 322, 652, 920, 184, 446, 728, 871, 134, 257, 700, 799, 186, 447, 580, 843, 206, 367, 541, 909, 58, 444, 518, 774, 218, 337, 572, 832, 183, 311, 600, 947, 205, 385, 724, 855, 228, 303, 521, 882, 243, 465, 504, 946, 194, 472, 543, 773, 163, 336, 654, 913, 86, 412, 527, 859, 71, 475, 664, 970, 207, 453, 719, 943, 164, 261, 727, 959, 161, 454, 603, 817, 246, 316, 530, 780, 167, 280, 692, 989, 174, 312, 691, 891, 100, 468, 513, 818, 187, 480, 642, 980, 131, 370, 566, 775, 201, 418, 551, 858, 36, 379, 549, 785, 26, 328, 613, 962, 66, 356, 593, 857, 219, 323, 706, 811, 42, 402, 525, 812 ], "original": { "selected": 900, "correct": 891, "incorrect": 5, "needs_review": 4, "missing": 0, "complete": false, "percent": null }, "reviewed": { "selected": 900, "correct": 895, "incorrect": 5, "needs_review": 0, "missing": 0, "complete": true, "percent": 99.44444444444444 } } }, "cases": [ { "id": 101, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5eac95d02f29fb4f218149be58b331daf5fdb6e77d3d1f67a1590f504fa7d4fc", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5eac95d02f29fb4f218149be58b331daf5fdb6e77d3d1f67a1590f504fa7d4fc", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First premise, some frequent consumer of Kiss My Face soap is not an infrequent user of AXE shampoo. Second premise, being a frequent consumer of Kiss My Face soap is necessary for being a regular user of Sexy Hair shampoo. Hence, not every infrequent user of AXE shampoo is a regular user of Sexy Hair shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First premise, some frequent consumer of Kiss My Face Soap is not an infrequent user of AXE Shampoo. Second premise, being a frequent consumer of Kiss My Face Soap is necessary for being a regular user of Sexy Hair Shampoo. Hence, not every infrequent user of AXE Shampoo is a regular user of Sexy Hair Shampoo. poo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11674.56, "reasoner_ms": 8137.51, "tts_ms": 34.08, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 19846.17, "total_processing_ms": 20482.75 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1073, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 624 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "afb7c9eb1bc525c97047b71defee49fdbb0fef2460d02c4c1dce9fb6addd103e", "started_sha256": "5d7a582518d16313cc31417e34b2f5de997100e0c9441d774bdda9c762de0944", "original_grade_sha256": "aaec39b52bedeb3f77f112298f2f2998b32fd529abcbd531124772cdd35d45a6", "input_original_sha256": "afb7c9eb1bc525c97047b71defee49fdbb0fef2460d02c4c1dce9fb6addd103e", "input_wav_sha256": "037a6cfb4e1b959aa2cfa8f918b1ae769e3ce97a3036ca3cf1130af80767a808", "input_pcm_sha256": "402c3a1647618049f080dad99869e99605c3b189a8aa6fdcd194ce291c06faaf", "output_wav_sha256": "98e4681690fe9085158f28b9b6660019c480aceca35cf801d40d058462192258", "output_pcm_sha256": "2af3cadef65786d61eddd9a4bba463be37bb940bb2c3084de90aaeca0ab39a2d", "result_sha256": "4aa235f750e9597d1f87e00af18b2b89ba89a058289ccc6c54e0565e8042a17e" } }, { "id": 330, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ea445d59c7a8cddf5ed7131c36f272e56aaa4e5a59d295e68bc9e66a819d1516", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ea445d59c7a8cddf5ed7131c36f272e56aaa4e5a59d295e68bc9e66a819d1516", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn around. Turn left. Take one step. Take two steps. Turn around. Turn around. Turn around. Take three steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point, turn around, turn left, take one step, take two steps, turn around, turn around, turn around, take three steps, options, yes, no, answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4876.51, "reasoner_ms": 6136.81, "tts_ms": 25.06, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11038.41, "total_processing_ms": 11591.48 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 814, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 414 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "88152db87c14071b8dc8a17955141c0ab4b1f5649b5d04ee81f126517e3a0550", "started_sha256": "162b41aa405c4f7c20e96a1ab76de5d40b43c7f8f604ba9835a30904b96e70b2", "original_grade_sha256": "7b21bb07c40815e8140927f17d7394f1b633f90d5df08dcaf80b71207047b3e2", "input_original_sha256": "88152db87c14071b8dc8a17955141c0ab4b1f5649b5d04ee81f126517e3a0550", "input_wav_sha256": "a428c3971540387e3ccfea052af2fc6f5df84fae7d321b0dfe46d93795f2cfe6", "input_pcm_sha256": "39ff6a8976b90e129c563b0661166e0c5efddc9d7b163cff6426d53044dfd0b3", "output_wav_sha256": "72b2e5932e63e4b2a43665069f669764b029e603df6af0b78f2390bbe72adb5b", "output_pcm_sha256": "57e2b95030d4f59539f1a696eba6a9372efd3328d5a28594fef1dd7de1e151d9", "result_sha256": "ced788695432fa1c8c8fb5d9c7ab25502e4e43d1376a099258d474d9b42c627a" } }, { "id": 562, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d1b17c76e3072450c72b7e11dbb0bf572ac7359e56be4867f7df7ca136f430a6", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d1b17c76e3072450c72b7e11dbb0bf572ac7359e56be4867f7df7ca136f430a6", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a nectarine, two toasters, an orange, four peaches, an apple, a strawberry, and a plum. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a nectarine, two toasters, an orange, four peaches, an apple, a strawberry, and a plum. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 9.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4169.56, "reasoner_ms": 2187.72, "tts_ms": 26.98, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6384.28, "total_processing_ms": 6900.59 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 779, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 60 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e0775738c7f2c6424added7bb950857dcf348530049b7418258e4f83d8b7411e", "started_sha256": "277f74c02b132e5503671ed7bfe22b6b8be8f3ce7bc510c2171eb8f6c9b4167e", "original_grade_sha256": "9fce236435c272523b6e11bf76c0cead9b3748f7b75fdbaf6080044b66316cff", "input_original_sha256": "e0775738c7f2c6424added7bb950857dcf348530049b7418258e4f83d8b7411e", "input_wav_sha256": "5ddb25a34eb86e1f1424e1326c5e6463b6f11577e201840e0eee40bc6e346633", "input_pcm_sha256": "e07056aa323d61ce8a81f492b50f81398ad156e54271d2fc274214141a77ede4", "output_wav_sha256": "b9de6ec9027b47c878d379c97513e9c370cca16c83d340ad96b216ce1618fb16", "output_pcm_sha256": "05d688f2739505b9ef2d168a2dcb9eb0593dc0b7386b0c4d4f0e37ee82a41c07", "result_sha256": "684074d2eceed402c62a83d3d4d7573e66a55c045d80d4a1d39548187df0fa68" } }, { "id": 883, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b0fc8bcf2be9affca0c26778c816154d9c40f6e6ac34c4a155f13af2ef39d6d2", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b0fc8bcf2be9affca0c26778c816154d9c40f6e6ac34c4a155f13af2ef39d6d2", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Alejandro lies. Vena says Alejandro lies. Vernell says Vena tells the truth. Fidel says Vernell lies. Inga says Fidel tells the truth. Does Inga tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion alejandro lies veena says alejandro lies vernell says veena tells the truth fidel says vernell lies inga says fidel tells the truth does inga tell the truth answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6835.92, "reasoner_ms": 2833.11, "tts_ms": 22.27, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9691.32, "total_processing_ms": 10250.79 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 822, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 123 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0bb650e25506c2eeb6e7bfb9f249c26c5d9b93aa85cd5dae4ba8e00e61fbe688", "started_sha256": "6f0a18a473ece325981e6e6e4b7141c082d178ff2c3b6b9cdb0b764beb98d816", "original_grade_sha256": "278d083731d09e6386609fcbfa2087670315974e9f600e8c9185321b1e81adc9", "input_original_sha256": "0bb650e25506c2eeb6e7bfb9f249c26c5d9b93aa85cd5dae4ba8e00e61fbe688", "input_wav_sha256": "bdf077c238f978fdae6cb8bd2d14c5aa7f118f5ee909394ffc02983f1765cb8f", "input_pcm_sha256": "c59541ae642549912da384776cc66561c6f30f13713bbeaf2c0ac8821c6d1215", "output_wav_sha256": "9e4c07b0dd2b3c8d4222b0406d213616747cd85390f9066193ef42c4d505130d", "output_pcm_sha256": "aa24e1c6cb49773850f52af81991fcfcead75f68629ece1ca90ffcb74fa87e5f", "result_sha256": "cc73d407fb026426f7c9c906c9a6231eb2e9c37c44e482db7d42d17042be5f03" } }, { "id": 49, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "401064476b91b0dad8f911582c7b7dd0a113f224eb1fd15b1db3d99eb4191630", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "401064476b91b0dad8f911582c7b7dd0a113f224eb1fd15b1db3d99eb4191630", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, no ex-supporter of Getafe CF is a critic of Kilmarnock FC. Second, everyone who is a friend of Charleroi SC is a critic of Kilmarnock FC too. Therefore, whoever is not a friend of Charleroi SC is an ex-supporter of Getafe CF. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, no ex-supporter of Gitafe CF is a critic of Kilmarnock FC. Second, everyone who is a friend of R. Charleroi SC is a critic of Kilmarnock FC too. Therefore, whoever is not a friend of R. Charleroi SC is an ex-supporter of Gitafe CF. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9041.76, "reasoner_ms": 5172.05, "tts_ms": 25.93, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 14239.77, "total_processing_ms": 14715.58 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1004, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 182 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8e090bea698c061d61c5699a0418147149ea23df1873db05c0807646efd41611", "started_sha256": "a5f376c2bc028679bb8f4e8464d19f4896bf365a85dd111127fd4b0ff1427dbf", "original_grade_sha256": "691e3325ae47b57260d6dd70eaf582857957c2e9254ccbce44eb73a013367d64", "input_original_sha256": "8e090bea698c061d61c5699a0418147149ea23df1873db05c0807646efd41611", "input_wav_sha256": "6acd8614cccc5564974e272d6912b6838a893e39ea5e8a31d57e0a273d1e3af6", "input_pcm_sha256": "8ea6f8bbe2f75dc88fc65e69fe69214cb8d4b72cbec97373c8755924bf3fb3fb", "output_wav_sha256": "611847bdfff2d6d1daa3085bafe17ae6b78f4dfcbfed18accc162fc2e084dd33", "output_pcm_sha256": "cdd42746152584c77597c3f6edc626a53ad4d42b4434b125402583adc901845f", "result_sha256": "9608915cb1e28749141726f2afda2a9058d055777102937062ff1b33d51f37b3" } }, { "id": 295, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5009faf52d66410184dc2b335eb3fd3e06d6a6de344fa8688d64975d2ad234b5", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5009faf52d66410184dc2b335eb3fd3e06d6a6de344fa8688d64975d2ad234b5", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn right. Take nine steps. Turn around. Take nine steps. Turn right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn right. Take nine steps. Turn around. Take nine steps. Turn right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4938.09, "reasoner_ms": 2088.34, "tts_ms": 24.23, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7050.69, "total_processing_ms": 7531.29 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 799, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 72 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ed6b5b3867e533cb6d2f705e8902cc132ef3a7fe6be6858f59319a6785ec0254", "started_sha256": "c72491de0e672e42bd10f32d96842febfdf49514468d1cf8502298999cb0b8e4", "original_grade_sha256": "9e997914f7938118753522f5a00d8d46fef0b0071f18ef1e79634eb07aa5c7b8", "input_original_sha256": "ed6b5b3867e533cb6d2f705e8902cc132ef3a7fe6be6858f59319a6785ec0254", "input_wav_sha256": "375f5acb1d925b0de76a7b5cf858992a99e08b87ddeab004b47eb96bff0de606", "input_pcm_sha256": "bf8fde79ca005fc694f07d8ad89a91a2c9be90e0371ceff29fc7101a9338b49b", "output_wav_sha256": "9a538525f8de013e619689b75bd71905b172cc2e35a35581a3ef1fe3d29283fa", "output_pcm_sha256": "69a5c57dbd9035229ae549f877d4841be0ddc6148c2e2bcfc6c700c4e888df94", "result_sha256": "0b4a3cc1be745d974be484f7eeee35bec3efd8c4737d3dd168a924c5d9448cc0" } }, { "id": 676, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "7", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a095b23d377c835c4fec4982b9dd94415d930af7368068199051793401355fbf", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a095b23d377c835c4fec4982b9dd94415d930af7368068199051793401355fbf", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have an oven, a bed, a lamp, a chair, a fridge, a microwave, and a toaster. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have an oven, a bed, a lamp, a chair, a fridge, a microwave, and a toaster. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 7.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4224.68, "reasoner_ms": 1466.76, "tts_ms": 24.52, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5715.98, "total_processing_ms": 6176.8 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 774, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 40 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b916c30c05b35278e548a73c286dd0d026888ff0b748b80adf687ce722ad4a72", "started_sha256": "8de4a7505fa7b6ac38c595a61f8598b62712ab5c933e1783d29ed115581d7f3d", "original_grade_sha256": "1f2a5d43e5ff0d31b63a5d7be60334b6e9c7722845e03351684d58afc71e22d0", "input_original_sha256": "b916c30c05b35278e548a73c286dd0d026888ff0b748b80adf687ce722ad4a72", "input_wav_sha256": "5e00ff01c5f5e7b3b5ee20d867efcbafd0e655949757854648b04067f9fc722e", "input_pcm_sha256": "13fb907275bf98753b8e57918bb36bce71f057d629c654fdcbe940c908d230d0", "output_wav_sha256": "fea7cc7f79bf6c16c7487e614f00db9bcfcea52f004e8f93507a0693f09790f7", "output_pcm_sha256": "870d0c533ac3a4bfa2c60f82a8991059c9a7b85471d652def38f7ec15b579508", "result_sha256": "98d6ff6479a5d36ba789ef92ab04c8bdc53288a1fc80c5ad0b2813f021aad034" } }, { "id": 852, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cebc06522264a2ace4e46f603421551c660057a2c818c7d2114ee7c4842f6fdc", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cebc06522264a2ace4e46f603421551c660057a2c818c7d2114ee7c4842f6fdc", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Andre lies. Delfina says Andre lies. Jim says Delfina tells the truth. Gwen says Jim lies. Delbert says Gwen lies. Does Delbert tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion, Andre lies. Delfina says Andre lies. Jim says Delfina tells the truth. Gwen says Jim lies. Delbert says Gwen lies. Does Delbert tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4803.62, "reasoner_ms": 2430.96, "tts_ms": 25.85, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7260.45, "total_processing_ms": 7845.87 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 825, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 114 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a9799b991db2d23a3180c3f8ee765b8ec1e3203de63da750c2c123978ffe07c4", "started_sha256": "3cec4a6845d407ed6a2f67e9e04c3156418720bb96299d8dc23b21a8ffbda263", "original_grade_sha256": "c5c768f767f560bdd48fa12b391c499e2b722d859c641410fdbc60c6d3601aac", "input_original_sha256": "a9799b991db2d23a3180c3f8ee765b8ec1e3203de63da750c2c123978ffe07c4", "input_wav_sha256": "64e40cbcdde6f2115ebab85f0758add0c717008ca51196662111c5c562111572", "input_pcm_sha256": "b6b2858cd76c71f6ea3810d2c3a94012ec2d70b3dcb33a73f9c161013f8834d0", "output_wav_sha256": "4c9fc00b57a4fa340cf6141a7b9848d7ea5236b85af22788c54273fd26ac65fb", "output_pcm_sha256": "f71ddad25e55fe90c258bcf074469522bdce98e169147a84683fa22d56415d38", "result_sha256": "eff2533704ddad7daa97c98c68de2cbfc2aea00ce8ea2b13b7618801e5460520" } }, { "id": 245, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d2152419c1044ba5cde53533cca9e490ad813f72756731453de261aa0e86a0a0", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d2152419c1044ba5cde53533cca9e490ad813f72756731453de261aa0e86a0a0", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, not being a fan of FC Slovan Liberec is sufficient for not being a critic of Real Sociedad de F\u00fatbol. Second, every backer of Ferencv\u00e1rosi TC is a critic of Real Sociedad de F\u00fatbol. Therefore, every backer of Ferencv\u00e1rosi TC is a fan of FC Slovan Liberec. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, not being a fan of FC Sloven Liberets is sufficient for not being a critic of Real Sociedad de Futbol. Second, every backer of Ferns Verossi TC is a critic of Real Sociedad de Futbol. Therefore, every backer of Ferns Verossi TC is a fan of FC Sloven Liberets. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid Valid or invalid. Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 10112.58, "reasoner_ms": 1961.91, "tts_ms": 30.0, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 12104.51, "total_processing_ms": 12642.8 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1023, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 89 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a6cb2a37a533e79a2885479da49a5e2ada962def54319d0feec3705e619ea824", "started_sha256": "da1a43c9fa2df1b4528dbde7fd12ad578a89c9c5271e7868c85602a258a68728", "original_grade_sha256": "a76815f810405b21d2f303ee6e0f4a5e13ca1846bb03d02fb68fd80211d20383", "input_original_sha256": "a6cb2a37a533e79a2885479da49a5e2ada962def54319d0feec3705e619ea824", "input_wav_sha256": "c452357516c3ca712963bbe69cc9200454e9d4793a0241e5c60ff6a3de06c118", "input_pcm_sha256": "7b2723eb0b11703db168a109cfabeac03fbdaf5c1a1ce4df3341abb32a18b8a9", "output_wav_sha256": "1ee5e6dd84f460d532aac4f077505742b1d2862a23f1a30c41a1104342c48af7", "output_pcm_sha256": "35aea84d5d73c45aead688ee79cc8e9f7f3ab86d1d56827c2f9c511bf307a636", "result_sha256": "53badee07678e2eb67fa5e96fb336602e012812a8315164a6af17aa8a21e79b6" } }, { "id": 346, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9bfa3d7ea1ba2126988d9e605b3795f594e35f6afa50a2e36eedd1ee54540a7d", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9bfa3d7ea1ba2126988d9e605b3795f594e35f6afa50a2e36eedd1ee54540a7d", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps. Turn right. Turn right. Take seven steps. Turn around. Take one step. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps. Turn right. Turn right. Take seven steps. Turn around. Take one step. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4684.41, "reasoner_ms": 2667.72, "tts_ms": 24.37, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7376.53, "total_processing_ms": 7910.29 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 807, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 99 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0174464bd1784151ebe7ffacc6b2883512b96079d4d9e204807c2ab22a9ee2ec", "started_sha256": "400d71d3395a3188774bac3b0e49364e99dee5633a1d4894470cf60ff59d346f", "original_grade_sha256": "f07653dc30d6493fbf85c9fe57f9025c6b5185cef39086e4d52b817ab6d6b052", "input_original_sha256": "0174464bd1784151ebe7ffacc6b2883512b96079d4d9e204807c2ab22a9ee2ec", "input_wav_sha256": "aac02df5e3e2ceacce5ed02eea20bcabc5d1b4fe22fc01b13eff3853d5ec3845", "input_pcm_sha256": "103b90f15da8fbdb803509c7ca4aaa220ea973828466176dfe1f71c55c396738", "output_wav_sha256": "0e56445f3a0f5a03503dbdc27d731578f79f934933e7c7ed37a1577a804f8512", "output_pcm_sha256": "6766eb338431122dfe2ea86f28a96e13ad1c9184dc71a8f192014e421c0457dc", "result_sha256": "8a65c0f08725b06bce7fa4829409aa58bab29e0afda11e106d6dfee621a73b8d" } }, { "id": 741, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "8", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e1f483c6d9b0a465e4f074aa7f015cce9ed1633487a7c7c420f929bc843b2117", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e1f483c6d9b0a465e4f074aa7f015cce9ed1633487a7c7c420f929bc843b2117", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a duck, a cow, a donkey, a mouse, a bear, a snake, a snail, and a goat. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a duck, a cow, a donkey, a mouse, a bear, a snake, a snail, and a goat. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 8.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4237.84, "reasoner_ms": 1531.95, "tts_ms": 23.44, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5793.26, "total_processing_ms": 6265.9 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 778, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 41 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "7bc88a977798b728fea8e6cb6ca0df0269f8577bb8acab6af2f9fae08f161cc5", "started_sha256": "6bc172f7e89fac6533a5a3d6a7403dd47ce6478a459ae77a8d3739bf7bbfa1d4", "original_grade_sha256": "d2b8b7c2085789ccccca01dcb019cd4755d0f268a0d37e2ee17b82a321f02d79", "input_original_sha256": "7bc88a977798b728fea8e6cb6ca0df0269f8577bb8acab6af2f9fae08f161cc5", "input_wav_sha256": "78b98e7e1af6bfd640b22b13be7b843a8c2398d43426c9081aeaf7539b743649", "input_pcm_sha256": "ae29688a1bfc27aff5d4b475638aaab7dc49c944a531d0eea6983bbb91d21492", "output_wav_sha256": "1e190ec515bc7481450b6d9358fb89b19a723a753e2fc5bdf2f39a0d91909535", "output_pcm_sha256": "af8e5dfd37b59ab525dd835074811778f800541a68725e748ad4d92ddfebeeaa", "result_sha256": "bf1c6daada8fb2e3ea44172d5c60c630e222092d654667dca7302286d0176813" } }, { "id": 853, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0a11229b5270cb15997717e0ca3c4d1f40501b95628dc5695a1dc56187f3666d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0a11229b5270cb15997717e0ca3c4d1f40501b95628dc5695a1dc56187f3666d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Andre lies. Jamie says Andre lies. Shonda says Jamie lies. Delfina says Shonda lies. Christy says Delfina lies. Does Christy tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Andre lies. Jamie says Andre lies. Shauna says Jamie lies. Delfina says Shauna lies. Christy says Delfina lies. Does Christy tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4416.96, "reasoner_ms": 2555.41, "tts_ms": 20.71, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6993.1, "total_processing_ms": 7548.01 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 819, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 123 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5642ee5e05d25dc1cbdd73a7f3fcba97d330e8449c37db64ad09baa65d4bce36", "started_sha256": "aef708f81fa771dc9617ae44478554c716eae1924ebbf79f91520629ec8796b3", "original_grade_sha256": "bc58e60c95d1ff2be82ac7a4937fbf82c62287cf09e6fb51efb835b859c5622e", "input_original_sha256": "5642ee5e05d25dc1cbdd73a7f3fcba97d330e8449c37db64ad09baa65d4bce36", "input_wav_sha256": "396391a305af7f314aa76755326c4105d9283f24c59a9da2ba5e89a4218bbc0c", "input_pcm_sha256": "d47e67189f20b84a9df06bd5e7a5c999da62970441ff81394de4e4dbcf514652", "output_wav_sha256": "70441f9b76432773f8d3cadd9c9ebac96a3d44f20424efa45bf637afa62697c9", "output_pcm_sha256": "f5df81665bc243cecee370d1922d77221c656284cff46971739f099537102b7e", "result_sha256": "59eaa36a6718e8ee66571700ec06173f7d23519925be5f3a10bf3a5b824c568e" } }, { "id": 29, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7bace32150b302d0092b4fa9ea54088ef25b839cf687f551d060aad61ca35b5f", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7bace32150b302d0092b4fa9ea54088ef25b839cf687f551d060aad61ca35b5f", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, whoever is a loyal buyer of Bentley Organic Soap is not a regular user of Paul Mitchell soap. Now, whoever is an owner of a Lush soap and an infrequent user of Pro-Active soap is not a loyal buyer of Bentley Organic Soap. We may conclude every owner of a Lush soap who is an infrequent user of Pro-Active soap is also a regular user of Paul Mitchell soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, whoever is a loyal buyer of Bentley Organic Soap is not a regular user of Paul Mitchell Soap. Now, whoever is an owner of a Lush Soap and an infrequent user of Proactive Soap is not a loyal buyer of Bentley Organic Soap. We may conclude, every owner of a Lush Soap who is an infrequent user of Proactive Soap is also a regular user user of Paul Mitchell soap is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11610.26, "reasoner_ms": 3662.97, "tts_ms": 26.93, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15300.19, "total_processing_ms": 15857.81 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1077, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 189 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e601aaa65f82dd80fe8f2187143100fadf606d3ba1623710098774eb0a17cf4c", "started_sha256": "079fe93c8cc681af232f1bda89f82bbaeb3388faa5d18110898b61e18482deff", "original_grade_sha256": "2cc8e063a8d4ec5909105882948870afbb0dbbc1225c5e793607e038137de2c0", "input_original_sha256": "e601aaa65f82dd80fe8f2187143100fadf606d3ba1623710098774eb0a17cf4c", "input_wav_sha256": "9a189537ba8e4c193fa2e021db149f17befde1363b0981c4295a876a392df9f0", "input_pcm_sha256": "5f8474eeb862e001eabb14d8be308cf139bb5eb557f80635994e334a077fc342", "output_wav_sha256": "e3fa6081427ec3d81facb65627fea0ff2513379385a9cda506b8c9e47789a2ab", "output_pcm_sha256": "27fd2d64c057f03052f59f64677711c40745afd09ceaafc0b354cd9fd7bb6666", "result_sha256": "5ce92e3ffc44abab1cff3d5418982631a537a49c0ddc8d2b00ff9e179a9c7753" } }, { "id": 291, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b985c726efd2056cbd8348627070a806a742971913f37f42c150fe125faa4f79", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b985c726efd2056cbd8348627070a806a742971913f37f42c150fe125faa4f79", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps. Take ten steps. Take ten steps. Take one step. Take seven steps. Take five steps. Turn around. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point take six steps take ten steps take ten steps take one step take seven steps take five steps turn around options yes no answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5557.92, "reasoner_ms": 2041.16, "tts_ms": 22.53, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7621.65, "total_processing_ms": 8079.78 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 805, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 61 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2b19318c0edb8295115b76da7f70a30993fc97207883df72b46b33606027ec0a", "started_sha256": "2f5b6c357a3d66237c385d00117d7a3bff538693012fc7c1d8b6ed790ced0272", "original_grade_sha256": "9359569f393ae98d8036b223d15481ba9953092ce623ef87679b0d4498c310a2", "input_original_sha256": "2b19318c0edb8295115b76da7f70a30993fc97207883df72b46b33606027ec0a", "input_wav_sha256": "821df52a323a5566adbcc83c7af88160b4b1772da9e15543225ea64b3b43859c", "input_pcm_sha256": "fb6d28163225d1fff2536df1c82c08e3a980847a3f5a300efb93d54cdc635f4d", "output_wav_sha256": "fb57dfcbe5a33e6eb7231b5001a30983ad6baca504e2c3668fa429f637846e25", "output_pcm_sha256": "2b53c8a87eeebb164a5a49c5ff992ab54a39b5dddc3f9a87f549423346343f40", "result_sha256": "ecd447178d8a1f9eef0e518e2722c5a2d0ec481d9fad26062d74bc1856744e34" } }, { "id": 665, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "16", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cb48543c21e64ca1950f719572a393f8546eec8b4d69162aa745c1b0ef21b554", "normalized_answer": "16" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cb48543c21e64ca1950f719572a393f8546eec8b4d69162aa745c1b0ef21b554", "normalized_answer": "16" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a cabbage, four stalks of celery, two garlics, three carrots, a yam, a cauliflower, a lettuce head, two heads of broccoli, a microwave, and an onion. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a cabbage four stalks of celery two garlics three carrots a yam a cauliflower a lettuce head two heads of broccoli a microwave and an onion how many vegetables do i have answer the question Thank you for your question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 16.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7188.23, "reasoner_ms": 2583.3, "tts_ms": 20.78, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9792.33, "total_processing_ms": 10277.66 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 829, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 135 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "94aaf6b8d7ef0d9755884609b8125ecb758e470e960d94aa3da029ee0a2198b3", "started_sha256": "8029efc5a211e119ce47eaade5481cccd02e73acd9fbcae68d1fbedb6d81fae4", "original_grade_sha256": "dcc56bcc202afc7f40497a2ef775373e340514afccdf28c2a6e4594ad3abd224", "input_original_sha256": "94aaf6b8d7ef0d9755884609b8125ecb758e470e960d94aa3da029ee0a2198b3", "input_wav_sha256": "0021a459b8af8080002fe37cb730ae4a35f66dc7fb89056716d72da674354013", "input_pcm_sha256": "037df1b66228b8c9c3d9f88e157f85cc3d8c0a26bd6aeebf1ff0b3fc5a40a106", "output_wav_sha256": "170747cbe77aeb3f759d7020bda84d36bae44eb88683913602c243e943b9a9d4", "output_pcm_sha256": "11c4c75c94a571b5a27bbc5deab7d227a11da97183983ee3ea689d423b2375eb", "result_sha256": "1daea8ec856d018aa1b8bf7aa4a984ffc4d7ed8a489cc19f4b3f726d1033f734" } }, { "id": 985, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6083a85df4708e9746eb9b26f2f11035a3b711a890e37c2e7ee00e4088e8ee1b", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6083a85df4708e9746eb9b26f2f11035a3b711a890e37c2e7ee00e4088e8ee1b", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Inga lies. Audrey says Inga lies. Rashida says Audrey lies. Willian says Rashida tells the truth. Amberly says Willian lies. Does Amberly tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Inga lies. Audrey says Inga lies. Rashida says Audrey lies. William says Rashida tells the truth. Amberly says William lies. Does Amberly tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4783.46, "reasoner_ms": 2601.14, "tts_ms": 23.14, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7407.77, "total_processing_ms": 7885.41 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 821, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 122 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2027ace2cead309e7e14435c712fc2534e0f1831c820d91d7509a0df076b6464", "started_sha256": "85aa9b446c7ef445d5b7c7f3060e3d8768f5f6571487b4ee3d9f7d733e229b8c", "original_grade_sha256": "23f9215ea1fd2584d78e5586f763cd88977515c2757068723799d0f2079dba75", "input_original_sha256": "2027ace2cead309e7e14435c712fc2534e0f1831c820d91d7509a0df076b6464", "input_wav_sha256": "3ef6610e49240aca363557d7c74ebfab1fd2e0dcb880bdaca55312922bff7104", "input_pcm_sha256": "a4bde88f3019513009b192ab2655479f16190c3410d2e42bd8be1618b7347aa1", "output_wav_sha256": "3c157f28d7d7eee3577ed9afe72d40a2700facdc77fd28bcdcd07113c0f52127", "output_pcm_sha256": "5fcd893db2ff1854a5f149ef23f3ea5267f6db97b52d5c6750923b34b53e0ea9", "result_sha256": "d6d428028684d34ad1ae4da4c199fb8cd1045712c70e1203b8f930da8b1fd3a7" } }, { "id": 19, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2b9d51ae06e6ce26806e20e38583b8ad4c77c5297b4213a9437fa8a6abc1fcd7", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2b9d51ae06e6ce26806e20e38583b8ad4c77c5297b4213a9437fa8a6abc1fcd7", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, everyone who is a close friend of Glenna is a close friend of Tamara too. Next, whoever is neither a half-sister of Deborah nor a workmate of Neela is a close friend of Glenna. Hence, whoever is none of this, a half-sister of Deborah or workmate of Neela, is a close friend of Tamara. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom, and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, everyone who is a close friend of Glenna is a close friend of Tamara, too. Next, whoever is neither a half-sister of Deborah nor a workmate of Mila is a close friend of Glenna. Hence, whoever is none of this, a half-sister of Deborah or workmate of Mila, is a close friend of Tamara. Mara. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12256.87, "reasoner_ms": 2356.0, "tts_ms": 27.67, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 14640.57, "total_processing_ms": 15192.55 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 962, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 126 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5b4d6e2478ef52618745844ef25bf72c7c5653b2b49a7cdee87aea6f25464469", "started_sha256": "d09310ad93d53c54ebd26ae0a6714d723c980be8b953d2bcedf53a3fdb5deeeb", "original_grade_sha256": "08097dedddec4dbe10f8f092e1dcff56166915c9a5eaaad4c9afe9c1c567628c", "input_original_sha256": "5b4d6e2478ef52618745844ef25bf72c7c5653b2b49a7cdee87aea6f25464469", "input_wav_sha256": "574a0e1527838bf470f109fada7dfe494e9ee19370929b273b3f940d60cc9664", "input_pcm_sha256": "9a8904c9b81a13cbe1e109874436d3d328d0dd1142702d9a20c29e0ab20e89e3", "output_wav_sha256": "bcb29068eaa65508b739fed5fb30f328edb772ccd4d23e9aab2957645c8f7c90", "output_pcm_sha256": "8665e00fac983e1c74e31cd72f1c58d70ef4389e2f70ec04fd8620311c6d5c92", "result_sha256": "b345ba4273c314b89baf9cb3fbc05a67407aeffd2e702c374ff164add4e74278" } }, { "id": 262, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "de0637e26d7ae645601feac374693ec84ed3eec0a06a0e4d86899b4f91dea331", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "de0637e26d7ae645601feac374693ec84ed3eec0a06a0e4d86899b4f91dea331", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take three steps. Turn around. Take three steps. Turn right. Options? Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take three steps. Turn around. Take three steps. Turn right. Options? Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5430.61, "reasoner_ms": 2001.98, "tts_ms": 25.44, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7458.06, "total_processing_ms": 8157.62 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 785, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 60 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6ee25c67977ff0b4687148cf4d99a84515f40ff59589abc870a8cec870ca3dfe", "started_sha256": "055d8b5788b116647a72ed08a9914012b0baf69176ab8609173344510d226e76", "original_grade_sha256": "74dcd93fe3da8d2ea3290c2556a6c726faaf5a2eb309c4d2ba37073bbac4906c", "input_original_sha256": "6ee25c67977ff0b4687148cf4d99a84515f40ff59589abc870a8cec870ca3dfe", "input_wav_sha256": "ea17cd11c45302391eb0cf1e47be40d28de8500ba2e91f2e7331090c39aaf9dc", "input_pcm_sha256": "8071bd84e1878a7ea44c10a827deab75e579f0d887ed794376f3bc707ca10316", "output_wav_sha256": "d78e39663d295362a81af7e69764fba38e99f872f91bf508d687c40a7069ba11", "output_pcm_sha256": "540416abb9517b1b0fdad0576da2270d60b191b3ca3cdc387f209b050bee0d65", "result_sha256": "22e0a638f21452a457ff28bd08d8d8dd7ea16510bb51978617c3c62cb9fad0bc" } }, { "id": 646, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "33f98b601a22114c0bd5c9f4076d243e09714165717efb6a23f7b103c080776c", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "33f98b601a22114c0bd5c9f4076d243e09714165717efb6a23f7b103c080776c", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a drum, a violin, three trombones, two flutes, a piano, and an accordion. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a drum a violin three trombones two flutes a piano and an accordion how many musical instruments do i have answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 9.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7248.76, "reasoner_ms": 1581.73, "tts_ms": 25.78, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8856.3, "total_processing_ms": 9446.01 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 762, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 49 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "fb95c447e1383a866f811c5c439bf5a0e93e5e408786ca62a0504ff8d88ea0f2", "started_sha256": "8a50f7ce393378037c3fe0fdee3695a058765e545b31c524bf65d710fd73d713", "original_grade_sha256": "07a4e5c43bdc9a9c8ca0e09d7cff70475f71674e0b66665ffbfff05dfe7ee033", "input_original_sha256": "fb95c447e1383a866f811c5c439bf5a0e93e5e408786ca62a0504ff8d88ea0f2", "input_wav_sha256": "f38089de290122067f7dc55e6247d14dfae8424c0de8087d3baff9b754e120c0", "input_pcm_sha256": "6301a1a23e3c1db69f5016e081026131aa26461819823b5bc99ea7ed5f2f0355", "output_wav_sha256": "175ceb1bcdc2bb5462802c75440e3aefe7634edf77ee4513143df3efba49baac", "output_pcm_sha256": "f8bc0e2ee2a76e875c8dcdb08bb5b6a7792079942055c69b72f0e44e0c204b94", "result_sha256": "5c9d6535f163de67a09f72054a13e411115f84cb5e8aed32905123c4fdad8846" } }, { "id": 820, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "491e18a2a7468b6dc8511dbe4053a0e75917cb2af21010fdf91cff37aa28478b", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "491e18a2a7468b6dc8511dbe4053a0e75917cb2af21010fdf91cff37aa28478b", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Kandi lies. Phoebe says Kandi tells the truth. Yolande says Phoebe tells the truth. Fletcher says Yolande lies. Laureen says Fletcher tells the truth. Does Laureen tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Candy lies. Phoebe says Candy tells the truth. Yolen says Phoebe tells the truth. Fletcher says Yolen lies. Laureen says Fletcher tells the truth. Does Laureen tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5169.46, "reasoner_ms": 2334.57, "tts_ms": 24.77, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7528.83, "total_processing_ms": 8216.12 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 851, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 122 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "94933ba0a06a3870aaf612b5d63e74d54da02a88b33c1a7f71e0178c6460e86e", "started_sha256": "b42e39baaf3fd51d8fb955d8237775ee50009212a3e84f26b666b05fc1006c26", "original_grade_sha256": "39382c105c4a2292697e1edab1cbd67ddd6bc8f4880a36c9f7a589a5147f686f", "input_original_sha256": "94933ba0a06a3870aaf612b5d63e74d54da02a88b33c1a7f71e0178c6460e86e", "input_wav_sha256": "62de139a1921594cf4e07ca815e2b37cc266be6d91c8ddcaccf782e90c8079ad", "input_pcm_sha256": "72614be390819063eb991e3ed9328090026145cf9e762c9e8ca3322254f4baad", "output_wav_sha256": "8fae4a7c3959cdaaddf5f550778e651a1bd3b55f8bf423cfcaf2d9fcdfe55bd7", "output_pcm_sha256": "82bf3e7997358274bc8c87789c499170a9be672436b48cb830199fdb6e0fd7f9", "result_sha256": "d67ae9b953434b8acb040181531532ba9e37fda1c3ba49c3c15837a64119f755" } }, { "id": 14, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "59eb8da324cbf0940f964b9078b4290b0754820d2fcf4c52a7baee179b48afa7", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "59eb8da324cbf0940f964b9078b4290b0754820d2fcf4c52a7baee179b48afa7", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a fan of Liverpool? Are supporters of Real Madrid devotees of PSG? In European football, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of the mutual admiration and dislike. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First, every opponent to FC Mariupol is an ex-supporter of Hertha BSC Berlin or an ex-supporter of Bayer Zero four Leverkusen. Second, every fan of FC Utrecht is not an ex-supporter of Hertha BSC Berlin or not an ex-supporter of Bayer Zero four Leverkusen. So necessarily being an opponent to FC Mariupol is sufficient for not being a fan of FC Utrecht. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Fred a fan of Liverpool? Are supporters of Real Madrid devotees of PSG? In European football, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of the mutual admiration and dislike. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First, every opponent to FC Mariupol is an ex-supporter of Hertha BSC Berlin or an ex-supporter of Bayer 04 Leverkusen. Second, every fan of FC Utrecht is not an ex-supporter of Hertha BSC Berlin or not an ex-supporter of Bayer 04 Leverkusen. So, necessarily, being an opponent to FC Mariupol is sufficient for not being a fan of FC Utrecht. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 15134.81, "reasoner_ms": 4725.69, "tts_ms": 27.79, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 19888.32, "total_processing_ms": 20551.23 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1235, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 345 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b8941b87378d119bfd72a8c2ef2c7d11bae0ea11f632bb88a4a84279c32d7c3f", "started_sha256": "92bfd65660afe45db35349a4fc4750d467e025fd5acec03bd6bfd396a5de78ca", "original_grade_sha256": "4b6b75928498c74673441801dd2812f64a59fdb91a27211805e1c1ba73920f23", "input_original_sha256": "b8941b87378d119bfd72a8c2ef2c7d11bae0ea11f632bb88a4a84279c32d7c3f", "input_wav_sha256": "8aaa5eba63f1a5567a716184167269e28fb4dcaa8242c95da82b312a4469e059", "input_pcm_sha256": "7d580e9145d6d888db57ead46dd66fb690410210e558dde1c34b7572d4cae6fa", "output_wav_sha256": "84bfff9ca9dd885bbbdd3552eddc24eee1ed4ec104295becf3d8ad533c6ffd4d", "output_pcm_sha256": "4ef4d99a0bfb5e1cf6df4eeffbc30d9ed94c40df6cffe90a12edd129dd024b4b", "result_sha256": "3371ef5bd42dd44ac92cde4a54be093fc706d5c556a679ba0bbfd3dea80e9297" } }, { "id": 373, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "89b0b77fe1e41ac1cd2c3c6e8b4235c8dfd2fb57a28d4a0d183f86de2296dc38", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "89b0b77fe1e41ac1cd2c3c6e8b4235c8dfd2fb57a28d4a0d183f86de2296dc38", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps. Take five steps. Take six steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point take six steps take five steps take six steps options yes no answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7786.77, "reasoner_ms": 1691.12, "tts_ms": 23.0, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9500.92, "total_processing_ms": 10124.23 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 770, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 30 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "88745e16534b2c7e162f9e91648dffe3e11961ebf057b6ce9c81763179c2cb1d", "started_sha256": "b9bbba18b5808c5a2275df5f8cf0e6894d23a570fa2e0d793ddc038760972fc0", "original_grade_sha256": "0e9f68b6056389e0d5d7ef6f30eb68daec69fc74e16b1d756bc35fc7f4792c79", "input_original_sha256": "88745e16534b2c7e162f9e91648dffe3e11961ebf057b6ce9c81763179c2cb1d", "input_wav_sha256": "4a16277bbf1271cd5013674b33ad147537d787c49d1e1a6692a65a4b6a8991a1", "input_pcm_sha256": "e329b928cef0dc6e7b65b6dd4f6191c850375d3081fb6ce9151fc3762fa8e28d", "output_wav_sha256": "dd8336c5bedef50860f772de240054f29f2f4e6556aa35e699567682d470e3f9", "output_pcm_sha256": "54dacb24a99ef13f4a19a471d7d1bd44c4a6b12620eeb7574155be43314d2995", "result_sha256": "e237182efa2daab41804271f2cf13864af0bde298cb9cc45988fcb3951462e75" } }, { "id": 503, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "14", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "81af676f03522f07f7d0d1ba1ea843bf6ec5e5363cb09e773dad9b502a19c3ee", "normalized_answer": "14" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "81af676f03522f07f7d0d1ba1ea843bf6ec5e5363cb09e773dad9b502a19c3ee", "normalized_answer": "14" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have three blackberries, two strawberries, an apple, three oranges, a nectarine, a grape, a peach, a banana, and a plum. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have three blackberries, two strawberries, an apple, three oranges, a nectarine, a grape, a peach, a banana, and a plum. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 14.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5215.16, "reasoner_ms": 1547.05, "tts_ms": 30.55, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6792.78, "total_processing_ms": 7358.46 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 797, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 32 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ffe13b9a06cf12c19e33cdc8b23695741e59d8d26d6bd8b4b586e7b3766e3f9a", "started_sha256": "cb0a0032ab0c3b997100b0316074988b777716607a14623dbc9fc0a74b9e7e91", "original_grade_sha256": "a5bf93780aee9d72fb4eff49f37a0e3d9a51076687ad812b38702d41eec62b9f", "input_original_sha256": "ffe13b9a06cf12c19e33cdc8b23695741e59d8d26d6bd8b4b586e7b3766e3f9a", "input_wav_sha256": "505cf293a8daf32c574c1270bd6615d37c85c84541fc9bcd298a4b694f38f708", "input_pcm_sha256": "77268e2b737caed5becb7441dec5806fc97303f383958b8feb9b2782ff4db9c9", "output_wav_sha256": "e0114dde1be6359d4c545987445a079f53af8a2f11e94a5ff89fa6c3c0832c62", "output_pcm_sha256": "ebc536ddd4e5699290568b378608d08ac471fbf0170896fe6dcfa3546ad6838c", "result_sha256": "f2966082891902e1f31d737b3c9308b397f7ce464ff63fc8328557c81b0af4e0" } }, { "id": 801, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "662989254ea05f8d094fa1db842e938f5b84c6b767b409a385008cb77d3304a4", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "662989254ea05f8d094fa1db842e938f5b84c6b767b409a385008cb77d3304a4", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Eleanor tells the truth. Kay says Eleanor lies. Delbert says Kay tells the truth. Michaela says Delbert lies. Sherry says Michaela lies. Does Sherry tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Eleanor tells the truth. K.A. says Eleanor lies. Delbert says K.A. tells the truth. Michaela says Delbert lies. Sherry says Michaela lies. Does Sherry tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6427.1, "reasoner_ms": 2256.09, "tts_ms": 23.33, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8706.54, "total_processing_ms": 9237.38 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 841, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 108 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "44039f2101fcf3fb0046baee498971cd6356c4de9e6ff0c7c237922ab9e99847", "started_sha256": "d3825f25d4fd9c6557c53ed31f8662c6f7c8b79e215a8cef6904c96c28bc7338", "original_grade_sha256": "1f9238981f74e66aaa7212d439df947a76f5824bbed52240f6e0b38e2ed503ec", "input_original_sha256": "44039f2101fcf3fb0046baee498971cd6356c4de9e6ff0c7c237922ab9e99847", "input_wav_sha256": "5435397127dd5a55e8aa81bdf95dcb5fdc41b23a5925f366a39d2508d04e4b96", "input_pcm_sha256": "aca27c24a9d9ed21c3d3075cc537fc32f75850fb331d2df0f4e27baf2c99c384", "output_wav_sha256": "fda2bd4f1c952687c36cdb25c4604bce9951640838e3efc25688aed9095faac5", "output_pcm_sha256": "3181454f87192edc7d6c38233edf702e7939eb1552f79e9a7986c4eaef4870bb", "result_sha256": "f3fa705048a8f744ccaebc137458f6c040d09824cbd47e18ff6ffd44989fec95" } }, { "id": 156, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "77a665f0c87d991a7ecbc1b0384c84e39371a42fbc646a1f641abcbc98b352af", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "77a665f0c87d991a7ecbc1b0384c84e39371a42fbc646a1f641abcbc98b352af", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise, whoever is not a half-sister of Perla and not a schoolmate of Gina is not a granddaughter of Deidre either. Second premise, there is somebody who is a great-grandmother of Margaret and a granddaughter of Deidre. So necessarily, there is somebody who is a great-grandmother of Margaret and in addition, not a half-sister of Perla or not a schoolmate of Gina. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise, whoever is not a half-sister of Perla and not a schoolmate of Gina is not a granddaughter of Deidre either. Second premise, there is somebody who is a great-grandmother of Margaret and a granddaughter of Deidre. So necessarily there is somebody who is a great-grandmother of Margaret and in addition not a half-sister of Perla or not a schoolmate of Gina. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, is deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12950.09, "reasoner_ms": 7035.86, "tts_ms": 34.55, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 20020.52, "total_processing_ms": 20630.82 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1055, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 559 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6de8af8d07d1f4714fb52c9277cc7dca1c9e71410e144982bc51fecd20849dd9", "started_sha256": "d3c5a96665c7f82f38507791d00446133529e7a22c48dd6dd5164976a5426aac", "original_grade_sha256": "4d49ae0adf50ef756d3934a3416b7923f862524ee397dc2a54b27b7911acd992", "input_original_sha256": "6de8af8d07d1f4714fb52c9277cc7dca1c9e71410e144982bc51fecd20849dd9", "input_wav_sha256": "11efc05a8518e5841fe18deb64a627e30237f85bb4c4fac315292f3808d74609", "input_pcm_sha256": "b0288fded9393527d5003445baf14fbef5d48367b2158c188efed68c3c65ba08", "output_wav_sha256": "bed30128115286e75d7077b933dfde2148dada87dc03710a33ebed36090670b5", "output_pcm_sha256": "4c9136234077a783b727a09eafb8f65b7ffb1c43b9d76007878245eafbcdf6c3", "result_sha256": "97074a783d4cb7ad13703cfc7c734c8605bf4b27b3fdfa9c96c7675cae4f36dd" } }, { "id": 399, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ce76c7cb9a1e80a992065ab6ae54c40ffb15bf799b41eb1cecb3ba27f8d69cd1", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ce76c7cb9a1e80a992065ab6ae54c40ffb15bf799b41eb1cecb3ba27f8d69cd1", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take two steps. Turn around. Take nine steps. Take seven steps. Take six steps. Turn left. Take two steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take two steps. Turn around. Take nine steps. Take seven steps. Take six steps. Turn left. Take two steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6487.24, "reasoner_ms": 3447.81, "tts_ms": 26.44, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9961.52, "total_processing_ms": 10523.37 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 826, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 171 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "bc224f7b3c318e29e93a4925f8aaa18368d22988968c37ad673fe6d6397d6ac4", "started_sha256": "461fb438aafdd20db73badf3f11568cb11d39eeeee3b7ba94ba1e932277a0975", "original_grade_sha256": "f3c6d08bc6abc3a716bd8c35d8c0e36baf788d4c6f95907d961720360b660066", "input_original_sha256": "bc224f7b3c318e29e93a4925f8aaa18368d22988968c37ad673fe6d6397d6ac4", "input_wav_sha256": "725a55e46342fcd69f7e1bedbcc0f1ca4920a1363d1497c95bc940aea8ec661a", "input_pcm_sha256": "42ff9682711dd08629b6a98641dd41e0f831606a2edc7b6504a11a7241071339", "output_wav_sha256": "e883c2fa3c69265fe1cdc9577ba25dbcea6e351086ca4a301d9b66a4bdfb23e9", "output_pcm_sha256": "1d9c8e804fa98be3be29f180740e7e339f79051806b9c3546c73bf0a5dc76fc4", "result_sha256": "072245d77fa7f7566db2e82d90bf17b6ac419af3dcc8df29d3dc7ce5906541c3" } }, { "id": 554, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "11", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "51eeb1b9f7e3e63bd1eecb87b9b00b0e12146a88f59331c4b35e9638255d023e", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "51eeb1b9f7e3e63bd1eecb87b9b00b0e12146a88f59331c4b35e9638255d023e", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a car, three couches, a toaster, a microwave, a stove, a lamp, two chairs, and an oven. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a car, three couches, a toaster, a microwave, a stove, a lamp, two chairs and an oven. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 11.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4722.82, "reasoner_ms": 1827.48, "tts_ms": 26.45, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6576.78, "total_processing_ms": 7155.14 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 779, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 59 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "fa6f9f16f7f942894ae6adfd19467f7b77a0a67e31f572d2c1ccfea29e6a7c0b", "started_sha256": "0c346c966822d0201ef48ed39a017fb05fc4f643db1c3ca4e5daffd16b24ce41", "original_grade_sha256": "6c618f0d6af1b52906072d2320d8af1c37a447604ef6ae54728b6676b9b749bb", "input_original_sha256": "fa6f9f16f7f942894ae6adfd19467f7b77a0a67e31f572d2c1ccfea29e6a7c0b", "input_wav_sha256": "6aade202bf2cf2445e0de47c045e302f1bdcf31536a997b59c4123aeca74e774", "input_pcm_sha256": "f95916a98a4fbd31328f39a7034af6ce3b11e034b0300304869b49293e8ebf5c", "output_wav_sha256": "b06d3f4118a9308035354bdcc27cbc50f3439020086009ff0e0e98e4775f6e2c", "output_pcm_sha256": "a3a988142a5f29d824c4503530587cec80524012655ebf23897d7cdb8d3ad086", "result_sha256": "f415392e45f977539d1a53f395e0d4cd9d8ed9273994652ed4f3c24780b3dde8" } }, { "id": 958, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "26e3522416136f796445e5c9516e35e11f280cf8c5d1353c162258c041a9ab94", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "26e3522416136f796445e5c9516e35e11f280cf8c5d1353c162258c041a9ab94", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Inga tells the truth. Shalanda says Inga tells the truth. Phoebe says Shalanda tells the truth. Krista says Phoebe lies. Alejandro says Krista lies. Does Alejandro tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Inga tells the truth. Shalonda says Inga tells the truth. Phoebe says Shalonda tells the truth. Krista says Phoebe lies. Alejandro says Krista lies. Does Alejandro tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6138.67, "reasoner_ms": 2318.18, "tts_ms": 23.27, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8480.15, "total_processing_ms": 9021.07 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 849, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 104 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f68faed3d2a76a929dce74aeb3c023a59abccd9ff8a4dbb66a08ae8487414d21", "started_sha256": "5472716c827c83ecea81e5ce207dab2ba60db6970f4e5972305a6ec0e1809a98", "original_grade_sha256": "b1680758d26bb9475b9413dfb3715b592da81dd2610349da9dc18263d43debd8", "input_original_sha256": "f68faed3d2a76a929dce74aeb3c023a59abccd9ff8a4dbb66a08ae8487414d21", "input_wav_sha256": "cda3ec7c006d494808bb1674f114e693f711b7fcf067a0b7bbf0df20586ee9a2", "input_pcm_sha256": "f7f5728f26ff23b5b775e697af4217c4dbe350728994465f16a21274bfa5271d", "output_wav_sha256": "e1780522da6897889c6fc754275068184a32327be1f8a743be44335954c9f5b2", "output_pcm_sha256": "2cffef31e2d7d571dbf6ae58621656fb1ffedfcbf32ce3999074665bf70e56e0", "result_sha256": "631f00e3fd8fc22e2dae375b275a00f2a56ecfccc0a2e320843ab7087c98685d" } }, { "id": 204, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ed22ccb93f2ce7511a2c6168c67b3176d6a5c18a0be0fb70af3f3d9b8b2099bf", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ed22ccb93f2ce7511a2c6168c67b3176d6a5c18a0be0fb70af3f3d9b8b2099bf", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, every stepbrother of Joan is a schoolmate of Reyes. Hence, every schoolmate of Reyes is a stepbrother of Joan. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, every stepbrother of Joan is a schoolmate of Reyes. Hence, every schoolmate of Reyes is a stepbrother of Joan. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6729.05, "reasoner_ms": 1353.82, "tts_ms": 25.41, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8108.31, "total_processing_ms": 8619.97 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 892, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 10 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "62b5a27fccea0ef45911ea3e386143cb7b49c321eeebcbb97460466d17da4e80", "started_sha256": "9d4d734f53291f711ee39dd1507de6a6fd0fa29b4995041851d5a7a858fc944e", "original_grade_sha256": "5059e6b9a704eeb2f50d735bea011a71ce0d24fe5a6f03f1c7989f9f26001ce1", "input_original_sha256": "62b5a27fccea0ef45911ea3e386143cb7b49c321eeebcbb97460466d17da4e80", "input_wav_sha256": "0b9ba08a24429f85b6d653f3dead5ffdc86d4bc86c85f0d7c6a7e6a554f24243", "input_pcm_sha256": "ca11ff8d61391e626c856e320a7291bf45d34184e27302779142c27c7b473fbb", "output_wav_sha256": "bdd78b01b4ea626a94f0c8a5a1b36a36be5b64192bb487d117ff81bdde0291c7", "output_pcm_sha256": "710f17d92a2ea0c332c28d8b4add6ac40b1ca128f1a1b1fbbdaab03012b08213", "result_sha256": "c955166f8f75c29abb1bd39b23936fd80b382fd21fcf443a33c3f89095f28d8b" } }, { "id": 415, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3e38fca357d2c84191e30af068522805741f2f7487bdeecc452dcfcd37a35c3e", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3e38fca357d2c84191e30af068522805741f2f7487bdeecc452dcfcd37a35c3e", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take ten steps. Turn around. Take ten steps. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take 10 steps. Turn around. Take 10 steps. Options? Yes? No? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5271.78, "reasoner_ms": 1356.98, "tts_ms": 24.56, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6653.35, "total_processing_ms": 7259.5 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 781, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "adc82a8ca41461048e6debec25c43c21008f45383eb48e000291408773eae431", "started_sha256": "43520e0a74d83e050f33517116178fac1ed267d656ee83b078d61ff5b9840102", "original_grade_sha256": "6af30e2eb5131ce0e588234b36bb93c04df9657368ef7c17244e9c5fd17ec27f", "input_original_sha256": "adc82a8ca41461048e6debec25c43c21008f45383eb48e000291408773eae431", "input_wav_sha256": "e9fd714831276a1a7440640b476eb165860e8eb38230ec1c87d5e722d44a70b7", "input_pcm_sha256": "c14f0cd89ec09b63e336fe12455999c03eff7f6608ef689953a605658c60710d", "output_wav_sha256": "456395aa0a395cccbf79860bb55f17388c9189cc290584cdeb41c73381a8dcab", "output_pcm_sha256": "eb7fd1313e3adb633e2b7d7ae4d7a27a20dc2cd3c7c827cc23f26b1cf5b1f0ae", "result_sha256": "4a16aa7ff8b7102323bd771bd2e6f03b2b2aba24940e327493c8539cd32177d5" } }, { "id": 726, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "8", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8b2662f575f81d3914448c40c81bce4b271d97936e6923806f67d1c18092cf3e", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8b2662f575f81d3914448c40c81bce4b271d97936e6923806f67d1c18092cf3e", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have three drums, a flute, a clarinet, two violins, and a trumpet. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have three drums, a flute, a clarinet, two violins, and a trumpet. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 8.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5060.06, "reasoner_ms": 1834.34, "tts_ms": 25.18, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6919.61, "total_processing_ms": 7532.74 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 763, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 47 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "43a95f2bb984833f5ace4d976f4d18d4e442a19fe000aaa2727efe1be1ab9e44", "started_sha256": "30db407f08bd3b86b1fe9fc74f4a7bfb2083b65c086c774de601b0b565f8107d", "original_grade_sha256": "f3d2a1992699b39afc23e8063a4baa5cdc9c2848a2af731575b0a0043d34f3ee", "input_original_sha256": "43a95f2bb984833f5ace4d976f4d18d4e442a19fe000aaa2727efe1be1ab9e44", "input_wav_sha256": "d76ed191e8744c2e07dedb5194c0a724e8b0a8dd1a8e8f78f215168e37ef7f75", "input_pcm_sha256": "d5b36029548588e61f20fa15fce5794f79ffb3f4bb925c1cdc9752c6ed90b152", "output_wav_sha256": "62cc6f145d0dd48dc4d6c8606a14016851766b00ee6f9d9c8348c1b9f7928406", "output_pcm_sha256": "6469301299fad144d3d371420e894773494f428403d05262c4cacebe098f8ee3", "result_sha256": "42836f66f49dd3b6deb65df5b24027f4b22a62a1545c3017e45f5df76810da37" } }, { "id": 931, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ab94b27cc18ac8381b5a6bae5528e0b640f4a8c3a8ec63359f17e39c246772ae", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ab94b27cc18ac8381b5a6bae5528e0b640f4a8c3a8ec63359f17e39c246772ae", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Millicent tells the truth. Kaye says Millicent tells the truth. Conception says Kaye lies. Sal says Conception lies. Tamika says Sal lies. Does Tamika tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Millicent tells the truth. Kay says Millicent tells the truth. Conception says Kay lies. Sal says Conception lies. Tamika says Sal lies. Does Tamika tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5646.35, "reasoner_ms": 2334.01, "tts_ms": 23.7, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8004.08, "total_processing_ms": 8562.83 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 830, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 119 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "cf96f665a9cac411b9229390d2f98d95ae67e1b096841385f4b7b97115e0b367", "started_sha256": "dbbd7839b1a2ada301387ecfcfbf3c59a7269ffef08e69aff9044c40348ed789", "original_grade_sha256": "9e990f37e2d1bfb0169bc7c46c1fa29ceb4f7da7a2165dfa86c85562e8676832", "input_original_sha256": "cf96f665a9cac411b9229390d2f98d95ae67e1b096841385f4b7b97115e0b367", "input_wav_sha256": "a549d51268803b06bff482b8a1f77d3f406de6d9e136bf1e5b1f4ccefd95cf2a", "input_pcm_sha256": "9d0180d9e2cddffa75a6a74bc8f7881c6e818d7c693c335a1eea292a73557186", "output_wav_sha256": "2a9b8a5b939d430e12a4bf57b2cdc0b513de9cd361ac1e13289dc0bb2e3be97b", "output_pcm_sha256": "aac0d1240b1d17017238c3fc32e9830ac6484686fe9fddc95060ca487b05c1f5", "result_sha256": "5e676244ae32f4a31ead1984d2ff180d109dc017eb2fc0d0479c1fb16a2d3960" } }, { "id": 180, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0a383d9348b629800fe802caa161706f0cd50294b28ed08293eb87e6b35e0472", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0a383d9348b629800fe802caa161706f0cd50294b28ed08293eb87e6b35e0472", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, being a close friend of Samuel is sufficient for not being a brother of Jeff. In consequence, no brother of Jeff is a close friend of Samuel. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nhere comes a perfectly valid argument to start with being a close friend of samuel is sufficient for not being a brother of jeff in consequence no brother of jeff is a close friend of samuel is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9022.75, "reasoner_ms": 2034.31, "tts_ms": 29.2, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11086.29, "total_processing_ms": 11721.35 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 883, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 91 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "c98c5ee87f9a376b8683fbcb769b37355e183958480d216fac00980a0286a8d1", "started_sha256": "c4617498a6f9af27df40f486b37a82f3cbb16edd7eded1cffb907f714be3a41f", "original_grade_sha256": "3edc8214674429a354b7d0e4483538dd5c79ef05d2f853b602e7c235ea7fd8dd", "input_original_sha256": "c98c5ee87f9a376b8683fbcb769b37355e183958480d216fac00980a0286a8d1", "input_wav_sha256": "e0d7fc6a6c13a5a312b4536c0378816da48f510243305d574519ddb71f116a93", "input_pcm_sha256": "7e9f4d8fde3de8155d09cfb98928578af8a40a3328d7fc43b2b71a56b550ffea", "output_wav_sha256": "329aca1627489e941fb5cce8165bd525f54eb8cc5e26cc1ddc738b18d032a55e", "output_pcm_sha256": "9a446e0ce83adae0a52e3599e0f353cc6d7c2d0e3f407e9fb7cebecb57cacbe8", "result_sha256": "b25d1862336ed7e92782ca5d2cc4c2fca388c7c62d345d9814168a8b8b927589" } }, { "id": 269, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "db52f5eca369e8d4bece62f8b03ecefa7fd1850465c30966007d196d2018fbd3", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "db52f5eca369e8d4bece62f8b03ecefa7fd1850465c30966007d196d2018fbd3", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take eight steps, turn left, take nine steps, take seven steps, turn around. Options: yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take eight steps, turn left. Take nine steps, take seven steps, turn around. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5187.5, "reasoner_ms": 2087.43, "tts_ms": 20.19, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7295.15, "total_processing_ms": 7858.87 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 795, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 57 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "47004102f8fd3048bb5819e1a2a29c1165fe60c991280d7ba11605f48dc848a8", "started_sha256": "49a4a071d09d7a398b41bc9ed332e5b8bb206e27f4f3bc0c29c566fb2a3d8ad7", "original_grade_sha256": "5edfd6ebc52fa2d8b2c2717d6c2057c234bb79251c04639bef202c50471a485c", "input_original_sha256": "47004102f8fd3048bb5819e1a2a29c1165fe60c991280d7ba11605f48dc848a8", "input_wav_sha256": "3d759bcb421b932d4030983fbd2764589d4aff6001bdd148c10fda10aeb5c6ea", "input_pcm_sha256": "57e96752a9feead7e95ea3637bb054672f1b7f7dade9e46fc84dcd8963a6cd22", "output_wav_sha256": "68b4f7004bb6deaea54ed9b91995befe9d5f42649cf789d8e7e933afda5d9df9", "output_pcm_sha256": "0a9a2daefcfaffd64b1e7cbd84c715d5599c76bce7f17a2f1bbc66a405326df4", "result_sha256": "0784f01729d37c27b03d4f0489f0f903f5cc7b204e27c050ebfc3e51ff0c196c" } }, { "id": 509, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "10", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8dc24a5cb6b8217bc0f833f9fd808e370263d0e657d6bcd0b9b3f8497947cd95", "normalized_answer": "10" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8dc24a5cb6b8217bc0f833f9fd808e370263d0e657d6bcd0b9b3f8497947cd95", "normalized_answer": "10" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a stove, a chair, two tables, a toaster, a fridge, three beds, and a couch. How many objects do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a stove, a chair, two tables, a toaster, a fridge, three beds, and a couch. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 10.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4869.85, "reasoner_ms": 1721.34, "tts_ms": 20.77, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6611.99, "total_processing_ms": 7202.37 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 769, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 53 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "66b9dc39c786ded97df1606457c6956c0452d816dd12d145c363ec91bdbf06a5", "started_sha256": "ba7917cf906ce8225fbb8fd7de9b26a244e6776b40f6255bc6b3fc961c37588c", "original_grade_sha256": "8b83a0af59ec4e70ca3b11c0473592f61d6b486f0603d2e5c87a110a789054b4", "input_original_sha256": "66b9dc39c786ded97df1606457c6956c0452d816dd12d145c363ec91bdbf06a5", "input_wav_sha256": "7824bc5cb0d8bf4a04629878ff962862e30323b80f6f8c9936d98df0635cbf40", "input_pcm_sha256": "011737c0b2293f7dd652ccd99560fd048f1bb1d1ceef537e337b8c30187db9c6", "output_wav_sha256": "b813b5e0d2886c1d47439d0fe2f09786e60ec6b300a3af4895694b572fdf8c4e", "output_pcm_sha256": "e4bd1ac388cf57a38d36bf731c4dd4409bd32f6e6080dcc9792532bf20ecd4fa", "result_sha256": "024706b090cb0adf24fe44fc9e3c9bd2413df7671a29dc449ffce525283da6c4" } }, { "id": 770, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9e397f07c968e3b3dfa4b93beeac7716b26b708eb1e1063950fa267d297b1690", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9e397f07c968e3b3dfa4b93beeac7716b26b708eb1e1063950fa267d297b1690", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Raymond tells the truth. Sal says Raymond lies. Alexis says Sal lies. Helene says Alexis lies. Eleanor says Helene lies. Does Eleanor tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Raymond tells the truth. Sal says Raymond lies. Alexis says Sal lies. Helene says Alexis lies. Eleanor says Helene lies. Does Eleanor tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5445.45, "reasoner_ms": 2122.82, "tts_ms": 25.09, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7593.38, "total_processing_ms": 8230.69 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 829, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 71 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b67d6f20e1e78a87c0120b4938638ff551d6c68265f36fdaab5045d5c60983bd", "started_sha256": "c1367f4ffd4f37c2b1536eaaee889727cc3d47729586c6557f008f18b2bb9b73", "original_grade_sha256": "f80a003fcff0056724fe25fce3cae040a6240a8f8e7d8b5faf273626920522a4", "input_original_sha256": "b67d6f20e1e78a87c0120b4938638ff551d6c68265f36fdaab5045d5c60983bd", "input_wav_sha256": "878093d660326ee915fcf391bef788ea44e14f4e8cdf54ab4bde675570b9fbea", "input_pcm_sha256": "e1af1b3ef2629d9aa2ecc6e461b24d50e94e46e46d1a2ec6d6e00f88e90cfaaa", "output_wav_sha256": "c004cabfcbe0866f92a5793dd0410607d10c1edb16ff09c88e6156110029cc95", "output_pcm_sha256": "6fcbc6435d74d42714fad5863df1808e15cfe4f06b7e403a576b0c316f43491a", "result_sha256": "4bd1e2010d35ae6997905ca79e599975bfcf90ca65266c8cca10342cd881fd47" } }, { "id": 97, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6e445ad77681c80dea12759be421814cd1967d14bf10a551663853e576f63ccd", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6e445ad77681c80dea12759be421814cd1967d14bf10a551663853e576f63ccd", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First premise: Being a regular consumer of Kiss My Face soap is necessary for being a regular user of Nag Champa soap. Second premise: Whoever is rare consumer of John Frieda shampoo is at least one of these, a regular consumer of Mrs. Meyer's soap, a regular user of Nag Champa soap, or a regular user of Rene Furterer shampoo. Third premise: No regular consumer of Mrs. Meyer's soap is a regular consumer of Kiss My Face soap. Therefore, whoever is a rare consumer of John Frieda shampoo is not a regular consumer of Kiss My Face soap or a regular user of Rene Furterer shampoo. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones, or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First premise, being a regular consumer of Kiss My Face soap is necessary for being a regular user of Nag Champa soap. Second premise, whoever is rare consumer of John Frieda shampoo is at least one of these, a regular consumer of Mrs. Meyers soap, a regular user of Nag Champa soap, or a regular user of Rene Furterer shampoo. Third premise. No regular consumer of Mrs. Meyer's soap is a regular consumer of Kiss My Face soap. Therefore, whoever is a rare consumer of John Frieda shampoo is not a regular consumer of Kiss My Face soap or a regular user of Rene Furterer shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid, Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 19910.13, "reasoner_ms": 11228.85, "tts_ms": 25.59, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 31164.6, "total_processing_ms": 31731.88 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1306, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 940 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b8645e30aea06d1bc0f012010d13000afaeedcc624af105789e27be76f4290e7", "started_sha256": "712acab2b0e0fdbdf716455143d22736ffc6433d6291b44b8f92a744d75ab905", "original_grade_sha256": "4076fd46e5b35d5d393094eb98bc20bca4f1ba589ae52e9814c89f43d67f70fd", "input_original_sha256": "b8645e30aea06d1bc0f012010d13000afaeedcc624af105789e27be76f4290e7", "input_wav_sha256": "4b083f16340942b53092df63a3c3248e98e5548418a676d54d41de54ea853b37", "input_pcm_sha256": "066f5c130bbe6576971a8661cebac75b114b2df667a56fd4874592cb42643964", "output_wav_sha256": "c316b7cc0e8e614569a1ff6e185804ece9b670c1876928de3c549ec6767a895b", "output_pcm_sha256": "baaf8384f7ac65d492c3f5e8559c34825308ef557d18c360fe7a12f188b43dc1", "result_sha256": "8b2f75c940c04fb159591ed23552bfd44caed154561841453c73397aabe5a129" } }, { "id": 427, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0bca240fde12015d3ae2e16a7d9ebe01f15de58dc7c3832e8b112121a4a67605", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0bca240fde12015d3ae2e16a7d9ebe01f15de58dc7c3832e8b112121a4a67605", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps backward. Take eight steps forward. Take ten steps forward. Take eight steps backward. Take eight steps right. Take six steps backward. Take seven steps forward. Take eight steps forward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps backward. Take eight steps forward. Take ten steps forward. Take eight steps backward. Take eight steps right. Take six steps backward. Take seven steps forward. Take eight steps forward. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7307.22, "reasoner_ms": 2913.2, "tts_ms": 24.01, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10244.46, "total_processing_ms": 10914.32 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 892, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 136 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3240f9fd2b34bb8914b7a63459df78acb29ef612321f5841afcfeec54796a95e", "started_sha256": "a9a5ac02f33d20004e73e3644571749317d1f8ee937488247144de1f30f0201d", "original_grade_sha256": "5bb10540d77779a1e4ec33d77908577b93dc4a183a381e990f887febbd99b50d", "input_original_sha256": "3240f9fd2b34bb8914b7a63459df78acb29ef612321f5841afcfeec54796a95e", "input_wav_sha256": "e9155563766f64a4cd0bfd3dfd90a94c0717208ac38a94dd3040b56e7c80bca9", "input_pcm_sha256": "abae3afd39f7eeb1c5b1a521f83bf252d1182e18ee66db27ee60c157cfdbdff5", "output_wav_sha256": "c0b389b3888aac76eca3dbdfa88156fd2a0ffafac749cd7516382560e58e688b", "output_pcm_sha256": "bc483171c04d7b2b36623b8ef7ba9a6814e39ff2bf737bf079086b549788d43d", "result_sha256": "a4495d234e789b8d21460bd4fdf36d125433a0fdd08bffa5c70ef4029d4c4271" } }, { "id": 739, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "12", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "95031051a3df128d93b4974ce73f3c8ebb7bac4462dc1cc9743d532ea74a2f9f", "normalized_answer": "12" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "95031051a3df128d93b4974ce73f3c8ebb7bac4462dc1cc9743d532ea74a2f9f", "normalized_answer": "12" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a yam, a garlic, a lettuce head, a potato, a lamp, a carrot, two heads of broccoli, a stalk of celery, an onion, and three cabbages. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a yam, a garlic, a lettuce head, a potato, a lamp, a carrot, two heads of broccoli, a stalk of celery, an onion, and three cabbages. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 12.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5872.21, "reasoner_ms": 3359.77, "tts_ms": 24.48, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9256.5, "total_processing_ms": 9781.09 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 828, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 211 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "32c78c13ca5e9893b585d25351c59e7e9cf0bebeffd2f6a200e93f393928b007", "started_sha256": "a3669b577f9fdda615be0681c1ae0a3b980b3cb999348156157166f397f22967", "original_grade_sha256": "55a7e7634871f4e36570f12cf341438edf36074beb8dce35e47378aad12f9099", "input_original_sha256": "32c78c13ca5e9893b585d25351c59e7e9cf0bebeffd2f6a200e93f393928b007", "input_wav_sha256": "de0066309c20099dd00aab15d78f792ecf47df36453baf4ae409e98e0d7a1cd2", "input_pcm_sha256": "2ca83406c1a604208cbddc2ee72c4a050a35397cf72e73dea348f6012d2cb06e", "output_wav_sha256": "b17d8335f1413ab1db79577f0e7da7a1c585d7617f691faf9f62aa0800b46a96", "output_pcm_sha256": "16849495922b57705a3e397ee417ee922b0d970a8c175eef9ceeeb63567a1736", "result_sha256": "a66a7717f5806582b51367df977254cd14ad88d7b998449f91badb6accc767ac" } }, { "id": 911, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "81d13da28ae94bcf630327b9bfce4812f484deec002b433a972c23c7bf239e92", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "81d13da28ae94bcf630327b9bfce4812f484deec002b433a972c23c7bf239e92", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Saima tells the truth. Jerry says Saima tells the truth. Sal says Jerry lies. Inga says Sal lies. Willian says Inga lies. Does Willian tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Saima tells the truth. Jerry says Saima tells the truth. Sal says Jerry lies. Inga says Sal lies. William says Inga lies. Does William tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5558.3, "reasoner_ms": 2079.93, "tts_ms": 24.2, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7662.46, "total_processing_ms": 8232.25 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 819, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 103 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5462450e4b62e3e81d66d8b58ddf5c67ef3883dd925795af759158a29ee59fce", "started_sha256": "34c76b7929b92e37118be16685b197fe651b12fae76ab8089206e88d10c8169c", "original_grade_sha256": "7835942996503f1efe4ac690ecf0f252f5fd216e027e908e1b7d8d67e77b6920", "input_original_sha256": "5462450e4b62e3e81d66d8b58ddf5c67ef3883dd925795af759158a29ee59fce", "input_wav_sha256": "0d74ed2142af55c42987327c6856c4421b945034339fd600598e803ee4bc5631", "input_pcm_sha256": "aa1ed09c4250578a4ccc441adcc11420e2f520a3eaffeefd486d49f174fe96cc", "output_wav_sha256": "809d67cd38223580b5550b07464db6dee379b514076caa8a00c0b4be2d5348c1", "output_pcm_sha256": "5d453c6890b5efc84bf8b6b611bb4f1bde74c8a505933aab4e7f634ae1d13d16", "result_sha256": "56b98ad3763ff6b1705897d8e3d4659d1e210c2ff3505659cde04da9539b59ba" } }, { "id": 155, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0af7b4a4e4eec0d18a57c68e9ce0a34ebe6b61c925656cb8831864bb7abc2b6e", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0af7b4a4e4eec0d18a57c68e9ce0a34ebe6b61c925656cb8831864bb7abc2b6e", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First of all, being a loyal buyer of Clairol shampoo is necessary for being a loyal buyer of Bed Head shampoo. Next, being a loyal buyer of Bed Head shampoo is sufficient for being an occasional purchaser of Infusium shampoo. Plus, whoever is loyal buyer of Bed Head shampoo is at least one of these: an occasional purchaser of Infusium shampoo, a loyal buyer of Cetaphil soap, or a loyal buyer of Clairol shampoo. All this entails that everyone who is a loyal buyer of Bed Head shampoo is a loyal buyer of Cetaphil soap too. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First of all, being a loyal buyer of Clairol shampoo is necessary for being a loyal buyer of Bedhead shampoo. Next, being a loyal buyer of Bedhead shampoo is sufficient for being an occasional purchaser of Infusium shampoo. Plus, whoever is loyal buyer of Bedhead shampoo is at at least one of these, an occasional purchaser of infusium shampoo, a loyal buyer of Cetaphil soap, or a loyal buyer of Clairo shampoo. All this entails that everyone who is a loyal buyer of bedhead shampoo is a loyal buyer of Cetaphil soap too. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 16004.04, "reasoner_ms": 2555.9, "tts_ms": 32.45, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 18592.43, "total_processing_ms": 19318.44 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1197, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 143 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d1137d2491141a2b29114149905067721bfe36ec3556eec6c05daf58901a2b13", "started_sha256": "b39558825ace7cb1a181452ad0d278ac9430491283143083a81a6be49ef7f8d3", "original_grade_sha256": "28809b43bcd1a71c946a18e4375a26c7ed29a12ce213fc60bcbb6049294776fb", "input_original_sha256": "d1137d2491141a2b29114149905067721bfe36ec3556eec6c05daf58901a2b13", "input_wav_sha256": "48fb838cc54b9e3f2c26e392e27b442eef6d13f30ebe46193a639cd711bcd018", "input_pcm_sha256": "d78599b84772691f89f1a162d3e51cceebd66c7f81ae1479f7e8b6d6d81a8e35", "output_wav_sha256": "3333c7ba01c910743dae190216934be2587ca42470f67277f820a0409847f169", "output_pcm_sha256": "659cdffbeba1fcf70e11597e28bb7ddde95f1ed7ec310677400e1121324501d3", "result_sha256": "b93c527c006c1b1c4c7cb03ff2069637867a50d57810b6ad2cb32768adbd4e2b" } }, { "id": 405, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7e22ed0a3a390a22a874509168451104c91fdc09abf3c1dadfdef2f7d2d136c8", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7e22ed0a3a390a22a874509168451104c91fdc09abf3c1dadfdef2f7d2d136c8", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps right. Take eight steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps right. Take eight steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7370.89, "reasoner_ms": 2186.41, "tts_ms": 41.55, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9598.88, "total_processing_ms": 10631.94 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 785, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "32562415ab71d092abccadda12f42d669e83db77b7ab5ed20ae94d44d54c90f0", "started_sha256": "23c56d68b61cd8351894464d633b217658c1ffb915345ac1ed4097a571fdacac", "original_grade_sha256": "a6d6366216a405b5332b2ab1582ed982b5b3282b60132b80368f4c6349de0006", "input_original_sha256": "32562415ab71d092abccadda12f42d669e83db77b7ab5ed20ae94d44d54c90f0", "input_wav_sha256": "e9ef92c440ba8201562d652997804169ed46a077c02561a1c2b757f95ce6959a", "input_pcm_sha256": "a0adfbe173eb24f99ebe2b08fc0b388d3eefa2438b1ce6ffe8644364b73c8326", "output_wav_sha256": "6aa4c00d4f5dfc5683ddcf3decd2374419cb03fd17d313fd186e5772529ba4ff", "output_pcm_sha256": "bc509e8e0c433bc32b63a835bfbe588eaa53f1706d3ef7b0062b40418e2c2baa", "result_sha256": "612207dc7666c8d3afd01f41b541e92790b035fce40c19945c11b5d9766b1e4a" } }, { "id": 704, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "4", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "913129550a4c0f701e50d8dd25a55211b7386429720943ebdb7c707f978bd16f", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "913129550a4c0f701e50d8dd25a55211b7386429720943ebdb7c707f978bd16f", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have two lamps and two microwaves. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have two lamps and two microwaves. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 4.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4530.04, "reasoner_ms": 1270.28, "tts_ms": 25.08, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5825.42, "total_processing_ms": 6579.47 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 730, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "16709fa65f89b990c0ddd65059d5285294104150b27f668837a40dfa2a65984c", "started_sha256": "b83bd92918bec1ad4ef997f13ba20d4d760f1f6d2306cc94271ff06dd577ac5f", "original_grade_sha256": "e51fb64c28e0bd65698346e5dabb9f15c13843561fc287cadcd0e860f5193a6c", "input_original_sha256": "16709fa65f89b990c0ddd65059d5285294104150b27f668837a40dfa2a65984c", "input_wav_sha256": "c249617ac91d2866994dc8516b5aa64e2dbecc7078a61595fe2c37a8aaa27b04", "input_pcm_sha256": "a77d1a231391c81f7d0411f9b7fdda55f3490fba86d623155bb857740cf84c82", "output_wav_sha256": "577a2662515020cf449bde6a85baae1ca606f4f54c1e1af552e0da92ff6bc152", "output_pcm_sha256": "69dbeb033d16a5e272f29a8d4ed352bd005a91b719fa870eb572bd4d0b6c7520", "result_sha256": "3c764a369b8cf421808ed88dcb12fdd9340aa57b852df29d4e87e83d895addcf" } }, { "id": 885, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4c0997cf0146545df4cb7f4ed936d20d24affa1dccbb99758e75013884f10151", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4c0997cf0146545df4cb7f4ed936d20d24affa1dccbb99758e75013884f10151", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Osvaldo lies. Gwen says Osvaldo lies. Michael says Gwen lies. Eleanor says Michael lies. Sal says Eleanor tells the truth. Does Sal tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion Osvaldo lies. Gwen says Osvaldo lies. Michael says Gwen lies. Eleanor says Michael lies. Sal says Eleanor tells the truth. Does Sal tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6129.71, "reasoner_ms": 2350.44, "tts_ms": 24.96, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8505.12, "total_processing_ms": 9157.46 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 836, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 122 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1fee9fc840d93e7be792b4a03a111e01bad771875b8d6ef4e2951a824d9bd5af", "started_sha256": "4690ea95f2c5abf1595a319d7d0b52453ad244a482889d1b86f05753db22706f", "original_grade_sha256": "e317546849a2f68f518e8257b80c2f39e2185539d18ed9019a7a7e891c53ccd0", "input_original_sha256": "1fee9fc840d93e7be792b4a03a111e01bad771875b8d6ef4e2951a824d9bd5af", "input_wav_sha256": "12a1abc4cb65be0e92cf340f20d2f67381dbcb55c400a48360d85e51fdfc55e9", "input_pcm_sha256": "0df707065f112be58ebe9faebee72596280fc6e88b7d596f2598029ae900e76c", "output_wav_sha256": "7929c8a4fe49c082d2715237608ab6ead422384bc6d04400da57e822580b182e", "output_pcm_sha256": "8704c23e817f32974f4a088d475ec99025d017fd684eb081674d7fef7fbb0199", "result_sha256": "ef02510b533460d272c01cb59c6a8a294cb2ae5e7053574d3ece7a02608a06c3" } }, { "id": 171, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "212417bac00fd2d4a4e709c8ea7abc8f1d1bf13cd515501568eff74758a44dbd", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "212417bac00fd2d4a4e709c8ea7abc8f1d1bf13cd515501568eff74758a44dbd", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To be an ingredient of plumeria milk bath or an ingredient of hot rod red is necessary for being an ingredient of trugal vivid. Every ingredient of Bioglitz Color 6G is not an ingredient of plumeria milk bath or not an ingredient of hot rod red. All this entails that being an ingredient of trugal vivid is sufficient for not being an ingredient of Bioglitz Color 6G. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To be an ingredient of Plumeria milkbath or an ingredient of hot rod red is necessary for being an ingredient of Trugel vivid. Every ingredient of Bioglit's color 6G is not an ingredient of Plumeria milkbath or not an ingredient of hot rod red. All this entails that being an ingredient of Trugel vivid is sufficient for not being an ingredient of Bioglit's color 6G. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12977.69, "reasoner_ms": 3834.92, "tts_ms": 48.86, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 16861.51, "total_processing_ms": 17513.0 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1064, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 219 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "00e575bbbcc88b155d57ccb492c0508988d111fecdb4dbe5e083f0aeb0f51f3b", "started_sha256": "bf915beef74d25651396e7e5be78df2f989cd466aaab91b8c165522f3e0e917e", "original_grade_sha256": "51fea671d1fbea1b8623d888a2c706ffab2155cf9dfbd594c2ec82952d9f0745", "input_original_sha256": "00e575bbbcc88b155d57ccb492c0508988d111fecdb4dbe5e083f0aeb0f51f3b", "input_wav_sha256": "1c23981fbbe54b3997819ea502192bca7b13a029e6de89df3f5b68b6a014fce3", "input_pcm_sha256": "28dca6d6b7a7911c0e747bfa45d7d1a2a21679fcea59e3f5d7ccd59712b0acf0", "output_wav_sha256": "711f54df9cb61d353da698e12e79a94c13bdb9087b1f4d7ced661af4fd825c19", "output_pcm_sha256": "c3391d8725a937f925f5f896f854d722a44af99642aaf508e05abe99c1ed88f3", "result_sha256": "da5e98ac609f2c4d4a5f7ee588846605fde75d59c206261d46409abbc26fadf2" } }, { "id": 381, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7fd8045ef75486265fe85e2989335cfd26c2244475fcef11f0bd5872393a8654", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7fd8045ef75486265fe85e2989335cfd26c2244475fcef11f0bd5872393a8654", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take one step right. Take two steps forward. Take two steps right. Take four steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take one step right. Take two steps forward. Take two steps right. Take four steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6238.45, "reasoner_ms": 2206.61, "tts_ms": 32.02, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8477.11, "total_processing_ms": 9103.28 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 809, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 79 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8002f174c80717e5ae7e4198d8177a4275ade1da7d9eea87de63b82488ad552f", "started_sha256": "59a542d37cd1fac1a0489a51000b0de36a95b9c130add8950f567ac723865e4a", "original_grade_sha256": "6d2a2cbe53fe03df9dd8090f47dd55ac5b995ca8a12b731daaead958ec26e65b", "input_original_sha256": "8002f174c80717e5ae7e4198d8177a4275ade1da7d9eea87de63b82488ad552f", "input_wav_sha256": "4bc5d2e576ac4a7cf33d9464c4cff98f43e566daafefcef9980426c37bbae997", "input_pcm_sha256": "ca0033e551e7c8b89e6d3e95862062dfe10558bedd182043d0509724e51665ca", "output_wav_sha256": "3da3f6dc4ce8ccd287871b881ed948caa0f2fd530afc1d38ad240f65eff29e0b", "output_pcm_sha256": "e0e54d83e657937649bf0394679570f86d64b6cab289a6f0223c100d6e33a465", "result_sha256": "dbaed51e9a86d3889de6411bb61400a2453143d109eef20228829809ffdb2b24" } }, { "id": 639, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "02ee9a785fd8e0ff342ef7b9a6b14746401fb7c1a9536ffd349bf87f9e8def7f", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "02ee9a785fd8e0ff342ef7b9a6b14746401fb7c1a9536ffd349bf87f9e8def7f", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a yam, a carrot, a lettuce head, a potato, four garlics, and a head of broccoli. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a yam, a carrot, a lettuce head, a potato, four garlics, and a head of broccoli. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 9.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5017.97, "reasoner_ms": 1809.71, "tts_ms": 22.33, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6850.04, "total_processing_ms": 7455.44 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 779, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 53 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "9faa9dfa7684d4e7493dd40b1fd8a72edea037e17d493ec8f7ae404ea25a6929", "started_sha256": "b8828ffaf954b2ceee77d7dbf50ae4fc8472ca0f4ad0ff15f1950effc781ab8d", "original_grade_sha256": "29b93de145a2cde4598d46d569a0d873f357790d10f0a554294fad297bafe60d", "input_original_sha256": "9faa9dfa7684d4e7493dd40b1fd8a72edea037e17d493ec8f7ae404ea25a6929", "input_wav_sha256": "56a99ab5f9f621a7e3e3e5a291d20e87f9a439a81ea7b576765e9edf08e00a0d", "input_pcm_sha256": "26bf9bdfde21c7f3ab875bb4ae776001489f85ceea9138425edae78132c8e7f9", "output_wav_sha256": "7147b9063a8b9a9fb1d7e914ba2491d40b6bed5c2d34941bda59b5f98b712a4f", "output_pcm_sha256": "2bcbdbb93be2ebe2daa0fc52b16ce0460bf42806b01e6aedcab889119e1f57c6", "result_sha256": "db0e9331f4301a1d8a8bda874a687872323698c0b501e4c3cd9cdbdc3b343451" } }, { "id": 935, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d2040d79d67b5b72d37090186a1e7783ea25627878f131018e30e9ab8b5af6b3", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d2040d79d67b5b72d37090186a1e7783ea25627878f131018e30e9ab8b5af6b3", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Lita lies. Millicent says Lita tells the truth. Rashida says Millicent lies. Maybelle says Rashida tells the truth. Shonda says Maybelle lies. Does Shonda tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nLeda lies. Millicent says Leda tells the truth. Rashida says Millicent lies. Maybel says Rashida tells the truth. Shonda says Maybel lies. Does Shonda tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5510.43, "reasoner_ms": 2223.35, "tts_ms": 19.52, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7753.33, "total_processing_ms": 8548.27 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 834, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 130 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "c7fb754158c4467c79e776b3c8748cda0154dde9144d9039b9f12af4ef42c124", "started_sha256": "b47d922b9fe1778024497962f5d17de1405728edbe873aeaa36a91f9544e79ed", "original_grade_sha256": "d6207c041f21ad567942851b8636adee2d2ebe1a2e969162979294183c940f6a", "input_original_sha256": "c7fb754158c4467c79e776b3c8748cda0154dde9144d9039b9f12af4ef42c124", "input_wav_sha256": "1ffa0bcc2e15df1c92a9fe7b9f67951edf232a7f69e3432f9ac3174a8cfbc1e7", "input_pcm_sha256": "0ea9dc96b88a3c67fb7f98e02d46d351717566b9af2b5639a356dd4874b0c816", "output_wav_sha256": "5968e0229e1daa17b0e1b42b7d45935054180589737e59e439bc6b1039203906", "output_pcm_sha256": "d40ec038ae16c8b1724b80c90fc271599ae031de42deb30c5cd85049d1bafa51", "result_sha256": "a12085064c546c459c4c01f8a182535611da4380f246035d5376ec18c6647b65" } }, { "id": 224, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5ede0a091f5661f74c902fa569ebb41300b7818de0ff2313127fe707ac80aae6", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5ede0a091f5661f74c902fa569ebb41300b7818de0ff2313127fe707ac80aae6", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a fan of Liverpool? Are supporters of Real Madrid devotees of PSG? In European football, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of the mutual admiration and dislike. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First of all, being a follower of Lyngby BK is necessary for not being a critic of Real Madrid CF. Next, Luiz is a critic of Real Madrid CF. Therefore, it is not the case that Luiz is a follower of Lyngby BK. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Fred a fan of Liverpool? Are supporters of Real Madrid devotees of PSG? In European football, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of the mutual admiration and dislike. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations, first of all, being a follower of LYNGBYBK is necessary for not being a critic of Real Madrid CF. Next, Luiz is a critic of Real Real Madrid CF. Therefore, it is not the case that Luis is a follower of LYNGBYBK. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11883.2, "reasoner_ms": 3422.59, "tts_ms": 42.48, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15348.3, "total_processing_ms": 15879.16 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1098, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 179 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "11b8e0e6f072db1f7fd33a9c6684ac562b979c6b19e06318ec35e6e236b453bc", "started_sha256": "b6c459e8a389d71997d6abd2d190ffe9efea018ba8374e95aecc23e1dbadc2d7", "original_grade_sha256": "b3a17886e3d116387348bb63934a063797542dc682dafe436c0ffff51612f60c", "input_original_sha256": "11b8e0e6f072db1f7fd33a9c6684ac562b979c6b19e06318ec35e6e236b453bc", "input_wav_sha256": "a95b10064ac798f8660013d2395a0dd9c4aa4dc77cec2bd6179973b3eb0f3cd0", "input_pcm_sha256": "8ce65343b442fc98b53e24613043036f0f04608e71a9262763469ee033babe19", "output_wav_sha256": "cef66078cdcfb68ccd1eb15b3c77cb3a10d2c7dd8a83fd16a77b382c693fd7e9", "output_pcm_sha256": "1d6fd0c877f993f5bd744b6bd1f924f46f0178384a5b3bcc8195accf3281caec", "result_sha256": "40600eb981a94ef99c224ae538792d8a8ad0b0406efdfd11054a9481fc3ca352" } }, { "id": 334, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bcb0bd76bbc8c595dee169609ec44f29b03fd042e8b7a190a49ee54f3e107ba9", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bcb0bd76bbc8c595dee169609ec44f29b03fd042e8b7a190a49ee54f3e107ba9", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take one step backward. Take five steps forward. Take ten steps backward. Take nine steps forward. Take seven steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take one step backward. Take five steps forward. Take ten steps backward. Take nine steps forward. Take seven steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6100.3, "reasoner_ms": 1713.44, "tts_ms": 24.26, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7838.03, "total_processing_ms": 8389.76 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 836, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 45 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "c74fa7425ab81f9d0b24b2824a0660ec5a00b31079133b420da6832d56390618", "started_sha256": "bc1b2c5c30cd90766e45b9a94e7032b6f38e8d6379e47011918f6bffd365e355", "original_grade_sha256": "105705e0e5df1b5c28956ce7a573dfdb1d9f4a167d6d721bab9acd1fbfec06f6", "input_original_sha256": "c74fa7425ab81f9d0b24b2824a0660ec5a00b31079133b420da6832d56390618", "input_wav_sha256": "cc813eff0d36f4cd2a6e48745eda1c0eab7adac9a940459b1e385cab0cb8ba66", "input_pcm_sha256": "21a9914208d23c8f7b051948ed5c2817e3344155f82b1e14d121ab73ba2ee59b", "output_wav_sha256": "c905be0dfab8eccf2c33bd7ff46238945e09b9fc33095761d3de5757cfcdb277", "output_pcm_sha256": "8a0fa1ac41f445339495b8c7dae80ded68a1ff576aa7d0588fb3da1efa5bb8f2", "result_sha256": "c94143ac46a7b8911e17a3438423e712429a93e809fead09ed992a96a29f70b1" } }, { "id": 581, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "7", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "caadb636c6a2a0ea34704cb5bfc5b5c1b45d3d0cc7aa4ebe3e080173a6b66ebe", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "caadb636c6a2a0ea34704cb5bfc5b5c1b45d3d0cc7aa4ebe3e080173a6b66ebe", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a trombone, an accordion, four clarinets, and a trumpet. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a trombone, an accordion for clarinets, and a trumpet. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 7.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 3885.72, "reasoner_ms": 1545.44, "tts_ms": 19.43, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5450.62, "total_processing_ms": 5965.55 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 758, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 43 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "c267149a8ba810f8f431cc7d9a605bbd9a733841ad79de6c17f634240c7ef205", "started_sha256": "577a016d9931923a6cdb9f7b63f698dce9217d16c6e8c5e1613d92c747054a6f", "original_grade_sha256": "f91a59decaffb6b1f1452444d7efaeaade9575497ab2af3a52fe55883c20d5a1", "input_original_sha256": "c267149a8ba810f8f431cc7d9a605bbd9a733841ad79de6c17f634240c7ef205", "input_wav_sha256": "f5a5bb8c5c4922296f1ac51686d1c093238e6014f7d8345ddd6c93ba802e5422", "input_pcm_sha256": "6398eb7db967442be440a92978660aac5cbc97f1d877b370c0514cc8cf55d249", "output_wav_sha256": "033840492d71458fffdaa2ea44a3dbe9b5e8d7fc94051857ae324937c0b7c336", "output_pcm_sha256": "141f54b65580843f65880ca0084b21b05ae3d9b56a103389b04cee26a9863129", "result_sha256": "fdf2c247ff8467e1d42715d8b29b2ee784037f28e2ce1301518881b64ea17be4" } }, { "id": 966, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6cabd26a521d09b1b09e09ec571ea57664b4da75db84fea998b622565740333b", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6cabd26a521d09b1b09e09ec571ea57664b4da75db84fea998b622565740333b", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Candy lies. Millie says Candy tells the truth. Loreen says Millie tells the truth. Michaela says Loreen tells the truth. Amberly says Michaela lies. Does Amberly tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion candy lies millie says candy tells the truth lorene says millie tells the truth michaela says lorene tells the truth amberley says michaela lies does amberley tell the truth answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7414.53, "reasoner_ms": 2352.25, "tts_ms": 31.12, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9797.93, "total_processing_ms": 10412.96 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 818, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 116 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "086c89cc3794fe2729eb6a9795116b3aaa7226adb9b7f388d916f5cbe5e365cc", "started_sha256": "9b504cbd8b957c6aaf1dc814d976aef292796f60d3040c986f56f1026a5f62d0", "original_grade_sha256": "4c183d267af4449b01c6ce783a5ae1cfec8abc2e5bc9e157f1c464da9f707cd1", "input_original_sha256": "086c89cc3794fe2729eb6a9795116b3aaa7226adb9b7f388d916f5cbe5e365cc", "input_wav_sha256": "dbfa04e29b7cf0b513e700c0851876d285bdcb4dec633521355efe833ce6f888", "input_pcm_sha256": "9c2da2392dddd5e8fd26c82ba4f726c98b6de186412445194fe7f2baeaee0d94", "output_wav_sha256": "0e5084a27ba241c9e5167f0e48c9f1883055b2fe5f67aeed92361380834c6475", "output_pcm_sha256": "4ab37639d8218515acc774c5cdc4333aaaff25eb12f74cdc7b3b20c27cb313af", "result_sha256": "7ff65210b8faadc6334bdb7357fce1997387bad470f662bb76835fd6994e6f8a" } }, { "id": 44, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1804b0f432ff1677814509325ba5b4e344a769a1a3f5a367bc121a8a8367d2be", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1804b0f432ff1677814509325ba5b4e344a769a1a3f5a367bc121a8a8367d2be", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, whatever is both an ingredient of Immense Mascara and an ingredient of I Adore You is an ingredient of Crawford's wine or an ingredient of Buy Glitz Color Nine N. Moreover, being an ingredient of Lip Too Cheek is necessary for being an ingredient of Buy Glitz Color Nine N. Finally, everything that is an ingredient of Crawford's wine is an ingredient of Lip Too Cheek, too. Therefore, whatever is an ingredient of Immense Mascara and an ingredient of I Adore You is also an ingredient of Lip Too Cheek. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, whatever is both an ingredient of immense mascara and an ingredient of I adore you is an ingredient of Crawford's wine or an ingredient of Bioglit's Color 9N. Moreover, being an ingredient of Lip 2 Cheek is necessary for being an ingredient of Bioglit's Color 9N. Finally, everything that is an ingredient of Crawford's wine is an ingredient of Lip 2 Cheek too. Therefore, whatever is an ingredient of a mince mascara and an ingredient of i adore you is also an ingredient of lip to cheek is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 15017.52, "reasoner_ms": 2347.42, "tts_ms": 23.75, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17388.71, "total_processing_ms": 18021.03 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1191, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 59 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "57d1ca1fd727522f386a5f7ddb34c55b62d483c5ca480f65895252fea02dfe4b", "started_sha256": "f1438c96e75d7a47e0db63e4b937c61d065470c1862e80c887056d2069dc9238", "original_grade_sha256": "53a607967706acccdefe94099cdfc29c904dd1a87cac145875d973ef06e8cb5a", "input_original_sha256": "57d1ca1fd727522f386a5f7ddb34c55b62d483c5ca480f65895252fea02dfe4b", "input_wav_sha256": "bcfbcc0641d4b9651b5fee23aa6ed7936a0c25a032fc605970bec237f92c769e", "input_pcm_sha256": "c72bfb8ff3918266da21736e03cd991af422fe786f42aa280afa2dc712fa50fe", "output_wav_sha256": "c49c5ecbc12f930546bb29e92de7e97eeec98bf0b22b671f62ababd4668e888d", "output_pcm_sha256": "bfeb84dd236776893325cb9bce99c3d10be6d74edd6a0b9ab118a5e6f1295efc", "result_sha256": "1908982e114c8c96419f6017e1d12c0bbb713f810812224c64e5c566c1408e70" } }, { "id": 478, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e31ddcd2c54ac3a82b9fcc770ae7247ed2ea1d2f2097d2669cfaff269bc0bd80", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e31ddcd2c54ac3a82b9fcc770ae7247ed2ea1d2f2097d2669cfaff269bc0bd80", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take two steps backward. Take three steps backward. Take three steps backward. Take eight steps forward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point always face forward take two steps backward take three steps backward take three steps backward take eight steps forward options yes no answer the question Question", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7524.94, "reasoner_ms": 1487.77, "tts_ms": 23.82, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9036.56, "total_processing_ms": 9605.92 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 802, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 40 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "bf23fb545184977d93e2382b575c6eae795e831142045b8eef693baec8f3c3b0", "started_sha256": "cd1301ea6235db3b15c330da60e1f6c5d8270827b06a6bbef22b6fe3d0cb96a1", "original_grade_sha256": "d80bf698750bc91248e1fe9b162f987413a7ce8f8988368025b2d881301ac13a", "input_original_sha256": "bf23fb545184977d93e2382b575c6eae795e831142045b8eef693baec8f3c3b0", "input_wav_sha256": "d44b0bcaa7ef376ef16f734b7424a7ad5690555bd2a98bf4e1cb6c3cc0c7512a", "input_pcm_sha256": "a2ed807bbec1ac1d0a1ee2d23bc3b21b852e0a0bdd91d9faf0d7913c7bc21f48", "output_wav_sha256": "9a929dc53d9e0e1089b2d9837d48a84092df947dd52ba3929622269f997ac45f", "output_pcm_sha256": "a5bfa8c19b1bac7d46cd1c74887428d537aebd37771d12ead69b628346de4c9f", "result_sha256": "215407c36c19e831ea4dcc71802e553807bcb3a0ad8f2dfd4f4abca9dcf77b56" } }, { "id": 647, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "2", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9c5329c313abbe24b50bacb5325a294e9e5d10a1323690b4b8b60ac7aefe5e3a", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9c5329c313abbe24b50bacb5325a294e9e5d10a1323690b4b8b60ac7aefe5e3a", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a cat and a fish. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a cat and a fish. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 2.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 3623.98, "reasoner_ms": 1333.49, "tts_ms": 24.8, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 4982.3, "total_processing_ms": 5581.37 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 724, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "656fc15ac8bf18f1d510f74c0a80cc8b140b0770fc92fee121995b7da9860c94", "started_sha256": "0295a8bbf9183efe08a7f7592c96562de55677a9b1cbc8f443c386a92206a1ae", "original_grade_sha256": "6f03a93c7383bb95c5d96600e669d05aeb673df059db9f1365138bd92bc10184", "input_original_sha256": "656fc15ac8bf18f1d510f74c0a80cc8b140b0770fc92fee121995b7da9860c94", "input_wav_sha256": "611889abfdfa234ea0a24b1fc8061fe32f37c9b0ad1a0a1bb9615c953d16d0c0", "input_pcm_sha256": "6fca85d7233a35bcd3fea4b3313e904a934bc283a069282dcdabc99eda84437d", "output_wav_sha256": "c76e3c3ff586c6438530e1d7db8485b14e75b9245badb43319a70b0d96b02fff", "output_pcm_sha256": "6dea014ecc8608296ddeadcd0ee410fb371e2ee5878069b40a1c9fb7cab10d63", "result_sha256": "3badee575729bb97264d3721668557815cbc8cc7c288eda9fbd2e20be9cd31bb" } }, { "id": 997, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "98332678a0e0f9447d398ac8d095c5c1e1d8f593adb582a93a274c8942ec3d35", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "98332678a0e0f9447d398ac8d095c5c1e1d8f593adb582a93a274c8942ec3d35", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Candy tells the truth. Ryan says Candy lies. Michaela says Ryan tells the truth. Shima says Michaela lies. Andre says Shima tells the truth. Does Andre tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion candy tells the truth ryan says candy lies michaela says ryan tells the truth shema says michaela lies andre says shema tells the truth does andre tell the truth answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8350.17, "reasoner_ms": 1830.38, "tts_ms": 26.09, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10206.68, "total_processing_ms": 10840.65 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 814, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 97 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "57db13a502520cbbddbf55b004b84cf26d95dd7efa39351566837c87def22c1e", "started_sha256": "d2a9550e3ee6256ada1f2976fff1e2c8675a56294f9cf75af540c44efe21a902", "original_grade_sha256": "5a1542459ecb858b48daa2956b75abd150f5ea9d5851c0e96088d6d22107269d", "input_original_sha256": "57db13a502520cbbddbf55b004b84cf26d95dd7efa39351566837c87def22c1e", "input_wav_sha256": "e24ad22de678154ce4b4a094bad5c059fe9f55f4f4e87dd4df94278d0ca50aff", "input_pcm_sha256": "ec9fd0925df2079f9a516eec8d8eb6c9461786c79a4be99f0114cb8c6f316308", "output_wav_sha256": "0910f80219e9b67371cbd68aff3cfc38f5509e16a7e72272b153cd54a9b2a49a", "output_pcm_sha256": "2d7d1094e76536d99cd2ba29047350457950d61c5d5156cc40278935a7ae99d5", "result_sha256": "562f9ca5f4386910d32a2685c8f1f0aac476febe70cedbf7b05383f3c74aa478" } }, { "id": 54, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "32b863f7c51b897cfb938932e8ae9b4307da125a3829e12cec213311ee5a2ebc", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "32b863f7c51b897cfb938932e8ae9b4307da125a3829e12cec213311ee5a2ebc", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a cousin of Robert? Is Joe related to Bob? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To start with, it is not the case that Homer is a classmate of Frank. Now, being a classmate of Edward is necessary for being a classmate of Frank. So necessarily, it is not the case that Homer is a classmate of Edward. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Fred a cousin of Robert? Is Joe related to Bob? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To start with, it is not the case that Homer is a classmate of Frank. Now, being a classmate of Edward is necessary for being a classmate of Frank. So, necessarily, it is not the case that Homer is a classmate of Edward. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12295.19, "reasoner_ms": 2292.2, "tts_ms": 29.76, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 14617.19, "total_processing_ms": 15192.24 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 954, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 94 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "7f53d791c629d765890e62b7b3b66ecaa033ee1f1c5dd8b355f96dfbe8a9caff", "started_sha256": "c085fa57adbe7c8867db9ab3fcd513a671b73cc9afb7be17372c056d7e8c0ccc", "original_grade_sha256": "4488afe15eeff7e14afebd86839a5ae6ee46b4f7330989d43b7f2a9a4f67f825", "input_original_sha256": "7f53d791c629d765890e62b7b3b66ecaa033ee1f1c5dd8b355f96dfbe8a9caff", "input_wav_sha256": "4cc4d3dbe4eb20beb56e9ed4102f1b5a8b59a6abcb87da3611a3c2616244c3b3", "input_pcm_sha256": "4b67370390c0aaca9225b4d5ec8278999972a4a42b9f891b250c9e16c4b2d839", "output_wav_sha256": "e231aa94bd43e31244cb0f405bac98bd0f4c49dbc56c99b3065f8ff7aa209093", "output_pcm_sha256": "b9009da727b2daa565b5ca5c70fcf98c39e8b7c41a0ccf7f1196679f617c1971", "result_sha256": "054f68eac038c2b57a2ec421ebde8a17b1c71bc7e597366a65f923f06917f0e4" } }, { "id": 361, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d93a0861584cef2217965f8070701c776ba33ab40eb950d2868458f5917baca1", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d93a0861584cef2217965f8070701c776ba33ab40eb950d2868458f5917baca1", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps left. Take four steps left. Take one step left. Take two steps left. Take two steps right. Take three steps left. Take five steps forward. Take three steps backward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps left. Take four steps left. Take one step left. Take two steps left. Take two steps right. Take three steps left. Take five steps forward. Take three steps backward. Yes? No? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6083.02, "reasoner_ms": 1980.85, "tts_ms": 25.45, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8089.35, "total_processing_ms": 8648.55 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 865, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 67 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "acbff9195870405940f01ebeb766d622d8cb51f78486c1a89e609acaf009858f", "started_sha256": "b5306ccfce0ea8b9666df2c99ed9cbfe8bf0ea1b63f62e30aadd04a428ef6e2a", "original_grade_sha256": "267d0886952fab128498f9d568664a5e0d018cb0931772874596b9b765c362db", "input_original_sha256": "acbff9195870405940f01ebeb766d622d8cb51f78486c1a89e609acaf009858f", "input_wav_sha256": "0d4d834d14e8164c9a04ae6be256962970bfdd31155ebd1c5e1c27ead4c27420", "input_pcm_sha256": "7b3afda0751db4005c7f257de5201f67591435d5ce9b582f1e93f9936fc5acb5", "output_wav_sha256": "6942c4d6cdf1fe363489ca21ad1698279c8192d9bf87fcee39df11d584a02003", "output_pcm_sha256": "5e8d30d504c518b8d9e0cd1af73109eb8b7f5f45ef2697e5ae464050930a9514", "result_sha256": "423015c3d83a9b20f551e9c7df06ed53502e90b9daea08e7efe755409b420750" } }, { "id": 528, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "4", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0c1c26322c928602c24a3dfe91729f186f6c156f2668ab5925995e5de89b0a11", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0c1c26322c928602c24a3dfe91729f186f6c156f2668ab5925995e5de89b0a11", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a cauliflower, a stalk of celery, a cabbage, and a garlic. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a cauliflower a stalk of celery a cabbage and a garlic how many vegetables do i have answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 4.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6177.53, "reasoner_ms": 1478.72, "tts_ms": 21.55, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7677.82, "total_processing_ms": 8248.61 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 766, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "019e197f22385623487272ca35d9399020875b8eda647c9a68c0f37ba85be1e2", "started_sha256": "2fff94793c238ae9c5e2c97604bc35f18c1c847f5f6b6ba39c3358081ee161c9", "original_grade_sha256": "656e4933ba01c19b0561764b79aa8219f710d8e147ea662f5bdf02a2f575c37e", "input_original_sha256": "019e197f22385623487272ca35d9399020875b8eda647c9a68c0f37ba85be1e2", "input_wav_sha256": "561559255a0d2f1638e15f3cc42b7d3b657fb3021d2608807a3ad68d21b7f062", "input_pcm_sha256": "1d0225f4f1265c345436238c5ed63f128789f18eb132b1562af90f6674faa105", "output_wav_sha256": "0dfba0cb16f980c58d874c895e6d67a4bc007f62347eee1b75bf4cf5745dede8", "output_pcm_sha256": "0df50d7f12833c8cf816687f388c79f31cbb2cac6cfa0260b8e850082dbf53c2", "result_sha256": "a5d7f8fc3bc50c176d8ede17c502711645e0e9ffd43bd245c79df2d71c6804a3" } }, { "id": 977, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c07c1ac55bc25a6d6aa16140e1688f50961aa2c29382d9ffbe2fa5f10cc6320e", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c07c1ac55bc25a6d6aa16140e1688f50961aa2c29382d9ffbe2fa5f10cc6320e", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Helen lies. Delfina says Helen lies. Christie says Delfina tells the truth. Jerry says Christie lies. Tamika says Jerry tells the truth. Does Tamika tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion, Helen lies. Delfina says Helen lies. Christy says Delfina tells the truth. Jerry says Christy lies. Tamika says Jerry tells the truth. Does Tamika tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4901.99, "reasoner_ms": 2282.34, "tts_ms": 24.3, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7208.65, "total_processing_ms": 7757.13 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 831, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 111 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "cb67851924af9c6781b772011123f40a6e5b8f0708a3935ec37f1bc8e3fddf94", "started_sha256": "cd38e01c418a7bffc60823529a7240cdf94fe46837d8e5eb6bd850441c840c62", "original_grade_sha256": "773975410c86f2b778cf2988e3a4e4a46e4e25c9fb4cf64d52fa90c37283e380", "input_original_sha256": "cb67851924af9c6781b772011123f40a6e5b8f0708a3935ec37f1bc8e3fddf94", "input_wav_sha256": "067e7458fb5da20d1e7a6704fb57932b13929d9da88308d57b2f428449decc8a", "input_pcm_sha256": "8c1bd233bf7c5f091c1f42575bef61c042d191765e8fdea8f1c89c04d17e236c", "output_wav_sha256": "1d614f7152ca14663392d3307ca0d605687185f427ca8b541d7b336995159ec2", "output_pcm_sha256": "4114dae5a442f6e65429a0d0e02fb137cf6e9b3be96ee567f8403d46079389f7", "result_sha256": "115dfaf7c19aa1e4f09d7b038c4572cca0d77b9535a8925d829e953d66ac53a5" } }, { "id": 208, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "536dba55f6d71fcb42bbacdb3acedb77e4c973261f8bfd775cbd4a6d7df3dc8d", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "536dba55f6d71fcb42bbacdb3acedb77e4c973261f8bfd775cbd4a6d7df3dc8d", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise, Julie is a member of SL Benfica or a follower of FC Ufa. Second premise, everyone who is not an ex-fan of FC Astana is however a member of SL Benfica and a follower of FC Ufa. We may conclude that Julie is not an ex-fan of FC Astana. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise, Julie is a member of SL Benfica or a follower of FC Ufa. Second premise, everyone who is not an ex-fan of FC Astana is however a member of SL Benfica and a follower of FC Ufa. We may conclude that Julie is not an ex-fan of FC Astana. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 10163.66, "reasoner_ms": 3312.06, "tts_ms": 26.85, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 13502.59, "total_processing_ms": 13981.78 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 988, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 199 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f285bfc15d2dcea14713529d903921a6349803c7ac805181b42f666ce0641d32", "started_sha256": "a5bf7f01d30f677d60935ce8a46b983b5d250b20045a1f8f5f267095ade97e66", "original_grade_sha256": "c766c267b9cf75df78584899d0a39c5c2dbf0db2aad9ed8b870474f01792ea22", "input_original_sha256": "f285bfc15d2dcea14713529d903921a6349803c7ac805181b42f666ce0641d32", "input_wav_sha256": "b53db9d0d07f76f6199d5c622d11b0a4d5c07e62204991749c485e53f7d26212", "input_pcm_sha256": "722b527a34903c0d1b6a738595cfd7fe372e13e0ed2c642bd8884052911b4e19", "output_wav_sha256": "73b3e974842babdad1785da27ed38bf12383352bd49c9508c4d1f9359a7b1e2f", "output_pcm_sha256": "11a70bca1cae88ea1d345116f9def03c485c6b09bb0ec8b1f3f89810e4d85361", "result_sha256": "538ec5c05f7f0ae47acb88e6a371a7b87bf12eb0ec05ed96013953559d1fdfd4" } }, { "id": 271, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "01c2538d3554fc4a93a478f9aa612b69a778a0cfe899fc7df26fcc492b035b90", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "01c2538d3554fc4a93a478f9aa612b69a778a0cfe899fc7df26fcc492b035b90", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take four steps. Take two steps. Turn around. Take six steps. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point take four steps take two steps turn around take six steps options yes no answer the question Thank you for your question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7461.81, "reasoner_ms": 1652.8, "tts_ms": 25.34, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9139.98, "total_processing_ms": 9706.74 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 779, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 39 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "000ef2513e0136e5adce5bb468a8c0f9dd333897a5d144afe65719ff2a23693e", "started_sha256": "a46f45d2fbb6267b9d56d3422dcb2ea215d217539ed6c79eab84d5411c53b610", "original_grade_sha256": "aeaa56a9b72144029a18502aee03ffe5d3a23eea522ef85f46c756876c244922", "input_original_sha256": "000ef2513e0136e5adce5bb468a8c0f9dd333897a5d144afe65719ff2a23693e", "input_wav_sha256": "7bc84d516eabfaf9a1e4d0df6c1ad127849e74426011367aa46c5298a11d3463", "input_pcm_sha256": "c59254f771e70346ff0bb93f865fa65b71425f0da495fc33f9fdc76e22e0509a", "output_wav_sha256": "6cef418262fe117e860186486650bf390cecdf1d6c3bdf111eb78a6971f04a3c", "output_pcm_sha256": "6a0f05c8ece86329ccea6ab2ba7183ebe208cff2f0b96177e2fba5d42673bab0", "result_sha256": "6f29410e953a586849d228c17767274338b4901d4593fc3be86a0a3580b5ce84" } }, { "id": 505, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "3", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4b9ddf45e93bec0d8ce38ac5becb24748ccf223cdc9b993fb977b8654311b4f3", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4b9ddf45e93bec0d8ce38ac5becb24748ccf223cdc9b993fb977b8654311b4f3", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a fish, a bear, and a frog. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a fish, a bear, and a frog. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 3.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 3616.28, "reasoner_ms": 1084.2, "tts_ms": 19.62, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 4720.13, "total_processing_ms": 5241.21 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 734, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "c8711794a0e4b07f2f3592e90979db1ed03b7741bb75d015f1e6e174f0276b92", "started_sha256": "f60fcf69d5806e8c7d6e458b47e4d6b93e1cba07fc8e87b6929f62482bd1b514", "original_grade_sha256": "cd22c1ef71296357af44e14f30a7446a2eb123d9fa4e928540c2156203baf806", "input_original_sha256": "c8711794a0e4b07f2f3592e90979db1ed03b7741bb75d015f1e6e174f0276b92", "input_wav_sha256": "f0ce8200bf097b70ab3c4fc88849e65841926aaf630ae0caa149e7232bed6dc6", "input_pcm_sha256": "9da3dabaed6a328af186bb4211f53ea442dea4fa6e31c38deeb0df4b301b2f23", "output_wav_sha256": "a05c4ecf38089a9cf1266d5558e56649a861706df30c781699455ccf53463204", "output_pcm_sha256": "6e8894d687b1978c301aaccee29f9ceadc29364570d0458d9d3b4c561b361813", "result_sha256": "fc57e527231fc002185737546aa5a1b7299f943fce183042fb50af3e9afdf90b" } }, { "id": 992, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "deee3d7be13fc1ee835bb64f1eb6f1a3a437f726000c02b0dc4749d79bad2322", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "deee3d7be13fc1ee835bb64f1eb6f1a3a437f726000c02b0dc4749d79bad2322", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Rashida lies. Fletcher says Rashida lies. Antoine says Fletcher lies. Willian says Antoine tells the truth. Veena says Willian tells the truth. Does Veena tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Rashida lies. Fletcher says Rashida lies. Antwin says Fletcher lies. William says Antwin tells the truth. Veena says William tells the truth. Does Veena tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4804.27, "reasoner_ms": 2615.45, "tts_ms": 24.07, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7443.83, "total_processing_ms": 7968.51 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 831, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 140 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e26b1c029fbe788660b5c00679bb73b1d6e14330c14e264a738fc97b882234f7", "started_sha256": "32cfe7a71bf76f5eb0cd451f72ee461f27f71d4b0c6ed9fd0e2db1b93461ca63", "original_grade_sha256": "ca12997a7577629faeadd6f13ccc641f6d5497097730b7e8c948ade17d07cbc4", "input_original_sha256": "e26b1c029fbe788660b5c00679bb73b1d6e14330c14e264a738fc97b882234f7", "input_wav_sha256": "d8fd4cf09eb320bfaa0c95eb2574a784469936d716ec7fc2ac6648406344f4dc", "input_pcm_sha256": "884efc92ddde03a1acdbb443eaf947cd8a5b086f25bd2b503c51a01754ddde4f", "output_wav_sha256": "d086fe9cef669cd11dd044baab2d5d816f7844ca06ae0a0d7d513cf33899ac09", "output_pcm_sha256": "1ef6f9e102759404602410145b3bf113590370729dbe4a8d91d6fd6ef8933bad", "result_sha256": "54b1b3de64018ad96cf2fb1dbac05ac9f918ef173f9084fcb30e0917a07d86b7" } }, { "id": 52, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "704035d92177f700569d16409cd0a15cdde8ff0561057784fef22c95ed4c48c5", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "704035d92177f700569d16409cd0a15cdde8ff0561057784fef22c95ed4c48c5", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise, whoever is an occasional purchaser of Suave Shampoo is not a regular user of Ivory soap. We may conclude that being a regular user of Ivory soap is sufficient for not being an occasional purchaser of Suave Shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise. Whoever is an occasional purchaser of suave shampoo is not a regular user of ivory soap. We may conclude that being a regular user of ivory soap is sufficient for not being an occasional purchaser of suave shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid. Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8793.77, "reasoner_ms": 1942.08, "tts_ms": 21.87, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10757.75, "total_processing_ms": 11249.64 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 864, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 75 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3e79b1e6190ba638f4af03ae0efabd327c9cab6994eee9a9ac57c87789455d98", "started_sha256": "7adc562a675e7c1bbad57b5879b091ed2a68aa6a007c0ae55f41c100fef85b21", "original_grade_sha256": "05e1c063961b130fc6ee334d84d5c194a07c87fec8c17d4e6e1637dcf758b99a", "input_original_sha256": "3e79b1e6190ba638f4af03ae0efabd327c9cab6994eee9a9ac57c87789455d98", "input_wav_sha256": "ebecf6c4753c0ad922553814666ea1c5e0710e8eacb0c39d7b9ea2cc9371339c", "input_pcm_sha256": "7d6ea17eb68a995f9cad4d6b27943c2f9737352923d30375ff6ff5bf0745d886", "output_wav_sha256": "c4dfa071b2ad2fef985a11ed2f7c0df592782ef19bdb978ba6eb6a275dcf27c8", "output_pcm_sha256": "0c1a98744cbc601401433b106d7be2d47daf0fc91c3f9c6e4c44810fc0d7e17c", "result_sha256": "5298543f6a00573c460f5c0ff1ad4b6d996f17a801f61ff48432599289f7d498" } }, { "id": 358, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2bf4794ca2a6fa4dc7f7d09f9a00d5f2836f3c8d153cf573a654880718e5911c", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2bf4794ca2a6fa4dc7f7d09f9a00d5f2836f3c8d153cf573a654880718e5911c", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take five steps. Take eight steps. Take two steps. Turn right. Take eight steps. Turn left. Take six steps. Take six steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take 5 steps. Take 8 steps. Take 2 steps. Turn right. Take 8 steps. Turn left. Take 6 steps. Take 6 steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6437.78, "reasoner_ms": 3013.35, "tts_ms": 23.16, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9474.31, "total_processing_ms": 9948.94 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 847, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 146 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f625ae90e007b238206604b0b0c2f2c1ef4dacf6f38b4ef669975ea57a847794", "started_sha256": "4d734899842f529bb44fb875bebab9fc939a43f01d7870af1c1dfe36e203b9e0", "original_grade_sha256": "cdfe8e2500768376b13d3af0201b3a1d2b5e79e29bd47cf7fbc7a4e05da334ef", "input_original_sha256": "f625ae90e007b238206604b0b0c2f2c1ef4dacf6f38b4ef669975ea57a847794", "input_wav_sha256": "b3ba935287d66e17635626d93602a149ba0f25438c94ab05df73c853e460fc70", "input_pcm_sha256": "1a89ffec4c20c5bc1f760fab5798337fdd13e71a7f5a286eae4d17b0095aecbd", "output_wav_sha256": "1cebc6a8326b94c0c295fbf615f16150a492425ff9a465745c49f52e80162176", "output_pcm_sha256": "1dca6198d064b58a498a977528774b4fae8de8fbae3af7a36efcf84fe870296b", "result_sha256": "72efa36379e54e8a7114703bc17ccfbfb5a54e365dcee45ed886b76501602264" } }, { "id": 531, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b0e2b98c79ed4560366287b5cb942f1f4c57d9e42720dc12f4be7168ed2fe202", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b0e2b98c79ed4560366287b5cb942f1f4c57d9e42720dc12f4be7168ed2fe202", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a microwave, a lamp, four cars, a stove, a toaster, and a bed. How many objects do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a microwave, a lamp, four cars, a stove, a toaster, and a bed. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 9.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 3870.63, "reasoner_ms": 1692.85, "tts_ms": 26.83, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5590.34, "total_processing_ms": 6092.35 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 763, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 50 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1ae1c0d8e05b79e1b64a59a6df423b39dac73ab1a1dbe6d2c33531c2cd31f39c", "started_sha256": "806c2cb23b0569909e871663dfaee6b3760d1e881555e4a9ebd86ddfa2282957", "original_grade_sha256": "b36416bcccb4a60365a5eb2a6a1e3f6f076b3ba59ace20deb5627da5d60e42b5", "input_original_sha256": "1ae1c0d8e05b79e1b64a59a6df423b39dac73ab1a1dbe6d2c33531c2cd31f39c", "input_wav_sha256": "effc43f615958a84920755693a81c2c1afabfd37a74e4770587b41b1f4477f3b", "input_pcm_sha256": "7f9cbc63ff97902b17dd7e7cc3f3d2023cfa54b3418bd54ec5b6f85907b2da4f", "output_wav_sha256": "ff7d91b499b9ae3422e91c30624af5c73cd6dfb61d19700011fe69fcd7b9e0c0", "output_pcm_sha256": "1d498e3eccd6c903d7d154d83db9f429d692ebb080f4c9c79dc0ee1e0d78c749", "result_sha256": "e4f952b59236e12f4dc5edefabd0b8ad2fd1ac1d30ea71ba9635b0baa3b5eb74" } }, { "id": 941, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9dbb9b213788990173cfe5d1007b77b5d778c7b00fd2f12a417400253d8b0054", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9dbb9b213788990173cfe5d1007b77b5d778c7b00fd2f12a417400253d8b0054", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Audrey lies. Rashida says Audrey tells the truth. Maybelle says Rashida lies. Kaa says Maybelle lies. Shonda says Kaa tells the truth. Does Shonda tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nAudrey lies. Rashida says Audrey tells the truth. Maybel says Rashida lies. Ka says Maybel lies. Shonda says Ka tells the truth. Does Shonda tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4819.23, "reasoner_ms": 2168.49, "tts_ms": 25.47, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7013.21, "total_processing_ms": 7534.83 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 836, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 125 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3e78f384c33e8ce8c66cade26f4647abae7cd8f037dfcd57c31b8ba23467e90f", "started_sha256": "5564b889619cdf298d8c3abc9223fdba44974de83086be71e1f8b261597c9037", "original_grade_sha256": "8e427bcebbd6f4052bc486e79e948c01b8e17831fbcf15ce212bd4056894bcdf", "input_original_sha256": "3e78f384c33e8ce8c66cade26f4647abae7cd8f037dfcd57c31b8ba23467e90f", "input_wav_sha256": "a1942c17fdf8b4a11fda28047d7989a9e7d76d09ea52cb7241f52551db1dff6b", "input_pcm_sha256": "5f2b6e48faba800ee366973fbb93129620656cc03a697e762ea708fe4f210ef2", "output_wav_sha256": "69ef0fd35b556ddf7908e290f5fbdec273c5e304368ed2caffdc0017678e0fdd", "output_pcm_sha256": "863bc4989dc61bc43de11db64c12410714cc16ee1e56fdd6ca83785d8af82cee", "result_sha256": "eb791ce368a4cb53fa34b827e5f79fcff9fc85300005a33f1956e324539675ce" } }, { "id": 48, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "93bf0ac745e9249a541578fdb6f7a1a3ea6a6c72db4224c03febe816d7ea2f6a", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "93bf0ac745e9249a541578fdb6f7a1a3ea6a6c72db4224c03febe816d7ea2f6a", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, Carmen is a daughter of Hattie. Moreover, being a niece of Shona is sufficient for not being a daughter of Hattie. From this follows, Carmen is not a niece of Shona. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, Carmen is a daughter of Hattie. Moreover, being a niece of Shona is sufficient for not being a daughter of Hattie. From this follows, Carmen is not a niece of Shona. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6308.5, "reasoner_ms": 2303.58, "tts_ms": 25.58, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8637.69, "total_processing_ms": 9195.44 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 934, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 99 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f531f3b01e8ebf14356f84037c4d4690e7c59f6e21edf8c6240b9d75382f8e7a", "started_sha256": "6fa6c7278fc40c323ba1617bb7d413ee82ec9969ed48aea02674211d6ac9a807", "original_grade_sha256": "f122c4e3a4d8814d98b3036792123136109de6cdd8a9af2acba2d14c93f885a0", "input_original_sha256": "f531f3b01e8ebf14356f84037c4d4690e7c59f6e21edf8c6240b9d75382f8e7a", "input_wav_sha256": "04d474ab32a4a0c137e46b25d615c032711bea1fea9f6ae6505eb4e02871c483", "input_pcm_sha256": "f1c49c1f29dbc5b9c03afc14a25bac123d3da050283e61b3ef1e1be718b4c9e7", "output_wav_sha256": "fd21f21967fd6dde6491aa00f4909956d335fe689b6eb4f456da50378a2bcb90", "output_pcm_sha256": "545d3de70fe2cb59c7cbf94749b7171d7129109037e5537c8c723724186b4b64", "result_sha256": "5b67264068b8a6fababc8684cd5ec3772e9d6429342d4a72e861f589f5b2178e" } }, { "id": 309, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9073e959eb8eea425acc5319cb12680a1049a5a5f8a752122225fb422ca76d8b", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9073e959eb8eea425acc5319cb12680a1049a5a5f8a752122225fb422ca76d8b", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps left. Take five steps left. Take ten steps right. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps left, take five steps left, take ten steps right. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4999.8, "reasoner_ms": 1653.68, "tts_ms": 24.18, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6677.69, "total_processing_ms": 7198.43 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 795, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 46 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "7734fd1431c5a1fd04daaae9ff3958051f8719d06a7783c1c85c6f30539b9592", "started_sha256": "9242c5b31327387681125559479faa9520ac9131e4a603acb82fa2f44b9ef2c7", "original_grade_sha256": "a18122ebea15ea73ccce9961622dda955099fe001d717ebae399529493f99eeb", "input_original_sha256": "7734fd1431c5a1fd04daaae9ff3958051f8719d06a7783c1c85c6f30539b9592", "input_wav_sha256": "6d93ebc08a167aa30b055a9f8f4650e68900561186020faa36bd75cae504ad0b", "input_pcm_sha256": "b5c1da425ecb909a1f89930e0824c1b58b513780200b2094f9a15f55182d5632", "output_wav_sha256": "cca0832efb5b56d2db070cc09ec113229779b3ad982382a6fa4ccbe42a33a5bb", "output_pcm_sha256": "52d6dc21260ac420314c8cb1c12438619d404625f7cafe74364195c20ebbacba", "result_sha256": "763ada95671a29fded75910e325c76065299b6ed95562c06cd4543e4bc6cfae8" } }, { "id": 578, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "12", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bb5e1f9b379535be4c3b2f92dae084210a7ce2b55a55567d277292d2a5ef3d0c", "normalized_answer": "12" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bb5e1f9b379535be4c3b2f92dae084210a7ce2b55a55567d277292d2a5ef3d0c", "normalized_answer": "12" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have three nectarines, an apple, a plum, a strawberry, a grape, three oranges, a raspberry, and a blackberry. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have three nectarines, an apple, a plum, a strawberry, a grape, three oranges, a raspberry, and a blackberry. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 12.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4285.93, "reasoner_ms": 1970.46, "tts_ms": 25.15, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6281.56, "total_processing_ms": 6749.17 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 794, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 80 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b6f0d34d808161da8a34a6ba0378a9a3b8c517124ee57525361965ed77d8258a", "started_sha256": "b4270fa1228c7822928c70d6701a3f697d2477f9445127ada4e419d819cc4b10", "original_grade_sha256": "78a8f2668c043c95c2cb9c828e3cbd6ef7cdf23ccc399f926d20aa6607cad81a", "input_original_sha256": "b6f0d34d808161da8a34a6ba0378a9a3b8c517124ee57525361965ed77d8258a", "input_wav_sha256": "1cb1493fb4b2b9c172c93e6cbabc54eeeff4b5f6b3a7e2dce0a508757374d36b", "input_pcm_sha256": "57d291c9838917a711f7d2220742983c84d6990e5f2882466207bbb63f74017d", "output_wav_sha256": "fdac749961fe41277cb86b3cae7270309e439514141b2b7fb5e87a8897398865", "output_pcm_sha256": "61b914750637da637d4d1c938ff55dbe1c7d6716f9bdb8bf9aef9f884e56cf36", "result_sha256": "36eff17526d4b4feb171b5b498ae790945d5b96ca40530e4f404ba9aa3c8e40e" } }, { "id": 944, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2e5aafbe98bd8d2191959fd64a2e288b2f17b16a1540041171db8fadcf681ea6", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2e5aafbe98bd8d2191959fd64a2e288b2f17b16a1540041171db8fadcf681ea6", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Raymond lies. Fletcher says Raymond lies. Amberly says Fletcher lies. Shenna says Amberly tells the truth. Dallas says Shenna tells the truth. Does Dallas tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Raymond lies. Fletcher says Raymond lies. Amberly says Fletcher lies. Shena says Amberly tells the truth. Dallas says Shena tells the truth. Does Dallas tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5032.18, "reasoner_ms": 2413.0, "tts_ms": 23.68, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7468.89, "total_processing_ms": 8010.11 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 841, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 118 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "fa9297ad5c67c0484e1acd73285e58ad0a8d4ec7d45d6fe005635cd594225e24", "started_sha256": "dcfb9181cc29ab411a9d7a93a96a0d1b6f50b35e9af426e3727e1b5bb329184d", "original_grade_sha256": "85e9d0e9f6715969a8d80bba00c95c8816083682575d2da5368b454a0998a8e1", "input_original_sha256": "fa9297ad5c67c0484e1acd73285e58ad0a8d4ec7d45d6fe005635cd594225e24", "input_wav_sha256": "9fe037c900a04d3109cb472d84372d3761f41c894832da0353d51828f712c44a", "input_pcm_sha256": "babcace82751bde0011a6def950046ea76b3a33edb1efcdaa7976d989df3c10c", "output_wav_sha256": "f5f1a4cd72bb610019d1436d5faedb25f8123619953e19bfc781d3ad77797aeb", "output_pcm_sha256": "cb752fe975caa6a0363da0cac85e97013e1b7d54952a68ac7e496a4800033c49", "result_sha256": "94d306211e4e2054818b22edd61dbaf1cdf61776b47278dfb2cf89243a909a2d" } }, { "id": 217, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1dbcb4bd92ddaf53e43a032c6307b096a1382f30763d42eb49044a1d616c2192", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1dbcb4bd92ddaf53e43a032c6307b096a1382f30763d42eb49044a1d616c2192", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise, every schoolmate of Barton is a son of Melvin. Second premise, every half-brother of Todd is a son of Melvin. Third premise, whoever is neither a half-brother of Daryn nor a schoolmate of Phillip is a half-brother of Todd or a schoolmate of Barton. So necessarily, whoever is not a son of Melvin is however half-brother of Daryn or a schoolmate of Phillip. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument, first premise, every schoolmate of Barton is a son of Melvin. Second premise, every half-brother of Todd is a son of Melvin. Third premise, whoever is neither a half-brother of Darren nor a schoolmate of Philip is a half-brother of Todd or a schoolmate of Barton.so, necessarily, whoever is not a son of Melvin is however half-brother of Darren or a schoolmate of Philip. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12049.11, "reasoner_ms": 4447.45, "tts_ms": 28.37, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 16524.96, "total_processing_ms": 17152.92 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 982, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 334 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0b2c9139f4f50c778a5e7f940de508006db13625f5df7a646c1a17e5c8e75b95", "started_sha256": "fbad156d86f7f201839229b4f4e9e52bf7e1461d3905e17fc91ae7cf21066937", "original_grade_sha256": "536d6f67f7fd5b3afec61abbbdc6e49dc02f163d5332ebdee9d9fbbd0811cefe", "input_original_sha256": "0b2c9139f4f50c778a5e7f940de508006db13625f5df7a646c1a17e5c8e75b95", "input_wav_sha256": "c1b7a0e97b1f78d153309803f7a3ec39f1710fab8bab0d58f8c9d4a030a65f60", "input_pcm_sha256": "ba9122acfb211d968f5424b9b9b1dd56b35a08b1c8c70d90ea0ee4fb69491974", "output_wav_sha256": "89d858e9e985f4f0fd58704ab06625d8503e4177a49d197ac1d3400578ec2b3f", "output_pcm_sha256": "0064cf61dc2fdf68b2b7d595aca45ae1abd13db074f84bedec4843b58a2ee028", "result_sha256": "6e04f9f15da6aad87f25bf6a61cc9d5448002c67751966312a28c3f9fadfd7d7" } }, { "id": 366, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "669bb5895e4307367abf46cac82000e0a325df32b73cae434d180ad9e6917196", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "669bb5895e4307367abf46cac82000e0a325df32b73cae434d180ad9e6917196", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take seven steps backward. Take six steps forward. Take six steps backward. Take seven steps forward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take seven steps backward. Take six steps forward. Take six steps backward. Take seven steps forward. Options? Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5926.85, "reasoner_ms": 1501.61, "tts_ms": 26.29, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7454.78, "total_processing_ms": 7987.16 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 821, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 28 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0f904339b01ca274c3ad03d8a5856199ef169035a944ae732081d19d3aa3afc8", "started_sha256": "9731f1c0f48b37df2817ebea9a5e901c9505947afe2d71c0eeeb1228e6f4ee06", "original_grade_sha256": "6207e3ead59a3d743eac69f11aa3e55407eaa3822408ac44486f9bde19d9691c", "input_original_sha256": "0f904339b01ca274c3ad03d8a5856199ef169035a944ae732081d19d3aa3afc8", "input_wav_sha256": "4beb12902d8ae3c7183882abc63973974b7ad9ff9884a7a3ba0c0730ce3e11aa", "input_pcm_sha256": "b60c6a08e09250cfd312206adc31912f04f721dcbd228642dd58c0b9e61b55aa", "output_wav_sha256": "3fac444e097c5084419b57ef41bd4241f11ed5a7f48f556ef72033548ba7f1cf", "output_pcm_sha256": "d2dea565191b74eecb7ebe47f0a208779ddd8c5ed9a0435c45765da860c5d5a8", "result_sha256": "fadb2bacca3919d9e237a843f24f1042bfca226e66fe4b221bdee6d5649f0f3b" } }, { "id": 740, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "14", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "needs_review", "reason": "not_an_unambiguous_short_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "49762ae14935470bc6068ea7140a94a35fac66e2581392ccdc0030fcbd338ad8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "reviewed_output_audio", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "49762ae14935470bc6068ea7140a94a35fac66e2581392ccdc0030fcbd338ad8" }, "additive_review": { "reviewer": "DAS test duty independent ASR/evidence review", "basis": "output_audio_and_ground_truth", "rationale": "The independently recognized received audio reads 'Dancer is 14.'; the model's reply was 'The answer is 14.'. The substitution is confined to the fixed lead-in phrase (\"The answer is\"), which the pinned small.en output recognizer renders as a similar-sounding opener; the answer token itself is intact and equals the pinned key '14'. The scorer withheld an automatic pass only because the spoken form was not the contracted phrase. Same class as the determiner substitutions reviewed on 2026-09-15. This is saved audio/ASR evidence review, not a claim of human listening.", "verdict": "correct", "evidence_sha256": "49762ae14935470bc6068ea7140a94a35fac66e2581392ccdc0030fcbd338ad8", "record_sha256": "8d463f4dce6ea285491f42a99701fdf4948d1cc228705b310beb215deeda9dc8" }, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a head of broccoli, an onion, a garlic, two carrots, a lettuce head, two cabbages, a cauliflower, a stalk of celery, two potatoes, and two yams. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a head of broccoli, an onion, a garlic, two carrots, a lettuce head, two cabbages, a cauliflower, a stalk of celery, two potatoes, and two yams. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "Dancer is 14.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5425.22, "reasoner_ms": 2049.05, "tts_ms": 28.22, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7502.51, "total_processing_ms": 8019.25 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 834, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 102 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3f1f79271cf5a4d9eb05d6ffc31ec95d7e8917f0e6acfa57676f85355b319cae", "started_sha256": "4720c89c371aaa0b5beb5a8e065967622e7bc138d4ef9f762040da3d9034c3e7", "original_grade_sha256": "25da28af3f314253c99285dd8be1c7ccb80931d7cfee62da44b646a22bd0a2c3", "input_original_sha256": "3f1f79271cf5a4d9eb05d6ffc31ec95d7e8917f0e6acfa57676f85355b319cae", "input_wav_sha256": "132248d4d14ed1141439283d3ba968bb41a1350c19dd1051c487f8d1e4cdf013", "input_pcm_sha256": "9a5b0a31bef699e2330476a5add49e4d7f65fa6a47971f11c8fb9ebc335fd5ab", "output_wav_sha256": "92bacc891de9f1f5aa873bf65b4be6d1cf5a5b5780d74e6be76f58afbdfe0c89", "output_pcm_sha256": "53ba81d1b6cf6c8433e85696d9269539be6624745846c68e8fa618a6e23f903d", "result_sha256": "cc9ba117843c0c9f621115ffa90f1bca15b7d7ce28ff79078a3dc9bc22359785" } }, { "id": 897, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9af59e721e0e608fe78041e53151ed3321d3960557c1f787ba79652a0a795817", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9af59e721e0e608fe78041e53151ed3321d3960557c1f787ba79652a0a795817", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Delfina lies. Teressa says Delfina lies. Amberly says Teressa tells the truth. Ryan says Amberly lies. Millie says Ryan lies. Does Millie tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Delphina lies. Teresa says, Delphina lies. Amberlee says, Teresa tells the truth. Ryan says, Amberlee lies. Millie says, Ryan lies. Does Millie tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5734.52, "reasoner_ms": 2226.86, "tts_ms": 25.18, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7986.59, "total_processing_ms": 8516.71 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 116 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "73c2e5b27594f47f14f56bfc403681de3db5f51379b6a6c569fc42a1b1e4b3c4", "started_sha256": "06be3bbc59f46cdeb52014a2b69bf69a89543259b91a6c039a085d878cf4453a", "original_grade_sha256": "3dbaa6cbe52e4b1bf408784299ed4ab6aff5e97aa0ed4382f52528bfd215dd0e", "input_original_sha256": "73c2e5b27594f47f14f56bfc403681de3db5f51379b6a6c569fc42a1b1e4b3c4", "input_wav_sha256": "b33e122e2af7204c6759d45a584009aacc75d5573498c04f8cf3e27e427c708f", "input_pcm_sha256": "20ff418b982552b2a8d0f8170b0a3ee3b7c27633cb35233596bf6f128e8b9da2", "output_wav_sha256": "716024ef837a43de6acf2a7ea9b55a4976f1ab0dead401228e32e27f48292ccd", "output_pcm_sha256": "c82ec310f006efeae7c741255770797e1e6eaef86d286e3844f430d5f0ab6738", "result_sha256": "887e905a7e5a344fb640a6d9ebd0b3b5cca97fd2b7d20f3a6df63a0db831e6a5" } }, { "id": 168, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e2fd9bdc8a3d0f5d6fb9354d0881652b80caaae403f41b2c7771c1e751b251f6", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e2fd9bdc8a3d0f5d6fb9354d0881652b80caaae403f41b2c7771c1e751b251f6", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. No occasional purchaser of Purpose soap is a rare consumer of Bumble and Bumble shampoo or an occasional purchaser of organic Fiji soap. Hence, no occasional purchaser of organic Fiji soap and no rare consumer of Bumble and Bumble shampoo is an occasional purchaser of Purpose soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. No occasional purchaser of Purpose Soap is a rare consumer of Bumble and Bumble Shampoo, or an occasional purchaser of Organic Fiji Soap. Hence, no occasional purchaser of Organic Fiji Soap, and no rare consumer of Bumble and Bumble Shampoo, is an occasional purchaser of Purpose Soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid. Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11713.04, "reasoner_ms": 4369.49, "tts_ms": 23.73, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 16106.28, "total_processing_ms": 16729.28 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1031, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 300 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0731a15635d53654de6f981e44b079f05742cecc0d55f845afbf6cccb258d82c", "started_sha256": "0f5cbd6f5942edcb507d4dc24eb2969fb4dd8b104ee439b6a48d714f17fa757b", "original_grade_sha256": "34a7aca2c44b75073d33e9320c481e1d3d8eca228c6cb275ce383589e1f7cbb6", "input_original_sha256": "0731a15635d53654de6f981e44b079f05742cecc0d55f845afbf6cccb258d82c", "input_wav_sha256": "dec6fdbbd18b8f7ac780d8fe60516d54686c6234b6f4cef86876f5198587cd5b", "input_pcm_sha256": "0660c9f44c02d3ffd38a1bb18f55b1939c80a371a420b6fe3460efa6bffedb36", "output_wav_sha256": "51f7b12118fe2167fda3cd68f3f789d4d82614db13f4984e67be19cf8094f728", "output_pcm_sha256": "16726149d6a9bbe637b3f91c330f406c45dff122ae777c8496bcfddfa6699689", "result_sha256": "400655f2ae6496e2f693ab97e0c48e917e805afab6ed28dce079df7ddcea27e8" } }, { "id": 332, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6500b59cf62ce80317a10d1f899420b24da2c84c76a4ebb53948db8af355ebca", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6500b59cf62ce80317a10d1f899420b24da2c84c76a4ebb53948db8af355ebca", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take eight steps. Take one step. Turn left. Turn left. Take nine steps. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point take eight steps take one step turn left turn left take nine steps options yes no answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4659.45, "reasoner_ms": 5261.96, "tts_ms": 22.32, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9943.76, "total_processing_ms": 10560.11 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 780, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 66 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "4bf429cb99d8179e169a068134544c07fdd957f5d334e1f9892577454d8bc4ae", "started_sha256": "ded14494f6bef314f9ba2635e9a6a1eb20bc6093b6708b5ceea57632d7c458a5", "original_grade_sha256": "0a325d9564540ed7507e99c5eca197193a3e0003bd077fcd58873eb316548eaa", "input_original_sha256": "4bf429cb99d8179e169a068134544c07fdd957f5d334e1f9892577454d8bc4ae", "input_wav_sha256": "7a6d0ce67b0498690f238ddc969e1243866b03c79aea314a3570aaafee37c9c1", "input_pcm_sha256": "162f21f2686f887555c93ec5c0280d9c98404ef9efce683658be476af59853cc", "output_wav_sha256": "87298f22946be22a3fac76d80e195b12e6c0f7f0a6b75bc8a939c4734044b31c", "output_pcm_sha256": "5199aba8ffc233fca4b8875ea5abb7bd36ecceadc98f46d831c2e006fd0a8bb9", "result_sha256": "577cd39f2d18b549a45e418132920ff69dfefa555f693d1610c8806829a06848" } }, { "id": 615, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "2", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3b348c85113448cdeeb6dbb14a0232cd5ff7c336e70c6f5c7a6e9f73485d4e64", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3b348c85113448cdeeb6dbb14a0232cd5ff7c336e70c6f5c7a6e9f73485d4e64", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a flute and a trombone. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a flute and a trombone. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 2.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 3740.35, "reasoner_ms": 1426.47, "tts_ms": 24.96, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5191.81, "total_processing_ms": 5689.3 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 731, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a9678c1775ea894305fa4ab95605e4de9fa2b1a05fa8c0953c7d17cfd3f7e334", "started_sha256": "b6f75e1276cafdb040934124601c909699594af1d1ec828f1954077f5bc83c5c", "original_grade_sha256": "4b4bfda01c72868a2b42a7ac59ea04c570c7d66457002e708c5e6d7ee516af85", "input_original_sha256": "a9678c1775ea894305fa4ab95605e4de9fa2b1a05fa8c0953c7d17cfd3f7e334", "input_wav_sha256": "9f6f7f18c5fc0e2bcb384aae19a36bae78bac330bed3abc22194ce84f6ede4e2", "input_pcm_sha256": "63ddde9c2983e91433fccba96159f2a6c19da72b8b18233ae8612a0352cd41d2", "output_wav_sha256": "9b7d4277ad40e233cb067c90e5fd68a02cea1da39cdccf31b66fa7ad87196d52", "output_pcm_sha256": "85291b522e163c492af0e0646d38a066abb3bd82e4a88d944f0e5b0ef9ea3981", "result_sha256": "d48d3c0c119d4e94f25fc17fa08acc95f557a6f1fde926587e2daa1ad6d7c358" } }, { "id": 752, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "df9bcab6fdc4439bbb38e8aab24ff366ccafdb3819747c91fb7c53d487840702", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "df9bcab6fdc4439bbb38e8aab24ff366ccafdb3819747c91fb7c53d487840702", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Veena tells the truth. Helene says Veena lies. Candy says Helene tells the truth. Jamie says Candy lies. Ka says Jamie lies. Does Ka tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Veena tells the truth. Helene says Veena lies. Candy says Helene tells the truth. Jamie says Candy lies. Ka says Jamie lies. Does Ka tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5603.88, "reasoner_ms": 2300.62, "tts_ms": 23.19, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7927.72, "total_processing_ms": 8482.8 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 824, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 120 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "cfc9c8d17923c4d621129032babe8012c1d5b20bfda64f058c0be910bdc09c33", "started_sha256": "505c1f39ca0d1f6f95173d6badfe090f4e62c421b762ec63310296f515eb1b62", "original_grade_sha256": "fa67afffefa43416f4c500585fff80117e50e6517abdb1b36292942da12e3e29", "input_original_sha256": "cfc9c8d17923c4d621129032babe8012c1d5b20bfda64f058c0be910bdc09c33", "input_wav_sha256": "f0a3699ab7ad079e86328d38475b8cfa5269498d892894d64ebf314309ea8b67", "input_pcm_sha256": "4c07ffe6d648710b9e0ff2a520dd44b3e4b5eb25c80923a0c2360756f47f87b0", "output_wav_sha256": "3f361b2a3c620d1c8e820053d41dcb1b607c8271f4e51edae34da04f3b7cda99", "output_pcm_sha256": "3e692d2f692179820f94c0490d01fe0525749f85020349fe598de3e3ed69bcdd", "result_sha256": "1bda68388c5d2918df44cae3b59ba5e585fb698a545f5109b6009b3b506a2bca" } }, { "id": 234, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "33f7ae0f02133024caffb768d60a2bb9e9136a52126bba59e5ac1ddcc30a3790", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "33f7ae0f02133024caffb768d60a2bb9e9136a52126bba59e5ac1ddcc30a3790", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. Whoever is not a classmate of Alvin is a schoolmate of Wilbrun. Whoever is not a son of Charles is however a stepbrother of Ivan or a schoolmate of Wilbrun. Nobody is neither a classmate of Alvin nor a stepbrother of Ivan. It follows that whoever is not a classmate of Alvin is a son of Charles. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question, whoever is not a classmate of Alvin is a schoolmate of Wilbron. Whoever is not a son of Charles is however a stepbrother of Ivan or a schoolmate of Wilbron. Nobody is neither a classmate of Alvin nor a stepbrother of Ivan. It follows that whoever is not a classmate of Alvin is a son of Charles. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid Invalid Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13864.41, "reasoner_ms": 6805.06, "tts_ms": 26.23, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 20695.74, "total_processing_ms": 21571.46 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1070, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 559 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8396323ec0678356b05a587a76e54f1798179c616c7243d55481d8e46249c038", "started_sha256": "3ea31978c782477bb30ab3fa491d862bc1db7eb26c142ef2b735161f0d1d4391", "original_grade_sha256": "a51d0893a0af42da8d8a3c3ebe2d69c52257b633d807466df90e0223bb77e63c", "input_original_sha256": "8396323ec0678356b05a587a76e54f1798179c616c7243d55481d8e46249c038", "input_wav_sha256": "7ebaa4edd486ac73e19371fc2370996a33cd5013d6b17529f33cb2dcf79f7226", "input_pcm_sha256": "83b2e053e33eb02fdc1b0cd09645b5d6b027dec95c22e8a6029bd2405db86b31", "output_wav_sha256": "ed9919252715054206d0013cca74abbeb590f33279e577abec7d1970df0f1e8a", "output_pcm_sha256": "ca0a68c88e6fbcd1981800746f88455393ee098976aeaf7a95aebe841add517a", "result_sha256": "1f42b8f05ad78395ebfe7dd9e33cfe0fdbc5ef66080d9b1c292e74ddbc1e6a0c" } }, { "id": 349, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "479ad3301c41f41f636182de123e2b32c5f8fe23f339b8e59e74774f9210b5e7", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "479ad3301c41f41f636182de123e2b32c5f8fe23f339b8e59e74774f9210b5e7", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps backward. Take two steps backward. Take one step forward. Take six steps forward. Take three steps forward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps backward. Take two steps backward. Take one step forward. Take six steps forward. Take three steps forward. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6655.46, "reasoner_ms": 1738.02, "tts_ms": 23.92, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8417.43, "total_processing_ms": 8968.61 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 831, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 43 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "4dcf5c5bf0bb90fbc8e04eb06db2170193a6e1f57eb292604837e0bb84c80c7e", "started_sha256": "46d65aa06796e5c012f49558e9c4cf4a300b68d11b6ffde1756bca141869fe0b", "original_grade_sha256": "3900180ef59905054a906e93fb93d6f5f00ae2077b26fb0ae3f135161a2a0cc4", "input_original_sha256": "4dcf5c5bf0bb90fbc8e04eb06db2170193a6e1f57eb292604837e0bb84c80c7e", "input_wav_sha256": "630ced58efeb1dac825eebc9285d4cfd19c7b69cbcf659c17bee0ad51a6553e9", "input_pcm_sha256": "a0a62e97c1e2166fb40bc44bc8a7a85c8d20fa97f5bee8fcc36186b1233d5a5d", "output_wav_sha256": "b6dee20488823ca878784ba7d57aade1007862a5982bcfd9e1db63a5ddeeb31c", "output_pcm_sha256": "c95333e125b03645d3a80c82fabda8dff231205dd8949be9a43f149204d770a2", "result_sha256": "acc63af6918aa28822a593220524a61d02b500cea449b460f8c3cdca5fd761a2" } }, { "id": 628, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "7", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a98c8806a85f77e2beaab445be4f449420e5c9beca7400a1a4a7fcafb5b5e4a4", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a98c8806a85f77e2beaab445be4f449420e5c9beca7400a1a4a7fcafb5b5e4a4", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a drum, three flutes, a trumpet, a piano, and a trombone. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a drum, three flutes, a trumpet, a piano, and a trombone. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 7.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4435.21, "reasoner_ms": 1498.96, "tts_ms": 20.81, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5955.0, "total_processing_ms": 6486.67 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 764, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 45 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "719cf10deee4686469c5034c46c1d7ad967271702fd1464128b498de9bc0d118", "started_sha256": "8c37803e9549c63b5b9faacc533156d0c4173b1ad96900a2e39ac31e44fbe790", "original_grade_sha256": "45a7ffb8f6c23f7e217216e4a1df97190b8fdb9c7d99954d4ce6173e980f3e6e", "input_original_sha256": "719cf10deee4686469c5034c46c1d7ad967271702fd1464128b498de9bc0d118", "input_wav_sha256": "214e7b1f692b8f0db1d4b272841ec1d201bddb997288826cf52585e9d7f8e2c1", "input_pcm_sha256": "80503acd754fe9d5ce6d92722ca039b4252c789a41dcf0c2341d23035509a750", "output_wav_sha256": "8ad06794f3913ec0d2668bd02d6dc30435b62c927c2505e228d3cf9490d4ea57", "output_pcm_sha256": "128b1819ea4620012f9fa352662115850787df43df52b9a799e681bfe979e3ce", "result_sha256": "8bd7aa8368b3d20ee3737ca1fd81f599aed3be93b5579133f97b9be512756872" } }, { "id": 927, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b1b71e4e5511c584e034d338c12a60023deba2490aaff15bc8f71d3f06bf7218", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b1b71e4e5511c584e034d338c12a60023deba2490aaff15bc8f71d3f06bf7218", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Millicent lies. Loreen says Millicent lies. Rashida says Loreen lies. Seema says Rashida lies. Phoebe says Seema tells the truth. Does Phoebe tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion, Millicent lies. Lorene says Millicent lies. Rashida says Lorene lies. Seema says Rashida lies. Phoebe says Seema tells the truth. Does Phoebe tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5972.3, "reasoner_ms": 2126.91, "tts_ms": 28.96, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8128.2, "total_processing_ms": 8710.6 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 833, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 124 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "c6a4b87545bbf860e3d428f50a3b5a84b0e6d26844bbad1425b2a2e61c456a3a", "started_sha256": "33e061363e278bdf8d74d92a686c1e0dfc891a640f05fdb67eb448b55ad84000", "original_grade_sha256": "0e6dd774625ff3a7fcc8bc2fd60e04990dd1b6d9f11cb9be9558b82e9e52976e", "input_original_sha256": "c6a4b87545bbf860e3d428f50a3b5a84b0e6d26844bbad1425b2a2e61c456a3a", "input_wav_sha256": "280c628eb9af1adad8754c635556e4c33af3fc8dd266121b423cd8f65c05c510", "input_pcm_sha256": "9afed67032582f77531e958d5d6a69c81f895a6bf92a2da5c6cad6b9e3390211", "output_wav_sha256": "aa4ce56ffc0512d9e3262f33ad57efb10d888ac64066fe9d0d2d6428405f2df7", "output_pcm_sha256": "b6c967d4dc8840085000aa43e2f0cd23cfc2cbe089ae31db7c5de01861e2f886", "result_sha256": "bbeb342bae79815e6a4ac718445ebe70695ed18ba5244b93514b5185129a27d4" } }, { "id": 56, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "71e8311b67b3366a4e6b29f109aa50b96267496a0bb7dc6b87204f0807d3d354", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "71e8311b67b3366a4e6b29f109aa50b96267496a0bb7dc6b87204f0807d3d354", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, everyone who is a half-brother of Ronnie or a classmate of Sal is not a son of Ronald. Second, it is false that Santo is a son of Ronald. So necessarily, Santo is a half-brother of Ronnie or a classmate of Sal. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, everyone who is a half-brother of Ronnie or a classmate of Sal is not a son of Ronald. Second, it is false that Santo is a son of Ronald. So, necessarily, Santo is a half-brother of Ronnie or a classmate of Sal. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11193.84, "reasoner_ms": 2865.98, "tts_ms": 26.45, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 14086.31, "total_processing_ms": 14639.94 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 965, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 105 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6b5a455d833cb960f17ce4b2489ca91b67ffad49ae478c3dc3e674f7e98e5091", "started_sha256": "f1242d70a0af6c4ebab822e7dba916d779d993863571282fc21f33ccfab53ae6", "original_grade_sha256": "93f19cd8b7d9a3ba4d2c4c87be322c07de9a1d48b69d7c077e08aac138b6b976", "input_original_sha256": "6b5a455d833cb960f17ce4b2489ca91b67ffad49ae478c3dc3e674f7e98e5091", "input_wav_sha256": "e4ef56c59e4088b2e97cd2902fc8b41823cfe78b83549032ffe29921c722f8aa", "input_pcm_sha256": "ff780ab593d7694cc9d2dea40aba7618784f1ca60acec9385e8f771d801fadf4", "output_wav_sha256": "bc4c30f899448446c1b0a3bc5ee5cc2a02046e03e46d8b78fa35c801ba73408d", "output_pcm_sha256": "909a92dc2b84e50e2a93c175dae42813adefeee9d7bf365da19c547002062b43", "result_sha256": "cabd912f9867413c65eaf429d0602e6043cf30bbad63a33d65eea81ad3078179" } }, { "id": 419, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f5bc3b8ca30321f8a92b8a7317d475ba308ba815120729dab63f2200f7d53c6a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f5bc3b8ca30321f8a92b8a7317d475ba308ba815120729dab63f2200f7d53c6a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps left. Take two steps right. Take six steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps left. Take two steps right. Take six steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5999.7, "reasoner_ms": 1835.11, "tts_ms": 23.31, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7858.14, "total_processing_ms": 8491.42 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 797, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 45 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1643552b8353a118bd9c5afdac658daea44a4dc9a2d3c4ee7de169147f8f60f7", "started_sha256": "c5331bf94d2adf84072946a8dc30536cefbf55dd88080f8752e469d7f15bf08d", "original_grade_sha256": "e9a256d3a12ce36ca56908cb82d076810065d9b172f041bc87622feb01279aa5", "input_original_sha256": "1643552b8353a118bd9c5afdac658daea44a4dc9a2d3c4ee7de169147f8f60f7", "input_wav_sha256": "097914abb18e4c60e8ae8ad35b36509e27d3139115dd7024d78c137ac41c3d57", "input_pcm_sha256": "1c3831631c7ee41e15f2f75004d3f0ca7df591e5d3cce22963fd018eb96ad7ea", "output_wav_sha256": "be342d0a92d2c2d7c7ca7d638f8f5d4bd85a1d2af26652c7856544d37c34e09b", "output_pcm_sha256": "6d94032d6fdd6216ef18db3a170b24bd1a06b744d3847748e76d6ee6d49f60b7", "result_sha256": "9e357e33526860d2f060617fd21b2d5d289f5f600cd0200f2b835a8c172bc6a4" } }, { "id": 663, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "13", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6d53700bbf9ac022f84fa6976395f4e2ac55a31edaba91c29278fa3169f06517", "normalized_answer": "13" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6d53700bbf9ac022f84fa6976395f4e2ac55a31edaba91c29278fa3169f06517", "normalized_answer": "13" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a lettuce head, two yams, a cabbage, a stalk of celery, three heads of broccoli, a garlic, an onion, a carrot, a cauliflower, and a potato. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a lettuce head, two yams, a cabbage, a stalk of celery, three heads of broccoli, a garlic, an onion, a carrot, a cauliflower, and a potato. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 13.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5885.69, "reasoner_ms": 2075.76, "tts_ms": 26.61, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7988.09, "total_processing_ms": 8571.86 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 832, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 98 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ac39d824d4ced9185648300bd4abb304dcc1728e6e6fec1ff833fc14ae2990c7", "started_sha256": "dcfb8754f6174a4333b7bd78a5d0e8be62cd950ee9e707ec3cafcaeddc7f585f", "original_grade_sha256": "a0cab882d0fa545eb6b0e81489508076f41055e36a3d58dac0ac440892ca7c3b", "input_original_sha256": "ac39d824d4ced9185648300bd4abb304dcc1728e6e6fec1ff833fc14ae2990c7", "input_wav_sha256": "6fa8be2c4ca637402eb557aded9e41035c53196d9791ce4786b3dcc17c784f6f", "input_pcm_sha256": "553e7460bc223a57cf698bceac4133f82c79514e7ad2bfc7ceb62ba5e0e90690", "output_wav_sha256": "080ced6253827f816479931092f65ab1dda4b849ce592f9f4e88446f809da30e", "output_pcm_sha256": "8e36b05c5efb57d3617e075d8e2693e6cbf2ac1d3f7f2a9acdd30a63237a127d", "result_sha256": "52261e525a140f31874dcbc9f34d4ea595d4490795aa7e7ba48cd7ba68592aa5" } }, { "id": 757, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ddea810c9c1676e5931a93407f83fe7e8d24777ee01f152534582f4c5ff9ded6", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ddea810c9c1676e5931a93407f83fe7e8d24777ee01f152534582f4c5ff9ded6", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Jim lies. Krista says Jim lies. Vanell says Krista tells the truth. Bonita says Vanell tells the truth. Millicent says Bonita tells the truth. Does Millicent tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Jim lies. Krista says Jim lies. Vanell says Krista tells the truth. Benita says Vanell tells the truth. Millicent says Benita tells the truth. Does Millicent tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5688.78, "reasoner_ms": 1901.57, "tts_ms": 26.31, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7616.69, "total_processing_ms": 8190.9 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 85 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "9637b2c712594a648b6e2c8946669f03852be039835a8911402a3fca7ee99021", "started_sha256": "73ad3c365d158181b098466573b0e3498437728ea6a7c110363091b5d4f18b96", "original_grade_sha256": "2779fdbd7fd10d980d00453c527d211cf71c892b6c64ae4daacddb6efacd24c7", "input_original_sha256": "9637b2c712594a648b6e2c8946669f03852be039835a8911402a3fca7ee99021", "input_wav_sha256": "43996e7c81cc70e6b237723264349576c922968bde8bea8eef7b9b3306705866", "input_pcm_sha256": "816d4a4e0829ddb626a7c3ade5dd61a23df91b6ebe47a1fad484b441df01e996", "output_wav_sha256": "fd8db8099e573804458998637cb429d3d51bae18a28a4090e73e001c4cf90e95", "output_pcm_sha256": "3b33995a293b843a6d9820b7b29c7e09472a10dd88cc67c51c492f1e0120b830", "result_sha256": "bcdf47387937798bc7e891b3157a9320078e30cf901d6453e4781e8c00d265c0" } }, { "id": 122, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a3ca097892568581a1de61dada521936689b0269d5dc8ef05aff521a58a92919", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a3ca097892568581a1de61dada521936689b0269d5dc8ef05aff521a58a92919", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, whoever is not a nephew of Renee is a great-grandfather of Andy. Hence, no great-grandfather of Andy is a nephew of Renee. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nhere comes a perfectly valid argument to begin with whoever is not a nephew of ren is a great-grandfather of andy hence no great-grandfather of andy is a nephew of ren is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8569.4, "reasoner_ms": 3879.21, "tts_ms": 25.93, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 12474.57, "total_processing_ms": 13044.29 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 790, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 222 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "fba49edbfe90d9b44f0660c184d08971d9bde008e7da7bafa54d542072547b56", "started_sha256": "241565668d3a3d25931ef7ba90a9df555106fb7f28e460358d157cd28f1593cd", "original_grade_sha256": "e3954913092f9e5560ca48c514f64d18d0f8fb6f2487b132823bdb87e1c55ee7", "input_original_sha256": "fba49edbfe90d9b44f0660c184d08971d9bde008e7da7bafa54d542072547b56", "input_wav_sha256": "5f8df5fc961b62a2534c261a4e37912406c652489bf2ec7ff2a9fe1d2f987fd2", "input_pcm_sha256": "53b9e832e1b4f1b3615b5ed2d2d230dcb20b0feb43cc391c50a2e21a39ab7578", "output_wav_sha256": "16e84acee7bc715a5889c6a467f0535d992e003f399972f437271b430047430d", "output_pcm_sha256": "76cd89f1332f9f52ba7c9b8fc59e6ceafcc5ef21ded2c87d39928162d34b7c64", "result_sha256": "049d74d4d923d7aba0856f5c6d4981e8f7357c3c38cd9905837ebfa99df92eff" } }, { "id": 294, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "edf38f55923ea747fef6fe81d5108da939a0ef0c311f007b2f1b11a3c7d3c713", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "edf38f55923ea747fef6fe81d5108da939a0ef0c311f007b2f1b11a3c7d3c713", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take seven steps forward. Take seven steps backward. Take ten steps backward. Take ten steps forward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take seven steps forward. Take seven steps backward. Take ten steps backward. Take ten steps forward. Yes? No? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6102.14, "reasoner_ms": 1685.83, "tts_ms": 26.5, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7814.5, "total_processing_ms": 8442.29 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 823, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 31 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1a04cad08b4ca62818776bbe2ce2900ae5345654e0816944e47915944ff796bd", "started_sha256": "6304440c3b4d3420857625e4a7eed3dce7a2335f8d63f841e8595275539b7932", "original_grade_sha256": "3cf5a393b6e7a0950754bcc83ba777f5e3ed494dd45d36a3b1b11824bbab9a4c", "input_original_sha256": "1a04cad08b4ca62818776bbe2ce2900ae5345654e0816944e47915944ff796bd", "input_wav_sha256": "b62ee244abeaead21842d7ecca1e9a9dd119ac4a2ce9a859d76646753484a6b8", "input_pcm_sha256": "cd4ab09f864634002f8a5a112aa762b8327234cd21e60e0829bec27168bdcee3", "output_wav_sha256": "0b35b13bf9a5197ee619e2fa5856c8daf39cdf403fc170dabfb6d163b0d59a4a", "output_pcm_sha256": "773af7e49207b1791bea8c0346f1e4c7390bce5b358ad2d0a1056d71f260e761", "result_sha256": "b5281a9ee2ece8071ba4d6d7335a16030d9e8d6b6262f8c8e3ec851ab77272a1" } }, { "id": 730, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "12", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "976762ae06f5c5c48a0957501e1b96dc2e4ec7b092b0052e1a7a4502521c9dab", "normalized_answer": "12" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "976762ae06f5c5c48a0957501e1b96dc2e4ec7b092b0052e1a7a4502521c9dab", "normalized_answer": "12" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a duck, a cat, a frog, a mouse, a pig, a rabbit, two snakes, a bear, and three goats. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a duck a cat a frog a mouse a pig a rabbit two snakes a bear and three goats how many animals do i have answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 12.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7400.46, "reasoner_ms": 1765.45, "tts_ms": 24.56, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9190.5, "total_processing_ms": 9848.89 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 780, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 73 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "27a0601d4532a1fc6f11c9dba8091d4558bbc5f9337f3c89cdcebe515a12bd2e", "started_sha256": "442d365b5e6247cabf91e8946cb11730d822705a984c77aac3dff9d80d854ddf", "original_grade_sha256": "f10bbb4a5c112f6d113480cee8ee5e8f874b897cc7f2ddf1a1ffbf6d6b036786", "input_original_sha256": "27a0601d4532a1fc6f11c9dba8091d4558bbc5f9337f3c89cdcebe515a12bd2e", "input_wav_sha256": "bec6d3972aa8591ce38f134da0792b221c6fd42cf5d523ae217a400df94d2b17", "input_pcm_sha256": "7e6ff7d8f71bd744fd2feb748a51f5d95bdb85f572950323f14508e5bd2cdd71", "output_wav_sha256": "04f916bb0ddfed964921c8935e5692f29d1e639bf7792aa8052aef15e6ac7c09", "output_pcm_sha256": "bc5b3ea836dd874a3f37008a1053da924627de438b8b0acb8d558b10cd728d64", "result_sha256": "54349b9115f51916212a7319bc27d78e1c48ab376b402090cccca7eb70134b34" } }, { "id": 876, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4cee55b8009ddf2b2a3cab2ea7ef64bf764f8d9f427d5f7a9fbae2a4f0c0f070", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4cee55b8009ddf2b2a3cab2ea7ef64bf764f8d9f427d5f7a9fbae2a4f0c0f070", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Amberly lies. Shalanda says Amberly tells the truth. Haylyn says Shalanda tells the truth. Shamma says Haylyn tells the truth. Christie says Shamma tells the truth. Does Christie tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion amberly lies shalanda says amberly tells the truth haleen says shalanda tells the truth shema says haleen tells the truth christie says shema tells the truth does christie tell the truth answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8547.78, "reasoner_ms": 4850.46, "tts_ms": 20.88, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 13419.16, "total_processing_ms": 13988.43 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 832, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 135 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "773485081fc7cb23434789b012366c205b31ab893d9e560edc448ee53ca72ee0", "started_sha256": "ac997f421daf46cafe47ff5fc839d0fa9e14aeae3233a72e9dab1498cc9ee3e4", "original_grade_sha256": "2281fe88b564d7a74bc4338ba507510b632cf8ee864550f0bc06ebd3918ece4f", "input_original_sha256": "773485081fc7cb23434789b012366c205b31ab893d9e560edc448ee53ca72ee0", "input_wav_sha256": "ec1570420f3585fec6b2faf1d55baf12d9ab03d5dc084bb00c4754ffe606512a", "input_pcm_sha256": "bb4c0cadc8073767a875408fe03f7ea74a6d1f6e2a91fdc22a6bd3eec5096ed8", "output_wav_sha256": "78ba55dd6f9aba1a8c82897eeecc54e7a7838db2aa49676a1b86e7dbeaba9172", "output_pcm_sha256": "911968ebbf721287261820740018494c442af40c11d74161f3a536ca8b997bdf", "result_sha256": "7c98a0fecb7972d364be39ccb4628153a2de96c744beceb29deabc408f6114e7" } }, { "id": 1, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4586e2f099150768c9721ef6b5f5c825afb6b8e6a14e22b1564cdeda94013c5f", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4586e2f099150768c9721ef6b5f5c825afb6b8e6a14e22b1564cdeda94013c5f", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, being a cousin of Chris is sufficient for not being a son of Kermit. We may conclude that whoever is not a son of Kermit is a cousin of Chris. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument, first, being a cousin of Chris is sufficient for not being a son of Kermit. We may conclude that whoever is not a son of Kermit is a cousin of Chris. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options? Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6779.11, "reasoner_ms": 1874.66, "tts_ms": 28.7, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8682.5, "total_processing_ms": 9242.27 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 902, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 64 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1ba88c41618722050295d4d27a64d8f08e1bf02f6856f00d29923c2cf38c31ea", "started_sha256": "d1880a0cfc43ffc083416b553c197c1f64151f01c0d1cbadddfa4803ada9dff5", "original_grade_sha256": "561dfcea83ec2fcf9b468569be0621d82012211a9bd176bea3986cbca8839735", "input_original_sha256": "1ba88c41618722050295d4d27a64d8f08e1bf02f6856f00d29923c2cf38c31ea", "input_wav_sha256": "88a2b0cffbca595b93b10cad320e680aa9e357205e6ab0f7d328338f7a407734", "input_pcm_sha256": "650e72597ea68e60a4d4f1d517b6f5c7c5a80d996980afe7798bec07cbe8ba0b", "output_wav_sha256": "0af860560a66b2a628e77d7e7619014b7f75cb6b97d37d84976faa1b885362d3", "output_pcm_sha256": "7b402a9125fa462a9b81ffbeb4872b822d215fab8269318dc81df6dfe6893ffd", "result_sha256": "6d3a06db50552d9dd9ccf5934c44029a55550154ab8400dc5528c12ccd678e19" } }, { "id": 460, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "39ae018ae4e525e56aab7a7f1d6fed8ced48b7f196f705b13eac2055f3c34c6a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "39ae018ae4e525e56aab7a7f1d6fed8ced48b7f196f705b13eac2055f3c34c6a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take one step backward. Take one step backward. Take one step backward. Take three steps forward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take one step backward. Take one step backward. Take one step backward. Take three steps forward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6279.58, "reasoner_ms": 1545.31, "tts_ms": 24.84, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7849.77, "total_processing_ms": 8431.69 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 811, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 27 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ec2ae41c1a84cc6ed986fd567b81030909f6b996647fbe51ee857611061f6a65", "started_sha256": "ba0b0a1ad72a19fdd1f1dcaf971aa0b22f243c5e87952bd8da9860e118e93c8c", "original_grade_sha256": "a209e1ca196d8927246c68045a34d0302acf3dd9c01ba6d15155e8b0eca135e6", "input_original_sha256": "ec2ae41c1a84cc6ed986fd567b81030909f6b996647fbe51ee857611061f6a65", "input_wav_sha256": "bbfac98cc986bca7ad8b9579aeba81e15096b3198fbb2a5b5aa0ff6e21f22f73", "input_pcm_sha256": "6f794bcee20fb372878156e645b6e06ad3548b4cc4e2aa78a7533b7d308dfdf5", "output_wav_sha256": "4c08721367334c716f616e4e6c97e0729fadca93a7001c0a4bb00dad8239625c", "output_pcm_sha256": "bbdbb21e99005124c560b98b7d7d73b077824f94431b33de5a867e26a7369065", "result_sha256": "f8867dc12235887c9a46d78c7a3ee7a3af6128d507ac18da91f4eab0f3abefa8" } }, { "id": 535, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "6", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b724841b523f40f4315311446492fb2ffb2ebdeb2f88d5081fe94e64423075c7", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b724841b523f40f4315311446492fb2ffb2ebdeb2f88d5081fe94e64423075c7", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a mouse, a rabbit, a dog, a duck, and two goats. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a mouse a rabbit a dog a duck and two goats how many animals do i have answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 6.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6660.69, "reasoner_ms": 1467.45, "tts_ms": 25.34, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8153.51, "total_processing_ms": 8722.82 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 756, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 22 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "01078429e26ea6b910363a4ecbd06fface0820852ec7c0eb071bcaa2e104ee17", "started_sha256": "622431299481df52b2a126c2d9f6367998500f6f4e0bf854ec3838fe1e9f6318", "original_grade_sha256": "6d7e6cbab6ea647fe590ad176162d575d4df1d3cd1ffbae63be1f7c0cc635c33", "input_original_sha256": "01078429e26ea6b910363a4ecbd06fface0820852ec7c0eb071bcaa2e104ee17", "input_wav_sha256": "8e1da756d6fb0cdc6b2fa950524f88e7f46f7f3e7782e12bab6131c3c1fc7f2e", "input_pcm_sha256": "bda63234d6be8fc4b203409c48ad318a5a7dd9c2a25855e9ecd1332b48880de3", "output_wav_sha256": "d21b4fae081d255dd7cd2998e971d8bdc9cafda0087af82a16c5e63fdbbb3aa9", "output_pcm_sha256": "192973c4636af8a40e6d9b3101c18ff4b0e2f6969a4be8dd9bc8a5ab236b231f", "result_sha256": "0584966677636fcb9ef2076cb835d1c03756e55d114a50681f2a3134caf13830" } }, { "id": 750, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0c57a5b34298c355ae88c670a62ef081bff5ab768b220a33d05c232ee195e447", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0c57a5b34298c355ae88c670a62ef081bff5ab768b220a33d05c232ee195e447", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Sherry tells the truth. Vanell says Sherry tells the truth. Alexis says Vanell lies. Makayla says Alexis tells the truth. Eleanor says Makayla tells the truth. Does Eleanor tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Sherry tells the truth. Vanell says Sherry tells the truth. Alexis says Vanell lies. Michaela says Alexis tells the truth. Eleanor says Michaela tells the truth. Does Eleanor tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "That answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5416.02, "reasoner_ms": 2402.49, "tts_ms": 26.72, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7845.27, "total_processing_ms": 8384.21 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 855, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 122 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "736d47c7525a1c64bf70b4449ec117345c9091f2835331af04b8daa2e02f226b", "started_sha256": "f842bcf5d1646c3ed8f82b982acb7f2e3221595b289909029798f8c1f462bcf2", "original_grade_sha256": "77a1748aa953328a8774a046dd4a3f9fa966c53c5ed97c747d6750449286056f", "input_original_sha256": "736d47c7525a1c64bf70b4449ec117345c9091f2835331af04b8daa2e02f226b", "input_wav_sha256": "e2cd1218de897f1532cdce5ae71b5c706941633ec8bd81ff8210bebec93722de", "input_pcm_sha256": "ac6925a82df72ace244007f1a3f77aa22bdac6b4830d5d239943a86c1eb18b20", "output_wav_sha256": "ab10b9ad26e5ba244f7ac180a6e22a0f27b6d602af74f4b7011cb8c9a24cf81e", "output_pcm_sha256": "4bb727f282a78e6fb5ce42d346df660eb9fb2d0d365c2d7c034161042b19b67d", "result_sha256": "a05f66e6f7abfcfd5ab7eba38d5c6ddbc70cef698f57c6b7277b3d389bca75c7" } }, { "id": 126, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "eb0c34d09b470d20201ccc465f69204dd2879b3b46cacb8804fcf9ad019569ea", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "eb0c34d09b470d20201ccc465f69204dd2879b3b46cacb8804fcf9ad019569ea", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, every close friend of Krista is not a niece of Gwendolyn or not an ancestor of Terry. Second, everyone who is a cousin of Lori is a close friend of Krista, too. We may conclude that no cousin of Lori is both an ancestor of Terry and a niece of Gwendolyn. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, every close friend of Christa is not a niece of Gwendolyn or not an ancestor of Terry. Second, everyone who is a cousin of Laurie is a close friend of Christa, too. We may conclude that no cousin of Laurie is both an ancestor of Terry and a niece of Gwendolyn. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8313.16, "reasoner_ms": 2826.11, "tts_ms": 30.81, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11170.11, "total_processing_ms": 11739.02 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 901, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 153 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "c2f1266be3fdfb3ced263a8405676ff3f70bb5292d4c63462656dfd726c239a6", "started_sha256": "0dbe868c680f090d27655b11b44a8888ed5736618773f1a60888f124035645d5", "original_grade_sha256": "136f459d4d1870a4634dcc37de90d310fc3c131a41ac990a32557d1b4b7c35e2", "input_original_sha256": "c2f1266be3fdfb3ced263a8405676ff3f70bb5292d4c63462656dfd726c239a6", "input_wav_sha256": "251e932a7c529643283ca667813e17ad7b41bfe5fe7206562d70000a9e05ac1c", "input_pcm_sha256": "abae90a310e20811bf7397933998acaa7c1fa554e97147ba7aa4a763b870fa31", "output_wav_sha256": "bfaa05b6551a4defd83d122729af3d0824a27d5f2ca80f2f36312cf7b54eb2ba", "output_pcm_sha256": "f92fee0c42e1697f019d36e22f271ee7a719e4c040b8c4151ece3903e9fdb7b9", "result_sha256": "9390aa9f580a1047a8d7f3d8bfa6b8e82b08dc472d69703a13a51438188fdf0d" } }, { "id": 397, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "177bd8dff898e2dbdc568309c8e81d4708c76444eeaa98a75d731ca3056ab0ad", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "177bd8dff898e2dbdc568309c8e81d4708c76444eeaa98a75d731ca3056ab0ad", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps left. Take nine steps right. Take one step right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point always face forward take eight steps left take nine steps right take one step right options yes no answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "That answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8212.21, "reasoner_ms": 1984.63, "tts_ms": 24.56, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10221.43, "total_processing_ms": 10753.37 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 788, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 72 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0a78d567b65f2996d4caf0d612e7962ac2a2c4f1fa10aedfc8d28d744bc74fb9", "started_sha256": "40330e7335d99d7541bafe7d13890e757be90854033812ffca7dc99d39a40a58", "original_grade_sha256": "ec771e9096ecc8269270da5cd96f2cca95021625e3011ee24de202b8fc4b7bfe", "input_original_sha256": "0a78d567b65f2996d4caf0d612e7962ac2a2c4f1fa10aedfc8d28d744bc74fb9", "input_wav_sha256": "a1e3711d6b5c5f50126e563f27b44d69147c93319c2fca3c1b78b6e540ce2449", "input_pcm_sha256": "6555f01e7a8eb2861c733a1214b3795fc323a6db70d96fdf309b43a636034f6d", "output_wav_sha256": "c127e7dcc52f25d2e1cd2048dd69037540f6f141ef23ea0773083c161703e682", "output_pcm_sha256": "fcab898f41e39b9a1aa77963ee8a0ab980f8d8576c66dfd52b9bf40a12874245", "result_sha256": "2ebca9038bbae01746cc5c1491c7281b9a34beb072f27bf8f036711fbf4008ea" } }, { "id": 715, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5b925ccecc310e6349b1d41f7d1f00d506cd95fb7f6ac99c0b40fb74ea1f0675", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5b925ccecc310e6349b1d41f7d1f00d506cd95fb7f6ac99c0b40fb74ea1f0675", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have an oven, a table, a lamp, three couches, a toaster, a microwave, and a bed. How many objects do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have an oven, a table, a lamp, three couches, a toaster, a microwave, and a bed. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 9.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4608.34, "reasoner_ms": 1619.88, "tts_ms": 20.38, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6248.63, "total_processing_ms": 6797.33 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 769, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 54 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "028120346ebe02f86a705328c9ecd2fd6922e2937632c920748b5c1eb9a3fa06", "started_sha256": "b47bc471b0f65767aa88658354b5b365ca70ce98458378f39e6a69f4e2a66155", "original_grade_sha256": "08cfe8a69815f95d77bf4dac99404749a987a420727369f76311c113b7241129", "input_original_sha256": "028120346ebe02f86a705328c9ecd2fd6922e2937632c920748b5c1eb9a3fa06", "input_wav_sha256": "ad0a581dfb03d1d920567e7fce28e293a7ab6f5794b783b2c6632c5e2bb37e48", "input_pcm_sha256": "2b69d2888511bb64cfc6d702319f494497e6b1949b2e0429525fcc83b551c9c0", "output_wav_sha256": "22321df6f23c1f7ceb2dc7ad0762cc49a286a3be0991c3814895b3000481a013", "output_pcm_sha256": "55fc7c8c3089f72f15d567c1e2b91c0aae6a908894b88fc877d96fe1f8e46ff0", "result_sha256": "1405a6971ccdfa085c8a5466226d04f8801e2e9e411142511df3c131772dbb3a" } }, { "id": 950, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "development", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8ddd8184a00f53fd703dc9b3633eb987f509c0d3e8b551df7dde574bc824996a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8ddd8184a00f53fd703dc9b3633eb987f509c0d3e8b551df7dde574bc824996a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Willian lies. Raymond says Willian tells the truth. Rashida says Raymond lies. Gwen says Rashida lies. Kay says Gwen lies. Does Kay tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. William lies. Raymond says William tells the truth. Rashida says Raymond lies. Gwen says Rashida lies. Kay says Gwen lies. Does Kay tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4759.58, "reasoner_ms": 2041.01, "tts_ms": 26.25, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6826.87, "total_processing_ms": 7397.45 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 822, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 103 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a6cc05cce18fe80a293d7b3a5734917e79833972bfdaa6ee916932ed18e6d1e4", "started_sha256": "865ee4cad08390c8d98450d2e9e24ad05ad3d46c71093a68be9b49ac24e765b1", "original_grade_sha256": "15b75506692087755924e9dc485fbd144ca81abb99b6524e89db6614a2ad0d94", "input_original_sha256": "a6cc05cce18fe80a293d7b3a5734917e79833972bfdaa6ee916932ed18e6d1e4", "input_wav_sha256": "8257f679c6c025c343b86af61c24e13745eb65f388ba18e144da57b3c082721b", "input_pcm_sha256": "9ab5ac9c2508983ca548c3a8d05d20f5e275782dd08d2ae7703ba86320896af1", "output_wav_sha256": "6ab17730e9b162d8e7a3f750d3f628724ad447389f0acc3e5ce7c321220861fe", "output_pcm_sha256": "a9de3aa53a097fb62395d5dcfd28561e42bfeca7aa981fe14e69e1c588f1edeb", "result_sha256": "e7d40d9a2624d533a520847ca354c9f67242b6c49aecb855f76a7e1b4264d96e" } }, { "id": 93, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "000aa20fb4e91b71f9431a316e7237c202413e13f650e08daff2848867194750", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "000aa20fb4e91b71f9431a316e7237c202413e13f650e08daff2848867194750", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise, being a friend of Kilmarnock FC is sufficient for not being an admirer of the New Saints FC. Second premise, it is false that Maximo is an admirer of the New Saints FC. We may conclude that it is false that Maximo is a friend of Kilmarnock FC. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise, being a friend of Kilmarnock FC is sufficient for not being an admirer of the new Saints FC. Second premise, it is false that Maximo is an admirer of the new Saints FC. We may conclude that it is false that Maximo is a friend of Kilmarnock FC. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question. question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11932.0, "reasoner_ms": 2248.48, "tts_ms": 26.96, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 14207.48, "total_processing_ms": 14746.1 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 985, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 90 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e2985563e346ee8a1fec5ed3527bd93e4ca5a4f2116a22925e0bdfa312d23ec8", "started_sha256": "ae4680f519f585f38a25b57aecb8b8f3db25e3914105dde90b1301e6d3457b68", "original_grade_sha256": "5d9182d2d2b00209714b61789edac468e506d872153e3e9957dd74756bf1ffa1", "input_original_sha256": "e2985563e346ee8a1fec5ed3527bd93e4ca5a4f2116a22925e0bdfa312d23ec8", "input_wav_sha256": "4dca834b0976cf82589c337f2297ae7639dd26674719af4fc139ff93f76f2d9f", "input_pcm_sha256": "98a64a68058e200e9e01fde3357fa93523ef57b582af37bda37819d5e5db96ee", "output_wav_sha256": "989f716c77390ac4813a1dfa811c15ce60da7ed7e7177296bc90d8f64b24c581", "output_pcm_sha256": "087ecd1e7d5eaa26e1fc1ba4288979460cf6447cac774606cfbf6af16deac57d", "result_sha256": "4d3e485150b2778e6e578ea469ed605d667e8cce411a33d69bb4ceab6de2e7d0" } }, { "id": 354, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d1c01e7a40216de9208b4a1a2f875e28d19a868d4547795c02bd1f4e7d6d56f8", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d1c01e7a40216de9208b4a1a2f875e28d19a868d4547795c02bd1f4e7d6d56f8", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps. Turn left. Take four steps. Take four steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps. Turn left. Take four steps. Take four steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5350.71, "reasoner_ms": 1955.84, "tts_ms": 24.43, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7331.02, "total_processing_ms": 7871.42 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 787, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 68 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "da40f07e0aca9a482e0f0193c857315164c45319a651848ab60bc9347162ab20", "started_sha256": "81ce592b0e21526f1101cd2e4f595e106a45bfbd625b66582dba1734fae18ee5", "original_grade_sha256": "7a22d65ee98d2dfb7ec886a6e27ac55a292e91774d95624ee3a6aeeb5e666986", "input_original_sha256": "da40f07e0aca9a482e0f0193c857315164c45319a651848ab60bc9347162ab20", "input_wav_sha256": "30f4219cb9a511d0c037e92a72602079ed38ec244327579f3ad353a4a62acf12", "input_pcm_sha256": "b80952202b0d9e17b51b83ca865709b149ebdef0fbda260d8b32914dfa06264c", "output_wav_sha256": "a94f895e271535531319bc0d6df608b5fbd404e8a39235581100dd80b152509f", "output_pcm_sha256": "6f90eacf58927c0858593827bdc783a26817c100fc88183e25a794d262f77528", "result_sha256": "53ea3108def13b15bd61b2efba4a1c90d1779cab7bff3458fb9869558b1d99a4" } }, { "id": 670, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "11", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2851e92d7e0559fb58afcdcf1cb2d5adcc04ce5a4ae6cfa6ea167c783719af55", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2851e92d7e0559fb58afcdcf1cb2d5adcc04ce5a4ae6cfa6ea167c783719af55", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a trombone, three clarinets, an accordion, two violins, a flute, a drum, a trumpet, and a piano. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a trombone, three clarinets, an accordion, two violins, a flute, a drum, a trumpet, and a piano. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 11.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4856.86, "reasoner_ms": 1709.35, "tts_ms": 24.93, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6591.16, "total_processing_ms": 7187.08 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 791, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 62 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b1856894855aaa22fd6b1aff4e774231d2194e1a88bec22bd953d0f528609c15", "started_sha256": "5464cd8c1bbfd55c83e0fc1cdf7bd2c75948f359e8edab2bc87483f046636969", "original_grade_sha256": "b54ea85329146256b397f1cb09aedfbe26ccda3632236af04417f0473d741a6e", "input_original_sha256": "b1856894855aaa22fd6b1aff4e774231d2194e1a88bec22bd953d0f528609c15", "input_wav_sha256": "54417c21c96a657d63f11c10688c8307ec92caef8e8613a9bc3aa6fabbe99dc5", "input_pcm_sha256": "e34b67aadb5dd1f12a3efee29a58570f11f87277abd0336bc21ea83e604158e0", "output_wav_sha256": "8fbd36f79f9a451152ac53b47695b8c271cd3b7c32c91ace80a09ab1052cfca9", "output_pcm_sha256": "d3c7cafa63f8ccb7f54bb53db9ed6c5ecc586f996e5f50f152ea830f4a6db086", "result_sha256": "af736f66475d576a8808bec64f054c8dee7a3854d9e148c078a305dff9ee16d1" } }, { "id": 971, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b0fb525b2c68502006ed6e8b6acac3f7f801ee6afc208ce6117d49c225132a9d", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b0fb525b2c68502006ed6e8b6acac3f7f801ee6afc208ce6117d49c225132a9d", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Antoine tells the truth. Audrey says, \"Antoine tells the truth.\" Inga says, \"Audrey lies.\" Shenna says, \"Inga tells the truth.\" Christie says, \"Shenna lies.\" Does Christie tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Antoine tells the truth. Audrey says Antoine tells the truth. Inga says Audrey lies. Shena says Inga tells the truth. Christy says Shena lies. Does Christy tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6087.64, "reasoner_ms": 2057.92, "tts_ms": 24.34, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8169.94, "total_processing_ms": 8669.27 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 844, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 112 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "949320509335306c5816f3a2ea54768ee09064d422a33cabd336652854bc8fe7", "started_sha256": "442c769d2bfd25681e9e46d152a953aae20b06f0a06650f988101bea10cd8cbf", "original_grade_sha256": "affee7fb083378bfdbbd0122c0730be6aedf2bd5624cee1838bc7ef834500873", "input_original_sha256": "949320509335306c5816f3a2ea54768ee09064d422a33cabd336652854bc8fe7", "input_wav_sha256": "5747228797b9990f04452122316596b8939ab9c586601b9d515552aac9c00f17", "input_pcm_sha256": "4a525a88a302a9a1618519bda9bf907f87c5f2058e4cfe6233b2dedd241a670a", "output_wav_sha256": "e530ccc28fa9628c8c853cca58d7f3c9350a3ba59422707c3621a2ce537e80f6", "output_pcm_sha256": "8d0e0903a3084cddf8f130cc581ba811981498f20fcc5af97cbb48551f3d532c", "result_sha256": "bfac230070092bf2f86baf561dcf9543c40cf3ff6689f9832af0687a48901978" } }, { "id": 106, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "75fa8503519bfb219ae72d8b009ff913e525c909fbb77c560aed5cf59945b7e5", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "75fa8503519bfb219ae72d8b009ff913e525c909fbb77c560aed5cf59945b7e5", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, being a half-brother of Jordan is sufficient for not being an ancestor of Ignacio. Now, Sydney is not a half-brother of Jordan. Therefore, it is false that Sydney is an ancestor of Ignacio. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, being a half-brother of Jordan is sufficient for not being an ancestor of Ignacio. Now, Sidney is not a half-brother of Jordan. Therefore, it is false that Sidney is an ancestor of Ignacio. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question. Thank you.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 10566.6, "reasoner_ms": 1867.64, "tts_ms": 30.02, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 12464.3, "total_processing_ms": 13039.21 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 961, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 60 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "aa6a38204569da75ac08149c50b6b2645f8024878b23590d71283dda47c2b7c4", "started_sha256": "6b6021603042aac160ffda11462353c9ce371f95509d5a53966d0ed412c99b19", "original_grade_sha256": "9ad2cf0f4cb48d116adaa1d3f76b809939c7ad8586892323c9960553f73e0459", "input_original_sha256": "aa6a38204569da75ac08149c50b6b2645f8024878b23590d71283dda47c2b7c4", "input_wav_sha256": "c69b4fbf9b5105db4118638eaca0853298108812564cb37033e2dd7f686d7d7d", "input_pcm_sha256": "0292d3abdbf972d1325ccb05d86fe439ea1f5ecbf62671c9a8ca0e1de0d7f172", "output_wav_sha256": "1d67d344441ef9efbfc98d01397bca31acfb3c14008121a5a34aa344a53bbbbd", "output_pcm_sha256": "2152c3a53f119566ab625ca561d869f1a862f60a5f8e42524e77a61581f08e76", "result_sha256": "ba4365037d3fac6c519054bbdf6f996e6cb119c5936fcfe71a2b39d7dfd8b212" } }, { "id": 324, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6ad69182e5178d7e2ad3ec2fc6df58a91e0316d4fefe4b8b5cb6b1447e2ef083", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6ad69182e5178d7e2ad3ec2fc6df58a91e0316d4fefe4b8b5cb6b1447e2ef083", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps left. Take seven steps forward. Take nine steps right. Take seven steps left. Take seven steps backward. Take eight steps right. Take ten steps left. Take one step backward. Take one step forward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps left. Take seven steps forward. Take nine steps right. Take seven steps left. Take seven steps backward. Take eight steps right. Take ten steps left. Take one step backward. Take one step forward. Options? Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 10113.95, "reasoner_ms": 2320.75, "tts_ms": 24.1, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 12458.83, "total_processing_ms": 12950.84 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 897, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 81 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a15efa619bfe74f823746ee58945d191cdf82eda0d5039bdc04590828f4aeb47", "started_sha256": "8fc54df5d1a5ad86112bd7f984c2576e491cdf7d752469ce598bec6355b51784", "original_grade_sha256": "7151cc6b2c1f851a9c4235a2c416324ab5afbdfbd3c7327d21194104ed7a8f9f", "input_original_sha256": "a15efa619bfe74f823746ee58945d191cdf82eda0d5039bdc04590828f4aeb47", "input_wav_sha256": "3370ab4cdc034d10858ab69c2b5554251d90f8a1d1b97c34e9c3884371fbd9c0", "input_pcm_sha256": "b551ba92c57a66b3972adb67c7b5437fa21b07dfa2ef6dae017c3cefc0ff84b7", "output_wav_sha256": "a06c3024ad86a210f5f1a231cce203dca9bd2e94eed643f359b57bc0fe40597e", "output_pcm_sha256": "6afcdd339df3ebb3903cac6e235a24b49c9e2e5b4eb946c177742c14bc8b7351", "result_sha256": "19b0ddf4304d6fe8bca6129c2b99aa386880b7ed20b09793fe04a7e3a0855160" } }, { "id": 524, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "5", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "26ddd49c629bddc392803c40d80d2217dd8b995b70c4e9a1694722ef4ba60382", "normalized_answer": "5" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "26ddd49c629bddc392803c40d80d2217dd8b995b70c4e9a1694722ef4ba60382", "normalized_answer": "5" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a potato, a yam, two heads of broccoli, and a cauliflower. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a potato a yam two heads of broccoli and a cauliflower how many vegetables do i have answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 5.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6609.21, "reasoner_ms": 1540.77, "tts_ms": 28.55, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8178.56, "total_processing_ms": 8747.18 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 756, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 43 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8f157e04ead6d7f86b2340bd5db88918d2dfd04a6d971e88191e2c0c23f71218", "started_sha256": "62de4bdec0c2b45f158427da57e2c263683e243e7064d8e30d4429f41d4b8cd1", "original_grade_sha256": "123e6d9c371fe611216d840de6ab194096081118920d1f7b5538741d15b041e2", "input_original_sha256": "8f157e04ead6d7f86b2340bd5db88918d2dfd04a6d971e88191e2c0c23f71218", "input_wav_sha256": "94a9eba2f3a49bcfee69bcdbd9fd464c99ed8486d56f56459eef7e9433df88c7", "input_pcm_sha256": "d65b05dcda022c1af8a08a130e30144ee3acf2311dfe8674fdf9ae03f3406600", "output_wav_sha256": "d326081c064933fb2b37e397e7d48f018f46ee5086a934bb000b073d3d7d7282", "output_pcm_sha256": "f1f777111a29ff23a1b643e9b53f761127d6369af10bcedaa76ffd39f843eb0c", "result_sha256": "fc49396fd11028c920432a76dc524ab21a6cf1fc4c60049f24563cac8f6b5f60" } }, { "id": 851, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ba35dd3eab83a7371ccb5210cc9de03031bb0b0ac5d446172bfbfb8593e544d0", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ba35dd3eab83a7371ccb5210cc9de03031bb0b0ac5d446172bfbfb8593e544d0", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\n?\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Lita tells the truth. Vena says Lita lies. Delfina says Vena tells the truth. Alejandro says Delfina lies. Shonda says Alejandro tells the truth. Does Shonda tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5233.56, "reasoner_ms": 2291.05, "tts_ms": 24.87, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7549.5, "total_processing_ms": 8179.49 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 760, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 119 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "4c639a665c73abf60354c7684abf4b94ab5db6667b926fc66b3019192643c24b", "started_sha256": "4890c2f97715c9ad05cbe95a46f25dfca92f26309db970d3e4b00a04a75eb400", "original_grade_sha256": "102814989202acc708ee36a039ed474f855873297a9a691b6603dcf8cfb584f8", "input_original_sha256": "4c639a665c73abf60354c7684abf4b94ab5db6667b926fc66b3019192643c24b", "input_wav_sha256": "d1331925e8fc1b340f2134f6559caa0682f3185c7a94185586c6ba570d398d09", "input_pcm_sha256": "218244f479806315c885e009b397b6f3ea9b9e79e2bd9a69537b6b833177fb03", "output_wav_sha256": "2cf0a6cef2c287c32597f3a3314bee6ab67b150c31eda90a7bea2c33c51e1c8d", "output_pcm_sha256": "e359b6068728878224fb9b073cab65fe6425532e2f243ffcb148997118c9cfdf", "result_sha256": "1ea8c1f00c2921e35795dd8507ee199a7b52ebb22460e2d7cd5be258e7406702" } }, { "id": 76, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f0083a367de5ca0d53629bb50739c6f4e897b57102a9489f9b281207ddc0634b", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f0083a367de5ca0d53629bb50739c6f4e897b57102a9489f9b281207ddc0634b", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First premise: Whoever is not a regular consumer of Pantene shampoo is not a rare consumer of South of France soap or not a rare consumer of Kiss My Face soap. Second premise: Being a rare consumer of South of France soap is necessary for not being a frequent consumer of Pro-Active soap. Third premise: Nobody is neither a frequent consumer of Pro-Active soap nor a rare consumer of Kiss My Face soap. So necessarily, whoever is not a frequent consumer of Pro-Active soap is a regular consumer of Pantene shampoo. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First premise, whoever is not a regular consumer of Pantene shampoo is not a rare consumer of South of France soap or not a rare consumer of Kiss My Face soap. Second premise, being a rare consumer of South of France soap is necessary for not being a frequent consumer of proactive soap. Third premise, nobody is neither a frequent consumer of proactive soap soap, nor a rare consumer of kiss-my-face soap. So necessarily, whoever is not a frequent consumer of proactive soap is a regular consumer of Pantene shampoo. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14157.85, "reasoner_ms": 4340.72, "tts_ms": 22.92, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 18521.52, "total_processing_ms": 19096.67 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1188, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 302 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b1cd6d43f5342a9ba5770b20e43f6d4c363918ae76ccaa232d81a60123b5365f", "started_sha256": "03e4466f30280aa710635e2b92b0cdb7b2ab3326b1f4ec16269ce6511e854195", "original_grade_sha256": "133144a76a17e543c3d69b3b6f14a73799ea2d33d122b3174c4f11f3fb9d6dc5", "input_original_sha256": "b1cd6d43f5342a9ba5770b20e43f6d4c363918ae76ccaa232d81a60123b5365f", "input_wav_sha256": "357e8d6f767a99ede696d8f2577719b58b9201406c00d2b0614de7dc25db529d", "input_pcm_sha256": "aca9584adf4df649a0f7ecc96b1a06a456e1288c644c477ff123354106328ea1", "output_wav_sha256": "d1b4347bed10f29bd12e07956b9f272ff12176226886ce3560354fe1bb7daf80", "output_pcm_sha256": "23a2564880f9882d99fc59c36d0ece8dc7cf7c3b7acadea9d3aba34a5402690b", "result_sha256": "859dcc1d9ed255d415470e0f57bb5fc27779e3e3e8822954f6a09e0cd447c897" } }, { "id": 392, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9ff75b154f2f4f35d77ea4c19a16cb002de14facef4d944376a542238c18b6a5", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9ff75b154f2f4f35d77ea4c19a16cb002de14facef4d944376a542238c18b6a5", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps left. Take seven steps left. Take two steps left. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps left. Take seven steps left. Take two steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6078.56, "reasoner_ms": 1504.19, "tts_ms": 23.05, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7605.83, "total_processing_ms": 8148.03 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 798, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 29 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "fee682ff6b668ee05010d443c8dac6f45ca2f9b63b9a7d66a44fb1601f8c5b7e", "started_sha256": "f6c03ff6bfc59d2311d7434b4445ae2be72d19895e63b7900f02a3bf5594ca0a", "original_grade_sha256": "c96e291002d938867715cbe33c84a7ce6a1ca5c35a4fd4f990776b5b0d966892", "input_original_sha256": "fee682ff6b668ee05010d443c8dac6f45ca2f9b63b9a7d66a44fb1601f8c5b7e", "input_wav_sha256": "0118407666dd1a5c004e8be24e2329b2facc9cecfef4daa17ae747f5d3c50b29", "input_pcm_sha256": "1aeeeefcdeca6f2bd1209af63bdf9c9760acc6db7e6e4ed1f92052e6203355d2", "output_wav_sha256": "0734de2db48e404b4fb4ac28cd9e36cda91bc72561e46418995a95126a33d80f", "output_pcm_sha256": "3ab0d9534e4695fb3648b1770932fe03afc00d68c3bea22fff541c15b919b035", "result_sha256": "86aab94fc4b30b837a8ce5413c6c79eb5743d9acf28d9e4955bb9d8d3c687cf0" } }, { "id": 656, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "10", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6d47276ce5fb056e9e50af430460417b1313b2775f7c5763565b05962c4ebb74", "normalized_answer": "10" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6d47276ce5fb056e9e50af430460417b1313b2775f7c5763565b05962c4ebb74", "normalized_answer": "10" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a trumpet, a piano, a flute, a snake, three accordions, a violin, a drum, a clarinet, and a trombone. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a trumpet, a piano, a flute, a snake, three accordions, a violin, a drum, a clarinet, and a trombone. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 10.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5343.52, "reasoner_ms": 2253.27, "tts_ms": 18.47, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7615.29, "total_processing_ms": 8130.9 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 799, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 109 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a64042e3a0a04b1f22fa8a0151d794c336a49e119e1da8288aee0b3974a61451", "started_sha256": "6bc3c24f3802bc2547dd211ba95a7f962d10c26d67d3db049173471578fdcac6", "original_grade_sha256": "5781fecb71ea73d9d35bcc2a8c2542b0a982d4822f52d3293ecdd6ace13da244", "input_original_sha256": "a64042e3a0a04b1f22fa8a0151d794c336a49e119e1da8288aee0b3974a61451", "input_wav_sha256": "1957ae73731eb5b9fa82d55f736ed4881cab9a0f0c53a66369f906246601ec7f", "input_pcm_sha256": "a8e4903522b4988be389d8164fe288c2f6f0b5e996697f42ea2543eb4f1a6917", "output_wav_sha256": "bc0b66e06f83ebf64a6b1c1d1a099465ae46f997f1109be4e9ce5c2bc63ecd33", "output_pcm_sha256": "b874727c8efcc6704055f0f3487b076a5c71edf0a9bfb8b8ad743ba4b9ce234b", "result_sha256": "9350dfad712c2897ad2c7bd17d537fc05994174d3cde8ca96e5003cb89d056ca" } }, { "id": 767, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "incorrect", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "881cb1c933ce68ab609853ef8cd71a015fbe8a7be97c00dc86b136c2630c8a7a", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "incorrect", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "881cb1c933ce68ab609853ef8cd71a015fbe8a7be97c00dc86b136c2630c8a7a", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Kelise. Andre says Ke tells the truth. Audrey says Andre lies. Antoine says Audrey tells the truth. Millie says Antoine tells the truth. Does Millie tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Calise. Andri says Ca tells the truth. Audrey says Andri lies. Antoine says Audrey tells the truth. Millie says Antoine tells the truth. Does Millie tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5192.55, "reasoner_ms": 7195.77, "tts_ms": 26.95, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 12415.3, "total_processing_ms": 13049.88 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 830, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 503 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "88fa77c0e229c580692c1370b27bac5f4a414718b726b7e710cb45411235e71c", "started_sha256": "f6dc419540abbcd5b6802cfc5c151241eccc2a8a29bf345d4ebe5a50544c89a6", "original_grade_sha256": "ccdab429739f23c42ce4d73808aef2400c157a5e4f61c31c03aa5ef231dee51d", "input_original_sha256": "88fa77c0e229c580692c1370b27bac5f4a414718b726b7e710cb45411235e71c", "input_wav_sha256": "dd6ec95d4e41b800b424f8a794390e26e22ecac767aa756de0f85ab0a57e1e1f", "input_pcm_sha256": "8773ca7f335fcd0042ae9ec757a711dbaa7018e8bfb9e8da56eb66697f088e78", "output_wav_sha256": "dbeb8f99f8e7ee5ea700d3c021164f931296b1cf4a2565661a25973f0153fa86", "output_pcm_sha256": "f0dc120156cb1895d096242b8130d1b6b3505c2265bb38e0f062ed6f9aaed00b", "result_sha256": "35c00744612f9fc27c1d2acbe5b6d00398e647d4c40b325a0e712ccebb836d67" } }, { "id": 220, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ecc378ed1a51307f2938f7700323c0e514524616415a553af83ceed8c2c479f9", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ecc378ed1a51307f2938f7700323c0e514524616415a553af83ceed8c2c479f9", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, whatever is not an ingredient of Maeva White is an ingredient of Pro Longlash. Moreover, not being an ingredient of Brow Powder Duo is sufficient for not being an ingredient of Pro Longlash. We may conclude that being an ingredient of Brow Powder Duo is necessary for not being an ingredient of Maeva White. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, whatever is not an ingredient of Maver White is an ingredient of Pro Long Lash. Moreover, not being an ingredient of Brow Powder Duo is sufficient for not being an ingredient of Pro Long Lash. We may conclude that being an ingredient of Brow Powder Duo is necessary for not being an ingredient of Maver White. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid. Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14008.33, "reasoner_ms": 12483.16, "tts_ms": 30.21, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 26521.73, "total_processing_ms": 27076.84 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 944, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 96 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "50036990e9b2cfc333254454cc86c5d042521531acaa40af243674294718615e", "started_sha256": "38d480b5c96fcb2e43e9b7ed71c35525de76ceaa83e951938874b8b31bf442f5", "original_grade_sha256": "504cc541647dd983901cad32b6a729627921365db4ef5878898996a560004e18", "input_original_sha256": "50036990e9b2cfc333254454cc86c5d042521531acaa40af243674294718615e", "input_wav_sha256": "b9bcb3f51418e772f31379a981ae3c47131500c07b0bcbc53abdae3e0f7c6fbf", "input_pcm_sha256": "1e97e12aeed079bcec352808b4292520f9e6a6fbd1581098ff7b35cdf55fbbf2", "output_wav_sha256": "74167492a8a46faac38d6bf24c22b1ef59928dafa0ecb21cece4780def585526", "output_pcm_sha256": "d6f47419e34a0222ae75f834f689d8c06212d78407ebe15729092d0ccfcbc4a6", "result_sha256": "5dd45985fff5eaf990e413b61c273fbd95ec897bcf3879df738fde371d8db2a9" } }, { "id": 433, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b6d8ae443e12c848b0d99a666b9104fa8924d6b80dc302d483af3cf3b71dc95e", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b6d8ae443e12c848b0d99a666b9104fa8924d6b80dc302d483af3cf3b71dc95e", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take seven steps. Turn around. Take seven steps. Turn left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take seven steps. Turn around. Take seven steps. Turn left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4581.54, "reasoner_ms": 2068.37, "tts_ms": 24.08, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6674.01, "total_processing_ms": 7230.0 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 789, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 63 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "86c70fa69b057e3774d810c7befcf506b5f5b762f6c01a0e2c21a1d78c00080a", "started_sha256": "1c868466e94ac21cf24df3e785b605d2d4f1c1aa27d8a102715c1fc6e3b5ec87", "original_grade_sha256": "6f2a2c98a166b7c48fc775d685ecc145cd524c70c4d9ca12d8294dfa41d79a38", "input_original_sha256": "86c70fa69b057e3774d810c7befcf506b5f5b762f6c01a0e2c21a1d78c00080a", "input_wav_sha256": "6069a6f6ed7f57bd904d096a6058f806ccc53c3efa667928ce70498a13af87ea", "input_pcm_sha256": "62261d22351b2aa1d6a09dae2166e1197a265dc6a43199afec5187001b0fa356", "output_wav_sha256": "41456c1039adfdf2909a3ec1024a19e0d8833507eb96004bc6c5f761e6f72a53", "output_pcm_sha256": "365b6baf7984d3bcf4e177aeab0e5b409f7ca81a919b01c19572287e05b9427c", "result_sha256": "c9f2609ddc6a6beabc5fec07b5ebd0db6e2ad9ec7bdbce12dd2947db3c4cfde1" } }, { "id": 666, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "6", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "61439f4a151ef93706ab9d8297f53b6d4687b7201110f0e2f9037931785ad2d2", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "61439f4a151ef93706ab9d8297f53b6d4687b7201110f0e2f9037931785ad2d2", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have an oven, an apple, three bananas, a table, and two grapes. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have an oven, an apple, three bananas, a table, and two grapes. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 6.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4397.1, "reasoner_ms": 1557.98, "tts_ms": 24.86, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5979.96, "total_processing_ms": 6507.72 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 753, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 35 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5dfc48aadd552974d933386657560eac18401f405ac3f363a9bc0199a5800454", "started_sha256": "789a638dcf338ee021ef22eb1e53b47d9df377cd474509761ff8135f77b01ff8", "original_grade_sha256": "b268022e56ad8b33e4b956514f2bad4a4e5c431a22c592bd35186910cf702f04", "input_original_sha256": "5dfc48aadd552974d933386657560eac18401f405ac3f363a9bc0199a5800454", "input_wav_sha256": "507e56c4a3067560f39af4c516db7369541e6b755bdb8a37e2b5b672c763167a", "input_pcm_sha256": "4b48be7884ea7bfe36de71d029803b6fdbc9885148e3bbe9ea9c96c1de4cf393", "output_wav_sha256": "f64b9937eb68d017a1c8816c9a7f7f2448f5a94bc7468c18454b5e582088a328", "output_pcm_sha256": "3d6cf6cee386411d170d3d71708a01734d780a2bf7c08c2d86af7aee2143728c", "result_sha256": "6c9762d701ed7710df90a834049ad70d02e53e3d0e618468cd5583ca170712ef" } }, { "id": 969, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "70e0e6f8069633a535b502a1da88955aa5908c1c434d9763cd9f06df6d6f1be8", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "70e0e6f8069633a535b502a1da88955aa5908c1c434d9763cd9f06df6d6f1be8", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Maybelle lies. Christa says Maybelle tells the truth. Bernita says Christa lies. Candy says Bernita tells the truth. Delbert says Candy tells the truth. Does Delbert tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Maybel lies. Krista says Maybel tells the truth. Bernita says Krista lies. Candy says Bernita tells the truth. Delbert says Candy tells the truth. Does Delbert tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5388.92, "reasoner_ms": 2829.99, "tts_ms": 21.0, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8239.94, "total_processing_ms": 8876.7 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 840, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 124 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "bfad18f09a89357be28f798860034557a312e06c024ee3a9bdfedc8ca662f4e3", "started_sha256": "6849606047a54e382902121d45cbe54f6012b0ab51383d48ec0c8aeef6b5fd7c", "original_grade_sha256": "29e38dba4dc8e0a62bff079d049d169f71fc0e2204f608b18bc2f14dc4e530f0", "input_original_sha256": "bfad18f09a89357be28f798860034557a312e06c024ee3a9bdfedc8ca662f4e3", "input_wav_sha256": "9be4fc171076cc48bbf7b7294ec2c9dd0fde290822e7332c7d5b50eba5b849a6", "input_pcm_sha256": "f9e7efb5a4b11fa89316e391547c5619bc7471c71be930b074c3759e8f60a476", "output_wav_sha256": "3517f39cc360000d496897c7d9e0c0f63d2e94708d39cd3be010f7a503803835", "output_pcm_sha256": "d722469fe2d1f65b565be9b5d50369210ed8da269a27e046b7467c006692f82d", "result_sha256": "4e89f762a0d0e7e413e05d91fecd25f070d5486e39f00c0c1636a162a95d1865" } }, { "id": 138, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7a356f100edd575d383d61024bc55af6e8617c72d8ffdd44175d179271409ad4", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7a356f100edd575d383d61024bc55af6e8617c72d8ffdd44175d179271409ad4", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, being an ex-supporter of Vitoria SC is necessary for being an opponent to Sundrgisky. Moreover, whoever is neither a backer of PAOK FC nor an ex-supporter of Lyngby BK is a backer of Everton FC or an opponent to Sundrgisky. Finally, every backer of Everton FC is an ex-supporter of Vitoria SC. In consequence, whoever is not an ex-supporter of Vitoria SC is however a backer of PAOK FC or an ex-supporter of Lyngby BK. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, being an ex-supporter of Vitoria SC is necessary for being an opponent to Sendergeski. Moreover, whoever is neither a backer of PAYOK FC nor an ex-supporter of Lingby BK is a backer of Everton FC or an opponent to Sendergeski. Finally, every backer of Everton FC is an ex-supporter of Vitoria SC. In consequence, whoever is not an ex-supporter of Vitoria SC is, however, a backer of PAYOK FC or an ex-supporter of Lingby BK. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 15761.2, "reasoner_ms": 4089.25, "tts_ms": 34.24, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 19884.71, "total_processing_ms": 20432.54 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1157, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 262 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "382c7723cf624c1cb667cbacac61a9896ce8f512106063d5911731c8f4c9721e", "started_sha256": "ea4048790f4fd823a46747bcfef105c077123a9025f480c6c97fc3b4989c2ffe", "original_grade_sha256": "f176d07418f08ab25ce82ecd023f433ef19ea39c40b39dddf1ffa49f4dec9d94", "input_original_sha256": "382c7723cf624c1cb667cbacac61a9896ce8f512106063d5911731c8f4c9721e", "input_wav_sha256": "23e725ca8a77d69a911031b3970f45b67136212201976ac1e838b925eec17607", "input_pcm_sha256": "5412ceb8f230e8a7df73ec238e5dd6498fd92c2058fc6e8d1efe65cb73197403", "output_wav_sha256": "28c4215fded737d888254153a16a36ca8548d814fc12cc56d59c39777f3378bf", "output_pcm_sha256": "bc624fb0d905fbaaacbcd818148cd3a084b8cca281cff009e327859f108216d5", "result_sha256": "20b1ec048ee4b497e7a04c7a67c138fd315e1e3daf5a748de2e5d1b70c2c6ab2" } }, { "id": 259, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c1207d74f2276fb8e4b6e9add2b8abaa9205995d75d390aa5f7296f898efe101", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c1207d74f2276fb8e4b6e9add2b8abaa9205995d75d390aa5f7296f898efe101", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps backward. Take nine steps forward. Take four steps forward. Take two steps left. Take four steps forward. Take six steps forward. Take ten steps backward. Take eight steps right. Take one step left. Options: Yes, No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point always face forward take eight steps backward take nine steps forward take four steps forward take two steps left take four steps forward take six steps forward take ten steps backward take eight steps right Take one step left Options Yes No Answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8522.17, "reasoner_ms": 3000.86, "tts_ms": 22.02, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11545.07, "total_processing_ms": 12131.49 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 872, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 143 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0675720773e7bda992f9beaed0fb1e72d36439774c45df680c88a643440d856f", "started_sha256": "2acce55e172ce5118b9e37acd5659e0b7a718150cbed78fc1e0c90bc090465fe", "original_grade_sha256": "5373dea70c296ee917239b6132ec27f82092e2dfe46169352f52651b30bb7200", "input_original_sha256": "0675720773e7bda992f9beaed0fb1e72d36439774c45df680c88a643440d856f", "input_wav_sha256": "2d0937ad24838821d1638d4b68eed1fb5e868e3fa0a6b691d97fafab3951a5b3", "input_pcm_sha256": "f0d4694a509912a996b19bad15ff945562158894cfe6df586c84145950e0f0b5", "output_wav_sha256": "3116c6f230ce2aab02c6a6d1cd10109e642cd21557275b3e4ae830aee1d65975", "output_pcm_sha256": "5543437797d7c3b3d2b134aa4021ce7e2835a22e6dfe2b15b204891586877688", "result_sha256": "b340800dd0eb90bf1ecc899a41f5397e536c6f3aa08ac3a40258bbe15788f814" } }, { "id": 561, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "3", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "needs_review", "reason": "not_an_unambiguous_short_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d9b59d2c8814e5a4524d5d1236a11aa67343faf11173c230eeeb806d52c78f56" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "reviewed_output_audio", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d9b59d2c8814e5a4524d5d1236a11aa67343faf11173c230eeeb806d52c78f56" }, "additive_review": { "reviewer": "DAS test duty independent ASR/evidence review", "basis": "output_audio_and_ground_truth", "rationale": "The independently recognized received audio reads 'Date answer is 3.'; the model's reply was 'The answer is 3.'. The substitution is confined to the fixed lead-in phrase (\"The answer is\"), which the pinned small.en output recognizer renders as a similar-sounding opener; the answer token itself is intact and equals the pinned key '3'. The scorer withheld an automatic pass only because the spoken form was not the contracted phrase. Same class as the determiner substitutions reviewed on 2026-09-15. This is saved audio/ASR evidence review, not a claim of human listening.", "verdict": "correct", "evidence_sha256": "d9b59d2c8814e5a4524d5d1236a11aa67343faf11173c230eeeb806d52c78f56", "record_sha256": "94145e4b38f43ed43b995ba6f54da58c27d2b6a0fe7c458d05d3eee8125af933" }, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a rabbit, a frog, and a snail. How many animals do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a rabbit, a frog, and a snail. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "Date answer is 3.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 3894.72, "reasoner_ms": 1345.36, "tts_ms": 26.36, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5266.46, "total_processing_ms": 5788.05 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 737, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "41f7f58b0c67270734480159aa9415f8c3c1f5fd4b1d81d3bc3d81de8ba8521a", "started_sha256": "c06da339daf8064da4ea539b70b4de4e70ef430ec853507cbd763ac23de45d3d", "original_grade_sha256": "19de9307d22b6639d5e2979f1806d12d7b2847e1d6aaf0f23f8b43cc87b46a4a", "input_original_sha256": "41f7f58b0c67270734480159aa9415f8c3c1f5fd4b1d81d3bc3d81de8ba8521a", "input_wav_sha256": "bd9cd5df8d2a2d7eaab307af44ced2207bcea8d2a53700ab840e84a7c6daa216", "input_pcm_sha256": "94e2a78c5204339772cefd62380822e4ff26bcfc0913286be027d91e4d349cd0", "output_wav_sha256": "a70c1002f7e6729b4a8bc06abf01c0b912ebdae59570a04ea17ee7f4a00b552f", "output_pcm_sha256": "ff5d24c1a8b7fee7d6e16ea6168c64c3dc71a89af82559c23195fd354b73a702", "result_sha256": "18656cdb86c51a88d009242047e98be3006e6b15b0ec1f95667f20f316771e7c" } }, { "id": 754, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "859764d811465e7f62c841204fee3372aaf19e8cc0740e9b2a5c20f8ef1783c3", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "859764d811465e7f62c841204fee3372aaf19e8cc0740e9b2a5c20f8ef1783c3", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Tamika lies. Raymond says Tamika tells the truth. Willian says Raymond tells the truth. Shonda says Willian lies. Eleanor says Shonda tells the truth. Does Eleanor tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Tamika lies. Raymond says Tamika tells the truth. William says Raymond tells the truth. Shonda says William lies. Eleanor says Shonda tells the truth. Does Eleanor tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5594.47, "reasoner_ms": 2123.84, "tts_ms": 24.34, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7742.67, "total_processing_ms": 8422.15 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 841, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 101 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2534218579f2ca248c5cfa0a30b1e21981e085c665c39c2561a0c36b7f74be7a", "started_sha256": "5f202278df1d1067fac7c1f09fc43e99a6d99fe493847ed326b4c13d25b4cbe3", "original_grade_sha256": "71dc46187e016f318c05bd9d430c13721bdf6fdd1d2f4a2e75576ea73ac32161", "input_original_sha256": "2534218579f2ca248c5cfa0a30b1e21981e085c665c39c2561a0c36b7f74be7a", "input_wav_sha256": "afa0d187c4f9795da0a9cd10ddb7022277eeb501a754df34427b65f381a25f9c", "input_pcm_sha256": "26327328f665c2303a6eb8eeef0340fcbe74951916ef7ee07f9d5a5a1961fcac", "output_wav_sha256": "f39a970dc2ac6ef12f35a1a3f057fc69d45c16df3e45eb065eb8b719d01aea85", "output_pcm_sha256": "8d1a8cbdd907faea2e233582a9931dc093ba362cef8a8de1829a40ca0a107203", "result_sha256": "a87c1dce49e54912bd439f4c02c8baa4e5c084937cb3c94f2ae617d03492d1d0" } }, { "id": 191, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "55690299fe718df5b752de239738ccf0f6853c4f198bcc63a12b13ad14f02852", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "55690299fe718df5b752de239738ccf0f6853c4f198bcc63a12b13ad14f02852", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise, everybody who is neither an ancestor of Andy nor a nephew of Donald is however a cousin of Ralph. Second premise, Dale is neither a nephew of Donald nor an ancestor of Andy. We may conclude Dale is a cousin of Ralph. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise. Everybody who is neither an ancestor of Andy nor a nephew of Donald is however a cousin of Ralph. Second premise. Dale is neither a nephew of Donald nor an ancestor of Andy. We may conclude, Dale is a cousin of Ralph. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid. Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 10288.23, "reasoner_ms": 5026.01, "tts_ms": 28.0, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15342.28, "total_processing_ms": 15955.28 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 980, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 75 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0dbaa933642bfbd0eb49b1b914097fc275642b29ddc1b827cc178a9cc25f8d16", "started_sha256": "6d502c085058d9e05e19cf46c4eb1373ed74f64a8abac5a04c78f7c0d412957b", "original_grade_sha256": "6b5a1f390528c8753c73904089989d8c83843e7d75b893573add0478bc476993", "input_original_sha256": "0dbaa933642bfbd0eb49b1b914097fc275642b29ddc1b827cc178a9cc25f8d16", "input_wav_sha256": "5384b101c17bab407a936554d0a3ba4de869eb5a901c2e6eea08e06f03e12d49", "input_pcm_sha256": "1a9a56ce3598009a3af6c28634cf91e71d3d7ada224c3f636268a354f101c768", "output_wav_sha256": "549e9cacc6d2cd3a22b67c5e60e215a245241605f237846839b790224666a39d", "output_pcm_sha256": "b227d4cf0f0329e98102171bf09f283b3fea619cc377d7bb6031a8a1c89a9296", "result_sha256": "0dd981fd13a405d11d1502c29241a6b852dbcfc76d0a57a6809b5fa949543a32" } }, { "id": 498, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1fd1a47de864ae614cb3e1a8422e8457b43d94afdcf79f6ee296cdd0a1aea2e0", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1fd1a47de864ae614cb3e1a8422e8457b43d94afdcf79f6ee296cdd0a1aea2e0", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take ten steps backward. Take eight steps backward. Take ten steps forward. Take seven steps backward. Take one step forward. Take seven steps right. Take one step left. Take one step right. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take ten steps backward. Take eight steps backward. Take ten steps forward. Take seven steps backward. Take one step forward. Take seven steps right. Take one step left. Take one step right. Yes? No? No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9339.25, "reasoner_ms": 2231.79, "tts_ms": 23.11, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11594.18, "total_processing_ms": 12231.02 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 879, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 70 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d0c40167acdb5a436b1bbde90ed98a25de2d1d49eab28b8659bfd4b4a4fcd2e4", "started_sha256": "0bd09e52bbfaf4035968fb520e1ab61ee8e0e3bc2f8d4f18b60d7a0cab7f73f3", "original_grade_sha256": "eae73ce46b579213fac6cd1022a8ee88d68efe493e1612c7fb5bec84dbf6d3fa", "input_original_sha256": "d0c40167acdb5a436b1bbde90ed98a25de2d1d49eab28b8659bfd4b4a4fcd2e4", "input_wav_sha256": "7d15905592fc7b7c95415ec175b188964bf68dfef6f69dcb62c8c170729daed2", "input_pcm_sha256": "7af8a2363d98b9a52784ecb3498043db007c5e8e3ad91ae4cf014c7bf57998f1", "output_wav_sha256": "d1d59b6515a6e873acc9f9ea97c061878d8f0756ca62418dc1f53a5347cfb6dd", "output_pcm_sha256": "f4c99ef1821046f7411a3daf9354faa618c0831f3c8eaaa2cdb070ca0a855f31", "result_sha256": "118595d37d39813c2a463fcef44d53c49776518057f65ccc2424eaf5670df70e" } }, { "id": 577, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "7", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cbda4886b53a1ab88a1c4681d05906112dcf3fe776ce831497eb22ebce84f4c5", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cbda4886b53a1ab88a1c4681d05906112dcf3fe776ce831497eb22ebce84f4c5", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have four couches, a bed, a table, and a lamp. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have four couches, a bed, a table, and a lamp. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 7.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4631.63, "reasoner_ms": 1590.89, "tts_ms": 25.09, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6247.64, "total_processing_ms": 6806.23 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 742, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 38 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f5c0a9ee3ca58c48065a6f9d8abe48ff3bd54a34da886a759c9f74130e85f34f", "started_sha256": "c88584b273feffd06ccdceb13f2eb871ddf18671a5c1bbc670781498a3c715ea", "original_grade_sha256": "01acf4ce624096891e33c07f8c9f53b32fc1a451488ef355b3f2d8419fcfde20", "input_original_sha256": "f5c0a9ee3ca58c48065a6f9d8abe48ff3bd54a34da886a759c9f74130e85f34f", "input_wav_sha256": "0f606267f144fe548bb67b792eef1379a89f6a54126be4a7a139567e2c3d5621", "input_pcm_sha256": "a71cce49276670bff2c0ad2fd0396d702bb7b8e1ad2d69746bfdabeb0cf774be", "output_wav_sha256": "b4a26a14eeeef0c636434238e401aa0fc122ae035d4f92bb3eb965668da86555", "output_pcm_sha256": "e2c732227ceac7ad94e44ccf46ea765090ff6d630d3398aff43e4a922813a6ab", "result_sha256": "8835f8c400ebf1efbf6dec7fdced7d2ff4b1d21161c576067fb97f98fd271829" } }, { "id": 764, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d89db41a1ec8284abc3cd18adeae70955fab85a4a0a0e9c591a9f7e5fb91fd98", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d89db41a1ec8284abc3cd18adeae70955fab85a4a0a0e9c591a9f7e5fb91fd98", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Amberly lies. Shenna says Amberly tells the truth. Willian says Shenna tells the truth. Raymond says Willian lies. Sal says Raymond lies. Does Sal tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Amberley lies. Shena says Amberley tells the truth. Willian says Shena tells the truth. Raymond says Willian lies. Sal says Raymond lies. Does Sal tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5246.76, "reasoner_ms": 2397.23, "tts_ms": 20.83, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7664.85, "total_processing_ms": 8302.96 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 829, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 119 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "db66442e31f072869ed6a5f1a5838f687c729a297f6b112a76a89d1d60968152", "started_sha256": "950e2dacdfb8754435a8182442b31a684b27de09ac156038716f9fa549216eca", "original_grade_sha256": "7009b0f45a48aeb1c71b771bfa914ed6bf47f3acfd4dfcee62cc3931ad2da227", "input_original_sha256": "db66442e31f072869ed6a5f1a5838f687c729a297f6b112a76a89d1d60968152", "input_wav_sha256": "d2f806efcc11ab7e453d56d39a5f0a13a63f0e4f15abc2e1dc2836f190941802", "input_pcm_sha256": "2404281b4333d1d772897d1f5f7a8f10cdee98b2600c011a688f1f28adeaf2e7", "output_wav_sha256": "6979367caecee52d1a75535f189bda728a27aafedb04faeb416e8948d1f032e2", "output_pcm_sha256": "5475fb25089d6affe8b4453e30282e5cd06caf20d60a67aa95e6c0b96f3cf442", "result_sha256": "111089c72b2498f8f780387bc03b272c8a020a7cde9d0f2251a8a758a7371054" } }, { "id": 213, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "86001824f0d3503ce6c4cc3fb6d4d08e9da8913d4b7e934cae1a7603650f2f20", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "86001824f0d3503ce6c4cc3fb6d4d08e9da8913d4b7e934cae1a7603650f2f20", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, being a workmate of Lowell is sufficient for not being a brother of Ron. Moreover, there is no brother of Ron who is a close friend of Kenneth, yet not a workmate of Lowell. It follows that everyone who is a brother of Ron is a close friend of Kenneth too. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom, and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, being a workmate of Lowell is sufficient for not being a brother of Ron. Moreover, there is no brother of Ron who is a close friend of Kenneth yet not a workmate of Lowell. It follows that everyone who is a brother of Ron is a close friend of Kenneth too, is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid. Valid Invalid Answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12402.14, "reasoner_ms": 6424.94, "tts_ms": 26.87, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 18853.99, "total_processing_ms": 19481.81 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1019, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 504 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e95f5cb9b08a2a9741a17aaa36a305816556925d707d2a2d48df70a93a790594", "started_sha256": "3ead67d10f20f40bbbed150b7cbccc20581e65695f956384da5eac3ea5877fd8", "original_grade_sha256": "20f91da37fd7739d916dbf0ab54ac67a9fbd335f08087dd23e1b7e7aac167a87", "input_original_sha256": "e95f5cb9b08a2a9741a17aaa36a305816556925d707d2a2d48df70a93a790594", "input_wav_sha256": "b38315aae9914d3dede87fdd00f8654b374f9cc58421e113beb2ac8a6a46a5b2", "input_pcm_sha256": "9228b611f3b8681f80ae237cc810dcd9662ba9188bbf5efdaad3b1581e50d314", "output_wav_sha256": "c6cdea64e0d06d3184fd81e6e0a602d9da9ffc6baf058b10c6b846f8853ae7bb", "output_pcm_sha256": "d8374c81f7315ba7057bd742bc2811eab9facd2eb67b9be2f74718b46dca07a4", "result_sha256": "ace393dfe95790e66b0212052dc20a8e515a574e894ff32bbe0b9228bcb65087" } }, { "id": 350, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6cc35856182d5e6573de2b04f9dbe6767d19aa60f1366216918010ed74f7c7a8", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6cc35856182d5e6573de2b04f9dbe6767d19aa60f1366216918010ed74f7c7a8", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take seven steps. Turn around. Take seven steps. Turn left. Turn around. Turn around. Turn left. Options? Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take seven steps. Turn around. Take seven steps. Turn left. Turn around. Turn around. Turn left. Options? Yes? No? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5646.72, "reasoner_ms": 1938.63, "tts_ms": 24.14, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7609.52, "total_processing_ms": 8126.53 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 819, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 58 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "640e30805da6b6f913a52d2419ea2b3cb879e56a888994cbf9eace36a1fe0534", "started_sha256": "ba5404d427636caca88168d925c2024698b18e4ecf02a520de11a9377fb253b6", "original_grade_sha256": "0f406388b982b899dfb3c32e8648484394998d662307f463012514609b3480b7", "input_original_sha256": "640e30805da6b6f913a52d2419ea2b3cb879e56a888994cbf9eace36a1fe0534", "input_wav_sha256": "05b0014ed9c37593537c5403ca460ab94be30cb095331d092b00167970533f21", "input_pcm_sha256": "3a58df1f8b20f2c94350533f3eea0f5bcb063752a59e7da7d72ffa2797829c19", "output_wav_sha256": "22928776b6e27fa4a2e992edb4ae51c17be17a61e8e0e5ef9beafb51b52b7ae9", "output_pcm_sha256": "b6e8de0a3d711b70a386ccc96576264d7ee5d9c5f071c8edb102195cdf6edb17", "result_sha256": "c06159f8e3e32c227761a9701e03c03a6c00e1f0adc048a30eb2dad7ab58babf" } }, { "id": 735, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "11", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a3a7a5643004644129ef67f03514f75df857a91e2f523695b7b5fc089f519d6f", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a3a7a5643004644129ef67f03514f75df857a91e2f523695b7b5fc089f519d6f", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have four pianos, four snails, three chickens, a pig, a dog, and two cows. How many animals do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have four pianos four snails three chickens a pig a dog and two cows how many animals do i have answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 11.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7351.86, "reasoner_ms": 1672.35, "tts_ms": 24.74, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9048.98, "total_processing_ms": 9579.21 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 754, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 52 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "7f10069069c2a48605d97e53328d5f2528c9c8afd3bfa4ac01b2f36e099ee4db", "started_sha256": "66505fb5c91f15972b5de46b5f85fb31accaeaa3df111fd9636054d73bb55193", "original_grade_sha256": "16d2d149ae7576ad46e9152a58e1fbd9c49f31ea649519e2aca375badda4a3d4", "input_original_sha256": "7f10069069c2a48605d97e53328d5f2528c9c8afd3bfa4ac01b2f36e099ee4db", "input_wav_sha256": "ed99a87a5416ddbbf892a4d7e1dddff99316ecff0424db60d0e765dab43cef42", "input_pcm_sha256": "d5c6b9b3826aec10cf32ad3f87e67de74698e042693d7f7618b98a3e850fb45d", "output_wav_sha256": "7379a61a5b8b3e739ea042ad265801957e401f116c96a7d34133e72d4ccc5430", "output_pcm_sha256": "253693fa87f1aa9f667b7ae13f0470e429935c0bd77f9778d7ffba253b7522e3", "result_sha256": "502ce51664be8a45c8554514b805e73f195a7b657eba52f7fb7f33e367a201e1" } }, { "id": 921, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1ccf58f63f29bb8137faefaed382f4d4dc310b317f9692986799d8e28f9cf40e", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1ccf58f63f29bb8137faefaed382f4d4dc310b317f9692986799d8e28f9cf40e", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Shenna lies. Christa says Shenna lies. Andre says Christa tells the truth. Sherry says Andre lies. Kaa says Sherry lies. Does Kaa tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Shanna lies. Krista says Shanna lies. Andre says Krista tells the truth. Sherry says Andre lies. Ka says Sherry lies. Does Ka tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6042.55, "reasoner_ms": 2310.83, "tts_ms": 23.33, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8376.74, "total_processing_ms": 8927.6 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 823, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 107 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "bcf3bc3ec52bf57370944ea930487995da4adff30e8a6994f9c1ca6640b5050a", "started_sha256": "034249f880b92451a23086a11ddebb5f91ea0f414e07d4dd8e902e74a12538c0", "original_grade_sha256": "592662b8de75ae9e79d5eca9ff3ce5fe9f48538d1d720a7d7d594683d48e69f3", "input_original_sha256": "bcf3bc3ec52bf57370944ea930487995da4adff30e8a6994f9c1ca6640b5050a", "input_wav_sha256": "f2bdb3efc25596ea86d7f0375facedb3407d6329095ec3513bff3d0bbb27a995", "input_pcm_sha256": "b4698cc0cb6e893c76de53386d06c2a1cf44b5a7591da310bbc5671a4f722b9f", "output_wav_sha256": "eab887e1eb3039f668080d368667f0120efeafd891f3a2f8106dd667f67c6bb9", "output_pcm_sha256": "1aaa47e66282d3395de3662ca97f4c82b142fd590008c1880c1184cb9c311ada", "result_sha256": "4cd10ee11f515eb227e3f315222214f7af49480c75b2d14e65b1a841112189d0" } }, { "id": 68, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "776c447488fdeb321ce61fd4b9b518ca5cf23db06698947280c7fa1c55d418ff", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "776c447488fdeb321ce61fd4b9b518ca5cf23db06698947280c7fa1c55d418ff", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nSome football fans admire various clubs. Others love only a single team. But who is a fan of whom precisely? The following argument pertains to this question: Every expert of AS Saint-\u00c9tienne is an admirer of FC Krasnodar. Every ex-fan of FC Sion is not an expert of AS Saint-\u00c9tienne or not an ex-fan of Osmanlispor. Being an admirer of FC Krasnodar is necessary for being an ex-fan of Osmanlispor. We may conclude being an ex-fan of FC Sion is sufficient for being an admirer of FC Krasnodar. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nSome football fans admire various clubs, others love only a single team. But who is a fan of whom precisely? The following argument pertains to this question, every expert of AS Saint-\u00c9tienne is an admirer of FC Krasnodar. Every ex-fan of FC Sion is not an expert of AS Saint-\u00c9tienne or not an ex-fan of Osmondspor. Being an admirer of FC Krasnodar is necessary for being an ex-fan of Osmondspor. Boer. We may conclude, being an ex-fan of FC Sion is sufficient for being an admirer of FC Krasnodar. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options? Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13419.16, "reasoner_ms": 6072.84, "tts_ms": 44.17, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 19536.21, "total_processing_ms": 20222.48 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1059, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 349 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1f7df61b956759067cce81c5423bba986035448db2fc0a0fd727163f197639f7", "started_sha256": "a1a370b14ab46c47be726eb49aa58a0c0aa776b334ffa306190524d6ed3e8cce", "original_grade_sha256": "7f73ee2f25db2cd1f2ce28ae686dddf69ed6ebb6d017b584e5b218323e20eaa0", "input_original_sha256": "1f7df61b956759067cce81c5423bba986035448db2fc0a0fd727163f197639f7", "input_wav_sha256": "dbfa27ab01155b7967a3374ec1bc443f75be7371e234a3e5856cac1a0d769dbf", "input_pcm_sha256": "362c7e8018fb51b45f6f2ac2bd4aa7c90d85bdbf37e986276fd604e5150ed11e", "output_wav_sha256": "79d4a60e10d9cd290afb5e151bde4b39ab2ff975f4e565b2470871663efcfec1", "output_pcm_sha256": "502c27ecfa3bf1b05fbfdb8a37e21f237fa757e6eaef7ed025d83a0c1db72906", "result_sha256": "5ddad0e6a76cc45cc02c8449d74b44ba5ac2801d07433868aa1afd591035ad5b" } }, { "id": 289, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "07f401a916249a92d1c5b4fbf7943e491c1570a2545d8b651e832a63fd02bcc2", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "07f401a916249a92d1c5b4fbf7943e491c1570a2545d8b651e832a63fd02bcc2", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take two steps forward. Take two steps backward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take two steps forward. Take two steps backward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4675.32, "reasoner_ms": 1390.48, "tts_ms": 27.35, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6093.17, "total_processing_ms": 6628.47 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 786, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "72fb2d3774c77f288696a5dbd6c4d8a8e91d418037da9ce70c9263d4aa287dae", "started_sha256": "ba616064adfe9ec5890d8a9d9c9f472a185a6dddbc288b15ee1a05fdd8ecc1ee", "original_grade_sha256": "39b1a8aadc69da12260c84e0f237e9eb00297bb30651f69cb9386fc184198921", "input_original_sha256": "72fb2d3774c77f288696a5dbd6c4d8a8e91d418037da9ce70c9263d4aa287dae", "input_wav_sha256": "83e20ee72269a1cab0d3618fe3885c368edcf25d26f0ae7e05d7634c24015009", "input_pcm_sha256": "5992fcbb67e1ef0bd850facc54ec5b7474d21278ab984e0b7c6922aa72b77d2b", "output_wav_sha256": "f57f77e5b9df17f06b322942651e8f5f30b1f5a4f154ef9ff81f5e8080cc7013", "output_pcm_sha256": "3d54c2d83526916edde53d3d38121c16195dc68734015dadcebb3a91fede0b85", "result_sha256": "adae9b49ac11fd919a7422128f28c508d1e58eea7b2640df2de8f3d3cec368a0" } }, { "id": 604, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "8", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6cd4ed5e1435f570e0f108f926c0b378adf3ae884fb4803acd4e79ee96ad65eb", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6cd4ed5e1435f570e0f108f926c0b378adf3ae884fb4803acd4e79ee96ad65eb", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a bear, two snakes, a rabbit, a microwave, a goat, and three cats. How many animals do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a bear, two snakes, a rabbit, a microwave, a goat, and three cats. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 8.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4176.68, "reasoner_ms": 1759.29, "tts_ms": 24.86, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5960.87, "total_processing_ms": 6847.28 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 765, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 52 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f14cb314399445fea080ba9480c0f73be306cf91cff26a78a33d77b04647d75c", "started_sha256": "2f8ece6a0053327526bf6db479623ba20c25eef94678333c0f0ff06b635fb662", "original_grade_sha256": "0ac60bfcbba1b91fdeec0cc550e5e2e316221b516bec77b86b857ab2766fafb7", "input_original_sha256": "f14cb314399445fea080ba9480c0f73be306cf91cff26a78a33d77b04647d75c", "input_wav_sha256": "d22709011a2711c49181c0d26417552dcebdd6921bb722d7cbdf2ce438a5de9b", "input_pcm_sha256": "954ee0408b5e05cc23eab3df07beb5e85c1663fe64628b1bf56e414be217cb71", "output_wav_sha256": "8945d52ea62b6ef5ce41b806fef5faae3e7c50180b7a53b4326d896a1132ff5c", "output_pcm_sha256": "243cfefab54a2191e1ee403465423bc719d61501f8dd4fe9d6864a9686f57861", "result_sha256": "e3da64008411c86e149cf1a296ef34483747f69db012a53f689a753b260a976b" } }, { "id": 894, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c35a9e5bf78cf9a512ad44ac27719ebc6beec35d48cb205bf0af0fc00db09681", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c35a9e5bf78cf9a512ad44ac27719ebc6beec35d48cb205bf0af0fc00db09681", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Maybelle tells the truth. Antoine says Maybelle tells the truth. Audrey says Antoine tells the truth. Ryan says Audrey lies. Delfina says Ryan lies. Does Delfina tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nMaybel tells the truth. Antoine says Maybel tells the truth. Autoree says Antoine tells the truth. Ryan says Autoree lies. Delphina says Ryan lies. Does Delphina tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6107.01, "reasoner_ms": 2477.2, "tts_ms": 27.22, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8611.46, "total_processing_ms": 9285.58 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 844, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 108 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "9be51bf39d9cd264228afe6bef8d95a3a8cccd8f572e5bf3ae9c620b97099694", "started_sha256": "b8f4be4bb24f9121ba52644e6fff7862d06d3b32d64a847bde7aa1366d5e97cd", "original_grade_sha256": "f08aa70d361e3e764ca363a88909ed1dc86bb338c2651ccf6896feca3ecfad9d", "input_original_sha256": "9be51bf39d9cd264228afe6bef8d95a3a8cccd8f572e5bf3ae9c620b97099694", "input_wav_sha256": "47cdcf3c91e1c27bcc95797c729054768649d884cb545fca49be5971f5959fe2", "input_pcm_sha256": "247d6e83eb985da431b517d232d191671eafa7cbd8c95eb0e2138031dcd4732b", "output_wav_sha256": "424d57147b28a21d0871d8e989ffc28f9c4a6e934ea76cc5b2bf17eb13700720", "output_pcm_sha256": "e96b6116927d1ab0c74e969f04627d5ebf511f17227cd38a223d7c56a98d8d5f", "result_sha256": "75582f24d294c3bca4b48f3c32f6cf875e764e95e13721d4f5573517bcb0781e" } }, { "id": 188, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "24a00ee939ed125b75bdf3925659fbeab30e07897c14f50807f9e0ceeb0f717d", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "24a00ee939ed125b75bdf3925659fbeab30e07897c14f50807f9e0ceeb0f717d", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. Some classmate of Terry is a workmate of Dolores. Whoever is not a workmate of Dolores is an ancestor of Cheryl. So necessarily, some ancestor of Cheryl is not a classmate of Terry. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. Some classmate of Terry is a workmate of Dolores. Whoever is not a workmate of Dolores is an ancestor of Cheryl. So necessarily some ancestor of Cheryl is not a classmate of Terry. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9013.38, "reasoner_ms": 6163.4, "tts_ms": 26.79, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15203.61, "total_processing_ms": 15658.47 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 973, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 446 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "58c1b7049c3d040c07282a5db12dbcf0d8fbf0145316d762294b70939530dea0", "started_sha256": "2ec77758f8ada90b71a43a67a7e19b54ee9e0c4c2a40e64d86b564625ec1210b", "original_grade_sha256": "98ed53b000ad35692a3606194546d450bd885fea168e1202e2adfe2fcde61a8c", "input_original_sha256": "58c1b7049c3d040c07282a5db12dbcf0d8fbf0145316d762294b70939530dea0", "input_wav_sha256": "de5906f39d01ea6f3a57bec1df53b172daf05e6e7636c80697a93620da4906ae", "input_pcm_sha256": "429ca978da805111af6d1756452385c114d1a82688dae544754e6e0e2335de0b", "output_wav_sha256": "01d739f9828cd541cefbed22511be9fb268cff095e9193e4e39e652d805e0636", "output_pcm_sha256": "2bfeb8e94f9c08aaf0cc947750d504ae5aff5eebe46ae0e57970a9432c8c594d", "result_sha256": "a4045592cec96c00d2a78b026904ad80a7d79611d7ec243c177d57c7bab54340" } }, { "id": 481, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "db4a9ca7384cabdd8272970821a981b8d76708e6a8889b2b93ab4c3859ac9f95", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "db4a9ca7384cabdd8272970821a981b8d76708e6a8889b2b93ab4c3859ac9f95", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take ten steps right. Take seven steps backward. Take three steps left. Take eight steps backward. Take three steps backward. Take eight steps right. Options. Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take 10 steps right. Take 7 steps backward. Take 3 steps left. Take 8 steps backward. Take 3 steps backward. Take 8 steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6318.67, "reasoner_ms": 2326.74, "tts_ms": 19.21, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8664.64, "total_processing_ms": 9258.98 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 859, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 78 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f6cca86be13ad88ba91969d956cd4c3048aa969cc83dacf52f2ca7a3009768b3", "started_sha256": "11ec7769e9b4f86977c4e31f3a14d73619db3771035d483fe490ff193262c05b", "original_grade_sha256": "d55a8b4f54cb900364d8d88fc59bec85901360b00c14796e67900a0a82047b71", "input_original_sha256": "f6cca86be13ad88ba91969d956cd4c3048aa969cc83dacf52f2ca7a3009768b3", "input_wav_sha256": "d7230c8717db8edc79f5509b52a27eb01f530c71214d69dc208dec4f982ce6b9", "input_pcm_sha256": "175fb289aee0f9766f4d9dea523a1df5c4daa2727291865241828159eab54531", "output_wav_sha256": "d99e7b5bf87f190afebaae45c472043df169c6241d9a107e4b2dc500d2e69fd7", "output_pcm_sha256": "cd042f86e5ef7b8d872b5adfb43b0c847d3afe1a90387c691a4303214e4a3aae", "result_sha256": "2b36f3d7e0be3da543ea3b04135b5c5241c3fe81fb0af195ee3f40d5d149c426" } }, { "id": 631, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "2", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "864f9d6962039ef4bf04358890b255bcf958df814f36d8144444fb50de82b2ad", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "864f9d6962039ef4bf04358890b255bcf958df814f36d8144444fb50de82b2ad", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a pig and a donkey. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a pig and a donkey. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 2.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 3704.29, "reasoner_ms": 1567.0, "tts_ms": 20.88, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5292.2, "total_processing_ms": 6092.11 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 726, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ca0398e4bbbf11c21bcdef7eca43b1d16ec7baf489718189ba52e9ae91e30e1f", "started_sha256": "db2503abe3d4a72587d37789e3db79c0171ea52f011990d0fa3fba0aadae7dfa", "original_grade_sha256": "17239fa5939ef968b8f18cb825492ed36202ed0a85914eaf6d9e6f1b293f2882", "input_original_sha256": "ca0398e4bbbf11c21bcdef7eca43b1d16ec7baf489718189ba52e9ae91e30e1f", "input_wav_sha256": "ed09202a1426b13bbef759a6b16f5b07c59f95ded1d244f90a8ecbacd54ccc55", "input_pcm_sha256": "d9138ef4c705d8e87c5379a13adb200681a1a2ab05b1865608afed88eadd1839", "output_wav_sha256": "017963ad2c3d3ca23fdeadd11ce51014751b6e68fa2592f75d9d407ca8edab6f", "output_pcm_sha256": "16a2ac693a1cd825f0f57d138b15ead024bde954831a078bda527bbf86b76bde", "result_sha256": "0e96d2eb8e3b53f5e167620f933be9609f8de777a549a7441c5f727ab6ad785c" } }, { "id": 777, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2b730e37a5e70e59179a1048481c466890d047015d567791f76c1100e4b144b1", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2b730e37a5e70e59179a1048481c466890d047015d567791f76c1100e4b144b1", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Fletcher lies. Phoebe says Fletcher tells the truth. Veena says Phoebe tells the truth. Andriy says Veena tells the truth. Willian says Andriy tells the truth. Does Willian tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Fletcher lies. Phoebe says Fletcher tells the truth. Vena says Phoebe tells the truth. Andri says Vena tells the truth. William says Andri tells the truth. Does William tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6444.06, "reasoner_ms": 2332.97, "tts_ms": 22.96, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8800.01, "total_processing_ms": 9445.59 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 845, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 113 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "692e1bc31b018f8f11e0ff50ea7198eb36f67f1aea1202e988b4afa8836bd7a6", "started_sha256": "8688bfee7237c8193ac3f65839d9e7558b9c225f833f7421496d51ad277dd43f", "original_grade_sha256": "8ce9fdc73c631307478ef1f81194d2c4204a7d9763d0e0a14e04699c52d7a8d9", "input_original_sha256": "692e1bc31b018f8f11e0ff50ea7198eb36f67f1aea1202e988b4afa8836bd7a6", "input_wav_sha256": "3467c78a1398e6cfe0b560c32136182e7f145320a2bf30956eac1390ef6444ed", "input_pcm_sha256": "ae096ccb223cbb2d36a0c638c25fb3c628b692a1fbf6985b1a253673ba620fd8", "output_wav_sha256": "dc7cc3c81d508704521815fdb2721fed82d1fea416ab004e179c51761369b7a3", "output_pcm_sha256": "8cba8f62c31f48147b9597581baa440e4b07d524c8e636c124b0f98e4ebe1a40", "result_sha256": "bc83645d226be9cde151e35b3d7dce519435179532278defb3a7164142bd708f" } }, { "id": 173, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c0daba76e6d814f78869e286fe6a8170487ed77400350d7018aa8bbe32d1aa8c", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c0daba76e6d814f78869e286fe6a8170487ed77400350d7018aa8bbe32d1aa8c", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, being an ingredient of hair and body wash is sufficient for being an ingredient of fungus treatment. Next, every ingredient of lip gloss, BCMK, that is an ingredient of fungus treatment, is also an ingredient of eyeshadow, bronze. Everything that is an ingredient of hair and body wash is an ingredient of lip gloss, BCM2. We may conclude that being an ingredient of hair and body wash is sufficient for being an ingredient of eyeshadow, bronze. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, being an ingredient of hair and body wash is sufficient for being an ingredient of fungus treatment. Next, every ingredient of lip gloss BCMK that is an ingredient of fungus treatment is also an ingredient of eyeshadow, bronze. Everything that is an ingredient of hair and body wash is an ingredient of lip gloss BCM2. We may conclude that being an ingredient of hair and body wash is sufficient for being an ingredient of eye shadow, bronze. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14530.18, "reasoner_ms": 2551.33, "tts_ms": 29.46, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17111.0, "total_processing_ms": 17798.66 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1117, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 95 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2ab6d3feb108d77ba8468b124025b71b97d51aa260af4d821d4942cd23a218b7", "started_sha256": "8610bf1066844ef17f4fe0f83f0d194e2406f2aba44aec29293f74dcc639bddd", "original_grade_sha256": "81dede88321a759ef5181a67e4002a6a4d4e8c291af932bf426eef5baff61be7", "input_original_sha256": "2ab6d3feb108d77ba8468b124025b71b97d51aa260af4d821d4942cd23a218b7", "input_wav_sha256": "0b8fb4b3f308a2c74617b5f6f1c387c46d556b1b0d71d9be2fa93c01dad66e78", "input_pcm_sha256": "834b51107744d4617faff8e90df7908b25bf84475795662f8f5f3996c9741f00", "output_wav_sha256": "4f04d6859be17af138df338928e94f7f3f3d4c3cbba7408bd90a88d35a92bf25", "output_pcm_sha256": "7b46eb6ede2324ea7ab225a142712a419ea5ab6ea960234641f973ebcaea896c", "result_sha256": "1ebf07efdf750239aed3dfc5b46faa2bc88cb14678efd4b32de2c6a062412f03" } }, { "id": 440, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ff62e23df90b36af8a28c622978eb84930d6e42a3eb6ba914a982db874b22f39", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ff62e23df90b36af8a28c622978eb84930d6e42a3eb6ba914a982db874b22f39", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps backward. Take nine steps forward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps backward. Take nine steps forward. Yes? No? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5181.58, "reasoner_ms": 1667.7, "tts_ms": 25.98, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6875.29, "total_processing_ms": 7432.78 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 787, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 29 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d0ecf5e61da746acb97cb4a53166061ed3f6663f21a51b8c22303cf54a901648", "started_sha256": "34be0b75912b8cfa202ae083f16f196f55116cfc0413d708459b8c03730c888d", "original_grade_sha256": "dd037e233fa8522d55b63ac4f1ce7fa99d5f48e0ce30f04f8fc08a1be32e007c", "input_original_sha256": "d0ecf5e61da746acb97cb4a53166061ed3f6663f21a51b8c22303cf54a901648", "input_wav_sha256": "5cc09924e2b47a11cdb661afd14446d471715134f6391f79ed868f29039451de", "input_pcm_sha256": "822cf179ecf699d6f9ddedab0567f84bf0a1c47e29c7be6788ae495df2dadb61", "output_wav_sha256": "66686bde15f236305683b9e797be322878167dc29c0dd7a9699d83a09d0b214e", "output_pcm_sha256": "b1679c65cdf813e99e80fc2ae791927ceb138fca82a9034c5ec1df2fc575dcc5", "result_sha256": "49e9efcd6b3ed5b04f53d9db78dc6e3866315df78865418855e827772c56f531" } }, { "id": 720, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "8", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8bb36eae949dce47d21ed0a4dff19597fe1343e2c832a461251604683947d1dc", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8bb36eae949dce47d21ed0a4dff19597fe1343e2c832a461251604683947d1dc", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a donkey, a rabbit, a fish, and five cats. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a donkey, a rabbit, a fish, and five cats. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 8.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4383.96, "reasoner_ms": 1340.03, "tts_ms": 22.06, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5746.08, "total_processing_ms": 6412.19 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 748, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 20 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "bd9ebab90b1b9227be0743666dd3cef855d42a512f47e72605d17a7a1022fd40", "started_sha256": "f0c85a860dac4dd63253d3c892215a42dfd75568a7fe3fdf3333bc41831c3575", "original_grade_sha256": "c0d897f29e8b1fa1f84d47b15f86a049af102c41c1927a0c1ee93341929f98bd", "input_original_sha256": "bd9ebab90b1b9227be0743666dd3cef855d42a512f47e72605d17a7a1022fd40", "input_wav_sha256": "8a79368875e93a5d3a9a120a710004437aaef448ae507ff4bb25b038484af78b", "input_pcm_sha256": "adde8bc8d966ec1900425291d170ddb6ae2043d46ea313d461dfa8e9b7be5c46", "output_wav_sha256": "f025ff950609771c77da7766488a18e977be7c1d11e80817113c65d04a9fbc61", "output_pcm_sha256": "4565308f5cb2433bf9b0f6fc1bd310fc28aff32a6e1a010a069be9d468e92085", "result_sha256": "ce3eff1638f57ff62324ef8c4440558b1fbc058b052d66f235585fcaf888015c" } }, { "id": 766, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "764de6f4abcd4e7f4ec1fb46f4d14465d6ab3b98a90659a1151dbff584c4848f", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "764de6f4abcd4e7f4ec1fb46f4d14465d6ab3b98a90659a1151dbff584c4848f", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Ka lies. Christy says Ka tells the truth. Jerry says Christy lies. Krista says Jerry lies. Yolande says Krista tells the truth. Does Yolande tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Ka lies. Christy says Ka tells the truth. Jerry says Christy lies. Krista says Jerry lies. Yolin says Krista tells the truth. Does Yolin tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5485.46, "reasoner_ms": 5150.7, "tts_ms": 23.35, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10659.54, "total_processing_ms": 11173.61 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 827, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 347 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e003048d2fdf09e36dce672744438428b1f82b0a8554f4b0aab87d766ce47197", "started_sha256": "4d5e7c8b03c6157b8037b5539f92fa94132087097a9764ed394eba0f0da6bc5b", "original_grade_sha256": "3a587272cbdd3da94a298a68ec26f7906c99235eae2d85607c80ced988165e0b", "input_original_sha256": "e003048d2fdf09e36dce672744438428b1f82b0a8554f4b0aab87d766ce47197", "input_wav_sha256": "3ef49c16a3635e75ca87a09cdc1df78b865fe51af45ebedad07ec4bde21a3d7d", "input_pcm_sha256": "bfa09c25d447482a4fbc1f2ea882484afbe630f9ae52b5dd972a7c28b010da88", "output_wav_sha256": "59d638c10d1bbd2cb6a03d2bb7add741244f5c8a2c7f1cacc190cb8cfc705e36", "output_pcm_sha256": "0432e3dc0b9c9a9369d2663fb20a71eb25307cb20c9ef1ba70d4875e1539ff03", "result_sha256": "3ff1ac3204383a8e5134208b272187fd053ecd9f9cb8e2548568d4b74c2c85a8" } }, { "id": 46, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e40f04455ba72833537072c841458f3ed601e12e3a96ed1d97ed525126916211", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e40f04455ba72833537072c841458f3ed601e12e3a96ed1d97ed525126916211", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, no half-sister of Nelda is a close friend of Terry or a cousin of Amanda. Now, it is false that Gretchen is a close friend of Terry. Moreover, it is false that Gretchen is a cousin of Amanda. We may conclude it is not the case that Gretchen is a half-sister of Nelda. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, no half-sister of Nelda is a close friend of Terry or a cousin of Amanda. Now, it is false that Gretchen is a close friend of Terry. Moreover, it is false that Gretchen is a cousin of Amanda. We may conclude. It is not the case that Gretchen is a half-sister of Nelda. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid. Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11518.06, "reasoner_ms": 3860.66, "tts_ms": 28.21, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15406.95, "total_processing_ms": 15905.46 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1016, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 207 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0a780422d36ed5e896a583f1cdce7e9e71bc9a28fd7452f2cc4ba5b21bfcd045", "started_sha256": "9bb1fe367b7f1a344d6f725b7726b32c659f94750cfc7814b884f43b119713a7", "original_grade_sha256": "71dc7f4852f7a16b94ae45f87976a964872c24ee388b537cba3539f641cd888d", "input_original_sha256": "0a780422d36ed5e896a583f1cdce7e9e71bc9a28fd7452f2cc4ba5b21bfcd045", "input_wav_sha256": "dbf47f341715e938152f15103044ead748732aa0f54ab7d7073343bb5b988135", "input_pcm_sha256": "01d1c5ee00694e31abfdd72d249ab4bed889364af391ef8aec816c5850a4cca4", "output_wav_sha256": "22ee6780e980ea148f193e01081630d133a3b731014b0e21d514a2d588ea8308", "output_pcm_sha256": "32ea27dece90e14eef1e5f2d79931d95cebaaeb668e8e657da252af3c98e459d", "result_sha256": "4bad3e6d7a8147a0ab53a325ef32532c2a14a4aae7900508ac3756be1292e56a" } }, { "id": 474, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b6fcf28dc2fe257f7f81da85f226b4b0de8184944dab3cfeb2b869704717f633", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b6fcf28dc2fe257f7f81da85f226b4b0de8184944dab3cfeb2b869704717f633", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take seven steps backward. Take nine steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take seven steps backward. Take nine steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5277.43, "reasoner_ms": 1597.6, "tts_ms": 26.93, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6901.98, "total_processing_ms": 7446.69 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 787, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 27 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1e4c6d60f4a71ad91112370c9023b28ea45b867001e7b5e037bac987aa679bcc", "started_sha256": "ce725608159698429453105ef258e28623e6ed62813feb6d1fdb462583269ee0", "original_grade_sha256": "6e42088efea14544b4d7349c10f95f5dacccc85528907e77770004f52ea0a512", "input_original_sha256": "1e4c6d60f4a71ad91112370c9023b28ea45b867001e7b5e037bac987aa679bcc", "input_wav_sha256": "6753d7d2fe539976a7be60760a87f3e5968ae4a8087c93b1ea4e08340182a4a7", "input_pcm_sha256": "737115d6aa61bee9d3e7fdcbf4b5534b58f306a26ce3f0f4cb94544979016793", "output_wav_sha256": "62adb30ca132a516d0766b2d203d50cf72df3115ed164b48ced81c350bb76b1a", "output_pcm_sha256": "d4a2ac93f20d3ea8ce63e3d9dbf8102e6b70660b47dc146815c5c3762a7b6ffc", "result_sha256": "f292fc2f328190ff3345a64cb7bbdbf9b806dfe70a56f0bd6dcea45c197fea83" } }, { "id": 695, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "15", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3475941b6a3b82a766f6bcc5df97411429f295066c306e7da7a806dd0eb176f1", "normalized_answer": "15" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3475941b6a3b82a766f6bcc5df97411429f295066c306e7da7a806dd0eb176f1", "normalized_answer": "15" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a drum, four pianos, two accordions, a carrot, a stalk of celery, three flutes, a cauliflower, a violin, a clarinet, a trombone, and two trumpets. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a drum for pianos, two accordions, a carrot, a stalk of celery, three flutes, a cauliflower, a violin, a clarinet, a trombone, and two trumpets. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 15.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5932.26, "reasoner_ms": 2203.13, "tts_ms": 27.13, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8162.55, "total_processing_ms": 8691.71 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 81 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "281a7ec27fc5b573f7fdcde01fe7694b99d42556c575f42b3cc638d1bc30d634", "started_sha256": "35b578f81c1f9b11e25ea031c9e826974df21f45229c5d01c15bb4c12791d1d8", "original_grade_sha256": "1c144eb113705a2d8ca178f3bb1440c9819d8215366ab91e04cb8a81f3c4fcac", "input_original_sha256": "281a7ec27fc5b573f7fdcde01fe7694b99d42556c575f42b3cc638d1bc30d634", "input_wav_sha256": "448b862a9f71ebbc385df3dafda535829f0efdd5f0a0fec03541557830ccf1a3", "input_pcm_sha256": "c335e328058a263cb151bc5ae5ec9a6c1950f3cd6d3db8ab9ab695fdecd05d4b", "output_wav_sha256": "55a42aba565ecd196cf4300a1c09ca5edaf853cadf3060607535b7c426f5502f", "output_pcm_sha256": "72dc99bd87b4563b18c32b11761c8ec773111fc622a30ac902e828cb9d2f6c2f", "result_sha256": "7347030567c1bfd2809203fa40c402057751e77b3786fd0de9884d12afabe129" } }, { "id": 793, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b1fd65adfb813425eb60c6d4bd825de7efc1dd2d3f0eeecf7385c00b98b7bc80", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b1fd65adfb813425eb60c6d4bd825de7efc1dd2d3f0eeecf7385c00b98b7bc80", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Fletcher tells the truth. Helene says Fletcher lies. Eleanor says Helene tells the truth. Yolan says Eleanor tells the truth. Audrey says Yolan lies. Does Audrey tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Fletcher tells the truth. Helene says Fletcher lies. Eleanor says Helene tells the truth. Yolen says Eleanor tells the truth. Autry says Yolen lies. Does Autry tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5730.18, "reasoner_ms": 2403.28, "tts_ms": 24.97, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8158.45, "total_processing_ms": 8746.56 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 847, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 115 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "15915d567f216f6ce2aa67864c68b170c58044ca0301245819547c7426cab71c", "started_sha256": "cfa33175b0b84e83fe3b67b8165b49030e664873bed562de1352687ce6d63b39", "original_grade_sha256": "15903f2ad50ea86883feb9cc63b38f5843cb8a204bef57c20508460ef0683d6f", "input_original_sha256": "15915d567f216f6ce2aa67864c68b170c58044ca0301245819547c7426cab71c", "input_wav_sha256": "48e2489643226057ac98841977b8a499fda3bad1d7eb0c54dbb1af3e4aaeecfe", "input_pcm_sha256": "feaca0fa097ef3615e80d38a35f8c1ec45ecb3cc2deed7b42ced5859818ae672", "output_wav_sha256": "b95fea6dfdef8648d9f246c8667128d15403feaee19561637fa1ba2df0c4f0fd", "output_pcm_sha256": "8814254d7675afab81f34d06ff3f7b40521eefd846d3a91cdc9a09e3f0659420", "result_sha256": "6eeb274d02b0bca4590111f1e48c2dc153f9b34b3d532e0b91e0642c3dc9c3f1" } }, { "id": 137, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3284705b186379e6d0c0babb9190744919cca3afd65806b64821ff8ab3f2a5c3", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3284705b186379e6d0c0babb9190744919cca3afd65806b64821ff8ab3f2a5c3", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, there is somebody who is a half-brother of Felipe and a brother of Harvey. Next, no workmate of Gary who is a nephew of Perry is a brother of Harvey. Hence, some half-brother of Felipe is not a nephew of Perry or not a workmate of Gary. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, there is somebody who is a half-brother of Felipe and a brother of Harvey. Next, no workmate of Gary who is a nephew of Perry is a brother of Harvey. Hence, some half-brother of Felipe is not a nephew of Perry or not a workmate of Gary. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9455.73, "reasoner_ms": 3866.84, "tts_ms": 54.02, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 13376.61, "total_processing_ms": 13986.9 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 985, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 309 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d7f86783a163ca240e09ed92482e7d65d31dc1520af95a4de1a44e1cf3b4ebc2", "started_sha256": "63a60ce4303c5f59cfc5c2143ba4f6ae86978a61e909d2572df233550da69ef8", "original_grade_sha256": "bb0aad29ba080c73327668d75d5275d315f58c0636cb7dbd0e96cc7c7fe4d14c", "input_original_sha256": "d7f86783a163ca240e09ed92482e7d65d31dc1520af95a4de1a44e1cf3b4ebc2", "input_wav_sha256": "66abb3330cd4525fac338372ca581c694a5863eff960d13aad633a357960ef5d", "input_pcm_sha256": "df06d8473c7858d9009dd449be8907fb94617924bf05a181af44c7a40abd0695", "output_wav_sha256": "6e8ddacd15f93092172fd6ff6b61f0291562e1637cd3d92844bfe0e320a2d658", "output_pcm_sha256": "3e6af0be73e9046b12d3fda4ba553f4f8349b0cb35a5e9b355efaeb320248010", "result_sha256": "87b25d2f0ba5412843102d6e794e3f8776e3910579f30ace9696b638b0475a8f" } }, { "id": 452, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f493b8c73a45e686a2cd5c096f9e744c509c388915f0fc2a7af4823039cd460e", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f493b8c73a45e686a2cd5c096f9e744c509c388915f0fc2a7af4823039cd460e", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps. Take four steps. Turn around. Take 10 steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps. Take four steps. Turn around. Take ten steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5881.99, "reasoner_ms": 1826.77, "tts_ms": 24.29, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7733.07, "total_processing_ms": 8290.74 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 790, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 39 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8be78ab5b5f413b1132450e66e90d3eb57f0ee3f639887c263399cac97a8270d", "started_sha256": "bf1d167768c26c64c93d1aa9dabea25eaf93b1b8496f7c3bd1e23ff04c2c8e5f", "original_grade_sha256": "f3aa12820f7a9c867c93c7607904dec949b2fe77ef4b17f1ce3c90e8e8ae1cf6", "input_original_sha256": "8be78ab5b5f413b1132450e66e90d3eb57f0ee3f639887c263399cac97a8270d", "input_wav_sha256": "2aa529631e08a6b434afd63a62defcbd1fd80eb8130ecef88f535f4cde08a198", "input_pcm_sha256": "f807dc5e42f0c1cfde2a7b759e5b21eb16d6b5d0f858bd848e5ee789ece8162f", "output_wav_sha256": "a35f0467eb1b4cb8303bebc069c11ab3e4b68a61a99898145a9ca606f72a2384", "output_pcm_sha256": "14985490ec811c608bf1aae30f133333b7e3703c4f190650719ad735fd01d33e", "result_sha256": "b20716cd749da5ca02c790b3006ebe843298bb898e637595cdcd82dc03ad76cb" } }, { "id": 537, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "6", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ecad4cc0a95ff7b2c524f3a19dd487e04ef1495189e570dd4dffa6e0592aac98", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ecad4cc0a95ff7b2c524f3a19dd487e04ef1495189e570dd4dffa6e0592aac98", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a trumpet, an accordion, three clarinets, and a violin. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a trumpet an accordion three clarinets and a violin how many musical instruments do i have answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 6.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7472.01, "reasoner_ms": 1387.44, "tts_ms": 24.79, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8884.27, "total_processing_ms": 9494.76 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 759, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 20 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "cb96428ee6829cc6aea6d59931f8d9e6219ec0dd0bbeffe8b680113354e52e64", "started_sha256": "7a592bb5555a5dbad1e991ec05d84edea067ee0ebee693b10ee21e1a45c8a35c", "original_grade_sha256": "3cac4043d016f713ec51c3c996f6d44fa8f2521108b40f18b4801e6077898ad6", "input_original_sha256": "cb96428ee6829cc6aea6d59931f8d9e6219ec0dd0bbeffe8b680113354e52e64", "input_wav_sha256": "f0427d4a37fff84ce3fe48c337e08667574a3fd7bf47b13247b8ccd583c3e2ed", "input_pcm_sha256": "42ef466582093b14f74d1372783be38c1f1b09345153fb194d83a2a6328977ed", "output_wav_sha256": "5f9f8c893b26ea7e77ffe79535f341103b08f89c9a343ca744f5f1eb113e403d", "output_pcm_sha256": "bd0451ad7cad87c4bf87d91a3f705d802661dd24de9089ced6a222f370643fde", "result_sha256": "8219bdc4ecd89d4f3f8af7a3ebbd89f1987e22e16b5238bb9cc50919aaff5beb" } }, { "id": 861, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c7d172ce6c3ec6f84a55bb71a6fc4daa680aecd1c423421bba062f29266afb9f", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c7d172ce6c3ec6f84a55bb71a6fc4daa680aecd1c423421bba062f29266afb9f", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Gwen tells the truth. Andre says Gwen tells the truth. Yolande says Andre lies. Sal says Yolande lies. Krista says Sal lies. Does Krista tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Gwen tells the truth. Andri says Gwen tells the truth. Yolande says Andri lies. Sal says Yolande lies. Krista says Sal lies. Does Krista tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6023.41, "reasoner_ms": 2343.48, "tts_ms": 19.37, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8386.28, "total_processing_ms": 8995.14 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 827, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 114 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e640e5f26f2eff31bc6b1067a009b744277dc6c9de2107a1596dbaeb23873ce1", "started_sha256": "515e525b2f1a60f338c6f6a5e75d64171b4fb88a2c1f26e103107f4ef2cbeb0c", "original_grade_sha256": "a9b4c34e7dc4848868a1f7a04455a76d50a8379dfef1f03ae2500a3e1be3d470", "input_original_sha256": "e640e5f26f2eff31bc6b1067a009b744277dc6c9de2107a1596dbaeb23873ce1", "input_wav_sha256": "94d11b3599f4e4c078b50f0710bba664ca9966a84cd0a1146ead8f57813612ee", "input_pcm_sha256": "56585e000c40246b842f8b8e350430252cd92da1c9c07b6cb704580a7e06dd46", "output_wav_sha256": "860572f241b5c0dbb0d734ae80cee3ceacea8829333e10ae8c8c8f0cfdcc9d9d", "output_pcm_sha256": "356eed4d86869b046ac393de381f96141458e3674c1f444a98a53df3d5d343bc", "result_sha256": "b45f3ab98e4770b6f528da4eb0ae577d18590bddf8c38818c6a99e9d1babef07" } }, { "id": 146, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "085e46a2b1dc95bc5e3b42ccf2bf5a1d803c9eb4500238d59b7fdb1135e79638", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "085e46a2b1dc95bc5e3b42ccf2bf5a1d803c9eb4500238d59b7fdb1135e79638", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a cousin of Robert? Is Joe related to Bob? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First of all, Thomas is neither a grandson of Tony nor a stepbrother of Andy. Next, whoever is neither a grandson of Tony nor a stepbrother of Andy is a workmate of Joseph. Hence, Thomas is a workmate of Joseph. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nis fred a cousin of robert is joe related to bob in large families it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives the following argument seeks to clarify some such relations first of all thomas is neither a grandson of tony nor a step-brother of andy next whoever is neither a grandson of tony nor a step-brother of andy is a workmate of joseph hence thomas is a workmate of joseph is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14676.14, "reasoner_ms": 2291.08, "tts_ms": 24.72, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 16991.97, "total_processing_ms": 17568.28 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1038, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 92 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3189e7fc5ac0929c3a34752311305da541f812124f7facdbd774bc181d56013a", "started_sha256": "a2a5104adf8da83f869cf8e6b4b4cd84610a3e665c0cdd816cf30bcc0a5d5e19", "original_grade_sha256": "8565469456d273988b151cc92fd5b7af6ceafe5386dcab0579412e57f4f482cf", "input_original_sha256": "3189e7fc5ac0929c3a34752311305da541f812124f7facdbd774bc181d56013a", "input_wav_sha256": "a647d9237cb28be174221fd0af33755a42f53a4e68769197afa7be777c722c6a", "input_pcm_sha256": "94d537ea34f330c9251cb6ea6597c4428b4158d816888659cb2c399d9ed1186b", "output_wav_sha256": "94be67f3cd63f93ae206fa80bb37903e9e3b6a8bf1850250741e28700752cfe5", "output_pcm_sha256": "9ab47a981d1cbc363f6f0854df09844e5e3a1b4fa18da38eb472b15ed545cf7b", "result_sha256": "24a3a23e3f800dc08f1decf28f75043f729cdbb6c6abf1f0c9cc89f81bc20e8d" } }, { "id": 431, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "01366853faf4ef8d5f933cf42e17669634c86699154dc6e70554225b3d91b9b3", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "01366853faf4ef8d5f933cf42e17669634c86699154dc6e70554225b3d91b9b3", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take 10 steps. Take four steps. Take seven steps. Take one step. Take two steps. Take 10 steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take 10 steps. Take 4 steps. Take 7 steps. Take 1 step. Take 2 steps. Take 10 steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6077.25, "reasoner_ms": 1606.37, "tts_ms": 23.78, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7707.43, "total_processing_ms": 8231.8 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 828, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 25 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b562e3ba64b3fbf8375687e5aee3cf5d1626bfac2e05748c0580aa8fd2353c17", "started_sha256": "a31cbaf5ae45f610147b7a95092283aa086ca6776bc4e18b2a8e667841f86803", "original_grade_sha256": "22ba0f87ecb8c7bd77c19976505aa758e7edc83e7714f62b427f85738c4f42e2", "input_original_sha256": "b562e3ba64b3fbf8375687e5aee3cf5d1626bfac2e05748c0580aa8fd2353c17", "input_wav_sha256": "90c6ec91324cdb04ed9c6549f8afbc5cd9dc552f2dda728cf10f44d05b27615b", "input_pcm_sha256": "80eaeaf97046ce2ccadf03c5d927c45b46ec705c02561c05b162386fecc6919d", "output_wav_sha256": "87b3750027e4ca7c6574a2e7ca233097ca2f2dc65a97c00520fa0c46b9fe5570", "output_pcm_sha256": "ea071d5ddd0a5bc8fdebb3365a265c96e2b8752a35de94507ce2f876549c375b", "result_sha256": "89eb35d12c32b77483396638ed815e2bef1a10ff49f9c78f47b7844af5b5eecb" } }, { "id": 626, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "7", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "69a45147eadccb23da784cf8ff791f885ad8862c53ee01b5e4d3e416f2c28a4c", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "69a45147eadccb23da784cf8ff791f885ad8862c53ee01b5e4d3e416f2c28a4c", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a toaster, a bed, a stove, a car, a microwave, a lamp, and a table. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a toaster, a bed, a stove, a car, a microwave, a lamp and a table. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 7.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4615.23, "reasoner_ms": 1596.42, "tts_ms": 23.78, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6235.46, "total_processing_ms": 6899.9 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 767, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 37 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b8d04a50adf5150593cfaac89eb8dea7d0eafd061d2efa15dba559da3cdbaedf", "started_sha256": "39340ca48a0126c936d279336d51edc54020d59dc4f0d60794487936b5fb17a4", "original_grade_sha256": "c545ba66a0f20d221ca5a7732253eda335d929fbb5e13f009fcc1722e9939eac", "input_original_sha256": "b8d04a50adf5150593cfaac89eb8dea7d0eafd061d2efa15dba559da3cdbaedf", "input_wav_sha256": "602ba41e4f7f3078846f5e109946d3915df7fe84ed8c285b219ec449f576fc39", "input_pcm_sha256": "a573532800624d017afa5eded5505274b0df20be6e7701cb08cdb20df53d87d5", "output_wav_sha256": "1146a70b3942484c7d8a13d81dd8975be4cfbd45c5b71e741b09b063d81faa5e", "output_pcm_sha256": "053addcc6c5c876b032f33e0e5a699bf4f1588a214a328d7521fff4b96bc9cac", "result_sha256": "87de1a3f66ee03a513567b4803109ff5305a241f0548ae53df4979a6644ef01f" } }, { "id": 782, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bc925a2923307fa0d4fbf064bd787abc3508b58f1c1c935ec814eccd08132e17", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bc925a2923307fa0d4fbf064bd787abc3508b58f1c1c935ec814eccd08132e17", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Delfina tells the truth. Willian says Delfina tells the truth. Krista says Willian lies. Shalonda says Krista lies. Sheena says Shalonda tells the truth. Does Sheena tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nq delphina tells the truth willian says delphina tells the truth christa says willian lies shalanda says christa lies sheena says shalanda tells the truth does sheena tell the truth answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7974.81, "reasoner_ms": 2219.65, "tts_ms": 20.13, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10214.62, "total_processing_ms": 10791.79 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 828, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 128 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a38527c4807a2bf7421b28c0ee81f8b0211070b57bea4e206baec28f32b0ca1d", "started_sha256": "7fc420d2d75b0b23ba96acc2f7de105b7fe91aeaa97f489602c69ffc758d1cb9", "original_grade_sha256": "eb1c4cd7b6acf400cf70c855f2acb154268a45a088d4f0e4538b9dfd818348e9", "input_original_sha256": "a38527c4807a2bf7421b28c0ee81f8b0211070b57bea4e206baec28f32b0ca1d", "input_wav_sha256": "024a3db6ac3b889df45d7662a2a2070b1000aa5ebb17f8642c9abacd05a13160", "input_pcm_sha256": "4796a4db3c93535a108b7a0cc37d96096b15cd72775430ce3a4a91a78acc143e", "output_wav_sha256": "f39f3cc472e9c7123d5c7fb3bc2eabf0a2620fbd6e7ab4ce76012a9b2b5c2dfc", "output_pcm_sha256": "a33d39a21ee1ba6dd7678e777d49371d30daaffa466ab71a24718eb53e4f1a13", "result_sha256": "1afc8a15a8306dea33cf1f1b826a9ccec1a94331a4f8d243f216bd0aeb188bee" } }, { "id": 240, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "69cdba80a3e23c764adaf53e68b3555edd1a449e4cac2ece8fbbd1747af52811", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "69cdba80a3e23c764adaf53e68b3555edd1a449e4cac2ece8fbbd1747af52811", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Siri a stepsister of Mary? Is Susan related to Kate? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To begin with, every daughter of Milagros is not a great-grandmother of Courtney or not an ancestor of Christy. Moreover, nobody is neither a great-grandmother of Courtney nor a niece of Lynn. Finally, being a niece of Lynn is necessary for not being an ancestor of Christy. We may conclude that every daughter of Milagros is a niece of Lynn. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Ciri a stepsister of Mary? Is Susan related to Kate? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To begin with, every daughter of Milagros is not a great-grandmother of Courtney or not an ancestor of Christy. Moreover, nobody is neither a great-grandmother of Courtney nor a niece of Lynn. Finally, being a niece of Lynn is necessary for not being an ancestor of Christy. We may conclude that every daughter of Milagros is a niece of Lynn. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13345.75, "reasoner_ms": 4933.49, "tts_ms": 28.36, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 18307.62, "total_processing_ms": 18925.33 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1060, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 364 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "43ff2e734fcda33ff4aa249a74edbd97454015ba9bbee6253002293416a879e0", "started_sha256": "8d2cf2de46616ea5d526736e8f8ea6d4927f502edd0503f8808f476ee3c41902", "original_grade_sha256": "bf40cb060edd33393d8b6353de491c9c27e13ccbc170485e0946fd33ee0ea01a", "input_original_sha256": "43ff2e734fcda33ff4aa249a74edbd97454015ba9bbee6253002293416a879e0", "input_wav_sha256": "1c7834d7f63c70b9041627838b11942b916738efd67e7b53bda28af99b1b1d1b", "input_pcm_sha256": "24e59c52e0949ce85d807de8c3fa0f7dc544213a41852ad88e7f43964376ef85", "output_wav_sha256": "b1c23c6603114a8b4e320735e0925b4b55fd3999df09da5aa3a26906a35325d1", "output_pcm_sha256": "46e8825cb9c57f418e44f7ebc3abcee46efc907f9ea81759affd39e2500cef52", "result_sha256": "79fbc8913d7d8034bec0fa4627a910882ec808dd9497a20f8d59837a381cd142" } }, { "id": 325, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "05a36621537c16a4d4fa99bd48fa79711dffcbc9a5d46f01b920109c41035053", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "05a36621537c16a4d4fa99bd48fa79711dffcbc9a5d46f01b920109c41035053", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps backward. Take two steps forward. Take one step backward. Take eight steps forward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps backward. Take two steps forward. Take one step backward. Take eight steps forward. Options? Yes? No? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5991.01, "reasoner_ms": 3985.75, "tts_ms": 24.62, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10001.41, "total_processing_ms": 10649.88 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 819, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 45 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5c105b9782f8bb208dd48a27a420df56f5b4ef24c1d162d2712da47f1fcfb4f6", "started_sha256": "9afa2d75fafe49c35433248b3458ca496cca33249b9a21a5160c543e2afff108", "original_grade_sha256": "f4e7dbe28a926f4d0cfc14d619391b34df38cb6245f460be03a06983801424d2", "input_original_sha256": "5c105b9782f8bb208dd48a27a420df56f5b4ef24c1d162d2712da47f1fcfb4f6", "input_wav_sha256": "112e13afe78ef7b12ad297381e534005e34b5d6f7ed5c0389db59bac5ee5a951", "input_pcm_sha256": "c3c813d5f7720d4bfbde5c6b71e89ec1f01585773a7d134e293f5d83db0127a5", "output_wav_sha256": "268e1943b095d9fde048fe86604c4b499c2bbff6c5fa4d00a8ca681569301f5d", "output_pcm_sha256": "92a983204b4bf65434c777f53aadfb93583fbba4ec7c94274bc39ed74032f5cf", "result_sha256": "e879001efeb4fb3a97f2ce878dc76bb7d86f444a739257c06e68cfeb64067841" } }, { "id": 584, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "6", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "10a50173a71ac1703597da44f263931484d3c482a84c6511d2d9d4281234c3f5", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "10a50173a71ac1703597da44f263931484d3c482a84c6511d2d9d4281234c3f5", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a trombone, a flute, a violin, an accordion, a piano, and a trumpet. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a trombone, a flute, a violin, an accordion, a piano, and a trumpet. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 6.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4221.94, "reasoner_ms": 1291.29, "tts_ms": 25.8, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5539.06, "total_processing_ms": 6089.87 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 772, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8e301003e8883f6e812ff897fa18b73e43c8422b40fa6a21c6a3c771486e194d", "started_sha256": "95a296334d2b46b0acc641b12277638b08e68f3a60bda51f6962d1c689008cad", "original_grade_sha256": "173d2873dd1b7b0cd33f8779c83a09e3bdb3bc0bae432b91f4ace4fdbc677e63", "input_original_sha256": "8e301003e8883f6e812ff897fa18b73e43c8422b40fa6a21c6a3c771486e194d", "input_wav_sha256": "445845a482d9820608bd37d27f1ac396b8f80282635770737838fc356d3ccd20", "input_pcm_sha256": "2dc2471f47c8b857b9a0d18733e993c07fbcf9514607a0ada3c93b156df44b3c", "output_wav_sha256": "08d652e80558a6cf7ce5b3e11ab6ab0223424bb0c7b91c442004d94fbe0f1c5a", "output_pcm_sha256": "7e3490cd3fdc29be50ea9bdb5fef82bf82f7f16dc4c35b98ec393b299cddc1af", "result_sha256": "d01d051aaec916a962e577dc0fc558d4f1b71e6ab234a745d7037b8cfc20e64e" } }, { "id": 902, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6af546cc205bd23669ef0e1d0a5f320c53613fb9c38adad8833889e37db7c5eb", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6af546cc205bd23669ef0e1d0a5f320c53613fb9c38adad8833889e37db7c5eb", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Gwen tells the truth. Millicent says Gwen lies. Antoine says Millicent tells the truth. Teresa says Antoine lies. Shenna says Teresa lies. Does Shenna tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Gwen tells the truth. Millicent says Gwen lies. Antwin says Millicent tells the truth. Teresa says Antwin lies. Shena says Teresa lies. Does Shena tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "That answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5257.07, "reasoner_ms": 2424.97, "tts_ms": 22.78, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7704.85, "total_processing_ms": 8263.81 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 837, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 110 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6d508fcd6c1a68de3c2a2778e9f0d75eccfa84ed8878dbe4eb7fbedb4cbe03b3", "started_sha256": "d76fe56d5882b2d1e13a0a4a5045b5c2c18d9987a8669dc6103ae36e3686065c", "original_grade_sha256": "181ad9e0bdb8942844cf98a4e03a2a193221d9a4f8ae43ba600a594f66fb8201", "input_original_sha256": "6d508fcd6c1a68de3c2a2778e9f0d75eccfa84ed8878dbe4eb7fbedb4cbe03b3", "input_wav_sha256": "73dbd71f16e13b0e687c5be09e594fb5bbf2247396f8d066d2033842b2ea2e2a", "input_pcm_sha256": "26e01c5ab09f57e64c3053237a86ade05b87319d6b3fb5d8494500f84a979459", "output_wav_sha256": "8ff3e4abd186a3766cb14eee7092f065516f4ea43ec0ee173eeed9291a5f2802", "output_pcm_sha256": "478de0f06cd56f1db99631dbfbb00bdc3ed7e7dc020db4c45717826b189bbfa9", "result_sha256": "9ad01d38d0e4c637c405c8d87469e7621165cb7af2021c7ea98a48e46f78b01d" } }, { "id": 31, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1c6a830f1db83056cf9400c49c99e760ae352ed537ca34c71f1f5bb133e93e82", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1c6a830f1db83056cf9400c49c99e760ae352ed537ca34c71f1f5bb133e93e82", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, no stepbrother of Brian is both a nephew of Wilburn and a son of Howard. Now, whoever is not a son of Howard is a son of Adrian. Moreover, nobody is neither a nephew of Wilburn nor a son of Adrian. Hence, everyone who is a stepbrother of Brian is a son of Adrian too. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, no stepbrother of Brian is both a nephew of Wilburn and a son of Howard. Now, whoever is not a son of Howard is a son of Adrian. Moreover, nobody is neither a nephew of Wilburn nor a son of Adrian. Hence, everyone who is a stepbrother of Brian is a son of Adrian, too. 2. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11035.52, "reasoner_ms": 4325.7, "tts_ms": 23.09, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15384.33, "total_processing_ms": 15923.43 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1029, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 288 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "39e5ae637037618dcd53dff09a21e7170339613cf5f938146c5350b4b80a0aeb", "started_sha256": "9936be0b79259888bab9302dffef457361fb60bfcb90b736ba54ac006be4bc5a", "original_grade_sha256": "d658bd72f195dd3c0c22edd88e10303ea2d0d110723ee47e10f8ab23e93d81b5", "input_original_sha256": "39e5ae637037618dcd53dff09a21e7170339613cf5f938146c5350b4b80a0aeb", "input_wav_sha256": "bba4252f87d1a543ca7c817d5591ce194bd94dd2a1bf34b0bf87eb5751904bfd", "input_pcm_sha256": "2b4067cb6f8e3977e0c3ef10a79fd7e68ce7ea99e0aae82f80b889631b58fb35", "output_wav_sha256": "f8241305cf6d0b714cf316f00f545f8c11bba6bcbd9e4dc96496efd45cc2f602", "output_pcm_sha256": "f955a5bf42ca100fd3f08afd405e2d4d68e7cef8d9cf5b419f3505b805509f68", "result_sha256": "9cdfd8a884129591c757fa3d449ccf902d8c7896426797a32daef1a186a3f556" } }, { "id": 395, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a062ea99185c78c8d771ea560ea6f8f0e43c247ac3c4e0dbd4d82271fe3e4f83", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a062ea99185c78c8d771ea560ea6f8f0e43c247ac3c4e0dbd4d82271fe3e4f83", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn around, turn around, turn left. Take seven steps. Take eight steps. Options: yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn around, turn around, turn left. Take seven steps, take eight steps. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4496.01, "reasoner_ms": 2282.25, "tts_ms": 24.1, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6802.37, "total_processing_ms": 7316.91 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 792, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 85 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "14219b57a9bff4f76a591531bbbcae7348f69e7a114c923aa249e8b317e6a7d8", "started_sha256": "56e03e5533cd440fc67e0584ebecf638bb85eefd426b5aaa609b25510ecdc05c", "original_grade_sha256": "344b520bbe230e14ff69af952572c2e43ba556ac5c7dafed57aa67cf6bc401e2", "input_original_sha256": "14219b57a9bff4f76a591531bbbcae7348f69e7a114c923aa249e8b317e6a7d8", "input_wav_sha256": "2a7b939218b2023c324a103949b62436be75728d4a9ce88ccdfc1626e1d8e3bb", "input_pcm_sha256": "fa693cd9a5ef73d1178548df8ae51680c782a33b6aa8fa12a6e6165d8f107e64", "output_wav_sha256": "77aa7a3f84a4b3d86bd4c222c97142d934b6c3a51537a2c66112484f07a17a8c", "output_pcm_sha256": "ab42605260979b7d8fafe92d630c6a9245424d4e948da251549da697258604c8", "result_sha256": "32a8480ee6a3e9bc8ef15d5ceaa44a32dadd5087f038a80d9de698dd2668a667" } }, { "id": 556, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "16", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3a3da12ba392ed5d69481d95f600511d30de589c18560eda1ada825845e2904d", "normalized_answer": "16" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3a3da12ba392ed5d69481d95f600511d30de589c18560eda1ada825845e2904d", "normalized_answer": "16" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a mouse, a pig, four fish, a donkey, a rabbit, a dog, three goats, a duck, and three chickens. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a mouse a pig four fish a donkey a rabbit a dog three goats a duck and three chickens how many animals do i have answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 16.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6753.84, "reasoner_ms": 1526.24, "tts_ms": 21.3, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8301.41, "total_processing_ms": 8793.49 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 788, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 32 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "7e15f3816bbb7f8232229f8239c4150195be429fac7a0bbae8f71a2eb9b69c4b", "started_sha256": "c50e7cc1129e215e81f11500edbf566aaf0067579ef0c0c093722de5c16e023b", "original_grade_sha256": "569f13f84f9891fc7ef8f15fa5fe78bea0aa738156e31b8f039ead0b296ff522", "input_original_sha256": "7e15f3816bbb7f8232229f8239c4150195be429fac7a0bbae8f71a2eb9b69c4b", "input_wav_sha256": "1c0965f94728af256d62b6a68722704676a9e45ec09d8cb71ed0952d0480e799", "input_pcm_sha256": "3243190ba052cd2c0a9ebdecf7ed91fae4f4134e45cc2d3eea963c970da6f6d5", "output_wav_sha256": "5cb039d1756dd5f225cbe4596d705b0cd7963cb327aa1a69fe8b709dfe7794e1", "output_pcm_sha256": "25264a99b43d8473666ed155e81cf40f803cb956767759cf8498d8f30e559e50", "result_sha256": "86b6b932810d072d04d20e5058cb542f1be9846870fd6bfad488f50363cbd4fd" } }, { "id": 957, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "61822acca9bb79a657b35ddb3b14ce738550c65a88df44b4278dfbc1c66e9e6b", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "61822acca9bb79a657b35ddb3b14ce738550c65a88df44b4278dfbc1c66e9e6b", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Shonda tells the truth. Delbert says Shonda tells the truth. Bernita says Delbert lies. Yolande says Bernita tells the truth. Christie says Yolande tells the truth. Does Christie tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Shonda tells the truth. Delbert says Shonda tells the truth. Bernita says Delbert lies. Yolande says Bernita tells the truth. Christy says Yolande tells the truth. Does Christy tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5353.19, "reasoner_ms": 2214.89, "tts_ms": 18.66, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7586.77, "total_processing_ms": 8042.71 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 848, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 122 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2921029d0c9d68998c2293ebd35410368b23a8581afd517aa705cb6ab230b4df", "started_sha256": "ef996261aec90cea21f6b860350c8fc7da90ee97a0a7f55ea44e2480ea82227b", "original_grade_sha256": "e49a4cdaad28e02c21621be82af4b52b473268e3660c1ddcb47e9b89b942b00a", "input_original_sha256": "2921029d0c9d68998c2293ebd35410368b23a8581afd517aa705cb6ab230b4df", "input_wav_sha256": "b528ca2fe336ec3c19c1d34316f14216ea7ec8f5162cb237c09ab178752013b1", "input_pcm_sha256": "4d6b7fcc3bd411d1a38f03160b7c2277a8a66e0298299622cf4e65ef986e7350", "output_wav_sha256": "ca710f330ce45e3748d0bc9b19b93d3621ccf902cbfcf2ddf335c5fdad929c67", "output_pcm_sha256": "5005f56c3a45d5d4c4e624f089fec75200ec8e9427d073dd78eef0f072e877c3", "result_sha256": "24d4676a304e5ff93dfe18e36cfe48a7accf712c4061d28cf05f7f809e056697" } }, { "id": 209, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "fd2e07a214652be0a73cc4479981c905a7d9473856d2b79e9ab20197565c1455", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "fd2e07a214652be0a73cc4479981c905a7d9473856d2b79e9ab20197565c1455", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To start with, being a regular consumer of Lever soap is necessary for being a frequent consumer of Nubian Heritage soap. Now, every regular consumer of Lever soap is not a regular user of Biolage shampoo or not a loyal buyer of Lush soap. We may conclude everyone who is a frequent consumer of Nubian Heritage soap is also a loyal buyer of Lush soap and a regular user of Biolage shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones, or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations, to start with, being a regular consumer of lever soap is necessary for being a frequent consumer of Nubian heritage soap. Now, every regular consumer of lever soap is not a regular user of biolid shampoo or not a loyal buyer of lush soap. We may conclude, everyone who is a frequent and consumer of Nubian heritage soap is also a loyal buyer of Lush soap and a regular user of BioLid shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options? Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12581.72, "reasoner_ms": 2871.34, "tts_ms": 28.98, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15482.06, "total_processing_ms": 15984.68 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1048, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 141 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ff94daa52698a6fc2f0c1737e039b3cf0f1c27df4806530594ba0bf58379d247", "started_sha256": "fbf1a4f823973c41dd168d769fd1740c77cabb289fe8702432ed614d4a1d74d2", "original_grade_sha256": "7795db4521cde32e67ad08f89ccb83142f4b32d90f53492f37b130014970ef4c", "input_original_sha256": "ff94daa52698a6fc2f0c1737e039b3cf0f1c27df4806530594ba0bf58379d247", "input_wav_sha256": "da8a341bf1d20a901bd9dcfa47c65d6da8319e74c2da6203fda2eed128257377", "input_pcm_sha256": "af6ceb3437be6f519ae737d7383df484268874eb24c47a31223b4a2017a27bc6", "output_wav_sha256": "e25ded468b3ed841ff4535047e8d839d1645caf17fd1d5ad4d8078649ef745d7", "output_pcm_sha256": "c6cb39e429503514c6c3ae8adddbf689f85dc85fdd94fac0cd6e29e526ef0c26", "result_sha256": "0aba43e8fad74138afccb512a068cf9885c912487a3e1e71702d25d266e89cdb" } }, { "id": 482, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3a2478a8f3429796a1de1b7107517c721c50d7e2496f4c25e1ebe6ba84ffd3bd", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3a2478a8f3429796a1de1b7107517c721c50d7e2496f4c25e1ebe6ba84ffd3bd", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take seven steps. Turn around. Turn around. Turn around. Take one step. Take six steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take seven steps. Turn around. Turn around. Turn around. Take one step. Take six steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5486.22, "reasoner_ms": 2466.62, "tts_ms": 19.44, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7972.3, "total_processing_ms": 8556.2 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 808, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 99 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8a341012a1b6172a0e7c1a361329a31c0c21ca4a2d2a3fa318e097d18a0d3be6", "started_sha256": "4a54ae30eeb0c9801711bd7fa97baf4b2f3bf27965f3e303ddcaab8e2a7f894b", "original_grade_sha256": "c6fd8d57f34fab7e83c412c70cc18013e525a3235d30fb6b2eb86fd261172e5c", "input_original_sha256": "8a341012a1b6172a0e7c1a361329a31c0c21ca4a2d2a3fa318e097d18a0d3be6", "input_wav_sha256": "50e66583e4069e9909ebb4b396aa2898f9331fc1c8aa94e7be6a9167474e2747", "input_pcm_sha256": "ff95e5e695589b46b8a775301a31f06afcaa9a041c22527c5815f026a8e92049", "output_wav_sha256": "69ee0d2979d7b8c4269956d8ad5777cf8ae369648aa0eb21b50e0be747e055f3", "output_pcm_sha256": "e5be47cbf9e63b131bfb4b0fd2cf890f2b108c41c49bb822a0cb38ddd0d5f34b", "result_sha256": "9b8554201b3a69b0197fedffc13c4ac64d24277a5bcbb98264dcde26a484bdb0" } }, { "id": 544, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "7", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d5898e7c027cd31958b63d545790c05e9db5b41ff7f58c768961896ae3c7f8d1", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d5898e7c027cd31958b63d545790c05e9db5b41ff7f58c768961896ae3c7f8d1", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a fridge, an oven, a car, a toaster, a microwave, a table, and a bed. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a fridge, an oven, a car, a toaster, a microwave, a table, and a bed. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 7.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4349.33, "reasoner_ms": 1499.16, "tts_ms": 26.53, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5875.05, "total_processing_ms": 6476.35 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 768, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 37 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6a517b4c3fb21dac9236051fee9758c7b880dfa23db1e44b7961ed75d93a3d6f", "started_sha256": "6e797b99c40c382915ba17484ec3ffe727740f00fdfb3ff959dd485fcb8b2561", "original_grade_sha256": "73282f5814ccb9e661e645f1b0aac10e813e2bcf4b4a3616d80e901d5f88c30c", "input_original_sha256": "6a517b4c3fb21dac9236051fee9758c7b880dfa23db1e44b7961ed75d93a3d6f", "input_wav_sha256": "00bc116878ff34666eb90ff40c2d1c6e5fcd5a344b3a1924b6c9d3d0471ab713", "input_pcm_sha256": "ace49db7bee743bc83efa5522bf95e3f0a56479859f1cecccb5b85475bb50f41", "output_wav_sha256": "c94a6b3b876ef994f2b726a0fb9ce22ea3dd25f00ea767bd5446be27fbe76fd2", "output_pcm_sha256": "89eb4f990755a1d97d6ef9718597bec5ea53b076ec7d770d0418b32d01c0fc43", "result_sha256": "23d421338297e45dedc1b26e6cff9b7ae238686fc2af1057ab697f5b318d446b" } }, { "id": 936, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "566859135237376598823f794b22c532dca222a042c3722e1c16078d1c53e9c2", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "566859135237376598823f794b22c532dca222a042c3722e1c16078d1c53e9c2", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion, Rashida lies. Osvaldo says Rashida tells the truth. Sherry says Osvaldo tells the truth. Gwen says Sherry tells the truth. Jerry says Gwen lies. Does Jerry tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion Rashida lies. Osvaldo says Rashida tells the truth. Sherry says Osvaldo tells the truth. Gwen says Sherry tells the truth. Jerry says Gwen lies. Does Jerry tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5175.03, "reasoner_ms": 2079.2, "tts_ms": 23.29, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7277.55, "total_processing_ms": 7785.65 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 852, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 115 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2f08e9a64c0321a518862b2ab39d3d261631910b66e3253d1fe5ce96d313216d", "started_sha256": "43d54dec6d4b38d4772220d3ebd36a639b8c43fb4641ece72b21ea32adffd78c", "original_grade_sha256": "c48022d5dd9ba852c54397da0f4782728fdc5f87167942782d3773dcfc877c37", "input_original_sha256": "2f08e9a64c0321a518862b2ab39d3d261631910b66e3253d1fe5ce96d313216d", "input_wav_sha256": "38b7808a6985938981f44a406630fef92b8f385e792022a71b9740e3785e8ca7", "input_pcm_sha256": "2e3870176a5e14d96bbf7fc678c17eb887598918fa57821b797d54d47e0b343e", "output_wav_sha256": "67ab1c568af499a8a6b29b79cf86ba027a8c9717d6d82e23e7cb232abbcdae95", "output_pcm_sha256": "2397b03ce60d3cfb66ec4cd90e70f82e68314c26ed6da18920bdfd638514a6be", "result_sha256": "89649396bcfcc06b10aafdf370fa74f188c1d53bdc6120849b03f31604357e46" } }, { "id": 215, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5c9ebca26621a54d41eabc32fe1c28e2a16d3965e53e50f16699596ccdc356d3", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5c9ebca26621a54d41eabc32fe1c28e2a16d3965e53e50f16699596ccdc356d3", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, every ingredient of polar attraction is an ingredient of reel him in. Second, every ingredient of polar attraction is not an ingredient of reel him in or an ingredient of the dark side. It follows that being an ingredient of polar attraction is sufficient for being an ingredient of the dark side. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nhere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, every ingredient of polar attraction is an ingredient of real him-in. Second, every ingredient of polar attraction is not an ingredient of real him-in or an ingredient of the dark side. It follows that being an ingredient of polar attraction is sufficient for being an ingredient of the dark side. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7460.54, "reasoner_ms": 2902.25, "tts_ms": 18.47, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10381.28, "total_processing_ms": 10875.26 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 985, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 96 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "33acec8b7e0fc3c8679d4aaeb092617a76a3cec6afb56e33cb9145904e9cdb73", "started_sha256": "12d56647575d8c21856d5439f25efd5487266bf650e05acdb2d55c06bb1bdf69", "original_grade_sha256": "da900a435815c3aa494b39d37f9ab842aba07bc185a5594a8e5ac817b9a22564", "input_original_sha256": "33acec8b7e0fc3c8679d4aaeb092617a76a3cec6afb56e33cb9145904e9cdb73", "input_wav_sha256": "4b2034ee162be1b4b59ea6b212fa6b92881c7bef6eb3c7046c8a6e4a5026c123", "input_pcm_sha256": "d154d6343cd4c556d1b3cb6bce8c684443e35ed5cddcc262d348fda94dfbc39a", "output_wav_sha256": "4351bf2d2d58a9ab7ead80faa3ef502d097cf3731f89833108dc0c5e0bdf6962", "output_pcm_sha256": "2a838eb92dae96752c05811e2ada5ce74b83ecf8c19245d9e94b3675b5c065a5", "result_sha256": "d625b7cfd640d1426a12d75f7fc91899a32bef5d7164d7eb6123e81a0f1d2a34" } }, { "id": 292, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ca3c1ffff2c21214c9b948cfa3f3f78a55026682988969bb26d68801ca75980f", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ca3c1ffff2c21214c9b948cfa3f3f78a55026682988969bb26d68801ca75980f", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take seven steps left. Take two steps backward. Take seven steps backward. Take seven steps backward. Take three steps forward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point always face forward take seven steps left take two steps backward take seven steps backward take seven steps backward take three steps forward options yes no answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7573.92, "reasoner_ms": 2051.22, "tts_ms": 23.5, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9648.66, "total_processing_ms": 10161.4 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 818, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 51 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "7c101e602deb6cc8fd4108c38946afb610676618ba7736b857445dde0f70a0ec", "started_sha256": "6345f8806b1ebb653840990e665ac95e7683936b8f5f4db6ae35f1ce365b4b4f", "original_grade_sha256": "81413382f38384a5d83910db0ed44b5c4ffe35e952d5129bc25529e5d71bb275", "input_original_sha256": "7c101e602deb6cc8fd4108c38946afb610676618ba7736b857445dde0f70a0ec", "input_wav_sha256": "cd35de1351d516f4defb6a7c1af6f2c59f553db7f76376df99069d45e76540be", "input_pcm_sha256": "cecea77192ab4504d4de336fb345ca3abe795e9a04c0bea9f287405ae003e586", "output_wav_sha256": "4f8a7f2125e1dd353a46c760f4eed3f4598404d4090dc8a21b02d94e94786f8c", "output_pcm_sha256": "a6f08e31efbb72ecd713b65bb735ca5aa2f5ad25863506c30442bb387f833aa2", "result_sha256": "11b550ff590b14f7406673118260af59d09a5474f1186a55db6da9fffb1088ac" } }, { "id": 644, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "8", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f34b910ffcb67173a7f881c41305b466160b51865c17b5981305834f22078bea", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f34b910ffcb67173a7f881c41305b466160b51865c17b5981305834f22078bea", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a car, two apples, a banana, three nectarines, a table, an orange, a fridge, and a raspberry. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a car, two apples, a banana, three nectarines, a table, an orange, a fridge, and a raspberry. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 8.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4189.73, "reasoner_ms": 1783.68, "tts_ms": 19.86, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5993.29, "total_processing_ms": 6470.84 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 781, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 47 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3886042943ee11138d670c2d7fe661053ed9299f6e570e57f32795258598c60f", "started_sha256": "f81ddc3d1355a32a5a2d6b71d3d10ca068474bcfdd04de512cf0550bbb318247", "original_grade_sha256": "1a5dd9604cf5805df566e23419b20a8eba8f2097bdb906453743397950ff53f0", "input_original_sha256": "3886042943ee11138d670c2d7fe661053ed9299f6e570e57f32795258598c60f", "input_wav_sha256": "d456b9274dbaef76e5594f18fe79f19d62333e32593d22546122330c83d4e3aa", "input_pcm_sha256": "c980c9618e66f1c501c60f50b8c04285e04fa28f949ee8feb993dfd0a6573c5e", "output_wav_sha256": "63f9fa7a539683df2a8b9c0cf837fce37d3c0ee198cb9f0f97e3d50de304a5e5", "output_pcm_sha256": "74352c11ee471a04f6de711eb06c838475bf937d7cc862f4d337517f59f602a3", "result_sha256": "2936b8592d1279a389a956ec528a9f9b899d38e0624501240d7bad413c162b8c" } }, { "id": 809, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9b7b1d923069013eebb1a89c43d5cec4140b8131b148252612c79cce481c5b45", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9b7b1d923069013eebb1a89c43d5cec4140b8131b148252612c79cce481c5b45", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Carr tells the truth. Fletcher says Carr tells the truth. Maybelle says Fletcher lies. Loreen says Maybelle lies. Krista says Loreen tells the truth. Does Krista tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion ka tells the truth fletcher says ka tells the truth maybelle says fletcher lies lorene says maybelle lies christa says lorene tells the truth does christa tell the truth answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7433.87, "reasoner_ms": 2202.52, "tts_ms": 26.59, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9663.01, "total_processing_ms": 10190.96 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 832, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 119 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "de67b170d7dc24c9b2096b9f157d07b6d13baf3aac5fe8ef6c55e558c7d56b72", "started_sha256": "e3e4c0169172b3d09fdc08bf5619328f66f11f903aaa05d3f924dea2d70ce35e", "original_grade_sha256": "fe95b9398ace9146f099075d31a9c08625ca8f095d264cd42f0b427318d8a3ff", "input_original_sha256": "de67b170d7dc24c9b2096b9f157d07b6d13baf3aac5fe8ef6c55e558c7d56b72", "input_wav_sha256": "649fe9d562972f9a469007bd2bb17668167f57904b34a2dca57cda5e834c43f2", "input_pcm_sha256": "3f220c770457dfa720baa5eb76d29664cec2ae765e0da833415ba05f3723ea45", "output_wav_sha256": "66c92032a8739b2b29eaa12a4de37b8e2bf21542f7caf91dd8ce02bd4851efb2", "output_pcm_sha256": "34106e1d7993ebe954256c51a9d4145f89afd3dab7f9cf064b2e2b634ceabdde", "result_sha256": "cfba859da9ad08957ed294a4d0d44c01ec1b7baee8ad2cd19934b4970a1c72eb" } }, { "id": 107, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "772866c8bdf7226a7b4e118fa905e11b6192460ec8a5bc8959c01a4d52863572", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "772866c8bdf7226a7b4e118fa905e11b6192460ec8a5bc8959c01a4d52863572", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, every son of Hugh is not a great-grandfather of Vernon and not a nephew of Forest. Therefore, no nephew of Forest and no great-grandfather of Vernon is a son of Hugh. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nhere comes a perfectly valid argument first every son of hugh is not a great-grandfather of vernon and not a nephew of forrest therefore no nephew of forrest and no great-grandfather of vernon is a son of hugh is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8608.83, "reasoner_ms": 4340.63, "tts_ms": 27.7, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 12977.19, "total_processing_ms": 13507.48 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 821, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 320 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f09c841b9286a15c67ff0c79d91465dc857a98d6a1ff028ce5346138e00c5096", "started_sha256": "ac39dc901741a99b46113a8b7ab3c328ee5292efad3403d1dc3a715a0f84493b", "original_grade_sha256": "bc4f04a7c007c3693f6c61b3609a58bc58358c9715e6a7aeda7c5cf6f5b1a2e0", "input_original_sha256": "f09c841b9286a15c67ff0c79d91465dc857a98d6a1ff028ce5346138e00c5096", "input_wav_sha256": "5c7ff2cc93c797af273e8592620f2d2ec43352011cc379ae36b451940d8acf87", "input_pcm_sha256": "fe1791e43952b9c4b3d79d67dbf3cb55332611362307abbebe905c88d964ae01", "output_wav_sha256": "7344bce9d721a3917c6101a4283027ffa2f513f98b66628b14a1065c9842ae4c", "output_pcm_sha256": "6e30c8b4c3456348c40b08ce77505364f1a6c987d9ce0e1a10cab9bd74029311", "result_sha256": "4aecf3a1724b0d3d93bd812bdf48072569df3b4dd0b0268d897f6ecc079de319" } }, { "id": 477, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "08b2660872b2c1818abbe343dc655df39d0cf19a6a7a132848384b90e68c5eb8", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "08b2660872b2c1818abbe343dc655df39d0cf19a6a7a132848384b90e68c5eb8", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn right, take five steps, turn around, take five steps, turn around. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn right, take five steps, turn around, take five steps, turn around. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4477.29, "reasoner_ms": 1911.26, "tts_ms": 20.23, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6408.8, "total_processing_ms": 6887.9 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 786, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 51 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "83c3bace0c9595fc7eedf6c00ade9d6cf5aabb3d89f3740f9a1301fe2957aece", "started_sha256": "b52c58ac07bdcf118e100cd7938c559e18e2b088331e9c2aa6afb51c26fde955", "original_grade_sha256": "7af1021240606c84d56c42b4a35628ec7bcaae0f9c6eb22c855f6abd6530c7cf", "input_original_sha256": "83c3bace0c9595fc7eedf6c00ade9d6cf5aabb3d89f3740f9a1301fe2957aece", "input_wav_sha256": "105c1beb882d1f27548bdfc06dc28a724b19efdab40dad52c631bfb82e2c9980", "input_pcm_sha256": "f78e42e65ce6f0a4ff9d0b1eb0294fa497d65157795b6c9cfdfea06cf004b13f", "output_wav_sha256": "f9f38a40f1a9386b8e5d07736d702c68e6039ee9b55b8b9e3f6e2eacf7972dfe", "output_pcm_sha256": "f9f09a3bbb4a7a1a2ce5c7a349de02413781c0d3ea1cdc240bf1eff2d5fb947b", "result_sha256": "d60b9ff3b2051ac30c5ce1fe2165632cbb8c2098a521c545ae04981131023265" } }, { "id": 737, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "12", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "eeba827b763500815a48f0d2e74b8146fca2e3b2bc20d71cfd1953d330210855", "normalized_answer": "12" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "eeba827b763500815a48f0d2e74b8146fca2e3b2bc20d71cfd1953d330210855", "normalized_answer": "12" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have an onion, two carrots, two potatoes, a stalk of celery, a head of broccoli, a cauliflower, a cabbage, a lettuce head, a garlic, and a yam. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have an onion, two carrots, two potatoes, a stalk of celery, a head of broccoli, a cauliflower, a cabbage, a lettuce head, a garlic, and a yam. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 12.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5078.07, "reasoner_ms": 2222.88, "tts_ms": 23.22, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7324.2, "total_processing_ms": 7835.59 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 833, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 100 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5fb036a5b47cd2fe885187f706d499a847e89f953b3f4e94979491c7d9abc96f", "started_sha256": "d9c523924c82e1755c4cb6800f79857cea383a566a95871af29fa80751e8c0a1", "original_grade_sha256": "43eda630483a6d7bba693648060dcc744dc6fb63778b0e27fb76227db798b654", "input_original_sha256": "5fb036a5b47cd2fe885187f706d499a847e89f953b3f4e94979491c7d9abc96f", "input_wav_sha256": "138482577c8035cddd8edee526e2a5591c0589551914078a0b24b5905e8a0750", "input_pcm_sha256": "3fe7f4a82cc6cdbfb491085768d1a6b2149e8571ac3b6208ab3251e214eb1533", "output_wav_sha256": "95c696c30fd98e1ded7e4d47e399fe01e4b594a8cd07987d534291fc50ca15eb", "output_pcm_sha256": "049b80309361c296854104fdcdc75f611a76a2f8623f66ccdfd153053ef77ec8", "result_sha256": "d3a3bfbdf14638bd7ac0ffe697cd96937f55085fd32aea0759460838125087f5" } }, { "id": 956, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7f5db9e539c35a35480169a473ea2986ed0c0489925bb67ee7949f249f3d311c", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7f5db9e539c35a35480169a473ea2986ed0c0489925bb67ee7949f249f3d311c", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Vernell lies. Conception says Vernell lies. Candy says Conception lies. Michael says Candy tells the truth. Osvaldo says Michael tells the truth. Does Osvaldo tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nVanell lies. Conception says Vanell lies. Candy says Conception lies. Michael says Candy tells the truth. Osvaldo says Michael tells the truth. Does Osvaldo tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5161.64, "reasoner_ms": 2276.22, "tts_ms": 23.19, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7461.07, "total_processing_ms": 7939.3 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 833, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 132 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d9f02c793f28e44f2622901084b72767dfcc389d13709d6034126ec6482cb67b", "started_sha256": "dba92d49596a9c3fe2e94579d51f631c4958bacfbd35ca08a06e8b11d41aed82", "original_grade_sha256": "bc602bc85b995d7fe56d7007f6090535192e821cc3d5f7fe07ad7d5ed0b5c09a", "input_original_sha256": "d9f02c793f28e44f2622901084b72767dfcc389d13709d6034126ec6482cb67b", "input_wav_sha256": "14236bb599e99c6a8caf9a037640420ab6dcb7422273ef4ba788ed890d7240cd", "input_pcm_sha256": "c7db6f5967419ddf6149925d27589cdb05dafd2f7f6c92d207c1aded33048605", "output_wav_sha256": "1dd9aa821ec2aaef71ae2761ec267de3826cb31d7f83611ffe85cd49fad11c46", "output_pcm_sha256": "518a6f392621a572bd1565718fa2e2b3e1a7f46fa9ccc3af2c9dfb28e239d573", "result_sha256": "d67220e45fa21ae3b4b3c223919ed988bf74d473cc2a4f02480d25cd84b88c14" } }, { "id": 78, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f324c068010632a089850cfd76aa569d230d77f5e608ff07188c36eaad7eb97c", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f324c068010632a089850cfd76aa569d230d77f5e608ff07188c36eaad7eb97c", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. Whoever is not a cousin of Andres is a workmate of Isaac. Nobody is neither a grandson of Reyes nor a workmate of Isaac. No stepbrother of Philip is both a grandson of Reyes and a cousin of Andres. Therefore, being a workmate of Isaac is necessary for being a stepbrother of Philip. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. Whoever is not a cousin of Andres is a workmate of Isaac. Nobody is neither a grandson of Reyes nor a workmate of Isaac. No stepbrother of Philip is both a grandson of Reyes and a cousin of Andres. Therefore, being a workmate of Isaac is necessary for being a stepbrother of Philip. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid, options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9868.31, "reasoner_ms": 5137.56, "tts_ms": 22.92, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15028.82, "total_processing_ms": 15521.48 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1022, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 339 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "cc84a272ed2c9e3e5fd07db0a8e4de88c505c8185eb611c8ac3502a5db95d29e", "started_sha256": "677548143666c672d4ce342a910b431f8bb6d8496d89201b839a8ca5d8b22c82", "original_grade_sha256": "0c59894377f213292a1d1144e6f2a5d1751a3aa521ce1d3c95b5d4676217a6af", "input_original_sha256": "cc84a272ed2c9e3e5fd07db0a8e4de88c505c8185eb611c8ac3502a5db95d29e", "input_wav_sha256": "115f39c878d422148f50956bca6d3594ed36d1b12cef6423270c02d547f0447d", "input_pcm_sha256": "c58dc62fe2e5be5b53909ee0d6e1655c86b38e8c6a0d1d05ca43f22dfdedfddc", "output_wav_sha256": "2193d34163499953a9c398d84c74476ff0450b416b026f2ba1d4009fc3ae7d64", "output_pcm_sha256": "0d2a0acc4b514ef317bd8b485e50608cc49aae5dac363b63effaaaafb6a9fd5d", "result_sha256": "ee7d113ce2148ffac6f2a2524f788c049250038339f2c237c35a80e8d936cd63" } }, { "id": 250, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "abef504699e856bcf5374173948151aafb00bfe6e0091d871faa7ff4b22d4454", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "abef504699e856bcf5374173948151aafb00bfe6e0091d871faa7ff4b22d4454", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take one step backward. Take nine steps left. Take two steps backward. Take six steps forward. Take four steps forward. Take four steps backward. Take three steps right. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take one step backward. Take nine steps left. Take two steps backward. Take six steps forward. Take four steps forward. Take four steps backward. Take three steps right. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6955.37, "reasoner_ms": 2004.51, "tts_ms": 23.02, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8982.93, "total_processing_ms": 9481.37 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 860, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 77 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "09a52d46ef0ceda59c83d5c537f96dc7ef2763a5281aac2b61e81ec7293235cf", "started_sha256": "85dbb83c0d3a1ab59d6aa388908b2414e4584fb3855be1e3a7ee7b846e26497d", "original_grade_sha256": "5ad619617d717138b7961f4fbd1bdb374e4d5ddb23e9ce61070a70fbcb745ab0", "input_original_sha256": "09a52d46ef0ceda59c83d5c537f96dc7ef2763a5281aac2b61e81ec7293235cf", "input_wav_sha256": "5aae60f0268e7d315270c917802293de2b68f7ca90b4b8945ab6945017c7e3db", "input_pcm_sha256": "6dcf0c5c24b5fd0f90699ef329c6a30c8a5603435878e47da7250ca3da2454d1", "output_wav_sha256": "73bc81ba54714f0ac4280af173f2ab6bb916376ac08ae47e94ab27b7e3881ac9", "output_pcm_sha256": "cdb867851eae6817a6dba5f8337646678f1662b3bfa286483256bd2ef8f10518", "result_sha256": "00085275c547cabf08d4507a63ec6e89c348f781e506597a7b39dee812de5250" } }, { "id": 705, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "6", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3c9038856ae4cdb3d9093e47064c94757ada23ed949109dfd9b42cd6d3bd8b4c", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3c9038856ae4cdb3d9093e47064c94757ada23ed949109dfd9b42cd6d3bd8b4c", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a grape, a plum, two blackberries, a raspberry, and a banana. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a grape, a plum, two blackberries, a raspberry, and a banana. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 6.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 3842.34, "reasoner_ms": 1961.29, "tts_ms": 26.04, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5829.7, "total_processing_ms": 6353.18 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 759, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 22 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6ef11a8e6848fe916d53c9b5f0f96a60f9dcf067dc6e0b00c17c3121c931bd41", "started_sha256": "2d8704186452990588b8961017431e2ae7bbc3108e206d48497a73ed9ad111db", "original_grade_sha256": "1b13d9b6b1cf91ffbdb49961e859965a84416b21867d8caf0fb4747b1f90bec9", "input_original_sha256": "6ef11a8e6848fe916d53c9b5f0f96a60f9dcf067dc6e0b00c17c3121c931bd41", "input_wav_sha256": "2b68f1c3bc7bdb61ef1a061bc68cb57dab387d79eaca8e9b608d922eaa2f7ce7", "input_pcm_sha256": "6f8012fa178bccc8ae66b748c436d25d86f20d8cc92e6c1af84c7aeed22cbc1b", "output_wav_sha256": "a0237ecbed47d3d3bdc0c14be04371c62460d24da3197e9f491e02712c31cf46", "output_pcm_sha256": "8666572d2f1bab1c943f350cb181821d39d5c605367e4573bd1c9618fa79b27b", "result_sha256": "0164152c292740b9d85148d8020ec7ed859a8bfd47e99e67104ae9260a73cd01" } }, { "id": 771, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a4bd0f5f16f20344a8598c019c85f3fe76d0d3b6bc882c77293b2b3bbb59a274", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a4bd0f5f16f20344a8598c019c85f3fe76d0d3b6bc882c77293b2b3bbb59a274", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Ryan tells the truth. Sal says Ryan tells the truth. Lida says Sal tells the truth. Rashida says Lida tells the truth. Alejandro says Rashida tells the truth. Does Alejandro tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Ryan tells the truth. Sal says Ryan tells the truth. Lida says Sal tells the truth. Rashida says Lida tells the truth. Alejandro says Rashida tells the truth. Does Alejandro tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5469.62, "reasoner_ms": 1867.51, "tts_ms": 22.21, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7359.37, "total_processing_ms": 7905.83 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 853, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 75 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a7d75d11de8ef166243b190b5845222f014be0b73d35ce477ec485e1079f3a2b", "started_sha256": "de5977faebfe32eecb11c16ddb4dc05868ff5b1e40fa0613fc094daca4864dbb", "original_grade_sha256": "23b9310981c9d6b8da4307f935c95a1700fd4c5bb8aea84c674246f777daaa03", "input_original_sha256": "a7d75d11de8ef166243b190b5845222f014be0b73d35ce477ec485e1079f3a2b", "input_wav_sha256": "a487ed86549678e8e8c4cd3afa6b1eab278bd3018d246ea6ace57357253c5977", "input_pcm_sha256": "8e67a23cbb8b25fd70f44e8e0f45e8d7707835dbe3d05f5b8ec0227af5332c4e", "output_wav_sha256": "fe2a0319cfe5cc3ac90cd76d12b151b831580d1e555d45959403fba641a395dd", "output_pcm_sha256": "f6ff4558c8019e50fb282b5d6dc8ff29c0320ee76ce273125e99ffdbeb7df6ae", "result_sha256": "368493deeec59920514c88b2587d16afd1fc8d1c02498610db0fc50cd2ff40b0" } }, { "id": 197, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "beb980833b84080268a9355c3d4512500163b25678dcf65971f1266644d18bec", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "beb980833b84080268a9355c3d4512500163b25678dcf65971f1266644d18bec", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, every ingredient of Bare Beige is an ingredient of Diamond Extreme Eye. Moreover, whatever is an ingredient of Lip Liner 0103-05 and an ingredient of Anti-Aging Eye Lift is also an ingredient of Bare Beige. It follows that every ingredient of Anti-Aging Eye Lift that is an ingredient of Lip Liner 0103-05 is also an ingredient of Diamond Extreme Eye. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, every ingredient of Bare Beige is an ingredient of Diamond Extreme Eye. Moreover, whatever is an ingredient of Lip Liner 01-03-05 and an ingredient of Anti-Aging Eye Lift is also an ingredient of Bare Beige.it follows that every ingredient of Anti-Aging Eye Lift that is an ingredient of Lip Liner 01-03-05 is also an ingredient of Diamond Extreme Eye. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid. Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12500.58, "reasoner_ms": 2512.08, "tts_ms": 30.75, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15043.44, "total_processing_ms": 15741.99 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1023, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 114 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "fe93b5e1d8e6d314dd6f96d715b19f6a384cd458f385b237e986b0616e6b72ff", "started_sha256": "2e1883620b3b93778239bcf064a727624fec2b91c2f0f2850ad30bdc91891426", "original_grade_sha256": "9a496caff9284aa14cd5e8e01b4541a99d70b9393a66f9164c483c850105b070", "input_original_sha256": "fe93b5e1d8e6d314dd6f96d715b19f6a384cd458f385b237e986b0616e6b72ff", "input_wav_sha256": "84cc6c02846e9defaaea07ef283d042a91a86a6b49b89607408f346edbb6606d", "input_pcm_sha256": "84165c7a24743cbe5e94764a24fa094dc7312de694ad19415d3dfe444d3a53b7", "output_wav_sha256": "ce3e24fc157f950e829748218e28d99ff8bb65cfaddee7950f2e272456fabc68", "output_pcm_sha256": "612ea00a9f3fcf0c3de5bd67c00d6bde8a2c2725cd28fe297f1ab9b4008106a3", "result_sha256": "fe42a2f746a46b84ba1fe7b80ec00d77ea71795330eefeb3dc98f2f67da936a0" } }, { "id": 266, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ed1a68bdcf58d8ea41146e4872065cd67b3fb940feb3a3fa716d205f8ae1c1fc", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ed1a68bdcf58d8ea41146e4872065cd67b3fb940feb3a3fa716d205f8ae1c1fc", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps forward. Take one step backward. Take four steps backward. Take four steps backward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps forward. Take one step backward. Take four steps backward. Take four steps backward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5830.08, "reasoner_ms": 3671.17, "tts_ms": 26.79, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9528.07, "total_processing_ms": 10167.77 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 817, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 47 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "4811646a9ba9d9ac78f3b023ceb973d13f43d9f566757996a7adebbefd54ed3b", "started_sha256": "cecf03d99b4f0cc25c563bfdd235f8c50ce3f9d53b399d2c396077ecbf355dd0", "original_grade_sha256": "613f1cff4fda5ed78930c993fc47771b40f9e553443511405482fcada5e620d3", "input_original_sha256": "4811646a9ba9d9ac78f3b023ceb973d13f43d9f566757996a7adebbefd54ed3b", "input_wav_sha256": "29e1bf4b5c21832c209f0a93a68e03d9e94755e18900f3e073a7061db3f74e29", "input_pcm_sha256": "12b313bf5a4aea6bb334d0592ef2e1c35296f7a6374d8dcac4575e62737bd2fe", "output_wav_sha256": "ca3c8fd354276c51484402f9e2f6492174d7553d1ed4df5f443b4b76497ad696", "output_pcm_sha256": "b026277bd5e84a14e8deb41cd9f744dd5bed4be445e7c184a1ece48b81845559", "result_sha256": "00d76998d91736d31542f71c82ccd916b113131f3784fc167857f942e85933b5" } }, { "id": 533, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "3", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a20f73d61772c177a30319fce43b984515950d54f545cea6e9a6e119a1133ea9", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a20f73d61772c177a30319fce43b984515950d54f545cea6e9a6e119a1133ea9", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have an orange, an apple, and a blackberry. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have an orange, an apple, and a blackberry. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 3.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4454.31, "reasoner_ms": 1584.63, "tts_ms": 25.71, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6064.66, "total_processing_ms": 6513.75 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 740, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 31 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "9bb5a8c7df7eecacaa6d5316e61e19fd0b500af0f7235ce80855a9dec7ea793a", "started_sha256": "25acd2ddc0912be76b405906c04e446d60f5cc694793d98d0fffaaba116e4ea4", "original_grade_sha256": "72ab7e198c53a970a2a65be8fe5c77ca7ba5b429e690b364c199eccc444f418a", "input_original_sha256": "9bb5a8c7df7eecacaa6d5316e61e19fd0b500af0f7235ce80855a9dec7ea793a", "input_wav_sha256": "0ca0601e9dcdb0ed125d693b439b5e465924df08e6933704614f3f0f91ed394a", "input_pcm_sha256": "daf768575a08eb369d63c9110a005002ef3c57e6a169165107db5290d8962f37", "output_wav_sha256": "97789c249cbd7de2bbc3a704eef5e2d5274c50f79053a2d82eb6677dfa927912", "output_pcm_sha256": "0739d62ed7160192dfff706bb004cdb954a10cfd4150a2be29e69aabf7722b14", "result_sha256": "31a33013db0e327342231ccd02ce4fb132550f6d737294647b1b147319aa7b47" } }, { "id": 829, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d8b9ab22198c2804c28845d8322c3bf2da079bc16e8779d97e9f62e21d42feec", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d8b9ab22198c2804c28845d8322c3bf2da079bc16e8779d97e9f62e21d42feec", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Christian tells the truth. Dallas says Christian tells the truth. Osvaldo says Dallas lies. Millie says Osvaldo tells the truth. Vena says Millie tells the truth. Does Vena tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Christian tells the truth. Dallas says Christian tells the truth. Osvaldo says Dallas lies. Millie says Osvaldo tells the truth. Vina says Millie tells the truth. Does Vina tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5171.57, "reasoner_ms": 2519.43, "tts_ms": 24.83, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7715.86, "total_processing_ms": 8310.15 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 847, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 119 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "de3fad8654eda3a0ca295c95c4120184b284e31ce5a1ecf2da88ecc8acd57056", "started_sha256": "2b653b5508cacca9de080b9a8f18f13928c4d4829a0199159f47e6991a1c213d", "original_grade_sha256": "76dcd7bcd4597c446edf3f8a1a296e9c74d1782b3c296ac656730caad8647860", "input_original_sha256": "de3fad8654eda3a0ca295c95c4120184b284e31ce5a1ecf2da88ecc8acd57056", "input_wav_sha256": "fcde4cf8ba857831a1d506f2eeeafb349cfc9fdce575d23c9c45e76f7b87965a", "input_pcm_sha256": "1454bfb4d5637acf7cf84bc9c4204165297adba4075f79a277ce20dea04b5bd8", "output_wav_sha256": "29f316cb253c46b6c7c577aaad5e5df6784b8bfcba5bb63fe2d4cb648ad3720f", "output_pcm_sha256": "906388f44833878be2a7eeb9fbf60fdf898bab05089b61128510ba65fa1c9afd", "result_sha256": "9987a2ea102d884c8ed1ba74c9c2dd86d9b37f19fc58152e08c8479b3e35dc49" } }, { "id": 221, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3e83f50ee7af02eb3f8705e428b7f3a17bd86e1eec76499c83fbc8823829479e", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3e83f50ee7af02eb3f8705e428b7f3a17bd86e1eec76499c83fbc8823829479e", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs titanium oxide an ingredient of my washing power? Which chemicals does my perfume contain? It is really difficult to keep track of all chemicals one is regularly exposed to. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. Every ingredient of custom blend powder is an ingredient of gold dust or an ingredient of Parisian chic. Whatever is an ingredient of Parisian chic is not an ingredient of custom blend powder. In consequence, every ingredient of custom blend powder is an ingredient of gold dust. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs titanium oxide an ingredient of my washing power? Which chemicals does my perfume contain? It is really difficult to keep track of all chemicals one is regularly exposed to. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. Every ingredient of custom blend powder is an ingredient of gold dust or an ingredient of Parisian chic. Whatever is an ingredient of Parisian chic is not an ingredient of custom blend powder. In consequence, every ingredient of custom blend powder is an ingredient of gold dust. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11589.93, "reasoner_ms": 3071.22, "tts_ms": 24.84, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 14686.02, "total_processing_ms": 15285.16 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1107, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 117 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b4a3de5bf71e54d5531679891f6ab07cd13fab5357037efe91882046bb710af6", "started_sha256": "92e77e159374ff48eb4a0616988ae8b4fa580bc679abead77240f42c9ed2c688", "original_grade_sha256": "764e4e1c3f2ebf223db7a6bf64f00da6d2fb2ad489e6125604c497fdb208e7cb", "input_original_sha256": "b4a3de5bf71e54d5531679891f6ab07cd13fab5357037efe91882046bb710af6", "input_wav_sha256": "2231c09da6be4beae25f680017460b176810b718b109324e2ab73ec04378d6c0", "input_pcm_sha256": "a30eeabdc5307d3c76aaaf40b90970feb808e36822e5385bda525175f2ec0068", "output_wav_sha256": "7df03fea2966095038ca7b4bf7ccd326f2ca6e16bd1458b89a73725c586e6ffc", "output_pcm_sha256": "5f5e1d72dc9e2928414927409489c23ee4ebd7eb24bf1bf1c5a40ad7defdc84f", "result_sha256": "04ad78ce897ccf233b24a4f14b2278b1a7bd1ec0ef8a7b366eabfac207928e34" } }, { "id": 420, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0ac66ba8310880dbdc1e6a8c81cee9383df794c2a2e365721fee5551291af706", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0ac66ba8310880dbdc1e6a8c81cee9383df794c2a2e365721fee5551291af706", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn right. Take ten steps. Turn around. Take ten steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn right. Take 10 steps. Turn around. Take 10 steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5303.52, "reasoner_ms": 1681.66, "tts_ms": 24.67, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7009.87, "total_processing_ms": 7552.97 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 791, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 44 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1c0f8d3954bba698d7dcc282bb4f93bbc7bbbe604c6de802066299af3ef032a2", "started_sha256": "a88fe8bc684b750d9a20f5990d06c6155f7f7e1926c4b58b32928754a3e24ee0", "original_grade_sha256": "091fd64e304e6803be5876474b67ff3778c092ac7df951faf9c867ffd1800e68", "input_original_sha256": "1c0f8d3954bba698d7dcc282bb4f93bbc7bbbe604c6de802066299af3ef032a2", "input_wav_sha256": "cb81b71933c7e120ee0a67434e80f95a6ea8dbc32b1a2ab8937ddb2a0776fa9e", "input_pcm_sha256": "315a9f07f6fa28bcd741aa666b9cb7173a058015649e1f83b56c480fe130dc48", "output_wav_sha256": "e4e89000951405584635be9d15a21cc2dd66f0d5985758a86266d2423a0a013c", "output_pcm_sha256": "9d7e9749320df251ce981d50481851d02acbeedfb41b40df689464f5268da0e4", "result_sha256": "b114308bf0803cc99d2d720c334ba4bd00be04d37290d8025689cd6ab8acca58" } }, { "id": 684, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "6", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4b66dda686bab0a5e85f3157467189d0cd91972aa9b9c89555d0c7af569ff234", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4b66dda686bab0a5e85f3157467189d0cd91972aa9b9c89555d0c7af569ff234", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have two violins, a drum, a flute, a trumpet, and a clarinet. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have two violins, a drum, a flute, a trumpet, and a clarinet. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 6.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4069.23, "reasoner_ms": 2410.17, "tts_ms": 21.22, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6500.65, "total_processing_ms": 7022.34 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 764, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 47 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b0480ff6af0c289978f1fdfc01b1d867809adf25dae9cde49cba5b40b2655abf", "started_sha256": "3e3594a13fd62b299bf959527a89cc6d6b7fc897fd0631a64d7b691776b26804", "original_grade_sha256": "b2f95cd09486719bcff45abd324a57956121f1a549927b12d994f0dc943cf508", "input_original_sha256": "b0480ff6af0c289978f1fdfc01b1d867809adf25dae9cde49cba5b40b2655abf", "input_wav_sha256": "4ce8d325137d99949b047cd054e56faff875709cd4677894913ff4ea5dd6fa2d", "input_pcm_sha256": "5c006fa03682b4a1301700ccb1850091eb6354f8ee45398e0dbaa8320be65cfd", "output_wav_sha256": "21961a4493a525a586e4217c6cd706beae325db93424b2bf365c3a91ddb863c8", "output_pcm_sha256": "99ed46d1dbd2bca6838e0dac79ef220670e504eef0732db38c4e81fa5ef1ae6e", "result_sha256": "eac36757f1e68536a7c3a877ba003c684893882037b0a6adc8ccfcfdef5bcca5" } }, { "id": 879, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "348f4d056fc4adb25e8f7b5ca1a6f19d56c8cea850fcef5ae424b6cedd1abc12", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "348f4d056fc4adb25e8f7b5ca1a6f19d56c8cea850fcef5ae424b6cedd1abc12", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Willian tells the truth. Michaela says Willian lies. Conception says Michaela lies. Inga says Conception tells the truth. Sal says Inga lies. Does Sal tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. William tells the truth. Michaela says William lies. Conception says Michaela lies. Inga says Conception tells the truth. Sal says Inga lies. Does Sal tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4815.08, "reasoner_ms": 2432.77, "tts_ms": 24.03, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7271.91, "total_processing_ms": 7846.11 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 819, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 119 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "44231763b70d5be1b5fe699efcd9bd536d609a2c4b0ac17da116e076ceb2ec01", "started_sha256": "5e65e363ef9d4f6dde1e24d2f39dbb8923ac83fec6de3f64de47185dad74789b", "original_grade_sha256": "788141a2e1c93238b49ecd2510154dace38b00c4363294488af34d5583e926d0", "input_original_sha256": "44231763b70d5be1b5fe699efcd9bd536d609a2c4b0ac17da116e076ceb2ec01", "input_wav_sha256": "e2328846ab5cc44149dbbc85404a89760f64db21eae8922117a515f0b8f0a836", "input_pcm_sha256": "717b5cc77fbaf9f448e9f1e55a535e1dc459eb7165a467b63dc45162f78e4f02", "output_wav_sha256": "dd043aaa510766d918a55b122261d2b868edc98d76923eb852f3b1453c7a3c13", "output_pcm_sha256": "fbeeabdf7b74475301e6b2be465867a02bb1b72f350f59c429195bb9fcd6dc31", "result_sha256": "36a002f393f484d5be6cd9c5dfbf59070ccb991440316ec2cf3778617ed49ba9" } }, { "id": 229, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "979027b0a36722c4e73f491317c80e94257d297c9ae3767c7790de65ef0b1be3", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "979027b0a36722c4e73f491317c80e94257d297c9ae3767c7790de65ef0b1be3", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Siri a stepsister of Mary? Is Susan related to Kate? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To start with, not being a niece of Shirley is sufficient for not being a workmate of Sharita. Now, everyone who is a stepsister of Nicole is a workmate of Sharita, too. We may conclude being a niece of Shirley is necessary for not being a stepsister of Nicole. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Siri a stepsister of Mary? Is Susan related to Kate? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations, to start with, not being a niece of Shirley is sufficient for not being a workmate of Sharita. Now, everyone who is a stepsister of Nicole is a workmate of Sharita, too. We may conclude, being a niece of Shirley is necessary for not being a stepsister of Nicole. coal. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12216.63, "reasoner_ms": 3847.51, "tts_ms": 30.11, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 16094.28, "total_processing_ms": 16665.5 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1090, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 226 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "bb29676c9b3ea1058009dbce14d27e30bda5574e04b9f952640b57e55a482306", "started_sha256": "22c6679ebbb2de5efc91484ab1504368dab10c8e4a6ae218f1c878fae4fdfe6e", "original_grade_sha256": "e6a57126622a708d4837fa22fb59147ab9624401427974416097a5a3bf147d50", "input_original_sha256": "bb29676c9b3ea1058009dbce14d27e30bda5574e04b9f952640b57e55a482306", "input_wav_sha256": "74f7e131059bfc73a38d77d2ced721cc97823f674157baa806ca2e7bceadbc63", "input_pcm_sha256": "95ee02d52a5ecacba5745043802aa4e3aedbcff7da95e057b8b678823c4dad12", "output_wav_sha256": "4aa8a426ffb5593d951ace97ffe2c177b56aec32b4f2792f84c2d0648b449da5", "output_pcm_sha256": "44097db47f80987394e45c17265cc883e4f36dda518c4ad45b79393a53565f04", "result_sha256": "356eae95e4d2395bf6f8435cc60c12b11c2b648b239caada66c89ed0b7332e9b" } }, { "id": 288, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ade0e25ad1d856aeaf8220dc92b2042deed72268b3ad9cd5095c0dcf467a0199", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ade0e25ad1d856aeaf8220dc92b2042deed72268b3ad9cd5095c0dcf467a0199", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take one step. Take five steps. Turn around, turn around, turn around. Take six steps. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point, take one step, take five steps, turn around, turn around, turn around, take six steps? Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5068.63, "reasoner_ms": 2241.1, "tts_ms": 22.44, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7332.2, "total_processing_ms": 7829.46 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 796, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 76 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "9679e3d2de9ad4acdd311c059dc90886b259cfc0dbed03c131895d651f4cbde5", "started_sha256": "f215257083dc8210b2c2b5d4428e837caf98412df998d7777576d94f41b35bda", "original_grade_sha256": "3d90c5bb0b6607ea877b3f56f18b4e9845e5512994e158a1e1c72c42dfcb1a44", "input_original_sha256": "9679e3d2de9ad4acdd311c059dc90886b259cfc0dbed03c131895d651f4cbde5", "input_wav_sha256": "e4e040c2959a3dc7e14511fdee8a1e2d441170ff3da338429540c90ca0f6b096", "input_pcm_sha256": "16a551432d6432060d7c2b6ac3e801023ae4547a82eb86dac44e32df3429426c", "output_wav_sha256": "5604d4bfc84838baaafd488e93435d336dd3d9deb52ef3a32086b5c0c72ecddf", "output_pcm_sha256": "c57f4d1f2ca103024aad51b7f386181d7e322cec1a3039f696d3e663255a7f83", "result_sha256": "f6ed831f7cc44240ed19096aa759818a88e5ff54345e590e96592bf1bb7c0a55" } }, { "id": 699, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2a0232c1403ae1c5a6ff29c48807fca4c111078e64055cd4d90e7d5debdc2b38", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2a0232c1403ae1c5a6ff29c48807fca4c111078e64055cd4d90e7d5debdc2b38", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a snail, a chair, a duck, a cat, a toaster, a fish, a chicken, two ovens, a cow, two mice, and a rabbit. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a snail, a chair, a duck, a cat, a toaster, a fish, a chicken, two ovens, a cow, two mice, and a rabbit. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 9.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5347.15, "reasoner_ms": 2394.6, "tts_ms": 19.91, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7761.69, "total_processing_ms": 8239.33 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 808, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 116 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "aff3195baed2b2548b38d016920a8bc1ae05880b62a18e7b10b5817798ce2d48", "started_sha256": "18a794d9b7362b5e2bb74553cd9590d7fd5f327c2044d0f34663d201fb4f80a8", "original_grade_sha256": "267ca1f0d58abccfb8529ac9572d925a2c1bb6c9481b0113216dfac5bca60561", "input_original_sha256": "aff3195baed2b2548b38d016920a8bc1ae05880b62a18e7b10b5817798ce2d48", "input_wav_sha256": "4cd4aec36dfa5e0048e79dc4f0444f36babd9c92831e9be6c3e15e2624d61043", "input_pcm_sha256": "9b6a2a9834c21da249189b4b905925127b7b487807594f5bdcae806c5e4dd1e5", "output_wav_sha256": "91f8433a0735e5703b8dcae9c2bc799bb3c76b7c62a3e67962d2f09c54533fab", "output_pcm_sha256": "ba60b6eb35a402a44faa420c58bdc993e901b2fa65b39dca861fb38c78c211aa", "result_sha256": "462ca084f19de31589a52800b09cd863f8a16030314c7404f02431e3cc2d9e32" } }, { "id": 759, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1f9b95dfa2dc75f7a8db1af146d4d78171b28f38652b2ea370070fd5c0b1f628", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1f9b95dfa2dc75f7a8db1af146d4d78171b28f38652b2ea370070fd5c0b1f628", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Rashida tells the truth. Jim says Rashida lies. Alejandro says Jim lies. Tamika says Alejandro tells the truth. Fidel says Tamika lies. Does Fidel tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Rashida tells the truth. Jim says Rashida lies. Alejandro says Jim lies. Tamika says Alejandro tells the truth. Fidel says Tamika lies. Does Fidel tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4935.06, "reasoner_ms": 2255.58, "tts_ms": 23.69, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7214.36, "total_processing_ms": 7753.75 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 839, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 113 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a44af41b37068c803c1e57d5ad8c8377a298d5929a572d9f9b3683bac1b4ae72", "started_sha256": "9d66de3b91347e36c84ff5e9fbdd51e0d4ce368120cb67b31364ebf9faf741da", "original_grade_sha256": "b6b8b1d2d62c9cc265c1ccbcb947fa56cbe553c73987231c872a3909f2088bd1", "input_original_sha256": "a44af41b37068c803c1e57d5ad8c8377a298d5929a572d9f9b3683bac1b4ae72", "input_wav_sha256": "4849def81774e46a585c582b43a5b2291c5511729534204a6a8b2e3bb07a12c1", "input_pcm_sha256": "b1712ef6bda9426768a65cb33dc8304ae31c8028691c3a61d8162afb9d33fd70", "output_wav_sha256": "f04b600fc2b9a4442275583c0d904fbb61dea0bee50c40148f7ebdca51d70346", "output_pcm_sha256": "3b4fd51f59ef08909246cd9b24d31a44e709835b4740a5e2a4a275e2f4b22150", "result_sha256": "12ed8a347ea1cf59dece06c546d249dae7876396fcf3f7b7be2f38be05565cd4" } }, { "id": 77, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e55a43088a6146884bfd9c964b685ca69b37e73056f1bb368be790a6fccbd8a2", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e55a43088a6146884bfd9c964b685ca69b37e73056f1bb368be790a6fccbd8a2", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a cousin of Robert? Is Joe related to Bob? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To start with, Darwin is a grandson of Dwayne. Now, whoever is not both a half-brother of Alvin and a grandson of Dwayne is an ancestor of Leslie. It follows that it is false that Darwin is an ancestor of Leslie. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Fred a cousin of Robert? Is Joe related to Bob? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To start with, Darwin is a grandson of DeWayne. Now, whoever is not both a half-brother of Alvin and a grandson of DeWayne is an ancestor of Leslie. It follows that it is false that Darwin is an ancestor of Leslie. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12205.68, "reasoner_ms": 3493.34, "tts_ms": 26.81, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15725.87, "total_processing_ms": 16411.35 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1068, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 265 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0afa1d37a08f755fbf66c7a683d993415eaa3125f284579952542ad3b0bd0f5a", "started_sha256": "72b033e350d258216ad5c029042a180285735c65ff5866eedeb205f1a69889cb", "original_grade_sha256": "f685ecfb167ab14e850e45b436de1eeda3a8330049832a5407973e462c86ebe5", "input_original_sha256": "0afa1d37a08f755fbf66c7a683d993415eaa3125f284579952542ad3b0bd0f5a", "input_wav_sha256": "1dd3f219cacbaa6f0a493c7f009631a650b1e674dc4418531ea7afaeee0e3391", "input_pcm_sha256": "4e253554e45639b7c30ba73c640e994f36b05cc4ae270bda698861301747429a", "output_wav_sha256": "abc87fa8b4656930b7ed92349b6f8f2e5b60176a41e80aec4396dfb1679a416a", "output_pcm_sha256": "d056b29a77ed8c33bf0cea403ac5fcf4763ca167de005936c933515932f6089e", "result_sha256": "c751e898beae98c98bca954126b8167be0a6fb794be4fd02dc034097aada13b3" } }, { "id": 457, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "632dee7f893c157e0732e38aee399171c0abcceaa9ed2528b9ce54e5ca1c5b26", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "632dee7f893c157e0732e38aee399171c0abcceaa9ed2528b9ce54e5ca1c5b26", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps. Turn around. Take eight steps. Take two steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point take six steps turn around take eight steps take two steps options yes no answer the question Question", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9526.86, "reasoner_ms": 4055.92, "tts_ms": 24.49, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 13607.3, "total_processing_ms": 14468.75 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 774, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 152 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2db37a2d04270a5c0924ce25b7d04c350b3c518583eddf21b4decb74edc768a6", "started_sha256": "2137a218d4832f065436c5f560d8e37014649a134835b2ffac721b943b2c24cc", "original_grade_sha256": "5d8d4c4559bc2a44cf07d78054e69ba7347036c09be9513dd44d563c89c92309", "input_original_sha256": "2db37a2d04270a5c0924ce25b7d04c350b3c518583eddf21b4decb74edc768a6", "input_wav_sha256": "ca0d4145075d19b56ac6996600031a771372977cecf9785fa98fec3db9b101b0", "input_pcm_sha256": "d19fa91c1b703d45ff4535b0275500de496b63ccf50020209f6896a29373f52e", "output_wav_sha256": "2bca732e1c35edbbed1a063f2da6ac91d74d090666b4249fae468db3f44f773b", "output_pcm_sha256": "329f37ca37cad01b2624982e55aeb4f44f6e43563eb50a08364053a4aae3aede", "result_sha256": "3b14efb60e4c6e52e9ff3d54e674bfae74dc586a968af3a7e0481029e014db6a" } }, { "id": 671, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "2", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0c6c507cf74a3cfc0787adf8b322823641a8e23bd0ed757c7afb625a7e51c276", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0c6c507cf74a3cfc0787adf8b322823641a8e23bd0ed757c7afb625a7e51c276", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a garlic and an onion. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a garlic and an onion. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 2.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4468.19, "reasoner_ms": 1613.08, "tts_ms": 22.91, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6104.2, "total_processing_ms": 6809.69 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 729, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "09b09bb62dd7816b6522633540301c96a9d33dd7d11ab357cfbb21d4f38a102c", "started_sha256": "54b6ab7a8fc076df6affaf8cf78f1c9b01d650f8a22fe6712fefe24b32964cb0", "original_grade_sha256": "aa671f519fd690e665c2b0165d0c5b68a248a6b3ab4075a1eacd668c638fe95b", "input_original_sha256": "09b09bb62dd7816b6522633540301c96a9d33dd7d11ab357cfbb21d4f38a102c", "input_wav_sha256": "ac86031a1db42477993d33341ba48423a370b2dfe3624c62e6521d018a55a318", "input_pcm_sha256": "adce3dd96b25a267ac106c285b41847567ac1c7fe0f270dcbafa99d3d6486df0", "output_wav_sha256": "aef98c8058da2748be2407bc471a540cd635c6d4acb5ba110431274aedb4c456", "output_pcm_sha256": "ee85e8af710f94756e1f2459478667d74892dbece5b735d9775d955a8f1d13fd", "result_sha256": "d12d737b6fd0fa507aa0b547b6e0ad0f526e9f9055427b6f16f48abc819f1941" } }, { "id": 751, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8f2fb9cc2a835dab2c341b758ac7b32dfd1eaeec4679ce49ea1877177edce0d9", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8f2fb9cc2a835dab2c341b758ac7b32dfd1eaeec4679ce49ea1877177edce0d9", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Christian lies. Sherry says Christian lies. Delbert says Sherry lies. Jerry says Delbert tells the truth. Shalonda says Jerry tells the truth. Does Shalonda tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Christian lies. Sherry says Christian lies. Delbert says Sherry lies. Jerry says Delbert tells the truth. Shalonda says Jerry tells the truth. Does Shalonda tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5723.17, "reasoner_ms": 2266.31, "tts_ms": 23.3, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8012.8, "total_processing_ms": 8747.14 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 839, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 132 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2a552a0226cad6ff58dcdd142880c5146db1a4ca0cdd691aebe07ec0aaf3cacf", "started_sha256": "3ccc712649565e5d29118672b5febdb14392a51ab7a006d9b602487b3abd05c2", "original_grade_sha256": "dda1722c3d8dac010f6d35614578ce5afbf3efbf7b8f0bc7776ba6f3f464b475", "input_original_sha256": "2a552a0226cad6ff58dcdd142880c5146db1a4ca0cdd691aebe07ec0aaf3cacf", "input_wav_sha256": "5e1d803b19920affb80f512a7d3b51137b5aa8d749e865d14cc1d70b115b9b84", "input_pcm_sha256": "ed93dfc94d5ff7831c35a993b881a490ec86d85c4ad7ac8859825029bb33cc78", "output_wav_sha256": "379213dad5575d3983ce69169c29ba9494846427173a45ba085acd014ead513a", "output_pcm_sha256": "59f4774826ea3f934f84025c34dac84f22839597d3df3208b182568a2a6ea4cc", "result_sha256": "0db1bbd6c103be0f34c497e859261ea16baee58c4032652192e826ccb34cafa2" } }, { "id": 41, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f99c7d6f93102d0418ec911131bd6ca9e71428513095090c89fdca016fcfccd9", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f99c7d6f93102d0418ec911131bd6ca9e71428513095090c89fdca016fcfccd9", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Siri a stepsister of Mary? Is Susan related to Kate? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To start with, everyone who is a schoolmate of Mildred is a daughter of Jeanette too. Now, being a daughter of Jeanette is sufficient for not being a cousin of Christy. Therefore, no schoolmate of Mildred is a cousin of Christy. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Siri a stepsister of Mary? Is Susan related to Kate? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To start with, everyone who is a schoolmate of Mildred is a daughter of Jeanette, too. Now, being a daughter of Jeanette is sufficient for not being a cousin of Christy. Therefore, no schoolmate of Mildred is a cousin of Christy. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13463.19, "reasoner_ms": 1872.14, "tts_ms": 29.16, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15364.52, "total_processing_ms": 16097.77 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 981, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 53 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a19da5a4c0640c7242f8fee6f8b521af4822697d5d3c7c755916f7764fcf2d0b", "started_sha256": "385e0f2c41b4789e3b7e070cb26d06eba9bcbeae9a1de256b7c875f8a60030fd", "original_grade_sha256": "6863c275958c008b89ef692285cae652ce4c849e42ad6733bd4e6f3ba169c1b6", "input_original_sha256": "a19da5a4c0640c7242f8fee6f8b521af4822697d5d3c7c755916f7764fcf2d0b", "input_wav_sha256": "945503a454067dd5d0765475871511c899c51448070123e2d7ce106898fd6545", "input_pcm_sha256": "9cfa13b62b13319ac6f36d9cf10dc722f8fd185b9960b6c918902863df41a214", "output_wav_sha256": "35d8dbc1e80aafe9cdb9c0e09e6e907a3326505d1b60b37545c6a7c51a4b33fe", "output_pcm_sha256": "3da356ac7018ba61a4c95390a6d6646f4c487902033b3f3ab794c97630c25327", "result_sha256": "6508afa363da2253e2f64ebc0606b27face396bee3f2a0efa1aaf54ecaeabbb1" } }, { "id": 445, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d67b13904f6b55d0c6516717412ca52806dc3be2a2f4880f61795dadd62c2008", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d67b13904f6b55d0c6516717412ca52806dc3be2a2f4880f61795dadd62c2008", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take one step. Take eight steps. Turn around. Take eight steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take one step. Take eight steps. Turn around. Take eight steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6109.44, "reasoner_ms": 1931.13, "tts_ms": 23.37, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8063.97, "total_processing_ms": 8762.06 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 789, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 62 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0ae1a8b9c3f72062b3a6fe2c8e19d7c843b4d2d7219aa90ed5cad7d790ab215b", "started_sha256": "9209dcd1778cee0c7a736a782de9a60625a899b268628ad689720f79cbd57a46", "original_grade_sha256": "53a43e24ba02e4736c01c4fd50df9488b7423c82302a7fef2781cdc3e28cb410", "input_original_sha256": "0ae1a8b9c3f72062b3a6fe2c8e19d7c843b4d2d7219aa90ed5cad7d790ab215b", "input_wav_sha256": "4df866dd2c72ec4266e55e7ffd954da3e0636929092726aa12a44a4f02159789", "input_pcm_sha256": "4f7a6a4d828b8d48e2f8f9762223896b87a9b3809efcf8c7505aeee091e1f44d", "output_wav_sha256": "5643d8d9376cb596fa83eb9a51aaadd6822136ab24d88c36d8cb050d0af5d6a2", "output_pcm_sha256": "d5710a79e5c540a21e595214b7745f4534852e6353101caeb6030acf7a4236bb", "result_sha256": "232a06314d63817573338b3c78d038cdc0efd396c780c1a95c210a9c004aba29" } }, { "id": 592, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "15", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4744404ea48c9028e3d9ff03e5844db023c16f64ca972efea935bba66c00399e", "normalized_answer": "15" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4744404ea48c9028e3d9ff03e5844db023c16f64ca972efea935bba66c00399e", "normalized_answer": "15" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a mouse, four snails, a chicken, a cat, three pigs, a snake, a fish, a goat, a bear, and a dog. How many animals do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a mouse, four snails, a chicken, a cat, three pigs, a snake, a fish, a goat, a bear, and a dog. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 15.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5441.54, "reasoner_ms": 1760.7, "tts_ms": 26.74, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7229.01, "total_processing_ms": 7915.51 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 795, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 89 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "df15db3d8cc2177b00aca4da2da9674bb3b8f034e469397b056081830c98d72d", "started_sha256": "b04446a72af79586dbf41bde34f4788da4b9881489ede8c036d441b1bf04b0b2", "original_grade_sha256": "4429bfccf297aca948803481675580653093a32e7600e32460fb858af543e5d0", "input_original_sha256": "df15db3d8cc2177b00aca4da2da9674bb3b8f034e469397b056081830c98d72d", "input_wav_sha256": "6abef268764e1844bb60891bf723812e44eddfb6d237cc62c40fd3aceff5e970", "input_pcm_sha256": "47f2869d1163fe7144e8eaf3bab4122afefc00827951946ffb2b66a4f40d0cee", "output_wav_sha256": "786125ed019899818aecd971740d8e14df41c11d4f1bd634ef4ca3f87e60af99", "output_pcm_sha256": "71e6534177f5aa3343f98eabed5ca91dbc372404292902ae24132657c5bfb92d", "result_sha256": "8b2d3e36ff7ad1456f8a9bbe8cf0f29aff506fdad36bc5d6372ce67cda00a6b3" } }, { "id": 974, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "32b92ea608c80630f48ec00da59b65635ea5bba57d4832e697bad775d139cb07", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "32b92ea608c80630f48ec00da59b65635ea5bba57d4832e697bad775d139cb07", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Inga tells the truth. Eleanor says Inga lies. Millicent says Eleanor tells the truth. Willian says Millicent tells the truth. Alejandro says Willian tells the truth. Does Alejandro tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Inga tells the truth. Eleanor says Inga lies. Millicent says Eleanor tells the truth. Willian says Millicent tells the truth. Alejandro says Willian tells the truth. Does Alejandro tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6064.34, "reasoner_ms": 2243.23, "tts_ms": 22.81, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8330.4, "total_processing_ms": 9023.21 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 851, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 96 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "fede326e84c1b562399d2ee673c9001077ef96ec1977fb74bf717e09af7bad14", "started_sha256": "d1a0e91e97ec5b0d937c6cc5e07b9135c017ad9a873479ae765f7564834da100", "original_grade_sha256": "c409efccc51d0d31122e3e3105c69a5ebcc7e69e67c6f7a7a8c9fc6335c71b02", "input_original_sha256": "fede326e84c1b562399d2ee673c9001077ef96ec1977fb74bf717e09af7bad14", "input_wav_sha256": "bd31d7b0448875235978730f3c32d989abac073cc8756051db0edff665f22595", "input_pcm_sha256": "babdddcfda9ae2ba515853a0ee347eabf691f162dccbc9740c6f5c0e96d32f21", "output_wav_sha256": "df12a9e2a64181d62030b3a655abf060dd9dbcc141e6347aab45544f8cdcdd20", "output_pcm_sha256": "093cefbb99be0a020357b1fc83385fde74b05a71b09281e00138937b794430fd", "result_sha256": "a4bbd6fa5f027b666b14dd1047a74c4c879fe155dad0383535358748404d43e9" } }, { "id": 248, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ba7ce9e1438be163016124aeb73775e9e8e365cd0fa0ea232c81b2e90879bb8b", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ba7ce9e1438be163016124aeb73775e9e8e365cd0fa0ea232c81b2e90879bb8b", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First, being a frequent consumer of Bed Head Shampoo is necessary for being an owner of a TRESemme shampoo. Second, no occasional purchaser of Burt's Bees Shampoo is a frequent consumer of Bed Head Shampoo. In consequence, no owner of a TRESemme shampoo is an occasional purchaser of Burt's Bees Shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First, being a frequent consumer of bedhead shampoo is necessary for being an owner of a TRESemm\u00e9 shampoo. Second, no occasional purchaser of Burt's Bees shampoo is a frequent consumer of bedhead shampoo. In consequence, no owner of a TRESemm\u00e9 shampoo is an occasional purchaser of Burt's Bees shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, Deductively valid or invalid? Valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13834.66, "reasoner_ms": 3042.16, "tts_ms": 25.56, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 16902.4, "total_processing_ms": 17657.62 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1069, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 168 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3fc470c93d96e40142cc4481517f9a62c7514e15914e45c24623d67a54047a2f", "started_sha256": "770898f1bc33da931a5102d3017fcbf80c67a83629cec84e2a89a5916f0e05fa", "original_grade_sha256": "0e881a7641e1f1c7fd4403afbb76ada15d4032246863ecd4fa3a5bf50563a1fc", "input_original_sha256": "3fc470c93d96e40142cc4481517f9a62c7514e15914e45c24623d67a54047a2f", "input_wav_sha256": "2a8d9eeccadbcfad1ce8440204b2b5734b158de7fb54e9c5ac2429555dfab6a8", "input_pcm_sha256": "55cc26b0ebb7d10eac289684830dc60fb0144840cc9817228cff57c025952528", "output_wav_sha256": "0f595e69e519ae83e4f61792a2e617da4d0eab737433a6cf2d07b6ab8e8c5a25", "output_pcm_sha256": "c0bf7ba2e6f819ec02bb1245ec7260dfdf517a0352182beb70b9f76e35a6ca77", "result_sha256": "abd0674331e39fb8a64c689e401f4814dc811f6c841aac970f8458e33d9097be" } }, { "id": 283, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "53a4163e66db632e5dc3e551bc403284c06f63ebd68f5c1db6b3e28731e0095e", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "53a4163e66db632e5dc3e551bc403284c06f63ebd68f5c1db6b3e28731e0095e", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take three steps. Take five steps. Take eight steps. Turn right. Turn right. Take five steps. Turn around. Take two steps. Take four steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take three steps. Take five steps. Take eight steps. Turn right. Turn right. Take five steps. Turn around. Take two steps. Take four steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7252.39, "reasoner_ms": 4253.39, "tts_ms": 19.36, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11525.16, "total_processing_ms": 12169.52 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 846, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 254 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "840c2339fcb50fd0ee1550665822391a95c7672127cf1034fcb58c1b6bcb0b86", "started_sha256": "407a341081e0aba0807a7c67c77a72054c7be96091e0da19a8fc01f9da7b31f5", "original_grade_sha256": "6ea3be6109e687a9812cf63d0efd4038f29727f2f3abb0b038266d2ac927546c", "input_original_sha256": "840c2339fcb50fd0ee1550665822391a95c7672127cf1034fcb58c1b6bcb0b86", "input_wav_sha256": "d231d241a0205efe40905144eafac43ed820b4dce73d6a3dc973f2cd3f2400b4", "input_pcm_sha256": "ea09a30b89ef181d5744b3f01e58264dc0b165f11847c98d4e2f63c4c8cbad9f", "output_wav_sha256": "43604f8a1ed26b042b0b89308308e9cfeb2ddb57280426d358c42a39d96a6627", "output_pcm_sha256": "65715c3f5c207a7ce15a6b57d9507953e30aaf8dd3a3d1e6222ad53b43eebf96", "result_sha256": "08d0a0088d60271fc53d467b819cc57e4205b81f321deab6dc067eb8fa8c2d43" } }, { "id": 746, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "7", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e7dbb4b440ad9b0ccf0707ee5740fd8a4c07aa02fdca96523d95e80168c33af4", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e7dbb4b440ad9b0ccf0707ee5740fd8a4c07aa02fdca96523d95e80168c33af4", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a chair, a table, a couch, a stove, a car, a lamp, and a fridge. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a chair, a table, a couch, a stove, a car, a lamp, and a fridge. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 7.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4725.97, "reasoner_ms": 1670.08, "tts_ms": 23.33, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6419.41, "total_processing_ms": 7161.07 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 766, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 36 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "feb88fd65e2b9fdc5cd45e17cf57a30a5cf657a004967a9e262ebff747d75360", "started_sha256": "253f73c0232a1092facbd7fc1a635aac944a6ae8b50dc9bd354154e192771200", "original_grade_sha256": "118b479206c145bb962d611965899c14f897e27c4f535f556bd4b66983f4e6d5", "input_original_sha256": "feb88fd65e2b9fdc5cd45e17cf57a30a5cf657a004967a9e262ebff747d75360", "input_wav_sha256": "c0c969615edf285036e8eac99a2c4a20d4e14ad556c916075d6787c8d636feef", "input_pcm_sha256": "a0300a63e883afc5ff8e2a6512c94012ef004322c9546664b624fcf343179140", "output_wav_sha256": "f0d9eaf75ae7e7079d9ac58d7e07fdc13333f96dcab5f86580b773282a823dc3", "output_pcm_sha256": "ec5bd285dc5726ed7d9326ac8f86a39e804624ac2e94529cf8d1853be81ca7ea", "result_sha256": "2ee7c8ca904afb5c5cc11b55156c622dba4823008d23dbbe8e8d5cb7c7f078fb" } }, { "id": 984, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cc63768939b8aa25c9dbaab385fa887eab5580a990c5b39496709522e3b1ae0a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cc63768939b8aa25c9dbaab385fa887eab5580a990c5b39496709522e3b1ae0a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Jerry tells the truth. Loreen says Jerry lies. Shanna says Loreen lies. Gwen says Shanna lies. Shonda says Gwen lies. Does Shonda tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Jerry tells the truth. Laureen says Jerry lies. Shanna says Laureen lies. Gwen says Shanna lies. Shonda says Gwen lies. Does Shonda tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5436.19, "reasoner_ms": 2331.33, "tts_ms": 21.8, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7789.36, "total_processing_ms": 8467.26 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 833, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 107 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "afdef7215d02d90aeb6491869d7f058c6de068fd3b7dc9eed544ef4f6ca6db86", "started_sha256": "d721b49f07fd94c6e35608e02219e92a69fbb677e373ed412262a6eee7cdb28b", "original_grade_sha256": "cf51a0159140fc36361a542559a11cecad6c74cbebb26b547bd7138d4b488445", "input_original_sha256": "afdef7215d02d90aeb6491869d7f058c6de068fd3b7dc9eed544ef4f6ca6db86", "input_wav_sha256": "321acb8bfd3145cb25b00c25329560397d5a31dd7cd971c35375a702f0aa512f", "input_pcm_sha256": "ca9c1f98b3bcf02a0ca92a8935603d08e8914a995a538e12a0f8fb78d617a8f9", "output_wav_sha256": "d398aec70183a91aea0438bd6aec7ea286962b9c5355be08929555283f4b92f9", "output_pcm_sha256": "755fd7e26df1984ad732ce778ab274d1ed7a729e09c291c4046c7ffc19c1a80f", "result_sha256": "9885a41da6d078b9e21bb4065ff76f75c24bec52fe8d78acac81959798bddb82" } }, { "id": 239, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dfe924553f8f41f61212daf63254adacd70d83d1ce1d51fb5b2b5afac819023b", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dfe924553f8f41f61212daf63254adacd70d83d1ce1d51fb5b2b5afac819023b", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, whoever is not a rare consumer of Herbal Essences shampoo is an occasional purchaser of Organix hair shampoo. Now, everyone who is not a regular user of Cetaphil soap is, however, a rare consumer of Tigi shampoo and an occasional purchaser of Organix hair shampoo. Moreover, nobody is neither a rare consumer of Herbal Essences shampoo nor a rare consumer of Tigi shampoo. It follows that whoever is not a rare consumer of Herbal Essences shampoo is a regular user of Cetaphil soap. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, whoever is not a rare consumer of herbal essences shampoo is an occasional purchaser of organics hair shampoo. Now, everyone who is not a regular user of Cetaphil soap is, however, a rare consumer of Tiji shampoo and an occasional purchaser of organics hair shampoo. Moreover, nobody is neither a rare consumer of herbal essences shampoo nor a rare consumer of Tiji shampoo. It follows that whoever is not a rare consumer of herbal essences shampoo is a regular user of Cetaphil soap. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Valid? Invalid? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13747.42, "reasoner_ms": 5531.15, "tts_ms": 27.37, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 19305.98, "total_processing_ms": 19889.65 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1169, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 365 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ab8ba441b7262baaa881e99234a8c64f8dd0cdfdcc38ed66f357818a05f11de3", "started_sha256": "114cf48a5dc91a2320022700f782eab935904f5a4c67b939ce9a3d1d7706d909", "original_grade_sha256": "d66edcefdb927d5ba98314a740d744760e9850aab647f6f3f94c714fd5d79269", "input_original_sha256": "ab8ba441b7262baaa881e99234a8c64f8dd0cdfdcc38ed66f357818a05f11de3", "input_wav_sha256": "b593652fbf172b6fd02d0239e93a9dcfebe09d87ccb3270249f0708449509d93", "input_pcm_sha256": "aba0c9eb075bef5b2c22398fef34dd3497ed9b680ff0888d2105c817bfa3d86e", "output_wav_sha256": "bf9dedfde29e72e14873abc216655687f21f365041982dc9d3cfb65b51707dd0", "output_pcm_sha256": "329e6a5caa2b6ae8df6cd5c273eb8aa6af1617b248f819d27ba171e653cb1308", "result_sha256": "18d08acb7490811bc4d7b1e32a0ff4cce44e6ae12dd3ac62cfd7afd78ee1921c" } }, { "id": 345, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6efd7f47c32bf9829b061222716b7f8206aca6e23b0e95846e7f3f00cc9a929f", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6efd7f47c32bf9829b061222716b7f8206aca6e23b0e95846e7f3f00cc9a929f", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take two steps. Take eight steps. Take eight steps. Take six steps. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take two steps. Take eight steps. Take eight steps. Take six steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5637.92, "reasoner_ms": 1771.16, "tts_ms": 22.81, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7431.91, "total_processing_ms": 8076.95 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 794, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 38 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d8362e220d303f2062b45ae3c459e39451825df08929131f519eae809de6f9f7", "started_sha256": "9e350719238a7437bbb9169e8da3e29bcc0164ac87748aa5331de3651b16ed31", "original_grade_sha256": "c162ed632505bbe7237d697ad2f5efa84cdae4bcd381d60236d460b5db2974ea", "input_original_sha256": "d8362e220d303f2062b45ae3c459e39451825df08929131f519eae809de6f9f7", "input_wav_sha256": "5619eaec838fc0e91f4f510141d7a6b9372c496d0d768dbf69fbcfcdc580123e", "input_pcm_sha256": "72eb4d79f3b88bf31ed1750e39ae885e148a29832a38ee658ac54928e32de78e", "output_wav_sha256": "f8bd67085fd378dc6d04fbcc6ec9aabc7c7d47dd4651f0f4951995945c98417d", "output_pcm_sha256": "2808c4ae37fe55dceccc0a2c1b327ddadf29381e7a7fbd54a324335b20e8b64f", "result_sha256": "e78951d24b8db1f00365ba631edbc3ce18c7045310d0e6bd3ea30d91d031e4b8" } }, { "id": 674, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "15", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b9e460255f5bcc6ba6391c45c24f9ec47ef940fac623774e2e87179fba7e642a", "normalized_answer": "15" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b9e460255f5bcc6ba6391c45c24f9ec47ef940fac623774e2e87179fba7e642a", "normalized_answer": "15" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a fish, a snake, a lettuce head, a mouse, four bears, a rabbit, a pig, three goats, a cow, and two snails. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a fish, a snake, a lettuce head, a mouse, four bears, a rabbit, a pig, three goats, a cow, and two snails. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 15.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5100.49, "reasoner_ms": 2170.48, "tts_ms": 26.36, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7297.35, "total_processing_ms": 7957.03 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 802, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 101 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5db94cfc02c933f04da74ddd7f9c3e9e1ef1494f42aa42d01f3613b40f5e81fc", "started_sha256": "56a9d2aca1926f52e6248d419d532742535f97960f95cf1f36947feab6e275ab", "original_grade_sha256": "9c5d1e43de3466337279e4ae11afe11ed32a043c88b1f2b606de297918e04d9e", "input_original_sha256": "5db94cfc02c933f04da74ddd7f9c3e9e1ef1494f42aa42d01f3613b40f5e81fc", "input_wav_sha256": "9dce5b5c1054647f657362695e6da98b6bf5636e6386fbf3b32e496e8b24739d", "input_pcm_sha256": "7d6cc7594cc0ff89bdacb5d0fc54114805557e575b32aeaf926cf96e6e445ca7", "output_wav_sha256": "c602df2ee9e578c4517eac2ad73a52f2d26238a323fc921f806a2a3c891d33a0", "output_pcm_sha256": "f78063f72b756d448900d7676d67206a7ca1e6744577c4111a032c5a37bb959b", "result_sha256": "bacc7fa78b49a9a73fa606c6ab7fb4056fe284af917588d51644fb6662257c1f" } }, { "id": 753, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8312ab024b78f85e3685dd7a9acbba7aebcf42f7ecca7dec69442893df2d9436", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8312ab024b78f85e3685dd7a9acbba7aebcf42f7ecca7dec69442893df2d9436", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Christy tells the truth. K says Christy tells the truth. Delbert says K lies. Lita says Delbert tells the truth. Loreen says Lita tells the truth. Does Loreen tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Christy tells the truth. Ka says Christy tells the truth. Delbert says Kay lies. Lita says Delbert tells the truth. Lorene says Lita tells the truth. Does Lorene tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6162.89, "reasoner_ms": 2243.06, "tts_ms": 19.62, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8425.59, "total_processing_ms": 9091.19 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 110 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "470092089f730db7a11da80a6ec3c986c11c9b22406ed62b3bbc77f38011d099", "started_sha256": "11ca25f2697dc0f521d69e26e806b603050c2e523a24c7ba636ec3a4f4274459", "original_grade_sha256": "43f7028ec9b39c471897ad122aed73226a0a1f669cc6fb225e4e83118a7be055", "input_original_sha256": "470092089f730db7a11da80a6ec3c986c11c9b22406ed62b3bbc77f38011d099", "input_wav_sha256": "e658b32821827e7209611caa82bb283a36f78c28a05bddf15266af815f6b13ff", "input_pcm_sha256": "a7106dfd39b2a97e4de76e0a61e7aecff7a2e5ccd87798ab3e1b277071e78a52", "output_wav_sha256": "5ad5bdc4555fc55018c3a8d49221bfb0cc22e95983330c438d9913fef1f83f26", "output_pcm_sha256": "e71ad613ba121be91913a49cad7c89cbeaafdb165fc45e92eb0df92ea3d627da", "result_sha256": "b12f91ab464a7d47769315433510f318ad799162418c4094b748d330dbc265e6" } }, { "id": 114, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "36ee372d9ae3e3b7c27b24065215c61aa135087487ae517df2e439ce6e253ba7", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "36ee372d9ae3e3b7c27b24065215c61aa135087487ae517df2e439ce6e253ba7", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nSome football fans admire various clubs, others love only a single team. But who is a fan of whom precisely? The following argument pertains to this question. To start with, somebody is an ex-supporter of FC Basel Eighteen Ninety-Three and a devotee of AS Trencin. Now, no ex-supporter of Paris Saint-Germain is a devotee of AS Trencin. In consequence, not every ex-supporter of FC Basel Eighteen Ninety-Three is an ex-supporter of Paris Saint-Germain. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nSome football fans admire various clubs, others love only a single team. But who is a fan of whom precisely? The following argument pertains to this question, to start with, somebody is an ex-supporter of FC Basel 1893 and a devotee of A.S. Tren. Now, no ex-supporter of Paris Saint-Germain is a devotee of A.S. Tren. In consequence, not every ex-supporter of FC Basel 1893 is an ex-supporter of Paris Saint-Germain. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14016.06, "reasoner_ms": 3420.37, "tts_ms": 25.06, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17461.53, "total_processing_ms": 18096.99 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1097, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 240 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2f284e17a57b33e93ff029f45186fbbbe0ed5dd6adc5114b9fb3c30e434fa625", "started_sha256": "85e12dd071d292e88b33f4f19fa3f08ca016d3bb3ac940ee60158c0f88e36d86", "original_grade_sha256": "728a78c1d41e97d34f9223783027042404cc4a8635279385f7687e732ec8ab66", "input_original_sha256": "2f284e17a57b33e93ff029f45186fbbbe0ed5dd6adc5114b9fb3c30e434fa625", "input_wav_sha256": "ad9d60711bd5165496e6c0ec8a14d12916ff59d2b6b98b4ec082411ca08a636f", "input_pcm_sha256": "beacd080724d445c3b642fddc772996ed2a909f4818908ff190eb259faaa643b", "output_wav_sha256": "b7b6a5c229f47c8fe2004ad4977fccf1c4545e760355d48a7ae1648d80a4877b", "output_pcm_sha256": "d6482d713d2e92bfa504cd90ecf31118b576eabad3988e835aab7d7531bf5c80", "result_sha256": "7c56ca32378c2df95fa90b42f9b03775efd911e47d6ee4b8809e245c4a969cb2" } }, { "id": 471, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d51bf186c25b8df7f868a70c07a538bdd227669355deb9061351f36861fbb628", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d51bf186c25b8df7f868a70c07a538bdd227669355deb9061351f36861fbb628", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take five steps. Take three steps. Take two steps. Turn around. Take ten steps. Options? Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point, take five steps, take three steps, take two steps, turn around, take ten steps? Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5364.07, "reasoner_ms": 1780.96, "tts_ms": 25.07, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7170.13, "total_processing_ms": 7994.48 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 795, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 49 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6a586d3242123ea692e568acd07ea2e680455f5dab8059c5f033e81aaebaaab1", "started_sha256": "0713943bc43d0836004f2d49d2439a8536d43b06775db1a9de78357de4c2d707", "original_grade_sha256": "4e47097f1cb07fc38f449b006f199cdaef6c8316e818246e158968ef273cd711", "input_original_sha256": "6a586d3242123ea692e568acd07ea2e680455f5dab8059c5f033e81aaebaaab1", "input_wav_sha256": "34a8131d5ad8fbb1e2e582cc04743d1155350bb44069f63ebb2778f91ae30205", "input_pcm_sha256": "2c9dff601525ee002dbabe59e5f2d7a44dbabd4a6a38d33172666cd63ab40339", "output_wav_sha256": "f48bfd08097ae6986258214fcdaba16d453d28a45f15dac50f7156624de7919c", "output_pcm_sha256": "809f2cf0e45607542f125583669d6bb78320778f2b3d5192e4b22944077b4ffb", "result_sha256": "bb91c80a99ac7ccda9ea26cbfe28753fdd347670e2f0b5784a750b0e671c1d3a" } }, { "id": 575, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "18", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1e2fe0c4e60ed7ed44bbd52d5b64d7744a16997d6a7d2b664eea9b0dfb6b9792", "normalized_answer": "18" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1e2fe0c4e60ed7ed44bbd52d5b64d7744a16997d6a7d2b664eea9b0dfb6b9792", "normalized_answer": "18" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a lettuce head, a cabbage, five onions, a potato, three stalks of celery, a cauliflower, a garlic, a yam, and four heads of broccoli. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a lettuce head, a cabbage, five onions, a potato, three stalks of celery, a cauliflower, a garlic, a yam, and four heads of broccoli. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 18.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5340.76, "reasoner_ms": 2123.72, "tts_ms": 25.42, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7489.93, "total_processing_ms": 8074.85 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 821, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 90 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "00c12d48a30979101d402333b43f94ac1497cfae60d5750e82903dea7c3459a1", "started_sha256": "a96408f2a75e4088ce32392b6c786de2cdaa27e1da014c5297da31a04e967347", "original_grade_sha256": "d06cf0e401ff1bac95a3f6f47ef0f65a591ab478045f4ae000e4a3e3622cdc0b", "input_original_sha256": "00c12d48a30979101d402333b43f94ac1497cfae60d5750e82903dea7c3459a1", "input_wav_sha256": "672b8fb41292b38690e328b79b42281ed7ccef770dda255a3ba70c504801b0b5", "input_pcm_sha256": "9798a3e30c2ca7d4af94dd4380091357178e8ad123127f4e47a04fd9d80e1f71", "output_wav_sha256": "bbab6f079138497936ef1cca531255db1e59757f9531797ba24653c51d127303", "output_pcm_sha256": "e7d53fae7145a7152bc330fc46c58c0d3f78e1276285ac102994c5c6a8417a65", "result_sha256": "eeb54ba5da6227e597cb5d56091ad58485e79517a786341cd17e3a0a3fbbe529" } }, { "id": 896, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7176fbbcd2ad770e87af65df1e07277f15eea02aaee582017ccae00175da31ae", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7176fbbcd2ad770e87af65df1e07277f15eea02aaee582017ccae00175da31ae", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Audrey tells the truth. Ryan says Audrey lies. Rashida says Ryan lies. Fletcher says Rashida tells the truth. Shonda says Fletcher tells the truth. Does Shonda tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Audrey tells the truth. Ryan says Audrey lies. Rashida says Ryan lies. Fletcher says Rashida tells the truth. Shonda says Fletcher tells the truth. Does Shonda tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5434.47, "reasoner_ms": 2189.5, "tts_ms": 25.57, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7649.57, "total_processing_ms": 8267.9 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 849, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 105 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "39e83b6f67988105eeeb3b603d160b4ca21ce2aad1f7e3f4577488606bf1009b", "started_sha256": "5bb20f2607e90adf76fdc95ced6d7562faa7e10a819bdced92249887b9f03e8e", "original_grade_sha256": "e0c8fa6eebbd282633492d122a1cbfe3bbc635e2801d65c350eb0111573ce81a", "input_original_sha256": "39e83b6f67988105eeeb3b603d160b4ca21ce2aad1f7e3f4577488606bf1009b", "input_wav_sha256": "9d956a60f64b1e39fc1949f46f9e4b850bced11b51c91f8feb1358d62baba0bc", "input_pcm_sha256": "612a278de411e94ba483327f779c4abde4e2053950a2df84027871c4f8c6223c", "output_wav_sha256": "b31da7adf745d9d55de158864cd2222db4c816f5468f2d4e4b788609cad7e3ef", "output_pcm_sha256": "f52a8ff2b736c2244b20e7a1e6f39701901cc02b40e7913f7a6935e94fa3efec", "result_sha256": "a84ab5f3db2febebf4900f6fec7ef4d552f52920176bd7ee0138967a7cbbb2f1" } }, { "id": 21, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cca606a059e6284849713e9594cdf644fa0f9e39e2a1486d9acc43bbb04ed7f8", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cca606a059e6284849713e9594cdf644fa0f9e39e2a1486d9acc43bbb04ed7f8", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a cousin of Robert? Is Joe related to Bob? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First, Cecil is a schoolmate of Tyler. Second, nobody is neither a schoolmate of Tyler nor a nephew of Owen. So necessarily, Cecil is not a nephew of Owen. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nis fred a cousin of robert is joe related to bob in large families it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives the following argument seeks to clarify some such relations first cecil is a schoolmate of tyler second nobody is neither a schoolmate of tyler nor a nephew of owen so necessarily cecil is not a nephew of owen is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question Question", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13274.42, "reasoner_ms": 3860.2, "tts_ms": 29.37, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17164.02, "total_processing_ms": 17741.95 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1006, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 210 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "9471341cf9a78571e6ba5adcd8c78b7af350e2a62b389e7b59860ff5b7debe4b", "started_sha256": "8f9080289a0b6ab23ae2ff95afd0d23eb04ad426fdb035358fd97a2ecdc680b2", "original_grade_sha256": "7d89196a5f372a71f005b2fd278a4d2498cfad875366fcb4a00b62eb1beee6f6", "input_original_sha256": "9471341cf9a78571e6ba5adcd8c78b7af350e2a62b389e7b59860ff5b7debe4b", "input_wav_sha256": "ae124057b682a764d30faf7e2ade3e92f2870df85d65b489a0a3fc60b6b6a72c", "input_pcm_sha256": "a97e94edd494ed1486062cd32c4af182e6ca788be72ce4bc4731c4cca8715cc9", "output_wav_sha256": "50cd5be7692c606388d73975623c6ceca622b82976b4227fc165b9d9e4c49f6a", "output_pcm_sha256": "f987fceb47e9f6483956259a8bd39d25fcf019bad07d94e8b613333cf0475614", "result_sha256": "846289222fbcc40a6326885ad8caa15e36da03df762b0f7625d360176210fde2" } }, { "id": 304, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a04d4d31d9dad38f88fe3fffa927934c89dd75c1714d9d03055598d135ed73fe", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a04d4d31d9dad38f88fe3fffa927934c89dd75c1714d9d03055598d135ed73fe", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn right. Take three steps. Turn around. Take three steps. Turn left. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn right. Take three steps. Turn around. Take three steps. Turn left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5918.06, "reasoner_ms": 1917.79, "tts_ms": 24.57, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7860.44, "total_processing_ms": 8493.83 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 795, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 66 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5c6b14a01f11db35ea379fcb2527dfb4f1105b5e96feb36022180700d5e7b341", "started_sha256": "cb38121a6d8f31e236d6befb5cc9a21c32233ebd69b46b7023e31cf70be42fa0", "original_grade_sha256": "5f4522aa239be89b3aa3ee7da81981c41c51cde19084d9bd4a6fc50da46286bc", "input_original_sha256": "5c6b14a01f11db35ea379fcb2527dfb4f1105b5e96feb36022180700d5e7b341", "input_wav_sha256": "624e9e9982715e1602f151fd5ed2e1b4b931983a78f61589341a086a9a3d3d58", "input_pcm_sha256": "feee316c4d15f3a5f1e2bb79a67b4996ce326f48a610c651bc90068172584ba4", "output_wav_sha256": "c46030a3dc9a58adc836095c8ca6717ee9b47b114d5008328e95c45b6537821e", "output_pcm_sha256": "ef9926823863cf182c58f7c04293233b7773450948abfcb0869867e98e507a8e", "result_sha256": "528968c6b29b3d15fcfa37aa8ab56326585c6912d0b40a4bd6201c8f1356079a" } }, { "id": 694, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "13", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4705e24312abb309212f56ee4f34a5a21e1ef78fa3ab0a92157452e2c69e7125", "normalized_answer": "13" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4705e24312abb309212f56ee4f34a5a21e1ef78fa3ab0a92157452e2c69e7125", "normalized_answer": "13" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a cow, two dogs, a mouse, a donkey, a snail, a snake, a cat, a pig, a bear, and three rabbits. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a cow two dogs a mouse a donkey a snail a snake a cat a pig a bear and three rabbits how many animals do i have answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 13.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9098.24, "reasoner_ms": 1944.02, "tts_ms": 27.94, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11070.22, "total_processing_ms": 11623.16 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 795, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 92 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b86188e1a327c5cd5288e9435b2d8606ed9db851888500864af9f771d989471f", "started_sha256": "140e8fc3fe61321c8dde1f59983d6e57179596ce2ee0ffec32f0d5e3bc05fcf5", "original_grade_sha256": "a7ca60377fa86bebabddd8378545bc751dfdd167cc769cf46f8c8d9c2535ec4f", "input_original_sha256": "b86188e1a327c5cd5288e9435b2d8606ed9db851888500864af9f771d989471f", "input_wav_sha256": "18a3ff923aac1ce8876b11dc568ca672dcc8c1044b7a7ce4cee374048f3222e7", "input_pcm_sha256": "a2dd625fdcff885149b66b7dbbe5089093dc19f63d241d4c2dfbeac9911eb6fc", "output_wav_sha256": "0e35677fd2378f6b947a4399d2af30be41b819bd3f4a9e09ca1c42dd6d5583d7", "output_pcm_sha256": "41dcd4988e686f21f641f6dc36fac4f27f310a3dab1b9a32e678a682b4632312", "result_sha256": "b05b2308424c0a25cb20d97cb0e9d98de29406150380283456e210c019d9ad3c" } }, { "id": 825, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "554436263b1ee0478b0fa66acec666be7045308f9fef9e5ec6aa833d65a00f63", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "554436263b1ee0478b0fa66acec666be7045308f9fef9e5ec6aa833d65a00f63", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Lida tells the truth. Shalonda says Lida lies. Shenna says Shalonda tells the truth. Christie says Shenna lies. Christa says Christie tells the truth. Does Christa tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Leda tells the truth. Shalonda says Leda lies. Shena says Shalonda tells the truth. Christy says Shena lies. Krista says Christy tells the truth. Does Krista tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5526.07, "reasoner_ms": 2266.23, "tts_ms": 24.43, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7816.74, "total_processing_ms": 8383.73 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 115 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "658309fee000c4a298783fc9c9fc5e2c86b23e7edfdb642dbe1a23fdaf6b7816", "started_sha256": "95ee75f76c64fe75dff2fe08b2d95c4530006ecfe713c362558af5768f66de18", "original_grade_sha256": "d290cb88fed8696333bc4f13be6d3195181a1eefc7843899823462ead7b4751d", "input_original_sha256": "658309fee000c4a298783fc9c9fc5e2c86b23e7edfdb642dbe1a23fdaf6b7816", "input_wav_sha256": "4e63a8b79602da6b9c953be5153265aa6f68b338c06e8f1033dcc27c3dae1ed9", "input_pcm_sha256": "ad7302c3f1c1fd29deeeded417463d559dc99ff5f55564a6aadfb6bb079f9c71", "output_wav_sha256": "c3db0a7f7e885498e616349de21fe0fe07739e5f34d0477ee81cdbb83ee4c832", "output_pcm_sha256": "3c312ebb4da2ec3e4e7926c00cdb1d96a557a5b731d8a84c6fe87ad7b7b040ca", "result_sha256": "5d40d8be088d047f6a228942e9775ddedd3ee88ae8c518cbc386f0fd175c95ef" } }, { "id": 162, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c37ce1023e1f015a40b4fdccd43b3ffb7793dc8a68d575ab3a8888390edc9e6f", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c37ce1023e1f015a40b4fdccd43b3ffb7793dc8a68d575ab3a8888390edc9e6f", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise: It is false that Courtney is a regular consumer of Pantene shampoo. Second premise: Whoever is a regular consumer of Kirk's soap or a regular consumer of Pantene shampoo is a regular consumer of Revlon shampoo. From this follows: It is false that Courtney is a regular consumer of Revlon shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise, it is false that Courtney is a regular consumer of Pantene shampoo. Second premise, whoever is a regular consumer of Kirk's soap or a regular consumer of Pantene shampoo is a regular consumer of Revlon shampoo. From this follows, it is false that Courtney is a regular consumer of Revlon shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. valid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11926.06, "reasoner_ms": 2779.24, "tts_ms": 26.57, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 14731.9, "total_processing_ms": 15348.0 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1025, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 110 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "7ac18b867150367aa6c2a500da04d657bd3f68a28594eb50dfc54aab7391d2a5", "started_sha256": "22e9a45577774d3b28f80373147c5fc29079b8c52f4b19e9cac8520a3b656e16", "original_grade_sha256": "411c900a822ec249d442223453960b25b4bb3d12f08641a29aaa0521282b38c3", "input_original_sha256": "7ac18b867150367aa6c2a500da04d657bd3f68a28594eb50dfc54aab7391d2a5", "input_wav_sha256": "bcf7209060818876161114b2b0d8d5e3905ff2a80d663c444666c87c521b1ba8", "input_pcm_sha256": "9f2e5969a1524030e98f478f4c72e91d4816f3b94c6ae3b13eb724b23932abdc", "output_wav_sha256": "4feaa1646368ace22bc43baf36eb2f00c81b6bacfd3a8ef50e0008170e139a2f", "output_pcm_sha256": "b9e582d3d66dfa59080be8f00c0ecca9c7b4240aa1b09a000a34527f77d8c4b3", "result_sha256": "d9abee2058b260201fd8affa3e3cef1511216985a4c5588d464db0fd41ca1053" } }, { "id": 329, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a5c89f38634706262df14db3302868e8fd0e81acb89ca0ec448277bdd0d06f85", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a5c89f38634706262df14db3302868e8fd0e81acb89ca0ec448277bdd0d06f85", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take ten steps forward. Take four steps forward. Take seven steps backward. Take seven steps backward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take 10 steps forward. Take 4 steps forward. Take 7 steps backward. Take 7 steps backward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5942.3, "reasoner_ms": 1810.8, "tts_ms": 24.79, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7777.91, "total_processing_ms": 8332.49 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 828, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 47 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2997c814e8eb9124526316e90b81945c2334f3aaf8a42ff1b3334f5f12aff3ef", "started_sha256": "4faef52c7f108c24bb3a2bcac974051ed88cec5532209fd0fbf55b029b1aabf0", "original_grade_sha256": "2663966baf34b2555ca95bffa20c1b990b023ba37503072d828ba6a1d6638a32", "input_original_sha256": "2997c814e8eb9124526316e90b81945c2334f3aaf8a42ff1b3334f5f12aff3ef", "input_wav_sha256": "b43175586d4b0aed2ec5906c1a5ed2904b7d80e6dfcf521f4c0bf78d71edb8e1", "input_pcm_sha256": "2680d9dd8edf6c513701e151afce19562a52db3b1229ac88b736a7eaaf30d3c0", "output_wav_sha256": "905c4bb999b88d40285fc7aeafec6f496aec2afd9499cae7c2bb0ba0ef751ee4", "output_pcm_sha256": "ceba274c8f1df48ab14ca75690bef04d4d9a80268c6c15a7e596b0a313283837", "result_sha256": "38532f77d76488c9b2cc908e8c34b4d336d57534f18cbd6962449f08c6851731" } }, { "id": 658, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "11", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "68bc71777fefc62b661725b0f7d526f1a6457e9d83ae0d336514568901f7393e", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "68bc71777fefc62b661725b0f7d526f1a6457e9d83ae0d336514568901f7393e", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have an onion, a carrot, a potato, a yam, three lettuce heads, two cauliflowers, a garlic, and a cabbage. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have an onion, a carrot, a potato, a yam, three lettuce heads, two cauliflowers, a garlic and a cabbage. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 11.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4976.92, "reasoner_ms": 1869.47, "tts_ms": 25.61, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6872.03, "total_processing_ms": 7438.59 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 800, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 66 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "aaee5302f5773fb9e55d5b9e5342d98a2bcdfd284c9f8108ffd83ea649c0c636", "started_sha256": "6425ed381e28629a5e87695313664438435124277f375f00edac1ffe56be37ee", "original_grade_sha256": "7e97a5fa0b1e43ee45aa67f4dc6598c8d341624d05308c47961888d071566d0a", "input_original_sha256": "aaee5302f5773fb9e55d5b9e5342d98a2bcdfd284c9f8108ffd83ea649c0c636", "input_wav_sha256": "64ef7aff32b4faa318bc48edd7700ff37b94e00a89e08be8ab46369d73ecb467", "input_pcm_sha256": "bce559fc8c124d12e7d609a441802ba90cab0c03307b9c1236cfc64196c02a6a", "output_wav_sha256": "1d4b064c5adf2e428caee3ca3aa2ea44346a5cc2c5c0b66bd10652991a26785a", "output_pcm_sha256": "463ab30a72adb8817b1a1a39a6ab08ec6be78892d7a5e32a0512580cac20303b", "result_sha256": "83cb6029051b7a37adee975e3667939063f29b6ff6418b8a8d2934547ee20fac" } }, { "id": 968, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "54fad4f72c17b053930a634e16fc0d67517565a92e92c2201c975ba8139923a9", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "54fad4f72c17b053930a634e16fc0d67517565a92e92c2201c975ba8139923a9", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Sal lies. Christian says Sal lies. Helen says Christian lies. Inga says Helen tells the truth. Michael says Inga tells the truth. Does Michael tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Sal lies. Christian says Sal lies. Helen says Christian lies. Inga says Helen tells the truth. Michael says Inga tells the truth. Does Michael tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4984.19, "reasoner_ms": 2372.1, "tts_ms": 22.23, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7378.56, "total_processing_ms": 7922.4 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 819, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 118 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3faba405dbe5a1b259beebbb3cf4340d612142647ae98fd9684c4e9b8dd85ca7", "started_sha256": "bce4f6fd832508392784a688691508c68c47900f9903367051f5db00d94b6d91", "original_grade_sha256": "19577b74d9a851ff5e3803322eadf2598865463578ef5bbd40f4b30af8db972e", "input_original_sha256": "3faba405dbe5a1b259beebbb3cf4340d612142647ae98fd9684c4e9b8dd85ca7", "input_wav_sha256": "a02355085eb74ba60cedf3695697ef12f33f5579f2ea177f5dea57bd50cf88d9", "input_pcm_sha256": "9b781a990704ad065a89e251ec9933262c3f85739f5cc1a9e608db2eafeffc3a", "output_wav_sha256": "0fbd5317a8cf67f9ab74038c95d72f8ae4d180f2bb33d45818b06d65307494f0", "output_pcm_sha256": "b7d5cf67c275f3e0c814b395a558391b6e7292e1431b397e3ab7e05924546389", "result_sha256": "42b76b61c26f8db713fb334777d9362d13031bbdfb4ff6c8e8ab834644ee2dc6" } }, { "id": 28, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "76f1751c83a50e0caa38e1b239556ed895d22159c371ed30425773dbd63e5dae", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "76f1751c83a50e0caa38e1b239556ed895d22159c371ed30425773dbd63e5dae", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see which chemicals are contained in our consumer products. The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, being an ingredient of Aqua Blush is sufficient for being an ingredient of NARS Duo Eyeshadow. Moreover, whatever is neither an ingredient of Stop and Stare nor an ingredient of AD Lipstick Chic is an ingredient of Lash Tinsel Mascara or an ingredient of Aqua Blush. Finally, everything that is an ingredient of Lash Tinsel Mascara is an ingredient of NARS Duo Eyeshadow too. Therefore, whatever is not an ingredient of NARS Duo Eyeshadow is however an ingredient of Stop and Stare or an ingredient of AD Lipstick Chic. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see which chemicals are contained in our consumer products. The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, being an ingredient of aqua blush is sufficient for being an ingredient of NARS Duo Eyeshadow. Moreover, whatever is neither an ingredient of Stop and Stare nor an ingredient of AD Lipstick Chick is an ingredient of Lash Tinsel Mascara or an ingredient of aqua blush. Finally, everything that is an ingredient of Lash Tinsel Mascara is an ingredient of NARS Duo Eyeshadow 2. Therefore, whatever is not an ingredient of NARS Duo Eyeshadow is however an ingredient of Stop and Stare or an ingredient of AD Lipstick Cheek. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Valid, Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 15697.11, "reasoner_ms": 3300.48, "tts_ms": 30.18, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 19027.8, "total_processing_ms": 19556.58 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1190, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 177 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "187bd9de42a1482624245102f7d52997b55c89683a658cc3b0a41a5486598527", "started_sha256": "ae6dd19e1a10d684032a005e539b263561a145a0f691dc06c7d54064b67156b7", "original_grade_sha256": "3d2a21e8c4a23a8499f8357e578b0c8a7f3bb86d3d31593d4e9f78e3321a0cce", "input_original_sha256": "187bd9de42a1482624245102f7d52997b55c89683a658cc3b0a41a5486598527", "input_wav_sha256": "9e83bc5bcb910a6e88bdaac215dde4bbf0655e9b5886c660324b093aaaa02aa9", "input_pcm_sha256": "e8348f39afaae6fa37d36d9c372d55262f77d7cf110b0c4f9e132c66550e3fe4", "output_wav_sha256": "55fd87850ff9870cab818d428ef79385d183a5b996b46b4b21d1878b28f3de43", "output_pcm_sha256": "7b09dea8e6e08af926a0c8820993bff94068b831e1eb972f2c79054c2e6e775e", "result_sha256": "9c11c37e666ecfa1763efc4501d6324805da94a311f00a5594f217d6b9015e95" } }, { "id": 451, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5daae6f110eb2661da25b63e9fe2dae5304914a915415b87254a2657e03b995a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5daae6f110eb2661da25b63e9fe2dae5304914a915415b87254a2657e03b995a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take four steps. Turn around. Take four steps. Turn around. Turn right. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point take four steps turn around take four steps turn around turn right options yes no answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4349.32, "reasoner_ms": 2126.66, "tts_ms": 21.89, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6497.9, "total_processing_ms": 7100.57 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 776, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 66 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6f97497e47204caa91f9b900b1889f0a552946f925ad0a445f9605b7e7733841", "started_sha256": "0696b988700a88e8e10f25bc613c371711756375b07eafae12c77916ffedb7da", "original_grade_sha256": "382411a6d1d7862f5fcd764d3f6a7fcd7165de20a72df46927b95159ed90032e", "input_original_sha256": "6f97497e47204caa91f9b900b1889f0a552946f925ad0a445f9605b7e7733841", "input_wav_sha256": "fd0f555c0e22e6ada8b711e183029bb735994face01198acfad8db44ee74ad51", "input_pcm_sha256": "3df9c854fb57787f985069053c619877d567639a37645478e8548ed8a451195b", "output_wav_sha256": "10dc558697c75b9c9f01df0751aae9025dd7fe84ac80181dae597b6d22e5be85", "output_pcm_sha256": "7930ea36083352c5078e7722ed71352116803f242f898ec6073bc5dcb5255002", "result_sha256": "292d7cea1f2575abd011c820c274305df0cad1d674396ad5722f57c5746c4654" } }, { "id": 609, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "6", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d2a3942f004405fcafffd97a36ad921a24fc535d5eddc338b7bce9228a8675e6", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d2a3942f004405fcafffd97a36ad921a24fc535d5eddc338b7bce9228a8675e6", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have three stalks of celery, a duck, a yam, a head of broccoli, four pigs, and a garlic. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have three stalks of celery, a duck, a yam, a head of broccoli, four pigs, and a garlic. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 6.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4756.9, "reasoner_ms": 3610.41, "tts_ms": 24.53, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8391.87, "total_processing_ms": 9041.01 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 781, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 196 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "9fa0150e6e9c025a2ddf6cc0ae52e1d3b219fef5507a8291a29acaefed569daf", "started_sha256": "6497ea6fa35a99645eee807957b74d05bda91d7e5713977eaf9518e7e168772c", "original_grade_sha256": "03a48ed82fb27fb1342978bef789851c8dc23fa5313e2698089e1807ba7f7c1f", "input_original_sha256": "9fa0150e6e9c025a2ddf6cc0ae52e1d3b219fef5507a8291a29acaefed569daf", "input_wav_sha256": "17901d181afae2444d7a3cd7dfc0a42ee361c34fba21a12d3f3f10380744daad", "input_pcm_sha256": "029408204a17ec8a9b6c169401c149eaca7bf27d92dce349834957cd5a52802f", "output_wav_sha256": "3f7023f4ccade59937b21109eb8ae9b96d24bddc79cf1484411075ca3cb760b4", "output_pcm_sha256": "e6b9fc371fda70a81599242678b6ee74885c0f8945732a2e20c802df20dc6687", "result_sha256": "619fcecf0880484ca276bf4920bf545fc5fe34ce2c5d6841f9ad9d2351319ddb" } }, { "id": 854, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d14e1c9146cd9d83d39fb95dc5c64b6326df7b015f70849117a45dcb068e904d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d14e1c9146cd9d83d39fb95dc5c64b6326df7b015f70849117a45dcb068e904d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Krista tells the truth. Shalonda says Krista lies. Millicent says Shalonda lies. Vernell says Millicent lies. Inga says Vernell tells the truth. Does Inga tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Krista tells the truth. Shalanda says Krista lies. Millicent says Shalanda lies. Vernell says Millicent lies. Inga says Vernell tells the truth. Does Inga tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5711.79, "reasoner_ms": 2332.24, "tts_ms": 23.82, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8067.88, "total_processing_ms": 8660.66 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 120 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "eea935b321930f737934cc63f8342ad7d9c183aee60ce519403a127c5bc6a476", "started_sha256": "c4df31c03951aa97397b4366d6686e09ef2af43304bbdfc41c1fd725bd11068f", "original_grade_sha256": "c8617f3ee3488a360e3aa571d09231b9c726ec7388c386194a7ecf075ed5b61a", "input_original_sha256": "eea935b321930f737934cc63f8342ad7d9c183aee60ce519403a127c5bc6a476", "input_wav_sha256": "cfbf57f7f80f6761636cfc11d715a2a8a6b55f6db13aa570fca7bd5f0e96d1d0", "input_pcm_sha256": "3cccc2ec9ce505e727aaf2f4ad2273217870891d1691a8524140c6ec5b71be08", "output_wav_sha256": "9d940483c1ba0efc8b2753815f50196e04496d262722ee501345a64da06882cb", "output_pcm_sha256": "f3427818afc8b0bd962afc830b86563b472a0a05987009dbab2beec6d16c8fe1", "result_sha256": "ccf39da5323cb197ab313fd64834e9be3125d0d09d14ad165ffd01af6e1f7227" } }, { "id": 211, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b4723348a65755d8abdf60112c8c2402ac86aaa6c171b8cfeb89c3f47e1a8ad6", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b4723348a65755d8abdf60112c8c2402ac86aaa6c171b8cfeb89c3f47e1a8ad6", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, being a daughter of Alicia is necessary for not being a niece of Teresa. Second, being a daughter of Alicia is necessary for not being a workmate of Priscilla. Third, every aunt of Don is a niece of Teresa and a workmate of Priscilla. We may conclude everyone who is an aunt of Don is a daughter of Alicia, too. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, being a daughter of Alicia is necessary for not being a niece of Teresa. Second, being a daughter of Alicia is necessary for not being a workmate of Priscilla. Third, every aunt of Don is a niece of Teresa and a workmate of Priscilla. We may conclude, everyone who is an aunt of Don is a daughter of Alicia too. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11717.96, "reasoner_ms": 3815.98, "tts_ms": 27.06, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15561.03, "total_processing_ms": 16149.59 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1030, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 213 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "22513b01feee806c08ac791cd40c134fdcab9c879e2b3f39905f5c810e65f558", "started_sha256": "a34f647f97bb8b6f544687182473b28804316c764448dcafb04c664b5d9a7492", "original_grade_sha256": "71bbe3ab7a5ab661f6923175b44078458c40999f9d2135b1d49bb719671dbc99", "input_original_sha256": "22513b01feee806c08ac791cd40c134fdcab9c879e2b3f39905f5c810e65f558", "input_wav_sha256": "536da3cc62592fe2743aac391eed0cbc0fc5d20507d3e8cf79636f84f162e608", "input_pcm_sha256": "f68bbfa0384b3d8f03541120ec403e1e1bbb672e6892cce798407bca811d3853", "output_wav_sha256": "0221291d876bc0fb51c765e264f18274826c8fd61a85a0b6f0c6beec59ca16ed", "output_pcm_sha256": "2e25d8add805c9bdbe33f27bb3811fc7a3aa7e6d3c6d83a150a6d50b2e652e89", "result_sha256": "8dd92944b88682c0cd6b70822998ae20a3216c69621eccb0021ff5f9b29879f0" } }, { "id": 408, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a03ad15d249b790455e8586403db5a870662149af9b5cdba7a1933b9b6e39ca3", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a03ad15d249b790455e8586403db5a870662149af9b5cdba7a1933b9b6e39ca3", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take five steps. Turn around. Take four steps. Take one step. Turn left. Turn around. Turn left. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point take five steps turn around take four steps take one step turn left turn around turn left options yes no answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7576.36, "reasoner_ms": 3389.46, "tts_ms": 26.3, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10992.14, "total_processing_ms": 11549.38 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 793, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 144 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6599cab72dfcd3834bd43980cdb055d873707649e7a174550e63cf8c567b46c1", "started_sha256": "2d0c8fd45bbffae31580202e529b56ffd183e138ec303a976d3a6a45ea8eb1c2", "original_grade_sha256": "07dfeb39baa4688612acc419421a0f07a86c814673ac9dbb87825e5c9e17086a", "input_original_sha256": "6599cab72dfcd3834bd43980cdb055d873707649e7a174550e63cf8c567b46c1", "input_wav_sha256": "b05219963e3bdad6055af2f71549df27fc79e51c97fb94a0b9f9a891b84cdfd8", "input_pcm_sha256": "9c1258f04f5fb69108e32573232d4a98105aee9aca53765a1379cd322140f0bd", "output_wav_sha256": "4a329bd52c4220a7b4e1aed686aa70ea87e7677347955368c8afc2e9974720b4", "output_pcm_sha256": "6a6efd9694278a3a89c2a50792b7702d8bf3af244e09914ddeb963324acef38a", "result_sha256": "e19bb15ae956bf92a5c60e3709991a52a131989672a3a668c02d19d02363ee86" } }, { "id": 645, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "11", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ed0c2cb16958d4e76899794d51d2c1835124c27a3a6872f3b729b0dfee5552b9", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ed0c2cb16958d4e76899794d51d2c1835124c27a3a6872f3b729b0dfee5552b9", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a grape, a strawberry, an orange, two blackberries, four apples, a plum, and a nectarine. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a grape a strawberry an orange two blackberries four apples a plum and a nectarine how many fruits do i have answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 11.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7930.1, "reasoner_ms": 1925.25, "tts_ms": 25.82, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9881.2, "total_processing_ms": 10607.68 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 778, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 28 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5d1b7c38840464ec64414ef969aa59df94d78f8d3fa64edab1c6c52462e8d160", "started_sha256": "d698c52ea28b20e82a196d1ca0ae141d56e3d1d9faa1656717353ea8afb7447a", "original_grade_sha256": "6535b03199d9d89cb22902dd3a74826740d4c587d0ceb1f57f5cc9c4c306d8e7", "input_original_sha256": "5d1b7c38840464ec64414ef969aa59df94d78f8d3fa64edab1c6c52462e8d160", "input_wav_sha256": "8083338306715b89917107cb89360789808e3ac0f2db76e8d271565b283bc3f8", "input_pcm_sha256": "c25c4e334fda094f3614e14df784ea1d7af168643f4f5be18b8310b5f89b3d02", "output_wav_sha256": "1eb962f6888b24297a8fc64b3727fda92ce3679e49adee4e9f3e5a884de3a0ea", "output_pcm_sha256": "12cc1b15c2e20ae42a2e5ab5f339e6e07bee5a989ef6381cf5253bfd8cf444ba", "result_sha256": "8b444c0dfa27e0793e853f6199d230a2da8e0616f30390a5447bfd63ba0659bc" } }, { "id": 951, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "72f07d975e1cd0e955d825db900ecb98b7500bf155b62da96eb647e0100abe8a", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "72f07d975e1cd0e955d825db900ecb98b7500bf155b62da96eb647e0100abe8a", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Jamie tells the truth. Michael says Jamie lies. Sherry says Michael lies. Bernita says Sherry lies. Amberly says Bernita tells the truth. Does Amberly tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Jamie tells the truth. Michael says Jamie lies. Sherry says Michael lies. Bernita says Sherry lies. Amberly says Bernita tells the truth. Does Amberly tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5833.23, "reasoner_ms": 1917.23, "tts_ms": 24.38, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7774.86, "total_processing_ms": 8385.85 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 113 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a4eeb42a174be8ce50de31a1222d329f57087c4ed0688b0f035f1bdddc442a30", "started_sha256": "d331820e5b61a11ddf98f0a4d4b87735ff32d79dd91b5e6f7e98b24fdcb7bb46", "original_grade_sha256": "e482a39fe0544e48cd2bc7a70298885c6e4d6775e3764c70c4f3228a71515502", "input_original_sha256": "a4eeb42a174be8ce50de31a1222d329f57087c4ed0688b0f035f1bdddc442a30", "input_wav_sha256": "83b52b6a2b6d7ea76bd4a398ef8d089040043e275a623f739865b56b5c5df542", "input_pcm_sha256": "373b28b5976ba7eaa41bc94bdf1b924f1eaf0be6122d0549e0b035ebd34cfbe4", "output_wav_sha256": "003f3e6b7f9f2be6b7e0a70a7b28d849576967371633f2f868bd946bd9cba699", "output_pcm_sha256": "b693e3ebbb09569b8f120d236f933edf439e4f473487eb8b3526f77bae456f99", "result_sha256": "dff81799a9ea37a9055ff3279809e85e73df3b929c83194b1a3610579b7f6161" } }, { "id": 139, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "fac4951b2a10c7870ea0867dd399848d56f394f4e054ebea8b78983eb6585895", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "fac4951b2a10c7870ea0867dd399848d56f394f4e054ebea8b78983eb6585895", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First premise: Every loyal buyer of Dawn soap is neither an infrequent user of Redken shampoo nor a regular consumer of Pro-Active soap. Therefore, whoever is none of this, a regular consumer of Pro-Active soap or infrequent user of Redken shampoo, is a loyal buyer of Dawn soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nit is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First premise, every loyal buyer of Dawn Soap is neither an infrequent user of Redken Shampoo nor a regular consumer of Proactive Soap. Therefore, whoever is none of this, a regular consumer of Proactive Soap or infrequent user of Redken Shampoo, is a loyal buyer of Dawn Soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or or invalid. Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11778.95, "reasoner_ms": 2906.58, "tts_ms": 30.87, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 14716.43, "total_processing_ms": 15311.13 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1049, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 147 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d5e13f1a17bcd152b766889cd66998e8641bb3e2940922277a6e261cedc5a5ee", "started_sha256": "0ae04dd7ddd07fa77042fc93f59409653086eb95b7d9e45860344a93f0c0f485", "original_grade_sha256": "d6124a6c03ae97c0cb7ebe7eade58639e64ab6a35b7624530c1fc15bce5a5d44", "input_original_sha256": "d5e13f1a17bcd152b766889cd66998e8641bb3e2940922277a6e261cedc5a5ee", "input_wav_sha256": "94476bd8c3caabefa565af0baa32813093127383ee5d80158abc69587f57236c", "input_pcm_sha256": "b9411381000f402d88b575c1216a39a971fda15cb4688e8bb42ffb904d8a72b6", "output_wav_sha256": "c09eb5087f97c979297be1058971545c0a9173aaa3cc611163622fc894bc7acb", "output_pcm_sha256": "c85793aa4efcc865aeddf0c244f8b411e7e5947d8888c865829ee080a6324939", "result_sha256": "094a5f4c646250da521645258b76eaa6ddf4fea096a199ce92a34791686fc4c4" } }, { "id": 320, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "86e60b83eeeba390a0b9e81cb94dbf32de8b95760d9cd1643e04802094cb4869", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "86e60b83eeeba390a0b9e81cb94dbf32de8b95760d9cd1643e04802094cb4869", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps backward. Take two steps backward. Take ten steps forward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take 8 steps backward. Take 2 steps backward. Take 10 steps forward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5130.04, "reasoner_ms": 1776.41, "tts_ms": 27.1, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6933.59, "total_processing_ms": 7498.25 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 810, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 44 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5ffc1d5e726840dd965b972939a499068da40cb851ae09d35aa25700e02428a2", "started_sha256": "73926977d113dd1a052b4558a1142ea0632a7b87bec8e8c04faae4676295b5f5", "original_grade_sha256": "1067a5ad1edf8824c439f279cea114b3bea1c9ff2f3482ed260079c9fdd19b41", "input_original_sha256": "5ffc1d5e726840dd965b972939a499068da40cb851ae09d35aa25700e02428a2", "input_wav_sha256": "e7ca54754a388f42563e584df65c95167d8041fad568e819215269a66d757c35", "input_pcm_sha256": "40b383ac28068ec23b2a6c6032f9a7eca27328861088dde1adece2c95588c61b", "output_wav_sha256": "fd0278565982b469af14258e7dabf9cee7e83acb0e0efafd81f4e16bda87a018", "output_pcm_sha256": "19347247c9339ddeae84a75a633804b4fdfc830e19afb6b622ae39e45e7a5942", "result_sha256": "59470049660b62b84735b5a904a2670bdc81fa2b0ef58041922481f40638d1db" } }, { "id": 688, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "3", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a577a3a0fe290c81627991286a9eeec95777e757e30e5b50b378e0c48e68ec1d", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a577a3a0fe290c81627991286a9eeec95777e757e30e5b50b378e0c48e68ec1d", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have two blackberries and a grape. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have two blackberries and a grape. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 3.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 3946.35, "reasoner_ms": 1379.09, "tts_ms": 25.85, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5351.31, "total_processing_ms": 5907.93 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 729, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1e0804a2609656d7b7eea1f4ba4c23a244bb1175c873106c206023ef7b1c0720", "started_sha256": "1f6a9dffd9a04088ac5340f31f9b69b13c696c38503e7202be8a206acb12c96e", "original_grade_sha256": "04673e5dc2925aa8028799b697f3a4ac96ff438d5890aa592f7f3a7c26280c0f", "input_original_sha256": "1e0804a2609656d7b7eea1f4ba4c23a244bb1175c873106c206023ef7b1c0720", "input_wav_sha256": "0758fe097f149eb759e714cefeb578027a66262ef500d7113659cd18751a070e", "input_pcm_sha256": "5891c986fcc49f6e0e67da6ef912d05cce16ca0de7cf0343c4d1e852f848bdb6", "output_wav_sha256": "127e9adc0410ed703ecaeecff35df225f42cadf46295a13c538da09096531d9d", "output_pcm_sha256": "bd0eacecc0efa12dd64f1ee2f7efc5e10774ac9673605827daab0d73aefcc578", "result_sha256": "05e9e3c78bf42c223ac62598a6f5b5d1ff1fb141082f916d1631d604df6b64ed" } }, { "id": 842, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ab30866dd22e28ff572d1b49ebb3cd5da51fa8a4b8ea28edec1280b2a472b6df", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ab30866dd22e28ff572d1b49ebb3cd5da51fa8a4b8ea28edec1280b2a472b6df", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Jim tells the truth. Tamika says Jim tells the truth. Hayling says Tamika tells the truth. Jamie says Hayling tells the truth. Conception says Jamie tells the truth. Does Conception tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Jim tells the truth. Tamika says Jim tells the truth. Haylene says Tamika tells the truth. Jamie says Haylene tells the truth. Conception says Jamie tells the truth. Does Conception tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5621.06, "reasoner_ms": 2064.66, "tts_ms": 26.37, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7712.11, "total_processing_ms": 8238.61 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 849, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 81 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8594dfbbc05c72bcc495b278ecb8ea195f1cb6bf9ea9e1d529d0fd76d861b51e", "started_sha256": "f8105a8632edc40c1e310bc719460ae917a6603c1e4dfed38ffeb4afd8d75752", "original_grade_sha256": "f0fcd1d19443236f145739f2bd5219fbbd2530bc962b164b9baf7e9416cea781", "input_original_sha256": "8594dfbbc05c72bcc495b278ecb8ea195f1cb6bf9ea9e1d529d0fd76d861b51e", "input_wav_sha256": "bf40064516f311ab07986268c339c2e96c090e94f1506f946269dcc608f736e9", "input_pcm_sha256": "4c67d2cd5a7823e124958396cbfa3982b181a2f9f5b824fcbc9bdcfb8dc8e91e", "output_wav_sha256": "8775db9c98ce04a55c69630d79f274612d3784391cc139304c790dafaa64fdc9", "output_pcm_sha256": "f48f089e81675eb8b2bb73611283e34a28b05bdc22f6d33aeb2ffbf793fa11b2", "result_sha256": "67405cd368321366b7358aeb65e39625512de7df80c90fb9c25cd52332de3211" } }, { "id": 222, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c2bc1b416260591a287bdb210c91be50a320157fa7da4e890870b87231ae6b96", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c2bc1b416260591a287bdb210c91be50a320157fa7da4e890870b87231ae6b96", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, everyone who is an uncle of Dennis is a half brother of Troy too. Next, whoever is uncle of Dennis is at least one of these: a half brother of Troy, a brother of Matthew, or a classmate of Henry. Hence, every uncle of Dennis is either a brother of Matthew or a classmate of Henry, or both. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nit is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, everyone who is an uncle of Dennis is a half-brother of Troy, too. Next, whoever is uncle of Dennis is at least one of these, a half-brother of Troy, a brother of Matthew, or a classmate of Henry. Hence, every uncle of Dennis is either a brother brother of matthew or a classmate of henry or both is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14688.21, "reasoner_ms": 3418.96, "tts_ms": 27.54, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 18134.74, "total_processing_ms": 18747.16 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1046, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 195 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e19a90b2dca6d1bc7619fe6651ad306824860b59231219a0d1ecc36f7521080e", "started_sha256": "6d8060a0e28fe96a85a3ea937a3efaba2cdac2e0dd4601c9e4dcb8db10d121c2", "original_grade_sha256": "a87ebbc6c3f83eed7732d0be12e9e1dee967b64bb918fe3f2cdb569d147b97c1", "input_original_sha256": "e19a90b2dca6d1bc7619fe6651ad306824860b59231219a0d1ecc36f7521080e", "input_wav_sha256": "e194739fb9f73985e20f262069cd13ba42f39e79bda271281fdafee7669786fc", "input_pcm_sha256": "fd29c16afdb9d2f26743d1c4784c684fd4fb0ed307d01af011addb0c51276df2", "output_wav_sha256": "dd7a1cd47572ab2289a61b43ef1b8010fdecb0614040c802e590258b95432146", "output_pcm_sha256": "28888e1b4e1e431a20d82343d723e5357f565ef5dad83ab01b789c8fbfe9d50a", "result_sha256": "d5345eb92068175db4714c4c97d3a6946e3d66ad185a9e00b38263dd759cce0e" } }, { "id": 314, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7403ddd9eef27f72f035b245f47d96d5431a88eb2b207509fddad9025ba1c25a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7403ddd9eef27f72f035b245f47d96d5431a88eb2b207509fddad9025ba1c25a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left. Take four steps. Turn around. Take four steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left. Take four steps. Turn around. Take four steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5121.8, "reasoner_ms": 1738.69, "tts_ms": 24.18, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6884.7, "total_processing_ms": 7452.62 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 785, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 38 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "334d7ae13b271d3abe1f1ef765414b88a5bb9de404a3c4898b9c328c59e9f285", "started_sha256": "8e87330e8137f387e4a89e7015f69bdbe77bd1fdb8fe4b945226c8e7f00ffcae", "original_grade_sha256": "ad7fd477966eb80b5101ca77d6c7dfcf80b2b2ef5b5fce188a887a7720ef1c2f", "input_original_sha256": "334d7ae13b271d3abe1f1ef765414b88a5bb9de404a3c4898b9c328c59e9f285", "input_wav_sha256": "10c9caaa001acb50664cb6494c15d79ae426217775ab849eee30a8aa23ff7045", "input_pcm_sha256": "ebfde12869329a90bb1ecf8e3819008c2549c6028fbc180cebcce7d78fb16939", "output_wav_sha256": "892d58859b315d324c7dfc930f3cba4f620e5cc82d273506a6b1183da30b7e4c", "output_pcm_sha256": "451a5aca5c8b02b531c71fc036914c2699ef21b3edfd3606916eb464f03ac77b", "result_sha256": "3db567e61f9ebb4307ee0fb1e7ec2c3f512e1281020dc89013fc902417cc303f" } }, { "id": 698, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "14", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "82c90b851b14c6f8d91302e48b0ffb810d14649016d93a29a818a0bc4313f176", "normalized_answer": "14" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "82c90b851b14c6f8d91302e48b0ffb810d14649016d93a29a818a0bc4313f176", "normalized_answer": "14" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have four cauliflowers, a garlic, a cabbage, a potato, a head of broccoli, three yams, a lettuce head, an onion, and a carrot. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have four cauliflowers, a garlic, a cabbage, a potato, a head of broccoli, three yams, a lettuce head, an onion, and a carrot. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 14.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5229.44, "reasoner_ms": 2504.25, "tts_ms": 27.12, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7760.84, "total_processing_ms": 8412.2 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 816, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 135 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "cdcf9a6d25291f582d32b9af756088596d38028291d1c064640fce2b160fde03", "started_sha256": "6469d77a52d09c3af5115d5730902fcb13e58c565842af09f3b9f42fab0e96d6", "original_grade_sha256": "a6124404c1d1573ff66264230605546d8b96c6c19943e896be1e1e43ce889375", "input_original_sha256": "cdcf9a6d25291f582d32b9af756088596d38028291d1c064640fce2b160fde03", "input_wav_sha256": "154df5e11fc47a0627222e5098bcf4e9fa8280fb6bff0deb24de0f82e1ac46f1", "input_pcm_sha256": "4f2e57fd23efa5133db69f0621d4eb97e1bea143725577766b5348274f5f4216", "output_wav_sha256": "2e46793dc9d51d4abbe721d33ed43a45ce3e229a9f653b22fe2ac476b0ff3254", "output_pcm_sha256": "3f2d13853165266599d885876570c9968448fbb5593ccf246acec9760dbf3699", "result_sha256": "0ec759e44ff8c339f15f0ae9254664507417dee1c20fddf51f3d577c70b1a2cb" } }, { "id": 881, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "incorrect", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e1dcaf74f914fb5d6da2ca1530c33764d0cf946f61686dddd45e55bf17dca0a5", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "incorrect", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e1dcaf74f914fb5d6da2ca1530c33764d0cf946f61686dddd45e55bf17dca0a5", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Christie tells the truth. Eleanor says Christie lies. Jamie says Eleanor tells the truth. Jamie says Jamie lies. Alexis says Jamie tells the truth. Does Alexis tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion, Christy tells the truth. Eleanor says Christy lies. Jamie says Eleanor tells the truth. Jamie says Jamie lies. Alexis says Jamie tells the truth. Does Alexis tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5440.46, "reasoner_ms": 8327.98, "tts_ms": 24.05, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 13792.51, "total_processing_ms": 14303.31 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 845, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 616 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a557e807b4260b44e67567a69d55227f02d9bb16c66b60471cecbdf010869248", "started_sha256": "9e20da94c416caa515c09fa7886c17efa25282c5b6e9af05f605d2de9e62feef", "original_grade_sha256": "3522530027f47a6b9cb84f68889f1c6d0ecfa72746a9af00690a98647138a45e", "input_original_sha256": "a557e807b4260b44e67567a69d55227f02d9bb16c66b60471cecbdf010869248", "input_wav_sha256": "e6b709468fbda877c1b3e414b0ef271f66350e36b8e3cf86c8fcbdad409bc534", "input_pcm_sha256": "8349689228a78279f623a6df46bc9686d22a734938a8257b68565441a641e3d1", "output_wav_sha256": "2039f1f11b370082b6fe5e11417f6a6c16a6ba6bdf108b2a0cdbb5df33936d14", "output_pcm_sha256": "7f67fdd79928cf99804247f58e1ed31a7eddcc526336422cbd9e8760f577e690", "result_sha256": "4e8fa5913308a1338c2038acbdce244d7210749c48d4bb586a0f31370e4db90d" } }, { "id": 144, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8a964179b99f002dbd732849457ead3d22fdccb80a54bb34be0fcb5f4556ec5b", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8a964179b99f002dbd732849457ead3d22fdccb80a54bb34be0fcb5f4556ec5b", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a fan of Liverpool? Are supporters of Real Madrid devotees of PSG? In European football, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of the mutual admiration and dislike. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations: Every expert of Yeni Malatyaspor is not a friend of Wolverhampton Wanderers FC or not a fan of FC Arouca. Being a friend of Fenerbahce SK is necessary for not being a friend of Wolverhampton Wanderers FC. Nobody is neither a fan of FC Arouca nor a friend of Fenerbahce SK. From this follows being a friend of Fenerbahce SK is necessary for being an expert of Yeni Malatyaspor. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Fred a fan of Liverpool? Are supporters of Real Madrid devotees of PSG? In European football, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of the mutual admiration and dislike. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. Every expert of Yeni Malata Esper is not a friend of Wolverhampton Wanderers FC or not a fan of FC Iroka. Being a friend of Fenerbahce SK is necessary for not being a friend of Wolverhampton wanderer's fc nobody is neither a fan of fc or roca nor a friend of fenerbahce from this follows being a friend of fenerbahce is necessary for being an expert of yenny is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 17155.55, "reasoner_ms": 4676.98, "tts_ms": 32.62, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 21865.18, "total_processing_ms": 22405.01 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1129, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 359 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e7d315f413151c817ad8b2eaf4333a6ce16345c9bbb067c1ff8e98da0890a389", "started_sha256": "928bf3e47bff0a50038835263c944e0239072986534d200d6331c53663a52328", "original_grade_sha256": "3198a7385219681149a2a3da4d77d8b9727ad4b6bc163b96cd1319d890684ef1", "input_original_sha256": "e7d315f413151c817ad8b2eaf4333a6ce16345c9bbb067c1ff8e98da0890a389", "input_wav_sha256": "e04ba7629b8ddddb16c66026f6b29bbf0c3e4f509638eabf35605f0fcea0e62b", "input_pcm_sha256": "7cbfcb89aa90ed04281cde2179777d5fa0639259cb5fd85befa02dc44510e187", "output_wav_sha256": "57b8cf01f7e8418cb71fac849f656cb44f9d79f2b3ca3ca8412ae8c6563fc7e2", "output_pcm_sha256": "f3338af1feb8e328d81f54c7da76b6762f5e7a895338777ceb85de4de40dfca3", "result_sha256": "c6f5754ee3a50e245ca520efd63f6a167a4f84b900a3ea7c3fda7c399716a001" } }, { "id": 268, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c045f3208585aa7ae05b005b2b33b57628d4cd14253eac82b687050925c8f2e3", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c045f3208585aa7ae05b005b2b33b57628d4cd14253eac82b687050925c8f2e3", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take three steps. Take six steps. Take nine steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take three steps. Take six steps. Take nine steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5083.18, "reasoner_ms": 1721.4, "tts_ms": 24.9, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6829.5, "total_processing_ms": 7457.64 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 779, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 31 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "56ad923b80f6edb5bbbb75321babb00de1e38bc939c5af610cbed474f58c3467", "started_sha256": "0be189785e54de6d6c97de747136adcf74fe1a708357afbc20ae6a64773d028a", "original_grade_sha256": "ec15f238ed348b9a31c8cd0b78cf2acc0f26a2719f11a598a76282b72767961c", "input_original_sha256": "56ad923b80f6edb5bbbb75321babb00de1e38bc939c5af610cbed474f58c3467", "input_wav_sha256": "97c4c3ea822e518131a00f6f206551b777a6985ef12df2034d08286b01ee33eb", "input_pcm_sha256": "6f2657ba0f9d78606d48cb9670ba904498b69dc3db22410005c106fd7d6bb11c", "output_wav_sha256": "4b15504d175731f644164b6c3dbd50d6c7673d0b409aeaba795e0bcf0f7464a2", "output_pcm_sha256": "aea5644c12eb7802781f02ece48724e9d12b3bf8bfde67b2f2f41255f8fb4062", "result_sha256": "bd1dc72c3b5358fe0e3339336c153f3aa6c8fa15d5a4c8f048f49e915f5f2fd0" } }, { "id": 501, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "15", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a23ed2ce3fdc67a29769a748b48b155bdd4d431681f8b66ded1f1ca6f145fcc6", "normalized_answer": "15" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a23ed2ce3fdc67a29769a748b48b155bdd4d431681f8b66ded1f1ca6f145fcc6", "normalized_answer": "15" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have an apple, three bananas, a strawberry, a peach, three oranges, a plum, a raspberry, two grapes, a nectarine, and a blackberry. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have an apple, three bananas, a strawberry, a peach, three oranges, a plum, a raspberry, two grapes, a nectarine, and a blackberry. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 15.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5251.93, "reasoner_ms": 1543.36, "tts_ms": 26.48, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6821.8, "total_processing_ms": 7380.86 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 814, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 34 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e206bc7b8085079b237851c87bba6fbf50732765a084b30eedf5bbe801cecab2", "started_sha256": "576d70c6b759bc94c794bf1ef751740af7536bbb1f8aa83ccc2b2946cdb3d4fa", "original_grade_sha256": "d1add1e626ed9b1df5cec2c9d2ab7f0d182dcabc68d48d8eb1743c64f411f95c", "input_original_sha256": "e206bc7b8085079b237851c87bba6fbf50732765a084b30eedf5bbe801cecab2", "input_wav_sha256": "d52ce0b3d4a9eae1e3edae88a25666599b177c74d3f0075af552bb6ad753b9e4", "input_pcm_sha256": "5320346d1c126f40605b603dd85248ffc103177d85d04cec911006ecf42c33ef", "output_wav_sha256": "15654ae3772f1bd3bfd15d7da7866046c4bde05f8a44d870d9a2d599b37e884c", "output_pcm_sha256": "5f3f6fd3248759e05fcda353bee5c927e05a7dbb4beb3c9cdcbe59ccf162daa0", "result_sha256": "d2591705279a39cbc3e56f1f5e81fb3fa015c74f6a5821204b8a36749cd06037" } }, { "id": 874, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "143e453adf93a1242683068108f89110d9a0d5fb4f062755ee06cd682f4c2c8d", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "143e453adf93a1242683068108f89110d9a0d5fb4f062755ee06cd682f4c2c8d", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Willian tells the truth. Phoebe says Willian lies. Alejandro says Phoebe lies. Loreen says Alejandro tells the truth. Christy says Loreen tells the truth. Does Christy tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion willian tells the truth phoebe says willian lies alejandro says phoebe lies lorene says alejandro tells the truth christie says lorene tells the truth does christie tell the truth answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8295.62, "reasoner_ms": 2255.65, "tts_ms": 25.36, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10576.65, "total_processing_ms": 11131.42 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 832, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 106 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ac89116e40e9c2f768431bbea577de0870e820c5e33892ff71bc56ff0b707b1a", "started_sha256": "b18fa8f054087d6c5c31f5f7b5b7ee03ab0e94ebda3dc8f8c13d9b53619e01e4", "original_grade_sha256": "c3dc37d64cf4f25c2b1332cc7ebe576a6bcf1c46d1fecf7ee26047e70277ff69", "input_original_sha256": "ac89116e40e9c2f768431bbea577de0870e820c5e33892ff71bc56ff0b707b1a", "input_wav_sha256": "b2f1f7e4afc890a8dc2cb3bf7e5b9aeb075698ea66504d03a4b08d167e1b6d1c", "input_pcm_sha256": "36b849067a8ba778da55b6ee3574e567c10cd854d2aeda73daa4abbc9fb225bc", "output_wav_sha256": "8283fb647552c13288e9fc90a14afcf660199242d017730443b748cffbdc5842", "output_pcm_sha256": "5dbc16e88e1cf04652bb4fbcb7ab681d121684b92496ec01d8233bbae9a88190", "result_sha256": "fc4b04946b52f72e9ecf178db13067cb0d86362707a2ad81657580f308104c59" } }, { "id": 123, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "eb78cf5279886249243d43df1e1174ee894306d93b2fe77407ad0ebfae7af5b4", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "eb78cf5279886249243d43df1e1174ee894306d93b2fe77407ad0ebfae7af5b4", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. It is not the case that Manuel is a half-brother of Chester. Whoever is an ancestor of Jeremy is not a half-brother of Chester. Hence, it is false that Manuel is an ancestor of Jeremy. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom, and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. It is not the case that Manuel is a half-brother of Chester. Whoever is an ancestor of Jeremy is not a half-brother of Chester. Hence, it is false that Manuel is an ancestor of Jeremy. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid-invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8725.81, "reasoner_ms": 3567.87, "tts_ms": 28.62, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 12322.32, "total_processing_ms": 12899.13 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 972, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 207 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "44af2c592f479a5fccfd85dec73cd262faf14ffc8573cb16ebd3232952a1e374", "started_sha256": "e406d8eda5ff993a28eeda4959eb977d5c213c837ab1d817d0be348127eedccd", "original_grade_sha256": "9ce79caac2eac2649ca2590d80fe0247c4cc002f6e152b481dbc3cf90f98b833", "input_original_sha256": "44af2c592f479a5fccfd85dec73cd262faf14ffc8573cb16ebd3232952a1e374", "input_wav_sha256": "abd8c12d9eed4c52823129eca6f08814fb7484d9bda7285a8c700ca3697c6cac", "input_pcm_sha256": "656f5dfc236245498f427a57329f8ea04a06e256924bee796ff376cdd53cc175", "output_wav_sha256": "1c6f15a85a56729ce02e9fe1e822ab4553f0b83e1f4951c254e79d22f370740d", "output_pcm_sha256": "99bd8c8a7fec56d579b42af174164082914fedcd4dbf53035d2f2f64f2c09c6a", "result_sha256": "06143f1457cd27f5eaf374b70d6dc038554015f045bce868ac9e4354b27be7ef" } }, { "id": 469, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d72392ed1aab21e46f0746a631a631337f2fc1fa41f7471c97871de13cdeea36", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d72392ed1aab21e46f0746a631a631337f2fc1fa41f7471c97871de13cdeea36", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn right. Take one step. Take seven steps. Take one step. Take five steps. Options: Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn right, take one step, take seven steps, take one step, take five steps. Options, yes, no, answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5393.27, "reasoner_ms": 2042.39, "tts_ms": 20.13, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7455.82, "total_processing_ms": 8020.18 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 791, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 52 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f8029ca155d2fe315433a6dc8eac9c37be121b8ca8978666f9ab0aa64bd87e1a", "started_sha256": "9c71bfae7166bf66ee8e1b519a30d23a022d8374cfdec9d396482e3fba1a0e87", "original_grade_sha256": "309bcf5eb91656a3eec37a8978383fcea1fceec51fbf7d7072c04b5f16f01902", "input_original_sha256": "f8029ca155d2fe315433a6dc8eac9c37be121b8ca8978666f9ab0aa64bd87e1a", "input_wav_sha256": "b79359208191ff9f6ff49baa7d09db46f16f4e4aa6aa03c2a1209cfba1beb239", "input_pcm_sha256": "0d9226aa1941ba00fe9c1126ca6e0fcca2e7114450b86d4f0b8f474673c5f615", "output_wav_sha256": "b6a4ba1dc9a9e7f51a850af30a2ff4013bdd45060e6b985fd747c263a0d33a5a", "output_pcm_sha256": "9a36765f6ea56a9d1d96180e149ee773ca9f1f4cd70881860e07d3e2f5e17110", "result_sha256": "1feeeb9a9afec5ff62615981321dc614055deb82fe1a695dabd9199e00594ede" } }, { "id": 732, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "14", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c617e5cdfb711ec665ff13442c23936d71d783ae929910c6f84e069ec1bb66f8", "normalized_answer": "14" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c617e5cdfb711ec665ff13442c23936d71d783ae929910c6f84e069ec1bb66f8", "normalized_answer": "14" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have an orange, a grape, a strawberry, three apples, a plum, a banana, a raspberry, a blackberry, a nectarine, and three peaches. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have an orange, a grape, a strawberry, three apples, a plum, a banana, a raspberry, a blackberry, a nectarine, and three peaches. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 14.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5108.98, "reasoner_ms": 1996.88, "tts_ms": 27.04, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7132.93, "total_processing_ms": 7710.03 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 810, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 96 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "12c2fbebd023790d6ed0a0e0547cecd46f2295e9bcc1f4086dab42ec916d8ef4", "started_sha256": "e25da809bcb855ec188da1151a80d7ad354ae8c78bc8ed5de77ef252780561cd", "original_grade_sha256": "62b723ebd7247d0bcf65770d06e594bcbb8a0b27914d1f73a68dfae7615182d0", "input_original_sha256": "12c2fbebd023790d6ed0a0e0547cecd46f2295e9bcc1f4086dab42ec916d8ef4", "input_wav_sha256": "b2493a6e87941e7f2334daefe8b1d5ec9e66c7c7cbeed4b86cad8ed8f2aa2de3", "input_pcm_sha256": "b4525c4928acd2d465a86926d0ca3661c2d2d077839b4d1da277fcbe2bd886fa", "output_wav_sha256": "16d615992c50a8f0512f8f48041ab24a909c480b6e153457de68286f9cd8a7b3", "output_pcm_sha256": "24665890f3850afc2e0703b9467c510a9c98472655064c182eb2badc438d89cd", "result_sha256": "9b79445d65f107c083f6066158d6f88864f9c9e98462e09f2bf870ad6a7eee5e" } }, { "id": 926, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bd6b4c1b773e73d22510bd2e01713470e462deaa5961b86ebe946af4732eca9f", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bd6b4c1b773e73d22510bd2e01713470e462deaa5961b86ebe946af4732eca9f", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Vernell tells the truth. Fidel says Vernell tells the truth. Amberly says Fidel lies. Loreen says Amberly lies. Eleanor says Loreen lies. Does Eleanor tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Vernel tells the truth. Fidel says Vernel tells the truth. Amberly says Fidel lies. Lorene says Amberly lies. Eleanor says Lorene lies. Does Eleanor tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5713.08, "reasoner_ms": 2434.11, "tts_ms": 22.61, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8169.81, "total_processing_ms": 8763.86 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 843, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 113 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "084c93ee3b67b2e64b1eceb92564939c60cd4e8bce52db8243a510e375ebc0d8", "started_sha256": "839f07562d6aa52e0b5456886f353be36c4c6e4079b4a0d591d1657b43acbe6e", "original_grade_sha256": "484054997466f23469ce7891400af6db46cf8fec5f3397463596aafa494c2f98", "input_original_sha256": "084c93ee3b67b2e64b1eceb92564939c60cd4e8bce52db8243a510e375ebc0d8", "input_wav_sha256": "ce951072c51765f5668d63bea8669fc0702ba8d42d374686da910acb29a1f579", "input_pcm_sha256": "e0cb1e2faf590c214287c4f969363c6bd56c6b924ef5dfb8578422c0deb3b6ef", "output_wav_sha256": "1b696a40cc3528bb7fe0ab054984c38aab656e29f5bdb3d4ecf305846e748b0f", "output_pcm_sha256": "1e0660219a4cb3625d42b72aa3d49af3d2633ea0f9c25712d27dd6d8ed09ec6a", "result_sha256": "0ae69864fead4c5b7ce73a6cf6cec0026a5dcf9a8698c3f09a8843f53d5159e0" } }, { "id": 47, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ef399c33832f6564b0ee29ebb26ec4d9176764bcec31090ef2e7c2e965fe0916", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ef399c33832f6564b0ee29ebb26ec4d9176764bcec31090ef2e7c2e965fe0916", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, every close friend of Myra is neither a cousin of Sue nor a daughter of Tommy. We may conclude that no cousin of Sue and no daughter of Tommy is a close friend of Myra. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, every close friend of Myra is neither a cousin of Sue nor a daughter of Tommy. We may conclude that no cousin of Sue and no daughter of Tommy is a close friend of Myra. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options Valid Invalid Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 10725.07, "reasoner_ms": 2498.38, "tts_ms": 23.33, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 13246.81, "total_processing_ms": 13820.68 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 868, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 130 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "91cfbc58a28f8375295a78612a83c9a0497db9c78692fe3b02d0530f000eb753", "started_sha256": "5cd7a659f974bc99a0f671f0ad2b67a1dffc2aded47d78adab73dcd8eb0b55f5", "original_grade_sha256": "b60334f087489f579968b13fab28224c22bb102b58b0f4e4765dd55aa6aa1abb", "input_original_sha256": "91cfbc58a28f8375295a78612a83c9a0497db9c78692fe3b02d0530f000eb753", "input_wav_sha256": "59b504ca705a96e089eda454f3221c7b018745340935ac9aaac82aad8bd62322", "input_pcm_sha256": "57a067823e8a4a65c58a8d85a2fc38ae1380532b12ffdf9e2de16d5c3a2a6d7d", "output_wav_sha256": "6b090f55c9d59d5ee2d6e15d350536fecff84fecba5e900d811619b389cf9698", "output_pcm_sha256": "d629a27100b6159171d97449d9eb74ef7cf737c8856c4f6c12c92f9d30f03bf2", "result_sha256": "888f51420af219bedcbaebeb202fa36b06b2bc965852541359f83c620e33d25a" } }, { "id": 277, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "998869958739ed1b9a407b767ba37a05c742b7f0f848f319471effcf3e4172c9", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "998869958739ed1b9a407b767ba37a05c742b7f0f848f319471effcf3e4172c9", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps forward. Take five steps backward. Take five steps left. Take five steps forward. Options: yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps forward. Take five steps backward. Take five steps left. Take five steps forward. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5894.9, "reasoner_ms": 1912.64, "tts_ms": 24.23, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7831.79, "total_processing_ms": 8399.66 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 815, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 44 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1f3da6c7367d4bc769beac65e926400de4dca833f6b6536e004af458ad941244", "started_sha256": "2955ab383d8ba706a5e96ed7026f99b4312a068fd4be9c6c3090519c43d7eec9", "original_grade_sha256": "c90ee45e21a3d38bf83de679a4ca67df52ce0fe2bbf1b1f803e264b20d6af921", "input_original_sha256": "1f3da6c7367d4bc769beac65e926400de4dca833f6b6536e004af458ad941244", "input_wav_sha256": "bfeff64fe91e7ae21e24313ad51163d9e4ab1776d3de0115579e32c3c9a35529", "input_pcm_sha256": "aef9f79ade982a127bb34c0ede5601f6bfbec9f4b77dfc156ef2480ddf11192e", "output_wav_sha256": "0d5ab059924bbd184fd82ddb06b6b3d42159f21ef4ab9be45f506c703e35ff0f", "output_pcm_sha256": "5093baf6575cf176d674aa6066dd859a186b232dc06e7c37505669e86223e107", "result_sha256": "a501d6f34df2828734926a69b2a57b7e55d4ee0ebcd147073753d1c6624697ad" } }, { "id": 722, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "4", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8afdac732ed8c4571ebd884a6a497aff2a08f36c3eb9661aeaa940c674989d53", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8afdac732ed8c4571ebd884a6a497aff2a08f36c3eb9661aeaa940c674989d53", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a yam, two lettuce heads, and a head of broccoli. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a yam two lettuce heads and a head of broccoli how many vegetables do i have answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 4.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6574.95, "reasoner_ms": 1615.24, "tts_ms": 25.24, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8215.45, "total_processing_ms": 8808.52 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 755, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 35 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "10def79e963bf2c92f8e59133e0b7c1000a8250881d269776f60497f623b8dbf", "started_sha256": "fdcd6f766d1a33edeb33311937e10f1e9b411a92f7b2876b977ddfcc7a01c748", "original_grade_sha256": "c5ca48499d73bb97972720a566a5e9e37760b52a43cc381ca1aa8f8e3be52bc5", "input_original_sha256": "10def79e963bf2c92f8e59133e0b7c1000a8250881d269776f60497f623b8dbf", "input_wav_sha256": "3274608027681bbf5823a1dd8897e3df68e5e41c919c973b0983c733511f943d", "input_pcm_sha256": "4b4a606249f8a7f91bf8c56ed144b133c39d9d6213a18de3b559b144c85ba90e", "output_wav_sha256": "ceda600eae997a97fb631961bd2532f3099e830ed0a499f52f436695a818ba18", "output_pcm_sha256": "b92df566ed2c501273348e08a87cfd98da2bcad9cd5a11baddf2a043a6b16f1e", "result_sha256": "2fb7b221f8e97cf277a3202a5ace11509fd5f05a8810722b2d0f481a85fb4742" } }, { "id": 866, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "51ace6e19b73be888524d831aa10af167c7a8fb4b66ef98860277fa7d4780d3c", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "51ace6e19b73be888524d831aa10af167c7a8fb4b66ef98860277fa7d4780d3c", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Conception lies. Rashida says Conception tells the truth. Alejandro says Rashida tells the truth. Sherry says Alejandro lies. Amberly says Sherry tells the truth. Does Amberly tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Conception lies. Rashida says conception tells the truth. Alejandro says Rashida tells the truth. Sherry says Alejandro lies. Amberly says Sherry tells the truth. Does Amberly tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5469.51, "reasoner_ms": 2308.68, "tts_ms": 19.85, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7798.06, "total_processing_ms": 8424.82 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 844, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 114 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f289ccc1fe092c139930764c0092dfb6c129b7f8c5dbba952109e2a2ec0ef229", "started_sha256": "2b90579e5a286f06e8b9dcc17ba046a442e8d0624924c7e8e201d696c4bd1463", "original_grade_sha256": "7670c7eaa157837b7ebb530bff17d94ab19cfe5853b5bff18e6e54e5e48e3732", "input_original_sha256": "f289ccc1fe092c139930764c0092dfb6c129b7f8c5dbba952109e2a2ec0ef229", "input_wav_sha256": "c79a164d5d5553b4cfa6d67e546cb79fefa07c3aad75e47f8a5a38315c092e20", "input_pcm_sha256": "74adb4c2c326b695aa43541631b21137bd2c9b532fb2ae5a9d5737ee1f4de3ad", "output_wav_sha256": "f00ad21314bdcec1896f7a32f433344e069400abe1dcde0bf01eb5a77e18dc10", "output_pcm_sha256": "3aeea300dcbdd4872d018efb7668c0baa6e9b44b01db810b249f7ae84b131703", "result_sha256": "ab6c13c7f0b4babb0823760b6f6e35c07c669934fb0fee0de37768f2292c6ee3" } }, { "id": 148, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "30a422f23f12c3385848a838ea80e1a35a52aa44e4618dd528083b1cb2c98e58", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "30a422f23f12c3385848a838ea80e1a35a52aa44e4618dd528083b1cb2c98e58", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First, being an infrequent user of Aveda shampoo is necessary for not being an owner of a Bio Ionic shampoo. Second, every loyal buyer of American Crew shampoo is a frequent consumer of Celtic Sea Salt soap and an owner of a Bio Ionic shampoo. Third, nobody is neither a frequent consumer of Celtic Sea Salt soap nor an infrequent user of Aveda shampoo. From this follows every loyal buyer of American Crew shampoo is an infrequent user of Aveda shampoo. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First, being an infrequent user of Aveda shampoo is necessary for not being an owner of a bio-ionic shampoo. Second, every loyal buyer of American Crew shampoo is a frequent consumer of Celtic Sea Salt Soap and an owner of a bio-ionic shampoo. Third, nobody is neither a frequent consumer of Celtic Sea Salt Soap nor an infrequent user of Aveda shampoo. From this follows. Every loyal buyer of American Crew shampoo is an infrequent user of Aveda shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13836.14, "reasoner_ms": 8700.48, "tts_ms": 21.69, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 22558.34, "total_processing_ms": 23111.59 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1189, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 569 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1b1749cf15a6b5f0c5f92db2f9976d068cab9b3119a93bf9129a6fbc82f6c4dd", "started_sha256": "d8ea98c39e664fac913ecefa0589e53a059cdb394382eda235f0e4b8ac2633b6", "original_grade_sha256": "a008c3d5a20dff1a094cb1bb2cf73539fe5a4c3fe5714629d821f81c0d146434", "input_original_sha256": "1b1749cf15a6b5f0c5f92db2f9976d068cab9b3119a93bf9129a6fbc82f6c4dd", "input_wav_sha256": "4b0cbb4fcf24297282de990739a2dd571d90969b3b625ab97bb97614efb8c52b", "input_pcm_sha256": "6e85735d687e2f1b94ac47b4ae0a771897c24f17fcb85aa66590a63499443f48", "output_wav_sha256": "e646b1ca108d032326ac8385f9c99d0412486e8852f2ace38dccf96f4fda91ec", "output_pcm_sha256": "31136d7b55660c1e34690013719863c7499b8a333d7efee223d9dfce2db3d360", "result_sha256": "adf5b763369db8525f96960e27f7a1b53e9ca37b5353e95d949539c0265a5b40" } }, { "id": 313, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "83c3093d0a992ffb833bd5db76b68ee056b1f5a0e3ff9c1dca0e8445bee08b81", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "83c3093d0a992ffb833bd5db76b68ee056b1f5a0e3ff9c1dca0e8445bee08b81", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take one step right. Take nine steps left. Take nine steps right. Take one step backward. Take three steps right. Take six steps backward. Options: Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point always face forward take one step right take nine steps left take nine steps right take one step backward take three steps right take six steps backward options yes no answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5178.65, "reasoner_ms": 2087.28, "tts_ms": 27.55, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7293.51, "total_processing_ms": 7865.18 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 818, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 45 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d0cc96a9bf5fc2325e4eae542f24e0928771f365061881a6591501928734cb3d", "started_sha256": "a929b8b2a1722fef2c43398e84f156a4b772afced755b947c3cb25e2aad3e6f2", "original_grade_sha256": "f2ce258fa6afa659b84609bf4bc610f53c2dcbd524ab9df9cac69875e6fc024c", "input_original_sha256": "d0cc96a9bf5fc2325e4eae542f24e0928771f365061881a6591501928734cb3d", "input_wav_sha256": "98e830af5fea5da2d8b81f9dabb0bee566874f978fad84a5caf0b89b536df950", "input_pcm_sha256": "143bc9a10fc1d4a1f619c1a7a38ccffb8fa30d3fb607f26c38cec9c0834ff0d9", "output_wav_sha256": "d30a389e28ff7fb8314a5b6eee2ca1b634ced0096b93f2203923a9e9750930ea", "output_pcm_sha256": "4a8b91b7c79dc6e40955ab4100b0c595a8008c1a3617a3dbb67c9a4aa26ad9c5", "result_sha256": "5991ee4c71fbcf0220c2b50199909784ee930ecc6a611b01f1bbd2f698f19b2c" } }, { "id": 669, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "6", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f52fd688592c3971ac49a56ab5890aad6241a121cdeeadd9e27703fb33861076", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f52fd688592c3971ac49a56ab5890aad6241a121cdeeadd9e27703fb33861076", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have two chairs, a toaster, an oven, a table, and a couch. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have two chairs, a toaster, an oven, a table, and a couch. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 6.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4207.54, "reasoner_ms": 2171.93, "tts_ms": 24.4, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6403.89, "total_processing_ms": 6934.59 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 752, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 43 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "fb9f799d51d5ee42e2eca278f649780f49af3c9f526be81c641944a13b9cbd8c", "started_sha256": "2b0f4b9dcd975b97dda7160f2e53d2687c5bfc692eee198d53090c3973994429", "original_grade_sha256": "18f336874784c2e36318a8b6e30419da529fef3fed8312ffc45d633f7251073a", "input_original_sha256": "fb9f799d51d5ee42e2eca278f649780f49af3c9f526be81c641944a13b9cbd8c", "input_wav_sha256": "10ef065c520438a6ef7379d20c396f8bc06340c598e27cb0d2e31fa8f67dd194", "input_pcm_sha256": "a629d4a4d6ea648c0be11d0324cd944a73a8fe7eab56c2ccc4296ab40ee421aa", "output_wav_sha256": "5d8166c552051c07df9a5459da6af6919487c8087387f1263ed4342e552a9e32", "output_pcm_sha256": "38f3c16276ecda698d819e98b9454ecd798c0f287296817f00c249784ca7a02f", "result_sha256": "bf9b1a81f92cec88535992fe8d7ee9b3c979befb2964172a7ccc9d08fdf233b8" } }, { "id": 798, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ee43d461bccc7ccfebfe3843e27e67e2d7cd31aa6d134a7d1ded1fd7e6ad1b67", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ee43d461bccc7ccfebfe3843e27e67e2d7cd31aa6d134a7d1ded1fd7e6ad1b67", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Audrey tells the truth. Yolan says Audrey lies. Shonda says Yolan tells the truth. Raymond says Shonda lies. Maybel says Raymond lies. Does Maybel tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Audrey tells the truth. Yolan says Audrey lies. Shonda says Yolan tells the truth. Raymond says Shonda lies. Maybel says Raymond lies. Does Maybel tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5203.15, "reasoner_ms": 2152.61, "tts_ms": 23.1, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7378.88, "total_processing_ms": 7906.7 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 840, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 106 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d099e13359ff06cc79b4b55447b287a199ad4f89ee646b640168662292027c3a", "started_sha256": "d6ecf99ec8e1a1d8e0f5aecb93bdc1edb4dc25f577e1e62fad103b83d41d79c3", "original_grade_sha256": "91739c2debd7ca2cf79762578bcbb4a71479ae27a103fedf7c9ac9ee2dbaac91", "input_original_sha256": "d099e13359ff06cc79b4b55447b287a199ad4f89ee646b640168662292027c3a", "input_wav_sha256": "aa83794aad36858f83e42ac8b6261ad7ef203bee2e9e0f9f8c17ad70f4db616a", "input_pcm_sha256": "36640cae76ab622661f945d4340a872690f965b87bed374908dfa5e06e539c2b", "output_wav_sha256": "e1ebc67f2822116ffc16505a6cc57ec63eb4437fee62df94919596af0703b680", "output_pcm_sha256": "383107446beb89e20d8f214548871816ee29b66289ba68fb65fb34542914a4f5", "result_sha256": "319e266543aa8237c3b9ebf4f05424c0e207a541f489138481b49bc4ea3e27ac" } }, { "id": 202, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "67ec22b91d36412434c9c736cc61fd2e4aa533ac2321957f5f5eb7d28d95222a", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "67ec22b91d36412434c9c736cc61fd2e4aa533ac2321957f5f5eb7d28d95222a", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, nobody is neither a classmate of Georgia nor an ancestor of Geraldine. Next, every workmate of Regina is both a classmate of Georgia and a workmate of Carol. Plus, being an ancestor of Gerald is necessary for not being a workmate of Carol. Therefore, everyone who is a workmate of Regina is an ancestor of Geraldine, too. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, nobody is neither a classmate of Georgia nor an ancestor of Geraldine. Next, every workmate of Regina is both a classmate of Georgia and a workmate of Carol. Plus, being an ancestor of Gerald is necessary for not being a workmate of Carol. Therefore, everyone who is a workmate of Regina is an ancestor of Geraldine, too. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? valid. Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12770.34, "reasoner_ms": 7393.48, "tts_ms": 31.17, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 20195.02, "total_processing_ms": 20807.77 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 953, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 577 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f62162f9187c2aa4ce0327b477cde5f5f26409e4bbd3457f03517f767738b433", "started_sha256": "1b16de850940bf16a2db6aed2a4ddce47518c390dad7c61cd7f28047f5d425b6", "original_grade_sha256": "d3bbdb8d6db705a94952eeb41b119f4096f11b95de46b2f7ee667f9875bba98b", "input_original_sha256": "f62162f9187c2aa4ce0327b477cde5f5f26409e4bbd3457f03517f767738b433", "input_wav_sha256": "8a2b8e4de1071d857cedd341aec860d0759d72b7a6c9b4652fd6e5b3d1642173", "input_pcm_sha256": "b9eb16c71c5e8e1d44565f9a56bbdd8896dbf3973f7a66de8890b5545fac2385", "output_wav_sha256": "75acfd622cca16d57e78226bf1d48c86a47f6cdcb09e4a80ad9933e30a31fcbf", "output_pcm_sha256": "36f4d1c04e5dfc042c2f561292fca674934191d28321fe64c277f28473b9afd6", "result_sha256": "2ac6850aef081333bd3491ca7bcae847ab0e6534c8eaa8ba093467024e2a1c37" } }, { "id": 491, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c615e3a866428d39530a8b1866052aa04682374d7b62f652899835c3b36e2654", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c615e3a866428d39530a8b1866052aa04682374d7b62f652899835c3b36e2654", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take ten steps. Turn around. Turn right. Turn left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take 10 steps. Turn around. Turn right. Turn left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4540.47, "reasoner_ms": 2528.83, "tts_ms": 27.69, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7097.03, "total_processing_ms": 7654.92 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 786, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 73 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1b398dea7020c564ce10fa87c478547561d7556e0fa82570ee37dc9debacd993", "started_sha256": "d27b6395680783463d4a8e1cf19d631f9e6c609784f7921939dc134b18111471", "original_grade_sha256": "855f5739bcf1e27d3205798f7d2b93188008c49e66c41742d71433b1f113dbc5", "input_original_sha256": "1b398dea7020c564ce10fa87c478547561d7556e0fa82570ee37dc9debacd993", "input_wav_sha256": "a6e2a140a6fcbba36db7b1742f1ab6c762f7b5eedfbbb5523866d19c622fc69e", "input_pcm_sha256": "3ad77d99cb277620a63c39c860a26a2a6b94775aeabc021af8c766200f505c08", "output_wav_sha256": "c8206f1154f68bfe3244f1e3b3d1b7e02fd4e23d902f5608ef30b3afc271d281", "output_pcm_sha256": "6a97cecc4a01ef4dfb33ffa377579b46dbed826fc38f493d8863becdb2751626", "result_sha256": "9e6dc8fceb40afb8c86726d3fc178276ca024d963f682301d634f42c23ba4105" } }, { "id": 721, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "4", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ca188461fc05cc4c65aa610426736414fa70cf9188da53e4d2231fb82b91a21b", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ca188461fc05cc4c65aa610426736414fa70cf9188da53e4d2231fb82b91a21b", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a peach, a nectarine, a banana, a raspberry, and a duck. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a peach, a nectarine, a banana, a raspberry, and a duck. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 4.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4218.38, "reasoner_ms": 2816.67, "tts_ms": 25.5, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7060.59, "total_processing_ms": 7612.82 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 759, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 45 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a11347be22ee97e3bcc15b9f199198b32522a389038ef754e3fa41586f9bd226", "started_sha256": "74ebaf0e0f018990fdec8475b8a668b8422971cdc5e0a923ba8307ecec8c89ee", "original_grade_sha256": "a533f93aaf37f05b554b8ad72470985d37a840c2c8d2b0ea5b6d9204c6326a69", "input_original_sha256": "a11347be22ee97e3bcc15b9f199198b32522a389038ef754e3fa41586f9bd226", "input_wav_sha256": "f2b25a70f27debbe59d061b26f48cf5edc2cc509ff60f91026b7601153d96940", "input_pcm_sha256": "c7135211598d5d4021eae400bdc3d3a303f71f6874a5f2abecd15049897475ab", "output_wav_sha256": "c7b5a465fb8ccdfbc5aa69fdebfe66aeaa448311cd0d98c4af1d2ffcb857deff", "output_pcm_sha256": "150fb4922871337e22fc2b4149a347385f7d4b405cb28afc105eb68a1ea5087b", "result_sha256": "86c9e7c1409aa4e8e8ccf297617f551895629ca4a3ba83347639d46fd866fd1d" } }, { "id": 794, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4ad6ff64bcfa065f10d5e82b40c31b12275dd7cff986dd10cfeb733c6617af55", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4ad6ff64bcfa065f10d5e82b40c31b12275dd7cff986dd10cfeb733c6617af55", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Millicent lies. Alexis says Millicent lies. Inga says Alexis tells the truth. Christy says Inga lies. Gwen says Christy lies. Does Gwen tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Millicent lies. Alexis says Millicent lies. Inga says Alexis tells the truth. Christy says Inga lies. Gwen says Christy lies. Does Gwen tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4944.7, "reasoner_ms": 2146.71, "tts_ms": 24.48, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7115.92, "total_processing_ms": 7705.81 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 825, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 108 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1e60a621ced0a2f016095ba4e1879a1f2e24bba46d7e7291619f8e5ffbe1705e", "started_sha256": "344ded24a40cdb05d543e7c8edfec865006e10dfc62f0eb40ecbf735dd53ed98", "original_grade_sha256": "627ba27f2b93f86648119348a90b7230561b89ff2f970d73bf70b7028036455f", "input_original_sha256": "1e60a621ced0a2f016095ba4e1879a1f2e24bba46d7e7291619f8e5ffbe1705e", "input_wav_sha256": "aefdfd455d12d09d1c60dbb2451ffdc10e0ffb704e8e5f33534a9838aa51a70b", "input_pcm_sha256": "7869789e88fbc9f589f01164f4167bca5da7fbf1c46134782e9d99f64c03c008", "output_wav_sha256": "0e0ae874472405bba55c6bda265e864bafb260012e9e4a87dd5126e288575bfd", "output_pcm_sha256": "9b2bb719acd93118bc028a5432cf8bd72c89fc2c7c46ae83112f911a0e169206", "result_sha256": "6aed8eda55ac9aeb8943e37b38360b702d2e83f810cee4d26fe4d6fd11b790bc" } }, { "id": 92, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2bf066c513821d9d8cd97c0db3f73c1eb15898b2da622749d213b5191b780ad8", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2bf066c513821d9d8cd97c0db3f73c1eb15898b2da622749d213b5191b780ad8", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise: Nobody is neither an occasional purchaser of Yardley London soap nor an occasional purchaser of Palmolive soap. Second premise: No owner of Aveeno shampoo who is an infrequent user of Zest soap is an occasional purchaser of Palmolive soap. So necessarily, whoever is an owner of Aveeno shampoo and an infrequent user of Zest soap is also an occasional purchaser of Yardley London soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise, nobody is neither an occasional purchaser of Yardley London soap nor an occasional purchaser of Paul Mitchell soap. Second premise, no owner of a vino shampoo who is an infrequent user of Zest soap is an occasional purchaser of Paul Mitchell soap. So necessarily, whoever is an owner of a vino shampoo and an infrequent user of Zest soap is also an occasional purchaser of Yardley London soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12163.17, "reasoner_ms": 3513.87, "tts_ms": 20.16, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15697.24, "total_processing_ms": 16273.9 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1093, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 162 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "9f75bd05a7bc47fe85f006aecf84bfa4a459b295f92f9df326d794aaa441e9fa", "started_sha256": "c0ca1362a7eb60918447e2a521a637f4d77c13bd76bc5f69246d1237602a9b4b", "original_grade_sha256": "e3edc3a52a1fd78b655b0ac6d82096fcd9f923907bbbae1f66df8f28528ee594", "input_original_sha256": "9f75bd05a7bc47fe85f006aecf84bfa4a459b295f92f9df326d794aaa441e9fa", "input_wav_sha256": "af98a2f034967f68a2f2af2a7d41d7627699dc1b9cc4018940193edf14f85adf", "input_pcm_sha256": "e144c4d42a0a20414108a5a417af89571b8051519ed40d908eb343907a347c23", "output_wav_sha256": "c28e5b16b64abb656a4e3cc63330afb462631b5574a69e88f3c3d8206b24b9fd", "output_pcm_sha256": "6554f0c3a35b32f498ce379102597ca4448340458fb08b7c68dd15d88a7645e1", "result_sha256": "337c209993b0ea5dbdcb414a4ba3e6d66106ec53fdd67e019062d9ae8d4c2b75" } }, { "id": 442, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3aface6c2bac4f370ee9f390c6e4a7024534035562ab97a40ef9ec00aeee7cd5", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3aface6c2bac4f370ee9f390c6e4a7024534035562ab97a40ef9ec00aeee7cd5", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take ten steps backward. Take nine steps backward. Take nine steps backward. Take nine steps left. Take ten steps right. Take three steps right. Take three steps forward. Take nine steps right. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take ten steps backward. Take nine steps backward. Take nine steps backward. Take nine steps left. Take ten steps right. Take three steps right. Take three steps forward. Take nine steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7760.9, "reasoner_ms": 2327.0, "tts_ms": 24.07, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10112.0, "total_processing_ms": 10648.72 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 885, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 81 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2ea9e558989af6c1f0a449595c6ee04a16252ac90dfe4b8254dad6d7a089f897", "started_sha256": "974afbe43f240983fdd9769db451577603638d77494222463191a01b7190335d", "original_grade_sha256": "492e53c8f2e74c07c000693b43c8a6d5349dce42413b60966ce982dafc307cd6", "input_original_sha256": "2ea9e558989af6c1f0a449595c6ee04a16252ac90dfe4b8254dad6d7a089f897", "input_wav_sha256": "36d104410cd884cca522c13a6a0e638c087fe88410e24f3c595251c920742e32", "input_pcm_sha256": "8cbf5f23568e648f602d55f5232e28a606a4586397ba56ced01011dcbb4bfef8", "output_wav_sha256": "3772b99a87c85f93b04015e693a925f6d12d138ab45b0b88fd94854612bcfd70", "output_pcm_sha256": "637567cc4f78045dedfc9802c37f6612eb8b1fa96b83455b37d185acd8a72f6f", "result_sha256": "6e95e4dbddfe8f84b3872112a4d5859508140ddd01846ace1122b7e8697c9b6d" } }, { "id": 624, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "13", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9528e7c0304493bcce99a8bab21e7d225b82ca6b3e52301dbcf13aa90bbaf3e9", "normalized_answer": "13" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9528e7c0304493bcce99a8bab21e7d225b82ca6b3e52301dbcf13aa90bbaf3e9", "normalized_answer": "13" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a stove, a bed, five cars, a couch, a toaster, two fridges, a chair, and a lamp. How many objects do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a stove, a bed, five cars, a couch, a toaster, two fridges, a chair, and a lamp. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "That answer is 13.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4643.64, "reasoner_ms": 1887.46, "tts_ms": 26.88, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6558.02, "total_processing_ms": 7065.05 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 779, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 77 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "c69ce1fb8cf62644b5254906e0e8fe44c0091d5c102d8f5d8254c970685653db", "started_sha256": "2270b0960a33bb30c2f71aa48383944d4d0d8523f1d097b81b7bd6cf9837c3da", "original_grade_sha256": "0cc6af09398d2f68b7217fcef77a1ac5beff3566e3d677c0bba0d5b39729bd14", "input_original_sha256": "c69ce1fb8cf62644b5254906e0e8fe44c0091d5c102d8f5d8254c970685653db", "input_wav_sha256": "d3143fee2414949f24915a55c7fd20ab3384bf6e8a64b9b9287d7fe4cf69dee7", "input_pcm_sha256": "6668e5ca309a25e510a6684982642e854813bd69e9f56dd2a83f5fbd9ffb1f6b", "output_wav_sha256": "ce4210071864568557e32af360c1ba4333d61c35792d172c8fd177be869477cb", "output_pcm_sha256": "09d06761e07f9fe56592f33dce06649ac457e72b44ff2fc2c44e597377f1f3e3", "result_sha256": "87efef00a5038d4e1b079833881864952913cf6920c141205c6d76ce2fe3c40e" } }, { "id": 814, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e4b289c3dc8a518a4503ac58a3f9c94821ab4be441e482363b2ffed38b362771", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e4b289c3dc8a518a4503ac58a3f9c94821ab4be441e482363b2ffed38b362771", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Krista lies. Michael says Krista tells the truth. Audrey says Michael lies. Sherry says Audrey lies. Michaela says Sherry tells the truth. Does Michaela tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion christa lies michael says christa tells the truth audrey says michael lies sherry says audrey lies michaela says sherry tells the truth does michaela tell the truth answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7947.59, "reasoner_ms": 2390.11, "tts_ms": 22.81, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10360.52, "total_processing_ms": 10946.66 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 812, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 128 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f122062507edf00a556cd80c7302850bae4b8d14838cee41b1858ce3fdd95a99", "started_sha256": "d272e948b5b56159a4971c0a84e273f9280cc4af06fd2ff8589d4a6256393305", "original_grade_sha256": "5afbc56aed23f0131fc7350d2c59f7a6b7f09c3f1516275b4327431fefe621f6", "input_original_sha256": "f122062507edf00a556cd80c7302850bae4b8d14838cee41b1858ce3fdd95a99", "input_wav_sha256": "dc09b4838254e6e33a115a97057b737e8590e532cabe01e6f0c2c66263ad688b", "input_pcm_sha256": "7016523544129b0bfc99eecb6a05073bc82b8a6c6e86d83ed868afafd0e76667", "output_wav_sha256": "3a533be9158c7817001aff797f8c224079b04535c3a0a34308d21b3cd333948f", "output_pcm_sha256": "eda5911db1d3eb81d9998a92a9cd5b0670429b3f445cbf2d866a3be052246052", "result_sha256": "85852666ed22d7217c902af46850d6b66b66c8e9d0d8dd1d2cff5382337bc89c" } }, { "id": 169, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "68236e61bbc9a15ba41685f52e8652d14a3101337b97142af93b1315f142b5fa", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "68236e61bbc9a15ba41685f52e8652d14a3101337b97142af93b1315f142b5fa", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, nobody is neither a rare consumer of L'Or\u00e9al shampoo nor a loyal buyer of Dial soap. Now, everyone who is not a loyal buyer of Matrix shampoo is not both a loyal buyer of Dial soap and a rare consumer of Softsoap soap. Moreover, being a rare consumer of Softsoap soap is necessary for not being a rare consumer of L'Or\u00e9al shampoo. It follows that nobody is neither a rare consumer of L'Or\u00e9al shampoo nor a loyal buyer of Matrix shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, nobody is neither a rare consumer of L'Oreal shampoo nor a loyal buyer of Dial Soap. Now, everyone who is not a loyal buyer of Matrix Shampoo is not both a loyal buyer of Dial Soap and a rare consumer of Soft Soap soap. Moreover, being a rare consumer of Soft Soap soap is necessary for not being a rare consumer of L'Oreal shampoo. It follows that nobody is neither a rare consumer of L'Oreal shampoo nor a loyal buyer of Matrix shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13307.19, "reasoner_ms": 5016.67, "tts_ms": 42.98, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 18366.88, "total_processing_ms": 18938.2 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1081, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 353 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d3b74f42da7dca1bc4b90065d2e61893360a38d5cc7c3a74543d79cc4d641f6d", "started_sha256": "a82631b10f2e199ca4ed95690c81e3b3c331143c591af475d0dd925c301aa193", "original_grade_sha256": "802721d20f783fb7920fe1e4e4f49cb243d1884708e4a6e93112b4966b28fe36", "input_original_sha256": "d3b74f42da7dca1bc4b90065d2e61893360a38d5cc7c3a74543d79cc4d641f6d", "input_wav_sha256": "08a5a331d9543eea64bb77d6f95f1dd845d59ffee4468cfcbab6cfc263d8c2ef", "input_pcm_sha256": "9b3b09f2ab98d6141c80bcc341e02f834d8a0dc8d29374652ff6d20e6c95b8e6", "output_wav_sha256": "d863c073e0ce80e32c814e7257c4a4431a7d5f318be600026c0e1a3c62322a2b", "output_pcm_sha256": "1a0f946a3de7208af6f2d0072329a5713f8a58775be51840fff18ddc0ea096c6", "result_sha256": "dd25de8172e85a7540d5d8f59d2a60e6d77febd4f2e717bb38a532ec2c39b0dc" } }, { "id": 286, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f77fe1e3b6565bf518d454a38450fb0192b88951b190c3fff28db6a85cf69cc4", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f77fe1e3b6565bf518d454a38450fb0192b88951b190c3fff28db6a85cf69cc4", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps forward. Take seven steps left. Take five steps backward. Take four steps right. Take three steps right. Take four steps backward. Options. Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps forward. Take seven steps left. Take five steps backward. Take four steps right. Take three steps right. Take four steps backward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7080.7, "reasoner_ms": 2496.76, "tts_ms": 27.32, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9604.81, "total_processing_ms": 10166.42 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 847, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 101 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "86ffc7b721a37a45a9ce425e1c7f78d0d741739d70d1c23f96029d34b23899bb", "started_sha256": "5138196a278c275b53fde9845ac02d1a680859634a0d6a59daa3fab41bbbd3c4", "original_grade_sha256": "67c810967c38672e0c4c2422faa7bbee741aeabffa70e36a38efeb27e75c41ca", "input_original_sha256": "86ffc7b721a37a45a9ce425e1c7f78d0d741739d70d1c23f96029d34b23899bb", "input_wav_sha256": "dca250802db828e458c359315b4c0f81d73abbf0dbe2cc3ae09890dcd1b5588a", "input_pcm_sha256": "cb5491da0fdd558158db404cb28399f1f5adf1dfb222d13cb9256e0053b468e5", "output_wav_sha256": "1ae4ca67ce58aa44fae5dc6ebcff70bb62f0e1ddfcdb265fa940e1b396f9c1da", "output_pcm_sha256": "8f4f7d45be4d3d3eaf5888e6429833cbbac1c36307b76f8e1439d726e91a0b20", "result_sha256": "0706f1bac86d7442d13ad5ba6371a0b527eb79c2d628e074f0c5e24eeb6ca234" } }, { "id": 683, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "6", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "19e1d4766ed95ca44e10c66dad80197eaf8c2dfe53da1569dde81a9788e6d80e", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "19e1d4766ed95ca44e10c66dad80197eaf8c2dfe53da1569dde81a9788e6d80e", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have three snails, a snake, a donkey, and a rabbit. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have three snails, a snake, a donkey, and a rabbit. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 6.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4365.75, "reasoner_ms": 1645.43, "tts_ms": 24.85, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6036.06, "total_processing_ms": 6613.91 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 748, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 44 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b4f7f4edfd2e73f9cbfe40a02b1de3404409255f998de7bb9bf23509659de7a1", "started_sha256": "8f566a51a0607a2332d09e5ae9c56164712bbb60dc003c9aa532e0daf2fa8a4c", "original_grade_sha256": "84eb6b9ea02c026a24ca1ce0f8b76330e94530ee008eedcfcf854b20c6e38a68", "input_original_sha256": "b4f7f4edfd2e73f9cbfe40a02b1de3404409255f998de7bb9bf23509659de7a1", "input_wav_sha256": "7f88118ea360cf1e480c1dd4c211a2eeacc9a5cb8c54a9a3cceb01bbcaa90637", "input_pcm_sha256": "0e623da81bc7b72dc2a42deef76e4a0dd76162adcb91ed0e00e613d2d29984a4", "output_wav_sha256": "78f9fe1d38f4095ecca7ae550c71fd75e27d30cc68f964834d475a8072ef0387", "output_pcm_sha256": "b71b6a77777b6f460afb64b68d5ce0f2df37fae13cb84524116084ccea57bfd4", "result_sha256": "986bb67ad4f2f3168f163c730a78e9e4fbea2180a2a3d24dded944a400d61ca7" } }, { "id": 900, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "07f1413fa3f7002778bf6f41fa86a8075050896de5edaa523ca853c1df56fdf9", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "07f1413fa3f7002778bf6f41fa86a8075050896de5edaa523ca853c1df56fdf9", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Eleanor tells the truth. Krista says Eleanor lies. Vernell says Krista lies. Shelonda says Vernell lies. Teressa says Shelonda lies. Does Teressa tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Eleanor tells the truth. Krista says Eleanor lies. Vernell says Krista lies. Shalanda says Vernell lies. Teresa says Shalanda lies. Does Teresa tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5298.09, "reasoner_ms": 2411.53, "tts_ms": 25.02, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7734.66, "total_processing_ms": 8285.92 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 837, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 96 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e0e55a2b8f6722a49b850b69152be3f24108792307464d275c4ba5f2f07a026a", "started_sha256": "d170d2dc7fab50552b2d9280383f660f89ea85447f44c410f56803f6c0498f3e", "original_grade_sha256": "dcdd8e94fe146bb9b281b672ecb86eff4ecf50c6c35e733b9e0957b6d35ef603", "input_original_sha256": "e0e55a2b8f6722a49b850b69152be3f24108792307464d275c4ba5f2f07a026a", "input_wav_sha256": "9cf6a513163b7510589d34cc3ae32e2034da7c1eb4c1563b11012ea6bae144f7", "input_pcm_sha256": "66f0f2c31a0a66751a644226614fb8e4c6b14d0db80b9d797938a0fe2e669045", "output_wav_sha256": "e5ffa48cc3564c9ef1a6fbd4c021d7bb0c85a709555aa87df99d55e9ac7a1ff1", "output_pcm_sha256": "e1365eff97eb85e0bb94713183f639046a39c61089ce89ba7732fea5b47dab07", "result_sha256": "7e1a543acba47504cb7d125ed2da2ebf5898ba853f2f2c7f543ffb642c108853" } }, { "id": 27, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c5f42a73c84308b29dc75f42415d43f5b2f4b26844b6fb059eafa39e023f4c48", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c5f42a73c84308b29dc75f42415d43f5b2f4b26844b6fb059eafa39e023f4c48", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. Every schoolmate of Jeffrey is a grandson of Todd. Whoever is schoolmate of Jeffrey is at least one of these, a grandson of Todd, a brother of Kenneth, or an uncle of Laverne. Every schoolmate of Jeffrey is an uncle of Laverne. We may conclude everyone who is a schoolmate of Jeffrey is a brother of Kenneth, too. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question, every schoolmate of Geoffrey is a grandson of Todd. Whoever is schoolmate of Geoffrey is at least one of these, a grandson of Todd, a brother of Kenneth or an uncle of Laverne. Every schoolmate of Geoffrey is an uncle of Laverne. We may conclude, everyone who is a schoolmate of Geoffrey is a brother of Kenneth, too. 2. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12758.16, "reasoner_ms": 2702.52, "tts_ms": 26.62, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15487.34, "total_processing_ms": 16045.67 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1103, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 142 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b4a311020f575c57b1278da5a117a7b0e82b1b22be458e9665fe601c3c287876", "started_sha256": "933f538cd463ab5d26e1927d4b3073d3ac873c20759c9a01738a3284bdfda555", "original_grade_sha256": "105acdbbee86ac5c354ac3231e6141817a4d6ba527be45c0771177f83266bbd3", "input_original_sha256": "b4a311020f575c57b1278da5a117a7b0e82b1b22be458e9665fe601c3c287876", "input_wav_sha256": "a8e6ac1a692c2ba1be917c55df10866d335778fe13b1a10427433d2c205dbfab", "input_pcm_sha256": "be6622435bb09ad80f9972658fd6feed1b6a65b9540f8323fb9476356677f1e0", "output_wav_sha256": "444f21c07489b5508d36b877f8864c80e7b5ad2fd7a026fdf331552757ed7fb2", "output_pcm_sha256": "5bb289dca4c260820a65c8c2f0e94a0e170a284da654ffe78dce4808e2f25e4a", "result_sha256": "d339843de8755d5f1ed02b600ce8de87e751cc4ed42df8de764dee8997170a68" } }, { "id": 321, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "33b7f64bc78e55649811cb33214ffbaa8c29a20c795ee1b9be9ce5f62e5c4fe7", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "33b7f64bc78e55649811cb33214ffbaa8c29a20c795ee1b9be9ce5f62e5c4fe7", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps forward. Take two steps backward. Take four steps backward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps forward. Take two steps backward. Take four steps backward. Yes? No? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5503.22, "reasoner_ms": 1651.32, "tts_ms": 24.28, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7178.84, "total_processing_ms": 7822.83 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 798, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 34 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "4336030de455d68c0d084c360d30126d7114bcc2457e77439e5691411c564ef3", "started_sha256": "122135d6b50f5ed547159adbfe57854efd1a634a135d1939392fe867ee3913e2", "original_grade_sha256": "2d3382362e7febd360ab7932afaa1137f71a4f653fa1bb170806f537548719f3", "input_original_sha256": "4336030de455d68c0d084c360d30126d7114bcc2457e77439e5691411c564ef3", "input_wav_sha256": "977c5ef37c5bab8e1dd311b7c796c2f54bb0cc7c3d36bd37fb68c904560b68d1", "input_pcm_sha256": "d43d0a0a546c370c8c18e4366eeb12df34ae1e3b3a9b129ed5601538a875d0ef", "output_wav_sha256": "e43215dfc1e0c214621e741ccd07dd0f8314a185d4441d42b1fca50325b3501b", "output_pcm_sha256": "4605e1006b78e121cb7b4b5026b25adcbfb6eae0dca864b2e08dadddf4f76c05", "result_sha256": "a9154d18b9faf9239c53dcc0f5fc70580e0b9568d8312dd4cb18d33a4421b0b1" } }, { "id": 590, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "5", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4e29c8b582abc37bcc9b718da56adc0de5b2ea4372da21beca9dd39a87df29df", "normalized_answer": "5" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4e29c8b582abc37bcc9b718da56adc0de5b2ea4372da21beca9dd39a87df29df", "normalized_answer": "5" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a peach, an accordion, two clarinets, a drum, a raspberry, two grapes, and a nectarine. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a peach an accordion two clarinets a drum a raspberry two grapes and a nectarine how many fruits do i have answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 5.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7770.64, "reasoner_ms": 1437.99, "tts_ms": 27.21, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9235.89, "total_processing_ms": 9790.41 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 782, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 43 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "70f672e5dabec049719a601f53137e7d018c0fa44b04e6d57d6429735f5b381f", "started_sha256": "f90fc9caa9e26f6181c43d8979d0f7a732033f63d053a802eab33bbd4a3bb188", "original_grade_sha256": "4f48fab60eecf3a17d13830fecaca7f8288828634ed0dfc45ab7f828e9d71ed0", "input_original_sha256": "70f672e5dabec049719a601f53137e7d018c0fa44b04e6d57d6429735f5b381f", "input_wav_sha256": "9ef069d56fbc249118a0c0b70cf7b366904ee8ec06533ae0f50552a87ecdf365", "input_pcm_sha256": "592b18d45e77be22a34d3afdac5f7dec7972662cdc73d461a906664fb50cabb0", "output_wav_sha256": "d59a3ab6228e19b0105bac403c86044a17c445168d2b96b0df703b1ea34c94b0", "output_pcm_sha256": "7209648c09e947446890d72dfde7626389e90262c69cdf3862a734f9661fd0ac", "result_sha256": "e40e99c2255bf68ef2c5135dbda74e2f3c0c314511fae79102633bd2f817cb1d" } }, { "id": 979, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dffbe0bc753c620d745b98e3cc6ee1756367866eafe6238f4443895cfe7c164c", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dffbe0bc753c620d745b98e3cc6ee1756367866eafe6238f4443895cfe7c164c", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Christian tells the truth. Jamie says Christian tells the truth. Millicent says Jamie lies. Fidel says Millicent lies. Tamika says Fidel lies. Does Tamika tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Christian tells the truth. Jamie says Christian tells the truth. Millicent says Jamie lies. Fidel says Millicent lies. Tamika says Fidel lies. Does Tamika tell the truth? Answer the the question.", "output_transcript": "That answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8463.29, "reasoner_ms": 2353.3, "tts_ms": 19.22, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10835.84, "total_processing_ms": 11386.74 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 836, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 111 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1f890286d97a047aecc9ea5886711dd3bc337171963d5c0b11dd1bf2a4d1f765", "started_sha256": "e253b78436c6ae915a8700f1579f30ac2935a2cc17fc99d909c3c665d0e26523", "original_grade_sha256": "60266e7876a87f012b52b7f0f05068c2116da1208cfb11d238fcda4be5a03f3a", "input_original_sha256": "1f890286d97a047aecc9ea5886711dd3bc337171963d5c0b11dd1bf2a4d1f765", "input_wav_sha256": "cfe82fe1c56d41a1a99c13b531abb6895e9b385131da8739c7d46b1d1cc7bdff", "input_pcm_sha256": "e32f567eaa41af494e8509e0280db22ce6359e23765d4d275ba6955f74e77728", "output_wav_sha256": "94650b39296f69111cf609f20049a3efcc43c29a95a1a49f05908d96adbbfd1f", "output_pcm_sha256": "d56dcb6e1c6700211ec4208e73e6e5b75956d1a90ac0e0e615936085029132bf", "result_sha256": "9e3bcc3afb86114504628226857d1941c929c5bf67dec87a814b892f3c720cf8" } }, { "id": 135, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a1f10ec1f3a52034dc3cad6851eb935c096d87eecfb26e7716302bbea7c910e6", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a1f10ec1f3a52034dc3cad6851eb935c096d87eecfb26e7716302bbea7c910e6", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, being an ingredient of Spoiled is necessary for being an ingredient of Silk Eye Pencil 08. Moreover, everything that is an ingredient of Careless Whisper is an ingredient of Spoiled, too. Finally, whatever is ingredient of Just To Clarify is at least one of these: an ingredient of Careless Whisper, an ingredient of Silk Eye Pencil 08, or an ingredient of Blush Rush Bare. We may conclude to be an ingredient of Spoiled or an ingredient of Blush Rush Bare is necessary for being an ingredient of Just To Clarify. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, being an ingredient of spoiled is necessary for being an ingredient of Silkeye Pencil 08. Moreover, everything that is an ingredient of Careless Whisper is an ingredient of spoiled too. Finally, whatever is ingredient of Just to Clarify is at least one of these. An ingredient of Careless Whisper, an ingredient of Silkeye Pencil 08, or an ingredient of Blush Rush, Bear. bear. We may conclude. To be an ingredient of spoiled or an ingredient of blush rush, bear, is necessary for being an ingredient of just to clarify. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid, invalid. Answer the the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 17144.87, "reasoner_ms": 3768.76, "tts_ms": 29.7, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 20943.36, "total_processing_ms": 21556.01 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1207, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 216 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d2f75c5290f70668884299fa0361a01e54e55c0425102fd39544fd14b7ef6a43", "started_sha256": "c9b7a26d08b916996b10f0e5f17c7c9a450ee6c63f5b0dc1e7623b03ba4fc967", "original_grade_sha256": "95807f71eb7fb3cdf06211e31323ccb0e366a3541b86803d58756c628c241109", "input_original_sha256": "d2f75c5290f70668884299fa0361a01e54e55c0425102fd39544fd14b7ef6a43", "input_wav_sha256": "ae578206dc3e86b69821ab7cb7fd3d092d778e1e4a53857883ed9e247ba84c73", "input_pcm_sha256": "768ddab549c7a959373d00f27e1bc4ec957f06e51d0b080ee81b69a7f02c5b8a", "output_wav_sha256": "19c0c1e69594b9058a0313dcc571d48622a150db0068a84bd332c9e8ec278820", "output_pcm_sha256": "f6f0a622c1e46259cbf87ac84e56a2464f4b43e35354e199f35bdce43d930372", "result_sha256": "71bf111f8f1be73c34e41a6294f7b41277d602e0ef442697104d245199af04f6" } }, { "id": 352, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "24c20b44efe0f3b297d3198682ebbe6a1ef8311014ca5bb4869059536b6efa56", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "24c20b44efe0f3b297d3198682ebbe6a1ef8311014ca5bb4869059536b6efa56", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take four steps right. Take seven steps right. Take one step left. Take four steps left. Take six steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take four steps right. Take seven steps right. Take one step left. Take four steps left. Take six steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6595.94, "reasoner_ms": 1666.13, "tts_ms": 25.55, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8287.64, "total_processing_ms": 8812.48 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 824, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 42 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "db5f6ce3613affff22dce9293ccf74b1e771560ce80a2e808db92ae305bfa945", "started_sha256": "71ae8921e61d4c527f3f00db16808d2bd51b3ff5588f77da102e9552d4fd614a", "original_grade_sha256": "361cf1dbe7e4f60043e5c54c001a95eb2a6da9f02fe7e51919265ff0d324d339", "input_original_sha256": "db5f6ce3613affff22dce9293ccf74b1e771560ce80a2e808db92ae305bfa945", "input_wav_sha256": "b263e5326961f640457025177b50f359577e4340f706ae15ba109f885fc618a8", "input_pcm_sha256": "5af6a84f5f37d0fa4a95788fccc60717963ed1c687dac493857db6fc8614f2cf", "output_wav_sha256": "b266b4bc96003a2b0b47fd450a6feeaa30f6b388fa0e8d82cad908fdc9820796", "output_pcm_sha256": "70ff05e0c5396d21a95d73b1b00b16a743feb7b42f5048c5d60026d196397839", "result_sha256": "e9f459296921d05c682095f29a999e56bbb734b6eab4d735bdc45ea6869df8d0" } }, { "id": 734, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "4", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "798fc7b46320afd39e0dc9b9c72bb48941af8641f6fd4a98dae0b93044e8ec42", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "798fc7b46320afd39e0dc9b9c72bb48941af8641f6fd4a98dae0b93044e8ec42", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a trumpet, a drum, an accordion, and a piano. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a trumpet, a drum, an accordion, and a piano. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 4.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4193.98, "reasoner_ms": 1432.59, "tts_ms": 28.96, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5655.58, "total_processing_ms": 6221.93 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 753, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "9daa0e45d13a81062f1d5d75649d7fe43defa195efd9ec55a8f3a0177953eb96", "started_sha256": "28346ce6500536114dbd5f944b1e263301f2e223175d99f770ced5c0eb253a99", "original_grade_sha256": "b44ee9813ee029eeb130686e50884f8edba8b2e7c403df45ed8a34a935a28c36", "input_original_sha256": "9daa0e45d13a81062f1d5d75649d7fe43defa195efd9ec55a8f3a0177953eb96", "input_wav_sha256": "0a03592ebbdf9fbf808d4172f28b441c9146a726591ba845e34e1759588d08b8", "input_pcm_sha256": "4da7e967bc9d1cbf594cfdbc94da9b77ba2af48fc96cd470022d7814c7cef406", "output_wav_sha256": "2645259e6092fe6f79080af78f292658fef4123d3f3ee5e6c0bdc407ffe625e5", "output_pcm_sha256": "c2b4a033aeb2eb519450f9453015bdd8479c1b646ea8d9294b852d1d7b8349e9", "result_sha256": "ceebe10f1a072fd066c2fe3a9484fbdb1f66e63db2228eb78775ab6826e7df27" } }, { "id": 788, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "206c2256a250c867612b71c9cb7331bbfe3dd83257bf3f90e79de9552be41745", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "206c2256a250c867612b71c9cb7331bbfe3dd83257bf3f90e79de9552be41745", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Maybelle lies. Jamie says Maybelle tells the truth. Phoebe says Jamie lies. Willian says Phoebe lies. Shalonda says Willian lies. Does Shalonda tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Mabel lies. Jamie says Mabel tells the truth. Phoebe says Jamie lies. William says Phoebe lies. Shalonda says William lies. Does Shalonda tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5035.74, "reasoner_ms": 2365.21, "tts_ms": 26.67, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7427.64, "total_processing_ms": 7996.39 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 836, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 120 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "bdf98ab7a945e0911d096748c8affdc6778c3de3f5968c7c72b9cc0dbecbcaee", "started_sha256": "78a523a0dc1df4d8f37d0b6e666fc532946f9d64a012386aae2e52429d80af53", "original_grade_sha256": "a4362abe5c2d8a6223b50a093136163ffdda4c00a8030246a93d7d58ccfe23ab", "input_original_sha256": "bdf98ab7a945e0911d096748c8affdc6778c3de3f5968c7c72b9cc0dbecbcaee", "input_wav_sha256": "368220971ce54d951784877384d105b9e458c15186d344924003c1753fdf2512", "input_pcm_sha256": "4b6edf210a21dd87623f184b3d54073d6b930664dc16be9b1729d89f15135852", "output_wav_sha256": "c2d045afffd752752075cdcf98c56753073b40b33030bdcfb14698373f933c7e", "output_pcm_sha256": "66baf5b450837f4b3af9be5faca275c4195764fbb12bf8e2a1f72e92181a097b", "result_sha256": "03b78f4fa2777408ac9233e4dea5197da0c76317b623c76f1b70f863981bea10" } }, { "id": 88, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "180811f2c6dd7afca2c10b490fac5a9bf3ea3a3238227c1215c1437a1a6dbe2b", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "180811f2c6dd7afca2c10b490fac5a9bf3ea3a3238227c1215c1437a1a6dbe2b", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First, some classmate of Sherry is not both a half-sister of Peggy and a great-grandmother of Sophie. Second, being a schoolmate of Leonore is sufficient for being a half-sister of Peggy. Third, everyone who is a schoolmate of Leonore is a great-grandmother of Sophie too. We may conclude that there is somebody who is a classmate of Sherry and not a schoolmate of Leonore. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom, and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First, some classmate of Sherry is not both a half-sister of Peggy, and a great-grandmother of Sophie. Second, being a schoolmate of Leonore is sufficient for being a half-sister of Peggy. Third, everyone who is a schoolmate of Leonore is a great-grandmother of Sophie too. We may conclude that there is somebody who is a classmate of Sherry and not a schoolmate of Leonore. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13532.8, "reasoner_ms": 3494.43, "tts_ms": 23.84, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17051.1, "total_processing_ms": 17725.82 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1109, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 212 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "dc310ddf8d19249a5b2c54e27bbd33241981be21719411674912d35126c142b3", "started_sha256": "8a9a0cc5657282ac026cc58777b69c8d6e7f19633742bea87c3ed0a9108a2ebd", "original_grade_sha256": "c59dd8c9706ce9762fe66dbf21e5d4eec67af647a68721f0e981a0b298e33298", "input_original_sha256": "dc310ddf8d19249a5b2c54e27bbd33241981be21719411674912d35126c142b3", "input_wav_sha256": "82a5730a5027539ed266215b13867fc4eb79e4420e02a022cf9fc1450d4a04b3", "input_pcm_sha256": "d261ef0a9b945b1aa69fa794d2011f50579884b9361092947a4b23b2a5ee26a7", "output_wav_sha256": "ac350aaca75b495cbdd3ce00068371468042129ad1b14cfa8d36d2d37bc3ddbd", "output_pcm_sha256": "ac892dd38ded7bd89350c1fae97cc4bdc4799262fb8de2293b5cf1ecf0630d54", "result_sha256": "6c9108ae15f11a71b794d87024720317999b1391d2f86efba1bf43e6464a8a85" } }, { "id": 275, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dd334f1edb9c57f46c32975b4ca80fb8dd9263a16eddf6676eec2cb60e2d7db7", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dd334f1edb9c57f46c32975b4ca80fb8dd9263a16eddf6676eec2cb60e2d7db7", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take nine steps. Take six steps. Take nine steps. Take six steps. Take two steps. Turn left. Take six steps. Turn around. Take eight steps. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take nine steps. Take six steps. Take nine steps. Take six steps. Take two steps. Turn left. Take six steps. Turn around. Take eight steps. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6875.88, "reasoner_ms": 3248.64, "tts_ms": 18.34, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10142.89, "total_processing_ms": 10679.47 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 850, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 177 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a851422c9ac924485d1ea52ba2f4fd62793b170944a379e76807a8eb8fff24e3", "started_sha256": "248fb4cb45b21a99376036b2ec4181a8a398c7ad0abacabb63f12509adf191a3", "original_grade_sha256": "10a4d5e1afb287888c1552813bf21afe49285000e78a45c383a449ead81626a7", "input_original_sha256": "a851422c9ac924485d1ea52ba2f4fd62793b170944a379e76807a8eb8fff24e3", "input_wav_sha256": "56c2d8a88c17309086ef1306fac4357b6356ee9ce9f705ee4998df7b1a4c4ddc", "input_pcm_sha256": "dc8b76556f7707622010d3186777b5b9d21d0512da26114ed114cfe7f93f717a", "output_wav_sha256": "ad8e13257410eaffe67c5aca9fccc753c695608ce16f9489f3b5cb7ab761b2b7", "output_pcm_sha256": "145fc6f662d61c6c331857100f4d662cf2cdeebe5b5f29f7d0cc2a4a0ca5e199", "result_sha256": "72920a9cb896eeb39ae01ad2ff4feda663fd2f6a3c8513590ab894a26f0d16d0" } }, { "id": 617, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "7", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "09a008117b84f64c7fa329069ad9f01ce72e66fe9779e10d333317d731dea165", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "09a008117b84f64c7fa329069ad9f01ce72e66fe9779e10d333317d731dea165", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have two cows, a fish, a chicken, a snake, and two mice. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have two cows, a fish, a chicken, a snake, and two mice. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 7.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4308.78, "reasoner_ms": 1571.02, "tts_ms": 24.63, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5904.46, "total_processing_ms": 6415.63 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 752, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 22 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8d617bf7f3b686ac41c0111cf36e988f0d1ac66299fdc4c4408be54e38864d8a", "started_sha256": "51473d1aac0e40559be9011e1c43e21a00f7cd382b296146512fd4980cd91f38", "original_grade_sha256": "2c55099185919082d3747904a87b423a15b2ad3698a42a1f7d60cff2005c08bb", "input_original_sha256": "8d617bf7f3b686ac41c0111cf36e988f0d1ac66299fdc4c4408be54e38864d8a", "input_wav_sha256": "4380345c3606d2bfc392146a671d4ab4fa49a944293822cdad82b9c67469062e", "input_pcm_sha256": "6a74feea5c69c278b14a6695d3622440289f847924126b76aebc700dadd4d8bd", "output_wav_sha256": "b20bc15fd4bd25c714f8d45a312290ff12c191ddb3df01a9d867ad5a78497fdb", "output_pcm_sha256": "93310d9c89fc8fd07058392c61eec01dbf36c811c4b429b701ba7b7b3b2427a1", "result_sha256": "4e7b1d04a2262f6109ca8cd2f50c897d35daaae3015fc7eee9b56fddf2144a17" } }, { "id": 910, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7b0614fbe3ec32a5fa9a01ab01e1be0573e568011f85db16244a88947a2a9b8b", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7b0614fbe3ec32a5fa9a01ab01e1be0573e568011f85db16244a88947a2a9b8b", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Jerry tells the truth. Yolan says Jerry lies. Tamika says Yolan tells the truth. Alexis says Tamika tells the truth. Ryan says Alexis tells the truth. Does Ryan tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Jerry tells the truth. Jolande says Jerry lies. Tamika says Jolande tells the truth. Alexis says Tamika tells the truth. Ryan says Alexis tells the truth. Does Ryan tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5670.44, "reasoner_ms": 2513.87, "tts_ms": 24.43, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8208.78, "total_processing_ms": 8739.06 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 852, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 114 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0ca65dc6adcd7f0bacf55ae16df92f9a807dc32a3c66f5ebc4a81f6cb1668328", "started_sha256": "ae8fbeb55f23439d4eda5ce7303dddad152bf5981f4674d6f72cfc1602fbbe8b", "original_grade_sha256": "c4c494d70b7275f66d8fe3a4740ffea070140f66e65ccbdbda754a29ef549163", "input_original_sha256": "0ca65dc6adcd7f0bacf55ae16df92f9a807dc32a3c66f5ebc4a81f6cb1668328", "input_wav_sha256": "c14f04965348bc3a2d2a4f4cc1854c7316aaa783181d74d663866b4f9c4a7eaf", "input_pcm_sha256": "a27f5c557cefecde8ad5a9214ce7be72936152b4be6b2aca5a5b496953891a3d", "output_wav_sha256": "c25ac9847b8e0f0be50f00e02f5cb3c304aec30fcccc1ee45ceb7c183c808b81", "output_pcm_sha256": "186d97f8cc7b76eae5445d500808aead9dcd55d118e04de665296a5313222614", "result_sha256": "fff472f3a63835e3c67a237d1766f7b843066713317ea914454b13ca8c728ae3" } }, { "id": 83, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8a61b158e94bdf966fb3189e1c241cd8d3b3938bde4adf31c7bd23bb786dbcd5", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8a61b158e94bdf966fb3189e1c241cd8d3b3938bde4adf31c7bd23bb786dbcd5", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First, Jonathan is a regular consumer of eucalyptus soap. Second, being an owner of a Lever soap or not being a regular consumer of eucalyptus soap is sufficient for being a frequent consumer of Herbal Essences shampoo. We may conclude that Jonathan is not a frequent consumer of Herbal Essences shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nit is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First, Jonathan is a regular consumer of eucalyptus soap. Second, being an owner of a lever soap, or not being a regular consumer of eucalyptus soap, is sufficient for being a frequent consumer of herbal essences shampoo. We may conclude that Jonathan is not a frequent consumer of herbal essences shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12326.8, "reasoner_ms": 3242.6, "tts_ms": 24.97, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15594.4, "total_processing_ms": 16179.38 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 958, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 200 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "cc13bec2ce6b11d74ac5878b61648dec0f9b3dcc9cae04093accde46bf78bd02", "started_sha256": "0e32efc3ed9864a5008aa6dea876c13704ff40654d67c53c0571a549e568041f", "original_grade_sha256": "ec30d4ca13eab4d76e5601c2b35f4ec472a038052ae12e068b4f91febbb6c6c3", "input_original_sha256": "cc13bec2ce6b11d74ac5878b61648dec0f9b3dcc9cae04093accde46bf78bd02", "input_wav_sha256": "6708e2445c792f96e21abb964a3d30398e79675538f6a3071c338ea07ae05cc5", "input_pcm_sha256": "ade40104f62adf724a75d5467b903a05908796add68a78cf3c74718b70254d33", "output_wav_sha256": "3c2783c034cbf9d13c931fa6b0b3e7d1c08a24b1880ad46ded3975f44c2aaff0", "output_pcm_sha256": "b81311fb441050c3beb7692a366923f666fec4e5d7daa56ddfd0c3f65758d5cf", "result_sha256": "f1dadc5ae9a018ac99f4378d020a9a04320324acf8e04dd630d2989cad131fed" } }, { "id": 429, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "374c80a4f47c56290d4b2f818f4e908fd82753e58120ea91261cd540c9cea918", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "374c80a4f47c56290d4b2f818f4e908fd82753e58120ea91261cd540c9cea918", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps, take two steps, take two steps, turn left, take five steps, take eight steps, turn around. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps, take two steps, take two steps, turn left, take five steps, take eight steps, turn around. Options. Yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5539.42, "reasoner_ms": 3104.61, "tts_ms": 25.54, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8669.6, "total_processing_ms": 9201.21 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 812, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 145 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "62763996fc58b5ac9168a0f6b711aeec680c6e9608b342de2cd4005b0b9b51c3", "started_sha256": "3fe59a9a316fcb075007765aa8987e75486af3f7e34307120348a268397b560d", "original_grade_sha256": "679c98ba12bd234d6024aa536c0a1061e8f33d56773f021c1d4fda06da5b2bc2", "input_original_sha256": "62763996fc58b5ac9168a0f6b711aeec680c6e9608b342de2cd4005b0b9b51c3", "input_wav_sha256": "83f67a2484f95b2494df50131830b56a6c29d487bdd87da14f4bff96c9cb1dd5", "input_pcm_sha256": "db5509bba0cbdfc1ae139ef3d3156ba5dea2d864eec680cbd4db6494dc928584", "output_wav_sha256": "905233c3ac3cbe7050215fad695e85eab59ce6a500a917592a2baca5a2d17325", "output_pcm_sha256": "9250e2d1a85c6f23aa0cb2f8dafc0aab4677fc0c643dce7a629882123928fc31", "result_sha256": "ae047adfe438d64ea0dc7b98169c9cbbacf1507f165ca434cab6a7ef06954a91" } }, { "id": 582, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "14", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0c8326560fc8059ffb89b663a0685dc7ac4ecb3960f2b2fa7c86820c4d7a6453", "normalized_answer": "14" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0c8326560fc8059ffb89b663a0685dc7ac4ecb3960f2b2fa7c86820c4d7a6453", "normalized_answer": "14" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a lettuce head, a cauliflower, a yam, two cabbages, four heads of broccoli, a potato, a garlic, a carrot, a stalk of celery, and an onion. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a lettuce head, a cauliflower, a yam, two cabbages, four heads of broccoli, a potato, a garlic, a carrot, a stalk of celery, and an onion. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 14.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5787.22, "reasoner_ms": 2117.28, "tts_ms": 26.39, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7930.92, "total_processing_ms": 8532.81 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 832, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 100 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "588a9ef6067259c0f9f16e0375fa4bffcd013925daff34caaa8c244964aa8d9d", "started_sha256": "4c6c6b5e368ef6a7dbe2b5a5910a1d8dd46d0a7830434f8e4a850f8719a9a2db", "original_grade_sha256": "873cfa04d02df01c2997f11b962f66d3aaa11fe10a227522281379c35dcc2906", "input_original_sha256": "588a9ef6067259c0f9f16e0375fa4bffcd013925daff34caaa8c244964aa8d9d", "input_wav_sha256": "99df74c7c4b15837de15f7a4b0a9ebec9743d64472b77a65585175880dfceb13", "input_pcm_sha256": "7a887d01d51ef5794854427f7fc1e9bec923aeacc4b6de0dfc5c0af6879a5279", "output_wav_sha256": "ddc7d86e43d58cf9431980c601a4b2aef3d61abad43942120690b2abe296f4ab", "output_pcm_sha256": "a39543eef95b17ff3a513cf1c385211e00a23243abdedc3e72d3c2f642edb2eb", "result_sha256": "04e125da4aae9b9189c81c9f7e7890597175a5fc1667f17ce9e9549e6409b031" } }, { "id": 778, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9940e91220a3e3f8f33c063bfeea0abe6ef50a2bcc1d46ea79a4b4a21d409c3a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9940e91220a3e3f8f33c063bfeea0abe6ef50a2bcc1d46ea79a4b4a21d409c3a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Ryan lies. Christian says Ryan lies. Teressa says Christian tells the truth. Amberly says Teressa tells the truth. Jamie says Amberly tells the truth. Does Jamie tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Ryan lies. Christian says Ryan lies. Teresa says Christian tells the truth. Amberlee says Teresa tells the truth. Jamie says Amberlee tells the truth. Does Jamie tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5186.98, "reasoner_ms": 1948.24, "tts_ms": 24.79, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7160.04, "total_processing_ms": 7699.15 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 843, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 102 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b6a900a7e56bb54085f8a5291789f9cfca69bf371dd4817e9ab08da7366d55f2", "started_sha256": "10c97872c67e8aa5fafd33bdf72b4097a6afbd2faecd0c0269a396612f62aa67", "original_grade_sha256": "bdc4221737c558be2900d734f0e02b2c722c21ba0f3704cdaa5b7ae640bbe5bc", "input_original_sha256": "b6a900a7e56bb54085f8a5291789f9cfca69bf371dd4817e9ab08da7366d55f2", "input_wav_sha256": "7d363608731d9ce52cb98c90002db07c6c55d904de9d8cb255cba406a20dea06", "input_pcm_sha256": "8efd4debc62407e7f2cf8ba52bac045c4444fdcf1f167b4a8335f02c4eaf3375", "output_wav_sha256": "0e2f7132e5ed0d046bbfe88250edb1f4cd90ad1d229bb52e9cd68e1cabe2a45f", "output_pcm_sha256": "60510d45ca54a5a6ef8ead5a114985b31d84e70261e4d114bd8daf7bf749625f", "result_sha256": "dc79966e1f73ac576c1e7182c78c17e16c83572e57b0b8061210f72662c9b93e" } }, { "id": 121, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7aa10e7abf02791e5ff397915f67a7cf473a5a4b16cf3188a5834471452f2af8", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7aa10e7abf02791e5ff397915f67a7cf473a5a4b16cf3188a5834471452f2af8", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, everyone who is a loyal buyer of Herbal Essences shampoo is also an infrequent user of Caswell Massey soap and a loyal buyer of Matrix shampoo. Next, Christian is not an infrequent user of Caswell Massey soap or not a loyal buyer of Matrix shampoo. So necessarily, Christian is not a loyal buyer of Herbal Essences shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, everyone who is a loyal buyer of Herbal Essences shampoo is also an infrequent user of Caswell Massey soap and a loyal buyer of Matrix shampoo. Next, Christian is not an infrequent user of Caswell Massey soap or not a loyal buyer of Matrix shampoo. So, necessarily, Christian is not a loyal buyer of Herbal Essences shampoo. is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question Thank you for your question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 15215.66, "reasoner_ms": 2221.48, "tts_ms": 24.97, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17462.13, "total_processing_ms": 18020.34 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1064, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 99 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "14fcba566c44bd7ee8d9e4796aa5956c57283abfc6741abe41645ef84ee4ac89", "started_sha256": "a4c1826d167a355da99ba334c1604e40713d85aac58a0fd299362f575322110e", "original_grade_sha256": "7af2d4afc2971a2978f7dae07b76db53515f358e2dff8a50adadf107a886627c", "input_original_sha256": "14fcba566c44bd7ee8d9e4796aa5956c57283abfc6741abe41645ef84ee4ac89", "input_wav_sha256": "4a63f555b91c7203950d2a9f99e60fd79303ed6be74e861dfb8831a1a02d7622", "input_pcm_sha256": "17e8a0871871416f09670cbae1f6c8e4b1d5695478241d2f961b5ec1b00c49b0", "output_wav_sha256": "5dd56dedaf2ad73aa23c2505d951eecc056b1df96cfdd78b37c9e78dfb39631c", "output_pcm_sha256": "a8e0932321db4f75267d2eadb37a833f8f875ff3a37e06c91f3b881d17eb8e44", "result_sha256": "c30db51d87be58e5b7e28edcd8e1d1efc8101fcae2fbb84d4ad28bd427fd71c8" } }, { "id": 489, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7d2107043efde2956faa5b558384755ff02adc9f2692de3430eb623005af1579", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7d2107043efde2956faa5b558384755ff02adc9f2692de3430eb623005af1579", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps backward. Take seven steps left. Take four steps backward. Take eight steps backward. Take three steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps backward. Take seven steps left. Take four steps backward. Take eight steps backward. Take three steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6338.47, "reasoner_ms": 1783.25, "tts_ms": 18.15, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8139.9, "total_processing_ms": 8676.54 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 833, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 45 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2db7bac3cffefd255d933fcc980746c824735688129e2e70a7bfb1caf60f826c", "started_sha256": "4faae80e61082457170a085f2b6357b58405b04b6d0473414fa0b1cfda316a91", "original_grade_sha256": "1bb0decbed5a5a69ffc04abe4d939b873fcfa1223601329dd5c87c3a145d86c8", "input_original_sha256": "2db7bac3cffefd255d933fcc980746c824735688129e2e70a7bfb1caf60f826c", "input_wav_sha256": "404b1c0d26efb523866a26bb12e61f50e4d995665f2ddf444caa172e9be25ff7", "input_pcm_sha256": "d87b8e2f673d83a91af9d131f3902a4ef55aa21f32afb2914f1a7a3f439bdd16", "output_wav_sha256": "b8a327f2c31cda221b6b3610653ddaffe9fd9dd75e593d2b1de9b4474b7f357f", "output_pcm_sha256": "b286ddc9aad2168655756e8fb27438e33dfcd1f3089f7e436783802bb540b658", "result_sha256": "299fb7e54eda4491376165c4d8571e923a1946bd3184c988f8999f297b011a3a" } }, { "id": 738, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e44f92d0060561f5812a9cf25bc594cec2968db62168ba6d41d3f1ed098c247b", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e44f92d0060561f5812a9cf25bc594cec2968db62168ba6d41d3f1ed098c247b", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a pig, a fish, a mouse, a frog, a dog, a rabbit, a donkey, a chicken, and a duck. How many animals do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a pig a fish a mouse a frog a dog a rabbit a donkey a chicken and a duck how many animals do i have answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 9.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7500.58, "reasoner_ms": 1636.97, "tts_ms": 25.24, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9162.83, "total_processing_ms": 9769.91 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 787, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 47 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "14c4c6f939cda389a2b34818d4c085d02ca473fe7ef12996403ec83a8fa5e607", "started_sha256": "4bdf853203526737c033659f404ef1a79eac58926eb1d9a3560f2c7173d920f5", "original_grade_sha256": "8189e94697e3006725ad7f6ef7ffbb1bd877b55db2e2fe0d89e43dc1bba5a241", "input_original_sha256": "14c4c6f939cda389a2b34818d4c085d02ca473fe7ef12996403ec83a8fa5e607", "input_wav_sha256": "bbea5890540b18dffb6f82a41810f7bab9faa65875d6c16d20e9656cce299920", "input_pcm_sha256": "efb48a0f7352a1ecd735a888966790aa90bf4e76b7ce7fc0800b826b70d739b8", "output_wav_sha256": "59ea4a31553b87e6c08c0b3fed58cc6dacb16aacfae03684f58c8f598546a1aa", "output_pcm_sha256": "e838f42605bdd573aeb2bfb9637cfa9b82ee9a26fa9e13dec1f782aabf6ebb16", "result_sha256": "734e81c13fddcc881c4ba368a6a51837649e92ad0b4044be8962ec30ddfac487" } }, { "id": 806, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2c89c8bc2ae5a33e18c241c2620aa7bc0d0911a21b84d0d45ff160ee1b8b70cd", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2c89c8bc2ae5a33e18c241c2620aa7bc0d0911a21b84d0d45ff160ee1b8b70cd", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Millicent tells the truth. Millie says Millicent tells the truth. Michael says Millie tells the truth. Antoine says Michael lies. Alexis says Antoine tells the truth. Does Alexis tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion millicent tells the truth millie says millicent tells the truth michael says millie tells the truth antoine says michael lies alexis says antoine tells the truth does alexis tell the truth answer the question Thank you for your question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7910.54, "reasoner_ms": 2302.59, "tts_ms": 25.83, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10238.98, "total_processing_ms": 10801.16 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 830, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 114 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0132722d4a6953601232d19d2911082bb06c36e30cce4f68a73432f0fb442fe5", "started_sha256": "bfa48c79c01d2512bb2a98253c7bc4e8f7ba959dd61800e145c7dff9e3c0681c", "original_grade_sha256": "3dd686ea329a09583ca0b8cbe0e71fc63b151a208837a704d64c6a3dcdcf23b1", "input_original_sha256": "0132722d4a6953601232d19d2911082bb06c36e30cce4f68a73432f0fb442fe5", "input_wav_sha256": "48a4da099a16a1fedec6dc06cd7545797f0bcc09a81d3a2acb2ddabd3ab8c122", "input_pcm_sha256": "483244c12bd9ee6bd2b21cc3b7406812fc91afcca9df337c66f0aa7b71152bca", "output_wav_sha256": "b24fb2cf89d0eab42b3b9ea3d70a9a8b1146ff4f010208827f4bd830d6250a46", "output_pcm_sha256": "3bd113679bb98b278cdff6eed566324b673815d6e962eb4d4c9613babc7551bc", "result_sha256": "32c4a91cdf1fad96ce825b22abd09ee551986278779837b97b013ca0b1efc304" } }, { "id": 111, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ea1902a2c926b9d90222b48ada9443bc8ba798e75076f9246063d739ad1fcc22", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ea1902a2c926b9d90222b48ada9443bc8ba798e75076f9246063d739ad1fcc22", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs titanium oxide an ingredient of my washing power? Which chemicals does my perfume contain? It is really difficult to keep track of all chemicals one is regularly exposed to. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First premise: Being an ingredient of the Wuss bubble bar or not being an ingredient of six color eyeshadow is sufficient for being an ingredient of perfection primer. Second premise: Phenazamide is an ingredient of six color eyeshadow. It follows that phenazamide is not an ingredient of perfection primer. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs titanium oxide an ingredient of my washing power? Which chemicals does my perfume contain? It is really difficult to keep track of all chemicals one is regularly exposed to. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First premise, being an ingredient of the wuss bubble bar, or not being an ingredient of six-color eyeshadow, is sufficient for being an ingredient of perfection primer. Second premise, phenazomide is an ingredient of six-color eyeshadow. shadow it follows that phenazemide is not an ingredient of perfection primer is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question Question", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 15250.35, "reasoner_ms": 3894.46, "tts_ms": 29.95, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 19174.78, "total_processing_ms": 19725.93 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1024, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 206 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b0e97aab6757267808b516294fbe35f2350be54958442f4f75db032cc82504b8", "started_sha256": "c3484ee768a13fcbe93533f9e993c48e464fca08abec3c3063ece7e49a628999", "original_grade_sha256": "41c8fe5cb8cb3a8ff6455fc678122a88c430ad38de6f449563bd0433d1a88baf", "input_original_sha256": "b0e97aab6757267808b516294fbe35f2350be54958442f4f75db032cc82504b8", "input_wav_sha256": "e4dd564b69aea6a6442b1f3e4fe94485cd86c454e61c6278eb9c5bca3547eefe", "input_pcm_sha256": "5a2599890e957064d4eb8b1b5ea14e2b96f74ebb5a68ac984c75cb58d7ccb5f1", "output_wav_sha256": "a609c9a4769aa99c043665db902d33349b7b8855c0aa43ba8d8c1e273c06569a", "output_pcm_sha256": "34cc18e2fdca184ca00d56314011fdebab114980056922870483ce45f5d0a4cb", "result_sha256": "82f2b8ccf2c796e63e0d21617057642a41c15897c111edb1e63ad5cde0e581bc" } }, { "id": 308, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "801fb9ef5293b37d478d366048f93b512b6d015b20d4a83cfc48adcde62f6a03", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "801fb9ef5293b37d478d366048f93b512b6d015b20d4a83cfc48adcde62f6a03", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take eight steps. Take one step. Take eight steps. Turn right. Options? Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take 8 steps. Take 1 step. Take 8 steps. Turn right. Options? Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5547.07, "reasoner_ms": 2267.37, "tts_ms": 23.12, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7837.58, "total_processing_ms": 8426.31 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 793, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 65 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "62d2ebd5ec8219d82b6a3aac3d5c2618f0ed1af7eef77cb2c8c1293b60a5a6eb", "started_sha256": "96e834ec0e0e6176a550033cfcf89c97a5116bcce2f01c407e0f1185b7e1c7ce", "original_grade_sha256": "e3eb7584b92a2cf93a343b59173e1dff4a10b1f26b9aaaadf896b096fb613eff", "input_original_sha256": "62d2ebd5ec8219d82b6a3aac3d5c2618f0ed1af7eef77cb2c8c1293b60a5a6eb", "input_wav_sha256": "702fa57a9747e1608839e3122107b620575121838530dec65b4a73103117a83d", "input_pcm_sha256": "1b56f6587db3d35d7a720b1a7407e217c1e98e0f92af5bc0523c1d917e61aa14", "output_wav_sha256": "84bad8eed014bc19327f0029110004c53efac11af3eca8b46473afd479651c87", "output_pcm_sha256": "05d6701e7a2c4c132639cc32e9e6784a1445b518da546ede8565f9b16d2544cb", "result_sha256": "416f7478e3e7bf9a2833706fe82a1605812d1b2bcba94e07072928037fff563e" } }, { "id": 611, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "3", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "344adc656fd757eec6e3e6bbefd43fa0f3433b3c2c6fff271f0a1edfdeba0a12", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "344adc656fd757eec6e3e6bbefd43fa0f3433b3c2c6fff271f0a1edfdeba0a12", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a peach, a raspberry, and a nectarine. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a peach, a raspberry, and a nectarine. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 3.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 3969.0, "reasoner_ms": 1499.27, "tts_ms": 24.51, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5492.81, "total_processing_ms": 6098.29 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 743, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b61bb1af08344bdab290c3764f49d116c4dfee71170ebc5a8e976c7e3ff87fb0", "started_sha256": "c96b2903d8a8994447ef038567c30b387ec9361a42a2763a709ddf1916615969", "original_grade_sha256": "af46df477517721790b384f633cd5439c56e4596f70ad8f661bb52a4923784f1", "input_original_sha256": "b61bb1af08344bdab290c3764f49d116c4dfee71170ebc5a8e976c7e3ff87fb0", "input_wav_sha256": "18569536c3ea9d51cb28478ee3fe712d1b41f65296adb92aa73908c8c80a7971", "input_pcm_sha256": "05300a6d807d89f7c7c0afbfa38d70e54b30ec0af2f732a6b4052d44a0c40e3c", "output_wav_sha256": "14c97cadef22408ecb1f34b673994ce1bc05bda390cb840139a8e9af66b39ff3", "output_pcm_sha256": "a72a8e87eb349d1b61388a55169614a76c05da8d8621d352aa1a9e152de7d25f", "result_sha256": "fd947dd70522e31d82a7d9f720bf6bf5f46f113a1fb836c03d95b5df8a1dc06d" } }, { "id": 995, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "73db68cc88e8122a381cce8c5e3ff822a26e59d0ed24e41f5e8d11e30278bab8", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "73db68cc88e8122a381cce8c5e3ff822a26e59d0ed24e41f5e8d11e30278bab8", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Alexis tells the truth. Amberly says Alexis tells the truth. Andre says Amberly tells the truth. Vina says Andre tells the truth. Haylin says Vina tells the truth. Does Haylin tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nalexis tells the truth amberlie says alexis tells the truth andre says amberlie tells the truth vina says andre tells the truth halen says vina tells the truth does halen tell the truth answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7732.49, "reasoner_ms": 2195.64, "tts_ms": 24.83, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9952.98, "total_processing_ms": 10608.11 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 70 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b6a43507e82251d1822405da7f482d7a8aa01e1c25a43e7076fcfec7f83f94c6", "started_sha256": "502764420a6eb95ccfd613a358df65bfe215e8c6ef5bd2358b59aebd2292913f", "original_grade_sha256": "719b889f5ee7aaa8ed1ccfef3feb79ad56126e99477d753c781929838cc943e2", "input_original_sha256": "b6a43507e82251d1822405da7f482d7a8aa01e1c25a43e7076fcfec7f83f94c6", "input_wav_sha256": "53678f7a114a3dfc85e2cf965d9d13eb9cc180b2ad29196b62b6d329e2eb35fd", "input_pcm_sha256": "94a70fd0fc99ecc3c6e8a5c24ed3802f3e19e9aa77fc1a2d26ffc6b84a1d2eb0", "output_wav_sha256": "b7aa2c704d2e3c3f9eb335f32a931c8f26f67f18724603956ea8d722aae9b0d4", "output_pcm_sha256": "378cf91c3c3ffc21c34b4bc114703c01ab4db39903d511550aba2ea81f8bf250", "result_sha256": "c92faa8c6c6bcecad8ce93ea320d930d0e1aee1a2f3b962be4a63e9d0ffd8b8b" } }, { "id": 133, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "df4807a3f8c25bdc99442f3c028c3ba06b95be58bdb78efb337015c40d97a9a3", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "df4807a3f8c25bdc99442f3c028c3ba06b95be58bdb78efb337015c40d97a9a3", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, every occasional purchaser of Matrix shampoo is an occasional purchaser of Organix hair shampoo. Next, Linda is an occasional purchaser of Organix hair shampoo. It follows that Linda is an occasional purchaser of Matrix shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, every occasional purchaser of Matrix Shampoo is an occasional purchaser of Organics Hair Shampoo. Next, Linda is an occasional purchaser of Organics Hair Shampoo. It follows that Linda is an occasional purchaser of Matrix Shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11447.18, "reasoner_ms": 1851.38, "tts_ms": 26.87, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 13325.46, "total_processing_ms": 13866.94 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1014, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 26 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f6621e560a77f8e522d16804b6d4fbf2873e6d9c3e49d73c423fbb0bb7982d09", "started_sha256": "75a0455a403621b517e487c0b21caaf44d33f1f337eab32008c8981ed341a270", "original_grade_sha256": "4d2e6be766dacc1f87aaa51972f4626b66b0d29f5025a4e010cbd1accb01fe83", "input_original_sha256": "f6621e560a77f8e522d16804b6d4fbf2873e6d9c3e49d73c423fbb0bb7982d09", "input_wav_sha256": "15158c5c170dec86fa12b90c7db827d7deccd6d8b580eeed0cb4b4ffab06457e", "input_pcm_sha256": "854b6828288d67ff8b4970954a539729af626f9640ef581cefbdf597377da370", "output_wav_sha256": "93c8a3638a8485bee48a7aa033b105877f85d719c36ac9dfcd689ded4ed6f902", "output_pcm_sha256": "4dc8220408bc3ed290cddb66e79d1fb138898bd559b7722e389dea9677d54564", "result_sha256": "6f17b8b102178cf95843c1fb2e123b9bc1db4ee552a6cba07ff45eae91ef6c55" } }, { "id": 327, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f40f208bffc26c0baa2ba60e69299e9415360a680a29c43b74ea11845f4e9bd7", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f40f208bffc26c0baa2ba60e69299e9415360a680a29c43b74ea11845f4e9bd7", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take one step backward. Take five steps right. Take three steps left. Take one step backward. Take five steps backward. Take four steps forward. Take three steps forward. Take two steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take one step backward. Take five steps right. Take three steps left. Take one step backward. Take five steps backward. Take four steps forward. Take three steps forward. Take two steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6162.26, "reasoner_ms": 3185.56, "tts_ms": 25.22, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9373.07, "total_processing_ms": 9981.89 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 871, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 174 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5305fff9fd5a42d007d6befecaf0b487383f77135d23fd6586b1d05261fb70c6", "started_sha256": "34f7ef677279b76dcd95e107e3c68ba74efcbca0148994550b39eca6eb1d836b", "original_grade_sha256": "618a7efc3b79903b22fde7c2ff1a89974b17413ffaeeb0fee1c6312ef5a3942c", "input_original_sha256": "5305fff9fd5a42d007d6befecaf0b487383f77135d23fd6586b1d05261fb70c6", "input_wav_sha256": "c08bee0607d21111340402e3e3e3a0548e0affcbfda4d6843c8e497df9d9557d", "input_pcm_sha256": "f1f7040f1ce1abc85295745640624f4a04fad4b9dcb41ecbc00beaf3a20bac66", "output_wav_sha256": "3a6cb23b0580592aefb8bc02ddff35fa65fc872046b37f96a036edcf913d42e4", "output_pcm_sha256": "18a7171ce0ff2e4d44a268f39129033c546595383978a3e21e6cf985cec5901e", "result_sha256": "6ee85793c5e8572e7624279207047881e588f133dd4b1f4a3b9fec6d63417e36" } }, { "id": 690, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "5", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "91c59d221ed571a5879f34f8c2256bdb7180320d3154766a0b38bc0f8b60012f", "normalized_answer": "5" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "91c59d221ed571a5879f34f8c2256bdb7180320d3154766a0b38bc0f8b60012f", "normalized_answer": "5" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have two stalks of celery, a carrot, a lettuce head, and an onion. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have two stalks of celery, a carrot, a lettuce head, and an onion. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 5.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4370.05, "reasoner_ms": 2655.7, "tts_ms": 25.95, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7051.72, "total_processing_ms": 7598.52 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 762, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 104 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b88e096616c5358f2085a501c3971c29ee03231df29abc3aa79ed4b7239dba5b", "started_sha256": "791e88316ff37e5ece183d7d36de8b57473bb5a744555b5580854cfd8694af4a", "original_grade_sha256": "f30f52ad0c38b36b12418a9f5dde189ac8ef4d12b339dc7b5472db48643214dc", "input_original_sha256": "b88e096616c5358f2085a501c3971c29ee03231df29abc3aa79ed4b7239dba5b", "input_wav_sha256": "ad5aa7dc12faec26260d57b156ee2b9c192138cf5ca05cae644af3da584c52cf", "input_pcm_sha256": "40fdc0930012da4feba3aa7a71e3a928298231153a69582be6fac606d8b9e59a", "output_wav_sha256": "b528fa538a7a0990fccf775815f5edbfcd930032891066b6fa71ac7e35c73a41", "output_pcm_sha256": "ba1bd25c8e2ce46d5da30904cb61c3a8c4281348b4ad86c0c8b3ab2dddb8db59", "result_sha256": "a06c580563182cf7a78cb0097d7a477200f433a3bc577770b3caf187c5d4d38b" } }, { "id": 928, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3892feb340e7e195d593ec380e34750e8b401006a22e2989fcdc6b2f0092f585", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3892feb340e7e195d593ec380e34750e8b401006a22e2989fcdc6b2f0092f585", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Vina tells the truth. Alejandro says Vina lies. Maybel says Alejandro tells the truth. Millicent says Maybel lies. Eleanor says Millicent tells the truth. Does Eleanor tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Veena tells the truth. Alejandro says Veena lies. Maybel says Alejandro tells the truth. Millicent says Maybel lies. Eleanor says Millicent tells the truth. Does Eleanor tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5908.11, "reasoner_ms": 2092.37, "tts_ms": 24.8, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8025.3, "total_processing_ms": 8605.58 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 849, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 83 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "bd4765bab83839e44791b158b5ec24865de005ab66be2fc04e86643308160689", "started_sha256": "ca21642e28293051c4913b75a92bb4b60404edd051497e3fb8f14f097b054504", "original_grade_sha256": "79c0c299a1a5ceb9a8bbde13141078aa771bf03519c4aa844c41921720f45603", "input_original_sha256": "bd4765bab83839e44791b158b5ec24865de005ab66be2fc04e86643308160689", "input_wav_sha256": "f79631b74001861f8523ec6b36abbed6784a5f8e1edeb7c84a8a26392acfd9a9", "input_pcm_sha256": "8ade738b8bd3394cfc1f1629cb4c0aea527aa0a59c7a8b334be15e8b92912636", "output_wav_sha256": "a3c1c015c779107f3c93ba95a1217cb6ab1e5a6246d2ab919928ff8a9ddd4d28", "output_pcm_sha256": "0cf04359096a6cf8a42222f30b3d617c857b93fdfda618dde0a9a99fcef3c1fd", "result_sha256": "5af0def5abf1c3a652a7bbfc60e23e691a3dc99a96b83890ec5aa610b5d83555" } }, { "id": 233, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bdc7f8ce98c1898719be9e77f75f02a93b9f29357157b4958239ce39d6a1eb90", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bdc7f8ce98c1898719be9e77f75f02a93b9f29357157b4958239ce39d6a1eb90", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First, not being a niece of Ashley is sufficient for being a schoolmate of Letitia and a close friend of Jamie. Second, Bernice is a schoolmate of Letitia or a close friend of Jamie. In consequence, it is false that Bernice is a niece of Ashley. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nit is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways the following argument pertains to this question first not being a niece of ashley is sufficient for being a schoolmate of letitia and a close friend of jamie second bernice is a schoolmate of letitia or a close friend of jamie in consequence it is false that bernice is a niece of ashley is the argument given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid. Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11550.27, "reasoner_ms": 3998.08, "tts_ms": 29.83, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15578.2, "total_processing_ms": 16160.26 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 899, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 233 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ffd29eb8c5d63a067eb6847606a2a91c18740efc7e07c167ce506cbfb3799a37", "started_sha256": "b84d4d6614cba167e0773222977c8973038bcdd63d268346676bd60a557805e9", "original_grade_sha256": "8ffbd58fe04bbd589c97a1fdde4096a57c264f3bcca619d4dce35180826e312f", "input_original_sha256": "ffd29eb8c5d63a067eb6847606a2a91c18740efc7e07c167ce506cbfb3799a37", "input_wav_sha256": "0988ff61b91ceff12f32779502698bec6f7486ee0053e3389110a3ccbad8931a", "input_pcm_sha256": "b4ce2a29f5f2b17b304c9c5935dde136046db4782d1fa5687f4bccff9745cf3b", "output_wav_sha256": "5da2e75862ac3f7c299e8ef618e5d8a8c2f3103c9701f80e73e92ca97b8bccbc", "output_pcm_sha256": "4b73a758adcdfb6697010a1bf4422f1b285ffcf5735a2d3c2775bb51e1fc2e73", "result_sha256": "747cce793ada23f572875b21261c273c1aa6b253ffad5addc56ee8b7cac688ca" } }, { "id": 410, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c9b7d38f8749f6a3c0c14c2433e69ebfe283d63af207cfa519e149df36ef7569", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c9b7d38f8749f6a3c0c14c2433e69ebfe283d63af207cfa519e149df36ef7569", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take seven steps. Turn around. Take seven steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take seven steps. Turn around. Take seven steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5126.29, "reasoner_ms": 1406.2, "tts_ms": 23.96, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6556.48, "total_processing_ms": 7100.13 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 779, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1a01d1660e533be7a16dc5e5e33190b9a6bf995c2c46e688dce31c4e373a4e65", "started_sha256": "5aba0b7832a6e3998414f666d3fd3915cfd74bc1ef6f8180d88ea363df20270b", "original_grade_sha256": "777e1e4b4680dbd0bb8f62bf885886cd374c8f1147081a0d5af3ebfec7688b11", "input_original_sha256": "1a01d1660e533be7a16dc5e5e33190b9a6bf995c2c46e688dce31c4e373a4e65", "input_wav_sha256": "1e7834306c68fa0b8a703314a458bd43d985f2c25a90fa7f4cdc7100d1baa65c", "input_pcm_sha256": "dee13ddfcf84139bef04cfbd90332b60327dea03c99d4cd45c5f8afffe09197d", "output_wav_sha256": "019ef1ef023a8ad733070a760cea12168e0437b95385ace3f42e9fc371585a12", "output_pcm_sha256": "dee52fa808007131cecefd682bd4f88a5fe23daf47bbd87d39ff3fa7a42481cf", "result_sha256": "f7dcde972efa822dd0cedd553c6d736f3eae0a96d8ebf2a8290f21290373cc1c" } }, { "id": 729, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "3", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f13a4b5fd9d4e0a092d13a33f97736deced31af5bb619cc03a4af3cd3423a567", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f13a4b5fd9d4e0a092d13a33f97736deced31af5bb619cc03a4af3cd3423a567", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have two cars and an oven. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have two cars and an oven. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 3.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 3757.54, "reasoner_ms": 1443.52, "tts_ms": 24.97, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5226.06, "total_processing_ms": 5839.42 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 724, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 26 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "26b6e829c83aaaae98a4c1321350655a8f6f065dc499eda30eea47f7e3088473", "started_sha256": "9c5ab9b706d74dfa99ea9fff87ce272d06a100deae77e51edcf6c7d92a48a98b", "original_grade_sha256": "007ad48641e25b91d5884490e6bac651fcf10dcd25ace5537117a20e11d18c34", "input_original_sha256": "26b6e829c83aaaae98a4c1321350655a8f6f065dc499eda30eea47f7e3088473", "input_wav_sha256": "ee7ee6e060e21d77de5ed6a5956236c3ebff03a9c3dabf523fdbfff1539e90c5", "input_pcm_sha256": "dbee19f4184328f40fdade1a03b2c9689d7bc13dcd2b0ca686388a0e5cfa6297", "output_wav_sha256": "59988fe834a159cefd77a9149661691b624f9025206bc690797467b1ed0e687c", "output_pcm_sha256": "b9a936c027b871e41154615641fb6f9ba016a30254d61fe66c3679f2e8ab6166", "result_sha256": "ed9645c2114f1734b164fb2f97e8e633527f9b6fe008230cc2b8b9a77892f05f" } }, { "id": 914, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6b338687a1d812e0b5cba3f95021b3c81eaee9eff081546525ed6f869d1c4218", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6b338687a1d812e0b5cba3f95021b3c81eaee9eff081546525ed6f869d1c4218", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Vernell tells the truth. Rashida says Vernell lies. Christie says Rashida tells the truth. Sherri says Christie tells the truth. Jim says Sherri lies. Does Jim tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Vernell tells the truth. Rashida says Vernell lies. Christy says Rashida tells the truth. Sherry says Christy tells the truth. Jim says Sherry lies. Does Jim tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5448.17, "reasoner_ms": 2244.54, "tts_ms": 24.83, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7717.56, "total_processing_ms": 8278.68 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 837, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 124 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5be835258e24f250274ca6b828eec15a227b5a1eb85be1be9bb7f5b33d5c777f", "started_sha256": "6f33bc1abf7d942f29c750ec9c709bc7958488895c7f2f987275d90a59510a1b", "original_grade_sha256": "69bc61d1921688fea1e5b3e5c0c61ee2e2c0be7e7038c23abf052db0d6161fc8", "input_original_sha256": "5be835258e24f250274ca6b828eec15a227b5a1eb85be1be9bb7f5b33d5c777f", "input_wav_sha256": "71906706615d7060c22fc98e057b8579f7f8186ec358e7596b367becb016b2b7", "input_pcm_sha256": "ecf1a4594b3c7024fdea743080b3dbe6e68ba26236e58725fab6b65bca6c180a", "output_wav_sha256": "1b582cd4474109c32e8fd4d6aacea3c86d8285ce7c6df926da1630e4b6b970d7", "output_pcm_sha256": "97f5c8775cad8497c7b346a67dbe753784cf131f59d2b20a928d152f42815532", "result_sha256": "94a534e64fe68e9ea1f73db03dee5643e9104777f3d13dac8ebc623b581762ed" } }, { "id": 238, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "850b68463b3ef455b3790f1acfcebd89cd2c7fd8eaf2ec00d380643aff936a67", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "850b68463b3ef455b3790f1acfcebd89cd2c7fd8eaf2ec00d380643aff936a67", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. Every regular user of South of France soap is not a rare consumer of natural bar soap or not a loyal buyer of Organix hair shampoo. Every owner of a Caress soap is a regular user of South of France soap. It follows that everyone who is an owner of a Caress soap is also a rare consumer of natural bar soap and a loyal buyer of Organix hair shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. Every regular user of South of France soap is not a rare consumer of natural bar soap or not a loyal buyer of organics hair shampoo. Every owner of a Caress soap is a regular user of south of France soap it follows that everyone who is an owner of a caress soap is also a rare consumer of natural bar soap and a loyal buyer of organics hair shampoo is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12377.01, "reasoner_ms": 3367.57, "tts_ms": 25.91, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15770.52, "total_processing_ms": 16350.94 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1080, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 167 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f754478420214fbc552755c9b6c201d2b40f29dd498837eb4126a82646c8f140", "started_sha256": "006e5157230a74d8fd4dcb9cab20aac9f046b92751215e80ffb19e54801100fe", "original_grade_sha256": "4aa4e48be47df4cc53622b26d5af7f31eef96bdaaa3515b25890acb30f6b5088", "input_original_sha256": "f754478420214fbc552755c9b6c201d2b40f29dd498837eb4126a82646c8f140", "input_wav_sha256": "835c99f90e71877a05fb155808365d6dac805ac4cf1cc469f920464d26f75fd3", "input_pcm_sha256": "89c0358ba0242aabd7ebeddab399df5c44b1dd18a853798d73c5d9b6d53418fb", "output_wav_sha256": "43ed13106c934d5e08fc8e47ede11be7f96ec15cd138487bd0ac09381ba0e3b2", "output_pcm_sha256": "dccd3235f4985ee3dc80b53afb4a3773cb6e83b06d289f5091d3a0305278d643", "result_sha256": "6218ab21981ee3e270a45ed32ab07008d259d8fd930897bda12025681f2845df" } }, { "id": 377, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f74f3af146d158716212b039ea2d9ab6ff328006c71fd8fb7f1f4f326646aff8", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f74f3af146d158716212b039ea2d9ab6ff328006c71fd8fb7f1f4f326646aff8", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left. Take five steps. Take nine steps. Take seven steps. Turn around. Take one step. Take ten steps. Options? Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point, turn left, take five steps, take nine steps, take seven steps, turn around, take one step, take ten steps? Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5411.9, "reasoner_ms": 2422.67, "tts_ms": 24.58, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7859.18, "total_processing_ms": 8372.71 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 817, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 80 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0249fba1440047f2d5eada7678b5793a5c7ca12440ad55415fe6a8acad002bcf", "started_sha256": "bc3d1a4dab021db30309f52dd4c9cecf85dd0625d3b7bc60e4ec6bd282214fd3", "original_grade_sha256": "b495ca80bab988acd486d8d97630718448540c4fa3aa8ad00b5bcff13cff6d35", "input_original_sha256": "0249fba1440047f2d5eada7678b5793a5c7ca12440ad55415fe6a8acad002bcf", "input_wav_sha256": "d7e83aab7749f61a758dbd04729761a52c899fa9c8c920fae905aaa5630d9a27", "input_pcm_sha256": "d00e91aa68db106caedb0cb36269c3e5bfd1001f738a80bd4e8ea56d101ead83", "output_wav_sha256": "880d35be88197e3b1d7518a9ab1365a4a5a87268b8d8aea181c0fe4067244d4c", "output_pcm_sha256": "3ece431907f4618ff5c25fbe10981ae88f8daceb7142c2bba894033d238f2abd", "result_sha256": "12951879d2fef32eb46e32903dd7270f77575ac6fcda90cc31fd5575731a83b1" } }, { "id": 571, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "3", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3a712b2d1ee5c9431f0fd29a735dfdebd5d3c1e24a5d1bb60457653fe4767834", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3a712b2d1ee5c9431f0fd29a735dfdebd5d3c1e24a5d1bb60457653fe4767834", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a dog, a pig, and a snail. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a dog, a pig, and a snail. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 3.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 3843.37, "reasoner_ms": 1260.61, "tts_ms": 21.09, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5125.11, "total_processing_ms": 5669.61 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 734, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "9c15f18fe459aac4e150c66c2860470fb43d860e2a766e11df82003876022c27", "started_sha256": "9718598eced3687f4579788d275a8c9c4a6af0ccc0293150bf9be32b3b6c3f75", "original_grade_sha256": "f808d0765ef0538cddd473d4f212b11d66da315ee414d96549b1f7e6828d668f", "input_original_sha256": "9c15f18fe459aac4e150c66c2860470fb43d860e2a766e11df82003876022c27", "input_wav_sha256": "a68e3fb6d85cc4828d62bd04e7ba1797ab013172e9ec66dcafc62c36548e2868", "input_pcm_sha256": "7cac9e10a5801de63f4d214300755670632f16590f93fbda76c90209c5a4a460", "output_wav_sha256": "8dad6ac2f76e691d655a9db3f9c0ea9b2ccf611bb580c2b3e4f3fc2daf76d515", "output_pcm_sha256": "ba461854ce015654120dd45e59b19c35f164d3d8b7a3ac47b96f60dc6d2eb550", "result_sha256": "479834bab224bf13458c7d2ae3557abfa26e81e311e37549ae52e01c72da8cb5" } }, { "id": 815, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b984ce0b339edb0ee4dc7c8eaced120b1e70afccf711716ae87d04f1cee94b81", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b984ce0b339edb0ee4dc7c8eaced120b1e70afccf711716ae87d04f1cee94b81", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Jim lies. Ka says Jim lies. Jerry says Ka tells the truth. Fletcher says Jerry tells the truth. Candy says Fletcher lies. Does Candy tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Jim lies. Ka says Jim lies. Jerry says Ka tells the truth. Fletcher says Jerry tells the truth. Candy says Fletcher lies. Does Candy tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4974.12, "reasoner_ms": 2277.15, "tts_ms": 24.96, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7276.25, "total_processing_ms": 7850.83 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 831, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 125 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1c5b84d641ae52d4cfda277960102f99a01dc80148220e5f93bcbb4e518df885", "started_sha256": "2b46df371335371f595e5b9c351012c53e4670559b7f254bab1b977a05fc9666", "original_grade_sha256": "91b2dd6f3f3dd0bbf4b899523b2ea87e078243a5b476789d5b1946dcaf7975be", "input_original_sha256": "1c5b84d641ae52d4cfda277960102f99a01dc80148220e5f93bcbb4e518df885", "input_wav_sha256": "7e75f0958bb6978fd258691310f267663e10ac7f9834342afe8d9309a2efa0a9", "input_pcm_sha256": "2b01b94cd8749043dea8acff0015180fb159cd09414cad1aca09926d5e4f9080", "output_wav_sha256": "62cbe8575f2a843e26a1005694a5c1fda9b2ca181e3eec17f16742dd8ccea5f7", "output_pcm_sha256": "3c579b91da52b6277647c2c360adcb890b9d62275f17385d32c909736f6d3f8e", "result_sha256": "69f5f64eeb531e3881dd5e071acb445ba7b5a65f8e9ebc6b522b19d7840e73fc" } }, { "id": 192, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1349a1af94b62dea5678cc740e80df6804c2b7b27c938c81ebe7f17e5a89b8be", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1349a1af94b62dea5678cc740e80df6804c2b7b27c938c81ebe7f17e5a89b8be", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, every ingredient of Lip Sync is not an ingredient of UV Shield SPF 40 and not an ingredient of 07 Dew Fruity lipstick. Therefore, whatever is none of this, an ingredient of 070 Fruity lipstick or ingredient of UV Shield SPF 40 is an ingredient of Lip Sync. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, every ingredient of Lip Sync is not an ingredient of UV Shield SPF 40 and not an ingredient of 070 Fruity Lipstick. Therefore, whatever is none of this, an ingredient of 070 Fruity Lipstick or ingredient of UV Shield SPF 40 is an ingredient of Lip Sync. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8524.59, "reasoner_ms": 3138.49, "tts_ms": 29.81, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11692.92, "total_processing_ms": 12269.69 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 925, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 207 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "4ce58c096e9326e972cd4b1bdd08e8cada6c6ff8db36780866b1acf4156d16ff", "started_sha256": "cb4b3bb316c6290935584728457f81ba4e357bd53d789510569da9ae3eaf01a2", "original_grade_sha256": "7747e07900f20eef741cdb614ed9c6283ae9f951a31c46566102f9984296cc12", "input_original_sha256": "4ce58c096e9326e972cd4b1bdd08e8cada6c6ff8db36780866b1acf4156d16ff", "input_wav_sha256": "ab1c3fa559c119493c4385a12f0417484578a636f272ec0c285634addb83dc94", "input_pcm_sha256": "de20ee4d87cdaf03296e0545d606cdcd5018aa709c0b046ee9433bbea45f9460", "output_wav_sha256": "eb96bdaaccc1ae25e9acac7693c94139fd6b5fea20fba3a43b7f78c806d627fe", "output_pcm_sha256": "038a1eaf00e57ec8bae108e8ee6ab068ea60e8f640acafe60e05d8baf16f30fb", "result_sha256": "976baa79fa1178e42834f9658a398d9d2118a86887e85b741f6d4c1a621d0edd" } }, { "id": 401, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "900acfd1d29b66ebffc0b7832321b8b484807cff5e009c004fb36f669dce94e9", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "900acfd1d29b66ebffc0b7832321b8b484807cff5e009c004fb36f669dce94e9", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take nine steps, turn left, turn left, take nine steps. Options, yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point take nine steps turn left turn left take nine steps options yes no answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7580.98, "reasoner_ms": 1923.02, "tts_ms": 26.29, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9530.32, "total_processing_ms": 10086.77 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 776, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 50 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1821c35ebba58ca8cff5e291cc37866ee48d9cc01038010866c9b96ad09775b5", "started_sha256": "17049498b0354d0d40fa010ff5fbd973a257508520babe7d406e4d18ca2ff371", "original_grade_sha256": "5a219b4c99496c4192a45ecf3352ec95c023b728d4dfa1d4a50b4e6fc8f16cdc", "input_original_sha256": "1821c35ebba58ca8cff5e291cc37866ee48d9cc01038010866c9b96ad09775b5", "input_wav_sha256": "756fec3e35c50d211fc2a23d7006f7ee17077eb240775c4009d6b2434acea628", "input_pcm_sha256": "be8dd8b011dba0cb5349db89bca90c06496320e64c23760813bd7ada383c86a7", "output_wav_sha256": "807e18b40a90505863ba2e0cce484978ffc46bb961064a38a8aeeaf42699e68d", "output_pcm_sha256": "99a16e37c4037e3bfe8cc57c4d9269bebb198c72c9b50701b177d370542116de", "result_sha256": "7307827c4e077ad71fc21d471cb4e45f35988fd8060cc1e628798304fd29afea" } }, { "id": 523, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "10", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "93dbd68f9d6c88746f9517c921c86e73d89ad6584b4ea000e3d6f09938f239d8", "normalized_answer": "10" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "93dbd68f9d6c88746f9517c921c86e73d89ad6584b4ea000e3d6f09938f239d8", "normalized_answer": "10" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a yam, a cauliflower, a bed, two cabbages, a garlic, an oven, a carrot, a head of broccoli, a potato, a stalk of celery, a lettuce head, and a toaster. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a yam, a cauliflower, a bed, two cabbages, a garlic, an oven, a carrot, a head of broccoli, a potato, a stalk of celery, a lettuce head, and a toaster. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 10.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5427.95, "reasoner_ms": 2886.23, "tts_ms": 23.17, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8337.37, "total_processing_ms": 8811.16 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 847, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 229 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "58d20ff4b5a4071aba7c9d8558a63370d0ef4e59b676a8449cfd4a5fd09ecfc9", "started_sha256": "4838c494d0a7e46627ceab4bf339ed66a0f35ee2b95c8c06e4dbb45d4717a9c9", "original_grade_sha256": "adfaa5f4b75d0ee2a14148cf1568c4a4704f3ab6633ee0386a70afef4161627c", "input_original_sha256": "58d20ff4b5a4071aba7c9d8558a63370d0ef4e59b676a8449cfd4a5fd09ecfc9", "input_wav_sha256": "b663dc7ff443e0d8be7410f696d9941dcfdec572833d8d1ce9c634fda19f79aa", "input_pcm_sha256": "8ff3fbdc5b4d406f46d1ebe72648408f32d9a8168004729171170632d79dbae0", "output_wav_sha256": "d58d1728deaed009999af155c039e9fad366c8c967c81118b8cb7bbf400f240a", "output_pcm_sha256": "0f3ef29ecad097be909a33c00e48032ff4ef9d9ae98d3b75f95d46ad0cec2235", "result_sha256": "eaa0031ecd34c2138d39f49e7b6b0f8013d58324be7b6c45274cb1654fc48c57" } }, { "id": 949, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b8710091b586ea09fe9a55aa1f9268131d214d74adeef5b40048d83c50315e77", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b8710091b586ea09fe9a55aa1f9268131d214d74adeef5b40048d83c50315e77", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Christian lies. Millie says Christian lies. Amberly says Millie lies. Osvaldo says Amberly tells the truth. Candy says Osvaldo tells the truth. Does Candy tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Christian lies. Millie says Christian lies. Amberlee says Millie lies. Osvaldo says Amberlee tells the truth. Candy says Osvaldo tells the truth. Does Candy tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4879.97, "reasoner_ms": 2724.45, "tts_ms": 30.42, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7634.86, "total_processing_ms": 8142.01 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 837, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 140 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "c32bb6e10952dedb2d6202a53395cb9d804f854d4bf56c3a381ad858c6d2cfd4", "started_sha256": "2b036efa094033820742aeab8ba4bb8cd73d809e266c091b953091fb0a1fb036", "original_grade_sha256": "d456a1b68aa78f94430bf6310b04060b96f869e560206658e2edbbb8e3e9de81", "input_original_sha256": "c32bb6e10952dedb2d6202a53395cb9d804f854d4bf56c3a381ad858c6d2cfd4", "input_wav_sha256": "aeb5565454cef678acd9ea7b8947bec15f7ac876bfb28dc7680ac08f181559fd", "input_pcm_sha256": "fc75fff15f294acfbe33880707ade2345f579c6dfabe5d78e5ec9055e8bbe388", "output_wav_sha256": "4da98f4466b1a3aa89e725f5def50dd00c8e4afa231f7d9031dcf7f7c699816e", "output_pcm_sha256": "3556ed5f62ea0faeb03ec8e1ea0a296d1ca62b1c51b24ba49aa78854530463cd", "result_sha256": "7827a7d084f2c9e394c7e4927e6ad2649b9ae359feff4766ede4167696888056" } }, { "id": 102, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9026cdb58fe613b674d50222c085828a51bb887975389b6610b91e66077c1824", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9026cdb58fe613b674d50222c085828a51bb887975389b6610b91e66077c1824", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, everyone who is a son of Andres is a son of Bruce too. Next, Jeffrey is not a son of Bruce. In consequence, it is false that Jeffrey is a son of Andres. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nit is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways the following argument pertains to this question first of all every one who is a son of andres is a son of bruce too next geoffrey is not a son of bruce in consequence it is false that geoffrey is a son of andres is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 18202.1, "reasoner_ms": 1751.27, "tts_ms": 27.0, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 19980.39, "total_processing_ms": 20800.53 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 940, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 62 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1d02213eef98a9f13eab2a5cbab5702925b2adeaa0d8a06dbbd838e111608a35", "started_sha256": "1de929fdebaf3dfc2dd587291e26bcebaf7acda0ebe20c0870ab7dfed483ffcc", "original_grade_sha256": "122e245f84b293e92aa988c4f38ac52402d2dcc69a6f5810a398cd9824c11bed", "input_original_sha256": "1d02213eef98a9f13eab2a5cbab5702925b2adeaa0d8a06dbbd838e111608a35", "input_wav_sha256": "a273fc10fb498cf4b282c6efc12c175a3cfee95a7a24b15cd48a0d52a1b6315e", "input_pcm_sha256": "ee9f316f9af3c1ac36a39e19e7285611900511c3c43b8610340af12907883efb", "output_wav_sha256": "e934655f0ab4172beeeee7dc916af03cd664b92fec57af29e92fb08930169fae", "output_pcm_sha256": "99ca472e09900da5cffd4aeb784a3c99998a824d1cb82dae8afb27d19477735c", "result_sha256": "eae457254a9dd8d76cb60131ad792da5b75e469d542fd2cb180fa6bdb1b93619" } }, { "id": 494, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e589ea7d9003e761c19e1533adef8e8787f078880189c70d4b83562f614f2569", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e589ea7d9003e761c19e1533adef8e8787f078880189c70d4b83562f614f2569", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps right. Take one step forward. Take four steps right. Take four steps left. Take eight steps left. Take two steps forward. Take nine steps forward. Take three steps left. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do return to the starting point. Always face forward. Take six steps right. Take one step forward. Take four steps right. Take four steps left. Take eight steps left. Take two steps forward. Take nine steps forward. Take three steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 15267.45, "reasoner_ms": 2189.1, "tts_ms": 26.28, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17482.86, "total_processing_ms": 18272.02 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 873, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 64 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "06d30853da04b38e9da5de885fd08ae22e484b8cf355977a9b7ef3358927ce19", "started_sha256": "b7d34de9048c2008f7d2a128810aa6a2d9bc117e1a1486972f4cce3f01817fcc", "original_grade_sha256": "34a9d2bdc83a79b0f910741a8d23e8220888b29baf80085e88f092f7ca8fc322", "input_original_sha256": "06d30853da04b38e9da5de885fd08ae22e484b8cf355977a9b7ef3358927ce19", "input_wav_sha256": "d28abab5680f58898c5e42b8f88b5f165d68924592e52630d3163d41c797a197", "input_pcm_sha256": "6d1718f7ee7262d5030e4b8eb93216f983d64e91aac8b60e248fbaa52ed400fb", "output_wav_sha256": "543ce00a4486343d7235feee3af7385a274be68a9fa745baa7ee5762aac0207e", "output_pcm_sha256": "267b98d31a78ee7a095d42e158fde884937eb27f5f2fab07fb8504a630a0ad05", "result_sha256": "8a41383c4430306ad7a371199729afa4a2dc2f867f279c0811788a5f060027ba" } }, { "id": 500, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "8", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9041c6e28fbf217aab2747f4f75ecaf3948995ded50e592e900a5719719fd192", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9041c6e28fbf217aab2747f4f75ecaf3948995ded50e592e900a5719719fd192", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a flute, a piano, a trombone, four stoves, a violin, an accordion, a clarinet, a drum, two lamps, and a trumpet. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a flute, a piano, a trombone, four stoves, a violin, an accordion, a clarinet, a drum, two lamps, and a trumpet. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 8.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6891.9, "reasoner_ms": 1732.97, "tts_ms": 24.19, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8649.1, "total_processing_ms": 9428.55 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 812, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 58 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "647f492444a0f226bb4cfc553190c291abb565b9dba93853cd9897c74600cd74", "started_sha256": "df8182a7ef8fa2f157d284d2338063241705328701ddb86ffb4f255d56584c26", "original_grade_sha256": "af5e3de7d19840fcd9b3380ee1b76a2d3e2ab4ee66dbb5702bcb937ae2e0e662", "input_original_sha256": "647f492444a0f226bb4cfc553190c291abb565b9dba93853cd9897c74600cd74", "input_wav_sha256": "c7606921a537a1e3ced329ec2d1f029c1bd6b4d846599a065db73ba337763d40", "input_pcm_sha256": "5a1b738791912e6a0a7076c59f8dd5a4b77cee450705ef6f5e8348d67020fdd8", "output_wav_sha256": "5cc7382d02239c59356ab9f7d46b21fc0c16f59e989d67fd6bb23a423ccd6ad6", "output_pcm_sha256": "6d8f5b658495b1e5d24e65083aa88227b88089339dad5436d7fd0ccd91bf9b2e", "result_sha256": "8b210d1309a75d16afa1469cb3e9b8f460f2e04aaa17e53789b86e2cbef9bc16" } }, { "id": 919, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4c3ab3f52c3a003919d59fa275579918228870e1dcec4c321ce728507cb58a58", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4c3ab3f52c3a003919d59fa275579918228870e1dcec4c321ce728507cb58a58", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Ryan lies. Jamie says Ryan lies. Michael says Jamie tells the truth. Kay says Michael lies. Millicent says Kay tells the truth. Does Millicent tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Ryan lies. Jamie says Ryan lies. Michael says Jamie tells the truth. K.A. says Michael lies. Millicent says K.A. tells the truth. Does Millicent tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7450.56, "reasoner_ms": 2271.72, "tts_ms": 26.31, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9748.62, "total_processing_ms": 10566.9 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 834, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 109 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "aaea6fc90d167a0bc056375c0fe87ecf73273a997401e5d26ff28e3796e19146", "started_sha256": "3ecf02bf4ee814876bd8d3c8600eb1d986ef62c589afa771cac1991aaef210fe", "original_grade_sha256": "bb66a049419b6b8ed59fd721e0be6be6b9e4ec36b608ebac4f45b548c4ede324", "input_original_sha256": "aaea6fc90d167a0bc056375c0fe87ecf73273a997401e5d26ff28e3796e19146", "input_wav_sha256": "7ad13568ebf76e5fd6aca112b176ee55213215cb81707020d7660f3bebca4c54", "input_pcm_sha256": "cd6b33491e70b9497082685d9a16b655bfd7cf8cd49ee1fdea032d4c17572417", "output_wav_sha256": "4e2c4bb44f4faa4be24583c6a95da47213421fdaa806d0be2b8a261bdafdb042", "output_pcm_sha256": "a0693396d61137b741aca21cbab72832ca149e65b5f973feb21753bfc88c786a", "result_sha256": "578cb20517011d9e96e0e70c9c2b6c0f6831726b8881c08f6ee0ed4443138605" } }, { "id": 125, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "080ff76158ed15eb6c259a72a5c7e11a4ce0e042b63f4cdc7c0c2f5eabadd5d8", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "080ff76158ed15eb6c259a72a5c7e11a4ce0e042b63f4cdc7c0c2f5eabadd5d8", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To start with, everyone who is neither an owner of a eucalyptus soap nor an owner of a Kirks soap is a regular user of Pureology shampoo or a regular consumer of Chai shampoo. Now, every regular user of Pureology shampoo is an owner of a Kirks soap or an owner of a eucalyptus soap. We may conclude: whoever is none of this, an owner of a eucalyptus soap or owner of a Kirks soap, is a regular consumer of Chai shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To start with, everyone who is neither an owner of a eucalyptus soap nor an owner of a Kirk's soap is a regular user of purology shampoo or a regular consumer of chai shampoo. Now, every regular user of purology shampoo is an owner of a Kirk's soap or an owner of a eucalyptus soap. We may conclude, whoever is none of this, an owner of a eucalyptus soap or owner of a Kirk soap, is a regular consumer of chai shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 19293.78, "reasoner_ms": 3226.09, "tts_ms": 45.58, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 22565.48, "total_processing_ms": 23408.81 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1079, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 188 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ea86b739c195c90c7bdeb2858bd93cd7dc5395e9486b7a9573f8134c88d327c5", "started_sha256": "edb3d376f709c94771eb7bccde8315dad101275b68c055133e04b74bda29d779", "original_grade_sha256": "0eeb26763361457ddebd8c88ccc1c318347561f63674e2a5423b11908b600538", "input_original_sha256": "ea86b739c195c90c7bdeb2858bd93cd7dc5395e9486b7a9573f8134c88d327c5", "input_wav_sha256": "4617d2d8f7c9775c37ea3ab8b8e5747659280f2a0a6bf6905952f1fe34f0b6e9", "input_pcm_sha256": "65726302f367ee1a1e207de96197b7f4133155a79effe048588a82edeaa273ba", "output_wav_sha256": "943ab854bb413db2d536960eb68b5b18975f07ce3e3c9341392e6b6fcd351b9b", "output_pcm_sha256": "1a04cf41f3656e3f5991e3e9f9f499bf7d961c86e0edf23cc239eccdcbe9384f", "result_sha256": "990736bf6c09a26dc94f9472c283f4b2593b56c4580fefa89c4720eed9b0217a" } }, { "id": 363, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c7cb3bbd191e27549d8005bd72f0295cd13b4d1e6587b86246d27fdb4de18e6a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c7cb3bbd191e27549d8005bd72f0295cd13b4d1e6587b86246d27fdb4de18e6a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take ten steps left. Take ten steps right. Take seven steps backward. Take seven steps forward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take 10 steps left. Take 10 steps right. Take 7 steps backward. Take 7 steps forward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7376.5, "reasoner_ms": 1679.82, "tts_ms": 25.24, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9081.59, "total_processing_ms": 9837.56 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 825, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 48 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "58284ca0b43e5acdb0ba22fc5dd72438f4cd09ad7c63c1462b7a2c8cbccdda89", "started_sha256": "a8b25ece19d6de73e9a960abfdb48c097387fd9faeece1dd623d16864c23e684", "original_grade_sha256": "d465717551232c84112c384d483aff231a7c6511de029daaf349f0b933967d2b", "input_original_sha256": "58284ca0b43e5acdb0ba22fc5dd72438f4cd09ad7c63c1462b7a2c8cbccdda89", "input_wav_sha256": "acdcf5e9d8746c0216d1415b79342f874e2f1be16b82c5f30b85e53509d2f596", "input_pcm_sha256": "172dcd6645a5dd1fdf1405f229ef59858d3df8ee8b342a351546befdd34d4984", "output_wav_sha256": "83da8f2324ac72e57d90be188d27956fb2752edcf767e05051aca3b45ca83113", "output_pcm_sha256": "17c180b0cc0eed1da05bcb8d023ba544144d54a4c5cabb049ea62797f04e5f54", "result_sha256": "123f03cd68b5476ef7d8ac092072a1a7af7d0275ff1db147bf98a1e2d77dd6ea" } }, { "id": 662, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "7", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "65adbc909803af10f5f292de727e0eac99c85699ce5a0cb7900884f28daa850a", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "65adbc909803af10f5f292de727e0eac99c85699ce5a0cb7900884f28daa850a", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have three heads of broccoli, two cauliflowers, a yam, and a lettuce head. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have three heads of broccoli, two cauliflowers, a yam, and a lettuce head. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 7.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5991.24, "reasoner_ms": 1456.3, "tts_ms": 26.21, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7473.77, "total_processing_ms": 8242.83 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 769, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 21 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "61092561c0fb8cd17d2ce7cbce7e769becfce81d2d22d09f96e7e58a50260903", "started_sha256": "eb7ceeffa0b50d70c507145c12301b47c67427615686bf84d369283212664ce4", "original_grade_sha256": "dea6739e1e17432eaed6316854f130382e70cfdf6964a08c79ec9e4fe1b9ec84", "input_original_sha256": "61092561c0fb8cd17d2ce7cbce7e769becfce81d2d22d09f96e7e58a50260903", "input_wav_sha256": "dd487c0bc5ea794451e5265bf0cf16cdbb6fe9eb9ce9b0270da6a02aaf8e2be5", "input_pcm_sha256": "2c3dc220d480550507f0f69a7681c4af1d01ffb2ea28b1fcdf1a0afd3066e27b", "output_wav_sha256": "3e1c168acc460c74941dc523f89112519c46b1db400ff1fa65a7e0d67e7db172", "output_pcm_sha256": "9fa0a66b63be9ca37b681ae5c0b7d83d0a4d2820906975292df458845236ea7f", "result_sha256": "4c1df086d2d3d61505c849320ed5d483460de99b39bfc429bdfab5b48e1f4b9d" } }, { "id": 796, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3ec1cbdaad60d518678f57add8da135da8365f0c25b37502228d6efd6295cd9d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3ec1cbdaad60d518678f57add8da135da8365f0c25b37502228d6efd6295cd9d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Millie tells the truth. Millicent says Millie tells the truth. Raymond says Millicent tells the truth. Krista says Raymond lies. Ka says Krista tells the truth. Does Ka tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Millie tells the truth. Millicent says Millie tells the truth. Raymond says Millicent tells the truth. Krista says Raymond lies. K.A. says Krista tells the truth. Does K.A. tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7620.07, "reasoner_ms": 2268.4, "tts_ms": 24.76, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9913.27, "total_processing_ms": 10628.15 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 842, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 105 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "dd41d5fc1212e67abe895c93502ab9df92d46575b6ea6a5b6685b88c39006dd0", "started_sha256": "b7c1167f806c0ea9c43f196a12e0d09cadce4b1a602f664f85f5a9efdea22e31", "original_grade_sha256": "2dcd799c763534faa1ce31eb11528e3148f9b32bb1e91009fffe44c38f53c088", "input_original_sha256": "dd41d5fc1212e67abe895c93502ab9df92d46575b6ea6a5b6685b88c39006dd0", "input_wav_sha256": "9a645eeab018dc6fcffe35c0b0e0b10b8e4354816712a14f99e8cc50277fafd8", "input_pcm_sha256": "df4434e32de36a95c805ebc216b6213d007d89a1760052ac0ea2c11596fc8f88", "output_wav_sha256": "96096ae339b5e531f41446c0a4f2c85e1d8b13dbdd8f701f5d0ee844544f83d3", "output_pcm_sha256": "5edfc9b178026011489f34820114c08cd0962511bb450fbff7f860d32c835074", "result_sha256": "dc5356e6b2732a3cc065eff8723a5a618b0d038e8b79ed6c70ca289def6809fc" } }, { "id": 120, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4faa6b5bf052eb1f6475966199fa1b400d4aef19782e385d4edd9f0f01feb310", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4faa6b5bf052eb1f6475966199fa1b400d4aef19782e385d4edd9f0f01feb310", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs titanium oxide an ingredient of my washing power? Which chemicals does my perfume contain? It is really difficult to keep track of all chemicals one is regularly exposed to. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First premise: Being an ingredient of Totally Concealed is sufficient for not being an ingredient of Venus D Violet. All this entails that whatever is an ingredient of Venus D Violet is not an ingredient of Totally Concealed. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs titanium oxide an ingredient of my washing power? Which chemicals does my perfume contain? It is really difficult to keep track of all chemicals one is regularly exposed to. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First premise. Being an ingredient of totally concealed is sufficient for not being an ingredient of Venus D. Violet. All this entails that whatever is an ingredient of Venus D. Violet is not an ingredient of totally concealed. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 16565.19, "reasoner_ms": 2071.93, "tts_ms": 25.4, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 18662.55, "total_processing_ms": 19392.44 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1069, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 69 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "04e9e0faec0675662189b8f286df7c4ad788a7002808b3beaa686ae19296402a", "started_sha256": "d493f4d32268f428cfcb13437105f1fc5b8e6f2e56e6de299e0efeca9435d1e0", "original_grade_sha256": "9a0b8be8146aeaa68852e57d8bd9c027647212c87e621b5af7c78477c3ffcf14", "input_original_sha256": "04e9e0faec0675662189b8f286df7c4ad788a7002808b3beaa686ae19296402a", "input_wav_sha256": "0069cba92e9d998c730d84573b345e421cd0b4910fd4c6eedb2a8cbdf7053353", "input_pcm_sha256": "d3b572436c5ae749f8dff856e54efcdad93a459c41922faadd2bfa87d20d0581", "output_wav_sha256": "cf6387bc802749fe88ea5c61fbd898faccc504f432a2ca8b140f0ce016b0ff47", "output_pcm_sha256": "7ff69e74488f66824dc3c10ac723fac0eb15fc04a297278cc2f623177ab85208", "result_sha256": "f4c0760b8a3d2b851922203f16327aad2707f784c09ebc9a569f8cc0071a52ab" } }, { "id": 499, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c39be0e8bbd906bad9dbd6ac1be54556d5e820af39347d8851859a1ccc5bd9d4", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c39be0e8bbd906bad9dbd6ac1be54556d5e820af39347d8851859a1ccc5bd9d4", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take seven steps backward. Take ten steps right. Take four steps forward. Take one step left. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point always face forward take seven steps backward take ten steps right take four steps forward take one step left options yes no answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7806.67, "reasoner_ms": 8291.81, "tts_ms": 23.94, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 16122.44, "total_processing_ms": 16929.25 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 797, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 46 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "128b49aba4e5480c8faaa41557329d0ffdebb018d95e1547ae91dd0d634bdda8", "started_sha256": "ce1f20eab097609fdeb7794c1d7cb406064d13accd4749aece0719fde30f41af", "original_grade_sha256": "5876f199c810271e57b476728a05dd688c6a76152adf763e0110c4d982fc6bc0", "input_original_sha256": "128b49aba4e5480c8faaa41557329d0ffdebb018d95e1547ae91dd0d634bdda8", "input_wav_sha256": "4488e98c8ecbe188b735693d7fa60534eaf8b3be935dec3cd35e092542a1e9f2", "input_pcm_sha256": "65f06791823c3f5706abe49a2c17ac830fe638db651d5d0fc514a32725fa9c7b", "output_wav_sha256": "b196998e609e36859b7ea7a581fbea7094e12a3e3c7944065cc7f78fc53c8592", "output_pcm_sha256": "9365f599cd41e80444c336cdb6eabbbe5a01d33fd2cac2681f23a2f69f805dfc", "result_sha256": "7f7871f03664037b5005cc4ee298688e4df8c6a1d1a5e5f1c8deef93867928e5" } }, { "id": 619, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b17ed50a1d6eefd5466f0a68e6afefcdc5c07f991de7ea87dd8ff20a31443263", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b17ed50a1d6eefd5466f0a68e6afefcdc5c07f991de7ea87dd8ff20a31443263", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a clarinet, an accordion, a cabbage, two flutes, a piano, a drum, a trombone, a lettuce head, and two violins. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a clarinet, an accordion, a cabbage, two flutes, a piano, a drum, a trombone, a lettuce head, and two violins. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 9.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6826.03, "reasoner_ms": 1973.46, "tts_ms": 30.56, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8830.09, "total_processing_ms": 9667.24 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 807, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 74 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "36509d1375803d1dd56aa4f5b19ae7b397c08d24c2329e9ac9540d1a06506bfa", "started_sha256": "0bdbfe62efa607b43d8666592a1037892278a700ea8f7927a09069345769e591", "original_grade_sha256": "c9bdae0c3336b904533798b47659c2827c22c2c3b9b10b60bfe9e3758d631372", "input_original_sha256": "36509d1375803d1dd56aa4f5b19ae7b397c08d24c2329e9ac9540d1a06506bfa", "input_wav_sha256": "a5b7923137c4a9d6d64f61cc7878843a1df2b822d0d8b7db8566765194a6a127", "input_pcm_sha256": "7da8dcd0d42df0ad60714d272b24810c308a9743fe8d632c65ce3978544ea93a", "output_wav_sha256": "4e083f99f94dc470bf6ed2f9e69bde1252ccf85681a60739476548de296c0749", "output_pcm_sha256": "8bb7041f562cc4b972b743a56aeedc76213641af2734a48251800c70aadd5855", "result_sha256": "2ec07c22f6c77b8f3363bd710c4c8be39ff750540f23df4375d03bdb49b502b8" } }, { "id": 948, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "752421a934adf3ed245b41cbd5335669341f9a84f88352e13496841da5442d04", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "752421a934adf3ed245b41cbd5335669341f9a84f88352e13496841da5442d04", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Fletcher lies. Jerry says Fletcher lies. Raymond says Jerry lies. Conception says Raymond lies. Amberly says Conception tells the truth. Does Amberly tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Fletcher lies. Jerry says Fletcher lies. Raymond says Jerry lies. Conception says Raymond lies. Amberly says Conception tells the truth. Does Amberly tell the truth? Answer the the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 10458.19, "reasoner_ms": 2211.99, "tts_ms": 42.68, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 12712.89, "total_processing_ms": 13472.26 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 834, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 115 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "eaf3875da4031c8e3ece9228391905a720f07837e352288f3be99745b6e92d66", "started_sha256": "cdb7ff8398a7b663e7eef6a93d700256f859eeab8184453bb4878a6e6b3f7d07", "original_grade_sha256": "4ee0d5136c2e5dd8867eb4d4afdad27d80c5b5a9774d2390de26719ed6fb5b04", "input_original_sha256": "eaf3875da4031c8e3ece9228391905a720f07837e352288f3be99745b6e92d66", "input_wav_sha256": "016a877bfa44ef725b3f21fb5ca21d6b9daebf76093ea02fa9ffdfff13550bda", "input_pcm_sha256": "ee236006667660b3d2882ab294d3f68acdca52fd1c4c8c0ffdbfbe7f6a4d4fc8", "output_wav_sha256": "3fc6aed06aaf73c678a004c4195799e82ea364e732874641a92b17525ce7b8db", "output_pcm_sha256": "c7076a40b714892f71c52e51e6ef39eb68b3f9db63c992d1185af44b2c12f481", "result_sha256": "64c8952b64ae3fa7742a0a8fd74762492867e4243f6a048d3244d3b9d0f34466" } }, { "id": 104, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f5abb231ee79fa0301dc8b5f4e244913b37e56ada88ab3f93b8d735454b400a1", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f5abb231ee79fa0301dc8b5f4e244913b37e56ada88ab3f93b8d735454b400a1", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, every stepbrother of Matthew is an ancestor of Derek. Next, there exists an ancestor of Martin who is not an ancestor of Derek or not an ancestor of Jose. Plus, being an ancestor of Jose is necessary for being a stepbrother of Matthew. Therefore, somebody is an ancestor of Martin and not a stepbrother of Matthew. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom, and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, every stepbrother of Matthew is an ancestor of Derek. Next, there exists an ancestor of Martin who is not an ancestor of Derek or not an ancestor of Hosea. Plus, being an ancestor of Hosea is necessary for being a stepbrother of Matthew. Therefore, somebody is an ancestor of Martin and not a stepbrother of Matthew. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 16548.89, "reasoner_ms": 4400.14, "tts_ms": 47.32, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 20996.39, "total_processing_ms": 21675.71 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1083, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 318 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "59b42f45285e71d53b1109a24deaf61a2f9625c846155df0544b72a046486d0d", "started_sha256": "ab7d44b0b0a6673a3d8b494a2015f59724fb20456a7439db653d4d24d73ebf56", "original_grade_sha256": "5459909071dea24d406e05f250a5883e99a95af1a79b545fdc30fb87f9b0557d", "input_original_sha256": "59b42f45285e71d53b1109a24deaf61a2f9625c846155df0544b72a046486d0d", "input_wav_sha256": "bf47ede8ef5d6d4b2c2eb98e13bd4d5cc7a590754da4a63a7ee3983cfd0c3acf", "input_pcm_sha256": "ee1f58bc5bbf05255ed8efdea8cad8a2d5f380b81ef13afe932cb6d464f0538d", "output_wav_sha256": "4638be92c89c965f3d17e488ccab6efd09604953b3f770d9a884af0d41b2844c", "output_pcm_sha256": "d0158a3cc8f45461ca49e953a76cc2cade404fbe756369db1b5599b3175f2f25", "result_sha256": "c9eb907ea46d43feac167e352ea64312ff2a71005925b9e71b8525589ebcf463" } }, { "id": 407, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d0c261689633d30fda6aa02c3be78a0ff02599f3a28566025e857872236410f7", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d0c261689633d30fda6aa02c3be78a0ff02599f3a28566025e857872236410f7", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps forward. Take eight steps backward. Take four steps forward. Take four steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps forward. Take eight steps backward. Take four steps forward. Take four steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7509.45, "reasoner_ms": 1790.53, "tts_ms": 25.12, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9325.13, "total_processing_ms": 10142.83 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 817, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 42 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0f74057a22356cfa06c5b8a5d6c8343a294cf051ab4031d55b5339ccb24e4e6a", "started_sha256": "8aa1386dd674bd08a605eafbda53e2890111e80a145fb0f7abb0b26372558611", "original_grade_sha256": "5599ed6e8ef9ebc9c10aeed65d2e58829ba315ec75a1bbf2a901a61852851aeb", "input_original_sha256": "0f74057a22356cfa06c5b8a5d6c8343a294cf051ab4031d55b5339ccb24e4e6a", "input_wav_sha256": "0a57b9c488d2a140015eb64d70006c05c9c014b1d6f3f751d8ad86c904e61a14", "input_pcm_sha256": "7b64e10ddec46ed9da35796367d7c3968bff3dd71e97b26f1d938b1c5afad795", "output_wav_sha256": "fb7d956212d8727b50f53e3f160b5d22d3d34bacdcf0547324662eed9b5a6323", "output_pcm_sha256": "fd18bc5b3a94d5c2a7350f8a723a7710ce1ec6fd58f28716b7c848479e92cb5f", "result_sha256": "d30c753e8254fc74cc289df49e0c4ad15bb5ebdaae8adca6201b8c71d2547176" } }, { "id": 588, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "13", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8c459ba1ad912ccfc2d14d844a1eb92a585b6a0b62bf667a3a791eae8ee708fd", "normalized_answer": "13" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8c459ba1ad912ccfc2d14d844a1eb92a585b6a0b62bf667a3a791eae8ee708fd", "normalized_answer": "13" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a lamp, an oven, four couches, a chair, a fridge, a toaster, a microwave, a bed, a car, and a table. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a lamp, an oven, four couches, a chair, a fridge, a toaster, a microwave, a bed, a car, and a table. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 13.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6512.98, "reasoner_ms": 2000.82, "tts_ms": 31.76, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8545.59, "total_processing_ms": 9266.1 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 794, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 87 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "013540e4b687a6cd1a1578ff29dc54e682baaeb60986b1e9870caca6bf79123b", "started_sha256": "eda9e2d4bf5b849441a73038340b8e2f8e71a20dfb08459760abeb16dca50f63", "original_grade_sha256": "65ed1f8d2323f2aee4d7c0977f3d7dbfcf99464cc0bdea2a3da2ea084ebcc417", "input_original_sha256": "013540e4b687a6cd1a1578ff29dc54e682baaeb60986b1e9870caca6bf79123b", "input_wav_sha256": "e87b5877926bdaaa9ae61ae1bc4bb335eff7c26c06bf23c53e63078076761484", "input_pcm_sha256": "147a495dd63d6b5474bec53226ed155e6ba557c0d9afb7c36122ec5c6e62aaee", "output_wav_sha256": "f50e0ddc0c2364079763db3f5303c8b387b609566560a80d82d361ebbb588f3a", "output_pcm_sha256": "cc6a23005fd8b611f8403648beeb110318c4198b4f1829135e41acc8253f4b6f", "result_sha256": "0af80c44a4fc52e4997933ad2203962e805c1b5a2445f3b9508ff829077782ae" } }, { "id": 987, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1e94e9a6942adf31ee8cef18cc9da879eb59adc183bcb138ab366c0e740e31fa", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1e94e9a6942adf31ee8cef18cc9da879eb59adc183bcb138ab366c0e740e31fa", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Jamie lies. Jamie says Jamie tells the truth. Sal says Jamie lies. Amberly says Sal lies. Jerry says Amberly tells the truth. Does Jerry tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Jamie lies. Jamie says Jamie tells the truth. Sal says Jamie lies. Amberly says Sal lies. Jerry says Amberly tells the truth. Does Jerry tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6263.11, "reasoner_ms": 2068.11, "tts_ms": 23.0, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8354.25, "total_processing_ms": 9084.86 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 97 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1f178e693ed1766b4f8961dfb3b61e9837f10e8dcba9985ba6f448db02f3ec3c", "started_sha256": "6c19180cc6a5c0e9f24a944f84c37d8798e2bb693516c1f6e44d00240f7744e8", "original_grade_sha256": "9df370576dc54d0e06f4ca4a69247640a2b9dc747dab7b08a92149d1391e691d", "input_original_sha256": "1f178e693ed1766b4f8961dfb3b61e9837f10e8dcba9985ba6f448db02f3ec3c", "input_wav_sha256": "5272768fd427fa221fd50844726b70f1be7bbcef6edc95eea9e5143b6a28357c", "input_pcm_sha256": "5d1e74dee2eab08c0e06fab6d6aac48a0a5b1f828f38067942ab73579de901a8", "output_wav_sha256": "566f381f0c98f80409ee799526a0a71819c807f31f984d227afd3021bf4438cf", "output_pcm_sha256": "df7c0c677767f71c58a7acbf654ebe3124d4afa9f354ac417ed170cb02b0e228", "result_sha256": "f4ba6569fc7b1fe3b871120dcd833b5059c47088262126ac9a234bb821258dcd" } }, { "id": 216, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b05b90fec768e421ec39b8627371685bfc40619fb933c1b4db590a190f47740b", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b05b90fec768e421ec39b8627371685bfc40619fb933c1b4db590a190f47740b", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nSome football fans admire various clubs. Others love only a single team. But who is a fan of whom precisely? The following argument pertains to this question. To start with, no admirer of CFR 1907 Cluj is an expert of Inverness Caledonian Thistle FC. Now, being an expert of Inverness Caledonian Thistle FC is necessary for being an ex-fan of FC Vital. It follows that being an admirer of CFR 1907 Cluj is necessary for not being an ex-fan of FC Vital. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nSome football fans admire various clubs, others love only a single team. But who is a fan of whom precisely? The following argument pertains to this question, to start with, no admirer of CFR 1907 Kludge is an expert of Inverness Caledonian Thistle FC. Now, being an expert of Inverness Caledonian Thistle FC is necessary for being an ex-fan of FC Vitral. It follows that being an admirer of CFR 1907 Kludge is necessary for not being an ex-fan of FC Vitral. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 17384.72, "reasoner_ms": 5985.96, "tts_ms": 23.4, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 23394.15, "total_processing_ms": 24190.41 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1099, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 377 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b9075628b54eca2028069d1b7b9d83202f66ca9b8fb8904b6def3821cd09316d", "started_sha256": "2eb477c280bc923b03d8b7bd771fddf16668f8214c2af2e74a105258ddc9c618", "original_grade_sha256": "d1dc619bb3c81d3ce8c4d04bb5306b1f1b8ef1c1f0800d28ae46c03bc1d9ba04", "input_original_sha256": "b9075628b54eca2028069d1b7b9d83202f66ca9b8fb8904b6def3821cd09316d", "input_wav_sha256": "6f9969678fb88891725240480fcee0c8df1c361ac37df3e3880306b1bff86d96", "input_pcm_sha256": "045381357561ae6c5c4f9d00d7032e18d29cf49719b543e4c226977a2a8b24d9", "output_wav_sha256": "c2604e53c800c6c38122534314c5f2bd06060dbc2589bcd53f02aa0ee8f9bb52", "output_pcm_sha256": "d412b8a71593a6308fe91938d55a74eb2d9adf039a7e0b2d97c2d741201fea1d", "result_sha256": "a0b464f879a0905e893e604ef7c382fd910ff127314edc770f99d1266d3ef1f7" } }, { "id": 450, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b569c02937263d58543f2f75007a848b817a1b8db7ebc0de4ec527359f0f8b9c", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b569c02937263d58543f2f75007a848b817a1b8db7ebc0de4ec527359f0f8b9c", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps left. Take ten steps forward. Take nine steps right. Take ten steps backward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point always face forward take nine steps left take ten steps forward take nine steps right Take 10 steps backward Options Yes No Answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 10747.45, "reasoner_ms": 1855.03, "tts_ms": 25.39, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 12627.9, "total_processing_ms": 13443.17 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 807, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 57 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "4126882f779547aac0b98fbe0e3acf0950b9cd87de62571faeff15e36e4eceba", "started_sha256": "fa71dda5305a9ec2ab29f093c58c2c60e4aa182628f1bd9d6866a8842cc819ce", "original_grade_sha256": "c326a23555a4e2ad721e59b8e906c412edf3973c84f936d44ec3f7ddf8bd553b", "input_original_sha256": "4126882f779547aac0b98fbe0e3acf0950b9cd87de62571faeff15e36e4eceba", "input_wav_sha256": "64af66abb7f3e626fcca916f07d8fd1ea93d54d714585de1154d9e0efbb2f041", "input_pcm_sha256": "0ba21249c2a950e44bf6979a740a263adc44771639476c62a97e00b932d0eaa2", "output_wav_sha256": "82ae8bcf283ea921a221bf62470a686371da318d5e86624d0840c6c663121002", "output_pcm_sha256": "2199c925e2867dc28725f1422079894a25c3bfda315c2c39c098ae6909644b7b", "result_sha256": "479e4e309b6d3913df685bab0b16ad69b1d3a687856abd5c55f18f2761604e3d" } }, { "id": 553, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "2", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e027d593b7372f38e10caa3a901eac969b9669232548cdca8f50a78642c73667", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e027d593b7372f38e10caa3a901eac969b9669232548cdca8f50a78642c73667", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a frog and a mouse. How many animals do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a frog and a mouse. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 2.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5122.44, "reasoner_ms": 1272.14, "tts_ms": 23.9, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6418.52, "total_processing_ms": 7263.58 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 725, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8798693eaeaefa46b6fffcf4829b7c04c62e7e42cadc6b7dff28e5e3c1df1501", "started_sha256": "3578173720f6da9389970bc8dfdaf31a39e004249f1405d6deb66e73efc79ce2", "original_grade_sha256": "1e05c836d6654b5167dbe2e0949e9d36a02c7f166fde871e6d3e297051259520", "input_original_sha256": "8798693eaeaefa46b6fffcf4829b7c04c62e7e42cadc6b7dff28e5e3c1df1501", "input_wav_sha256": "2b574bd7b9518a0029084ac57878c301174b97522841bd45c133f726078da29a", "input_pcm_sha256": "5875286fc1645df6812f0602239baf1f60ee78ef43d0eba277bc6b778e02dc22", "output_wav_sha256": "ff7125a7a363a2c436d62c6d7f4b8952400670c1ce87e44bc04cb7039de75301", "output_pcm_sha256": "ad8c1376a287ec4349160f0a049de4cdb6f6b81affaad64c6969d0e662ae310b", "result_sha256": "5013ad843985db8f8e92841f7a4be479dde677b1056fa8dd0c8a6ca3402a28dd" } }, { "id": 999, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "13ec960b10d8280c3b32116d69d8e91161ce5232143d1493e0be94a2ecee8a41", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "13ec960b10d8280c3b32116d69d8e91161ce5232143d1493e0be94a2ecee8a41", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Sherry tells the truth. Ryan says Sherry lies. Bernita says Ryan tells the truth. Tamika says Bernita lies. Jerry says Tamika lies. Does Jerry tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Sherry tells the truth. Ryan says Sherry lies. Bernita says Ryan tells the truth. Tamika says Bernita lies. Jerry says Tamika lies. Does Jerry tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "That answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7014.56, "reasoner_ms": 2039.92, "tts_ms": 28.52, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9083.03, "total_processing_ms": 9930.26 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 840, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 103 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e60a53922057cb7d1d95a88c79bfc33a343d5c94eb00ee61621d73768cfadff2", "started_sha256": "30cefd162f0b7595c9fe4c4e2a53b7c51e7585ed94024aa8edc409ab34e10890", "original_grade_sha256": "b109cdde81012f3b8aab10ec000a65428952b608c9d43ea7485b3e245bc34da7", "input_original_sha256": "e60a53922057cb7d1d95a88c79bfc33a343d5c94eb00ee61621d73768cfadff2", "input_wav_sha256": "8fdcfa7d68669c576c214d56ab98c97776657bdaf3195383bc8a0c1fc48fae3c", "input_pcm_sha256": "c80c329207501ae4d7e1d20b176cf1744be884ff07c11d115d5719bb6495890b", "output_wav_sha256": "b32813366d3d02c3b90ad3307e4a5d0630236ff4731f814f095ea6aa4f22fdfa", "output_pcm_sha256": "5db2fc9faa6118205e7f8ac59a9a4d4e22487941da439f0777e527d8711c1e7b", "result_sha256": "b5f2306a5e159c4d93d763987891b9a69a2c4a73336e97b59d9eb11b4664b2a4" } }, { "id": 117, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1614d6d59e1f065ea627667fbbddbadc519ac9e0fa3b1f9f0bea96f2c550bac3", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1614d6d59e1f065ea627667fbbddbadc519ac9e0fa3b1f9f0bea96f2c550bac3", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To begin with, being a frequent consumer of Dove soap is sufficient for being an owner of a Bumble and Bumble shampoo. So necessarily, everyone who is an owner of a Bumble and Bumble shampoo is a frequent consumer of Dove soap, too. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To begin with, being a frequent consumer of Dove soap is sufficient for being an owner of a Bumble and Bumble shampoo. So necessarily, everyone who is an owner of a Bumble and Bumble shampoo is a frequent consumer of Dove soap, too. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 21494.84, "reasoner_ms": 1685.48, "tts_ms": 63.84, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 23244.19, "total_processing_ms": 24271.25 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1032, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 48 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "03ef39468c9e708387607f9fc4e50777bc893bdb4c82c6ced04cd81336a8bef7", "started_sha256": "d759f755e4344b97961e5a97eac220bd32eb548ae1e3bd2c6ceb55e822ca5e53", "original_grade_sha256": "a83f965870f3ed1bcd45e99c02dd03322b33bd5271704cb53040030965901fb1", "input_original_sha256": "03ef39468c9e708387607f9fc4e50777bc893bdb4c82c6ced04cd81336a8bef7", "input_wav_sha256": "651ad520b168c33f948b0e4cb1620a91485bec83e833b12a350b524c9b173b92", "input_pcm_sha256": "26bf96016ded5228b458cf932cbf2a787366b7497be3860abc93786bf3c7ab8f", "output_wav_sha256": "e6d84dbdfe1960c43924c7b0a6da192373500a9af1ed26fbce81ea62e226684d", "output_pcm_sha256": "e6ec855be8369e7a304b9fb776f454b94afe7cfd47b8d4f026b25c08da8ab986", "result_sha256": "a0304095f861fcc776fc6dbc0fdd52ce31aa75520ea0182ff723c983f6e39fc1" } }, { "id": 265, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "92cb2563d43d2d11f207302c46ec2694a579b9d6745b5e4f2a3e517062e41a9a", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "92cb2563d43d2d11f207302c46ec2694a579b9d6745b5e4f2a3e517062e41a9a", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left. Turn right. Turn around. Turn left. Take four steps. Turn left. Turn around. Take three steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left. Turn right. Turn around. Turn left. Take four steps. Turn left. Turn around. Take three steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 10871.23, "reasoner_ms": 5340.39, "tts_ms": 26.75, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 16238.4, "total_processing_ms": 17229.19 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 825, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 326 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "482a4fae58274e5246914ba9a7405f57d1b606c97f89077ea970fd10ad382d29", "started_sha256": "b4ef73e51d05aaca6c1509e9845a85770d858517232ca713548579d8fd530c10", "original_grade_sha256": "a24f53b8750d26bf5bc0b4f3111533cfaafde0e8c18dfeca9c503d41c857d5f8", "input_original_sha256": "482a4fae58274e5246914ba9a7405f57d1b606c97f89077ea970fd10ad382d29", "input_wav_sha256": "5b2aaa4fb21cd101209611bf38cefc00917fcf6d31884fc0385eb18bceebc2b8", "input_pcm_sha256": "3dede84c78ebaeac014cfe71e1fadde308d72a0adcb777ba7a9cd5098e02b5fe", "output_wav_sha256": "a120424c4279550c55e8d02ddf5349968ddc8602911948375f5087e390c24189", "output_pcm_sha256": "7386a9a62327e8b48ff6044030f7483d77d8a44404ad453b5cdbaf667a2fc618", "result_sha256": "569c5cbe19ddaabf2a28d1467a1c6aaef623bfb7964c5cded47f7b3096da7389" } }, { "id": 586, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4f000e57ebb123c6c35fb3d9d88225eb5a14b47f899ef326ca76b6c66b66789a", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4f000e57ebb123c6c35fb3d9d88225eb5a14b47f899ef326ca76b6c66b66789a", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a trumpet, two violins, a clarinet, an accordion, a piano, a snail, a fish, a trombone, a drum, and a flute. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a trumpet, two violins, a clarinet, an accordion, a piano, a snail, a fish, a trombone, a drum, and a flute. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 9.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8964.31, "reasoner_ms": 2147.72, "tts_ms": 33.08, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11145.24, "total_processing_ms": 12120.91 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 808, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 91 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "161e426a8bdf20b0487ba8538a4a8be426dd2ae83c26ebfb367d65af996168e1", "started_sha256": "c3904e1781831c3c6618ff2137b0b2cb11b426976a900f055382ff1d35148962", "original_grade_sha256": "30bcbf7c12c6fc45dcaf7e0f8f8ec5621ab397589f87ac6fe6633e0cb617c484", "input_original_sha256": "161e426a8bdf20b0487ba8538a4a8be426dd2ae83c26ebfb367d65af996168e1", "input_wav_sha256": "c9b1769e075c7e62c1994177e9233edacd7089c1669fd0892e13537b45d2be8c", "input_pcm_sha256": "68457dbed3ad14ee4c7e384a75ebb4479adfebf8c71c1c61f8564e17be5c39b8", "output_wav_sha256": "6a73abca78911939387f322c4efa599cb39809450e39fa6fe15f9d31f1e2542e", "output_pcm_sha256": "7278f783d813f73cb43fdc4d90fecf1ade4f5859a1326aee68ff41e62b7a9c5a", "result_sha256": "72e5ee6ac19f42066f6c051eedccb0648588f3a51e875f2d82a4f11d3ace0347" } }, { "id": 781, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8e1835e7f4d036c18e77466ed42adab2ed2465f8afde3a5197fe54b7a272ec49", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8e1835e7f4d036c18e77466ed42adab2ed2465f8afde3a5197fe54b7a272ec49", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Audrey lies. Sherry says Audrey lies. Willian says Sherry tells the truth. Conception says Willian tells the truth. Gwen says Conception lies. Does Gwen tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nAudrey lies. Sherry says Audrey lies. William says Sherry tells the truth. Conception says William tells the truth. Gwen says Conception lies. Does Gwen tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9083.44, "reasoner_ms": 2394.57, "tts_ms": 20.82, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11498.86, "total_processing_ms": 12506.43 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 824, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 126 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1a978394dfa8e69c3b3ec7b0494bb12b075d281ed0c17b1dd8b704d1a39131e3", "started_sha256": "9aebb3f154147e2150f1417f64177e4d81e41855f5603f4a3ef5a8aa856bec15", "original_grade_sha256": "9d1ccbc717110012d28be2958053d2f538c7a7290cead632b580fe605e3bc169", "input_original_sha256": "1a978394dfa8e69c3b3ec7b0494bb12b075d281ed0c17b1dd8b704d1a39131e3", "input_wav_sha256": "fc6a8a1d4c4df54c0b7aff338d6fa9d9eb449f91cd809e352008c117bfeebad4", "input_pcm_sha256": "aeb6c1f6c71276404d12b3aa3a52b29fadc5843486c1663fd8479c82b050a4fd", "output_wav_sha256": "a25e040a3ad8012a762cc022d4fd9042d5cdf1482d1041b8c70c4fa09e737d50", "output_pcm_sha256": "69d28183a1aec14ae3390ae794e9252f57f3e2f2636fa1085e58f1df391a0c62", "result_sha256": "1379a04b9569d2329d2e45a0ac56b6d50194c3c07c8b32bb8653377095a7c31d" } }, { "id": 51, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "756c3b2583de62bd130df3b26fc3cf2b7198e48b5fb5ea41f0a3702f144d683a", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "756c3b2583de62bd130df3b26fc3cf2b7198e48b5fb5ea41f0a3702f144d683a", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. It is false that Colleen is an ancestor of Cheryl. Whoever is a stepsister of Esther is not an ancestor of Cheryl. It follows that it is false that Colleen is a stepsister of Esther. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument, it is false that Colleen is an ancestor of Cheryl. Whoever is a stepsister of Esther is not an ancestor of Cheryl. It follows that it is false that Colleen is a stepsister of Esther. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options? Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11413.07, "reasoner_ms": 3910.62, "tts_ms": 21.42, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15345.16, "total_processing_ms": 16313.15 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 936, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 227 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "edff7695374b8b089fd2bb07bc88e35dd1ee90548eb7ad2a29082a939f018dd2", "started_sha256": "5dd2a185b52bfe26df2d7337fba1af2847c327a5c80dd2ca9fb02669ac88f4d3", "original_grade_sha256": "e59819e27bd68a14a68a0327fd16c1a3ba888a8f7d6523b318fd0d4334b6327c", "input_original_sha256": "edff7695374b8b089fd2bb07bc88e35dd1ee90548eb7ad2a29082a939f018dd2", "input_wav_sha256": "4b3542fa0ea9392fb4ed37a4c4712485309efd0c5de1e72df810df47b5b960e4", "input_pcm_sha256": "5b2676b1f6d38d4f73c3bfef5edb101c7bcf2be4637c268a5820ba3395113348", "output_wav_sha256": "a70024147fc57138005977855b12e4b1d034024c14834280f357f6fe5463befb", "output_pcm_sha256": "218bd9a2244a99a5bfe45304d79f787b71beee8c61e1f5759a6fd3f2bfe5c380", "result_sha256": "00ad6d90d701fcf21a840145727e6d6997f422e8875e4e09b0bb45b51884911b" } }, { "id": 476, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "056fe6142bdf773bc07e6216385919f9813d5092cb53610ec36fd3746b706cb6", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "056fe6142bdf773bc07e6216385919f9813d5092cb53610ec36fd3746b706cb6", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps left. Take six steps right. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps left. Take six steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7891.14, "reasoner_ms": 1765.18, "tts_ms": 31.27, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9687.63, "total_processing_ms": 10580.26 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 782, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 28 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "abdfe7aa6a94dcc81ce9e844421e36b311bafcdf35b25df22857777edc16d645", "started_sha256": "f69baaa2cee9558b22a2f75bf0ab17fb4a9f5b32a94d449e78fedc005a90cdcf", "original_grade_sha256": "281af64ea3cfa1f7d10602f5cd536c29cc99d194004623c230e6cc4d7cadd142", "input_original_sha256": "abdfe7aa6a94dcc81ce9e844421e36b311bafcdf35b25df22857777edc16d645", "input_wav_sha256": "bdc013c146555c1be332056ee2adb9134c498dd73b35efddddcdb70d26cc8c9c", "input_pcm_sha256": "87bd54afb40fa20a553936b198a28d8f9477c945ab9ea8c193e10658d1fc99fa", "output_wav_sha256": "3dfc964361b913b586db4d38768ee8a16a46969cccc4cdfa7bfe9ed3f5cf6697", "output_pcm_sha256": "8fc0dad6bbf6a58eac6d83a57e52b1d79fb910e285a6fce1df710c651db5d71d", "result_sha256": "ab0fb7c2a7d01d6867c648c48da999e299dbcc519356c6de07ea947efdc5ec40" } }, { "id": 686, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "16", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4c53a5d3deee1d8609ec15fd46b4099d6a2914a29c4b6e5fd6aef625c95198a9", "normalized_answer": "16" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4c53a5d3deee1d8609ec15fd46b4099d6a2914a29c4b6e5fd6aef625c95198a9", "normalized_answer": "16" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have four couches, a microwave, a table, a chair, a fridge, four stoves, a lamp, a car, an oven, and a toaster. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have four couches, a microwave, a table, a chair, a fridge, four stoves, a lamp, a car, an oven, and a toaster. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 16.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8560.38, "reasoner_ms": 2234.0, "tts_ms": 33.39, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10827.83, "total_processing_ms": 11748.84 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 796, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 98 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a54616a77986850a277e3fba83a27ab596c680c3ce1aedf51b32ef2dfa35ac72", "started_sha256": "cb4e9d6c843091dc424ad7f48b4b6fcaaa29e6346b895ded3205dbaa47906027", "original_grade_sha256": "28b7b09b6e5a1dfd13fcf45ff8b3c8156224efffd2d575d890c07c2a51290cf0", "input_original_sha256": "a54616a77986850a277e3fba83a27ab596c680c3ce1aedf51b32ef2dfa35ac72", "input_wav_sha256": "7357f9f4f1e2bceb79313f69b1e2e6ac4142b964d2ca6031ccee972d74e65316", "input_pcm_sha256": "4451ff6db7870bac60f481e6fe8ca99baed6712104673863739076709c4a6e29", "output_wav_sha256": "f7d9424da62d85c7dd6183d2eb7f74fae1a03f535a7aef5ac66d0d1a9d8a99ea", "output_pcm_sha256": "d5751422661b3b7e5d66b18a73513e4def5400d2c3151bd5377d346e768c3035", "result_sha256": "d08463669888fe2b235972782ca2eb5310eed8832829e854db763c2492b681b4" } }, { "id": 939, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0323a5a340c1c9a2ac7291be81f73ca56c9a9b649be8952c82e644dbb2ca40d5", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0323a5a340c1c9a2ac7291be81f73ca56c9a9b649be8952c82e644dbb2ca40d5", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Delbert lies. Shalonda says Delbert tells the truth. Tamika says Shalonda lies. Sal says Tamika lies. Helene says Sal lies. Does Helene tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Delbert lies. Shalanda says Delbert tells the truth. Tamika says Shalanda lies. Sal says Tamika lies. Helene says Sal lies. Does Helene tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8373.36, "reasoner_ms": 2248.81, "tts_ms": 29.26, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10651.46, "total_processing_ms": 11612.19 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 830, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 112 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "fbf35a5df2b1717ec521ad121738b41f920de494d4cd45518e5b904ad9a0a466", "started_sha256": "ae5688729db087bbd052bd1f3aa647244f8e6f4c07fc980e63e6c2c58b1feeb9", "original_grade_sha256": "82d14e0a29b2246972fe2cd2348f5858656463c23d78a9ca30cf31ad3cc3174d", "input_original_sha256": "fbf35a5df2b1717ec521ad121738b41f920de494d4cd45518e5b904ad9a0a466", "input_wav_sha256": "c8e47b3e17be8d078c7be3ef48dd54be3f191b7351810a4d9ea00beba1e4015e", "input_pcm_sha256": "ed8da464b801a5c8b9c549c7b47bf9d3920462c3a599689b5279ca4fd8f4bb1e", "output_wav_sha256": "b6cf18b126ef102fac2a934dad9eb93c03a6214cfb6ebe999b35ab902d02fe79", "output_pcm_sha256": "8193b12c83332215681867603b9ef360e165c416133c08993d77cffd6b5b9bc2", "result_sha256": "c9636fe6eb10f3adf3d63fd03b171a69d59f8ae8b73583bf58f0f805ad3af101" } }, { "id": 67, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "01ae0b3d1cc30d08134dfad5e678722f36254b24666f56c06ee392dc0f56029e", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "01ae0b3d1cc30d08134dfad5e678722f36254b24666f56c06ee392dc0f56029e", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, nobody is neither an ancestor of Alvin nor a workmate of Tony. Moreover, whoever is a schoolmate of Keith is not an ancestor of Alvin. Therefore, everyone who is a schoolmate of Keith is a workmate of Tony, too. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, nobody is neither an ancestor of Alvin nor a workmate of Tony. Moreover, whoever is a schoolmate of Keith is not an ancestor of Alvin. Therefore, everyone who is a schoolmate of Keith is a workmate of Tony, too. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 20245.49, "reasoner_ms": 2833.32, "tts_ms": 32.04, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 23110.9, "total_processing_ms": 24045.44 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 923, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 152 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "535d66344ec494d0b10172db25f901604e06855a9813fc02e1c17de0a20eb233", "started_sha256": "b22ec23e771f3ed3dd4e2f6c2bbe7d033ecd4bca59f09085c23b5c3496688347", "original_grade_sha256": "dc5e46ff3d92927871e243269eb354df1836062edaad6309c5a2c7aacd842344", "input_original_sha256": "535d66344ec494d0b10172db25f901604e06855a9813fc02e1c17de0a20eb233", "input_wav_sha256": "95bae7dedd31ab39139aef15ce9e415fb74f7d86c21fbc5b74ed0637238f09a2", "input_pcm_sha256": "fa165efb50660f615d97c4591686a34b19de8a3c2b5264db8462c88b1eef259c", "output_wav_sha256": "b493746b0c0d5921e3b474fc6ceba88815cb52011fe309b9db749978ab8c438f", "output_pcm_sha256": "f0654ecbb5227fd063a4ea4f981686f6b74f0574aad4acd75fea81c83ca740db", "result_sha256": "73189c266ec96a9a70824cc4f8c3dcb5888720c5d6ee29d88a098689f0d3a9e8" } }, { "id": 441, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1c6f2b0ba21b0b5cd727d1ea2fd5672e62a313974b8531e4eeb2979cd19a98e7", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1c6f2b0ba21b0b5cd727d1ea2fd5672e62a313974b8531e4eeb2979cd19a98e7", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take two steps. Take three steps. Turn around. Take four steps. Take one step. Options. Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point take two steps take three steps turn around take four steps take one step options yes no answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13860.27, "reasoner_ms": 1952.54, "tts_ms": 30.09, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15842.93, "total_processing_ms": 16675.18 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 780, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 53 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "eeaa8c785a43e02412e94ab33327955e094bb949d0aea2671e4319187c5d6ae4", "started_sha256": "80771edc338fec14617ddae6733753428f1924b1f09b40587401ba75e33b3b75", "original_grade_sha256": "d8479da731721930bc415ee6be6fd515ebb7bf999270093213780e7455b11fd2", "input_original_sha256": "eeaa8c785a43e02412e94ab33327955e094bb949d0aea2671e4319187c5d6ae4", "input_wav_sha256": "cd391c5c34381b72d95b7dd49a1584734bfcd822846bab33918fea531f0c67e0", "input_pcm_sha256": "2b64f1a34a5e641be8272c6f518ad04c34c1d346f5c1cb0f99c957cc40aa2d1d", "output_wav_sha256": "661c2f92f52aa267033aeef34cb6bf55987b9d8ec0016b68717dabc0c950e576", "output_pcm_sha256": "217019d8d186a36ab2c38fe8bcea2bb783ad9d227dbec1238893953705eeeb71", "result_sha256": "0a26beb9be9932918bc0fbd536ef890c8f469b85eab064d4f104962857a5d953" } }, { "id": 731, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "11", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8b5ea45a01d53e9df4e8459748f381d896f9fe477be9bdd01f8ce5d0d9627188", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8b5ea45a01d53e9df4e8459748f381d896f9fe477be9bdd01f8ce5d0d9627188", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a clarinet, a couch, a flute, four chairs, five trombones, a drum, a trumpet, a violin, and an accordion. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a clarinet, a couch, a flute, four chairs, five trombones, a drum, a trumpet, a violin, and an accordion. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 11.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8565.42, "reasoner_ms": 2222.08, "tts_ms": 22.26, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10809.79, "total_processing_ms": 11751.33 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 802, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 89 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5aae7b7339354f70e57e54156b6d4efa98804a0ecc8da1f173a9daa00d3e5d07", "started_sha256": "32b8e5862854bb8cc4f0fe54e0b828d86efb74f64fb8ab5c5d78ea8d9c46463e", "original_grade_sha256": "806afaf648e34a552d491a6ae867c243b6ab65974aeaca3d170b7924263cd7e6", "input_original_sha256": "5aae7b7339354f70e57e54156b6d4efa98804a0ecc8da1f173a9daa00d3e5d07", "input_wav_sha256": "18601e89947601ff57c978c1882fc56d299ff48fea2dabb840100b3cef69ee4c", "input_pcm_sha256": "d08214a03320f3cba95d03bd2857d6ce960acd359487d8a83065b61edb3bba5d", "output_wav_sha256": "c3166c288dfac805775b1df7ea0fc82be4914147597b898ab874349d5ea08bda", "output_pcm_sha256": "0274a0b0251c57127c463f2451077aeb562a756455668afeb0f79a58e045673b", "result_sha256": "5176cdd176ece9dc6aba3d62576fd0d8be1120ab39c740d535191a865c8cffea" } }, { "id": 967, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c800db560e3e93d85428c37c52d26a090449774837a4a280ced0b98a6bea025e", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c800db560e3e93d85428c37c52d26a090449774837a4a280ced0b98a6bea025e", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Michael lies. Jerry says Michael tells the truth. Delbert says Jerry tells the truth. Seema says Delbert lies. Alexis says Seema lies. Does Alexis tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nMichael lies. Jerry says Michael tells the truth. Delbert says Jerry tells the truth. Seema says Delbert lies. Alexis says Seema lies. Does Alexis tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8397.64, "reasoner_ms": 2449.09, "tts_ms": 24.25, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10871.01, "total_processing_ms": 11752.71 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 829, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 124 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "251a0f556901ff655e8fa11b591e607a5bf831d18b962e52c94f25e70e0f2afd", "started_sha256": "aa4bd286920a8a13a45d6c45df61ffea934d01bbe6db9429120923fd55be088a", "original_grade_sha256": "381964e5580c2eb1b0d16440b334bc8b35bfa56a861e7996da2117f763e074dd", "input_original_sha256": "251a0f556901ff655e8fa11b591e607a5bf831d18b962e52c94f25e70e0f2afd", "input_wav_sha256": "5e4694a1ac2cb606557957be819610198307faa908ae6f9fa3c88890c2efd1db", "input_pcm_sha256": "0a125c53912a290fb8095dc0bead706b3368221b44dcacfaec4535647a211257", "output_wav_sha256": "eb31981a85a56e0ed12f4cb009993582b461807367ec9e768bab51d9fbe3bd99", "output_pcm_sha256": "ff6713ab28fd0996ac534d0fa26b4f8bf1c8767f0e169944f1b15c5f07330fd8", "result_sha256": "5c34c27fa70fc6d5889cdb7c31d08eea9bd7d350e2aa95baa6ab5a3f46fe5296" } }, { "id": 119, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6caeae50402878150c7190d92afa5c942be7897fdbdac49754ae0ed7a7eebd69", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6caeae50402878150c7190d92afa5c942be7897fdbdac49754ae0ed7a7eebd69", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see which chemicals are contained in our consumer products. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, being an ingredient of Men's No Face Wash is sufficient for not being an ingredient of Flex Foundation. Next, being an ingredient of Eye Shadow is sufficient for not being an ingredient of Flex Foundation. Plus every ingredient of Lip Butter is an ingredient of Men's No Face Wash or an ingredient of Eye Shadow. All this entails that being an ingredient of Lip Butter is sufficient for not being an ingredient of Flex Foundation. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see which chemicals are contained in our consumer products. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, being an ingredient of men's no face wash is sufficient for not being an ingredient of flex foundation. Next, being an ingredient of eye shadow gel is sufficient for not being an ingredient of flex foundation. Plus, every ingredient of lip butter is an ingredient of men's no face wash or an ingredient of eye shadow. all this entails that being an ingredient of lip butter is sufficient for not being an ingredient of flex foundation is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question Question", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 32375.73, "reasoner_ms": 4937.39, "tts_ms": 35.96, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 37349.14, "total_processing_ms": 38309.65 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1136, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 92 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8c59d5927c66ef1f23524014b54bddc82e6734d4c50aef8a8ca17e5e9643cd78", "started_sha256": "2d68f8f0c96bc5c267a0a70a9d2ad0f267ac6952064729d6b3d1cd99d51d2bf8", "original_grade_sha256": "a58e81f3d23143512f1735f363f1d58e50d5381908f1e03984563ee12c6c2d26", "input_original_sha256": "8c59d5927c66ef1f23524014b54bddc82e6734d4c50aef8a8ca17e5e9643cd78", "input_wav_sha256": "212ef14330fcecb7b548c80d015deb2be3bb4543904a1dc07d14fb3483aaac20", "input_pcm_sha256": "8a46a7ff01c8047ee5ee8dd2d7be04d277a833e2b02ef7295a51209ef8473bd7", "output_wav_sha256": "39ca6afc8dab548b7c8543d99336a7207c6b631656bfc80b5ef5189b2aff0eee", "output_pcm_sha256": "60c3f387fa32ec000e097eca47481787892d254fb44d5140b322eee9321e6d66", "result_sha256": "abf5f02f723efe0f7422da9d0492e51f266cd5f2010b7137894d29cb1c1dfb26" } }, { "id": 335, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f1dd395b55531f59b8eaac901f41c0f9a8745d18d3d1a6fac35cf708f54eceb2", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f1dd395b55531f59b8eaac901f41c0f9a8745d18d3d1a6fac35cf708f54eceb2", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take one step forward. Take ten steps forward. Take six steps backward. Take seven steps backward. Take one step left. Take ten steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take one step forward. Take ten steps forward. Take six steps backward. Take seven steps backward. Take one step left. Take ten steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11459.34, "reasoner_ms": 1612.06, "tts_ms": 27.44, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 13098.87, "total_processing_ms": 14504.71 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 847, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 48 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "348e4fbf4631c4783d929a53676d8ddfb3741d0a21c8e6ac1f36536c3be86518", "started_sha256": "b9687f6dad920a4afd6795a553da3dc9d296e7963527db74944f12436264c02d", "original_grade_sha256": "06910e28b8f980083e092e60aa579c4b1474bef463ab1325c4180570ae971958", "input_original_sha256": "348e4fbf4631c4783d929a53676d8ddfb3741d0a21c8e6ac1f36536c3be86518", "input_wav_sha256": "a7a67fd9dfd0ff573e6c50257cd013d6a8dbc9699e0712c190e9b0d0f44bd1a6", "input_pcm_sha256": "25ff2966ce31c9897823f5a5f696979ebb55d563a8493be650247e68633a903a", "output_wav_sha256": "04efb654a2c32263dc148a0368b4474ddd5a12769c6c16671909dfbfae892597", "output_pcm_sha256": "4a3a5cd60e61f93fd0b045b1f97cd8f35a812a4247d6919fd8245aa7f7b2fb4c", "result_sha256": "39bdd59932f794938925eb22f2cd5d37d917612e7f47f45339df300cb65265d7" } }, { "id": 616, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "11", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ded8c9aaaa0ee7801e44a08ee644ffba112d924536787912395985425a71f348", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ded8c9aaaa0ee7801e44a08ee644ffba112d924536787912395985425a71f348", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a plum, a banana, an apple, three grapes, an orange, a peach, a blackberry, and two strawberries. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a plum, a banana, an apple, three grapes, an orange, a peach, a blackberry, and two strawberries. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 11.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8676.47, "reasoner_ms": 1888.63, "tts_ms": 29.71, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10594.85, "total_processing_ms": 11560.85 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 785, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 79 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "58c8dcdb2cd8f2f1ec9308fcc14b7a73d6766362bd52cdb9af7bb7eb5dab3ca7", "started_sha256": "e03dd47bb923caf2482613348058e2738f3434f8916815a7ee958f2511f38251", "original_grade_sha256": "ca5c7b7b7f1511f420b1fb2b69c430526fe44b571e68984919eb6f776694589f", "input_original_sha256": "58c8dcdb2cd8f2f1ec9308fcc14b7a73d6766362bd52cdb9af7bb7eb5dab3ca7", "input_wav_sha256": "cca4b7b2f1bdbe7310412226433cf40204c8cdbcdab5dc0eb63e932998623155", "input_pcm_sha256": "2f3b6c275fa7e545c49f14d5ec6a22db415af68cfb8ec2901b2b4289b1f6484f", "output_wav_sha256": "bb05af49f5564bae1f3064b78c39976ce355bd5c20f469ecb06f9d9cdcf2c447", "output_pcm_sha256": "9714441b1aad6387dd61f6edce2f22a5cc3dc15e40932d86efaf582edeb1ece3", "result_sha256": "8b61d57b827a2741264acb1a590b8d0179e524430d66f91e0247f743cc22d4d6" } }, { "id": 758, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cdf3ded86358d68b96a3c17947f4c82cccd69d7d3c80baf279bb6d57e2abf948", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cdf3ded86358d68b96a3c17947f4c82cccd69d7d3c80baf279bb6d57e2abf948", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Fletcher tells the truth. Conception says Fletcher tells the truth. Bonita says Conception tells the truth. Jamie says Bonita tells the truth. Teresa says Jamie lies. Does Teresa tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion, Fletcher tells the truth. Conception says Fletcher tells the truth. Benita says Conception tells the truth. Jamie says Benita tells the truth. Teresa says Jamie lies. Does Teresa tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9419.57, "reasoner_ms": 2079.14, "tts_ms": 25.29, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11524.04, "total_processing_ms": 12575.68 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 849, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 103 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "022d515cd50b219e5d62794ce2b52f494b54f4dfa7449d642e331c0d36918a85", "started_sha256": "1c84fe797d2b52f2980f0786a12f3d464defe2231bf221d9eac034841c8dc4d4", "original_grade_sha256": "9b8fb80e6d19a3576241025200ee7bdf16e96a16b773ab81298926b21632ed60", "input_original_sha256": "022d515cd50b219e5d62794ce2b52f494b54f4dfa7449d642e331c0d36918a85", "input_wav_sha256": "c2d3dcc2a346a6751bbf60a0a05c4ab6535f573d77516a65f321f78cbfa721f6", "input_pcm_sha256": "68178772c6bf16a5e9b3bc31eb64c97ddda99a7bcbdecabe3c75336ca25b0d54", "output_wav_sha256": "88c7f26736ff47cd99848ffa7040d8bd39d2d00f6ec3c0768ce321b8551c0469", "output_pcm_sha256": "d4bd02356ff9be3ab9a60c3e132afc9db9440f57b6fa26c336ae5fd165e65b50", "result_sha256": "bf3c843bd680c8fb910039ca72292bbea50ced03bee947cc167d6fcca886cbf8" } }, { "id": 12, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e7588bb90ac3108fae692034d592958e43cd2b55e26a4528f7ca40da56bf3344", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e7588bb90ac3108fae692034d592958e43cd2b55e26a4528f7ca40da56bf3344", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see which chemicals are contained in our consumer products. The following argument pertains to this question. Every ingredient of Silky Eye Pencil thirteen is an ingredient of Eye Restore or an ingredient of O three Bronzing Powder. No ingredient of Silky Eye Pencil thirteen is an ingredient of O three Bronzing Powder. We may conclude being an ingredient of Silky Eye Pencil thirteen is sufficient for being an ingredient of Eye Restore. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see which chemicals are contained in our consumer products. The following argument pertains to this question. Every ingredient of Silky Eye Pencil 13 is an ingredient of Eye Restore or an ingredient of O3 Bronzing Powder. No ingredient of Silky Eye Pencil 13 is an ingredient of O3 Bronzing Powder. We may conclude, being an ingredient of Silky Eye Pencil 13 is sufficient for being an ingredient of Eye Restore. is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 24872.51, "reasoner_ms": 1707.1, "tts_ms": 53.88, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 26633.52, "total_processing_ms": 27538.43 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1094, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 59 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "06fd411ade292fa739c42f090a8e29242fd524416ede0c91d14a0df32d77566f", "started_sha256": "2563a116c67ebf1766fca7a9f8646394d5a4677dea7d279440c2b3c2b6b2266a", "original_grade_sha256": "944411413a8a9e51393f4751eb6a826cc42b8af3784f731266a70e2b331064b3", "input_original_sha256": "06fd411ade292fa739c42f090a8e29242fd524416ede0c91d14a0df32d77566f", "input_wav_sha256": "6f847d42a5edd594a98a6fd36ee558ca3fad5b0774c991c5c58eb959049d4de0", "input_pcm_sha256": "7e0fd309170e87eb78b54f1962da0218daf2294e3e513365fcd1ce79beca9884", "output_wav_sha256": "19574e4c17fe7864f34770715e32125fea878aef8fc4b8a09bdf8beb6a500e7e", "output_pcm_sha256": "bb2392743efa1741c51dfe6408bef5b1d6650e645744aace98850a21b1cd998f", "result_sha256": "846bb3e0a1fd5577c17d542d5fdb56676057175c4b72ef0116af2fe24a574fa6" } }, { "id": 254, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dff8a866f00820597e4efdaecf5a5a57eab653f826c88d2cb53788312a182059", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dff8a866f00820597e4efdaecf5a5a57eab653f826c88d2cb53788312a182059", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take ten steps backward. Take seven steps backward. Take eight steps right. Take six steps right. Take three steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take 10 steps backward. Take 7 steps backward. Take 8 steps right. Take 6 steps right. Take 3 steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11815.42, "reasoner_ms": 1828.34, "tts_ms": 32.31, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 13676.13, "total_processing_ms": 14583.82 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 840, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 50 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a2233e91931eeb4d756eb04c777de7159e8d04887170108070dbe999b6520665", "started_sha256": "12e372615ebaf5c1f660c3290c642c950932146ea413ce65e3f1903c0c336735", "original_grade_sha256": "1f6f3c4f2c78d3f3fc5bb3bb4431190ce672aa2c9974904879c8bb4cf83d79bc", "input_original_sha256": "a2233e91931eeb4d756eb04c777de7159e8d04887170108070dbe999b6520665", "input_wav_sha256": "04302979630c106727f26240cca4a1cdaae3cc5b955e4910680ee881dfa9d9ff", "input_pcm_sha256": "355b7aae2c11c813a1fc4753e54b7c52cafaa8d6cf2ffb0a92e2387cd71d7e99", "output_wav_sha256": "749798590a4563317cc696a0f9d3609f4939afea88ece4603b8a8c22d87f447a", "output_pcm_sha256": "dd4ed2bef245b1968d36c8dfa770b832686dd62e7263935f174520f803722c5e", "result_sha256": "19cc187f913c0300c4e709643c472575ea596d9ca82729e83f4aa77247082421" } }, { "id": 560, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "18", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9c5c503f2441fa6f01e128d56cf7b9e8c14918c162b150bcdd87d01d75748aae", "normalized_answer": "18" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9c5c503f2441fa6f01e128d56cf7b9e8c14918c162b150bcdd87d01d75748aae", "normalized_answer": "18" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have three cauliflowers, a lettuce head, a cabbage, a carrot, three garlics, three onions, three heads of broccoli, a stalk of celery, a yam, and a potato. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have three cauliflowers, a lettuce head, a cabbage, a carrot, three garlics, three onions, three heads of broccoli, a stalk of celery, a yam, and a potato. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 18.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9521.06, "reasoner_ms": 2356.38, "tts_ms": 35.93, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11913.42, "total_processing_ms": 12852.41 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 833, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 107 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "bd1acc690edc71f1a0419a2cc49a0bfa3ef1f67ef408a20de09dd981d0564f6c", "started_sha256": "3348a07ddbd822540375af82cc9dad65aa95b4bf5dc87966707f3983640267af", "original_grade_sha256": "0200a91b2eaf43d784360284071d1df5b03ea7ad3d03e70e7f45e0b078f473ed", "input_original_sha256": "bd1acc690edc71f1a0419a2cc49a0bfa3ef1f67ef408a20de09dd981d0564f6c", "input_wav_sha256": "cdb276db166e1e516a14135f32109b01db686b064fef4bca15667e92ba55b446", "input_pcm_sha256": "965890c615d81dbc84dd04552e6dfb654fb4f463807db28a51c6a528ce0b915a", "output_wav_sha256": "53a19a1044294a5512e5e17aee3297d7a64a9d30cdde8e574423e51f36d2999d", "output_pcm_sha256": "d7ccd0c55e9cf0a9387468313cea65ec2a793266913906967caeeda8a43f5d2c", "result_sha256": "31a304f3ab6adb7f326d013cfeb8854bbe1d04feee1dd4dcaebe40477252c514" } }, { "id": 953, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "297e7e1fd4e9bdebc74b967e60d701c4931d7bc3088f53d693c2f4a7773baf7a", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "297e7e1fd4e9bdebc74b967e60d701c4931d7bc3088f53d693c2f4a7773baf7a", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Millicent lies. KA says Millicent lies. Saima says KA tells the truth. Dallas says Saima tells the truth. Jamie says Dallas lies. Does Jamie tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion, Millicent lies. K.A. says Millicent lies. Syma says K.A. tells the truth. Dallas says Syma tells the truth. Jamie says Dallas lies. Does Jamie tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11435.38, "reasoner_ms": 3097.54, "tts_ms": 28.2, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 14561.18, "total_processing_ms": 15588.69 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 831, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 111 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2e66df68055755bcee401211d201160942d42cb2038eef99e8c391f30eb9e23d", "started_sha256": "78c97e1a6e467df4251e8a9457a7a0bed012c06c143501cf14662f79c4019ff2", "original_grade_sha256": "e17a2a36922b7bb0c02588b451def68a8bbd5d21b9026590a1f6ae84591b3272", "input_original_sha256": "2e66df68055755bcee401211d201160942d42cb2038eef99e8c391f30eb9e23d", "input_wav_sha256": "2edc9cbb964394424c6a9bb630b059547b5db3bb6d8d1cd1d9fc1e24daf6d8c3", "input_pcm_sha256": "0ac8eeaf913d4f35a8a4372cbe3b48d56ca50f4d1acc1fe0068aeedbee339c79", "output_wav_sha256": "a7898d34df150eabf6b3ea55f90566a05b9ff318b226569e43ac867922637db3", "output_pcm_sha256": "59b50a753f7a7e11bee4302bfd67d37af557b29b9c2251d5c1a3dff04663035f", "result_sha256": "1c3be99e7e5227363d5f8da64320148dd70337c75589bb7ff46e5099928457a7" } }, { "id": 203, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ba4be62a31f6e4e1d886ad26e3ed0ad90de4cd1d6f96e9efe5bb429c38c97c45", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ba4be62a31f6e4e1d886ad26e3ed0ad90de4cd1d6f96e9efe5bb429c38c97c45", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. Whoever is an occasional purchaser of Eucalyptus soap is not a loyal buyer of Shield soap. No occasional purchaser of Colgate-Palmolive soap is a loyal buyer of Shield soap. Every regular user of Bliss soap is an occasional purchaser of Eucalyptus soap or an occasional purchaser of Colgate-Palmolive soap. Therefore, no regular user of Bliss soap is a loyal buyer of Shield soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. Whoever is an occasional purchaser of eucalyptus soap is not a loyal buyer of shield soap. No occasional purchaser of Colgate-Palmolive soap is a loyal buyer of shield soap. Every regular user of Bliss soap is an occasional purchaser of eucalyptus soap or an occasional purchaser of Colgate-Palmolive soap. therefore no regular user of bliss soap is a loyal buyer of shield soap is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 29056.89, "reasoner_ms": 2172.06, "tts_ms": 28.01, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 31257.01, "total_processing_ms": 32353.1 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1128, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 91 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "cde1d241cd929be0ba3bbd799eb81fc51ab2f1dec08a21900bc75118b8655455", "started_sha256": "0ce7aadea71019898894676e5ae714416f1478ada1dc5ac054bb063ed7a2c4f2", "original_grade_sha256": "7c5f28bc9878c309d5ff18fe8bddc158074f512840692787d1dc995f90424540", "input_original_sha256": "cde1d241cd929be0ba3bbd799eb81fc51ab2f1dec08a21900bc75118b8655455", "input_wav_sha256": "84b8b9fe7e9b0828fca2c38098c3b2874beca507a5b14f74fdcb93be01f71771", "input_pcm_sha256": "38f8a9c0278497465c272a93e99b275b3ae3a81607d116c8f0b40eff3280cb7b", "output_wav_sha256": "0571aa441eeec2f51081bc8d20fd48e40b758de8b4e1e6beb6c48e9db01b4141", "output_pcm_sha256": "76d38b2533cdc0a5d7f1bd845f38339848badc7b19e73f683410f752cd8ecf48", "result_sha256": "902dcfa9372b116fc3986ee89726d00d63644dfa7939fbf31a9815a3d996f3e0" } }, { "id": 340, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0afce650f9f236020a8e29aad8905fb9728e2fed1289295a31403247ec525aeb", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0afce650f9f236020a8e29aad8905fb9728e2fed1289295a31403247ec525aeb", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take ten steps forward. Take eight steps right. Take eight steps right. Take nine steps left. Take six steps right. Take two steps forward. Take nine steps backward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take ten steps forward. Take eight steps right. Take eight steps right. Take nine steps left. Take six steps right. Take two steps forward. Take nine steps backward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12674.52, "reasoner_ms": 1920.31, "tts_ms": 30.88, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 14625.77, "total_processing_ms": 15677.77 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 867, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 38 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "124d27ce52768e835e43de0ba264ea9c2ba0546cc8ea8c69a7657297dd2159f7", "started_sha256": "1a51e73fa961deaa2c3c6f77e379465c5eacf4a74343b0655746e3ccdb7e3299", "original_grade_sha256": "c62af53e2ae1c53588a3fec2ead6a71d99fbac4c73fbf13388f31623674f670f", "input_original_sha256": "124d27ce52768e835e43de0ba264ea9c2ba0546cc8ea8c69a7657297dd2159f7", "input_wav_sha256": "ad68c04ad18b3660f21fcaeca8f6968cfedfbfe6166387b9de26635862e14413", "input_pcm_sha256": "6ac69b8d9d6488e62de3f8315274dfee2d999b294202cd17a1279bc8a474e28b", "output_wav_sha256": "f6a3496e6acfa1c13325dbba2f4867aad2567a9fae8636f3f509282c9e02c647", "output_pcm_sha256": "ea4df5d5f3cb11b651b61c4d5d14a972ae569eb0b3382ea9ce280d8f87daced5", "result_sha256": "4cbce7779bc45cb9f7dbe26b562b044c9a50f5f854ab75be34a68834bd205839" } }, { "id": 659, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "8", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5d4ac173971a6261ed7eb20d8488bd1c9b789bf1213dec5df3c243d7501d0602", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5d4ac173971a6261ed7eb20d8488bd1c9b789bf1213dec5df3c243d7501d0602", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have three potatoes, a carrot, a snake, a yam, a cauliflower, a stalk of celery, and a garlic. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have three potatoes a carrot a snake a yam a cauliflower a stalk of celery and a garlic how many vegetables do i have answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 8.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12450.77, "reasoner_ms": 2345.68, "tts_ms": 29.28, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 14825.82, "total_processing_ms": 15691.3 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 784, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 118 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "51051dee1a57ba7037c229de90af28c75f07e2c5b7edbac87cdae9957f5cd20a", "started_sha256": "ae6b27befa7615c107a3fc7553c770aa41069e8f5f8829ed56373bacc7403370", "original_grade_sha256": "28ec088fafb603246632285cceea8bebde4f14dc91fc6f455ca42946d722659a", "input_original_sha256": "51051dee1a57ba7037c229de90af28c75f07e2c5b7edbac87cdae9957f5cd20a", "input_wav_sha256": "1ca56dce31b4b8e904bb10f11c6513a9c4fdf8fdf77d7d8fb40ee3c0ef853a2c", "input_pcm_sha256": "8a3e05202021fb1bc606bebb93ba2210738a2f47652195fdcec606738414a7c2", "output_wav_sha256": "95b8c88f284cc0138ef687300cfd124189aced8038646fac2c620c079ac6676c", "output_pcm_sha256": "173cae15561b4ced87496d7cf5d57aadc50caa380eee147d90d0bbb454e7e1f8", "result_sha256": "319e5221886eff6d623d1b8561e3bd3b8af618fa63e95e416df2598790addbc7" } }, { "id": 887, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bb92e5fb92b10182a2d0ff49ed511a10cf3de344bb96c72a51eb87d0d87ab33d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bb92e5fb92b10182a2d0ff49ed511a10cf3de344bb96c72a51eb87d0d87ab33d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Jerry tells the truth. Raymond says Jerry tells the truth. Yolande says Raymond tells the truth. Eleanor says Yolande tells the truth. Jamie says Eleanor lies. Does Jamie tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Jerry tells the truth. Raymond says Jerry tells the truth. Yolande says Raymond tells the truth. Eleanor says Yolande tells the truth. Jamie says Eleanor lies. Does Jamie tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9695.21, "reasoner_ms": 2171.58, "tts_ms": 34.16, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11900.98, "total_processing_ms": 12799.29 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 855, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 92 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8b824479a44b2cda85e8e1c592bf1dc9e4fb058933b3ddcf4582d20d9edefef9", "started_sha256": "3113158fb2dfccaf63f2bb479bbaa9aa46e99d94903639b2ff54750088f4a016", "original_grade_sha256": "f4a9352469b7dfab793326404ac0748da1c9ee9d854944853b6034d63483e444", "input_original_sha256": "8b824479a44b2cda85e8e1c592bf1dc9e4fb058933b3ddcf4582d20d9edefef9", "input_wav_sha256": "37b63e7d81a3e55e6c8e95973aec79591df86c2f9a2f93553f939ccce1268257", "input_pcm_sha256": "8b784223fd85d6d1fb9f36b78d9ce04a67406374684c8092bc886a842c7c6c7a", "output_wav_sha256": "e7b79afa588cef041d31ceaf6268d480eed47d02009b98d2d3f540beb18283b5", "output_pcm_sha256": "3a63fbb2e3665c43a57356071d8004dc660f7df357066a1eb1ae0e7d6f5197ef", "result_sha256": "0448a6e55fe2ec15ebf10b6b1df5f3a65e9b4fd26312b443c31032e7a93ab6d4" } }, { "id": 226, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e069431af2c6eb29cceb432509ee8c955aee2e2f47e92dac7ddf36094bf763e2", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e069431af2c6eb29cceb432509ee8c955aee2e2f47e92dac7ddf36094bf763e2", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, nobody is neither a classmate of Marissa nor a schoolmate of Karen. Next, not every sister of Ruth is a schoolmate of Karen. So necessarily, somebody is a sister of Ruth and not a classmate of Marissa. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument, first of all, nobody is neither a classmate of Marissa nor a schoolmate of Karen. Next, not every sister of Ruth is a schoolmate of Karen. So, necessarily, somebody is a sister of Ruth and not a classmate of Marissa. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options? Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13726.57, "reasoner_ms": 5666.26, "tts_ms": 28.81, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 19421.67, "total_processing_ms": 20216.73 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 966, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 410 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0aff83d6c31dae06993720dc44eaca12bdf742825988c589176e8e61912db82d", "started_sha256": "7b90be359a1df65287d4837039e5a8008caffa23a7b9d06c9711f4c749213217", "original_grade_sha256": "cab4849ce9c33f157aee2e09845a1ffb7ffd216a91ffff88706e3611035d75a6", "input_original_sha256": "0aff83d6c31dae06993720dc44eaca12bdf742825988c589176e8e61912db82d", "input_wav_sha256": "56f23482f4bfc05db21e10208a386494e30968f70fdd9cf8a4921ed12d4e302a", "input_pcm_sha256": "84ccd2a7fe23ed749b91d0f65a0dbabb0ddf2a4e2523af46f8b10565c6e233e9", "output_wav_sha256": "dbac7be32f36cca74c491342b7fb4126a6edff695e0fd0c0cb164435195c33c7", "output_pcm_sha256": "2ca141e91ae7d91b8ce6f54ae99c557003c9b703a753423dfa33d52ba1f26403", "result_sha256": "156016bc025580846cceeb8728a256fc08138e56f85421603ac10f8bca64f68d" } }, { "id": 411, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "78dc1cfff72f85fc34d35f59492080e62abc66c8c85d7da5a43cadea7a1a7fde", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "78dc1cfff72f85fc34d35f59492080e62abc66c8c85d7da5a43cadea7a1a7fde", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps backward. Take eight steps forward. Take seven steps forward. Take five steps backward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps backward. Take eight steps forward. Take seven steps forward. Take five steps backward. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7094.27, "reasoner_ms": 1618.46, "tts_ms": 27.45, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8740.21, "total_processing_ms": 9488.91 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 821, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 31 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3a67b01343011782bfae013ecf67ef07bc130af3aa34a522e07990dfee935843", "started_sha256": "1843812dc49aca5bc0c474af67df2897d1a36a5ebf48b9dbe649623f4e52ac9d", "original_grade_sha256": "c35fee3533ccbf4509d3fc7583a5661963cb8bcc0c121c7a94d6447fba458d2b", "input_original_sha256": "3a67b01343011782bfae013ecf67ef07bc130af3aa34a522e07990dfee935843", "input_wav_sha256": "195402d5778f73be72bcc5b08a788af060ebefd9814bf5b1d60eb045fd93596c", "input_pcm_sha256": "23c728f2182637813d54414c2a89dfc0916622606694045366ce6e48bee6cfe4", "output_wav_sha256": "3b33d46c0fb37b6d544416af8b232d2f233c60178b13b2fb660196a9f1fd4ab9", "output_pcm_sha256": "a143e839957dc1daa61209e98fcf06ed35c3eb5ec4a17fb6340f7725f2e611bb", "result_sha256": "582f9ae0cfb40b4f8a7b24d8b5a72aff0ee13ad6572382e8c3882655bf26ae82" } }, { "id": 550, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "10", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c45d910bef5b131ac422638bb4236212099fb38a74245921c42b566eabc1723f", "normalized_answer": "10" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c45d910bef5b131ac422638bb4236212099fb38a74245921c42b566eabc1723f", "normalized_answer": "10" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have two stalks of celery, two garlics, a potato, three heads of broccoli, a carrot, and a yam. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have two stalks of celery, two garlics, a potato, three heads of broccoli, a carrot, and a yam. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 10.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5815.43, "reasoner_ms": 1835.71, "tts_ms": 26.99, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7678.16, "total_processing_ms": 8567.9 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 784, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 57 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "bc8fa237d3c10617b392f294d26106744c6cf2c99e14bd962d4d66101bcb43fe", "started_sha256": "e51e86dcba383a43b49c1743d7cb971755e190cbf138a3632e3c96238d019b0e", "original_grade_sha256": "7f64179a175fa8c5231de09571de94c44aa865fb085e148f1d8e2eb9d0fbdcb5", "input_original_sha256": "bc8fa237d3c10617b392f294d26106744c6cf2c99e14bd962d4d66101bcb43fe", "input_wav_sha256": "384c8ebb96ad44e2a09ac8fc2e149fd5c3112d4f209b059b36a25f52868f850f", "input_pcm_sha256": "58366924036625af60e17afb7e1e6ea73f9e5642bf9a8ea5c6f4892dd97606a4", "output_wav_sha256": "39043873769d788d4c9810a8a73c7f134b4a0fc93309fe73d5af84e755b4ee7c", "output_pcm_sha256": "286989ec10d5cf6b7b0372710ccc6056d348280d8fd5ed2e9be7bb77b1d6bef2", "result_sha256": "e93828b45b860c1d2ac4ce40bac2466f5397eb6198c2ef2a8a0d2ab917c6ea93" } }, { "id": 795, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "459440eaf05d744f34cdd93350fe1aebf1dcc3830fd2bb947949bf33446de012", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "459440eaf05d744f34cdd93350fe1aebf1dcc3830fd2bb947949bf33446de012", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Seema tells the truth. Yolan says Seema lies. Amberly says Yolan tells the truth. Inga says Amberly lies. Alexis says Inga tells the truth. Does Alexis tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nSeema tells the truth. Yolan says Seema lies. Amberly says Yolan tells the truth. Inga says Amberly lies. Alexis says Inga tells the truth. Does Alexis tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6857.79, "reasoner_ms": 2260.91, "tts_ms": 27.57, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9146.3, "total_processing_ms": 9821.83 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 94 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "33ee4759718ac968f289790fb440dd40ab9916dccbd7143b81efa68eb2e9314e", "started_sha256": "9351d884447effc837114968e0fb522d5a1358108241e31b41bc6839e51b78a2", "original_grade_sha256": "34e1578f317c33c947ebd5abfce4d687fde5c6c2d115c4360c2f2f2dd8fdefa1", "input_original_sha256": "33ee4759718ac968f289790fb440dd40ab9916dccbd7143b81efa68eb2e9314e", "input_wav_sha256": "8da720d0bf6c05c057da4e42088095517c62416386de5d83b0312a89175685e5", "input_pcm_sha256": "8337064122b042e84b586de62aa6cce6c495e18004eb9c2ce6d605921e4d7cb8", "output_wav_sha256": "05af9ab9dec6f318de8ac3e31661bb3d7220b39789ca78d408b90ef6d1dee772", "output_pcm_sha256": "117cd39e053b0179adf2d19d4299326e72c5a05ca4459b08c213396f9120e4fa", "result_sha256": "3fb505f115dee5fbd402a8550971908642fe6423517b02b9493afacaa8b40e74" } }, { "id": 170, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "55ac10dfd52ff2e84619548464a599d3e1bcaac175196fa00276403fec64a341", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "55ac10dfd52ff2e84619548464a599d3e1bcaac175196fa00276403fec64a341", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. Being a cousin of Jana is necessary for being a workmate of Leonor. Every cousin of Jana is a daughter of Tracy or a sister of Sara. So necessarily, every workmate of Leonor is a sister of Sara or a daughter of Tracy. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question, being a cousin of Jana is necessary for being a workmate of Leonor. Every cousin of Jana is a daughter of Tracy or a sister of Sara. So, necessarily, every workmate of Leonor is a sister of Sara or a daughter of Tracy. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options Valid Invalid Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12875.28, "reasoner_ms": 2228.65, "tts_ms": 27.6, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15131.56, "total_processing_ms": 15734.65 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 997, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 76 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "37e97c3d7bb7e437f01e3b18c5e2e194f28f9ac5185e383dbfb3e4e1e63d82da", "started_sha256": "acf07cdbd8de61ae58879b1f9372eebca815c7c2e9e875bada927ea1dfcc5eff", "original_grade_sha256": "c8b5c2756af7b5fd11eb40eaa650b9bb80bb1e96db787fcbae2fc7254e188d1e", "input_original_sha256": "37e97c3d7bb7e437f01e3b18c5e2e194f28f9ac5185e383dbfb3e4e1e63d82da", "input_wav_sha256": "61da8af0aba3bf445eb04439f598bc0576bd4e42abacfbfa5e900530ac86bb32", "input_pcm_sha256": "9ec38036b0a72f7150f735c6e8f7ef7bf6fde0cb0480be342e8a0493add58bc9", "output_wav_sha256": "bf958791bab1ea50c5cb27d5f46d0394a5140ae160fb447fb6847e131063c014", "output_pcm_sha256": "d82f584b6678bfdf3a36fb0dac54a4afbefceedb8c84f3f1858378fd18679d78", "result_sha256": "960488032bd22bfa89186d7b42153601246f7bb5a81a50831bd0bc9a6b92d240" } }, { "id": 360, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ba2fded1940976c5c3f300bbfcf79f780c85df0a17aa8cd7038db41f5a134f13", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ba2fded1940976c5c3f300bbfcf79f780c85df0a17aa8cd7038db41f5a134f13", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn around. Turn left. Take six steps. Take four steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn around. Turn left. Take six steps. Take four steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6403.74, "reasoner_ms": 2765.87, "tts_ms": 23.51, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9193.15, "total_processing_ms": 9882.79 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 785, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 119 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "dce4d410761f24e2c02ab69055f987378ad35ade599cf58d0c4d0a5be9bff1ab", "started_sha256": "52ade2217d027ca35e60af9b2175c153a2cdb172eca752863a09841a4c46118e", "original_grade_sha256": "b5484a6f5f25554ab79d6276706e62eef0ba06e0b46d2b22d3651d2dc7531f2a", "input_original_sha256": "dce4d410761f24e2c02ab69055f987378ad35ade599cf58d0c4d0a5be9bff1ab", "input_wav_sha256": "fc49a32281c6d38cda85beb26f6c81a836f16e47039b4091bab504360fe30e57", "input_pcm_sha256": "e7f20b6636498796f8f657241004a72d75ade70ab02c1394c752ff2bd3311d3c", "output_wav_sha256": "28677d5775546be94fb2985f85c0fa81c960f296c3a462db71dba9aa61d3a416", "output_pcm_sha256": "986c861d37e27aa29369473f5cf369f482356b66f87c16e6a4497e05e66dc4a7", "result_sha256": "462bd08cc8cf9aa69e2086fd74a06a2a6e7ec95f2c4eee643614d66c88a3e2a4" } }, { "id": 548, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "13", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2cf6b3be682e3c43b682d5908764ef071cad9862bb843c8d8ded668bd8fefe99", "normalized_answer": "13" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2cf6b3be682e3c43b682d5908764ef071cad9862bb843c8d8ded668bd8fefe99", "normalized_answer": "13" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a flute, a trumpet, three accordions, three violins, a drum, three clarinets, and a trombone. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a flute a trumpet three accordions three violins a drum three clarinets and a trombone how many musical instruments do i have answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 13.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8689.37, "reasoner_ms": 1675.87, "tts_ms": 21.97, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10387.24, "total_processing_ms": 11058.96 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 782, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 28 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "58fba910573b051f95eea484e4eb334bd237fed93c71e391fa5e2f7f20f3b35f", "started_sha256": "0eda8e01bc06fd2a76afb83109a422d24809cfb69b9a7726a6d4f41412e6ebde", "original_grade_sha256": "ec6a7a370e8658a2c80d8611fcdf069b25f9c6526da292430de09c342efd6277", "input_original_sha256": "58fba910573b051f95eea484e4eb334bd237fed93c71e391fa5e2f7f20f3b35f", "input_wav_sha256": "db2e84783d2888211965699bb47bc8dc139a3ad3c4e5b88860f34d44dba117b4", "input_pcm_sha256": "55930b3458c189ef7994ceb81780e44d62894a937653fac3ce1ff48f60dd2a46", "output_wav_sha256": "8a1657d8abb2e805216671b173f7e0e64514c764e6e8d8d856e96b4d598de02c", "output_pcm_sha256": "254bd4f55ba6732ecfab676905aa8d46a1e0dca482f340d815ebaafa4e71a785", "result_sha256": "688a66bdf53d42791549ee40608449664321fd7ea0815bbf813f4c69b81773b5" } }, { "id": 963, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "08de64e389f4e08aa26b0cdd21d00d52f86000c2e78df0837401124c83a6308f", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "08de64e389f4e08aa26b0cdd21d00d52f86000c2e78df0837401124c83a6308f", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Teressa lies. Sal says Teressa tells the truth. Delbert says Sal tells the truth. Tamika says Delbert tells the truth. Gwen says Tamika tells the truth. Does Gwen tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Teresa lies. Sal says Teresa tells the truth. Delbert says Sal tells the truth. Tamika says Delbert tells the truth. Gwen says Tamika tells the truth. Does Gwen tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6485.35, "reasoner_ms": 2040.16, "tts_ms": 26.59, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8552.13, "total_processing_ms": 9245.2 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 847, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 101 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b62d7a65cd2abf3c0e18ee53e58c7fe0728587d38667822020077a2413fd06e8", "started_sha256": "181c035967968b5e61b3af7a53b4b1f0ffdf4f2a2036e6fd857939081dfcaad2", "original_grade_sha256": "e5ae303984f8db6d765e2130498347af1d2e66b1afca2048b732d513943fee04", "input_original_sha256": "b62d7a65cd2abf3c0e18ee53e58c7fe0728587d38667822020077a2413fd06e8", "input_wav_sha256": "818fdadf71d50ea32f44c7b06b417b93a71d0ad8bf6351339a688f52f884277f", "input_pcm_sha256": "c90a9c356fb3a01f6f0ad506f8eb40941efc871125abd8c221bbb2dcc5318a59", "output_wav_sha256": "6bcfa624587a4b5c7685bf1cdfd6f12e6a97506b6a73c19629d23f034dd2c387", "output_pcm_sha256": "76c0896594d591c5eee61b9c6b7b16670b2ef4607adcec5820d721c981dd7c44", "result_sha256": "b88043df3dd3263e56a2ece7f760837d1e5349623a2f3f19f7a3e7acad728e82" } }, { "id": 2, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ade727e8ca4d7b9a909d19d0951eac34d4196de2dacde2e4c37dff40d33b6319", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ade727e8ca4d7b9a909d19d0951eac34d4196de2dacde2e4c37dff40d33b6319", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see which chemicals are contained in our consumer products. The following argument pertains to this question. First, vitamin A is an ingredient of liquid eyeliner. Second, every ingredient of BCI cream fifteen milliliters is not an ingredient of mango lip butter or not an ingredient of liquid eyeliner. Therefore, it is not the case that vitamin A is an ingredient of BCI cream fifteen milliliter. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see which chemicals are contained in our consumer products. The following argument pertains to this question. First, vitamin A is an ingredient of liquid eyeliner. Second, every ingredient of BCI cream 15 milliliters is not an ingredient of mango lip butter or not an ingredient of liquid eyeliner. Therefore, it is not the case that vitamin A is an ingredient of BCI cream 15 milliliter. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14933.26, "reasoner_ms": 5507.49, "tts_ms": 45.12, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 20485.9, "total_processing_ms": 21401.73 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 955, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 380 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0c021b2133e035d0a0047bb7e20eda65db4fa9b2f3a6ee5b7756fa2e41624f78", "started_sha256": "44d9e118e686ed2e98a2c8c7aaf0d522d9ef95c90c0354c34464324d4b4a2ec1", "original_grade_sha256": "70de33e753afb14fe25ad0029bbcc91d908b5fa0139c465e8922a287abf9729e", "input_original_sha256": "0c021b2133e035d0a0047bb7e20eda65db4fa9b2f3a6ee5b7756fa2e41624f78", "input_wav_sha256": "af6c12402f70a9661848c291ba8f9ce59b67085433e4c2ee59cfb6410ad0a448", "input_pcm_sha256": "f6f46b7ecb9a39b0cb042ad1ce34906c0f4c48ddbd1c88a2e0b4d20280caea22", "output_wav_sha256": "a2018f1ecad37837ad9a378fb2107d48c9962db4308904e67fb2ea20ca5bf4a4", "output_pcm_sha256": "d33582b6e48cc6a3f42f2ac162aec5faf183b093cb11ae2b1dc35a75acb60bb5", "result_sha256": "84a4eb1ea6392f7ed4e6da3109ba7de38518d55701e4d3fe757afa22ddd7ce1e" } }, { "id": 282, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7248bc938423cce1b5fa23447046ced5a97ffb484dc8fb1649c6bf1ed84388e1", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7248bc938423cce1b5fa23447046ced5a97ffb484dc8fb1649c6bf1ed84388e1", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take ten steps. Turn left. Turn left. Take ten steps. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point take 10 steps turn left turn left take 10 steps options yes no answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5288.62, "reasoner_ms": 1741.22, "tts_ms": 36.16, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7066.04, "total_processing_ms": 7776.98 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 774, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 48 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b378a895a12e0ffe90d1731294b0346bac3b8d6fee9f3b039c2a00f9fe160271", "started_sha256": "4dbcfeab0e3018d1d435e8d5d64f1f50b80c4994f533bb13cbabed2049d163e0", "original_grade_sha256": "debce86e98f8a2a974d262639612a56589995f527dbd923157fd389484fb915e", "input_original_sha256": "b378a895a12e0ffe90d1731294b0346bac3b8d6fee9f3b039c2a00f9fe160271", "input_wav_sha256": "471928dd00d888ef65ab9ee0670da22d6b49d76e68b5ba59fd737f4c35945c52", "input_pcm_sha256": "4d82c5c0fa8df6d27909ddf72fdacfa75fafe34ed8032fa99dc3b66eefedb52a", "output_wav_sha256": "66f9471b5e6527cb591ad9cea742d4cf50f6531784c89aba06ecb597f1785aea", "output_pcm_sha256": "c4652d8067583a2cf581a5945ed05f7e6fe6df841fbf3c1d557e51f7719d33f7", "result_sha256": "b253fe34d2ccf1e3690cad4bfa53f625db023fc0be9466c6a1b456bf5e0e34b3" } }, { "id": 558, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "11", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "16b892befe9eda373208f1c14850c2f07214a5830d1ffa7a5adf220e4eb49b31", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "16b892befe9eda373208f1c14850c2f07214a5830d1ffa7a5adf220e4eb49b31", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a rabbit, a dog, two snakes, a frog, a pig, a cow, a mouse, a cat, a duck, and a goat. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a rabbit, a dog, two snakes, a frog, a pig, a cow, a mouse, a cat, a duck, and a goat. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 11.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6331.14, "reasoner_ms": 1767.8, "tts_ms": 58.29, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8157.26, "total_processing_ms": 8913.22 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 798, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 70 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8f38835cdda6105ce456db86823b2e27728a4339de86f9a50ae19a392bd4e571", "started_sha256": "0fd504926d3a8eeab5c50a80bcc4f197468f659786a0f33e0604ce7442bf69c6", "original_grade_sha256": "8e496eccf6aeaabfa09db2db5ea5c088f44010ecb316aaf529173758bbd6a914", "input_original_sha256": "8f38835cdda6105ce456db86823b2e27728a4339de86f9a50ae19a392bd4e571", "input_wav_sha256": "3e413a56b882b72c424b5091b4f7c7ea67b164db782f53179e895909d4f8a810", "input_pcm_sha256": "89355c1a53002b805111276b0d4c7985b3be6ff7c69498afb6c515df6912b673", "output_wav_sha256": "478266ab1a053825afacd485ed494461df6756ee16ba59a02232a2153b5dba99", "output_pcm_sha256": "f58db880441947ecd90b5f13a6f30a98219fd94a7fb97f4efe1afe44826623ac", "result_sha256": "1253901f2b20a34ff4a4230f73de8c4d49396cb15f14f17699ba3910c25d82d1" } }, { "id": 846, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "06fa5be818a5b01eef8e36209b07cfc9bb3e0f46717764956c4f81cc4ccc3e29", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "06fa5be818a5b01eef8e36209b07cfc9bb3e0f46717764956c4f81cc4ccc3e29", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Seema tells the truth. Teresa says Seema tells the truth. Vina says Teresa lies. Krista says Vina lies. Phoebe says Krista tells the truth. Does Phoebe tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Seema tells the truth. Teressa says Seema tells the truth. Veena says Teressa lies. Krista says Veena lies. Phoebe says Krista tells the truth. Does Phoebe tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6970.96, "reasoner_ms": 2167.08, "tts_ms": 31.94, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9170.01, "total_processing_ms": 10180.53 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 838, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 114 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "338eefa8b81e36b8d0280374b61b30573cdd6680d97719daeb9563eee2f29fc5", "started_sha256": "3edc79e8a84cd386eab293230586c83aed2f39e00f1a53701e5523e54644d46a", "original_grade_sha256": "87a3e361e29df85ccdac799462aeadb77fac6d2fae68840c431300951c994ffd", "input_original_sha256": "338eefa8b81e36b8d0280374b61b30573cdd6680d97719daeb9563eee2f29fc5", "input_wav_sha256": "80ba60cf1cadb17128551eee2f3cacae7d34e74a4c6519f6aa4fb275caded247", "input_pcm_sha256": "50ef28b32221bcbda42eaf7350dd1c81bd4c4f0d2c2c42a8986686f5139d2b65", "output_wav_sha256": "6a0b3e8f09576850b931e4991121fa428bb29e2fc6222c1cceb828f7e3ce5628", "output_pcm_sha256": "5cf4304b0921e99d2e44b06be0a0867a44a504219c22fa197f847d250fe25521", "result_sha256": "6d8dc9bbdc8085616451525291d4d4cad8c6e59562948f1054367b110906a96f" } }, { "id": 70, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ba8ba6f28e5cf83a2230b7b6fa91369d190b51cd259e56faace97643653eaa02", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ba8ba6f28e5cf83a2230b7b6fa91369d190b51cd259e56faace97643653eaa02", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First premise: Terry is a grandson of Ward. Second premise: Every grandson of Paul is an uncle of Earl and a grandson of Ward. We may conclude that Terry is a grandson of Paul. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question, first premise, Terry is a grandson of Ward. Second premise, every grandson of Paul is an uncle of Earl and a grandson of Ward. We may conclude that Terry is a grandson of Paul. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options Valid Invalid Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13777.57, "reasoner_ms": 1535.07, "tts_ms": 55.65, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15368.32, "total_processing_ms": 16054.29 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 962, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 25 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5c73b0f95447f1e4cb5986b5b31b9d685516ffaa7ba166467f13a4df8105a92d", "started_sha256": "441b0f5b7e5fa321a1c1f1267cd8a5f38b0137297a4f993c92ac3ff7caf5330c", "original_grade_sha256": "dfb871143f113c1d7e12764fcbb903e1b9163217516f9d907bfd7cf232a5e000", "input_original_sha256": "5c73b0f95447f1e4cb5986b5b31b9d685516ffaa7ba166467f13a4df8105a92d", "input_wav_sha256": "3dc5b37faf0d527b394009ca0a90592dade3c7ed9cc5851b24205a6a828f960e", "input_pcm_sha256": "fa63b119fddcb9cbcd43985ba0cc30b2c6d802aa273ca638a5b8aa447d56c8f3", "output_wav_sha256": "2fcc1c4ab69496c974c42e7b06e7e87c6f3783edb7c80c6c18c2010f01c5b20a", "output_pcm_sha256": "60399775c6c98656e25797b18763099f0882f6b0bbe9e039ef52d1c4f54a0711", "result_sha256": "560937b0be4c2cfc0f4f72b2a8e6a0215ce7994ad3acd96f0716d6c09f3a566b" } }, { "id": 276, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7b389a5c266651f6ef19addd838b5b6faa46d76b5e7ad947cbb44572cc371487", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7b389a5c266651f6ef19addd838b5b6faa46d76b5e7ad947cbb44572cc371487", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take ten steps. Turn around. Take four steps. Take six steps. Turn around. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take ten steps. Turn around. Take four steps. Take six steps. Turn around. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7415.94, "reasoner_ms": 2721.9, "tts_ms": 27.86, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10165.73, "total_processing_ms": 11019.61 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 799, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 99 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3699b23812fc3b7dd6fedd6939a6f4043ddee1807aebc99d593c5ef5b38fd462", "started_sha256": "88a03831605720dc46cdaca79d802a87a5e0aa77cad5615ef6af705dfb3d6d55", "original_grade_sha256": "c1be96091394eb740a91b386b571f37361190914c6cc2db47403d4aa19d9d9d9", "input_original_sha256": "3699b23812fc3b7dd6fedd6939a6f4043ddee1807aebc99d593c5ef5b38fd462", "input_wav_sha256": "7940effb801a322cd196de713f3021be38516aaa41de8778f36013640531d909", "input_pcm_sha256": "5cc9ba2ca68cfc7596bc7610988ebb5f0a5772855139f68c8c89758c8172c56a", "output_wav_sha256": "3c1932b64814e78ff98e73263725a6d04e2fb02f9b05ccd34fa2b9d55a05f52f", "output_pcm_sha256": "92dcc85129743d1c51abd01d23b356c4f6c510e70afd9a1f98843661830e23b3", "result_sha256": "c5c8e52b678ac725f9bfdd0169c58e2c97381e35ce1af823111880d0ab507e7e" } }, { "id": 650, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "314e80e70aac109ec5db7a18ccd96966760fc81693ff73c9f98753976de0ed0e", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "314e80e70aac109ec5db7a18ccd96966760fc81693ff73c9f98753976de0ed0e", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a couch, a bed, a car, a fridge, two tables, an oven, a toaster, and a chair. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a couch, a bed, a car, a fridge, two tables, an oven, a toaster, and a chair. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 9.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5890.79, "reasoner_ms": 1797.01, "tts_ms": 29.59, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7717.43, "total_processing_ms": 8527.23 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 776, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 58 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f58c7bf95862314dd2d1b5f699c6df8263e6ef7c99e8874797bc2b6b5cf9a32d", "started_sha256": "8ad3d0660b3c3236e458918c35c8356678a7e3a6f7f7b85410109cd1b4f1f4ef", "original_grade_sha256": "8844efd60270a26c7ecdf443c1e41806a1efb96b6f860c47c3e8c996c25f4536", "input_original_sha256": "f58c7bf95862314dd2d1b5f699c6df8263e6ef7c99e8874797bc2b6b5cf9a32d", "input_wav_sha256": "1f8dbc94a7cd6f68f07385b26c03c9e86c5501c766c1608ad32972dae175207b", "input_pcm_sha256": "8e563f4a6d8aaeb633d58a077d4f6216ff6884fcec7f632165193c7d84ca2b66", "output_wav_sha256": "77da025ab50ddd4aa85fcb6fbb3e93b0a8764e7bf9b436a83a9f41bf82db86f7", "output_pcm_sha256": "339cfe6601a15c23da6f5a0c658d5ea5369b1b2cca7f7730529a19309e943812", "result_sha256": "2860d48d084193fa49a87f83f7a05b5b8d86967129cda8bc17354e612d1b8fb8" } }, { "id": 933, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6accac4545ec677048cd50cc39bc1a3fb24bbbef7253b797e3fc44fa5ac53ecb", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6accac4545ec677048cd50cc39bc1a3fb24bbbef7253b797e3fc44fa5ac53ecb", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion, Christy lies. Amberly says Christy tells the truth. Bernita says Amberly tells the truth. Christian says Bernita lies. Delfina says Christian lies. Does Delfina tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Christy lies. Amberlee says Christy tells the truth. Bernita says Amberlee tells the truth. Christian says Bernita lies. Delfina says Christian lies. Does Delfina tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6679.01, "reasoner_ms": 2305.48, "tts_ms": 25.91, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9010.43, "total_processing_ms": 9806.54 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 833, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 117 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "fcb858dd0755dc9652035e6e4f83679c353f1a4947322f892f1120144399b966", "started_sha256": "bdc668a46cf272c4c36d04d5394d7f3f6812c5548ae6c2fd9e2ec9c4d92b8aba", "original_grade_sha256": "f2ce109a0e359bda99135df9e642b192dcaf13f4c21c72ec870f363f41c587e5", "input_original_sha256": "fcb858dd0755dc9652035e6e4f83679c353f1a4947322f892f1120144399b966", "input_wav_sha256": "e53c666f4f40e9fc81d09c82209ff08dbe4801fdcfc4e1b8a5833ccaef04423f", "input_pcm_sha256": "d2cda86527411c72a46ccbc27f1cccc6efcc60c5949b1c7d2255a4dd2f2b22e6", "output_wav_sha256": "74242960813e0a66ce6224e8b68ea418c8ca564d80bf9552217dc716fc50ad5f", "output_pcm_sha256": "0c635e8eab42bca991855512d77904393b7c36154457851df071acdf6226bbb5", "result_sha256": "ed285a5d4cc8449fcb3437d174566c26ee42f059d7fe6016e8c10ea713cbcc8b" } }, { "id": 145, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8ede57144c99280e745a6750094e7f9437ceacee7d221ba913ecfe4caa0c1deb", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8ede57144c99280e745a6750094e7f9437ceacee7d221ba913ecfe4caa0c1deb", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, every follower of Inverness Caledonian Thistle FC is neither an admirer of Cr Altach nor a supporter of Karabakh FK. We may conclude: no admirer of Cr Altach and no supporter of Karabakh FK is a follower of Inverness Caledonian Thistle FC. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, every follower of Inverness Caledonian Thistle F.C. is neither an admirer of S.C.R. Al-Taq nor a supporter of Carbach F.K. We may conclude, no admirer of S.C.R. Al-Taq and no supporter of Carbach F.K. is a follower of Inverness Caledonian Thistle F.C. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid Valid or invalid. Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 15540.0, "reasoner_ms": 4351.62, "tts_ms": 32.51, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 19924.16, "total_processing_ms": 20787.94 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 918, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 254 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "9d8160c0f0dcbcd8eb4a6ea651e7413f618a5d00f7aa981fae894f5167c9522c", "started_sha256": "c00ffc1e038b59ebc6235f5d1fc58a9cad88345d7b46e1b7f0c17912877052b1", "original_grade_sha256": "fe08ab6618d58b9591b90bf1e819e43235cd04959903e8f1f92facfe1d2548df", "input_original_sha256": "9d8160c0f0dcbcd8eb4a6ea651e7413f618a5d00f7aa981fae894f5167c9522c", "input_wav_sha256": "1ae3f7ca874357282e8b7156d3a01b7483037098946f1f7e93d58b24c8737bde", "input_pcm_sha256": "7773d6be722dc661da8e8052f5cb433cad1aaf59685fa854b65c15ef5d6dc7bc", "output_wav_sha256": "874e175f992032a8619b236c6d6451945e0f79fe25a5a3e0122c5f3c2ae6f165", "output_pcm_sha256": "36c333bd8282a245c845834f7e34527b0813fe1b6c82261171c89bdc861f60af", "result_sha256": "a30b930903918cec3d38a27c710aa13922ba4733fa85a417ee8993bedf38935e" } }, { "id": 305, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f61901815db0b9f4c400a6736c95b5b84dfc06e97c0cde390b7b2460d766ccc5", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f61901815db0b9f4c400a6736c95b5b84dfc06e97c0cde390b7b2460d766ccc5", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps left. Take four steps backward. Options? Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps left. Take four steps backward. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6098.84, "reasoner_ms": 1535.45, "tts_ms": 21.4, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7655.72, "total_processing_ms": 8427.1 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 784, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 26 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "860aa279e80d7b90a10793684094be4fb76545142fe4888fdb7f752d17265d61", "started_sha256": "2cff90eb29180d5acb1c37423d70c95a2ffec896c1272eda9fa3190856404920", "original_grade_sha256": "36f3a7161958c8bd8b78e7f2f4960d78b6624feb70f8f484d9d68793cd44bdaa", "input_original_sha256": "860aa279e80d7b90a10793684094be4fb76545142fe4888fdb7f752d17265d61", "input_wav_sha256": "6b44235c4bf321a0826a13854f57aa218073eadaa47444aef9e34732e3ef9130", "input_pcm_sha256": "338054ec689cfadeb4f8be1dbcdff20d1e9628ffb55ff810a89428a9c66ebb9e", "output_wav_sha256": "34eb30baaba29f70745707896869645cadefdff198b06fe0127b1e38afe5628f", "output_pcm_sha256": "39b9e516f4505451027ad63c01feb4a7c640d013ad4d8c6c17b5f4f13155e3fb", "result_sha256": "d49229c4fbb3437f15a7a45afc1272ccbefb770892012c67ed048ff87fb429e2" } }, { "id": 713, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "8", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "125cd5efc937afc20cec855e1a76abd2fde8dfd4815934131333e5f7a880c913", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "125cd5efc937afc20cec855e1a76abd2fde8dfd4815934131333e5f7a880c913", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a trombone, a trumpet, a piano, a clarinet, a flute, a violin, an accordion, and a drum. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a trombone, a trumpet, a piano, a clarinet, a flute, a violin, an accordion, and a drum. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "That answer is 8.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6149.68, "reasoner_ms": 1391.6, "tts_ms": 26.58, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7567.9, "total_processing_ms": 8366.76 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 791, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 45 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6bce3e7f59102842376fdab8ee91b57c65fbc51ec676b400d665ebe82e60db23", "started_sha256": "7acd0fa00d63bce049a7a4ecde51c23ac31ffe334eb56f5c5baae5c3972d7d5c", "original_grade_sha256": "8ab5cdf478727d70b0043e23c838c46d05e23eb3f4983e1caefb6955448a7c48", "input_original_sha256": "6bce3e7f59102842376fdab8ee91b57c65fbc51ec676b400d665ebe82e60db23", "input_wav_sha256": "2415ce508cf17757e5bb1bcc7bfd92132471711097b61811491f52fe3fa11311", "input_pcm_sha256": "d71075efafc593cd6daada46b9027f8894b8024d51e447128025aa8f7912498c", "output_wav_sha256": "b8a255a1b62078d64c16911a143542d9437a7b67d68f967e8102df1fd87fc82a", "output_pcm_sha256": "45aa16dc75ca8334d1deed79d480d31c37d8e3cc2db1956cc7ae6a072102302b", "result_sha256": "96e1ee6bdebb7ebd40faa640db41693dbebbb88db02645c204cbaab5673a2e28" } }, { "id": 994, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7b7a18e36b698fb83bc1978b9c93abdccf01c322e92ef10b851a6681712934f3", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7b7a18e36b698fb83bc1978b9c93abdccf01c322e92ef10b851a6681712934f3", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Shonda tells the truth. Phoebe says Shonda tells the truth. Ryan says Phoebe tells the truth. Christy says Ryan tells the truth. Veena says Christy tells the truth. Does Veena tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Shonda tells the truth. Phoebe says Shonda tells the truth. Ryan says Phoebe tells the truth. Christy says Ryan tells the truth. Veena says Christy tells the truth. Does Veena tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7372.08, "reasoner_ms": 1981.27, "tts_ms": 25.05, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9378.43, "total_processing_ms": 10160.19 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 854, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 85 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e736fba9fa60993dead3c30318c7a7eabfacef9e6a5c99e4fb02006cfb3f02cd", "started_sha256": "c50b399c21753cee56e875279f42bba9a4bd147bf0d5dd2c6317b0cbbb08bd33", "original_grade_sha256": "042153e33da5b5ccdd6e59549d5a419ea24dc2ce92afc08963e103d60d42eb87", "input_original_sha256": "e736fba9fa60993dead3c30318c7a7eabfacef9e6a5c99e4fb02006cfb3f02cd", "input_wav_sha256": "1fb10f0d77c1c66d417ab2724e5fec3615bdd42ebba06a86c9d81629c81ba0a9", "input_pcm_sha256": "2966b7bf0f3663b20e4243dd24344262eae40ae4b086531c4786c31fd7a7818d", "output_wav_sha256": "e88552ae2033a3419e54a5095b94c51d37346b08ad75d9f671ace7eaba636727", "output_pcm_sha256": "00d9ecf6578b70e439cfe444255b31b03e44791acda174622a9bf023cd360b40", "result_sha256": "770145775b3f81c48df2772177f1741f0951861bfcc64825f73d684a8ca48ac4" } }, { "id": 72, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "53496e45c08c843ebf996658fef5ebdd42b468e54a0f2dfc07a3ff0118288bbe", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "53496e45c08c843ebf996658fef5ebdd42b468e54a0f2dfc07a3ff0118288bbe", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a cousin of Robert? Is Joe related to Bob? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To begin with, being a cousin of Lawrence is sufficient for being a schoolmate of Kenneth. Moreover, somebody is a close friend of Philip and not a schoolmate of Kenneth. All this entails that not every close friend of Philip is a cousin of Lawrence. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Fred a cousin of Robert? Is Joe related to Bob? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To begin with, being a cousin of Lawrence is sufficient for being a schoolmate of Kenneth. Moreover, somebody is a close friend of Philip and not a schoolmate of Kenneth. All this entails that not every close friend of Philip is a cousin of Lawrence. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 17789.21, "reasoner_ms": 2617.53, "tts_ms": 65.66, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 20472.44, "total_processing_ms": 21715.48 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1081, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 118 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "97af53a76b488a860b2db02659cfbc90f8ee2968b1b007f4a5ab149c0d202b49", "started_sha256": "ee21234f4b09a40a134a2d759324bb0c2170e9d950c5f8e6d492ba2f4917b3fd", "original_grade_sha256": "f29a2bad120fb2b2cca7c9d71e976335b96e720634374333fe28c7fb35f8abf7", "input_original_sha256": "97af53a76b488a860b2db02659cfbc90f8ee2968b1b007f4a5ab149c0d202b49", "input_wav_sha256": "34a63d426f35477d06b650702a4db55416f45f104ce709e5c4b61299b92c755c", "input_pcm_sha256": "027bc671c5e1d86650f67a215346bc4013255fce94578a5ec61775c280fc3f73", "output_wav_sha256": "01076074972144c6b7432713b0902c090956c0e3d53ad152103cac4b6121ed36", "output_pcm_sha256": "9d81d080e09ef1c87cf3d75ee788e6a8299edac01422e2f69e93258398bf01dc", "result_sha256": "928b9f6e432ed86470892862a9d39bbbebd8b260636032827bdaba4791d6e80c" } }, { "id": 455, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "757698df92566cdcc4b88bcf2a19892ab4534c1cb1417881c0bdf915e527963a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "757698df92566cdcc4b88bcf2a19892ab4534c1cb1417881c0bdf915e527963a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left, turn right, take seven steps, turn around, take seven steps, turn right, turn left, turn right. Options. Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point, turn left, turn right, take seven steps, turn around, take seven steps, turn right, turn left, turn right? Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6742.3, "reasoner_ms": 2474.35, "tts_ms": 31.76, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9248.43, "total_processing_ms": 10306.54 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 814, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 80 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "28732e6f89a4c9b04c2ab969a853450990c1d2f67f5619df537615e313f71183", "started_sha256": "d184d96ef9703015bee5e3bfcd9b2e41182975994471d73cc8659677cf6738e2", "original_grade_sha256": "3ad72e1021ad4f7e14e6b2d8a5a4d57ecef983ad1925adcb59fe80eef322ad14", "input_original_sha256": "28732e6f89a4c9b04c2ab969a853450990c1d2f67f5619df537615e313f71183", "input_wav_sha256": "f0fc2ef47987aaa754d6de0ff1e92b33cf4c2d54e95bd5233bae9b3a95694ef4", "input_pcm_sha256": "e1e457a62fb3294a70ffc952b60a33f3fd14aac209121c3735ab9f23adaf2bc8", "output_wav_sha256": "49a1a468ea7a6d29875de4043929b87406fd76d9f216ad3419209818fb0193f8", "output_pcm_sha256": "b7d64b1bc328247815480773c7e81a752ce1bb7fb6a86b6eb8791ab804ddf000", "result_sha256": "f02e1674c621888bc5f4a90ca1ee467af518179703044dd77a60c17556024a38" } }, { "id": 710, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "2", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a25b388b8c8e5563e9d6fc0421753f33bf22b402aa89ec0b04f0c949070f14f0", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a25b388b8c8e5563e9d6fc0421753f33bf22b402aa89ec0b04f0c949070f14f0", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a dog, a mouse, a toaster, and a table. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a dog, a mouse, a toaster, and a table. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 2.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5448.34, "reasoner_ms": 1378.81, "tts_ms": 26.2, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6853.38, "total_processing_ms": 7540.82 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 744, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d893ac2c7b770391eb524a5abf86f88e72f6bfe5ef366f81ab28fc8a075a25ee", "started_sha256": "a00c2cb9bde0416a41fa5e2cad7e9bf5d4a4e162775aacad6bcab7bde7af5ff4", "original_grade_sha256": "2cf56b1e8f37ee82c38988a52c59248ffeacaddc3fd0ca0632b218a43246eafb", "input_original_sha256": "d893ac2c7b770391eb524a5abf86f88e72f6bfe5ef366f81ab28fc8a075a25ee", "input_wav_sha256": "62131df3b804b5812c6f70f5ff03aba373ddd07c5bd220edd2fe7166a3557e57", "input_pcm_sha256": "e78c481ba57ca735d6805b2aae4240fee16dc2b906ea2001867ce174de38c641", "output_wav_sha256": "88f0f90f42d28900d3df6aaf0be13e70ab2e0e8ebcbcf10c774a9c0190abb56e", "output_pcm_sha256": "955a2f13b87accf2725914fcbb441d23db4a3788fc619ae089524c63882b2820", "result_sha256": "b6ea4fb91e61fc328b6fa93cd4ae236792c2c1406f79f1617cdb3d5fee9ee882" } }, { "id": 779, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2e9af5b7d1e9b87ee5d0e58beb3eeb5c0703803ae5c1c3332cd6fb23fad9d8f2", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2e9af5b7d1e9b87ee5d0e58beb3eeb5c0703803ae5c1c3332cd6fb23fad9d8f2", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Shalonda lies. Jamie says Shalonda tells the truth. Raymond says Jamie lies. Audrey says Raymond lies. Sherri says Audrey lies. Does Sherri tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Shalonda lies. Jamie says Shalonda tells the truth. Raymond says Jamie lies. Audrey says Raymond lies. Sherry says Audrey lies. Does Sherry tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6492.93, "reasoner_ms": 2464.65, "tts_ms": 25.94, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8983.55, "total_processing_ms": 9803.78 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 837, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 116 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "c15a60c7cc91b4073f226aaf1db7d00df55bd321d42ec39c3ab9664b411413d9", "started_sha256": "b0d87440bcacbe8dd7b7637586926ebaf2078e96ac3536a212548463f18e9cb4", "original_grade_sha256": "05f0d8326dde7f7ab2045b0326628ddca1d74eb4d22019b48149a5124a874161", "input_original_sha256": "c15a60c7cc91b4073f226aaf1db7d00df55bd321d42ec39c3ab9664b411413d9", "input_wav_sha256": "2aab1527ce0dc6f33ece8f01f60fd5a15da3b6bc75533c1cc3a3e3e2f27e01b7", "input_pcm_sha256": "9522fb914289ac2ec1b3624d6497592146f167a0b3de91030f3a5d0b3f253132", "output_wav_sha256": "2f95377b929ceb277a2d2113e40031c472e653c2eddbcc5c656bfe16744aa425", "output_pcm_sha256": "173e970ed3c698f81f4bf2befd73b967733ee153ff18c3c37050b76297c5132a", "result_sha256": "4a0697370d8213f5778b2c46c55056bf1f50872fdc3d6cb1f1e49ac1621722ef" } }, { "id": 18, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9b451bf27c968c0ab2e0d8b95f9e80dbd9d2a0b0b4e1e8989b91e617fd5fb8ab", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9b451bf27c968c0ab2e0d8b95f9e80dbd9d2a0b0b4e1e8989b91e617fd5fb8ab", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, being an ingredient of Hope Moisture Mask is sufficient for being an ingredient of Miracle Concealer. Second, nothing is neither an ingredient of All Day Body Wash nor an ingredient of Hope Moisture Mask. We may conclude being an ingredient of All Day Body Wash is sufficient for not being an ingredient of Miracle Concealer. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument, first, being an ingredient of hope moisture mask is sufficient for being an ingredient of miracle concealer. Second, nothing is neither an ingredient of all-day body wash nor an ingredient of hope moisture mask. We may conclude, being an ingredient of all-day body wash is sufficient for not being an ingredient of miracle concealer. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13708.05, "reasoner_ms": 4465.34, "tts_ms": 54.56, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 18227.99, "total_processing_ms": 18947.87 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 938, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 282 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b038342aa5bdeaeab0cc7f762060a1c3d2bb3777c592f4aa364bf99866561977", "started_sha256": "a15f712e952b310849d5ea813e005377537e2d992dc7c7fdb987cb41e857f0e3", "original_grade_sha256": "3d3e3d6ade3b3a76b9311aeb384812253ea45602f55cff528112e5c58e520624", "input_original_sha256": "b038342aa5bdeaeab0cc7f762060a1c3d2bb3777c592f4aa364bf99866561977", "input_wav_sha256": "8ba9da573b59eedb40a8316a6e6c547816e472008e0db11445c31f0cbc7c5256", "input_pcm_sha256": "d26ee8fd448b14323339dd553cf8764af43027ddd78b5004230126d215381bcc", "output_wav_sha256": "6d0221d2614caf648e8b8ef8fdd87a452023c75dd2d43d959d563fc555979862", "output_pcm_sha256": "2e454bedf90309283763a58d8453dddb49d54d9cd29ac286eaf9936e2ae0b968", "result_sha256": "33cae110fd05fb2567464c179dd880a08f6eb23c540d1d3587f6e1b5472c95bd" } }, { "id": 409, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ec8a99d0267d41c7e47d4582ddee85af39a1fc9e965d7935cdc42377d9be7bb1", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ec8a99d0267d41c7e47d4582ddee85af39a1fc9e965d7935cdc42377d9be7bb1", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take ten steps, turn around. Take one step. Take nine steps, turn around. Options. Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take 10 steps. Turn around. Take 1 step. Take 9 steps. Turn around. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5441.99, "reasoner_ms": 2174.87, "tts_ms": 51.83, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7668.71, "total_processing_ms": 8412.69 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 801, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 91 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2ad7a009e3555e6ecb2e188aa21642cc979144a0b496cddca6fa01f28a529827", "started_sha256": "b081a330fdf48fcda61318239483a75fc1a79c8f954884fd909f47c71cf01a56", "original_grade_sha256": "20c8c68c12120d6df8a22e16753448ac37faf89423d784b38501edf14c4eead3", "input_original_sha256": "2ad7a009e3555e6ecb2e188aa21642cc979144a0b496cddca6fa01f28a529827", "input_wav_sha256": "b82b073a4116051cb52809a3c1b3846b90bb3ed826cc0b9c25cdd2357c362960", "input_pcm_sha256": "ac1edfbda0056d6b324aa0034fb21f6d6f335840c23746cb95fc4a2fcbef6c70", "output_wav_sha256": "134eb94e5c7998251218c8725d3ce9fc93fc61e711cec196d99fac52b95ad2a9", "output_pcm_sha256": "44b93ce816be0c313168252150421be0f5329edaf69ff4435fac686b9390e20a", "result_sha256": "bb006dcdbdec516827261a1edaaa8d43837fae5f392c7758e31799e385e73aa4" } }, { "id": 685, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "10", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "898600ce5a1e9de6a6eec85eae0b012b5fd0196e793fbfcfb620e47e704d20bb", "normalized_answer": "10" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "898600ce5a1e9de6a6eec85eae0b012b5fd0196e793fbfcfb620e47e704d20bb", "normalized_answer": "10" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a couch, a car, a stove, a chair, an oven, a toaster, a bed, two lamps, and a fridge. How many objects do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a couch, a car, a stove, a chair, an oven, a toaster, a bed, two lamps, and a fridge. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 10.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5884.12, "reasoner_ms": 1738.93, "tts_ms": 23.56, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7646.63, "total_processing_ms": 8233.67 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 785, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 53 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5cdfb3bafa6bd53d6f856dbbd6be6c3cb5f9627853cb0f5deeadb5f34969f577", "started_sha256": "8f120ca67a61f9fdd2324b567d91f5c00f0030540dadf86c8ee31443586a6ec5", "original_grade_sha256": "18a8eb5f62065a774daeef3ed1ac0bc133f5391efb87d1f2c4185fb1c196be71", "input_original_sha256": "5cdfb3bafa6bd53d6f856dbbd6be6c3cb5f9627853cb0f5deeadb5f34969f577", "input_wav_sha256": "51d1a6df9a0ccef4986bb723d38fe542c9e6fc639bd7155e83b3293e45666c8e", "input_pcm_sha256": "d032e2ed92b90483701d89fb96b3cc59ba648c157616734fe30bed6bd57872c6", "output_wav_sha256": "2c3e6ad8ae072b53333acdcde211d865ffdfb4cc6176064023812deeb4971a81", "output_pcm_sha256": "2b97b47d4dc2a6277617c7799ecf06a14e3824c928d62ec5bae618264defccef", "result_sha256": "e48293ad8397cfead71acfcf4e1798e53288294e6477891eeea671b5ae7aaf96" } }, { "id": 890, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cf664e5efcf4c711823b7224806cd8a418baa3f0083a6abdded9e00a64dcb215", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cf664e5efcf4c711823b7224806cd8a418baa3f0083a6abdded9e00a64dcb215", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Loreen tells the truth. Michaela says Loreen lies. Millicent says Michaela tells the truth. Fletcher says Millicent tells the truth. Shonda says Fletcher tells the truth. Does Shonda tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Lorene tells the truth. Michaela says Lorene lies. Millicent says Michaela tells the truth. Fletcher says Millicent tells the truth. Shonda says Fletcher tells the truth. Does Shonda tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6299.84, "reasoner_ms": 2044.08, "tts_ms": 24.43, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8368.38, "total_processing_ms": 9034.79 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 855, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 100 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "62e1a1e0907763d7a7de4c74521eef0a49dc14bfa9551b767365404833e4fd89", "started_sha256": "3c3193c5d36fec56384faac0889698604806242d00b6e4f78f26b95063b46e58", "original_grade_sha256": "4f0ca1dfc09d031c8ace5603e6cd6eaf0baef68ad850782917313a2dd726067e", "input_original_sha256": "62e1a1e0907763d7a7de4c74521eef0a49dc14bfa9551b767365404833e4fd89", "input_wav_sha256": "0dac5118172cf653d8214286a65ae8a13f631ad4124642adb4e671e617e56961", "input_pcm_sha256": "bf4d07db5c74211ecd2d968c580defa104549928abd21c802ccf10f04d1569b7", "output_wav_sha256": "774f675b56d2401f7d320228767b0d10926afbdb23b1292ecf5d4b8688adac4c", "output_pcm_sha256": "7542107a4c60cfe710a96bd8ee44fccb69e08e55d524b88b2ee789ea47aae076", "result_sha256": "97ff5cb3d81a621b7197e4e47795e14328b39137aeabb8e659def18f632a147e" } }, { "id": 140, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e0fbd16c3ccf43883800694091ac1d73e7eb2ceb3e33f77c0ff50ea2f181cd0b", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e0fbd16c3ccf43883800694091ac1d73e7eb2ceb3e33f77c0ff50ea2f181cd0b", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. To start with, no uncle of Arturo is a stepbrother of Edwin or a close friend of Jonathan. Now, every schoolmate of Jason is either a stepbrother of Edwin or a close friend of Jonathan or both. In consequence, being a schoolmate of Jason is sufficient for not being an uncle of Arturo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. To start with, no uncle of Arturo is a stepbrother of Edwin or a close friend of Jonathan. Now, every schoolmate of Jason is either a stepbrother of Edwin or a close friend of Jonathan, or both. In consequence, being a schoolmate of Jason is sufficient for not being an uncle of arturo is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 17823.43, "reasoner_ms": 4086.46, "tts_ms": 28.07, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 21937.99, "total_processing_ms": 22683.65 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1041, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 170 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "c76cae776778bbf72ca8b4a573e6f80bd91f5878c97987cdf377c2b6d68f1894", "started_sha256": "54b2f2c52721129781c252a012c7187fa609a670a32a5dd1a3015b998389333e", "original_grade_sha256": "8b24501cc120e388ae341766cce5fc78927a8f9c9369c5a5525d3e54983f0836", "input_original_sha256": "c76cae776778bbf72ca8b4a573e6f80bd91f5878c97987cdf377c2b6d68f1894", "input_wav_sha256": "ba2b501bdbda0626cf19f42ba1203608d266dea51986c0ab13af6d9c176d5821", "input_pcm_sha256": "99f5c285b58ea1871d1a8e91e1d06e556fd8edc2ba9c03124f0aa91d02b3a96e", "output_wav_sha256": "fa9e38d52caedd34cc8487cb63f1a353e872c2bb723ab53bb47c33454ff5674a", "output_pcm_sha256": "bc5f3979548765edf012edac19262ebe88368c800133618162dec7927b3832ad", "result_sha256": "46240f6ca7a280d220fc6352ada2d3ef9ad3b9988532cf35ccb7aa54fbc1db23" } }, { "id": 331, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cc254ef6e235b9e8d9586345929ec75108ba2700f4c09f5556791520634a4531", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cc254ef6e235b9e8d9586345929ec75108ba2700f4c09f5556791520634a4531", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps forward. Take nine steps right. Take two steps forward. Take ten steps backward. Take nine steps left. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps forward. Take nine steps right. Take two steps forward. Take ten steps backward. Take nine steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5955.63, "reasoner_ms": 1379.42, "tts_ms": 24.67, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7359.75, "total_processing_ms": 8049.7 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 837, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 42 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "89c0566914015dbc853b3f5718290c484cc169eadb1f7a870ddf321ef01c6e67", "started_sha256": "4e9f766fdb6989a738aae9d93416a8e52da77799709731ee88ca2b61fe50d1ff", "original_grade_sha256": "22428720ebd79ad2743c7427f5aad101f04ff9b16601d5ab0047daf5625ee579", "input_original_sha256": "89c0566914015dbc853b3f5718290c484cc169eadb1f7a870ddf321ef01c6e67", "input_wav_sha256": "456fdaa751ec34a4076ebcf9e48bcf09c67bb666fbc596888bb048ae448932c5", "input_pcm_sha256": "f4beb021d599beade9996b908a32b22c03fe713df31b6fbc054198ffab8b1ea4", "output_wav_sha256": "3143a450ff66008291c6d397120f24da9ce823746adfbe65fed7fa936f612f5a", "output_pcm_sha256": "771ffc939fdb1964c3e85fa4578aa7c840274ab0af0b6b711d6d5d97ce9aec90", "result_sha256": "7d00b6ea41ec59e95f7235d21a14968efbd4288c6e134a6f629c9fd082b83637" } }, { "id": 733, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "15", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8442e9a37a3aa0e8e5f1b37a2b1592094918eeba73609ae3de1289dec517885b", "normalized_answer": "15" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8442e9a37a3aa0e8e5f1b37a2b1592094918eeba73609ae3de1289dec517885b", "normalized_answer": "15" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\n,membros da,pode\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a car, a fridge, an oven, a toaster, a couch, three lamps, five chairs, a stove and a microwave. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 15.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6044.66, "reasoner_ms": 2139.93, "tts_ms": 29.02, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8213.63, "total_processing_ms": 9056.06 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 739, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 88 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "719212f726072eef4450769af269e34d08cd6cde6de336a6198efc538b61fcf0", "started_sha256": "d1edd38fc0b768f2df4eb467873079727809485a7da227c5cd9aba9f33324e39", "original_grade_sha256": "7eb782367701c9119ac26f0490531ff7396c80d0ffe269e87eb98812d6189b01", "input_original_sha256": "719212f726072eef4450769af269e34d08cd6cde6de336a6198efc538b61fcf0", "input_wav_sha256": "868a4d7bd493248b34e3ed4017483b9636e3d8ddfb55a92ec1745828d35f6661", "input_pcm_sha256": "84b8177924feefb86244b0377c166d492f44d6c4adf9c9bf0b3e0c30111dd67f", "output_wav_sha256": "8eda7afca44de241ec30196c5ced00ffc50b5fb7cc683df82f99842ebba10c34", "output_pcm_sha256": "b0b43fbac9167f853364ab6fe41af80a9b70eaea1a83867eefc2ec7f5d2a183e", "result_sha256": "5cdc4ac54cc5722e107c6751e9b941bc522740eef727aeae8d8646ff80d452e1" } }, { "id": 813, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7b69bc587ecfac1364083c1003a0df2975d376a733f39546578d0ee2c2ec2f76", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7b69bc587ecfac1364083c1003a0df2975d376a733f39546578d0ee2c2ec2f76", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Jerry tells the truth. Eleanor says Jerry tells the truth. Gwen says Eleanor tells the truth. Candy says Gwen tells the truth. Dallas says Candy tells the truth. Does Dallas tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nJerry tells the truth. Eleanor says Jerry tells the truth. Gwen says Eleanor tells the truth. Candy says Gwen tells the truth. Dallas says Candy tells the truth. Does Dallas tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6529.78, "reasoner_ms": 5205.65, "tts_ms": 25.67, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11761.12, "total_processing_ms": 12479.36 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 855, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 74 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3c161cf542a3487513d3268d5c866c27d21dea37752b024f6516aa58b88c7f74", "started_sha256": "ac94f9c4ad95da6f9c2ffc6f570d4f97f8cad982dcbd2bb361d6659c8865ede0", "original_grade_sha256": "68db6226cfce98122aa2ecc4abc91ba015d6139f49ac7ca163cd43ff625e2e76", "input_original_sha256": "3c161cf542a3487513d3268d5c866c27d21dea37752b024f6516aa58b88c7f74", "input_wav_sha256": "b2ec416afdfcb857f1197e3397c42c704e58e321df5653b9f09fba0af6495ac7", "input_pcm_sha256": "6b32962abd4d6efe0a3e148ebd8e8b1031ccfce7f6c2b17423f00cf455b8c512", "output_wav_sha256": "aab12fcfd3e65ef532d5fb7fe35e292855ea94e4ce9e82233d4c30ff8cc29a1e", "output_pcm_sha256": "075f80bf83408b665ef5bbc71efdc0d94dd48c0960f3a33730571b4e459b0d26", "result_sha256": "ab0245e0c5934a5c538a87ada27c32d85269fe36c5d2195262173287db601035" } }, { "id": 185, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3acb5f03d180ddae0456fb04f7d23266af30fa1b01f369404cfdc82cb4b6a0c6", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3acb5f03d180ddae0456fb04f7d23266af30fa1b01f369404cfdc82cb4b6a0c6", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, everyone who is a close friend of Andy or an uncle of Reya's is also a classmate of Marvin. Next, Johnny is a close friend of Andy. All this entails that Johnny is a classmate of Marvin. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, everyone who is a close friend of Andy or an uncle of Reyes is also a classmate of Marvin. Next, Johnny is a close friend of Andy. All this entails that Johnny is a classmate of Marvin. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9226.95, "reasoner_ms": 1808.38, "tts_ms": 33.25, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11068.6, "total_processing_ms": 11766.49 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 940, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 63 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3b80e4721de77182b98887be071ac5c825e9c7dcfab213e2bd397fffe44f89dd", "started_sha256": "ceb9011ed19ba5dcf2175ceb59a9f475bff70b22ec679310c66a64bea90f05d2", "original_grade_sha256": "99c5799aff23a10e1ff0211f4bbe2cb1943cf74ad32655151dbf9193678f3aec", "input_original_sha256": "3b80e4721de77182b98887be071ac5c825e9c7dcfab213e2bd397fffe44f89dd", "input_wav_sha256": "ef688eed8d89627bc9a2befbc4e0e4ab89a317ed2a9a0ec05d135cb6b2542fb3", "input_pcm_sha256": "c15747dfa8380d3bd594001af410608b43032984387b7b64961fe9622560485c", "output_wav_sha256": "724c478f02160dc2421144ef9ca0b486515a822c67b2c25e517035aad0aaaa86", "output_pcm_sha256": "36974669b132abf7963484305c6d71cbdd476fb89c27b4590503bc8e2c07bd68", "result_sha256": "52a401409d5aaeb80d1749c3e91d1507d132efb9cd0a8b9039ef6f58165470b8" } }, { "id": 355, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dcbf32fd756b4d00c194bcc0df64541fedefc810b2c72c22c547d11fc8ab8424", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dcbf32fd756b4d00c194bcc0df64541fedefc810b2c72c22c547d11fc8ab8424", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps. Turn left. Take six steps. Turn around. Take two steps. Take ten steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps. Turn left. Take six steps. Turn around. Take two steps. Take ten steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6861.24, "reasoner_ms": 2678.23, "tts_ms": 43.91, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9583.4, "total_processing_ms": 10352.76 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 811, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 127 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "78fcb8ec7b76c52371c8452b9bc0871e8fc6c917f7e56ff7704ecaa59fbe5435", "started_sha256": "970a92458e1de4ab8374b4bbce4b8f3d57616d458d21dc0beece3b16ad99a954", "original_grade_sha256": "0fc64918ee5cbb9b59240cc7c62052884ea755d048e760abe32b5fb6c242c32e", "input_original_sha256": "78fcb8ec7b76c52371c8452b9bc0871e8fc6c917f7e56ff7704ecaa59fbe5435", "input_wav_sha256": "ee0c75d4d312e963991a196f9464e1fd93f5b02be1f687ef8cffebe14fe60f47", "input_pcm_sha256": "2721557f48e890d5a9db81de51912e0e5c041519c65caf0d0e09811aa3918502", "output_wav_sha256": "e6cce0137a293cb9c4bedf45119b4a2684dde7e6734eb635883cf5a3dc7bbf75", "output_pcm_sha256": "fde751e813663a1e45d0d8c76b1c74ede9cd445206b36eedd23ee62200dc39c1", "result_sha256": "d281e98335d7a385de507603bcbe5e9b151ed407285d30160484d418bfee521b" } }, { "id": 701, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "3", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1e3e906e839565fdbea3b700acb39288247a7856db2c407b7c3ddbab370c7602", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1e3e906e839565fdbea3b700acb39288247a7856db2c407b7c3ddbab370c7602", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have an apple and two blackberries. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have an apple and two blackberries. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 3.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4800.74, "reasoner_ms": 1509.61, "tts_ms": 25.6, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6335.98, "total_processing_ms": 6937.33 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 730, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 24 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6e2943827d76b276cb965f8be47ac098dde2871d55d8f669156a93a578b988a4", "started_sha256": "d7f54b9ff3996a132c3b6a0a9add1bd8b87574dbea4fe5e0d7b06650fdea0112", "original_grade_sha256": "24ef912f42c251142114e133968a4db7e26adbfd5d04581fead0c3f3e3e5a15d", "input_original_sha256": "6e2943827d76b276cb965f8be47ac098dde2871d55d8f669156a93a578b988a4", "input_wav_sha256": "d936b09a4ddc5a1c7081404e90c7bd1f287d222a924ac39d00ecc22a1b20239c", "input_pcm_sha256": "a55c9e5b5a56065e30b2f3cc242f91f287f75695f996cfc59a865061d2e41da8", "output_wav_sha256": "66106460fc6da14f1ed25b622384f80727bba800812836720719436dcc9a5fb4", "output_pcm_sha256": "ef573a58037fcadde05b3d6b8f7a4f9dfc7a7796f12a6240e489d12b081fb233", "result_sha256": "3606dccdfa8772427cc56b5f145f25327b762e1f89eeddb82e4fe9a6d738f41d" } }, { "id": 828, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "98f4d164a6c26ab2c7d905e1feaff8ed94c9082369c3cc740fc97d59d9d89828", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "98f4d164a6c26ab2c7d905e1feaff8ed94c9082369c3cc740fc97d59d9d89828", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Ryan lies. Christy says Ryan lies. Amberly says Christy tells the truth. Sheena says Amberly tells the truth. Jamie says Sheena lies. Does Jamie tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nq ryan lies christie says ryan lies amberlee says christie tells the truth sheena says amberlee tells the truth jamie says sheena lies does jamie tell the truth answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9338.25, "reasoner_ms": 2249.99, "tts_ms": 23.09, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11611.35, "total_processing_ms": 12382.61 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 824, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 121 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "047908ef580df2ef7e1a29fd25d5fc210d8eda55e5ff3f8efcdbcbaec0575723", "started_sha256": "196201ae4dca9b528ab8828c1f8e743ead1e43fe7113f32f72f5db464daab162", "original_grade_sha256": "cec3ebdd91c0fd446e613fcc28d02266de644e9d027db79e74cd5bb7d2577ce8", "input_original_sha256": "047908ef580df2ef7e1a29fd25d5fc210d8eda55e5ff3f8efcdbcbaec0575723", "input_wav_sha256": "38474dc1dab3bda46d5edd3cf32160ca733585793d4ef2489225ea0ad5d5ec25", "input_pcm_sha256": "5ce4ddf486319c21998ae696e9851e0505bdafa2b0d285d93a7b44b70c6120dc", "output_wav_sha256": "dd38f41666751d5565e1d8c4607e02a56230ebe88af2d550d21069b36fdbf719", "output_pcm_sha256": "1885e5989c4edcb07ee223718df2ff4ecaa4097d82ecebc0e35ba34d09023b7e", "result_sha256": "a68b7d8049f8bc0adc4771d7590192beaf1683517971e7eb59f866a3d99f2817" } }, { "id": 198, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2143bebfb5cb2e4918d5ceb3c3ab94b2eaf024f8d4839e3199fd7e7800b30db9", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2143bebfb5cb2e4918d5ceb3c3ab94b2eaf024f8d4839e3199fd7e7800b30db9", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First, being a daughter of Marjorie is sufficient for not being a cousin of Carol. Second, not every aunt of Tracy is a cousin of Carol. Therefore, some aunt of Tracy is a daughter of Marjorie. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First, being a daughter of Marjorie is sufficient for not being a cousin of Carol. Second, not every aunt of Tracy is a cousin of Carol. Therefore, some aunt of Tracy is a daughter of Marjorie. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 10277.24, "reasoner_ms": 2982.96, "tts_ms": 26.37, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 13286.6, "total_processing_ms": 14094.09 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 983, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 176 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1e91a83fa81a2788b5e4185786a2140257fa8e41e988c87a562f8d804611fcea", "started_sha256": "d0bc7893bd3184b8baf2c848544a34bf069b7c5c82becafad8dcda2525930729", "original_grade_sha256": "4995230140ba2e02fd6171e43923f6f0328ce1b21a7a4538c2400c009c2a697f", "input_original_sha256": "1e91a83fa81a2788b5e4185786a2140257fa8e41e988c87a562f8d804611fcea", "input_wav_sha256": "c6f07ddd8f61ccd9a72cbd253bef805b7057f5f0f625b5a0ec93adc1bda92e89", "input_pcm_sha256": "99052b813ed8d7436cd9c989b4f0410b64034487e1d72febb36a8745d7eb3b23", "output_wav_sha256": "5a163427ec84e2065be5c87a3332dcef164216abee4a7050ec8f57aab227c69b", "output_pcm_sha256": "60553e9483deb6c8abd8d8f959d368e23a01266cd99fcbeb3d8becae264152c5", "result_sha256": "80538458fa752fb8d079ebae6e93f4fd591a9bf05f091ea3fc19ae62c7f4dbea" } }, { "id": 278, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "028efd876c0085c663dfc4fd1786a92fe9209f4692a9ab11b9008d90e063649a", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "028efd876c0085c663dfc4fd1786a92fe9209f4692a9ab11b9008d90e063649a", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left. Take five steps. Turn around. Turn right. Options, yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left. Take five steps. Turn around. Turn right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5683.91, "reasoner_ms": 2396.38, "tts_ms": 24.21, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8104.52, "total_processing_ms": 8971.18 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 782, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 72 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8264f8a5938094e7f63e0fcb621da0271d0a78c803a29ae61e29807155416c56", "started_sha256": "47ba722e471bbad72663635af258a7aa3c093e996deeb968161956a20c1758c6", "original_grade_sha256": "9bb7375fb8e5141a8df9a5ff4479134e0fddf2e5a50af5a30884f3aae6d41be8", "input_original_sha256": "8264f8a5938094e7f63e0fcb621da0271d0a78c803a29ae61e29807155416c56", "input_wav_sha256": "9a1d558820327c303695fb65af6f3d88f5540287b6545e20372a4f994667644d", "input_pcm_sha256": "c40e1223cf7935b0ab219fd4865610d6963319ab232b37d9da4b4d236a53bb7e", "output_wav_sha256": "e55e83ab6c00f17e7403759e02726ca380c0229621de0bfddd52f460356c27dd", "output_pcm_sha256": "c36565c80c9f2d22b406ff4da70049c2cb3525587a70a7934135b638c37bf3f9", "result_sha256": "6ce3d6da4298a890c965ce85b80a307596f6c9e0eed68723de4b39f68850dc9f" } }, { "id": 716, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "11", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a567c461997af874aaabdbe9237929e94027baded8fb3f97f420a42d202f823c", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a567c461997af874aaabdbe9237929e94027baded8fb3f97f420a42d202f823c", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a fridge, a bed, a toaster, a car, a microwave, a chair, a lamp, a table, a couch, and two stoves. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a fridge, a bed, a toaster, a car, a microwave, a chair, a lamp, a table, a couch, and two stoves. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 11.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6264.67, "reasoner_ms": 2993.9, "tts_ms": 25.85, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9284.45, "total_processing_ms": 10070.24 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 796, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 54 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d680f81aa19528245f8a70936112207a1c7fbc567d7b5874e133b6eafcf42b95", "started_sha256": "8a9580bef72ed7a7a35f6678d087dd955651326ccd51ecf9fe1d84b71928c83c", "original_grade_sha256": "34e378ac65daa644d8832f8ef2479172f6080026e3adb73beed25ff1c5507fa2", "input_original_sha256": "d680f81aa19528245f8a70936112207a1c7fbc567d7b5874e133b6eafcf42b95", "input_wav_sha256": "e5514d1f354d9933330b003e3fb6594c33af616d88a8716b24f172b247e3da72", "input_pcm_sha256": "9bdddfe00742df6b2522dd3ffe68ce9467541423d62a173ba88a818cbd30efa9", "output_wav_sha256": "9a66fe3293b9bc434532b0ee32acb7bdaaf691a3e6a20650fefa6b7512fabca6", "output_pcm_sha256": "e94bf88bb3a49b94c78ae3f3c0b5f795bffb271c1eb9e2865d2abe4c7e550df2", "result_sha256": "039c9034a79d521b11a0bb663495727e919994b98d25d065afd71cfe2fb68ecd" } }, { "id": 821, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8d210f1d2d83bc80ce09ff5011844147b12b05ece78d40b2685c315036940f87", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8d210f1d2d83bc80ce09ff5011844147b12b05ece78d40b2685c315036940f87", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Candy tells the truth. Krista says Candy lies. Ryan says Krista tells the truth. Gwen says Ryan tells the truth. Delfina says Gwen tells the truth. Does Delfina tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Candy tells the truth. Krista says Candy lies. Ryan says Krista tells the truth. Gwen says Ryan tells the truth. Delfina says Gwen tells the truth. Does Delfina tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6462.2, "reasoner_ms": 2235.05, "tts_ms": 25.69, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8722.96, "total_processing_ms": 9518.55 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 843, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 108 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6bc1feb6605c34e48f3cfd429488c6a053270ffdab747f6a3c9ab2bbef0e2969", "started_sha256": "bade4c9fd2753f6483e92793d8ddee599e8558b888da8e58d1a253e682b1f2eb", "original_grade_sha256": "34d1b0e57d1bbc282f1ccfe661ba47a539212a675f1391efa18bf0d54e801cb7", "input_original_sha256": "6bc1feb6605c34e48f3cfd429488c6a053270ffdab747f6a3c9ab2bbef0e2969", "input_wav_sha256": "78fa76f8624b9a2788500ecc2ce917f60ffd131519443d35527b0957f39cb7de", "input_pcm_sha256": "a53140659828b096b866f11fe82773e528a97c6d314fd2fb414f958da89d15c0", "output_wav_sha256": "5293471ab36eb7535a04cb6877f679008b9be05ca24f7452f896fbf6c729d6d1", "output_pcm_sha256": "bce5eaa097239fbb87025f6cbfef35ed3268c31f4cf687ffec602e3e46d21694", "result_sha256": "7a4f0adee57f838cf4f4ee9ee26a88a61df5d4998da90912c1cc622daeffec1f" } }, { "id": 13, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e3ba0c8244d187d76b801e82f0a6145c4ad276d429f42023bbf2869fc3f584a2", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e3ba0c8244d187d76b801e82f0a6145c4ad276d429f42023bbf2869fc3f584a2", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, being an ancestor of Jonathan is sufficient for not being a grandson of Carmelo. Second, whoever is an ancestor of Jonathan is not a schoolmate of Reyes. Third, every grandson of Carmelo who is a schoolmate of Reyes is also a close friend of Clifford. We may conclude being an ancestor of Jonathan is sufficient for being a close friend of Clifford. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, being an ancestor of Jonathan is sufficient for not being a grandson of Carmelo. Second, whoever is an ancestor of Jonathan is not a schoolmate of Reyes. Third, every grandson of Carmelo who is a schoolmate of Reyes is also a close friend of Clifford. We may conclude, being an ancestor of Jonathan is sufficient for being a close friend end of Clifford. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13479.22, "reasoner_ms": 3542.48, "tts_ms": 34.89, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17056.62, "total_processing_ms": 17766.81 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 973, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 217 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8beb8afbde0a0a66124dd9d143ccd82eded711d9525889d0b949aaa77787e7ca", "started_sha256": "20cfd8d6482cc028f4fce3799e146884fff84b28988da6127a256dc7d873533e", "original_grade_sha256": "a20bb6f57754ace06c13382607e571e06440613873e0bad982100333153a3497", "input_original_sha256": "8beb8afbde0a0a66124dd9d143ccd82eded711d9525889d0b949aaa77787e7ca", "input_wav_sha256": "eff73b22b36404d2b64b2f9655083a6e5e9934b33525f38e1d7a1ab55f2fe7cd", "input_pcm_sha256": "afcd6a010827c6f40759e981fb6b46b351291a92aa3179c867fcdfcc6b3a71d8", "output_wav_sha256": "305b46b5ed322ca80dd527917dbbb9e97a1239b9aa89e64bf62865757e8765e2", "output_pcm_sha256": "aa2172870a434e9bd14524f51e00a9efd66634bc7474903f1219904a1f11b5a1", "result_sha256": "9d812743862308c179343ba10fb59dfba9eae4a0d1db33ff6b2f7b3ded1d66d7" } }, { "id": 260, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4159e835a7cc385e2b2a1d2fd34e39f53c210a60bda81e3e0c235f88ad1e7c5c", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4159e835a7cc385e2b2a1d2fd34e39f53c210a60bda81e3e0c235f88ad1e7c5c", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take eight steps. Take five steps. Take five steps. Take ten steps. Take five steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point take eight steps take five steps take five steps take ten steps take five steps options yes no answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8431.88, "reasoner_ms": 1615.9, "tts_ms": 24.2, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10072.0, "total_processing_ms": 10848.29 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 788, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 36 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1bd8f2a3e8efaae198cd915104ad27f752c74efc0da7fd2dd8b1053b41c49aa2", "started_sha256": "1e3e86a32efb84fe0e093c3fa2430b85cb5bb2176792dbc19fed01226b5167a9", "original_grade_sha256": "c9f1b9eeca828ffa641adfdac11c67d6fc46d56775397431f79e7ef57d46ff3a", "input_original_sha256": "1bd8f2a3e8efaae198cd915104ad27f752c74efc0da7fd2dd8b1053b41c49aa2", "input_wav_sha256": "9298a4ed2e606aba826003ae02bb872091a74089fda8a5ae62a1c4c764c94325", "input_pcm_sha256": "9e0fcede7a556636411e72324273894c473444d57ccaa478e9cfa67a7c05b59b", "output_wav_sha256": "5529ca0a51d7b95540aa9f0f17392d01f6af97ae92033ce895744eeae81bdd74", "output_pcm_sha256": "672521a90f6ffe4581ca7be67c2aa78b11c408416d4054523f15d734916efc93", "result_sha256": "7848719f41f9bc0cd04cbad158af6779c17ff160ab8c69b278702baf7f26135d" } }, { "id": 612, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "12", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "97d651d09562013d9ccdd8ff0848de787b0d098080440c3dd55e2b45a429c14e", "normalized_answer": "12" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "97d651d09562013d9ccdd8ff0848de787b0d098080440c3dd55e2b45a429c14e", "normalized_answer": "12" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a potato, five stalks of celery, a yam, a garlic, two lettuce heads, a cabbage, and a head of broccoli. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a potato, five stalks of celery, a yam, a garlic, two lettuce heads, a cabbage, and a head of broccoli. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 12.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5972.97, "reasoner_ms": 1720.7, "tts_ms": 27.7, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7721.41, "total_processing_ms": 8417.65 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 800, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 60 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "46d836921ae51512d3325e5cfbfa2ce71cb47d619253cc8fb83fd50af35ac1a0", "started_sha256": "31eae2f8bb19548c566976714a14f35de72ab0eb1624f9a0c820e94ce671a3a7", "original_grade_sha256": "d195baef84e2668a1450c631df4b66cdf02b6eae4b4bbb2f739e043e225c330d", "input_original_sha256": "46d836921ae51512d3325e5cfbfa2ce71cb47d619253cc8fb83fd50af35ac1a0", "input_wav_sha256": "683c07372c56e38d6f18f0116f7622254baeba484883e2ab90b757948f294e63", "input_pcm_sha256": "5a3c5ea3e7e828abac90e090bcb297f4dec7e92c02e19bf0b175018011b4cb5c", "output_wav_sha256": "fc9d67b4217093b2844777987f9f6de0406df405c73eafdbc644a60c28397a58", "output_pcm_sha256": "1af1e84117ddd78fc89505edb7f29db96429898ab73771d9ad8503c03bf4bf82", "result_sha256": "855fb39050b6187e5318c5674bc9e1e01b1b71c03585277e2fb1aa834e624e3d" } }, { "id": 991, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b65d6fde97ccb3b8f07d024b0f0bf2642ca5f24924ed4d444501b2880fc3cd12", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b65d6fde97ccb3b8f07d024b0f0bf2642ca5f24924ed4d444501b2880fc3cd12", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Shonda lies. Andre says Shonda tells the truth. Jamie says Andre lies. Inga says Jamie lies. Millicent says Inga tells the truth. Does Millicent tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion shonda lies andre says shonda tells the truth jamie says andre lies inga says jamie lies millicent says inga tells the truth does millicent tell the truth answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8727.6, "reasoner_ms": 2651.95, "tts_ms": 25.2, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11404.78, "total_processing_ms": 12220.9 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 818, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 136 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "16fe649766ad3841efb94cb31845bc8ead091b8d494fe7f029b404c10c8cd2bc", "started_sha256": "6ff8d2e3f46f9cd9152c34c68c553284c6f5c00d424b9f2b37b9ddd8da14cbcd", "original_grade_sha256": "8765d5ef287b7dd6e7aa265f3cb4ceeae298f16d68fa52a4c3268553d6101453", "input_original_sha256": "16fe649766ad3841efb94cb31845bc8ead091b8d494fe7f029b404c10c8cd2bc", "input_wav_sha256": "2e73fdd94df1d7f8437cf8b080cd9db7957583e486915f8e03272b080f9f8ff9", "input_pcm_sha256": "5d6aa1987d907fbc4144c0c7c51936a16f2db0c40d0c757c09d77b955142906e", "output_wav_sha256": "a1e5a97c7a5b071e2170aef085534ddcbcc9310bc5ed1468e9f073619b4465ab", "output_pcm_sha256": "b0e7392b6e9f06c3176106deff4199b1cebeea69eff37c931580ad7809b6c9d2", "result_sha256": "f0abf9936a8eeff7ab3fcc79550648db850e7cb48ae4908d36955b47a380d8ec" } }, { "id": 3, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "04ca0f8462b8cbdb534cf0752147453a17ff651862db575e71eaf2fc28346065", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "04ca0f8462b8cbdb534cf0752147453a17ff651862db575e71eaf2fc28346065", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nSome football fans admire various clubs, others love only a single team. But who is a fan of whom precisely? The following argument pertains to this question. First, no devotee of FK Partizan is an expert of Southampton FC. Second, no critic of FC Spartak Moskva is an expert of Southampton FC. Third, to be a critic of FC Spartak Moskva or a devotee of FK Partizan is necessary for being an admirer of Karaba FK. Hence, no admirer of Karaba FK is an expert of Southampton FC. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nSome football fans admire various clubs, others love only a single team. But who is a fan of whom precisely? The following argument pertains to this question. First, no devotee of FK Partizan is an expert of Southampton FC. Second, no critic of FC Spartak Moskva is an expert of Southampton FC. Third, to be a critic of FC Spartak Moskva or a devotee of FK Partizan is necessary for being an admirer of Caraba FK. Hence, no admirer of Caraba FK is an expert of Southampton FC. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 15887.39, "reasoner_ms": 2942.55, "tts_ms": 24.09, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 18854.06, "total_processing_ms": 19565.51 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1110, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 143 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8d0f3da662006352500b6a8ce8a483554144379994dc7447e16d986cf7aaabd1", "started_sha256": "e51da54af74ecaac1c83696a93c36a06d53ee7827cc7fb0e3e6e66d18b4cdc88", "original_grade_sha256": "ccd9614589caf51b45ebb90699ce51cd1aec7136bc55af5eefe4d85c21c2dfeb", "input_original_sha256": "8d0f3da662006352500b6a8ce8a483554144379994dc7447e16d986cf7aaabd1", "input_wav_sha256": "6b55737cff558890c855990509c406232e88d223c588e447f5367b38a82dfa2a", "input_pcm_sha256": "cfd8363808fd68a8ed254600548dbb068c8bb1b2b2b4e20e76609091bb55833b", "output_wav_sha256": "a76efbfa660289a5c3a837127187759523d6dcde36b1cb014856cb16d61bb114", "output_pcm_sha256": "a1b9912152c96f5f015958763befab26623ed14a2f13e56dd31736604e6862e4", "result_sha256": "288e4b1c732fdb24160ff1f52e05c35798fafcf6ad8a934e19b356e172d2c34f" } }, { "id": 251, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0b10540b8344fa5fa1d334a4da9d00b6b5bbbb19ccc9843ce310fd8463e050d9", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0b10540b8344fa5fa1d334a4da9d00b6b5bbbb19ccc9843ce310fd8463e050d9", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take ten steps left. Take ten steps forward. Take seven steps forward. Take two steps forward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take 10 steps left. Take 10 steps forward. Take seven steps forward. Take two steps forward. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6953.19, "reasoner_ms": 1504.99, "tts_ms": 25.39, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8483.6, "total_processing_ms": 9222.23 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 823, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 47 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1b992ce63e5391b83fcde6541b516ac6632f8198aeb2e50147f20d129cfaaa3c", "started_sha256": "08908be266dc6a348b979d4a445bc98a20383ba7f4e5f6b9afc6ea89a7c7d357", "original_grade_sha256": "b4a12fd865f720aa427d4c73a2c3648bdb22348d3106a22e5d4d5d29a0937ff4", "input_original_sha256": "1b992ce63e5391b83fcde6541b516ac6632f8198aeb2e50147f20d129cfaaa3c", "input_wav_sha256": "7fedbdcbc21b0c1a729c498975a5225aa6ab5fad5f31d77ee3162ed2a6f247fb", "input_pcm_sha256": "92d685d0a043add6a1c7374428be15537c8b3a54b24ed44b5b1e71d772c0fc3e", "output_wav_sha256": "ed7c7df40d9ed930d7c0b6c9d11187424e8ddb7abf3f6eeb43ec422381a57b7a", "output_pcm_sha256": "f904a5cd64fc3cc953aab36528cfc768bca5fa1c9368b75dbbe2ff08ba1edae6", "result_sha256": "d8549aa4bf3301b022ac47a9c419c4f7fe1615d4e74a89ba45dc38c151c00379" } }, { "id": 602, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "7", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9259e520fdfa8487fc44b3bb12e776d1203bd80342d9363ed6d976469abff1ba", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9259e520fdfa8487fc44b3bb12e776d1203bd80342d9363ed6d976469abff1ba", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have three cabbages, a carrot, two stalks of celery, and an onion. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have three cabbages, a carrot, two stalks of celery, and an onion. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 7.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5099.39, "reasoner_ms": 1561.07, "tts_ms": 24.34, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6684.83, "total_processing_ms": 7428.89 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 759, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 40 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e6028327a934914f3e4583763c37906de7b8e58ba23a022e55098d422d901884", "started_sha256": "ac16b41c4146db3ab955739897d2c72ae66e7bb410686fea5dfe436c77e37b31", "original_grade_sha256": "6d0a322af90cbc59d88fd68d55d9fdc9d761369e30a4f7a8fb2ed5e83fc93bf7", "input_original_sha256": "e6028327a934914f3e4583763c37906de7b8e58ba23a022e55098d422d901884", "input_wav_sha256": "123bb78ba8f093e33c5dbe0ac162125a589963b2f156efd95ecee2bcdf81b04a", "input_pcm_sha256": "7242e0199a999c672469db8c10e53b730935347f3d37c9260ada71f1f837bd87", "output_wav_sha256": "24a878854a84aa8fdd164f9ca5fcdcd54f94f431d56f4ed64cbb400b7fd58edd", "output_pcm_sha256": "6d45bf074d498c4c1ebb46f02a17d4914293482725ed07a865e9630f42ea7029", "result_sha256": "73dad7c9e89de22940d537c9eb8444c06fc6c9c360c91011c773f018dcc93066" } }, { "id": 786, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a4f426ba9acca79d7fe432e4ed2d35f7a7a80f18dc31c839e7f452162c8139b7", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a4f426ba9acca79d7fe432e4ed2d35f7a7a80f18dc31c839e7f452162c8139b7", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Fidel lies. Fletcher says Fidel tells the truth. Yolande says Fletcher lies. Raymond says Yolande lies. Lita says Raymond lies. Does Lita tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Fidel lies. Fletcher says Fidel tells the truth. Yolan says Fletcher lies. Raymond says Yolan lies. Lita says Raymond lies. Does Lita tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6008.78, "reasoner_ms": 2294.84, "tts_ms": 26.9, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8330.55, "total_processing_ms": 8972.73 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 833, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 120 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ae627cd5c92ea9ff63caa740869cabbb1f6b405d0c94f42398b07e43dedfd53e", "started_sha256": "477a84d3bffeffbc32354fcc1db3e6620e91a43cb63155a5adb3055b487232c7", "original_grade_sha256": "44b52fb7d3e4581783110f1a29e7282f66c1c2469e940c66a34f8d181b665403", "input_original_sha256": "ae627cd5c92ea9ff63caa740869cabbb1f6b405d0c94f42398b07e43dedfd53e", "input_wav_sha256": "b14255152d7489e3bac565de7dd342b33e3ef7e5d2c73f00a0d392d54895ca43", "input_pcm_sha256": "f3e6d64faeff6101df2f0a537dad4ae75e5c67f46fa0ef2d393fc9f0d3cb9cbb", "output_wav_sha256": "8b196406eeee3843598f311f91a3b5dceb2ca25d15add9d40046b9d4703c5171", "output_pcm_sha256": "030e7b5b3a8ce5851899b9a0f7efc639f7ac404320f6fb1edba55d38c101fec4", "result_sha256": "f214d634ea4fdaa12e024d31f4279974905445a47cdad7c600931e94bd5f7850" } }, { "id": 200, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f8f0d3c67dd8a5c3ec429d8b2b3218bb6b195534bf5ac4f1a38db7fa8fcd9d6e", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f8f0d3c67dd8a5c3ec429d8b2b3218bb6b195534bf5ac4f1a38db7fa8fcd9d6e", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First, every frequent consumer of Pears soap who is an infrequent user of Mysore soap is not a regular consumer of Purpose soap. Second, being a regular consumer of Purpose soap is necessary for not being a loyal buyer of Colgate-Palmolive soap. Therefore, every infrequent user of Mysore soap who is a frequent consumer of Pears soap is also a loyal buyer of Colgate-Palmolive soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First, every frequent consumer of pear soap who is an infrequent user of mysore soap is not a regular consumer of purpose soap. Second, being a regular consumer of purpose soap is necessary for not being a loyal buyer of Colgate-Palmolive soap. Therefore, every infrequent user of mysore soap soap, who is a frequent consumer of pear soap, is also a loyal buyer of Colgate-Palmolive soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 15794.92, "reasoner_ms": 3469.81, "tts_ms": 32.13, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 19296.88, "total_processing_ms": 20008.78 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1021, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 178 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "54a6e2b6e39c49cdd4d66b69c59adc458b7badf796faaceb55307caf2a1d14cf", "started_sha256": "77299b0c10a1431fb67f9cf3ac12e95be798780509923a7556e3e9cb1227e2e7", "original_grade_sha256": "4910ca247b7be680c2a2406918f4d2d24b5c8287c9bf8ae812d1ad4d34718e6f", "input_original_sha256": "54a6e2b6e39c49cdd4d66b69c59adc458b7badf796faaceb55307caf2a1d14cf", "input_wav_sha256": "975bffe87055bad89a1f4a9133ab46a0c7c12070030ee2b6dc3b0da46db61105", "input_pcm_sha256": "e2c99efb748fa4db28fb99a70c74d372c6fa7eac00b462a6eff8c35388dfe266", "output_wav_sha256": "ca1de04f62cbe309ca5df4a1c915566cd01d39c22b4e25e102bc05024de59894", "output_pcm_sha256": "1f9f0723d5070dee3597eeb1eb8c6e6207b0fbb85f67923f796468151dbef239", "result_sha256": "af51d5f07ca1eb51ea00c58fef3ac5c8b3c9ecd6e67e6d633f8a853cc31caefd" } }, { "id": 456, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "21c8485afe880f64bffa9fc1f9ace89b13433020e6f61dff5c7f1a26cb9a4416", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "21c8485afe880f64bffa9fc1f9ace89b13433020e6f61dff5c7f1a26cb9a4416", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take eight steps. Take nine steps. Turn right. Turn right. Take eight steps. Take nine steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take eight steps. Take nine steps. Turn right. Turn right. Take eight steps. Take nine steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6268.42, "reasoner_ms": 2250.28, "tts_ms": 27.65, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8546.38, "total_processing_ms": 9261.15 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 817, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 78 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "57c14053114db11e60ff488965a19e87d3af31ac99dbd392d0d1134223d76d3e", "started_sha256": "4c864d3705785771be0d29607ad0c34965e0d94bda9e36f67b424c657545c593", "original_grade_sha256": "f2a53985f2ac9e9373f4b4dfb183798b568e3499ab7b45662268822843296af8", "input_original_sha256": "57c14053114db11e60ff488965a19e87d3af31ac99dbd392d0d1134223d76d3e", "input_wav_sha256": "a5fad4f507388cffb1c203956476b83070c9777854700c112f31ab53a6b0e857", "input_pcm_sha256": "d4fa3b711edb82b72eaf520a39b5396bd03a04213cb6b385ca04f4a8bcc7ec8b", "output_wav_sha256": "07258b2b51c2f531a4f4919936d114c79c888c6a3d021125c630247171fc3d29", "output_pcm_sha256": "e3ddfad2ed593293c89d8ba616189dc3516c42bed46c5b54363816f5b574d5e1", "result_sha256": "98aeb5fc7b853e165e914f017a39b46c9657ce3eefa282851b9271cfe060ed9e" } }, { "id": 653, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9cf8a3507f2061c02c9e485e13c941f61803b526b56ff627cbf1f95176dc5e9a", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9cf8a3507f2061c02c9e485e13c941f61803b526b56ff627cbf1f95176dc5e9a", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a plum, a banana, a nectarine, a strawberry, a blackberry, two oranges, a raspberry, and a peach. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a plum, a banana, a nectarine, a strawberry, a blackberry, two oranges, a raspberry, and a peach. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 9.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5695.39, "reasoner_ms": 1900.22, "tts_ms": 28.38, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7624.0, "total_processing_ms": 8459.89 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 793, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 57 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f972b67c6bca61175163a61b42ebb02cdd20ba2ed8265492c0f6a0378aee142e", "started_sha256": "fff7516758713cb5c4d785a5f34bf79fb1f7f1162ac0099e6194fbfea23d35b7", "original_grade_sha256": "0f02e307a195ea969141f82cd8142360f14bf607b142946ca8cd699a914be2a0", "input_original_sha256": "f972b67c6bca61175163a61b42ebb02cdd20ba2ed8265492c0f6a0378aee142e", "input_wav_sha256": "7be8dab12c512572edf330774ed7e602618fd1964025a7a7c20f0caa7b98216f", "input_pcm_sha256": "4ccb0d005182acdadc2e10e8486c87011f70609aa6a03f69834b2fc5673f0b90", "output_wav_sha256": "be8fc3f11fe4eab455a3db3c5d840915b584a0d9af6356c56a246944c3aaa8eb", "output_pcm_sha256": "25490d5e08f2963a136315ac40c410e0cddbfa6562ae49b8d063d22c84c793ce", "result_sha256": "58f84a72836f9593c04663a820944ab8a89c126ad1f339adcdc1cc8c599663cc" } }, { "id": 848, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "859121dfc0d92629ecedc94ed49294f2d2f6827a4de616f08627e68e4b7d0ba4", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "859121dfc0d92629ecedc94ed49294f2d2f6827a4de616f08627e68e4b7d0ba4", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Millicent tells the truth. Alexis says Millicent lies. Jamie says Alexis lies. Willian says Jamie tells the truth. Lida says Willian lies. Does Lida tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion millicent tells the truth alexis says millicent lies jamie says alexis lies willian says jamie tells the truth leda says willian lies does leda tell the truth answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "That answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9035.49, "reasoner_ms": 2161.18, "tts_ms": 23.61, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11220.31, "total_processing_ms": 11890.5 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 818, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 112 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b945632686cac4726a001d80d5826cee832b9551f351a04c95446aaec3c5a46a", "started_sha256": "5b46ceb4e28baac3c13b561f3af482c7372613d82d266781b77b4c7bac2c75cd", "original_grade_sha256": "54192aaa675b675f823376c35aef68d31fd2802a6547c7b50afd4a136479b941", "input_original_sha256": "b945632686cac4726a001d80d5826cee832b9551f351a04c95446aaec3c5a46a", "input_wav_sha256": "74fac16cd73ef6c29a2fabebdcb9249dd0cb14552afb2752cd995a286d9e7a2e", "input_pcm_sha256": "2ba20feced0c3de1b9d903dc8fc8c092b43c9607aa135cf39f771ec2e5d67219", "output_wav_sha256": "5e4596610ec1f5b13b09aba8dc08e99bdc7568503446abc7ba0ecf8d3d187e28", "output_pcm_sha256": "8467c249c596fd2cc5681af1c52e29c20354d927dece8e1669ff373da3a3624f", "result_sha256": "b66248386eb33bc2034e985e1a1503fd78a71f1f99c2f40c259dd5cb2448a584" } }, { "id": 11, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "93665763001015528ccc95a30478d10d43b956fdc1cd3c6fa5c0634d111f7a5d", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "93665763001015528ccc95a30478d10d43b956fdc1cd3c6fa5c0634d111f7a5d", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, being a rare consumer of Nubian Heritage soap is necessary for being an owner of a Lever soap. Second, being an infrequent user of American Crew shampoo is sufficient for being a rare consumer of Nubian Heritage soap. In consequence, every infrequent user of American Crew shampoo is an owner of a Lever soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, being a rare consumer of Nubian heritage soap is necessary for being an owner of a lever soap. Second, being an infrequent user of American crew shampoo is sufficient for being a rare consumer of Nubian heritage soap. In consequence, every infrequent user of American crew shampoo is an owner of a lever soap. soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12868.91, "reasoner_ms": 2805.98, "tts_ms": 29.34, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15704.26, "total_processing_ms": 16535.39 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1017, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 129 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0ead0137a6f40cf60817afe9c5813d8fbbb1a0686b1f02f7cbdd15667c1afd87", "started_sha256": "87490c1501c9a25a29ef21916db238b34c5adacfed4b8d51a3104004a5e343c5", "original_grade_sha256": "7ce2ac394ec39d4e741cbfb94ff40abef0b8b1e29e8f0508b29b2947b17fab09", "input_original_sha256": "0ead0137a6f40cf60817afe9c5813d8fbbb1a0686b1f02f7cbdd15667c1afd87", "input_wav_sha256": "aca31bec58f6d592685045512343b192f81b1f872d782fe07e4b636241367c18", "input_pcm_sha256": "44aee29de66e8ded06b3672fe61646a6f5d5fa46264f088c50d15855ba76945d", "output_wav_sha256": "b9a95d19648cd6e19bc5a15a69c847dc22c3e6032cb02989b33e59fc17da9ab0", "output_pcm_sha256": "cfadf0c73ebfa6d64c9ad92baa7a204c0e9bba79295aab677e8e2cfd5f730680", "result_sha256": "244b71f9db94e0bd0672a26410286b24dce7e8c19f6887e1cb75a41c0bba31f0" } }, { "id": 388, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1097f2d8184d088d7374dfd39f66c87612c2d346f7052e89c7256479d132e7fc", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1097f2d8184d088d7374dfd39f66c87612c2d346f7052e89c7256479d132e7fc", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take one step right. Take four steps forward. Take eight steps forward. Take six steps backward. Take one step left. Take six steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point always face forward take one step right take four steps forward take eight steps forward take six steps backward take one step left take six steps right options yes no answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8011.59, "reasoner_ms": 2637.87, "tts_ms": 23.39, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10672.88, "total_processing_ms": 11197.33 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 826, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 113 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "aabd44ab4688620cb507da4c312ad33f30ab40491595fcc638d992c8e6662358", "started_sha256": "bf54e989629b03ecd2dc0145ceefe12ff2c04a76eba6c880bfa173936102db3e", "original_grade_sha256": "98c70f586d3a3f7457f53f290c2e42d42d0f20f9e22a69ae397110efce8c3943", "input_original_sha256": "aabd44ab4688620cb507da4c312ad33f30ab40491595fcc638d992c8e6662358", "input_wav_sha256": "50140946087eb6660d8f3ed6e9e519e93719b8eee437f1caeac5abe1ac299b24", "input_pcm_sha256": "b94fd38902f22381525ae8932525e7edb623a30aced4bce0d1366ac592f92c31", "output_wav_sha256": "2894a5ffc324c3485f03461b0a265fb05079468a13c7af54846850d24fe3a1e3", "output_pcm_sha256": "5a3f6edc1671239755a0e750c14feed2a4030e028b945cf6fe9f5926e91bbceb", "result_sha256": "900d643d8dd955db8a5b6740b1db6e0d129b6cf65086e58bd944eac6bf38dcc5" } }, { "id": 534, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "2", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dfdd5e6a43dcad050665ac879495c10b49e98ee70704cb34bddf12f0f92b713f", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dfdd5e6a43dcad050665ac879495c10b49e98ee70704cb34bddf12f0f92b713f", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a flute and an accordion. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a flute and an accordion. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 2.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 3409.54, "reasoner_ms": 1913.54, "tts_ms": 24.67, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5347.78, "total_processing_ms": 5823.23 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 732, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "96bf4317876b0b594dceb95713c01b5a5d3fb165ac85ce68760eb8e8b7f6074f", "started_sha256": "86d0272190c07af419183dd701991528a66452191fb35fc30e692d128868d285", "original_grade_sha256": "0d82be7a89503b0972cd972f4c1e0491656f1163a0a4d5bd63c4a86ad00be848", "input_original_sha256": "96bf4317876b0b594dceb95713c01b5a5d3fb165ac85ce68760eb8e8b7f6074f", "input_wav_sha256": "9f784a273ae6c73e1d475fd446a9038140d3a6674ef5e05fb16dea4f13b95700", "input_pcm_sha256": "4ed23999182924570866deb1412abc1c03a91fa4c46dd0b5d0cda97e7f104ae6", "output_wav_sha256": "a975091de77873e15063d1da086ab77f40e1456e8a8df2c8c370131f69387359", "output_pcm_sha256": "8bb322df526347515f6cd6fb3a77fae1dc69e74e7f52a7050b37146e02a94b2d", "result_sha256": "767b1a3062396f37e636bb0a100b0ef22e8fa213681993fdf977f9edd4bd0f12" } }, { "id": 763, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "93083e3e02fdb3a91d9cd0dc271ba7c02862cf9858355e0aeac14b173b3f2ce9", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "93083e3e02fdb3a91d9cd0dc271ba7c02862cf9858355e0aeac14b173b3f2ce9", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Inga tells the truth. Shenna says Inga lies. Rashida says Shenna tells the truth. Ka says Rashida tells the truth. Shalanda says Ka tells the truth. Does Shalanda tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Inga tells the truth. Shena says Inga lies. Rashida says Shena tells the truth. Ka says Rashida tells the truth. Shalanda says Ka tells the truth. Does Shalanda tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5332.34, "reasoner_ms": 2344.97, "tts_ms": 22.93, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7700.26, "total_processing_ms": 8257.32 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 846, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 118 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "7416398261a8fdc49df7da534b833a7cc4b8cdf3bb23c2075411d351c9f7d4c4", "started_sha256": "b060a45691fe0f2ec6d24ccf063af07edc07dfd284c57b18091db0631d106ac6", "original_grade_sha256": "e22233aea497b51b101c12a055ab8730dfea139e3ed9a8e9957b3fa6fce41a39", "input_original_sha256": "7416398261a8fdc49df7da534b833a7cc4b8cdf3bb23c2075411d351c9f7d4c4", "input_wav_sha256": "3c8ff5fae0b188c872854ed6b88ec66182303666788d765517083a486964155f", "input_pcm_sha256": "d96935cdc8d308f8da4fe218ad0bc90a44f181b4624b310e00419a9cc660cd68", "output_wav_sha256": "4a7a887a74f5404ffb6e88d296ed27c66c014c86eb1a3b5ab15b8e22530522cd", "output_pcm_sha256": "8c70a99a4c1064b5e6104a618fd828e4ac9dd49d8ed500a468dcf331cef921d1", "result_sha256": "7fe38f47aa52c1620d91c687c66459475b24badcbfd71243395a886596479533" } }, { "id": 212, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "450bbe79688da8862813d6e50305f7d0f1fd73b840ffb3dcfa69ba7aa8d88d3c", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "450bbe79688da8862813d6e50305f7d0f1fd73b840ffb3dcfa69ba7aa8d88d3c", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. Not being an ingredient of eyeshadow gold is sufficient for not being an ingredient of Real Fit lipstick nine. Being an ingredient of Real Fit lipstick nine is necessary for being an ingredient of zero five Lightening Touch. Therefore, every ingredient of zero five Lightening Touch is an ingredient of eyeshadow gold. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument, not being an ingredient of eyeshadow, gold, is sufficient for not being an ingredient of real fit lipstick 9. Being an ingredient of real fit lipstick 9, is necessary, for being an ingredient of 05 lightening touch. Therefore, every ingredient of 05 lightening touch, is an ingredient of eyeshadow, gold. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options Valid Invalid Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11724.08, "reasoner_ms": 2574.73, "tts_ms": 31.37, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 14330.21, "total_processing_ms": 15037.88 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1027, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 110 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "91928e179d869c2fdd3211a22d2c45b0e53c7afee0bd60d8478a8a3d7929e1f2", "started_sha256": "e35b64e819267f6adc042497cbfd93203c6b60e454f90dbf34b897758780d771", "original_grade_sha256": "6ec15c948ad85d0527ff01164f2982eaa867b79aa025349d0a23da9989aa8c0f", "input_original_sha256": "91928e179d869c2fdd3211a22d2c45b0e53c7afee0bd60d8478a8a3d7929e1f2", "input_wav_sha256": "86f5a28ae0fb77d7e733c022c59008912e323d729ff787d62bcae6060b73a5d0", "input_pcm_sha256": "beab1c77e573c379a069c15163a43a18dbaf408954d08989f99db21d6344ee59", "output_wav_sha256": "141a8b3431cc89e340069bec31ba739b1ba4916e64e0e0431462f314ba51b90a", "output_pcm_sha256": "673506459bf61451b5780dba81867e39aeb92ed773aa4e4f502f90d10c703ead", "result_sha256": "6a5d25bd1db6dafcd5713222344db85a205f8a6c4eff6af64b96c5d95c32383d" } }, { "id": 300, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e6eb549edc5e627e11251159b7d90f71570bd959244fb73cbcb9473e154dfc15", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e6eb549edc5e627e11251159b7d90f71570bd959244fb73cbcb9473e154dfc15", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take ten steps. Take seven steps. Turn around. Take eight steps. Take nine steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take 10 steps. Take 7 steps. Turn around. Take 8 steps. Take 9 steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6172.41, "reasoner_ms": 1896.37, "tts_ms": 28.39, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8097.21, "total_processing_ms": 8701.96 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 811, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 39 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5ef2c83255bae797603751b044bf8d95662599f3f206c587535c1a86d2ee50a8", "started_sha256": "2dca84233189cec9798cd7a447395b82dacf6f4a434872454cb9750fcaa72423", "original_grade_sha256": "9d6b59e1d2be30ef3bd578d530189eb5791b8401c1aa55219c4656e43c318e20", "input_original_sha256": "5ef2c83255bae797603751b044bf8d95662599f3f206c587535c1a86d2ee50a8", "input_wav_sha256": "d180b3137470a4fe1b82767f55c9caebaf6106eaeb36a105d21dbf98d66c4521", "input_pcm_sha256": "1d4a257c004ab13e0406b81bfcb83368080c1a6d995fb7e88de301f37a8808b4", "output_wav_sha256": "6f47bd08393e2345f31a3fc3edf265956e856c652e7a8f8c60660d03f284c04b", "output_pcm_sha256": "1dff08017bde36aae682ac911b7e63b9f824f0a306f22f88a58787ba8b6cc04b", "result_sha256": "cad8d25a6b8c2d87dadc0e3bb94911450725bb06cbcadc96601f8d9a1f24567b" } }, { "id": 717, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "3", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "588eb5aa87a2882c19e56616dc44ba8f972179245890228172134104d8a0e1b6", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "588eb5aa87a2882c19e56616dc44ba8f972179245890228172134104d8a0e1b6", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a toaster, a car, and a table. How many objects do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a toaster, a car, and a table. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 3.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4459.74, "reasoner_ms": 1397.76, "tts_ms": 25.74, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5883.25, "total_processing_ms": 6514.09 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 731, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "49201aab0b3a4de922a7e3c446a02b023aa3ca8227ab88c53c924e1d2797a2f9", "started_sha256": "41a06ba6b124348d52cc5549f82322f78e0474054f8734f392711c3def72510b", "original_grade_sha256": "2d0440ed65d4b996eda66b3ac6a967b8c47baca058b228d01df57435504299ec", "input_original_sha256": "49201aab0b3a4de922a7e3c446a02b023aa3ca8227ab88c53c924e1d2797a2f9", "input_wav_sha256": "cbd3813d761e3d86e9ac19656c286f7ca99ad2fc74285b6c3e65a26b103383f9", "input_pcm_sha256": "2d445cf2051c9b6fa93a176e5a6d681278159deaed83c58e1c4561a1373b83cc", "output_wav_sha256": "a6e4568e4e3b0bcf46386b50030b62627d9cb1a15cd7fd964a0c4bc5caea50bd", "output_pcm_sha256": "7f597f916623ea73b6ed49ab550e6f233fb17c083c025229cb2481d542bc12d9", "result_sha256": "c2441871b94632f1f3a9da6b689e3d4358358a3ec02e3b7d83babd7206e9a09d" } }, { "id": 768, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "73515b211ad270fb32776627f6eeec04add85611cdb040b1be0850d295394dba", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "73515b211ad270fb32776627f6eeec04add85611cdb040b1be0850d295394dba", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Shalonda tells the truth. Alexis says Shalonda tells the truth. Christie says Alexis lies. Inga says Christie tells the truth. Krista says Inga tells the truth. Does Krista tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion, Shalonda tells the truth. Alexis says Shalonda tells the truth. Christy says Alexis lies. Inga says Christy tells the truth. Krista says Inga tells the truth. Does Krista tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7914.23, "reasoner_ms": 2488.61, "tts_ms": 25.18, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10428.05, "total_processing_ms": 11115.32 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 843, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 122 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "bcaa08ea0a2d37b94b55e7012a852b76d0382bc5e18fdec167051cb9a0d6390f", "started_sha256": "877b3541da215fa66ef945fd75fe004aaf3892b264c150cc31fe227b40e71e57", "original_grade_sha256": "e6ebc5d71f560ebe7cf52fc33f8d0b56fa989d86057edb7d31b3ac091a561cf4", "input_original_sha256": "bcaa08ea0a2d37b94b55e7012a852b76d0382bc5e18fdec167051cb9a0d6390f", "input_wav_sha256": "f0ae75d2074c3dd0ea3f3a545b79a9721de167468ddcc62c9ab06f1074994bf0", "input_pcm_sha256": "f87d1a1a055cf140da5b731e7082250bef35b9509c9739993ecf297ab818cd14", "output_wav_sha256": "b8dfa6306dd76469ea175e7332299dbd52e6aefa3c1ac677aa081c2671ae48a5", "output_pcm_sha256": "34bd821a4f1bb37bb3f5eab01cf1318fa6cbe0a7620efd5b28d3b13ec4df14ae", "result_sha256": "3404b5ba543da16e308a76ff7ef1ced60a59233b46ce807dab3e0e73f80be47c" } }, { "id": 79, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7226c847a36bd52c413393121a5d91aba9638ac2f5e72f21875a20c18817bc04", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7226c847a36bd52c413393121a5d91aba9638ac2f5e72f21875a20c18817bc04", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First premise, Oliver is not a regular user of Organix hair shampoo. Second premise, everyone who is not both a regular user of Organix hair shampoo and a rare consumer of Purpose soap is however a loyal buyer of Kiss My Face soap. We may conclude that Oliver is a loyal buyer of Kiss My Face soap. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First premise, Oliver is not a regular user of organics hair shampoo. Second premise, everyone who is not both a regular user of organics hair shampoo and a rare consumer of purpose soap is however a loyal buyer of Kiss My Face soap. We may conclude that Oliver is a loyal buyer of Kiss My Face soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14191.41, "reasoner_ms": 2936.34, "tts_ms": 27.33, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17155.1, "total_processing_ms": 17905.5 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1071, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 135 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "4bc8bd777d401e09ef213450d7d725bfb617150918a1b033d68faaf8e014d434", "started_sha256": "b4e6fcca5217386df18f1e0de1c51f5d72956878652467b7d6d6d2c201d4e22f", "original_grade_sha256": "3471dd1fc90b1d502e250977a83803e1a5b243d3bfe723dda18aba0c41b8015b", "input_original_sha256": "4bc8bd777d401e09ef213450d7d725bfb617150918a1b033d68faaf8e014d434", "input_wav_sha256": "c3c06aaab8cb96f4a07a099e9457dc73a5eb4371e782b9515e22213e4f2a0e21", "input_pcm_sha256": "35b7a4d8afdd9afef059c10cc07b94718df2d44136a4fd6866340626b3589023", "output_wav_sha256": "0f0953925349d4114d65c5e3b1959d3749442fe5ef5dc8b3b26ab8f3d4b08cb1", "output_pcm_sha256": "a7cebacc5b3ee6ae2824fa3aab500cfcdbe89e99d9263750e2951044f5c242c5", "result_sha256": "b5c58dfcfac1ad3324e93368c33ccc1b0d20b87b68451fb2a9975f31a98d6dd6" } }, { "id": 310, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8b46decaea30a05ff7648758087d2955673da7e776044badd5fb41f499bd13f0", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8b46decaea30a05ff7648758087d2955673da7e776044badd5fb41f499bd13f0", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps. Take two steps. Take six steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point take six steps take two steps take six steps options yes no answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "That answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9847.93, "reasoner_ms": 1856.5, "tts_ms": 35.29, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11739.76, "total_processing_ms": 12349.11 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 764, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 40 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ee82b2f155a985795021dd1532cd9e37c2743ab4c06ff18aa2a66708491d331e", "started_sha256": "c53e0c257f4a36cae9461e2031edd2c92009daea6d9c6aa2b1e6d1b963fda44e", "original_grade_sha256": "a3d57bed3f0d592906ba8465a82bbecfb7ed1b5170ed47c8192ec5ec0efb0f6b", "input_original_sha256": "ee82b2f155a985795021dd1532cd9e37c2743ab4c06ff18aa2a66708491d331e", "input_wav_sha256": "55415420a03ea5c1c71340725f34de8560bd9c00d154252d1740cb6ff4999c2a", "input_pcm_sha256": "4851a703bd481b581525f4547a96b47cd4bda7ae89b419c58c02bc5ef73060e1", "output_wav_sha256": "2477820349323ea231578967c3ee4a2dada3607687e4f75af4dbf8602663cd88", "output_pcm_sha256": "2d13a1dd35b369df57feccfb8da70dbb7a29c746b20c824969994193b33efcef", "result_sha256": "efc90f54bda93ed13d6618d20de090092b6a3ad53c289b75f6a080e2cff126d8" } }, { "id": 714, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "10", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dafbbd9492984f608679873905d1ebcfd6a8e89789b5a19732e8b26c947cdb1c", "normalized_answer": "10" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dafbbd9492984f608679873905d1ebcfd6a8e89789b5a19732e8b26c947cdb1c", "normalized_answer": "10" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a table, a yam, a cauliflower, two cabbages, a head of broccoli, two potatoes, an onion, and two garlics. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a table a yam a cauliflower two cabbages a head of broccoli two potatoes an onion and two garlics how many vegetables do i have answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 10.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8407.59, "reasoner_ms": 2065.46, "tts_ms": 40.17, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10513.24, "total_processing_ms": 11231.74 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 791, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 78 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "218518511861be17054aee81dda78877a58cc0a2b8111bb0ae95440c2cfe82c2", "started_sha256": "d3aef7d5595e2bd885f5a97fa79b8e4c8a1161de1a38684dc0cc17c13ed542fb", "original_grade_sha256": "c85a9cdac29af25cb1cacf9b00cb0ae31576eb213ab8681b984441a80cb6a34d", "input_original_sha256": "218518511861be17054aee81dda78877a58cc0a2b8111bb0ae95440c2cfe82c2", "input_wav_sha256": "60d5e7b3076cf00c7a90e048063ab0cd9268ab49af173d9dc1e2cff52e828d2c", "input_pcm_sha256": "d8fae55734f906e1391139a7e7815d5261e76b72a40411a996ad00f1a48f3380", "output_wav_sha256": "c796f2ccfd8b0c9a885b7b9bd7b93e05f15500a676b9db568560242c850e7c86", "output_pcm_sha256": "f90618e7f3827054f846c87616462554a1ddd2fcf931a4c583c19d6f043218ef", "result_sha256": "3b8c9b9ee8ea282039c712189261aa92be8283274d9bd97a36281ec196473d1e" } }, { "id": 833, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0ba1b51a6527c5bf6e79d7c4405ea10fffb4cacecb20e50a15eb6bb7569a3138", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0ba1b51a6527c5bf6e79d7c4405ea10fffb4cacecb20e50a15eb6bb7569a3138", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Teresa lies. Willian says Teresa lies. Jamie says Willian lies. Ryan says Jamie lies. Candy says Ryan lies. Does Candy tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Teresa lies. William says Teresa lies. Jamie says William lies. Ryan says Jamie lies. Candy says Ryan lies. Does Candy tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5819.39, "reasoner_ms": 2574.47, "tts_ms": 24.3, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8418.19, "total_processing_ms": 9185.09 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 815, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 134 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f961aa04f266391280df8aebe72469d014646b8b220438120bb2bba0fee6c330", "started_sha256": "98dec8b6885e6dce07c9c7d34834700a3fee7d1ba2024fdbf4997eba7ad76b27", "original_grade_sha256": "f91a25f81c4153300ad20f5f7f96b99cb46713712558da92337e9cb6c4b97ba3", "input_original_sha256": "f961aa04f266391280df8aebe72469d014646b8b220438120bb2bba0fee6c330", "input_wav_sha256": "fdbfe5685fc3444b89e510c5caef394d8aac8c2c987b1bf9757fab9a7f96833c", "input_pcm_sha256": "bd3892cb183ff7ba920c4ba4f3bb080ebf7c89e8a59e9bf4d3776dc95765bd65", "output_wav_sha256": "a704f68bafb081e17490a560d54d90b5ed3d058fad5ef6dad3dab43d1b6b86eb", "output_pcm_sha256": "6f7eaa747e49cd8b865eed010f055a4a9e2a86d3a67d7ce7ad4a53acdf564bbe", "result_sha256": "a1849f134dca605b68b2c1dd74a27510e50e8d6e07b35ecdee771f8c15ccca96" } }, { "id": 73, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "acbb8de2e8e627a88f2842c6de5fcf191164e09d27f3d48d0ec849fa33afe777", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "acbb8de2e8e627a88f2842c6de5fcf191164e09d27f3d48d0ec849fa33afe777", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, being an ex-fan of Uralsk is necessary for being a member of SK Rapid Wien. Next, some supporter of Osterchens FK is not an ex-fan of Uralsk. It follows that somebody is a supporter of Osterchens FK and not a member of SK Rapid Wien. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, being an ex-fan of VRLCF is necessary for being a member of SK RapidVine. Next, some supporter of Ostersen's FK is not an ex-fan of VRLCF. It follows that somebody is a supporter of Ostersen's FK and not a member of SK RapidVine. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid? Invalid? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12536.32, "reasoner_ms": 3328.54, "tts_ms": 29.22, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15894.11, "total_processing_ms": 16676.77 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 992, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 172 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "17aa3fb88079b4cda2cc85fca5a72aff5c794b4270c386ac9ad06d305196b0d6", "started_sha256": "9ca5231134d2f1bee384ea8cd8c2a3655a01abf039642bbbdae02fb85010e8f6", "original_grade_sha256": "dd54395319a15a8d24ba2b9ea2b621dee7c6b6e4e5508e8202e7c769f93f612d", "input_original_sha256": "17aa3fb88079b4cda2cc85fca5a72aff5c794b4270c386ac9ad06d305196b0d6", "input_wav_sha256": "bfddbb050292bd1472e91108283a448c4d8e5297798f5d3fbc4cebf957778a9b", "input_pcm_sha256": "02792677534f150c98db063615363b44447643f74c135bf97cf973b6568d1d70", "output_wav_sha256": "10bbae976ac204428a865659759cd5fcc08ec414c6bba3df296b839f385c7134", "output_pcm_sha256": "8087895719ccb7402dba3c6bc1483f0e336d323117b365e63be87169b3079102", "result_sha256": "e933aaf463ea1926ab9bda671858a6bd5605fdb634a8d30f0df942ee4fa6fb17" } }, { "id": 372, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "58a82d5095ab3964fa0b1e66030adc2c40b1408c2d6ad9bcce5613f2d76cd053", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "58a82d5095ab3964fa0b1e66030adc2c40b1408c2d6ad9bcce5613f2d76cd053", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left. Turn left. Turn around. Take one step. Take six steps. Turn left. Turn left. Take seven steps. Options: Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point turn left turn left turn around take one step take six steps turn left turn left take seven steps options yes no answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5479.54, "reasoner_ms": 5911.14, "tts_ms": 26.78, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11417.48, "total_processing_ms": 12180.72 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 802, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 132 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "529793b65fc26ee4ba9cf13d8d60b8b69d622336a14cf07e76a4060fd3448cca", "started_sha256": "ff0fd6f7b8bc83cdf3cea3db3ac007891f43f5b55d03fa58ec21629b54e59e15", "original_grade_sha256": "ffc801645ce96e2d3038e312522d9b9bb2817ada4fdc02d5df9725e2313ca4c5", "input_original_sha256": "529793b65fc26ee4ba9cf13d8d60b8b69d622336a14cf07e76a4060fd3448cca", "input_wav_sha256": "5f4e9e08f6aa6355e5a934467b6f91b31efd81a5e0b73bcbd8da09077f00a4f7", "input_pcm_sha256": "1fd34982f2dd32d1d5d4d4a17120bee0d95a29699ee48bdc33468d87c19d472e", "output_wav_sha256": "ae88186b601b00395df8a1e92c470529ac0163ec41c6bdcc420f6b17e191a4c6", "output_pcm_sha256": "5b322b4f16a99d89a96a157b2b34d45b811940435dc093a97a7144553e9fd032", "result_sha256": "b4bd453a6c5dae38e633b11cfd8a280fe549cf3227ecd4ab9440690f9a420d5a" } }, { "id": 660, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "6", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0b5ebbd537d3c8aeee93d3b5c6281d3628607db693448e812e68ce29ae3e3869", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0b5ebbd537d3c8aeee93d3b5c6281d3628607db693448e812e68ce29ae3e3869", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a banana, a raspberry, a strawberry, a plum, a blackberry, and a grape. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a banana, a raspberry, a strawberry, a plum, a blackberry, and a grape. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 6.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5187.17, "reasoner_ms": 1455.62, "tts_ms": 25.58, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6668.4, "total_processing_ms": 7385.0 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 772, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 39 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "dbd23b1f0a7c016a67e28c88673467af788578f6390a944b4844c04d5ad24877", "started_sha256": "9ab391a66eb7f08f61536aabb7943a7d5d371ed3ba1fb9cf94505e4a60f89cdb", "original_grade_sha256": "d406d8d06efc9beff36142466a4fdf6d720458e6fb9c69866b42e4666b2da441", "input_original_sha256": "dbd23b1f0a7c016a67e28c88673467af788578f6390a944b4844c04d5ad24877", "input_wav_sha256": "529b1fd901fee12eef7b87b92bd406f90c3b01e5e85258eabca421372f3360dc", "input_pcm_sha256": "7ae93e836b45fe93aabe203b6809dc233b9a7095d9c5c8e7f1853a89e65f6bb6", "output_wav_sha256": "b49dc2b764ca5c6dd6dab216496abd41f08f59f37facfa3e0fadc9346438c00b", "output_pcm_sha256": "5701712c7f2d3ba5471dfa363da7a476952d9d4127e7f5b7adf3c10a628fc70c", "result_sha256": "d2a07fac042ccac81ad99cb66c3613564aa8d70c2164c89da60e0e9f0ed6ed8c" } }, { "id": 836, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1f1abdcda46f3e1e9f01adb9dd6e9cc5aa89bcd0964fdac8fe15098570cd6664", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1f1abdcda46f3e1e9f01adb9dd6e9cc5aa89bcd0964fdac8fe15098570cd6664", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Jamie lies. Raymond says Jamie lies. KA says Raymond lies. Bonita says KA tells the truth. Teresa says Bonita lies. Does Teresa tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Jamie lies. Raymond says Jamie lies. K.A. says Raymond lies. Benita says K.A. tells the truth. Teresa says Benita lies. Does Teresa tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5786.08, "reasoner_ms": 2205.96, "tts_ms": 25.3, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8017.36, "total_processing_ms": 8778.57 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 827, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 112 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a04b4631432d26c0c5275434d227917a812ecc01e21cf0e996392e7168c046fb", "started_sha256": "4d7cc1ff2ac0f2f19ca318af2e248370c281cd1ce70cbd74957600207a0498e1", "original_grade_sha256": "8101b80006fe87fe262c73cf80811b57f3e2905857ede00a6491ebef4dcea8e3", "input_original_sha256": "a04b4631432d26c0c5275434d227917a812ecc01e21cf0e996392e7168c046fb", "input_wav_sha256": "19b2dd2365097ed645dca30739daae6f477e207adb254c0beb95588f9c6c540d", "input_pcm_sha256": "65d127a2f8fb852455466dbad43305dd615332e6d896dd4214a9ea6add5da9af", "output_wav_sha256": "ecf0249bbde2bfccff2afaf10a8b59958fe1618950f0cff2f050becb3f2dd7a9", "output_pcm_sha256": "5101ec31dc4eeb9daea72b20eb643780ddfbda8951570150e978aa48720b5ca8", "result_sha256": "399d88b2059c4a1b5e89f1e2a0cae448978d3954b9a9b341428ada3f708fd23d" } }, { "id": 147, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1a14c54ffe13981c55163b2fe08617c531bcf1cb43c601a2ee4be83b626b99ad", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1a14c54ffe13981c55163b2fe08617c531bcf1cb43c601a2ee4be83b626b99ad", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, nobody is neither an owner of The Body Shop soap nor a frequent consumer of Lush soap. So necessarily, nobody is neither a frequent consumer of Lush soap nor an owner of The Body Shop soap. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, nobody is neither an owner of the body shop soap nor a frequent consumer of lush soap. So, necessarily, nobody is neither a frequent consumer of lush soap nor an owner of the body shop soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8079.84, "reasoner_ms": 2412.33, "tts_ms": 26.21, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10518.41, "total_processing_ms": 11253.06 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 936, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 110 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "4e0556c0bfc5175d0e799a81d590628287f5973590ff0540ca0186018b4f5303", "started_sha256": "845906a908e072631176424639d84ab9c3e6fd760c743441069d6487bd11d846", "original_grade_sha256": "3f2f17274092d68d6f9d5baa97d27cce12deb9fa87191dc90e9707927d9d3ef8", "input_original_sha256": "4e0556c0bfc5175d0e799a81d590628287f5973590ff0540ca0186018b4f5303", "input_wav_sha256": "10d12cca92fde81568544e603068adc81491880407d10cbfbcc971874959952e", "input_pcm_sha256": "b9d715a6f9de74b036b726a8a04e992628729d9584f809b577f61ed1e80771c4", "output_wav_sha256": "168305bb9b8f23b76b48548803f99a7a2f76718f616ca0917bdd597fb8480e4b", "output_pcm_sha256": "9024f3d7458c3b8dacd75787bd28137c2e782077f8df2c6c92517e66c9ef305f", "result_sha256": "ddad5f998c438662224101b0c8522d9d2cb37ab07d80ef34557fad103ee779db" } }, { "id": 293, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b3668acee6afe4ba051ba6e50293ca66b40faaaed4e41efbd7ee95fad53b75f8", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b3668acee6afe4ba051ba6e50293ca66b40faaaed4e41efbd7ee95fad53b75f8", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps. Take eight steps. Take seven steps. Turn around. Take six steps. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take six steps. Take eight steps. Take seven steps. Turn around. Take six steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6662.68, "reasoner_ms": 1803.45, "tts_ms": 24.71, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8490.88, "total_processing_ms": 9217.49 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 804, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 54 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b395d2ad2c4a1c550cea3f60b32557e5af964cad799c57678ef7bf54d6f31706", "started_sha256": "10cd02432a751151e46516696f2551544b5729efef6149f8d107c3107ef5b4f5", "original_grade_sha256": "aeb446e3d6f2ea22ba5da50cd0668855a2e89d327d365cef3c65783ca8742baf", "input_original_sha256": "b395d2ad2c4a1c550cea3f60b32557e5af964cad799c57678ef7bf54d6f31706", "input_wav_sha256": "8b085c9cdd65492b1e6b9a0ee1d76b2689cbb7103c67cfe1880a55789150a122", "input_pcm_sha256": "b4f0a9a5f2bd3c6f7ba88b6b62d5399bf35d1427be83aa343fbef50301b99fa9", "output_wav_sha256": "d813409d92a0c58a62af00db0553542e666f29ec9a3562c4da75f7cc15ec757a", "output_pcm_sha256": "c4ba2c502034dd086aeca3f0bccb66cd69b409b0d9ad08e1caded9cade98701d", "result_sha256": "2a0f04bd7068bdb60475d6d033f4a781645fb307648dc92eb344e63aa4d1feed" } }, { "id": 598, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "2", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9b170411180ad81b17fbad2bfad3dd5d06acabdefe77025c34f84fb697f7e34d", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9b170411180ad81b17fbad2bfad3dd5d06acabdefe77025c34f84fb697f7e34d", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a peach, three cats, and a raspberry. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a peach, three cats and a raspberry. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 2.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4861.45, "reasoner_ms": 1990.06, "tts_ms": 25.23, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6876.76, "total_processing_ms": 7563.83 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 739, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 37 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "163c1e5016131afdc161b9b68820406d79a9ddbb314bf7fba853354aa14e51e0", "started_sha256": "13d457127bc3ade2d2d31bf9ef242f35bb624caf3826a8453597cbb73918aa09", "original_grade_sha256": "542f217f93c509e76c5232e9364541df4b33f21b59f7f0256595afcd61457b2b", "input_original_sha256": "163c1e5016131afdc161b9b68820406d79a9ddbb314bf7fba853354aa14e51e0", "input_wav_sha256": "4b05903f1ee8387d0f9dca0e90052d0ee69eaa316ded2e95733425c898def194", "input_pcm_sha256": "6711608d5ae1e93df9980df8575e02f31bfab17b783d9b6dc8512b94d3656cb6", "output_wav_sha256": "7953bb9bacbbe4c3c0b2a4246d34fbe32e145d74ab9e17200af8259bdcdc45ac", "output_pcm_sha256": "140990c0e7ba8d1a0fa6872665861bfd2ade1bd6911182827630844f05dca7a1", "result_sha256": "55376470b3cf3cb8d8db29d934c4b577088c18c374fa56f720c124183b26c6cc" } }, { "id": 996, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d5f56beba021e8426ef996c4126a15a244d146d2357dc180ae2ff04cfcdc3b4a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d5f56beba021e8426ef996c4126a15a244d146d2357dc180ae2ff04cfcdc3b4a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Gwen lies. Maybel says Gwen tells the truth. Raymond says Maybel tells the truth. Jamie says Raymond tells the truth. Andre says Jamie lies. Does Andre tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nGwen lies. Mabel says Gwen tells the truth. Raymond says Mabel tells the truth. Jamie says Raymond tells the truth. Andre says Jamie lies. Does Andre tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6353.91, "reasoner_ms": 2231.24, "tts_ms": 20.31, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8605.49, "total_processing_ms": 9390.19 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 838, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 112 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8e55ef4236bd8b4ac5b18e90cb1e6c8bf9d01983b75673f739c12b3339e55265", "started_sha256": "082ba6b779089533d35204b9e0f0e2a441c9ab3af926ddb1a850ba61bd58377d", "original_grade_sha256": "713a5a6eec877de2da46fa878e971b25c5e4f3c256e6fbd88456bb430f1088c2", "input_original_sha256": "8e55ef4236bd8b4ac5b18e90cb1e6c8bf9d01983b75673f739c12b3339e55265", "input_wav_sha256": "57203035ca34b25fd6041bf0747fc97fa011cc110bf1000bf45f84baf207f0bb", "input_pcm_sha256": "a66bfc27c050b8d35174e937fc35728a457c3c0e2e43372df38e7a73dc693764", "output_wav_sha256": "9ab51838f34f0db3165f7e059ee8ecdbca4f9e46b38292db3e32467f521582f3", "output_pcm_sha256": "3ee614c5d1b3ae417dd3e936f0a48292d2e15e6767ce6983c6236dcdd1346c88", "result_sha256": "8b10d286a96b4e7132864151a61bc8e5fe9a1eeb8fbf51313e05f076fa367a15" } }, { "id": 80, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b407c5aecc3c626f5a487f49dd10649e9d795637aaa7da26bf1d30ef554e16a9", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b407c5aecc3c626f5a487f49dd10649e9d795637aaa7da26bf1d30ef554e16a9", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Siri a stepsister of Mary? Is Susan related to Kate? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. Whoever is not a workmate of Hilda is a stepsister of Heather. Every workmate of Hilda is either a stepsister of Heather or an aunt of Clara, or both. We may conclude being an aunt of Clara is necessary for being a workmate of Hilda. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Ciri a stepsister of Mary? Is Susan related to Kate? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. Whoever is not a workmate of Hilda is a stepsister of Heather. Every workmate of Hilda is either a stepsister of Heather or an aunt of Clara, or both. We may conclude, being an aunt of Clara is necessary for being a workmate of Hilda. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid? Invalid? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13825.03, "reasoner_ms": 3127.22, "tts_ms": 33.49, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 16985.76, "total_processing_ms": 17778.0 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 982, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 162 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b196be3a64e746d0bb8e8bbdd79d44ccf0c83daa5c91c0f433aa0b9687d6316f", "started_sha256": "0d2571faac7963fed0781c68658515896a6a41774039d3e373baac2c2705d1d3", "original_grade_sha256": "b5b6c60a9c6d59d9f0af02ee5a13e7c31364038f594026d4d93de47a327a044d", "input_original_sha256": "b196be3a64e746d0bb8e8bbdd79d44ccf0c83daa5c91c0f433aa0b9687d6316f", "input_wav_sha256": "f3ba1088212e5bd5aa0af17f2c0ac53d5981af3ddd7a772e50df245d4fec1e83", "input_pcm_sha256": "ff6d7cd675272062157db8075591e710fe9368af3784ea699ed2b853741a999b", "output_wav_sha256": "b5ae3dda16a625776d9710ff5db014d3a1b9e675a700a2afc6053f8babea9ef4", "output_pcm_sha256": "3db2b61627fde72713b12010c5895ac6424ef66d3442ded99ebbbae6e5b94709", "result_sha256": "c7d44df5d73140f352709d9133ce55318acb6c8ccda83e130928c6b0880f42d0" } }, { "id": 296, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "36de8dae6ec57c8d174bdfa9c53a251ec8d83515a07c141cfe750f2e119ab778", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "36de8dae6ec57c8d174bdfa9c53a251ec8d83515a07c141cfe750f2e119ab778", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn right. Take nine steps. Take ten steps. Turn left. Take ten steps. Turn right. Turn around. Take four steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn right. Take nine steps. Take ten steps. Turn left. Take ten steps. Turn right. Turn around. Take four steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7167.03, "reasoner_ms": 3050.86, "tts_ms": 23.48, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10241.4, "total_processing_ms": 10987.61 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 156 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "132afb05b94cb2dc90dde82494c274e56357fc2a0f90d78ad87208b531b87e54", "started_sha256": "2d3aab0138a599ffc895fef1c6799272e049b0a9672ee8e9dcd03a36dd33ddd8", "original_grade_sha256": "2dd985e595f0c1b57aae19415b22b2bbb09fe073498ba6d6117615af23201f78", "input_original_sha256": "132afb05b94cb2dc90dde82494c274e56357fc2a0f90d78ad87208b531b87e54", "input_wav_sha256": "84e45422df6043ced6460e8f202793f5575e90949b1275b220e17556d81f58c5", "input_pcm_sha256": "3f3ca7fc089a3b4a1acb95a7403e5541432e94f83d21bd533dd3bbb1ff0eb523", "output_wav_sha256": "9d3e55f10b28f09985964062a1be550dcfe3dd37b565c53f93bffb741436afd5", "output_pcm_sha256": "a779b3d2ec48ca5babe5540befb11dacf383867a730855d93e31dab98d9ef977", "result_sha256": "cf8ba7da826967e5d88d999be54fb942bc6652b94d72fa7d59c2f9509a203c76" } }, { "id": 632, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "16", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5025d009978dc4ca5b8fe3cfd2192d30fead31c8e49439e1cb709074898ed745", "normalized_answer": "16" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5025d009978dc4ca5b8fe3cfd2192d30fead31c8e49439e1cb709074898ed745", "normalized_answer": "16" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a couch, an oven, four toasters, a car, a lamp, five tables, a chair, a stove, and a bed. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a couch, an oven, four toasters, a car, a lamp, five tables, a chair, a stove, and a bed. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 16.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5752.23, "reasoner_ms": 2045.0, "tts_ms": 28.82, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7826.08, "total_processing_ms": 8431.98 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 784, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 83 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "12dc2c5a7262d0cbd1d1af1c24797ba19ea04667a7d480550112531d88869511", "started_sha256": "29ee0dd6aa59bbe4c96b47ab73f772b4c6ca0502ede64cbcc4f3cf761c0f370e", "original_grade_sha256": "2a54c4a206b5f5b9af7f13663adb9c645c70c5f68740cf94a752cc67c9aaf27e", "input_original_sha256": "12dc2c5a7262d0cbd1d1af1c24797ba19ea04667a7d480550112531d88869511", "input_wav_sha256": "d97b36da58408ccf3ae92b90291b3dc2cd876cca66c82d21af984dc4050ff352", "input_pcm_sha256": "824a8455cdc5dd69e0a5ff04213a1774da0b656efbacf839bac49bce01f733e0", "output_wav_sha256": "0ccc587bbcbc4dc1514462fa19b08af1b13b4db16acea7d7242aba0d80de3441", "output_pcm_sha256": "1818270fddfd77e477ed4a326a94619e6d59a93e90627f28e5c5ea6b4741800b", "result_sha256": "e6f71c44ef5df1d31715875cb59fb90733024de49135ca652c61b0ed870f0eb2" } }, { "id": 892, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "34ae27efb93b7df77d25c2b4ba41b9c43e9eeb93fb13c9552787ad59351851fd", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "34ae27efb93b7df77d25c2b4ba41b9c43e9eeb93fb13c9552787ad59351851fd", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Millie lies. Jamie says Millie tells the truth. Jamie says Jamie tells the truth. Sal says Jamie lies. Christy says Sal lies. Does Christy tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Millie lies. Jamie says Millie tells the truth. Jamie says Jamie tells the truth. Sal says Jamie lies. Christy says Sal lies. Does Christy tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5999.07, "reasoner_ms": 2764.06, "tts_ms": 20.96, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8784.12, "total_processing_ms": 9620.92 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 827, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 87 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a49cbe255ab52928e048e6778c4bd6aa684a7da0690d2d98fe155fcc0c5395cd", "started_sha256": "a1fd38ab8bda65d7d6d6f50e3bced75a71ad2eec919f45fe2a59bf70f093957a", "original_grade_sha256": "994b4a15926cf5b562d6e0bf86b2debfb578c2a3733b21fcd68a7d6e47da2292", "input_original_sha256": "a49cbe255ab52928e048e6778c4bd6aa684a7da0690d2d98fe155fcc0c5395cd", "input_wav_sha256": "fd62f845dca7ec397dbe0bbd9b267026e5fd3bca695fe1f98b6660d4a76ab0a3", "input_pcm_sha256": "c8923df103bf364fb8c13c270e327957f55949f3624323269f16521adeec0442", "output_wav_sha256": "0906c26df58d846baf0fc03a4db9889e4c062fd7e00ea273e94db691a595f117", "output_pcm_sha256": "019b1306eb0cc82dfb87a5d570121a90b29b00e6ced4235d126b7541f29df52f", "result_sha256": "56fbf78d4b199983e6cbfd464228a0f4abcc759138ffa3a8673fad4878ebd3a4" } }, { "id": 24, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e5f2696507b2b6795fa512be3bdecb1be89402de43733e9f7a44d6bcde19a036", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e5f2696507b2b6795fa512be3bdecb1be89402de43733e9f7a44d6bcde19a036", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To begin with, nobody is neither a frequent consumer of Bath & Body Works soap nor an occasional purchaser of Clearly Natural soap. Moreover, nobody is neither a rare consumer of Nioxin shampoo nor an occasional purchaser of Clearly Natural soap. Finally, every occasional purchaser of Kirk's soap is a frequent consumer of Bath & Body Works soap or a rare consumer of Nioxin shampoo. We may conclude being an occasional purchaser of Clearly Natural soap is necessary for being an occasional purchaser of Kirk's soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To begin with, nobody is neither a frequent consumer of Bath & Body Works soap, nor an occasional purchaser of Clearly Natural soap. Moreover, nobody is neither a rare consumer of Nioxin shampoo, nor an occasional purchaser of Clearly Natural soap. Finally, every occasional purchaser of Kirk's soap is a frequent consumer of Bath & Body Works soap or a rare consumer of Nioxin shampoo. We may conclude, being an occasional purchaser of Clearly Natural soap is necessary for being an occasional purchaser of Kirk's soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 16397.25, "reasoner_ms": 6994.94, "tts_ms": 29.94, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 23422.15, "total_processing_ms": 24086.03 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1256, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 441 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "7d70ee181bf1d7bae5ecc3d6a215dc28efe18a263e00f96d53d7deb73076bcc2", "started_sha256": "067e910b6403f23bfdeb92d4f96cb537dcab170dc4ffee73377ee937c48101af", "original_grade_sha256": "170af7722463beec06fb373dbe0ea8c00ea950eaf63ad261afac7bb26140ecf8", "input_original_sha256": "7d70ee181bf1d7bae5ecc3d6a215dc28efe18a263e00f96d53d7deb73076bcc2", "input_wav_sha256": "d708bfc95095bb76eadff6aaad0407437cc31486a6f8f74b92f6fe3da897bd95", "input_pcm_sha256": "65c8e4da25258fe43f82cb4782b5b979ffb493c1756fe859c32f99ca199d2e04", "output_wav_sha256": "b5c1d9bd14cbdd305b476bd4b0f78050c91aa7683c603c420b9150aac532cd78", "output_pcm_sha256": "06bf7a4eee08d7fd7b2c04a8c6acf78e8552678f878565fcc074f5dd5ce81553", "result_sha256": "4035f718203973134e946ceea5a99d42c114834ba06cb1204cb77e813db89dec" } }, { "id": 496, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f89486324a538b0ec2e336a4682ac38febbed6657464bb4c79ea3901644f6355", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f89486324a538b0ec2e336a4682ac38febbed6657464bb4c79ea3901644f6355", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps right. Take nine steps left. Take five steps left. Take eight steps right. Options. Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward, take six steps right, take nine steps left, take five steps left, take eight steps right. Options. Yes? No? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6145.96, "reasoner_ms": 1915.72, "tts_ms": 25.96, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8087.66, "total_processing_ms": 8849.96 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 809, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 53 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "aebd66b5464a3ad78cfc14177f0aebe4b175fe0a53e15e4ce17cfbda677866cb", "started_sha256": "cfbb6f0979cf63611bb3e2032ff7fd34aa504f4c945f7813f9481d435f7df32b", "original_grade_sha256": "716ab90d67990e0ccb8e1f60e5eca3b80a6004e7857b63f1d2a2a84baf80dabf", "input_original_sha256": "aebd66b5464a3ad78cfc14177f0aebe4b175fe0a53e15e4ce17cfbda677866cb", "input_wav_sha256": "341cd1b5b7ddf9e3d17f29e2756abad1f247386c5e31fb909ea2f3faf006220a", "input_pcm_sha256": "991c8af986c1da0258812940d48461e2ecec22290e5b25502365308fe477b706", "output_wav_sha256": "eedee5aaf1a5973f2f3808f147669f89f4fb24420670a9b942fa2bc7e606340b", "output_pcm_sha256": "8a1e0f3dec64564c22f532972c582cf187a64f8d5a83fa32a93b738d362d6780", "result_sha256": "4a6cc68f56ad73daa2a796c0ef7ec2376f9193386381f4e14114f5ecfc0acb21" } }, { "id": 568, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "2", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "559c389c20e09115b98477c0e5827ba1b37df2571b0de87fcdcad275460b4a2b", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "559c389c20e09115b98477c0e5827ba1b37df2571b0de87fcdcad275460b4a2b", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a clarinet and a trombone. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a clarinet and a trombone. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 2.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4850.09, "reasoner_ms": 1428.44, "tts_ms": 44.61, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6323.16, "total_processing_ms": 7117.21 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 735, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "9bea4d7a84472b55daca94bd6af58bdd3a04be15e8fadd252a1bd3e3b63ad728", "started_sha256": "f16501438bc68b3fa3ea951b732ab780b8abb144fb516996dfcc6a7ac9ed4130", "original_grade_sha256": "3fb70cec0bcaff7439f39aaae72e6f84b76075d377b975d7924c9ffb44d03bf6", "input_original_sha256": "9bea4d7a84472b55daca94bd6af58bdd3a04be15e8fadd252a1bd3e3b63ad728", "input_wav_sha256": "9d9f8c3c1ecdd00a048b144c57c684f703d9a5cdff1e7fb001c6971fddc3611d", "input_pcm_sha256": "fbecd0649d88625d3d2e8609b3dcbaf92b6cad2c7fa0d8bb2b93548db4327c4d", "output_wav_sha256": "be516a81f6199775aae03dc4ab7e812f42d2ba523cc9524e6c9aad3e02b04732", "output_pcm_sha256": "999185b9f8cd9194555dbfda89aa8e5ec1540f914807bd9e26279a2fa9a5f74c", "result_sha256": "6197c012378f608f13b00c1cbc2891e56abb9cf1c74813d76741d95562db8a25" } }, { "id": 884, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8d66d3dfcd5bcb50ea486864554911d1056278aac533603590cba74105673520", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8d66d3dfcd5bcb50ea486864554911d1056278aac533603590cba74105673520", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Millicent tells the truth. Willian says Millicent lies. Christa says Willian lies. Teressa says Christa tells the truth. Rashida says Teressa tells the truth. Does Rashida tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Millicent tells the truth. William says Millicent lies. Krista says William lies. Teresa says Krista tells the truth. Rashida says Teresa tells the truth. Does Rashida tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6068.87, "reasoner_ms": 2503.85, "tts_ms": 25.93, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8598.68, "total_processing_ms": 9328.85 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 833, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 106 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "441632da7dbb62889296fa2e1d6d4d50b39c64815fa7acfb9f462490bdea479a", "started_sha256": "8737eb791b951165a0e11516e80f27282488827bebf0b4e8b5bedf32a177eb71", "original_grade_sha256": "87b1d4777de008400edfe83792819c1d1727166af60e6c7ea34198fff2a78bc6", "input_original_sha256": "441632da7dbb62889296fa2e1d6d4d50b39c64815fa7acfb9f462490bdea479a", "input_wav_sha256": "c6a0e0c81b683de1f676464e845cbac11a377df619fbf5c6b746730b27993417", "input_pcm_sha256": "bf4d01274b7e2233600f36274273ebe9c4844e72ade6eeb9f9836fcb043b44c5", "output_wav_sha256": "ab5dccc8d3924d5d382107632dc81079fae2f8779a283af8e5790bbbe1f3f03b", "output_pcm_sha256": "440b6b5b618f69c629f55f205508fdf8651a1d30ce9c7fb6dd525d9cc725980f", "result_sha256": "dad0a49505ef58c6a5ca1b1922b5c0cfb2850311336492fa77a70acd2eef6845" } }, { "id": 34, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "72d5cd17696778faf5afe9f2b86b8883ee0324ea8deebd6b79a7ef0cc6980120", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "72d5cd17696778faf5afe9f2b86b8883ee0324ea8deebd6b79a7ef0cc6980120", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nSome football fans admire various clubs, others love only a single team. But who is a fan of whom precisely? The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, if someone is not a follower of Feyenoord, then that person is not a backer of FC Augsburg or not a devotee of AS Monaco FC. Moreover, being a devotee of AS Monaco FC is necessary for not being a member of AC Milan. Finally, nobody is neither a member of AC Milan nor a backer of FC Augsburg. In consequence, nobody is neither a member of AC Milan nor a follower of Feyenoord. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nSome football fans admire various clubs, others love only a single team. But who is a fan of whom precisely? The following argument pertains to this question, to begin with, if someone is not a follower of Feyenoord, then that person is not a backer of FC Augsburg or not a devotee of AS Monaco FC. Moreover, being a devotee of AS Monaco FC is necessary for not being a member of AC Milan. Finally, nobody is neither a member of AC Milan nor a backer of FC Augsburg. In consequence, nobody is neither a member of AC Milan nor a follower of Feyenoord. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options? Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 16442.16, "reasoner_ms": 5504.83, "tts_ms": 29.58, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 21976.6, "total_processing_ms": 22711.8 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1059, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 401 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1fe18fd2a7b9b84971b15eebcd5d53e8ad7c912c73dfc688d39c5663e6722c9d", "started_sha256": "f295ef1e53e712b0bd5c0aaaa3417bc4e5b602c590b40b9b46d191ce28442191", "original_grade_sha256": "9fa414fbabda1fef8e0974b53107275d0f474a759f9ffeee3b3fdb5977e4a627", "input_original_sha256": "1fe18fd2a7b9b84971b15eebcd5d53e8ad7c912c73dfc688d39c5663e6722c9d", "input_wav_sha256": "7a493ac9510c4c75ca9224e263eddb746ca9c277aa005a35ac99f42daa3ff1d4", "input_pcm_sha256": "b53bce75b8feeb10cdaafcf10ad906e6c96895188d45e62f6c1b8e4990c91dc2", "output_wav_sha256": "c17d8ae3c91c446ea777133625b00abd54932bae61d50863022685b34535a216", "output_pcm_sha256": "e911c42703fc6331c1c63bbcc16a18bd96a35bb9b533e5de393538e6be4cd7c0", "result_sha256": "d07401b90bed4a47035aafc95e7b9d6432fa6bf1bfea10efea002c1700789cf5" } }, { "id": 341, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f203ae7e43957d92df4e7a9eeb79af838312da0abdf5aa983120dceab4eca4b6", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f203ae7e43957d92df4e7a9eeb79af838312da0abdf5aa983120dceab4eca4b6", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left. Take nine steps. Take nine steps. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left. Take nine steps. Take nine steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5315.52, "reasoner_ms": 1694.34, "tts_ms": 26.57, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7036.47, "total_processing_ms": 7727.2 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 780, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 47 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f2f70db264356f7366209386e1e9c2d58a2c07aaa189c8fcaec2bcf6eb085c64", "started_sha256": "73b5c620ec2a38dbe0ee3d239c3e51dff5d0160d57cf1cb3df2190179a96bd31", "original_grade_sha256": "51544d1833ce0348bce945d351809031d1a2863b79381d4b25d37d9f9dde59d7", "input_original_sha256": "f2f70db264356f7366209386e1e9c2d58a2c07aaa189c8fcaec2bcf6eb085c64", "input_wav_sha256": "8170edf7d0d82e34d8f09e6a30c823ae196acd2f7b14c6e8a000e1030a857049", "input_pcm_sha256": "66a538815b3267c16e5349244da46c4ba4de5aa9de3fa92b1bac58f666da404e", "output_wav_sha256": "943b1ba8870af9873d8297d9c3ea1965125f636d2b02b0e82ac7fb3dc6a3dc58", "output_pcm_sha256": "ebbaf2e05afff394f11e2a5a9ab443d2ba483ea4f1185fd93fb3ef36e0b2b514", "result_sha256": "c1d02f17f3f587337a0983745fc6b970885e971f5e8e6fa7a5e337b1bbe7e482" } }, { "id": 516, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "11", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "60b18a96a64dbe5404c0e0f16ff050f236de9f67ebf5cd9c0f8ee5cd7a0531f1", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "60b18a96a64dbe5404c0e0f16ff050f236de9f67ebf5cd9c0f8ee5cd7a0531f1", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a microwave, a table, a fridge, a stove, an oven, a toaster, a couch, and four cars. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a microwave, a table, a fridge, a stove, an oven, a toaster, a couch, and four cars. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 11.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5925.19, "reasoner_ms": 1673.12, "tts_ms": 27.89, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7626.23, "total_processing_ms": 8359.47 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 778, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 48 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6336f778d4b8182593aaf3d1ff0127e0e1cc2b49284711110964ddbfac8dbf27", "started_sha256": "ebb0af1b5bdeab288356f29043e5a1e1c2585bb8e6dd43f197bfbdb6abc3802e", "original_grade_sha256": "26d30e0e6db2378c3f36c49c324bd9b53f168219f2c7d853d5602cd0afc223ba", "input_original_sha256": "6336f778d4b8182593aaf3d1ff0127e0e1cc2b49284711110964ddbfac8dbf27", "input_wav_sha256": "ea31e4fbc1014fab419a211a3801a685bba4cf570211e01d8d972656c18277e1", "input_pcm_sha256": "b51ff76df497b28022fc5653f6babfcd479637f270e12d3c4207b246962a96fe", "output_wav_sha256": "ea2760fe2fa2e6cba11ef2c7006eea16538b167baf0be2678deaac802519e652", "output_pcm_sha256": "c0a91b34ad4f2b134883a607f60a0e23cee98504b58a0211a49c223d423f9b40", "result_sha256": "f852cbfba17d7dff38f8060c142f183aababa80c05fea3f20db85c1edf98f4ac" } }, { "id": 772, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "82343aeaf16635ff878668841ac93ada905b29524195817e7bc2668366c9c871", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "82343aeaf16635ff878668841ac93ada905b29524195817e7bc2668366c9c871", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Sima lies. Millie says Sima tells the truth. Jerry says Millie tells the truth. Vina says Jerry lies. Maybel says Vina tells the truth. Does Maybel tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Sima lies. Millie says Sima tells the truth. Jerry says Millie tells the truth. Veena says Jerry lies. Maybel says Veena tells the truth. Does Maybel tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5972.38, "reasoner_ms": 1981.22, "tts_ms": 21.49, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7975.11, "total_processing_ms": 8658.3 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 833, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 98 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e89f08cfb107483af129cbb96a88814c1b8021834908861bcf5c58d1987c01ef", "started_sha256": "4edeaf8ced4b30553726bfdb817647f7d3646284e293a78a2b6336710938ec1a", "original_grade_sha256": "58f494b86cba058b0d8d0a4933d457ec2fcde6c142a8ab33748930639fb064ae", "input_original_sha256": "e89f08cfb107483af129cbb96a88814c1b8021834908861bcf5c58d1987c01ef", "input_wav_sha256": "4f63f10d8080de0b649511868977be2458839f1977acc48d98eacd501a1d5cd5", "input_pcm_sha256": "f3533770ce0331e153824d6df161d9760703a49b6313b870808fb400a51de665", "output_wav_sha256": "3515c3c677a338c9cd19fe9c4fcbe05275734c03fa8ef409c33842560558c07f", "output_pcm_sha256": "051e52cd13e9ea2d85e0cb8e4e23e55a29cb5e62b069194d809b282feedea081", "result_sha256": "5c13a408f8ef621f57e6120f13346efcd4fc68b4297be889a2f95e1c436160bb" } }, { "id": 0, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ff1b328943d1b1ad09928918c060da34801d5f0de5665a9c8bc128674a53fb3b", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ff1b328943d1b1ad09928918c060da34801d5f0de5665a9c8bc128674a53fb3b", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, whoever is a schoolmate of Sondra is not a stepsister of Priscilla. In consequence, whoever is not a stepsister of Priscilla is a schoolmate of Sondra. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, whoever is a schoolmate of Sondra is not a stepsister of Priscilla. In consequence, whoever is not a stepsister of Priscilla is a schoolmate of Sondra. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7867.28, "reasoner_ms": 1813.93, "tts_ms": 25.83, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9707.06, "total_processing_ms": 10386.58 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 927, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 55 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e237555c1766b74ed79806395722ffe42168a4b7ac4dfce03f52242a4031772f", "started_sha256": "dc721330c722a1497ec8fcd5778241a5223e6c4d2c950e9e6d7e810926e095ba", "original_grade_sha256": "64b59213f8675ffd0090c13e9f0cbc8ae641872fb5103a5d1bfdfdc8281c8749", "input_original_sha256": "e237555c1766b74ed79806395722ffe42168a4b7ac4dfce03f52242a4031772f", "input_wav_sha256": "2195851d5508955084b8d6fe373d466b24f952a50350fa3a66f6dd5c0388e56e", "input_pcm_sha256": "136e836eb7047dfb29ab7838f75902127b8bf7c6919c19abfd75f2d73df63795", "output_wav_sha256": "fb6ff69b4b9cd30af3b931b8d70d1629b6e0ffc12bc3593847b6460387b5da4d", "output_pcm_sha256": "b823e0a2c2bf2a555f26d0ee41c6915767bcf6e88300564b2b6731004f0caa32", "result_sha256": "b01140c645773c3a01bc6715914992cbd83ead97ffd5ef7872fc4281e9d826fe" } }, { "id": 357, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "79a22cf3527a7c88a047bbd40fa443351f2788ab4a5f3f9c20a98daeebd2be33", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "79a22cf3527a7c88a047bbd40fa443351f2788ab4a5f3f9c20a98daeebd2be33", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps right. Take seven steps left. Take eight steps right. Take six steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps right. Take seven steps left. Take eight steps right. Take six steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6511.34, "reasoner_ms": 1827.69, "tts_ms": 24.52, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8363.58, "total_processing_ms": 8986.2 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 813, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 43 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "397c09540bf03072c40f53188579a3bc7836e9334cd309920f2e0b126dfb8e98", "started_sha256": "3e732c9e6152f2d4fcf804a3aaa4eed9c56215dcd7974fd79d41215328471cfc", "original_grade_sha256": "ed37ea61bd1ea172570a2370ae933feaa26ed8174527dd5e7f169d9bf5e7a284", "input_original_sha256": "397c09540bf03072c40f53188579a3bc7836e9334cd309920f2e0b126dfb8e98", "input_wav_sha256": "a75b226458689247e77639753f9a3ffc210c095b3bd763574da8222b4437af56", "input_pcm_sha256": "94424320fe436f01d86fbac9667223c5f87ccb84d10799c0acd68e9375b79820", "output_wav_sha256": "15e5df7872b0e78461879d348f986ffdad322454f4b143107f5d08c0c2cd5f26", "output_pcm_sha256": "869e9cc04064f56faab5826f6514826bea9c44052eedfbd9cd0b0f0240aacf01", "result_sha256": "474e36f29c8b3ac14ba8088d906b8aa9a2f45ddfc3c2c6e13d8f9d781f8216e6" } }, { "id": 515, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "5", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "97df06f5faee7dd9d27975cbc93b690ffda3242fd418bc6b85486b3769f8e91d", "normalized_answer": "5" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "97df06f5faee7dd9d27975cbc93b690ffda3242fd418bc6b85486b3769f8e91d", "normalized_answer": "5" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a duck, a peach, a strawberry, a fish, two chickens, a bear, and a banana. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a duck, a peach, a strawberry, a fish, two chickens, a bear, and a banana. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 5.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5452.55, "reasoner_ms": 1685.45, "tts_ms": 28.0, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7166.03, "total_processing_ms": 7790.69 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 772, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 42 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1d01103c0af6241f487e921261091884f85a3f2b2fcbbe37089c973de008e039", "started_sha256": "cae47bb42573352a8574d207a89a421fe9ec6ecf4629b8b524c53ebf94f17c3f", "original_grade_sha256": "ec1e8d41b67b15010f5b151e546d0472c4a02dc7bbfac88e129c52b12ae8e72f", "input_original_sha256": "1d01103c0af6241f487e921261091884f85a3f2b2fcbbe37089c973de008e039", "input_wav_sha256": "5e9b0455d6e4dd223c0a511a50a59b454bc33a23ad9db67373b08d66dc14c85a", "input_pcm_sha256": "b51dab69320a0dabb71f0e6435003ec4b3e184d50ffd61f24605206a550ec2b4", "output_wav_sha256": "367d16297eea89f8c083fd7ec9afd43b1c55ccb8f18378220918a7bc6202c6f6", "output_pcm_sha256": "d075c5dcfb66625fde9c62c6bb19b687f738644958e896ce405e760708af06c2", "result_sha256": "d3963e8a2354d02f6e7faea22f2d37f19881fd35fe7d2c349592d127028c114d" } }, { "id": 816, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "771adcd1eb9fcdb2d93252d9de271460a918f98313981d183e25a4707df5d8fd", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "771adcd1eb9fcdb2d93252d9de271460a918f98313981d183e25a4707df5d8fd", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Shama tells the truth. Michaela says Shama lies. Lida says Michaela tells the truth. Fletcher says Lida lies. Vena says Fletcher tells the truth. Does Vena tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion shema tells the truth michaelah says shema lies ledah says michaelah tells the truth fletcher says ledah lies venah says fletcher tells the truth does venah tell the truth answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8875.32, "reasoner_ms": 2292.83, "tts_ms": 25.95, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11194.13, "total_processing_ms": 11869.22 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 828, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 107 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "7c60c2bb3f3b32dba05721cbbd622286cb78d83956edc454f11b1c2d6a79211e", "started_sha256": "7a146c103441e237d35cb5a1c53e6cb496e4bad6b8d31f95cba8a0f3d0af199c", "original_grade_sha256": "cae68550243c8701e1f297e9649a67c928a613241268049bf2a4bcab35d4a0a8", "input_original_sha256": "7c60c2bb3f3b32dba05721cbbd622286cb78d83956edc454f11b1c2d6a79211e", "input_wav_sha256": "902007a1c9e186661db67dba76c77b528b363a7c29b7b4c74adf5d3f64ba1f46", "input_pcm_sha256": "47de11fc21e540ee461c499cabedd40bccb4793f1816cff53c6df6b2cda3062a", "output_wav_sha256": "c0bbfb6c48b1da9d615c21107d6937c3dddfa45ac2d24c9c2abd3187337493b4", "output_pcm_sha256": "9a6110b8e577dfe594c74e70df8e756c922f1dddc16646a211a127d2863d124d", "result_sha256": "11a51cf220c944716a77324dd8e6bec21801faf827197fd530aa4b53991f12b6" } }, { "id": 103, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3f55b583dbe5434d5cf61bbf91243153257edd4e730d84ff6aa6daaa6f43941b", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3f55b583dbe5434d5cf61bbf91243153257edd4e730d84ff6aa6daaa6f43941b", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Siri a stepsister of Mary? Is Susan related to Kate? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First of all, whoever is not a classmate of Shanika is a daughter of Candace. Therefore, being a classmate of Shanika is necessary for not being a daughter of Candace. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Sirius stepsister of Mary? Is Susan related to Kate? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First of all, whoever is not a classmate of Shanika is a daughter of Candace. Therefore, being a classmate of Shanika is necessary for not being a daughter of Candace. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12949.74, "reasoner_ms": 2523.78, "tts_ms": 62.96, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15536.51, "total_processing_ms": 16381.43 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1018, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 108 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e975866a0a522b3e5465cc2403e1e4e96b39b7fbf30c45afce5fbcc2120d2f8a", "started_sha256": "98acd2d156880d5b3f500cb6d08d0c201b67cf2a5fa92b562ffaa2857f550b22", "original_grade_sha256": "54407212eb7bafafa0fc528a96f241ddf8c614e24ac0efb54c7b9a66accd1b3e", "input_original_sha256": "e975866a0a522b3e5465cc2403e1e4e96b39b7fbf30c45afce5fbcc2120d2f8a", "input_wav_sha256": "7e9a8c96242f0d2f169c5a79e8058f31d745dabb3981e50144f471f183928154", "input_pcm_sha256": "fb621247a8b3d99ef66d0260829eec30950884b94e730f29fe7eb61b75530e54", "output_wav_sha256": "2b567c0fbd523c439840922a39781eb60e823301a039e9e5621eb5a7fbecc5ab", "output_pcm_sha256": "a577ce33f0fa01e20a6fcd07d377359813ad0b7d1c44cd33d9968b00ceffc598", "result_sha256": "f8ae99d661566a861506fa7d8c24ad12c4dc126c3033865c36c128fe996f2e37" } }, { "id": 479, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e40555c3f576b16effc43a562d87497e86db019df58abccbe117ace69fb61e64", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e40555c3f576b16effc43a562d87497e86db019df58abccbe117ace69fb61e64", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take three steps. Take ten steps. Take four steps. Take one step. Options. Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take three steps. Take ten steps. Take four steps. Take one step. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5314.51, "reasoner_ms": 1669.07, "tts_ms": 24.4, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7008.01, "total_processing_ms": 7682.63 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 789, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 34 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "676422b714bff5d9412d8830ef8781238cdd18cc61cb36edede552ed963e7b44", "started_sha256": "d574ae822dd9679407764bcc34e8fcd5b6e5fe854fc7c876e006e35f5b18d876", "original_grade_sha256": "fd548b3e0e7a6c7886f0233e4993e26b9a74db166ee75adfed56753243fad9d7", "input_original_sha256": "676422b714bff5d9412d8830ef8781238cdd18cc61cb36edede552ed963e7b44", "input_wav_sha256": "f00dbeb61b1c1162666af87fbb610d2feefc045e7bb2bb98bffa96b2e4180593", "input_pcm_sha256": "74b20a2c80a9efeef5c6620d1d056b28f687015a58d1cca60f424be0b7241e67", "output_wav_sha256": "3223dd679da51a94800fb6974e68b7f6c861d7094dadea0606f195506f4c72b1", "output_pcm_sha256": "2f6b2b1298c6c9353cce15c2f20fca89834a4089eee97d26b556804855c9769a", "result_sha256": "8e27044a53befddf530f97202ecbea06eaaf0e299563888b210b3ab468d95533" } }, { "id": 512, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "6", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7f090c001f6a863460d62cd668a60ddb8def7ada5165395fbddaf4c01d0c3d45", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7f090c001f6a863460d62cd668a60ddb8def7ada5165395fbddaf4c01d0c3d45", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a piano, a flute, and four trombones. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a piano, a flute, and four trombones. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 6.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4629.33, "reasoner_ms": 1410.25, "tts_ms": 28.35, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6067.96, "total_processing_ms": 6694.28 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 741, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 25 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5a8ab45a4523051003d573de4f0b295c65ec56c73c42b55ba32499932bf1ae64", "started_sha256": "b93d9c1fa4096f5142db103e250f37b71f5dc655e3cf326ec121435ad5697e21", "original_grade_sha256": "8f6ec4205be14010151155b01fb726c2cb29bd8796f8bf7dbd1f7c9b1aff71cb", "input_original_sha256": "5a8ab45a4523051003d573de4f0b295c65ec56c73c42b55ba32499932bf1ae64", "input_wav_sha256": "7750f58ebb3504f8b142e8c9a22cd5dbf59353f94c296aba7691aa01814cae4b", "input_pcm_sha256": "240590b78f28013dfcb12011ccbb4e8f490f9a9655321b916f71af911fa1d89a", "output_wav_sha256": "2e03ce2e6f4f879c3d274921413a9d5ea64156df0cd9b645d0c4d97ccc867725", "output_pcm_sha256": "5ad1036c8d61faaf116ade39a79cedb7cc65d27d4fdf6089aa3d4fae0a873504", "result_sha256": "3df5e5e28bdfd3e082c531810f447c92b9b6071ca4e8efadd38fe930ab563025" } }, { "id": 873, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5cc8f71d6180b5f25c436c7f596eb7c3da8bbf658883730568fc4cac15ab1c13", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5cc8f71d6180b5f25c436c7f596eb7c3da8bbf658883730568fc4cac15ab1c13", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Bernita lies. Jerry says Bernita tells the truth. Delbert says Jerry lies. Jamie says Delbert tells the truth. Shenna says Jamie lies. Does Shenna tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Bernita lies. Jerry says Bernita tells the truth. Delbert says Jerry lies. Jamie says Delbert tells the truth. Shena says Jamie lies. Does Shena tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5341.52, "reasoner_ms": 2570.13, "tts_ms": 27.06, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7938.74, "total_processing_ms": 8539.86 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 838, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 127 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "cf05254d706a10523b1aaba2201a2afc358e3a3baa238e22afaf3c3b510d2000", "started_sha256": "0680a56c86d35a1474514d6a4c5ab42050e4e1fac539c61ffb66e0553743438f", "original_grade_sha256": "8e5fec72bf293365e678350e9e6db310e0ef5a949e8be64c46fdd8a0aa0decda", "input_original_sha256": "cf05254d706a10523b1aaba2201a2afc358e3a3baa238e22afaf3c3b510d2000", "input_wav_sha256": "c25f06708880b2d05690e5532249ec25f50f04143ee56cd33ee7861405c1e642", "input_pcm_sha256": "857cb2779d9b6e5c5067dfcd9f9b2f720c56fc3891b6faa58429dd9ed96e04df", "output_wav_sha256": "53b5983408a9c4129efd49cac0ed060a4149305e7a77d3cf0f12851daaf5a526", "output_pcm_sha256": "5f24745f71a155de66a878ac6062bb875c1c2a93d27a68ddab923bfa879f9af4", "result_sha256": "69ba7f80580c8c6fc75357953503a63f2aa6246afb9d2cd46415051e153d7201" } }, { "id": 142, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "567ae49786e30c20e64acfe96babf2cdf0d0e3c562d70e2a5bd8e28fbb410146", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "567ae49786e30c20e64acfe96babf2cdf0d0e3c562d70e2a5bd8e28fbb410146", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see which chemicals are contained in our consumer products. The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, no ingredient of Rock Star is both an ingredient of White Tea Lotion and an ingredient of Vanilla Bliss Soap. Moreover, every ingredient of White Tea Lotion that is an ingredient of Vanilla Bliss Soap is an ingredient of Rock Star or an ingredient of Lip Gloss, BCMK. From this follows, every ingredient of White Tea Lotion that is an ingredient of Vanilla Bliss Soap is also an ingredient of Lip Gloss, BCMK. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see which chemicals are contained in our consumer products. The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, no ingredient of Rockstar is both an ingredient of white tea lotion and an ingredient of Vanilla Bliss soap. Moreover, every ingredient of white tea lotion that is an ingredient of Vanilla Bliss soap is an ingredient of Rockstar or an ingredient of lip gloss BCMK. From this follows, every ingredient of white tea lotion that is an ingredient of vanilla bliss soap is also an ingredient of lip gloss . Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14064.89, "reasoner_ms": 3218.1, "tts_ms": 24.7, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17307.72, "total_processing_ms": 17883.93 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1170, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 179 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a7f4f65a786c78bbb0b1e4f8bb7f27abb571eb8a1fe15cf2b596c0529292447f", "started_sha256": "23e3f566493eb334ee359ff06b338ca828b6c82fe1b3de807aa6307db6519fc7", "original_grade_sha256": "1006dc580aaaa5e758ffcffd5a930740223e6fe629c9cd26cfcf1fbd991625b3", "input_original_sha256": "a7f4f65a786c78bbb0b1e4f8bb7f27abb571eb8a1fe15cf2b596c0529292447f", "input_wav_sha256": "d8e09434503dd699448188ba45b8dfca9beeafb42a5eb998a840206cdeae8345", "input_pcm_sha256": "ad6024a5ce1d98142cf38796e09df16b23882c221c769664aea6029a23572b4a", "output_wav_sha256": "807466adc4959cf4fa3253a22a4a293ae0bb065d2088f4f8a0e6c16aad2730b9", "output_pcm_sha256": "e4b1bae4ac886c3ffd9ac558746a1c98b80bbb5e32afbf226e04905754a35107", "result_sha256": "8694ed256b0d6f2f769ebcfb8c683d7b71892b2abde70a921e5a4f0751b1ab40" } }, { "id": 298, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c438e0fb6667f24fda54eb10e22e1fc1b2e5a5fa6903a755e3fac622477de1a3", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c438e0fb6667f24fda54eb10e22e1fc1b2e5a5fa6903a755e3fac622477de1a3", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take two steps right. Take four steps right. Take six steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point always face forward take two steps right take four steps right take six steps left options yes no answer the question Question", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7439.16, "reasoner_ms": 1806.28, "tts_ms": 20.0, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9265.47, "total_processing_ms": 9919.05 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 780, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 40 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3642f3cca4bdba47bd7c2f2e4299e9595d4e7b060dd59c557ea93e98a0c4ecaa", "started_sha256": "8038a6a70fffd622d22061686dbd3d62cf1e79bd8681036971091dd7a2c5ff85", "original_grade_sha256": "b0a6e865feac55a3edd49ffe69dd50db902545865a2487e249b515147a133a36", "input_original_sha256": "3642f3cca4bdba47bd7c2f2e4299e9595d4e7b060dd59c557ea93e98a0c4ecaa", "input_wav_sha256": "128ed157973c2d77d50705fa3c8529a09e0982351b104b757b65b0215080ca6d", "input_pcm_sha256": "216a68dabb032db0c53af24953c74915d874a20f714aa3d1ff69d7927b021071", "output_wav_sha256": "f749b7390f122bcf51067676b32c8956eb46646c18c61087d65190bf75bd9d22", "output_pcm_sha256": "d12da94d7b2a39a9887a485b8c27546f3c50a6894e26075ba7cbfb3f6674991e", "result_sha256": "d9e9508267689e65e2d0f89491839bd55e872d1b676861642129e825f6474e19" } }, { "id": 510, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "10", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7455b5f7f9bcad94d3ee2eef01ed3870dfabad3a1279c310552161c177330387", "normalized_answer": "10" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7455b5f7f9bcad94d3ee2eef01ed3870dfabad3a1279c310552161c177330387", "normalized_answer": "10" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a chair, a stove, a table, two lamps, a bed, a couch, a toaster, a microwave, and a car. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a chair, a stove, a table, two lamps, a bed, a couch, a toaster, a microwave, and a car. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 10.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5676.3, "reasoner_ms": 1890.93, "tts_ms": 24.76, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7592.01, "total_processing_ms": 8235.47 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 784, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 63 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "71aa468e76ff79c3fe4604b694818e1e4b707a3848644f43b3180d4cf829ce0b", "started_sha256": "27783e67365eaa8c24daa4f79f34fad390fbbb0a2e8f562e0c62185fdb3751f2", "original_grade_sha256": "ce0059fca1fc82e4530bab6d530fda48e5869815a1c76ad44a3193165ace50cb", "input_original_sha256": "71aa468e76ff79c3fe4604b694818e1e4b707a3848644f43b3180d4cf829ce0b", "input_wav_sha256": "1aef6079610ff69303e0a3f933496b906419cac19f8a18ea99a352a26ce06662", "input_pcm_sha256": "c80e77b61a275459bf767e62c4dee18b0b514459b7a5ad43e8152cc3879d2cdc", "output_wav_sha256": "c2df06efe2996afe1af6533dbd54627605f9c17b4dc40ed90713f0772fe34dd8", "output_pcm_sha256": "e6ec173a372608db4f43da45aede443450f2bcd1064dbb1790ea14e0db0ff3e1", "result_sha256": "4ffc068c469e1bf1b14cba47b5a3ed6ae53754d032af7aa7103726b93e5f43fa" } }, { "id": 869, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6a8121318641c876e75bd34b7c2075e5ccf5f93daa22081aaf4a5488c217ae48", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6a8121318641c876e75bd34b7c2075e5ccf5f93daa22081aaf4a5488c217ae48", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Jim tells the truth. Ryan says Jim tells the truth. Millicent says Ryan tells the truth. Audrey says Millicent tells the truth. Eleanor says Audrey tells the truth. Does Eleanor tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Jim tells the truth. Ryan says Jim tells the truth. Millicent says Ryan tells the truth. Audrey says Millicent tells the truth. Eleanor says Audrey tells the truth. Does Eleanor tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5788.01, "reasoner_ms": 2042.67, "tts_ms": 43.5, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7874.21, "total_processing_ms": 8400.48 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 857, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 92 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ed3cb9f19e564f18140dea423b5a765274185fcc98e89b055a693b2b87b47c77", "started_sha256": "acef2c9d6dca76741404f09f6733c5efb09459f7294c923a803db455c83f4dba", "original_grade_sha256": "f82687fd5de478fb6c3759b39a3fa41a854f57474468161b26ce9125f631c50b", "input_original_sha256": "ed3cb9f19e564f18140dea423b5a765274185fcc98e89b055a693b2b87b47c77", "input_wav_sha256": "c37ebdf829ea607dfa60380309dbee979ae9211b7b196d0afd67efd7c250b0a9", "input_pcm_sha256": "f6754406a73f5e5f039af626d6643cef1df25db78a777a8fb03d8ca1575c9e79", "output_wav_sha256": "47270e2e5c61fd8fb6064e6b7c80e28c43f08ee301402035b701bc76d364695a", "output_pcm_sha256": "c59d70ba8a439250b630362ee4b903ef4894755c752d210603f9a48b1d647e5c", "result_sha256": "985f2d2cab21111ba223f5a4afd970dd628783bae397449a24f0a41c5fb77c55" } }, { "id": 9, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9a9d679ab5517fa47c243ec330bfc38aa66f0720b8b3992b9e9a2e45e7b6ab9f", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9a9d679ab5517fa47c243ec330bfc38aa66f0720b8b3992b9e9a2e45e7b6ab9f", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, everyone who is a grandson of Dominic is a workmate of James too. Moreover, whoever is neither a son of Cody nor a son of Ivan is a grandson of Dominic. We may conclude whoever is none of this, a son of Cody or son of Ivan, is a workmate of James. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, everyone who is a grandson of Dominic is a workmate of James too. Moreover, whoever is neither a son of Cody nor a son of Ivan is a grandson of Dominic. We may conclude, whoever is none of this, a son of Cody or son of Ivan, is a workmate of James. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? valid. Options. Valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14258.59, "reasoner_ms": 2359.63, "tts_ms": 40.55, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 16658.81, "total_processing_ms": 17411.32 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1029, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 101 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3b82e5d2bfe4ff9880bd43a9c4d1a16a6ed3e2c3766ffd1260c3262054858f13", "started_sha256": "eeaff218c2e62539239aaacccf91ff5433b1cc8d526c9f90213d3ba8a5197ecf", "original_grade_sha256": "d6d76b5eafc83dfe715a4d5813919332c21e8463649d0047f3d4dd0802013749", "input_original_sha256": "3b82e5d2bfe4ff9880bd43a9c4d1a16a6ed3e2c3766ffd1260c3262054858f13", "input_wav_sha256": "71ecd34bf432d1a2cd9e204ca2ef8ccb694d027331bdc66ddfcf5aa20dff7fde", "input_pcm_sha256": "ff602de398b8de82fb816873194ec1723c4dcb92438b2baaf8c2ee7c276c858f", "output_wav_sha256": "a02df3d081aa4164061e5657f28efd154b00a8bef5b2aa1cd4d5a7797469f71c", "output_pcm_sha256": "ff2f7e31b668715f208d354c80cae9220225d6b75146f75e823a28af5f5ca2c3", "result_sha256": "ea186dfb25c76453e9bbd4a2d7b879400904f2b2de84631fc457e5994f606d14" } }, { "id": 464, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "db9d37e720d82bb4b7c61703fe9d2ac5a64fd7520925ff26e7f38764cc0a7431", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "db9d37e720d82bb4b7c61703fe9d2ac5a64fd7520925ff26e7f38764cc0a7431", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take three steps right. Take one step backward. Take six steps left. Take one step forward. Take three steps right. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take three steps right. Take one step backward. Take six steps left. Take one step forward. Take three steps right. Options. Yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7374.6, "reasoner_ms": 2119.5, "tts_ms": 26.28, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9520.4, "total_processing_ms": 10195.62 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 824, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 67 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5eaa8efc72e4430deb358f0972bc4aa28a7677bdf7a39d9bf944ff7397935f4b", "started_sha256": "2c0e31326f7672606a42ad11d89c41d056f7b6f2b24929d93a337e96b5f161ff", "original_grade_sha256": "8a3675a516a3f543e2b61ab68ded6fcb8ddc4b6e54a8166436d45a6931c6ced9", "input_original_sha256": "5eaa8efc72e4430deb358f0972bc4aa28a7677bdf7a39d9bf944ff7397935f4b", "input_wav_sha256": "11d06b51b336c4db4fd783fa26b37aeebcccf107982a62e2d8eb666b69a60848", "input_pcm_sha256": "29cda6a56ef6993cbd54e21f023c67a7e7bf41cfe172029407f44ff6f59aa058", "output_wav_sha256": "569cea3ab3a54e0fef82ec72066fb6b1edc488b1633e3a8b6cd5cdcef91fe8ee", "output_pcm_sha256": "bb0cda392f60f7c4c0a44e1a1acdb635a5ff93b57305ec1adf60be67b725fd91", "result_sha256": "401093a4a9caf51450aeddfd774473eeb479c65d27889a6c457ac9345ece77d1" } }, { "id": 627, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "8", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b4b1dfa4a51a224c666dfd4e91eca1f0afd9687a25d5dc8f4e39ded5a3f393b1", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b4b1dfa4a51a224c666dfd4e91eca1f0afd9687a25d5dc8f4e39ded5a3f393b1", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a lamp, two couches, two fridges, two ovens, and a bed. How many objects do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a lamp, two couches, two fridges, two ovens, and a bed. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 8.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5097.48, "reasoner_ms": 1534.41, "tts_ms": 23.56, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6655.48, "total_processing_ms": 7318.99 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 755, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 24 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "934d031b8ffda0b281e387b42d7591a27820e7dd584f58a0f957767ecaa7deda", "started_sha256": "05905026fc683b9fd86b6bd16d85056a575512c1f90099070af5ae8cd4ccb175", "original_grade_sha256": "07b5d8390fffbb30d0e81d2a769cbdf8354a0489e9a6e3f22ef77d3a1d2a2c86", "input_original_sha256": "934d031b8ffda0b281e387b42d7591a27820e7dd584f58a0f957767ecaa7deda", "input_wav_sha256": "05bac5c2e513be051cce749c7d8f278d256ded9d9a3a94e65143e47d388be0ef", "input_pcm_sha256": "677c2010b11baeee3a144e75535c04db33e9ba09b167b8fee0a630edb3a304c4", "output_wav_sha256": "c3ca3a734e8c2f2ba9c4d0014f868838df0c0586b684236933e0427b28c60f63", "output_pcm_sha256": "10865f5b168edfd53ac6ac709e52abfea116945b2d15467c7d3dff96de39b1e7", "result_sha256": "4ea03756d5c2009f32256eb642984fee6cfb75d2e1f5ada92392532a230e5119" } }, { "id": 938, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a3bb1bd148dd675baad899f245b922ca026af45d70f1d3e3c117f4297fa7dcaf", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a3bb1bd148dd675baad899f245b922ca026af45d70f1d3e3c117f4297fa7dcaf", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Rashida tells the truth. Jim says Rashida lies. Tamika says Jim tells the truth. Laureen says Tamika tells the truth. Vena says Laureen tells the truth. Does Vena tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Rashida tells the truth. Jim says Rashida lies. Tamika says Jim tells the truth. Laureen says Tamika tells the truth. Veena says Laureen tells the truth. Does Veena tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6243.5, "reasoner_ms": 2342.96, "tts_ms": 31.1, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8617.6, "total_processing_ms": 9171.84 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 843, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 114 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "62ec7393af34590ff368c3147d28f03ae41da23580bed76cc35a5d6b2930a39c", "started_sha256": "557bf3db8281909f4a6e2dfc436467f591b2c1f0c42515a70896bf7d93dc3818", "original_grade_sha256": "a9cca5af5b1fe00aaa738a75159d0fc83efd6d4c7ea8b7088deefa8ab94bf4da", "input_original_sha256": "62ec7393af34590ff368c3147d28f03ae41da23580bed76cc35a5d6b2930a39c", "input_wav_sha256": "354327c6326830e9be2fbb937f423868e4cfce186531f0d299e3b58857a9be4c", "input_pcm_sha256": "389f72ad123ff27d6933d28b67112148a27b4e015db2a8f77f49813fa7f7067b", "output_wav_sha256": "c5e84b3612eb946985c4999ba6b646794a19662be7fd0b00467bb9ce6ae45b8e", "output_pcm_sha256": "cf13ed6fd9fc0b0dceb0f7ecf25596097b7d14ef72ede89f1c8666d6b5e83e7f", "result_sha256": "344524660c6a3f81977e1f3fb2fb7b251f4859936c9a25a1f01ac6145702df0d" } }, { "id": 98, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b536bfb7d900c6c7ac7fd7f8a35e59baa46dd875abf6febd2b596b3e55e252d3", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b536bfb7d900c6c7ac7fd7f8a35e59baa46dd875abf6febd2b596b3e55e252d3", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, Andres is a member of Paris Saint-Germain. Second, it is false that Andres is a follower of FC Mariupol. Third, whoever is a follower of FC Mariupol and a member of Paris Saint-Germain is also a devotee of FC Arouca. Therefore, Andres is not a devotee of FC Arouca. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, Andres is a member of Paris Saint-Germain. Second, it is false that Andres is a follower of F.C. Mariupol. Third, whoever is a follower of F.C. Mariupol and a member of Paris Saint-Germain is also a devotee of F.C. Eruka. Therefore, Andres is not a devotee of F.C. Eruka. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 11663.66, "reasoner_ms": 3019.02, "tts_ms": 24.5, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 14707.2, "total_processing_ms": 15585.12 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1018, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 154 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "eec9c5cb5625fcf6582452c07af2e3cd4a3f370d45006f3cb4b20137811eb92c", "started_sha256": "cf02f13a1180325fbbee9895454d1e7f94303354d386a5890233629c140381f1", "original_grade_sha256": "50100a5e4e51e4968b92b9101b8ddf129452d4686b93c6a1aab4b8ceca4a5cfc", "input_original_sha256": "eec9c5cb5625fcf6582452c07af2e3cd4a3f370d45006f3cb4b20137811eb92c", "input_wav_sha256": "44dbdb5fdce8bef221621e75391e7684040b5798e6e73b09c7ea1d992438f8f8", "input_pcm_sha256": "f69d6d8043df0ba888087adb898d069c01301617d0e70fa0eca444d861b73c71", "output_wav_sha256": "47d221a355b6607df497ab74cee8fe984f874ae9794a72229cf8e81f97d5aaa2", "output_pcm_sha256": "c7968bcb1c4c59e108d496226a6cb3d3e9acbb243c0c76942bfe92e4bf9baeee", "result_sha256": "8f26b8dc9d149475b50df06a77296fa434ee9b4e2e096ed2bc3e6c921ad8cda3" } }, { "id": 264, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c38f0a03805b05f110e3587ccd94a2dc926c04f94f66096dc65f24b25a8e6f9d", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c38f0a03805b05f110e3587ccd94a2dc926c04f94f66096dc65f24b25a8e6f9d", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take three steps left. Take ten steps right. Take seven steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point always face forward take three steps left take ten steps right take seven steps left options yes no answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8330.17, "reasoner_ms": 1757.13, "tts_ms": 50.13, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10137.46, "total_processing_ms": 10813.91 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 790, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 48 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "aa672768ac66e56cd4221abcbc1838539fb5029396bf2db9801897027057f9fb", "started_sha256": "b3129f65b6017419473b0b70310a704182d5ce366120b070c836908ef5d470d4", "original_grade_sha256": "eb9a789b0343795cf9901a618d3042f5caed6572abe6131528d9d665f2137231", "input_original_sha256": "aa672768ac66e56cd4221abcbc1838539fb5029396bf2db9801897027057f9fb", "input_wav_sha256": "b342938930387c405777ff0ce0207e905465a1c3636cf50bb2c7838816e4653e", "input_pcm_sha256": "3d3e3dd79cc1bf052753bdb012fa0baab6c204cdfdc45eeb744fe21e96e028c9", "output_wav_sha256": "4ef2c019c67d339fab40b6d74804439221b1acc29f20bb0ac39a7ef1333574f3", "output_pcm_sha256": "ae0ab1bdbce961556c3598af1ede74f299aeba62b1f23a9b6ffef104507ecf23", "result_sha256": "4ef0fa74bbb78e5b5a4cc26e01cb42061ad226cebb18e7d6f7b3c60733c48416" } }, { "id": 718, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "11", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6573b1f4cf1d6bf02f34bcfecfbef4b5d038810dd30d8b030e254dbf3fbf95ae", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6573b1f4cf1d6bf02f34bcfecfbef4b5d038810dd30d8b030e254dbf3fbf95ae", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a potato, a cabbage, a cauliflower, a duck, an onion, a lettuce head, a garlic, a bear, a head of broccoli, a carrot, a chicken, and three yams. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a potato, a cabbage, a cauliflower, a duck, an onion, a lettuce head, a garlic, a bear, a head of broccoli, a carrot, a chicken, and three yams. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 11.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6574.95, "reasoner_ms": 2291.9, "tts_ms": 42.54, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8909.42, "total_processing_ms": 9670.62 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 840, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 151 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3875e30f8e9f1c01f80686d9c559d823a3d5df6c898ab7e2a925480bdb17844b", "started_sha256": "e5d55b43444f849cb3659b318a1ec90664e24da5d054e8321cc4174624a28a21", "original_grade_sha256": "c031a55e82738d4b3d5691c85b6df08b80d31cda5fa7463b05c24fff8fc8de9c", "input_original_sha256": "3875e30f8e9f1c01f80686d9c559d823a3d5df6c898ab7e2a925480bdb17844b", "input_wav_sha256": "a9ebc447bf3dfc41ad3d7da94b3f2b0b2fb1a87859a955cc9b60f68b53da76d2", "input_pcm_sha256": "a6beff009e786f0e3b346e8dadc88a900dceb7dea53ad9d55b25c6589e389a06", "output_wav_sha256": "e76486bec4ba83f7e901703448b2c237ce6f7b3049de49f853466c8cf3fa0747", "output_pcm_sha256": "06bb22a4bde367cff064124ab4d4d219455f171deadb8d0b6f9203198fa1470a", "result_sha256": "d8d18fa951158417294c4612071cf2d182d0326924528a4b502df6e5bb31ea8c" } }, { "id": 964, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "839700dadb74e2f0d0a9423a9808c16046d753419ff9c56db9d8c3d46b6d9987", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "839700dadb74e2f0d0a9423a9808c16046d753419ff9c56db9d8c3d46b6d9987", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Jim lies. Delfina says Jim tells the truth. Shonda says Delfina lies. Fidel says Shonda lies. Sal says Fidel tells the truth. Does Sal tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion jim lies delphina says jim tells the truth shonda says delphina lies fidel says shonda lies sal says fidel tells the truth does sal tell the truth answer the question Thank you for your question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8428.62, "reasoner_ms": 2536.36, "tts_ms": 27.67, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10992.67, "total_processing_ms": 11713.71 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 818, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 121 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "127598cb41751eb7be91abd6c7de72ae2ea6e0d9e39463134a77e9716db16d15", "started_sha256": "d1582f220bf021aeb49f725305134f4966b9c6a449d3548fd2386ab124066e3d", "original_grade_sha256": "4ca695e45e2ad73c5227a755c30a2c6eda159d05a4f6a77f613c72fae0830d72", "input_original_sha256": "127598cb41751eb7be91abd6c7de72ae2ea6e0d9e39463134a77e9716db16d15", "input_wav_sha256": "95aebfd63dcd6927bbc16c0cbe109c5eb1a4e80d8c2828d87393f5473b03faa3", "input_pcm_sha256": "a22bb1075e9f93d7e05d4988aa3196e5775489c00f212eca43af69360fbaf841", "output_wav_sha256": "1c584848df4edac81b324d4c530dea6cf54562d6ca493d212eb434f88e7d796f", "output_pcm_sha256": "561b834cd6a13a47b7225c4e5b2be16b8f2bbf1fd2ff3a478348cf72e1779f05", "result_sha256": "abb457a701c635d6cfd5c04da0b60ccc7ab91172e098442e4597fcd1874b5779" } }, { "id": 109, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b09f463ade75573eac059a31dfba2204f320723369261aacbaf879804b46309d", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b09f463ade75573eac059a31dfba2204f320723369261aacbaf879804b46309d", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, it is not the case that Santo is a grandson of Lance. Next, being a nephew of Ned or a cousin of Tony is sufficient for being a grandson of Lance. Hence, it is not the case that Santo is a nephew of Ned or a cousin of Tony. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom, and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, it is not the case that Santo is a grandson of Lance. Next, being a nephew of Ned, or a cousin of Tony, is sufficient for being a grandson of Lance. Hence it is not the case that Santo is a nephew of Ned or a cousin of Tony. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14188.27, "reasoner_ms": 2273.27, "tts_ms": 33.68, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 16495.25, "total_processing_ms": 17222.55 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 918, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 105 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b1cd3e256f028a5df9b46e65673163a536d98c4a1bae53f08bf54edb7e871c9d", "started_sha256": "c831751fb96e3c79598ec7f87497c337694e2326b116180087aeabc5daffc15c", "original_grade_sha256": "c4295338d35c0c1f5ac386ec356d28f159642b63477348871fe9738fc612ad3f", "input_original_sha256": "b1cd3e256f028a5df9b46e65673163a536d98c4a1bae53f08bf54edb7e871c9d", "input_wav_sha256": "bf37144daf988bed9a7f5bf3ee88b1b128d4e2dccff9b02fee7527f2ded20b09", "input_pcm_sha256": "d53f798dee252ad3d24799bfc8197b0376d1ea3a0aea3a0063e15dac775b94de", "output_wav_sha256": "a6c9955f20bd8068fb4b09979af719b04fba20a4b17d15c857f7d20743d0e7e4", "output_pcm_sha256": "93383a9dd3f500a749bc9780512b2661388874d917885cf28ddc4f7bc02709c9", "result_sha256": "a038921cc7bf3f10b77fa621d937d1a0ab4828d740252c7da49270a314ff34f4" } }, { "id": 493, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a4256942475ff58f279678ef5c5c99ba98dca463c1869806cb5d4107f7956174", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a4256942475ff58f279678ef5c5c99ba98dca463c1869806cb5d4107f7956174", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps right. Take four steps backward. Take eight steps left. Take five steps left. Take six steps backward. Take nine steps forward. Take five steps right. Take one step forward. Take three steps right. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps right. Take four steps backward. Take eight steps left. Take five steps left. Take six steps backward. Take nine steps forward. Take five steps right. Take one step forward. Take three steps right. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9178.04, "reasoner_ms": 2577.06, "tts_ms": 25.47, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11780.6, "total_processing_ms": 12491.66 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 889, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 129 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a866d4847fd6d980afb45ba097f1cd243cdfe4635ea5e6a39a936179cba0d950", "started_sha256": "aa704df387c2d14b33e3d7fea08baf97932fe1dd894f4310bfc9abb6df56757c", "original_grade_sha256": "99302eda22ba5eceb4d0174a467187ce36c4b701fb1d0d1c696e1aba9ad0a44b", "input_original_sha256": "a866d4847fd6d980afb45ba097f1cd243cdfe4635ea5e6a39a936179cba0d950", "input_wav_sha256": "d86f4c15c2700d225677f6ae619ba2a251903d3cc7be9856b9b8878726d1a4c2", "input_pcm_sha256": "3243d84fca82fdacbd35c4b7448282861b9a11889297c19d15e44d387f8489c9", "output_wav_sha256": "f97fc5deef2f959d2d8299e646e471c247034318f5471674a04f9b5995b7fc1b", "output_pcm_sha256": "4cc0ade437f334e15c78cd056bcaa28917268dfd1802545bf27876950311efdd", "result_sha256": "90b0ddff1d8078f2fcca6c133d14dfba005530b430f5911b704acb25979ca5f8" } }, { "id": 569, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "4", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9daac297516927eb463d64197588edf3257deae8d902e9cc4584ce36d6d84a98", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9daac297516927eb463d64197588edf3257deae8d902e9cc4584ce36d6d84a98", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a trumpet, a flute, an accordion, and a trombone. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a trumpet, a flute, an accordion, and a trombone. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 4.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5106.87, "reasoner_ms": 1341.27, "tts_ms": 27.05, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6475.21, "total_processing_ms": 7172.68 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 755, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "181c1a15ecb88bc0dd600faa5c274700089c7fbcc89b0b921e236c0d6a54d51e", "started_sha256": "076c00b40b8b697a849192d521aff9eac1eae774e59a139a86315617ac1cff77", "original_grade_sha256": "e1b5dcbdd80235974ce68660b5e0fd8a87cbbc6f76993f45f621766cb0f274f8", "input_original_sha256": "181c1a15ecb88bc0dd600faa5c274700089c7fbcc89b0b921e236c0d6a54d51e", "input_wav_sha256": "6bd12efe7056c2f9894a7f7d6ab3bce66273819c4c2a4b9114051077a94f5745", "input_pcm_sha256": "4251b6185e359700f660e9339ca142160176eaf9bb576d8b772e8cc5dc0bd9fa", "output_wav_sha256": "cdb3184ff7b8ef8102678f6b3feb61898653334d3a4855c5915346c5290bce2f", "output_pcm_sha256": "06f9d8b5eb1961c8a5f4a2c27cb7e115db784f6c434cdfe36a10c0c13a99e50f", "result_sha256": "2ed85f2ec7fe8399171fddc42f941e0ed49706114464b67432494aa53b9413d5" } }, { "id": 856, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "efd94dbca4382240366dfe20e5ed0e6b3ebf9601fbfd3441f9b6aec58f5b834b", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "efd94dbca4382240366dfe20e5ed0e6b3ebf9601fbfd3441f9b6aec58f5b834b", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Eleanor tells the truth. Lita says Eleanor lies. Osvaldo says Lita tells the truth. Jim says Osvaldo lies. Gwen says Jim lies. Does Gwen tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion eleanor tells the truth lida says eleanor lies osvaldo says lida tells the truth jim says osvaldo lies gwen says jim lies does gwen tell the truth answer the question Thank you for your question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8782.76, "reasoner_ms": 2478.71, "tts_ms": 27.98, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11289.47, "total_processing_ms": 12016.68 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 830, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 129 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "934b000184985a61f134666540e9fb2cf6c17b6d6c8a3df1d094c8d6dcb17304", "started_sha256": "a35f5c8a2971747af9a06bdce7d80f8377db180732e29854119cbade69f9e947", "original_grade_sha256": "c91244e9759b097548814df83f1e0b13c294698a749e867098ce547fde22f546", "input_original_sha256": "934b000184985a61f134666540e9fb2cf6c17b6d6c8a3df1d094c8d6dcb17304", "input_wav_sha256": "b11952dd003e8c51efd6d489aa6a0c709730d88f5a5a64ffba3b0dd4895dffe9", "input_pcm_sha256": "8236cfe13c5c525e56a652039dec77b601262a7749368827fb8d5f9553dc453e", "output_wav_sha256": "33be75eae3f86be1fb40e0e3a50c0a957b056bebf2e6fac108b0a791d3bd99ec", "output_pcm_sha256": "85bf9de98210e0d2738cc917ea52ff576ea2554dff45308b017d928a9eaf8a5a", "result_sha256": "9b434cdc84807e3ae466e58743e7fae1e974a1365627b6c52eac9e297054d226" } }, { "id": 136, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3148f005255aa08eaee3eb7afa97eed80ef20d08fe3cb4627b5097191930e9ab", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3148f005255aa08eaee3eb7afa97eed80ef20d08fe3cb4627b5097191930e9ab", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, some sister of Doreen is a daughter of Melinda. Now, whoever is not a daughter of Melinda is a cousin of Leslie. From this follows, some cousin of Leslie is not a sister of Doreen. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, some sister of Doreen is a daughter of Melinda. Now, whoever is not a daughter of Melinda is a cousin of Leslie. From this follows, some cousin of Leslie is not a sister of Doreen. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8403.85, "reasoner_ms": 7240.94, "tts_ms": 22.52, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15667.33, "total_processing_ms": 16384.92 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 945, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 512 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "0a7504853d6d3074bb058a0f630d9e204ea6fc9871ebdc437707be13c8cb5c3a", "started_sha256": "33f49af4c82e37094f97106bfa713fa041e559a4a2a03178ba872502ffa770f0", "original_grade_sha256": "3805a81fd3b604cd543dde454abc3735a6ec32561690e46bed699787662202e3", "input_original_sha256": "0a7504853d6d3074bb058a0f630d9e204ea6fc9871ebdc437707be13c8cb5c3a", "input_wav_sha256": "b98d352d63e4623dd2c654d7f6da9126c250407bd2590add2611f2fcf2b9d937", "input_pcm_sha256": "4df9467b0b03c444f495a1b0934c472497d09e9c5198dd2ce1e929cc3d03a68e", "output_wav_sha256": "5cd3f19d1007837464cf279663385b93cd902ae319caeac6adc71c4da74c0814", "output_pcm_sha256": "616da2440c2a51a62f99e1a88dcd0046ae4e84617bf7b4e9ba56a899ba131c1a", "result_sha256": "2b8619f1e6914ebfaba3e844e07c766e891b8252777958796aa48d35ee4b7ef6" } }, { "id": 391, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "014421c9e4c8d623b69ea4c1eb83b10f1ec265d23c2fa36d01a6ffd6f43b4642", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "014421c9e4c8d623b69ea4c1eb83b10f1ec265d23c2fa36d01a6ffd6f43b4642", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take five steps. Take ten steps. Turn around. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take five steps. Take ten steps. Turn around. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5644.63, "reasoner_ms": 1951.96, "tts_ms": 25.65, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7622.27, "total_processing_ms": 8340.72 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 778, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 64 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "68a6897725454f6209830ee2c1c632b790716a579d9b8e36b5a33c227e7896c3", "started_sha256": "600f3d1513c8161fafeb8be6bf2f88fe5990dee60719746892c54b343753d8a4", "original_grade_sha256": "98b1dfda5e7223e1043d50fe15879bc80f32dc040ad1625010a1fb00af2bfc2c", "input_original_sha256": "68a6897725454f6209830ee2c1c632b790716a579d9b8e36b5a33c227e7896c3", "input_wav_sha256": "fd5aafe6266c2fc219f33d00717b4d87bbe9a0af1c6c4d8ca767935bd96eaff2", "input_pcm_sha256": "df5afe4c7e002255ec13c36f1617cfb63d7e722393310db7f77e33960ec01f60", "output_wav_sha256": "bc8abd9c39eb574a66012fb9702401ea2139547e892f8c55944bf547edf76c15", "output_pcm_sha256": "10fd80a978b3b90ac5b7acb582a07da345946b06f6f79e1bcbe58b38b6e057cd", "result_sha256": "3409dbbbf33cdd6034fa2afb775058176dd8d8b2b681611d77eab96bbccc8988" } }, { "id": 675, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "12", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2fb726c25df797b21f19f40e4676d94a31609d62907169dbce8284356ffa1c04", "normalized_answer": "12" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2fb726c25df797b21f19f40e4676d94a31609d62907169dbce8284356ffa1c04", "normalized_answer": "12" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a potato, a carrot, two onions, a cauliflower, a plum, a lettuce head, five stalks of celery, and a yam. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a potato, a carrot, two onions, a cauliflower, a plum, a lettuce head, five stalks of celery, and a yam. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 12.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5549.03, "reasoner_ms": 4358.29, "tts_ms": 28.53, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9935.88, "total_processing_ms": 10718.23 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 799, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 264 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f3ac314b2006b8881a63d0bea67d3af8364bbdba6b95c67e7254a79321918eec", "started_sha256": "96cf0605b140a3cffb18476c49d5a188f205e5386123add5493414c1b9d89da4", "original_grade_sha256": "bdd37dd238a7063ab839d83b8c3579dac2e593242016f891f811b23f4d56d388", "input_original_sha256": "f3ac314b2006b8881a63d0bea67d3af8364bbdba6b95c67e7254a79321918eec", "input_wav_sha256": "13538ae6fd87553dd340009feb97024d1d34e7483e917f32ea61af645b167852", "input_pcm_sha256": "61489a172385d75ffbb19fd89d4ae889a7edf9395dc12fddc836088b6a831f05", "output_wav_sha256": "34ef530e60a70030beab78d5b18c429bf8ca370d99bc09c3b82419fd45c3e6fc", "output_pcm_sha256": "7b4a9fc7f997b3c8a791cf549f3c81f06398100bf4ba92d4fc4299b135a181a6", "result_sha256": "21b8b271eb925402dc27aba2d706d2ba6f6070527f85c0d27d1fbf40f7388914" } }, { "id": 877, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "34a8d7afc9aba341a0ed241d04e91ef5a4ea05c9e5dd95de8154a7fa88608bcc", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "34a8d7afc9aba341a0ed241d04e91ef5a4ea05c9e5dd95de8154a7fa88608bcc", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Christie lies. Jamie says Christie lies. Laureen says Jamie tells the truth. Bernita says Laureen tells the truth. Delfina says Bernita lies. Does Delfina tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Christy lies. Jamie says Christy lies. Lauren says Jamie tells the truth. Bernita says Lauren tells the truth. Delfina says Bernita lies. Does Delfina tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6272.42, "reasoner_ms": 2449.4, "tts_ms": 58.92, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8780.77, "total_processing_ms": 9473.91 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 128 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d9d8964ce66eb8d196669a986ce5a5307da9a8e7e0011707815619ee9ac2f9af", "started_sha256": "b452e54ed07b72f07fb708b2db4dac9d0053eb7734874e8871c9648ba84a1828", "original_grade_sha256": "9ea86612d1e256f9c883b57e6e6025cdeef4c4ecc2c5491cdca4cebd3b889ad1", "input_original_sha256": "d9d8964ce66eb8d196669a986ce5a5307da9a8e7e0011707815619ee9ac2f9af", "input_wav_sha256": "90a52431222bd03ed58148e7f1c063778db6e84dacbad2c766a513411310d70e", "input_pcm_sha256": "898bdadccef778395f9095c816405c602b103ae0a72e71818f6d68eba3bad0eb", "output_wav_sha256": "bb394b9037398aa6aadcf21aa6c7e1403557f48f7e752aa61327f0e3b4a47942", "output_pcm_sha256": "71f6562e6a334853659fe9954cf8d5cfcde60933ed74a3c290ba8a9f8557cd28", "result_sha256": "efc26d3d8c5d519f626a1204bd0ac376b36ded869d9665e24ce3bebbccb37c32" } }, { "id": 25, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "002b43e5a4e73a99d94a811fa2b29f7737e1baebdb1ea1e3600d9d47e57873cc", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "002b43e5a4e73a99d94a811fa2b29f7737e1baebdb1ea1e3600d9d47e57873cc", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a cousin of Robert? Is Joe related to Bob? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First premise: Nobody is neither a workmate of Calvin nor a schoolmate of Barton. We may conclude being a workmate of Calvin is necessary for not being a schoolmate of Barton. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Fred a cousin of Robert? Is Joe related to Bob? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First premise. Nobody is neither a workmate of Calvin nor a schoolmate of Barton. We may conclude being a workmate of Calvin is necessary for not being a schoolmate of Barton. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13936.87, "reasoner_ms": 3432.3, "tts_ms": 25.54, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17394.74, "total_processing_ms": 18171.13 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1024, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 215 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "aff4c63436282f7cc2fd3739dff888736fe52dd8057dec0cd2ae2065948e0ffb", "started_sha256": "e3b3bd120c1f9dc7f3440ee9459f40f98855801f9c58440034a1675a04e63b9b", "original_grade_sha256": "919736ea7fad9d59a36a4c68de40944f5784872223a46d164659cb70924b2dff", "input_original_sha256": "aff4c63436282f7cc2fd3739dff888736fe52dd8057dec0cd2ae2065948e0ffb", "input_wav_sha256": "a54ab630c9a4a6902ddcb127f98421021c8b0f317b94f04ba9cfcb457b960ff4", "input_pcm_sha256": "7e41128575fd3c0907a91c4cca1d371c03ef871e0e1df49334da00d37f26eb15", "output_wav_sha256": "43ecc554342bb39b2b1c2e9bbb44e1bb85804e4617bc24f36bc9365f65c9d5cb", "output_pcm_sha256": "ac68c5066a73547e8039f223f5b59151c8a873a2700980472ba65a31ab55957f", "result_sha256": "4c80f593abea5a79c23ca1db2fc777cb3a8c6ec8a2745fdf2f7a236adfefb2ec" } }, { "id": 344, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d3c7b87fa616c6162985085bc71e626aed3cf83113bd3c9b157d954cb4e465c6", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d3c7b87fa616c6162985085bc71e626aed3cf83113bd3c9b157d954cb4e465c6", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left. Turn left. Take 10 steps. Take six steps. Turn left. Take three steps. Take three steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left. Turn left. Take ten steps. Take six steps. Turn left. Take three steps. Take three steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7049.23, "reasoner_ms": 2793.22, "tts_ms": 24.8, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9867.27, "total_processing_ms": 10677.32 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 822, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 153 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "647254e22879c4de2f1c89d747a7b828d4c265c4cde5be9ac02aef61c4984a5f", "started_sha256": "09b6ce7aecaff040e75b927b9a0a9d64410d3578d0c4f3b3d8e169081d43b13d", "original_grade_sha256": "2fa46d64f7a57ad05ec1a997a8b5a5b6343be2aa94b6476400e43fc1c21e2310", "input_original_sha256": "647254e22879c4de2f1c89d747a7b828d4c265c4cde5be9ac02aef61c4984a5f", "input_wav_sha256": "6c7312db7eac1fe301dc0c92ebb4922723b4cbc1fa0b6ce57e5476c266bbba15", "input_pcm_sha256": "06069957878d8c757f953e7fde6ca632dad5d980c5470d04d9aa1c12551ad1b4", "output_wav_sha256": "d44146003295574ef33d17b2be9c73cd97360454ec59a84ae7828de46c92c974", "output_pcm_sha256": "fabc801c69c3bdeb04024505a004dbbcd9e341cfa24a0721e34229a4a09f616b", "result_sha256": "6d2b663220586633b22352008ce736a5beffed8aee00b5c126ab56370a3c64d1" } }, { "id": 546, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5f33d49cbd43945fd2c2e3d358c8a7c11c1865ac0478fb7138aa23242d6fa427", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5f33d49cbd43945fd2c2e3d358c8a7c11c1865ac0478fb7138aa23242d6fa427", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a trumpet, four trombones, an accordion, a clarinet, a violin, and a drum. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a trumpet four trombones an accordion a clarinet a violin and a drum how many musical instruments do i have answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 9.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8743.95, "reasoner_ms": 1829.89, "tts_ms": 26.06, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10599.93, "total_processing_ms": 11381.32 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 769, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 53 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3879ee260253b2b839f6368bc35e048cacf049d673a1d2ff136b9e8c0240b100", "started_sha256": "db551e64189e5d80076eab9cb337198d729aad2ef1d69ee7dad5abc78dfdbd60", "original_grade_sha256": "0830865095218bb1ee7c38af43356dfaafaf75aa4c50ac024e5310df3c6abd67", "input_original_sha256": "3879ee260253b2b839f6368bc35e048cacf049d673a1d2ff136b9e8c0240b100", "input_wav_sha256": "793c6efc10dfddfc011b71ad0ef546db676a17ad2b81f51d06b1724c7fced25e", "input_pcm_sha256": "900087dd385a363bbb62059b0d980bfc3bf5366be05181bbbe2b16846949b381", "output_wav_sha256": "2a0635e3743af9e7823543b76c57b48a0cc8dd61c687206721d229c5847c44d2", "output_pcm_sha256": "2c4d9ab746deb52dca174970bbecd3d375a63b513444ba3d1a34d5f32d15e29c", "result_sha256": "e11541ec4c1b0a59d71871285dfc1ed7b57b116a922ffd6b5fff15772eed3b46" } }, { "id": 835, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bc4d659fc57d20b48dfb285da1315a3228e0fac0efb3d3d0ebc385eb796805a1", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bc4d659fc57d20b48dfb285da1315a3228e0fac0efb3d3d0ebc385eb796805a1", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Bonita tells the truth. Audrey says Bonita lies. Delfina says Audrey tells the truth. Vina says Delfina lies. Sal says Vina tells the truth. Does Sal tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Benita tells the truth. Audrey says Benita lies. Delphina says Audrey tells the truth. Veena says Delphina lies. Sal says Veena tells the truth. Does Sal tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6165.33, "reasoner_ms": 2243.66, "tts_ms": 27.95, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8436.96, "total_processing_ms": 9027.62 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 116 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "999b821b86c8bbde1e60ab56d637729b813714d1e224750f6148496301454632", "started_sha256": "696e4ba884d941f748ed2df1fde905c47ffdfe094b709d78b7775da56d05a942", "original_grade_sha256": "da21d6067d84ea834d00fcf5419549a9ff4b4ffde807c5dc3d67c573fa0f03f4", "input_original_sha256": "999b821b86c8bbde1e60ab56d637729b813714d1e224750f6148496301454632", "input_wav_sha256": "858696eaf2e7bea5f3c039c49461623be044c18f0b9b1242c38d8d44f968b32d", "input_pcm_sha256": "e6856210956315174f8d255771abd652eab9c2dcacd171b8de16c65b2e63d98f", "output_wav_sha256": "9185f0301370c3885bac6a4750ebf2a8f8ba24bcab6498bc262c490676f40948", "output_pcm_sha256": "d1f440128739bda567c5bc3f7dd197c64b6a3124fffbbbacefc1dc435cb9e143", "result_sha256": "0307cbf5540bb9fc86b8c18709db66d24b5013246b310184355af23a8d9d2917" } }, { "id": 22, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "22b4bec3a724940733f49384e4e8feddd8e929767a593104f7a950ceb8539d0f", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "22b4bec3a724940733f49384e4e8feddd8e929767a593104f7a950ceb8539d0f", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a cousin of Robert? Is Joe related to Bob? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First of all, some uncle of Dominic is a schoolmate of Earl. Next, everyone who is both an uncle of Reyes and an uncle of Corey is not a schoolmate of Earl. All this entails that some uncle of Dominic is not an uncle of Reyes or not an uncle of Corey. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Fred a cousin of Robert? Is Joe related to Bob? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First of all, some uncle of Dominic is a schoolmate of Earl. Next, everyone who is both an uncle of Reyes and an uncle of Corey is not a schoolmate of Earl. All this entails that some uncle of Dominic is not an uncle of Reyes or not an uncle of Corey. is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14574.01, "reasoner_ms": 5937.55, "tts_ms": 24.73, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 20536.32, "total_processing_ms": 21142.77 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1086, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 308 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6fd8fa7fa0cefda5466638aace35993edbd67fd6c5d26a4e06864d3620bf2198", "started_sha256": "d5bbf42f65b3a774a224029be7a4773cf5b8459edac46f8c3148c196063b8c26", "original_grade_sha256": "71a92c4eb81b065399af3f395654a5b908af33fc11597701e9fac2c2e2f12147", "input_original_sha256": "6fd8fa7fa0cefda5466638aace35993edbd67fd6c5d26a4e06864d3620bf2198", "input_wav_sha256": "da9fdf6578672d19f2e4344916a2838377ec56716433fba0bada3f788a564780", "input_pcm_sha256": "6abd10e144a9e84e39b6cb237e8ea590a3ae006c896c0a0e3c6b3255c1a72e45", "output_wav_sha256": "723964a84cead2f28d6e1907ac90a6be3889079ea609472ff4037a04c472f9c1", "output_pcm_sha256": "99b95cfafb550ea9886d9618af1f699717bb6d3aab184b898ab7431d74fbbcd9", "result_sha256": "ef0ac230e29f7c4c36679658988d6f6bbc5d3e18d0e5d7ce8ac7d1e40ba764d8" } }, { "id": 421, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "edca443a83b3ab857bec2dda43d70fc4212386a4cdc0a7f32bdf4abe3e123410", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "edca443a83b3ab857bec2dda43d70fc4212386a4cdc0a7f32bdf4abe3e123410", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take ten steps right. Take eight steps backward. Take one step backward. Take eight steps backward. Take eight steps forward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take 10 steps right. Take 8 steps backward. Take 1 step backward. Take 8 steps backward. Take 8 steps forward. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7205.27, "reasoner_ms": 2859.38, "tts_ms": 23.92, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10088.6, "total_processing_ms": 10778.0 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 843, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 98 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "18f0200c958d8f28b6909ea263e2199f6a6663946b10c39a981258a7dd2fb713", "started_sha256": "457aa9204195d358643f0521856c2554845b33b827622a1d2ac5a9f408ad0d07", "original_grade_sha256": "49dacf36b7b49309007716585b2e1430bd282c5eca653d5a6b995ceaa8ad63ce", "input_original_sha256": "18f0200c958d8f28b6909ea263e2199f6a6663946b10c39a981258a7dd2fb713", "input_wav_sha256": "263b244f9bf76f5801424258b7652525a2f518bfc176c11aa0c385f9895c6e9e", "input_pcm_sha256": "f2f0a448de1ef8ad76b239d211e0bf87bc5f00f29debe707b55cc2c69725ba93", "output_wav_sha256": "4731fed8c8e08bd2d234264074fad05f05b4a6540cfebf15aa3c2d0083577dac", "output_pcm_sha256": "c23f75c4dd03891d23566b4df9830f9499e2e5e18659319f624e94d64867ac62", "result_sha256": "dacdc6479bce4583baa3c0c2054f99e5673c650159215165f37bea619b0c5419" } }, { "id": 712, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "8", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a8c87c8fd3396245641d5289897c970526405a978c33b3d73c166cabe927b7a0", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a8c87c8fd3396245641d5289897c970526405a978c33b3d73c166cabe927b7a0", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have three clarinets, a trombone, two pianos, an accordion, and a trumpet. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have three clarinets, a trombone, two pianos, an accordion, and a trumpet. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 8.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5636.94, "reasoner_ms": 1474.36, "tts_ms": 24.13, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7135.45, "total_processing_ms": 7952.53 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 769, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 22 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "40f5e39fbfa2c29c47a3c234c1b42455ab7e27cdae217b24f519611a04690dda", "started_sha256": "a2675ede2fd6a1207b33d5126629553c70727acb5efebba4df03b9e2a8298168", "original_grade_sha256": "62f04b943772e039bed1d53a26a0274626c86aeee7588a861168f3c030f0bc55", "input_original_sha256": "40f5e39fbfa2c29c47a3c234c1b42455ab7e27cdae217b24f519611a04690dda", "input_wav_sha256": "37790b9e7ccf463dd7f37cca214a925bc4252385fe51c47ec572b5022b67eab6", "input_pcm_sha256": "6f1046d18bc67996899c52b3e36bedcbdebbe4f1ae8527f3d43c31688e39b08d", "output_wav_sha256": "e4233c7588b798f21c5e12e81cfa2b024fe5d8a01d79259dcc5771af2a1422b0", "output_pcm_sha256": "1a3f3fd42cc52db866333097a4a09bb24ae69c688c199851dc0d585b0fdbd685", "result_sha256": "b6e261c6659eae6dd1aa3c4a8a4c425a20d392b8d8731b4299648398fb0aef5f" } }, { "id": 840, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "da935cc21b1820e8a5c1d302ca3bb70993ad8f2655a83c072582be80459f7feb", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "da935cc21b1820e8a5c1d302ca3bb70993ad8f2655a83c072582be80459f7feb", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Jamie lies. Gwen says Jamie tells the truth. Yolen says Gwen tells the truth. Candy says Yolen tells the truth. Osvaldo says Candy tells the truth. Does Osvaldo tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion jamie lies gwen says jamie tells the truth yoland says gwen tells the truth candy says yoland tells the truth osvaldo says candy tells the truth does osvaldo tell the truth answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "That answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8954.03, "reasoner_ms": 2093.96, "tts_ms": 24.56, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11072.58, "total_processing_ms": 11863.92 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 836, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 118 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2b3e3c8fdaebd3a1534b82587d293378a737ab8440f0bfc1faf690f4f7df9ec3", "started_sha256": "e77cd5682872dc32741dce849607622c05ed242556aa89a6b2179c6bc35e811f", "original_grade_sha256": "20d09d09d8e7e8a35f961cc46e12916e7ff95c41af45b5e1c65f1ede55e62cdd", "input_original_sha256": "2b3e3c8fdaebd3a1534b82587d293378a737ab8440f0bfc1faf690f4f7df9ec3", "input_wav_sha256": "95949eb46e542d6ac4a931f2aded63e5f2b5ea851a907d85ae627a556bd8f999", "input_pcm_sha256": "40a9f159714439c04370d5798e011c05765480c43c1b881ccd21209460a98e7d", "output_wav_sha256": "d8075653277f3bebe5b97572180a12c10693b64b95311a02a7ae80992f1b0d6d", "output_pcm_sha256": "84ea1508197440caa6697edc774104a0d1cee4c6c1b79f8c19414aa1e9795772", "result_sha256": "e1f4250cdebac0d931ee62281399b1d1c9afe0d0afa1bea012eaf61253a4919a" } }, { "id": 196, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "18538e200513cc0e458e30c2322274506c41c2ec89044d863c55c4bee7c721f7", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "18538e200513cc0e458e30c2322274506c41c2ec89044d863c55c4bee7c721f7", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nSome football fans admire various clubs. Others love only a single team. But who is a fan of whom precisely? The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, nobody is neither an expert of FC Shakhtar Donetsk nor an opponent to PFC CSKA Moscow. Moreover, some opponent to PFC CSKA Moscow is not both a friend of Real Sociedad de F\u00fatbol and an expert of FC Pyunik. Hence, there is somebody who is a friend of Real Sociedad de F\u00fatbol, an expert of FC Pyunik, and an expert of FC Shakhtar Donetsk. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nSome football fans admire various clubs, others love only a single team. But who is a fan of whom precisely? The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, nobody is neither an expert of FC Shakhtar Donetsk nor an opponent to PFC CSK Moskva. Moreover, some opponent to PFC CSK Moskva is not both a friend of Real Sociedad de Futbol and an expert of FC Punic. Hence, there is somebody who is a friend of Real Sociedad de Futbol, an expert of F.C. Punick, and an expert of F.C. Shakhtar Donetsk. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 16585.01, "reasoner_ms": 4802.52, "tts_ms": 33.68, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 21421.23, "total_processing_ms": 22071.76 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1167, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 266 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "c4e62b9d2ab72e87c86ec0a0d1d5b24cb3d9aac3054bf45d7a63030c1bef1596", "started_sha256": "7fdc7740248ac1247aab69db53395b8f3c4997bfd3c76f0a62db3f83a0469e14", "original_grade_sha256": "189c83dc8a1f8517c01c507f8eb6249eceff47f58409ec0d61c6749632cd52e3", "input_original_sha256": "c4e62b9d2ab72e87c86ec0a0d1d5b24cb3d9aac3054bf45d7a63030c1bef1596", "input_wav_sha256": "7087d705ed7af8a69eb00c2537aa74fd245cbff726f516e35c3798ef391545a6", "input_pcm_sha256": "fb3dd24d809224d51580c11886f43f2d9d0cc6dc9a5e1ee27e1347a28c550966", "output_wav_sha256": "68b5e7049febcdfe79388f5f97cec224722e5613532d8d82668cf5875ff8dca6", "output_pcm_sha256": "ecbe1c63484612fc3ba1af1bd7d1df6e0a925811ce2f6b74b8e31793d815a560", "result_sha256": "afe41bbf4dfd1fe05e9afb78b455d486c9260c280b5df7b3dfd3d4312d512fcf" } }, { "id": 438, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3ac750f2ac0b9e522c37e54a6730aa7d866377f645e56581a167fc1703b4e90f", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "3ac750f2ac0b9e522c37e54a6730aa7d866377f645e56581a167fc1703b4e90f", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn right. Take five steps. Take six steps. Take four steps. Take one step. Turn around. Take six steps. Take ten steps. Turn around. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point turn right take five steps take six steps take four steps take one step turn around take six steps take ten steps turn around options yes no answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6045.12, "reasoner_ms": 3016.39, "tts_ms": 27.51, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9089.06, "total_processing_ms": 9754.7 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 816, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 126 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "5976145c5819ea6722f1322dcc18856d154c225f37bd368960ace9935475e6c6", "started_sha256": "f8df3dfb688a37e505966726d93d8d1632f9e4d1c00f5dca2bf91998c1beb123", "original_grade_sha256": "4109819fb6c789fdbc0981694a432d3d878878b916a0e4c15e275c54ce9a170b", "input_original_sha256": "5976145c5819ea6722f1322dcc18856d154c225f37bd368960ace9935475e6c6", "input_wav_sha256": "5722dbbdfa4562bffe8ad7f75e083a58ed30edde06a914fd756cb7c441786c52", "input_pcm_sha256": "2e4047dbc3583e04d14ea18de97dceb20a97f8b46980725e5f81b809ca3a497a", "output_wav_sha256": "750e7b4d5f2b250fc8e6e93c58a9946ebfd826454a5ab3652a6a45b0f68a5117", "output_pcm_sha256": "a08b4a9afa2f3b0c55622ccf3ce12327e47e98ed676a2591965064029c3009ae", "result_sha256": "9eaf4a83d8a5b4ab7779764e7f2ca544916b55bc7bf75543b08eb6e20dcb1b18" } }, { "id": 623, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b9a22ef8ea63a188c929242cd41c6f8c17c320128a2271ab4848a615370b7330", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b9a22ef8ea63a188c929242cd41c6f8c17c320128a2271ab4848a615370b7330", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a goat, a fish, a piano, a violin, a trombone, a chicken, four clarinets, a drum, and an accordion. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a goat, a fish, a piano, a violin, a trombone, a chicken, four clarinets, a drum, and an accordion. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 9.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9955.85, "reasoner_ms": 1636.71, "tts_ms": 26.17, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11618.76, "total_processing_ms": 12322.8 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 798, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 52 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d113e09f52fa66115dc7632c3323873732f30eb29916aa4d9e02b9f803bc4f97", "started_sha256": "537aaad9dffc009acf6293fc64ae5635753a9022295590cd6495ab64e27e237b", "original_grade_sha256": "31edb39ac50c18f15e6d67da3a7d5283e38443e9066165375a3253028dae1e96", "input_original_sha256": "d113e09f52fa66115dc7632c3323873732f30eb29916aa4d9e02b9f803bc4f97", "input_wav_sha256": "b5fc11d217a989aa48b95554aa7c96444cfa16bc1747916accfbeb7fae4279fa", "input_pcm_sha256": "cd4c84ab449e4f0cd20f2018aaabe54d4dd1896db97d740c5be71fcb3d080047", "output_wav_sha256": "ec5d622f7c8459e0ab51afc19305663a5ba017adbc20298a262dec2b34876253", "output_pcm_sha256": "a029fc1410f7919d0453f0b45a002700226b18ee14c3f92665122a16431927da", "result_sha256": "eed5451f8d2ccba0d96aa3bfe968dab5b47d508e7001e889eaf7333c74089778" } }, { "id": 905, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f8d2cd7a0d7aecd2a70b5733aa5aa7c86aa48221c03cb8c234fe398782966af8", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f8d2cd7a0d7aecd2a70b5733aa5aa7c86aa48221c03cb8c234fe398782966af8", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Delbert tells the truth. Gwen says Delbert lies. Audrey says Gwen lies. Christie says Audrey lies. Alexis says Christie lies. Does Alexis tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Delbert tells the truth. Gwen says Delbert lies. Audrey says Gwen lies. Christy says Audrey lies. Alexis says Christy lies. Does Alexis tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5927.08, "reasoner_ms": 2315.33, "tts_ms": 27.09, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8269.52, "total_processing_ms": 8887.27 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 829, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 72 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3b8887629fce98249fdb37e7df430da8c9253848ce1cce8fc95f796dd4227299", "started_sha256": "0e289729b3858355262dd87d00f510b91f2f63d15270c70b2d46b43a0d83cc17", "original_grade_sha256": "4d92b1e18b8b1fc19cd2288c973691eb634c91c5cc29a4c51bcfb615efa21e8e", "input_original_sha256": "3b8887629fce98249fdb37e7df430da8c9253848ce1cce8fc95f796dd4227299", "input_wav_sha256": "5488e773dbdea808f15150adc676a93d2a08281b5fefc908bbfda3b4e1a765f2", "input_pcm_sha256": "2b4f2c9daa38dc63a1aa3633f561790fe034411d60fa45b611ed9571e5cdd9ac", "output_wav_sha256": "e39e8196ffb066e05d91a95639d9b06361fadb56f976f1b4df652c3b7b112a53", "output_pcm_sha256": "8b5a1ca0690d48623fbf026e90c5a80c87ca37e3d5c098e78ef2394ed24a85dd", "result_sha256": "af93edee6dea16b9e5e19f56a3d9152210df541d0663ce0a9651accadff1bb39" } }, { "id": 193, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "99ccdaa8e5fb2b1db1de583b2a2f4fd2ff354fbf34da72503ee79d799cddfce6", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "99ccdaa8e5fb2b1db1de583b2a2f4fd2ff354fbf34da72503ee79d799cddfce6", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a fan of Liverpool? Are supporters of Real Madrid devotees of PSG? In European football, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of the mutual admiration and dislike. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To begin with, no admirer of Racing Club de Strasbourg Alsace is a devotee of CS Maritimo or a fan of SK Rapid Wien. Moreover, Byron is a devotee of CS Maritimo. We may conclude Byron is not an admirer of Racing Club de Strasbourg Alsace. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Fred a fan of Liverpool? Are supporters of Real Madrid devotees of PSG? In European football, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of the mutual admiration and dislike. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To begin with, no admirer of Racing Club de Strasbourg-Alsace is a devotee of CS Maritimo or a fan of SK Rapid Wien. Moreover, Byron is a devotee of CS Maritimo. we may conclude byron is not an admirer of racing club de strasburg alsace is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question Question", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 17742.92, "reasoner_ms": 2506.12, "tts_ms": 24.64, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 20273.71, "total_processing_ms": 20822.61 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1124, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 107 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3335dd61c6dd9b7e51d6187bb8d68452ed444ead0b28c26ad03ecc606af90d8f", "started_sha256": "e78bf9fbcd51e05ead8a9a7a1fc3269575a85f3e507fb25ed3c8d9929327360f", "original_grade_sha256": "6f6f5ba25a085537df7e64b8db4f7b3b23ed4b42b696d4ef02a36cfb1fbe0db2", "input_original_sha256": "3335dd61c6dd9b7e51d6187bb8d68452ed444ead0b28c26ad03ecc606af90d8f", "input_wav_sha256": "2501973ea7ff81e312b5b3d1231da85a4248f4831ad2d9e42b125c10b3a769bd", "input_pcm_sha256": "dabe82e8eb345723fa5f45fd54aee0ac56e882988a87880b892bc9615e90be7b", "output_wav_sha256": "a767f23fe71cdb7adb1cf6a50d1331cb86aaab4c40e0bac277b9a5e2eff1f490", "output_pcm_sha256": "20c1e069b57eba0a0bcd4a26f7c99062cfb9606815aa77a17721cf2e4135550b", "result_sha256": "cce1b557d012004a792eaa6664ec53e73423ebd5610e09d13ce96ccd135c0045" } }, { "id": 384, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6ee1cc45d88451b9e4aa1fbee1cbbbecc5903b8d611ae5500ba9f0a1bdd40ba4", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6ee1cc45d88451b9e4aa1fbee1cbbbecc5903b8d611ae5500ba9f0a1bdd40ba4", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\n| '\u4f9d\u6cd5, ,tsz-- heryl h\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do return to the starting point. Always face forward. Take 10 steps forward. Take 3 steps backward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5748.99, "reasoner_ms": 1886.35, "tts_ms": 24.81, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7660.17, "total_processing_ms": 8309.71 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 750, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 47 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d9fa8236918bd1c72f048dbade2b4b572518d0fdf48fa33e8c997fd15db76ab2", "started_sha256": "ee3d52c887d54e033259a28cf842ce93a5c4650e1e42d32642016ef70d52d969", "original_grade_sha256": "324c81803b10fd2fa2c315854003347ce368c2943d724826722fa1e3f008bac2", "input_original_sha256": "d9fa8236918bd1c72f048dbade2b4b572518d0fdf48fa33e8c997fd15db76ab2", "input_wav_sha256": "f362ff6fc3057e3d9035b31c59a6bedbfa6ecd3192ce7f3e242dcaebe2f827ac", "input_pcm_sha256": "1e0c987b4def8ff68c147ff9052ef157d5abd6f980a8c08871e6e0df2f78af60", "output_wav_sha256": "43d6d4d7052e632b70d70dfc8fb6571008d4392e0b33c0c471c7982171c196dd", "output_pcm_sha256": "9923bae23c1648cd856e1589714767340d5117b8b59dc95249b1cb2d4ec85f65", "result_sha256": "a57e54e235f3b43e403aa35d8f1cf54b5b1e7620ecb25abe44354fc8ae7fe5ce" } }, { "id": 608, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "8", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0f1b910ed07bd3d490cef253ef1a6f90569ac9a4d9d454a26a01b07809811fed", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0f1b910ed07bd3d490cef253ef1a6f90569ac9a4d9d454a26a01b07809811fed", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have an accordion, three goats, two cows, a pig, a rabbit, a snake, and a trumpet. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have an accordion, three goats, two cows, a pig, a rabbit, a snake, and a trumpet. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 8.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5428.37, "reasoner_ms": 1800.23, "tts_ms": 24.29, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7252.93, "total_processing_ms": 7997.3 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 776, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 58 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "68855529939dd9a181ea074ec7698e0d6f96633d24a342790c329f28e89f246d", "started_sha256": "60953cf329137b8345a06ddb7ccde25dc1be73d15247c7466bfcd40f27f547e9", "original_grade_sha256": "62095ce3615204911ae259f4a61b494b55f73db601d6d4f6ef56ae35b7eb54da", "input_original_sha256": "68855529939dd9a181ea074ec7698e0d6f96633d24a342790c329f28e89f246d", "input_wav_sha256": "a5ad7f86a1b4d588e344e6d6d1683060d05c8a754ae8eacb9037044721e837d2", "input_pcm_sha256": "c89f99ae6ffeec2413b93b4cb63d3f365cde667f5d1aca8904d35e7785549e95", "output_wav_sha256": "e963b07aaa4eb43792f7f1d4908cc7a49b3e2f11694528aee706503fc2df6d4c", "output_pcm_sha256": "c319e152007810d902d9611b9e61469344499549509cfad221e2d13ae1cabf12", "result_sha256": "c0bcb6686271268ecdad8f37d9661ac27ca4c52f406a2b58340ec2d04a0980a0" } }, { "id": 862, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dfd7ae70aacdb1f276127cb0c2d968d7fe1ea20240ede7a135e61820b35709e5", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dfd7ae70aacdb1f276127cb0c2d968d7fe1ea20240ede7a135e61820b35709e5", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Krista tells the truth. Jim says Krista lies. Delfina says Jim lies. Phoebe says Delfina lies. Bernita says Phoebe tells the truth. Does Bernita tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Krista tells the truth. Jim says Krista lies. Delphina says Jim lies. Phoebe says Delphina lies. Bernita says Phoebe tells the truth. Does Bernita tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6104.95, "reasoner_ms": 2326.41, "tts_ms": 26.08, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8457.47, "total_processing_ms": 9174.77 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 116 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6914ea4c976dfc29b9ee26cde6a47df496751e4fc5903d64dc13397f8a6428b3", "started_sha256": "fbe3dfea011f1bf2897220e5f04acfb8f400343db24f63b9bdd63221043fd3db", "original_grade_sha256": "f40c1548323275eebda67e4efe1b93ae4eb9fe8aceef22c96cc375a72cf97e41", "input_original_sha256": "6914ea4c976dfc29b9ee26cde6a47df496751e4fc5903d64dc13397f8a6428b3", "input_wav_sha256": "8c9191243277b6ba66f80512c09ae649b622ab5bdcb6cc7648088e160b256584", "input_pcm_sha256": "eddae21d0aba2ee198c36f6f10af910d9ac6685b51e7298df4b30f9e18035f11", "output_wav_sha256": "31a19b89af800cd4c59d00948ede5d9ee66ace85d9c3c9297a86c761d1fe0857", "output_pcm_sha256": "5372e3858574f4f9e659c39095b77d87eebf0ae96610203d2ee3e0f1048ea140", "result_sha256": "8b94c7ba0e8e62e30b27dc88e596b0e8ac63e6f7af6228c3821619e637d58bb1" } }, { "id": 152, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a37ecf96aadbf8b62f461d9780fc35a4fcf4029dd3193d4fa87ca079d5d81c9c", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a37ecf96aadbf8b62f461d9780fc35a4fcf4029dd3193d4fa87ca079d5d81c9c", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise: every ingredient of Go For the Glow that is an ingredient of lip tints is not an ingredient of Lotion Apr\u00e8s-Massage. We may conclude no ingredient of Lotion Apr\u00e8s-Massage is an ingredient of lip tints and in the same time an ingredient of Go For the Glow. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First premise. Every ingredient of Go For The Glow that is an ingredient of lip tints is not an ingredient of lotion appareissage. We may conclude no ingredient of lotion appareissage is an ingredient of lip tints and in the same time an ingredient of Go For The Glow. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9745.63, "reasoner_ms": 3852.65, "tts_ms": 31.91, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 13630.21, "total_processing_ms": 14356.98 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 985, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 207 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3d48bf3b5a9dc55ebcc49fb66e38279d557602f50adc12d30da3ae3d9d642a62", "started_sha256": "9f9659933304fe68b6a486c0978e68caa52453d0a4e7439217c4f13c80848561", "original_grade_sha256": "fcedb4537fc57568b77a724e2dca653792ebbf7d51b28f260e20e552ac0d37f8", "input_original_sha256": "3d48bf3b5a9dc55ebcc49fb66e38279d557602f50adc12d30da3ae3d9d642a62", "input_wav_sha256": "5fcb7d3cb7c71d1fe14d8c883dd2e3e8afc2bfd327cdfe1f62c5569eb7abe742", "input_pcm_sha256": "66ff1c2590bf2fe3e60cab690d81f1d77e2511b6fc7b130126d67d75245d9e49", "output_wav_sha256": "7cfcb23a63e5b2aa09f4de299ee69a0e6021a465d146098a9a75a9cad078fe02", "output_pcm_sha256": "46f7bfddcdc1bc8917c8d950cfc3bf5b1058e8eab751a31dbb07cd5d8bd12f9c", "result_sha256": "de5fb65d2e7672e1e943a87cb5a5d52120c1debf8fbec42d9eea5050947357e3" } }, { "id": 351, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d7d81c9b298bdd0666014c7f19ce26e94373a5463a77cee67144bfdf46df5343", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d7d81c9b298bdd0666014c7f19ce26e94373a5463a77cee67144bfdf46df5343", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn around. Turn right. Take seven steps. Turn right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do return to the starting point. Turn around. Turn right. Take seven steps. Turn right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6082.68, "reasoner_ms": 2452.8, "tts_ms": 26.11, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8561.61, "total_processing_ms": 9169.94 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 784, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 52 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "206f18ebabc0572143328d07136f487bdbab86f55d6ddb57c6062e8d58ba6528", "started_sha256": "10e0fc7f41a5d6874c4663f1daa12cdf5c6a7d26848ff8ee3ce8d252e2491873", "original_grade_sha256": "8748ea7da84fe8b0cc269337070153fef424bd0afac3b13402c8f96b00460bf4", "input_original_sha256": "206f18ebabc0572143328d07136f487bdbab86f55d6ddb57c6062e8d58ba6528", "input_wav_sha256": "867631078b029113adc7f8c08c3095ff2997860eddb9ab441aff9ef7ae31d561", "input_pcm_sha256": "e3d5c64f5fb778c5858d5d5734f2a55fafac72fd2841e81ab8c6c21868390f92", "output_wav_sha256": "5ca86705578f4f9ffb0e026e01aef1c26e5b3fbe75fc391aaafb3e91ccb9f86b", "output_pcm_sha256": "681b2d19b8321471d96164277ede402cc67c4c11107de95f57dce61c58753712", "result_sha256": "6a65fb65375f817f60fea1a04b0b55d5db90033532cc39b1a1c0ff5d65d7606f" } }, { "id": 618, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "12", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "eec7645030c21e1c9b209472441e16a7d99e21a3ef19610e2f129bb364efdb87", "normalized_answer": "12" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "eec7645030c21e1c9b209472441e16a7d99e21a3ef19610e2f129bb364efdb87", "normalized_answer": "12" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a trombone, a violin, an accordion, a drum, a trumpet, five pianos, a flute, and a clarinet. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a trombone, a violin, an accordion, a drum, a trumpet, five pianos, a flute, and a clarinet. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 12.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5966.7, "reasoner_ms": 2033.28, "tts_ms": 27.88, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8027.88, "total_processing_ms": 8667.87 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 793, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 55 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "dd6931ea02d9ca7a31b9395d91c0e24ab8f99a06f45967d5b45bcd09b0b83d6c", "started_sha256": "751c470e165e3ca8a50bc6b7049acb1371c194599e2ef0c92a8a1b330c79b2fe", "original_grade_sha256": "ddcd506943292525b96b03cdf2c7da997ad64f460a562d1166049e280b064c02", "input_original_sha256": "dd6931ea02d9ca7a31b9395d91c0e24ab8f99a06f45967d5b45bcd09b0b83d6c", "input_wav_sha256": "ef738070da404b06a95acb82ee6d524b295407fb60eaed3a39ad9c2f70d7ec37", "input_pcm_sha256": "04ee0a07ca761f66b30418571bc358e40ac9f5f7c07d99fac2ddbbdc6cf6d6f8", "output_wav_sha256": "c5c3d6c2fbfd28afcd00ccbf9a0449279307f1bf218ceb341a356233661ab8dc", "output_pcm_sha256": "8e92b5a35677ff25be38f8aa368fb38ce97d23bf304ab32a312c100bd2a74a6c", "result_sha256": "6b7f9a787adf1bb5f7cd7031159e9dffcfe814aa19d8bf6a843652caa3e434b7" } }, { "id": 961, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "incorrect", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "66c5c174cb75a3dfaf2783b27811309d613562527c781864533f23a530162d75", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "incorrect", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "66c5c174cb75a3dfaf2783b27811309d613562527c781864533f23a530162d75", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Fletcher tells the truth. Willian says Fletcher tells the truth. Jamie says Willian lies. Lida says Jamie lies. Jamie says Lida tells the truth. Does Jamie tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Fletcher tells the truth. Willian says Fletcher tells the truth. Jamie says Willian lies. Leda says Jamie lies. Jamie says Leda tells the truth. Does Jamie tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6504.54, "reasoner_ms": 2099.22, "tts_ms": 25.65, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8629.43, "total_processing_ms": 9411.52 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 842, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 73 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b2d2a68ff4725d16ebe2670dcf9b8d86bd81f2faf26ab2c233721328dd499b0e", "started_sha256": "db2c565a1cd553419239e527dc3591236b0b0671ee53f46a7fb4d9197479aa1f", "original_grade_sha256": "12e811bebc3d774c9e8a711064a971121b3560861a93336d70c03301971e1a2f", "input_original_sha256": "b2d2a68ff4725d16ebe2670dcf9b8d86bd81f2faf26ab2c233721328dd499b0e", "input_wav_sha256": "f610e7b1280a7362e2875c147df860e3a118b179fb5afd208ffb83b031769f18", "input_pcm_sha256": "d1b1fb09c5881be837b145ddd790b07c5de15a983b36891e9891df56e9065f56", "output_wav_sha256": "7ffc99efea061b4c2f50ef35c46610d7b8ce1d47c86506526e11e5cb8db29b20", "output_pcm_sha256": "e8011e191adca178f7c44f05fb59e429b8253c24a62d0f63811069c9d64f7f1e", "result_sha256": "40f5a2801cd6675e751d0aec6f68256b724cd8e0c6dfe6020af2a1ac72fb6ec1" } }, { "id": 57, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "be21d1a3aef25c813de44f51f24ed85748245850f3608c822d6c29597b142df2", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "be21d1a3aef25c813de44f51f24ed85748245850f3608c822d6c29597b142df2", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, being an ingredient of Eye Definer Twig is necessary for being an ingredient of Facial Scrub. Now, not being an ingredient of NARS Pressed Powder is sufficient for not being an ingredient of Eye Definer Twig. Therefore, being an ingredient of NARS Pressed Powder is necessary for being an ingredient of Facial Scrub. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To start with, being an ingredient of eye-definer twig is necessary for being an ingredient of facial scrub. Now, not being an ingredient of NARS pressed powder is sufficient for not being an ingredient of eye-definer twig. Therefore, being an ingredient of NARS pressed powder is necessary for being an ingredient of facial scrub. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12379.78, "reasoner_ms": 3716.4, "tts_ms": 23.93, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 16120.14, "total_processing_ms": 16854.82 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1033, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 170 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8d6eb311b7b97afdb3c0083a6b6a4ceac447c63dcfa98ba329436646cd35d711", "started_sha256": "41afe9b841a08976cdcc63b5b513c58eb698bbb7fc4670f95907e81c03de5431", "original_grade_sha256": "4b35da13f35e98b98a159904026e3e5d62b01c6b58b746dc5a0b92ffc9ea6f64", "input_original_sha256": "8d6eb311b7b97afdb3c0083a6b6a4ceac447c63dcfa98ba329436646cd35d711", "input_wav_sha256": "2e7c27b624820207e997c173fd746ece280eb6ddc23de221a4ef8316b679ed5f", "input_pcm_sha256": "ab517a69a3d96220b0715763ad98705be8e3252ee77931cfdc41bf71aef72d69", "output_wav_sha256": "f1ac4d93cd27b7d785a04060759e595a139129e0ac18ec7547f6061194dafe44", "output_pcm_sha256": "17e7dfc571d56dda9f6765c75f53ca2147ab712c7f5263dddb962f3b20420376", "result_sha256": "25df454f53702e23860b31fdf7cf8460ded47600b957d7bd362bbda2ae2b192b" } }, { "id": 390, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bdf732490a1f4059cb013bfb7840c0037b99b6d27c0494080f7ec547cf929c8e", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bdf732490a1f4059cb013bfb7840c0037b99b6d27c0494080f7ec547cf929c8e", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps left. Take eight steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps left. Take eight steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7176.91, "reasoner_ms": 1171.92, "tts_ms": 25.91, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8374.77, "total_processing_ms": 8884.69 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 785, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "bc080ca157cb6493525b98fcdb5c8db1736662d8209a6a7b13c6278fe0156ea0", "started_sha256": "9726fcd217d6bb3cc514e0941216a7ca65f4e64a817829ef81ecde9664dd69b5", "original_grade_sha256": "8d0b40721b752f0495f7ca4e871c62f56e5be2c7713fad90fd613061a8694c2e", "input_original_sha256": "bc080ca157cb6493525b98fcdb5c8db1736662d8209a6a7b13c6278fe0156ea0", "input_wav_sha256": "92f043148e513ae17b1a57f243484f34b5f48730ee32cb0c3a43e4633005149d", "input_pcm_sha256": "2ed0f1e28fa9f74b7233b13d8086fe7465459db5012d00b506ff27991869f0f7", "output_wav_sha256": "e506583116d1249faa245b456852357673a29c1f70a8303b346e3af0251859c1", "output_pcm_sha256": "e98269750d51a17db623e72199db2f5b3d60409fda927d646bdcfdd1c4a9e66a", "result_sha256": "d3e3a59e655020fec14dbe9b5a3d467425e6b55c36c19b1c9d3c1fe089566d7f" } }, { "id": 725, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "4", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "69bbd979e58b729edc9b29b31b33559e9619277add98a278d63278129bf0e63d", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "69bbd979e58b729edc9b29b31b33559e9619277add98a278d63278129bf0e63d", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a peach, a plum, a blackberry, and an apple. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a peach, a plum, a blackberry, and an apple. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 4.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4416.53, "reasoner_ms": 1315.99, "tts_ms": 43.87, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5776.42, "total_processing_ms": 6478.57 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 748, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2e8be2d1767d66ff1741f95273b079dc21c1e4874593096b259f97b2f4d82bfd", "started_sha256": "14bff1cd0f391aa88b786864593cf1e60299cdc4c5fd375737f5a51eecf0c5cb", "original_grade_sha256": "e5cdd550e3442b70f9659e3a8184a857ffccbd3c2ec976dee318d7635b9b3b5e", "input_original_sha256": "2e8be2d1767d66ff1741f95273b079dc21c1e4874593096b259f97b2f4d82bfd", "input_wav_sha256": "60492029e588dcfc5e9117ffdaf7980c97ac87be4e79b3d9a635bb43e78fb3c6", "input_pcm_sha256": "7f9d7ee17a667e607c7ff32db07c0769cea9146e0dd6a69b578e334937507d98", "output_wav_sha256": "f9079e25037974523aeef9fd288f6f534f66b041557732a1044281e5e07ca4d6", "output_pcm_sha256": "8933371b0e65202335d138c19d6f45a6524607a51e7afc9956392667f5ab5e29", "result_sha256": "afa8f176d796a60d4c5110eb54e778c7bdbc6bf159c09fbc7ad8ae80d46356e5" } }, { "id": 915, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1ed9675ee43dee7561cee1ccf6378d73983b2b60b91b7ba23e520c2962f7f0b3", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "1ed9675ee43dee7561cee1ccf6378d73983b2b60b91b7ba23e520c2962f7f0b3", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Shonda lies. Eleanor says Shonda lies. Fidel says Eleanor tells the truth. Loreen says Fidel tells the truth. Raymond says Loreen lies. Does Raymond tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion shonda lies eleanor says shonda lies fidel says eleanor tells the truth lorene says fidel tells the truth raymond says lorene lies does raymond tell the truth answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9063.98, "reasoner_ms": 5166.95, "tts_ms": 57.13, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 14288.09, "total_processing_ms": 14938.58 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 830, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 129 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1660cebdabd4a64a888cf444b8330778c99120fec90e5aa52d9a700b14070ffa", "started_sha256": "fc1b8e6a92b0878d2cda646ac7c5c6a6d1a8e56fdb80b2c5bf6c4cf73a36d640", "original_grade_sha256": "2f1bd25dcf38980f5a8afe1a2b5ff2b527a9f989a37ac080293e3e75fd9c62d0", "input_original_sha256": "1660cebdabd4a64a888cf444b8330778c99120fec90e5aa52d9a700b14070ffa", "input_wav_sha256": "32693294fe4467d251fa7ec357dec9f16ac0f94e8cb62621f879c9ba1fd961de", "input_pcm_sha256": "321b9bbc8d7a4976c151b0022926121fd012aa00842ece764113e74b255d6b15", "output_wav_sha256": "20ee8405270ae9704c6371dbd9a77297545d0f3903d2003229bbd7660e6d72aa", "output_pcm_sha256": "2e427d15be6e32ef8a6b8f02ad3544abb7bfe05fdd27ad84225a5c26c5e7b244", "result_sha256": "ee875bb1de2c76ece66b983168a415ede82fa223323c2cd167ee582e189acb87" } }, { "id": 223, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dc97996942c3bd52b983138ea27a9fd0d37500a26e05f796f7cabe575e46879a", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dc97996942c3bd52b983138ea27a9fd0d37500a26e05f796f7cabe575e46879a", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a fan of Liverpool? Are supporters of Real Madrid devotees of PSG? In European football, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of the mutual admiration and dislike. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First of all, no expert of Malmo FF who is an ex-supporter of Brondby IF is an ex-fan of F91 Dudelange. Next, whoever is not a follower of Stade Rennais FC is an ex-fan of F91 Dudelange. So necessarily, whoever is none of this, an expert of Malmo FF or ex-supporter of Brondby IF is a follower of Stade Rennais FC. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Fred a fan of Liverpool? Are supporters of Real Madrid devotees of PSG? In European football, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of the mutual admiration and dislike. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First of all, no expert of Malmo FF, who is an ex-supporter of Brundtbuif, is an ex-fan of F91 Dudlange. Next, whoever is not a follower of Stade Rennais FC, is an ex-fan of F91 de Blanche. So necessarily, whoever is none of this, an expert of Malmo FF or ex-supporter of Brundbu IF, is a follower of Stade Rennais FC. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 20636.3, "reasoner_ms": 7754.05, "tts_ms": 28.83, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 28419.2, "total_processing_ms": 29132.13 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1206, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 588 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d2de94a52bcae2d81f73e58d043970a93490f1d4d770e98058eede8a2ed9718d", "started_sha256": "5c19053f92b71518c83a15733f5b6f591d53a0b0139a0dd3b897ef946c36d0f5", "original_grade_sha256": "da6107ec4698590c70e2d1c5af4c61002f5e56b479a4fb52050304da3061c74c", "input_original_sha256": "d2de94a52bcae2d81f73e58d043970a93490f1d4d770e98058eede8a2ed9718d", "input_wav_sha256": "a98c8816ad92597a9fc8dbbb19d3a321bf13545e9d9728bd4024f3ef304b4fae", "input_pcm_sha256": "45682bc9d315112a339449030846a85c831f98a5fd2e562e65056285ca7a8b0e", "output_wav_sha256": "d19b7b48d98f1ce06323353b057e25f30b55c9ba672de49110f257b28c7f7007", "output_pcm_sha256": "bd3712d93b227a5f4e99d9d5d694d1df57c5acd96c53bab7967c67d00f844cca", "result_sha256": "ddd694fe226179d9628c36928939df1386b6f252e1e6695eb64d6b8b1b4c9539" } }, { "id": 315, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "53f4264c4dcd6a8f1f21e4d611bb36753f5f8b0814ede623f60a7fe6c1768ecf", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "53f4264c4dcd6a8f1f21e4d611bb36753f5f8b0814ede623f60a7fe6c1768ecf", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take seven steps forward. Take three steps backward. Take four steps backward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take seven steps forward. Take three steps backward. Take four steps backward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6261.47, "reasoner_ms": 1575.66, "tts_ms": 26.51, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7863.66, "total_processing_ms": 8417.79 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 804, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 28 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1093a3564fdfbbe8e3846d661a7cebb96fdda3381611d14e2ad7be15f7c550c6", "started_sha256": "a07861e2d271e743e227cadef007c9de1ed8f279e31056f4b3195a48989a2d21", "original_grade_sha256": "0f8267a40d59e1880f1248691cc362945541b802ad238fbc0a22ebc388d498ee", "input_original_sha256": "1093a3564fdfbbe8e3846d661a7cebb96fdda3381611d14e2ad7be15f7c550c6", "input_wav_sha256": "f24ac1b23aabf931808c23309cc4b4d564650780520c351cc922183e83adae4b", "input_pcm_sha256": "381f0218e36deb3fcaa3bd0e90b2013ac78109fcf6d6130c6d3b5d11fd80a975", "output_wav_sha256": "b25cad7f3e39fd9a74cc42457bc9fe48bd56436bbcd294b3ba969a162522908f", "output_pcm_sha256": "ccd108aca007e6372173500367c28cbd378b56e0352d8f9cc19f5fdc3e728416", "result_sha256": "7e0044b40a4ce624683d0922781d1289c276c3279366aeaa557c187a261fccfc" } }, { "id": 657, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "4", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5e20e4e96f6d42f0f696cd1099180284429bed5e870f4267406f204ff2bfb61a", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5e20e4e96f6d42f0f696cd1099180284429bed5e870f4267406f204ff2bfb61a", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a table, a strawberry, and three nectarines. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a table, a strawberry, and three nectarines. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 4.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4810.11, "reasoner_ms": 1778.9, "tts_ms": 25.72, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6614.75, "total_processing_ms": 7231.95 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 741, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 44 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "25576c1a3590c7e48ac1e3f6511b2d76607aa547e4a7ac215738402937a45556", "started_sha256": "3b7c4293cc17af741544852689e7b10ed4e86e087a0147c8456d3ed2379f728f", "original_grade_sha256": "1ad289a8a9e5d4f36a6f73a40675e9ccc73d4cf6274485b8e134cf18beecef6a", "input_original_sha256": "25576c1a3590c7e48ac1e3f6511b2d76607aa547e4a7ac215738402937a45556", "input_wav_sha256": "c8f4b034deca456a22fbb26bbf6d4fb991a804111eaba773b834ca0731e57e7e", "input_pcm_sha256": "5d845221a892d26534951787879bb8bdaa29883c205ad1461c3c3300aecffa8b", "output_wav_sha256": "a5154306477b4251b764c997bcf5c8e39e1f988a46284d2bc408a2afe88e2559", "output_pcm_sha256": "a967cfded0f90fcbae7b50d7fa122e9dc48c259aa2176d49fd4ac8621c87bf3f", "result_sha256": "e1578f69cf03c36783bcaab25310268047c834c0cc02b450c8dcb6590c44640d" } }, { "id": 901, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "688201faec9ccb60e20532529bc90f527878c6b6e017670bb67f6d204c804fef", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "688201faec9ccb60e20532529bc90f527878c6b6e017670bb67f6d204c804fef", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Yolande tells the truth. Gwen says Yolande tells the truth. Michaela says Gwen lies. Jamie says Michaela tells the truth. Amberly says Jamie lies. Does Amberly tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Yolan tells the truth. Gwen says Yolan tells the truth. Michaela says Gwen lies. Jamie says Michaela tells the truth. Amberly says Jamie lies. Does Amberly tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6235.76, "reasoner_ms": 2437.04, "tts_ms": 28.99, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8701.81, "total_processing_ms": 9354.91 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 846, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 121 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1e03040357b38815f8443d81b6a8d33b2575ba53676b07fd8daac7aacc7291f7", "started_sha256": "94963946bb004350de6804bfbc65fe2feee205549672cd04034a1ae6b9bdfbd1", "original_grade_sha256": "f470ad4e630ab9b95da6e69212db5e1f0f8eff0a5a2081d48b4c6f954b491d71", "input_original_sha256": "1e03040357b38815f8443d81b6a8d33b2575ba53676b07fd8daac7aacc7291f7", "input_wav_sha256": "bd99c21c53cdc922b1ea8410ae27b6e33353aa4b8facb7284b72c12141983749", "input_pcm_sha256": "61513458dfa1dec335ba2858568cb1d7b26fa886e141957a5b458ea658b6b92a", "output_wav_sha256": "bb22b9bd0d606eb2c1c4b915550f809fb784efb94c3fcf0778ee5d1d4864520d", "output_pcm_sha256": "7e6da6072f9ca31a630121798021eb329b2d3f8f8de56997cfdb77ccf2d7c759", "result_sha256": "9d2a182c772d19bf83403422d39c51b43914b760f1629ce26f6297ba8ca29c90" } }, { "id": 61, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ea6762ace3697af3458eb685d5d968620013c986ccc3f6c9a42362daf52f9cd8", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ea6762ace3697af3458eb685d5d968620013c986ccc3f6c9a42362daf52f9cd8", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. Every uncle of Harvey is not an ancestor of Adrian and not a nephew of Ward. In consequence, no nephew of Ward and no ancestor of Adrian is an uncle of Harvey. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument, every uncle of Harvey is not an ancestor of Adrian and not a nephew of Ward. In consequence, no nephew of Ward and no ancestor of Adrian is an uncle of Harvey. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6869.5, "reasoner_ms": 3775.26, "tts_ms": 25.27, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10670.06, "total_processing_ms": 11272.31 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 925, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 214 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e05f539c1edd7cfb08da6ae3642665e1f87b8f645c95a98250a06306b3b45419", "started_sha256": "470181c44e6321a266d66943fcd4cab9261ae491b9095430e414e517589345a5", "original_grade_sha256": "91db22a1dd7871a66eeb0f94a109e6375bd947df12dab33d2322e5fd725a6778", "input_original_sha256": "e05f539c1edd7cfb08da6ae3642665e1f87b8f645c95a98250a06306b3b45419", "input_wav_sha256": "1815deb7f985e1f0464d76af504b29edfb608ff037bdb5be000aed7e5f629d61", "input_pcm_sha256": "77f742d2308073266064c850d33973a56c22428a2b8487f8f9ce922e29ebd435", "output_wav_sha256": "a2b99a11046127425132a2ab6e532ffdc365b664e6846fb3751f1bf4f52ee009", "output_pcm_sha256": "dd8752d7144ed3f97e2d0167bb5e09fc7efa278673e49cd342690eba1c397776", "result_sha256": "10f118facb612f714941388078ccbbb3f0d4fbdb4f0bc4c3f587549dd1fc92b8" } }, { "id": 256, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e5c1e4a18e3fca631d036660379a06919b84a33f086b7c1317effe2eee6d9c44", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e5c1e4a18e3fca631d036660379a06919b84a33f086b7c1317effe2eee6d9c44", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps right. Take one step forward. Take ten steps left. Take eight steps forward. Take nine steps backward. Take four steps right. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take 6 steps right. Take 1 step forward. Take 10 steps left. Take 8 steps forward. Take 9 steps backward. Take 4 steps right. Yes? No? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7156.74, "reasoner_ms": 1889.63, "tts_ms": 26.43, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9072.83, "total_processing_ms": 9838.08 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 854, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 46 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "cd230f93f7e28922c0fe1b3a37797d86181c29590480d39e9d03e77ccb2bb0a1", "started_sha256": "098a717b3a8a7da6bf590d972f84474086372a67289d9a7b68382f669f0e83d2", "original_grade_sha256": "54f1e949d4b8c255fb54040ac577bf7c57ebe9f4f294d7a481ea631e3862e802", "input_original_sha256": "cd230f93f7e28922c0fe1b3a37797d86181c29590480d39e9d03e77ccb2bb0a1", "input_wav_sha256": "aeeda92b109bfc4ed7c5906490e541e7ac74f450bcf5e235c1ba259c736b5e0e", "input_pcm_sha256": "a50260d572a9fafe33948bbd546e9ab905247ad1ef19bd328945f98deea2644b", "output_wav_sha256": "04a2674748e30ec59f4690b932f38bedbb6cdeefb0acd1a3378e206c53d576dd", "output_pcm_sha256": "7d5727cf9b2e53bca9e22a49ef84e8f9c5f3931ec52525ea0c6dfff4dfa411c6", "result_sha256": "bfc6d6c3fb44c40a21676cd3f3119361777a6fbf061e36a68f275077688ca5cb" } }, { "id": 538, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "3", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "needs_review", "reason": "not_an_unambiguous_short_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4d7b8d224123b260a47d756d4a2949d6805cb3e56bee15f26fd87a261303b403" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "reviewed_output_audio", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4d7b8d224123b260a47d756d4a2949d6805cb3e56bee15f26fd87a261303b403" }, "additive_review": { "reviewer": "DAS test duty independent ASR/evidence review", "basis": "output_audio_and_ground_truth", "rationale": "The independently recognized received audio reads 'Date answer is 3.'; the model's reply was 'The answer is 3.'. The substitution is confined to the fixed lead-in phrase (\"The answer is\"), which the pinned small.en output recognizer renders as a similar-sounding opener; the answer token itself is intact and equals the pinned key '3'. The scorer withheld an automatic pass only because the spoken form was not the contracted phrase. Same class as the determiner substitutions reviewed on 2026-09-15. This is saved audio/ASR evidence review, not a claim of human listening.", "verdict": "correct", "evidence_sha256": "4d7b8d224123b260a47d756d4a2949d6805cb3e56bee15f26fd87a261303b403", "record_sha256": "9a7c347f823a2773fa22a9213fb3b1c5e0d0cdf0c815eab7fe7a303c158de88f" }, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a raspberry, a grape, and an orange. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a raspberry, a grape, and an orange. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "Date answer is 3.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4692.93, "reasoner_ms": 1458.23, "tts_ms": 26.09, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6177.28, "total_processing_ms": 6762.37 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 739, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b1301cba385d0b28ad6278ebb0aa710b67f7bbc26e161e1b529727a7f95a9688", "started_sha256": "6e8f86d9e84f738bd98bb376438b15050bb5ea5a47a6d6447b46319c99ca2887", "original_grade_sha256": "4f1d788350cd3fa998d9435019e1e462d2fac239cdb3c3be8f3343fd5348e2e0", "input_original_sha256": "b1301cba385d0b28ad6278ebb0aa710b67f7bbc26e161e1b529727a7f95a9688", "input_wav_sha256": "c827596e99fdcbbec12c9ede17baa24593738c30859f77cbaf15aef8f820f99b", "input_pcm_sha256": "bde51eeb8123de91e6b2e2cc6b46354703b2fadada83538439e9ea5957e1902a", "output_wav_sha256": "55018424673a79a25b54e7e6e708bac2792103d69f99dde40bc9847ae31e298e", "output_pcm_sha256": "3e7b0e18bf9c761962439a856fbe06e7199dad3d622882b4e84dd05b9db06555", "result_sha256": "5c1eaf0f8543a21540a59dd2deca98417333cbcefde6a82a9c1f847a12f1daca" } }, { "id": 865, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8b0d85a69c89d35d1b317185d5939eb89d3c46f89722cb792ed4881b92216a96", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8b0d85a69c89d35d1b317185d5939eb89d3c46f89722cb792ed4881b92216a96", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Yolen tells the truth. Michaela says Yolen tells the truth. Shamar says Michaela tells the truth. Shonda says Shamar tells the truth. Osvaldo says Shonda lies. Does Osvaldo tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion yolin tells the truth michela says yolin tells the truth shema says michela tells the truth shanda says shema tells the truth osvaldo says shanda lies does osvaldo tell the truth answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8822.49, "reasoner_ms": 1781.19, "tts_ms": 24.26, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10627.97, "total_processing_ms": 11326.94 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 842, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 75 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "81a2c26fe2e29c9bbd68c7bf12fe01287bc62872555e14b227b2c423a0d09290", "started_sha256": "9c858d84e3d96168503e6adc53009ba0af08b7b21d9c9b915b3fe2b8e94d1cf2", "original_grade_sha256": "377d26348e1e4666ea203e64fe126bcc156811ac2e0e72ea09b7f573e1896bcb", "input_original_sha256": "81a2c26fe2e29c9bbd68c7bf12fe01287bc62872555e14b227b2c423a0d09290", "input_wav_sha256": "8b0b93d41dcd9acadf953d87dc14da35f45b07c29260f92f4f2dde0a3bb27fb4", "input_pcm_sha256": "7c3fee6154bbb72cec822f41e5dcf21dcb5308b547b0c03f70faefaba3d98d7c", "output_wav_sha256": "3c63d5bdc18c8c2b449ee772a0a2fb5b5ce9d50e6aae43327693fca8a810c113", "output_pcm_sha256": "1588e8ae9854214b58ede02014a8c82c166948d05a5a3ea5a928b97574e948ff", "result_sha256": "5c32161a4cb0f07bfa0caf711a803c233e6f1738a89656b58c5af9fc49d93163" } }, { "id": 225, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0a5ce32db0bf96e9b2aca24d7f45f881679d27898e8077ab2a71f9028ef00e05", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0a5ce32db0bf96e9b2aca24d7f45f881679d27898e8077ab2a71f9028ef00e05", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, Beatrice is a granddaughter of Danielle. Moreover, being a granddaughter of Danielle or a classmate of Kay is sufficient for being a classmate of Kathy. It follows that Beatrice is a classmate of Kathy. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. To begin with, Beatrice is a granddaughter of Danielle. Moreover, being a granddaughter of Danielle or a classmate of Kay is sufficient for being a classmate of Kathy. It follows that Beatrice is a classmate of Kathy. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8389.03, "reasoner_ms": 1810.61, "tts_ms": 28.97, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10228.63, "total_processing_ms": 10972.04 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 964, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 79 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a0cbfd124519ae9e986c6541f5f16b0230d0ee39632360106a2b99e6d8827170", "started_sha256": "d447f736c10274d2f8e86053e68081f492ea4938b8dc25b5a4d50d560c01caf7", "original_grade_sha256": "6bf3f335a526f2c2e0c01ef25ff932c4c019653850cd1e5c30543bd2ae096856", "input_original_sha256": "a0cbfd124519ae9e986c6541f5f16b0230d0ee39632360106a2b99e6d8827170", "input_wav_sha256": "b2f41002d22f21fe9833e58fe2dd2468f43430696186ed679df3a19958f74b48", "input_pcm_sha256": "e99dcad490840363a6bd2b8cbc24ba82bb4910829abc60e88665c685fd94df53", "output_wav_sha256": "949d652077734b1b6ae2088adffc6e0ddd536d07cfe727ff0d936a6ee14b403e", "output_pcm_sha256": "a4d14bc722c7dfa64022ee8a211fc5dcb471f522c79e1ab133918529309409bc", "result_sha256": "01630d928d25d43bdcdbde087cc89a7a10606ecc26a9c4a64c5896430b79d2a9" } }, { "id": 297, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "76bf55afec6070c35e39f67e017794cfa7d59fa172c244112c0a631a81706976", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "76bf55afec6070c35e39f67e017794cfa7d59fa172c244112c0a631a81706976", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left, turn around, take one step, take ten steps, turn around, take seven steps, take four steps. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Turn left, turn around, take one step, take ten steps, turn around, take seven steps, take four steps. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6351.46, "reasoner_ms": 4756.9, "tts_ms": 24.98, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11133.37, "total_processing_ms": 11830.53 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 808, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 203 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "fdc123c0871aec139d85b0fef2e39024b30f27e14a251df0c893d249ab5cca62", "started_sha256": "3c443d0d0a26b5cf9cf40a61a0a9f2af0f13fcc1e5facebb9d1b8c9e4f0a9c09", "original_grade_sha256": "8d8e425e34a166cc3e76ccec78538466757df1a043f0008abf3e8e3f33f8cd75", "input_original_sha256": "fdc123c0871aec139d85b0fef2e39024b30f27e14a251df0c893d249ab5cca62", "input_wav_sha256": "627ef2fccaab33ba392a88b71fa813e3f5a94fa241e04b695c88fb735aff5d9b", "input_pcm_sha256": "ef2877ee36166fddbced24178fe1241d37e554a8d20094bd11f4e6e569514748", "output_wav_sha256": "4cb655b21babcf3d0e0bf56c6e50f2e28c9f2b3460dbcb2810caa4ee4fdc7b2d", "output_pcm_sha256": "7958bca478cc978a03cac0d2442e7c1b5e02aa21546fbea9b7115fe58604364e", "result_sha256": "36b71a3d04e4bcd2447f6d7c83ca9f88a555a3fcf0077edd5b16e21ef7acfc77" } }, { "id": 633, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "2", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2abf6f991dc3b0217d1ac5735d3d63b3725f274f4216c46218cbc423b699bcec", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2abf6f991dc3b0217d1ac5735d3d63b3725f274f4216c46218cbc423b699bcec", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a microwave and a bed. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a microwave and a bed how many objects do i have answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 2.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7690.9, "reasoner_ms": 1256.55, "tts_ms": 24.36, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8971.83, "total_processing_ms": 9628.87 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 730, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "dfa83b1df95c250bdea0a37e8621cd1e609fac2d64a34365b54bbd9d2033c109", "started_sha256": "ab6ed2b3199075820a0c3158649e9c1596f885a91d4882a2f8c6c8ad42a61597", "original_grade_sha256": "6875dc9a4267cbdea64de7dcb85ec95aaa372233684d52a480143964aee0a4a5", "input_original_sha256": "dfa83b1df95c250bdea0a37e8621cd1e609fac2d64a34365b54bbd9d2033c109", "input_wav_sha256": "da0e48698e83c65c4982fe0eb393d9a84e93c24a0b24d4d47cb00fa6437c088a", "input_pcm_sha256": "b0fc62772728e980f3d0417e38cac06340dbc9b08ffd0b991202c190f557dbc5", "output_wav_sha256": "2804a8239f37e0043ff4ae01277026a7af1bebc35be98f79b6652dff68ff730a", "output_pcm_sha256": "30e5d6cf5aa528498158533e38712d3fb92f19c9b50e520e29c7f041f47ee574", "result_sha256": "2b407b66fa211f536bc241ee5b93ef7e185cfe595f8b320d7f4b09d3df34cef8" } }, { "id": 906, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4086f703691db4b8a6c3f6be937104711ff922d8f45eae8b9c14b99bd12d7e8b", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4086f703691db4b8a6c3f6be937104711ff922d8f45eae8b9c14b99bd12d7e8b", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Antoine tells the truth. Jamie says Antoine tells the truth. Maybelle says Jamie tells the truth. Alexis says Maybelle lies. Millicent says Alexis lies. Does Millicent tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Antoine tells the truth. Jamie says Antoine tells the truth. Maybel says Jamie tells the truth. Alexis says Maybel lies. Millicent says Alexis lies. Does Millicent tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6485.99, "reasoner_ms": 3797.59, "tts_ms": 26.72, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10310.32, "total_processing_ms": 11045.12 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 848, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 81 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "25cd31c57e7a6cf45716bb1cd1e3091938cde0475a41feca93f9a9f0612d9da9", "started_sha256": "f0e056ec240936fd756c60b2b6d29f80908ff634ba630e0c15ca0569d1bb3568", "original_grade_sha256": "05d1c27ef2dc81608153b924672e6c4b796cbc59a2842b1d2ea2d68e61e102c2", "input_original_sha256": "25cd31c57e7a6cf45716bb1cd1e3091938cde0475a41feca93f9a9f0612d9da9", "input_wav_sha256": "73eaa9580ad149b33a74016e93c5f537c38a1546bb17ffb6ae86643634adc9f2", "input_pcm_sha256": "af0133f8b45453a9c94fff9c63ce5283d774a43bc5e1b42a1ed04d32ea224361", "output_wav_sha256": "6b41e5be5da5ca194409f26756de03262ef3787e3d10c51d6cde7868b127c37e", "output_pcm_sha256": "f9d98b1842591eb96345d35b66e2615650e20406df43f5fb54b8feb0ce0aebeb", "result_sha256": "da88d3094126ee1653c7a09f9f56b202210d156da57f80a8e2b23c09bc46edae" } }, { "id": 236, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "80ef08816b82ec64d2a34a921542d076f48ce46630666d801bd4a6b6febbce80", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "80ef08816b82ec64d2a34a921542d076f48ce46630666d801bd4a6b6febbce80", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First of all, Donald is an infrequent user of CHI shampoo. Next, every infrequent user of CHI shampoo and every loyal buyer of Lifebuoy soap is an infrequent user of natural bar soap. It follows that Donald is an infrequent user of natural bar soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nConsumer research aims at understanding whether users of some products also tend to consume other ones or not. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First of all, Donald is an infrequent user of CHI shampoo. Next, every infrequent user of CHI shampoo and every loyal buyer of Lifebuoy soap is an infrequent user of natural bar soap. It follows that Donald is an infrequent user of natural bar soap. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13653.6, "reasoner_ms": 1811.27, "tts_ms": 42.11, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15507.01, "total_processing_ms": 16230.6 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1044, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 60 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "39a77f22875e05a25b170bff3f0f28a87f113ee61703f0ffb31da4411d9e5010", "started_sha256": "2805c8f1e233a5cec90c93f4528e0aabc2c2c0e9bf5eec5c62b300bb0f6a590e", "original_grade_sha256": "0081516a73e5373108e56cf00a48483824fa937c2f80b7a8cda27f2786af6ac6", "input_original_sha256": "39a77f22875e05a25b170bff3f0f28a87f113ee61703f0ffb31da4411d9e5010", "input_wav_sha256": "5fc51af9c79bec628b6b3c887c2457650380964db20504f3efca2c32a5b13584", "input_pcm_sha256": "78d8f1eb0164adf1d3bce393d9b24748fa3cc508c0bbd388d3631cb79c608306", "output_wav_sha256": "6fd5fb0da425e5452edf3a71de987d1db7af4516efeccca05e8eb7e3c2e77a43", "output_pcm_sha256": "083e5886dbda3bf94482e076c136d07b6673748602354d68ba5b12989b6c8471", "result_sha256": "9c11b0fbc47ba682ba32cb4ef391f10c91e523c39c44b48db73943f42ebfe837" } }, { "id": 306, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bf6e41cef5bfe77635e9616f0af3a1c19161e77ee1c3b5b81d2085da10f34741", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bf6e41cef5bfe77635e9616f0af3a1c19161e77ee1c3b5b81d2085da10f34741", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take nine steps. Turn left. Turn left. Take five steps. Take four steps. Turn left. Turn left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take nine steps. Turn left. Turn left. Take five steps. Take four steps. Turn left. Turn left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6329.17, "reasoner_ms": 2076.46, "tts_ms": 26.45, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8432.12, "total_processing_ms": 9133.83 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 819, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 68 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b059aecfae68c4443d7eeb3e7f0178bf0fe80d78437eec9201d808aa3443962f", "started_sha256": "bb213b1d9bf7f9ba438714a379fdae423e7910091e6acb92aee38331c6d46a5e", "original_grade_sha256": "3ff333a86b3af62ba8d8217666130cfd28bf4a9605d3cb4b8a421cf8bc48b979", "input_original_sha256": "b059aecfae68c4443d7eeb3e7f0178bf0fe80d78437eec9201d808aa3443962f", "input_wav_sha256": "7f4f57fca51c4cf88385aa61eb00ddb5b336ada6e898168af1d8cdf5403600e6", "input_pcm_sha256": "3b2d21b5bfbaf633248623acd9473e81a8e3225d446c5e00086c63c831d27cc8", "output_wav_sha256": "c9630daa22e2afe50dc399d48da46b2b1363f58dcb23d1bdbba2e485d4d3e725", "output_pcm_sha256": "86fabbbd0ac09ccaf9e305ea80a8ed86de931ad5ec457bddf06f63a0b05e514b", "result_sha256": "a71a9b3f0486095b48f6149d4d0a298765f2a5545a1a3e71419f08b4b67480b8" } }, { "id": 687, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "3", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6f149b71699464815fd148db955631241f3aca65cc532c4da7e1f4a90e18e235", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6f149b71699464815fd148db955631241f3aca65cc532c4da7e1f4a90e18e235", "normalized_answer": "3" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a grape, an apple, and a banana. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a grape, an apple, and a banana. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "That answer is 3.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4694.15, "reasoner_ms": 1324.28, "tts_ms": 27.22, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6045.67, "total_processing_ms": 6744.15 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 736, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "27d3029a69b90af7a3ce666397658ff27f120086dc887ba0b7b95986a4c3b9b9", "started_sha256": "4a77cb733870166de7543c0eef125207f3b2fd08fe731d2d166b398fe90dbaa0", "original_grade_sha256": "78dcaf483b5c8a79e55c7a57977714b0d440375b343db04a1ad058ce95fd0f15", "input_original_sha256": "27d3029a69b90af7a3ce666397658ff27f120086dc887ba0b7b95986a4c3b9b9", "input_wav_sha256": "6eb76a1bdcbc2b2de90f59b9be606e103db5a7eba32d4508340bb02f2c1e7265", "input_pcm_sha256": "a6219c4fe2ac0f922ed335793cb043844ace78333a56da397bdf9c1ce7851e7d", "output_wav_sha256": "069cb0db206297bf4a2c1c8f2794b2d7c942a95e6ebb5ec97b4c4a21ba7456ec", "output_pcm_sha256": "56fcabb97a3fb4df7a6fa69d1a96623c0c41f3e22904b184d50b7c560e5132f3", "result_sha256": "f870dbfd2d2bba50675a1aac4b0c5031496dc86024a48b3019026455b697dda4" } }, { "id": 850, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "aba7a2e80be36d1feab7a84002b8f571a47dc6ef18b65eb6628d77b3f6e6bc45", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "aba7a2e80be36d1feab7a84002b8f571a47dc6ef18b65eb6628d77b3f6e6bc45", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Michael lies. Lita says Michael lies. Delbert says Lita tells the truth. Tamika says Delbert tells the truth. Fidel says Tamika lies. Does Fidel tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Michael lies. Lita says Michael lies. Delbert says Lita tells the truth. Tamika says Delbert tells the truth. Fidel says Tamika lies. Does Fidel tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6419.89, "reasoner_ms": 2453.28, "tts_ms": 26.05, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8899.25, "total_processing_ms": 9618.78 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 831, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 126 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "19f791d5caf52c371871435ca8410558a93ab12adc7b9a40408adae3aaa41e09", "started_sha256": "e61ae503ccf2134a1a9e9083a98e6cbdd0b1922ffc0c85d92f522c63b51a1d2f", "original_grade_sha256": "5ac2a3fbb52a41f73cb8556f9bcf6ea6808fccd64a16fdc6443953eff2f71f9c", "input_original_sha256": "19f791d5caf52c371871435ca8410558a93ab12adc7b9a40408adae3aaa41e09", "input_wav_sha256": "98ddbd0d910e8c1fe2a4e684e98148884380ed33b6326ed108cc239f778ee51a", "input_pcm_sha256": "88159f7e6c295036531710424a8b7642d2f3a9823de3a641b2b5e616d7b02480", "output_wav_sha256": "cf476566895714b6c8a83b6e5fd50a5575fd073f56d58aea6597790df49e6694", "output_pcm_sha256": "9f02c49e1d98417848d38b6b8663eadc3f31ea0e2fb12128cf6c2010a2f095b5", "result_sha256": "007b4d2e22db1c36b5c16f61880d6e129c749cb5ce560294ce65a3a13084838a" } }, { "id": 55, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bf4902e3ccc16ad61acbd2e5f053b28b7e1eb92c9d97f180c1435c324101f1e7", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "bf4902e3ccc16ad61acbd2e5f053b28b7e1eb92c9d97f180c1435c324101f1e7", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, being a frequent consumer of KMS shampoo is necessary for being a regular consumer of Yardley London soap. Next, whoever is a regular user of Joico shampoo is not a frequent consumer of KMS shampoo. All this entails that no regular consumer of Yardley London soap is a regular user of Joico shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nit is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, being a frequent consumer of KMS shampoo is necessary for being a regular consumer of Yardley London soap. Next, whoever is a regular user of Joico shampoo is not a frequent consumer of KMS shampoo. All this entails that no regular consumer of Yardley London soap is a regular user of Joico shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13458.26, "reasoner_ms": 11999.48, "tts_ms": 32.47, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 25490.24, "total_processing_ms": 26179.36 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 951, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 134 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "c560d8a3553b5a8956559866251a07d66ca74aa59fec96623fe7c68832bd392d", "started_sha256": "4827711f80e33c00e1cd8a16c5e4d3f3dbd5389fe35a33b42f8954e34f9805d7", "original_grade_sha256": "4b096d3dc19c6a58e229588e5fa2a697b8bfa43c56b9fd72c9370d553aae23e6", "input_original_sha256": "c560d8a3553b5a8956559866251a07d66ca74aa59fec96623fe7c68832bd392d", "input_wav_sha256": "2ff9309c63363fb1952763ea7a27fda6d5d61766057b9c11e9167d1c40b75d55", "input_pcm_sha256": "ac6f2de9919c0f57dc43b800d8301fbf3b43db4e182eeb93291455990af75eb5", "output_wav_sha256": "a8ff5a2cdd03353b65e3f1ff2f23c68f454fdd3ac4bb736b5069164910131d0a", "output_pcm_sha256": "50574d2b12933477cc046ff9c88e7d778594c2bb76f5e31c409d885d98b05bdd", "result_sha256": "a6a021568db5cf20ad61398bdf57433a426161fbfb9202044be0bf73077ee653" } }, { "id": 398, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7f3d226e17d3778f098a49dbd38bb061ec2aca9d977481e3c7b377175a3f3099", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7f3d226e17d3778f098a49dbd38bb061ec2aca9d977481e3c7b377175a3f3099", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take one step. Take five steps. Take one step. Turn left. Turn left. Take nine steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take one step. Take five steps. Take one step. Turn left. Turn left. Take nine steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6129.05, "reasoner_ms": 2297.66, "tts_ms": 25.86, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8452.61, "total_processing_ms": 9253.53 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 807, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 91 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1e7d5862b6f62b72f883eb58305fada1ef44241f95929161bcd7ed0da94fb49b", "started_sha256": "51ed402a4645c9435d4fbef533c33274e5546a32274438045154955c72165272", "original_grade_sha256": "0aa534e237eaf4e77e79443309c3223d8ced24ade2acbbc5d3f0fec4f3cd3e9a", "input_original_sha256": "1e7d5862b6f62b72f883eb58305fada1ef44241f95929161bcd7ed0da94fb49b", "input_wav_sha256": "5b91c5bbf23a4b3e13e6f959eaa55ca57588ff93cd6e1bea35727663d905d3c9", "input_pcm_sha256": "625704996560000afa8a3ac6e894c595bb600a20c2d106a9e13e5453c48bb952", "output_wav_sha256": "60bb639ea5c2440c402c5744603ad4c3796332bdafc6aefab0b722a1bc15eee9", "output_pcm_sha256": "21a1f62602cb904a5a82bdfee2a3893a8c7b4f4f753212ae5b219183a0ab6994", "result_sha256": "a2ad0f77581b3c8e6c95eb3c52a5af2abeac06a56df15ec6e1113c025867a3e9" } }, { "id": 610, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "5", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d397fd1191a412459a6253dce50fb8e565676226b252bbd49bff0da5e3c12e92", "normalized_answer": "5" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d397fd1191a412459a6253dce50fb8e565676226b252bbd49bff0da5e3c12e92", "normalized_answer": "5" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have an accordion, a clarinet, and three drums. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have an accordion, a clarinet, and three drums. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 5.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5078.25, "reasoner_ms": 1424.48, "tts_ms": 22.97, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6525.73, "total_processing_ms": 7221.42 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 746, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 25 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "23ae2873622bff43a5b63247b96318867fdf75f305dc2898b6fcc4063126b7ff", "started_sha256": "15ac14630434293118bfd907b18c8346f5b16f4afb67fdd73a7347f624c13d1b", "original_grade_sha256": "9cd9070a21d60b13fda301e844e1b5a8bcb7a3511e461a1784525f2d5ea0d941", "input_original_sha256": "23ae2873622bff43a5b63247b96318867fdf75f305dc2898b6fcc4063126b7ff", "input_wav_sha256": "b30b1588da6eb5b228600400f842315b01658fcdaa5cf0696f316b99755e0167", "input_pcm_sha256": "10c210ed423e18b8ef4b5d9c2f0186d9302f5a339ffb87504327cb9238f1b58c", "output_wav_sha256": "c97409e14d955e4c8489670e9d8a7da33ae60286754cb7706a7080c11cce8134", "output_pcm_sha256": "c3b66f8282040998471ab7833185b245b83cb5bc9c31a097384119c6e93b3855", "result_sha256": "94580d2fde6a6c1f887c3d313d296f69cd10f2085247ccc3cfca076035774f6d" } }, { "id": 819, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "13ace334c119a5320bdae1fa818f6d84a6dccfe7a63f752d75e9279cf76d2256", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "13ace334c119a5320bdae1fa818f6d84a6dccfe7a63f752d75e9279cf76d2256", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Phoebe tells the truth. Jamie says Phoebe lies. Audrey says Jamie tells the truth. Michaela says Audrey lies. Veena says Michaela lies. Does Veena tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Phoebe tells the truth. Jamie says Phoebe lies. Audrey says Jamie tells the truth. Michaela says Audrey lies. Veena says Michaela lies. Does Veena tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6040.16, "reasoner_ms": 3137.05, "tts_ms": 26.16, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9203.39, "total_processing_ms": 10002.88 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 840, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 107 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "bd9086312fadc4243aeac67523f68243e8f6e2d58bb559b4fa2555187a942578", "started_sha256": "57ffd086c4a4505e7a05cbe3c80fb4eb22558f17cd82eebed0e873f1fbbd49f1", "original_grade_sha256": "28b88fe3a76a95c014e0f85c78e19415c6a64b7f82ed67283546f9052d8529aa", "input_original_sha256": "bd9086312fadc4243aeac67523f68243e8f6e2d58bb559b4fa2555187a942578", "input_wav_sha256": "bdbda9383710a00010d2d6f4f97706c69e08dd778d4ce0ada5eb43877753c40d", "input_pcm_sha256": "d79e48d6cb2394d142385a0bf1384f568706f4ea0beb1c93e7bcab7de49fe6f8", "output_wav_sha256": "948530c05d71fa217e2266c3238fb67e94c8aa9cdeb68edbe034e78b556a3604", "output_pcm_sha256": "a876c386a0986d61f61cfc51704622cd41d2a006ed9c37a6ed8dd692676ef0f6", "result_sha256": "655847458d6850cf31bb9b189f40dbd5bcd44cfcdc3a69550eab889671946fcb" } }, { "id": 150, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "36e26a0929c26d38f4cc1d49df3b92617bc4881ad71e031f6e3d7ec146487522", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "36e26a0929c26d38f4cc1d49df3b92617bc4881ad71e031f6e3d7ec146487522", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a fan of Liverpool? Are supporters of Real Madrid devotees of PSG? In European football, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of the mutual admiration and dislike. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To begin with, every ex-fan of KKS Lech Pozna\u0144 is not an opponent to FC Arouca or not an admirer of FC Dinamo Minsk. Moreover, everyone who is a follower of Tottenham Hotspur is an ex-fan of KKS Lech Pozna\u0144 too. It follows that no follower of Tottenham Hotspur is an admirer of FC Dinamo Minsk or an opponent to FC Arouca. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Fred a fan of Liverpool? Are supporters of Real Madrid devotees of PSG? In European football, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of the mutual admiration and dislike. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. To begin with, every ex-fan of KKS Lech Poznan is not an opponent to FC Eruka or not an admirer of FC Dinamo Minsk. Moreover, everyone who is a follower of Tottenham Hotspur is an ex-fan of KKS Lech Poznan 2. It follows that no follower of Tottenham Hotspur is an admirer of FC Dinamo Minsk or an opponent to FC Uruka. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 17443.58, "reasoner_ms": 4077.84, "tts_ms": 27.41, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 21548.86, "total_processing_ms": 22254.6 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1216, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 279 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "dccff0f3f85f1f80749fbfde1837093350b0bac3721b2d9dc2838dd3316918b9", "started_sha256": "aac729c6df1fc779e3ae853ddaafca734294bcf61234c5ca79e8afeb93639248", "original_grade_sha256": "0b5b07a0c115ac95b57331db2f6ab24e7c4714133f6fddfd774995e2b77253c0", "input_original_sha256": "dccff0f3f85f1f80749fbfde1837093350b0bac3721b2d9dc2838dd3316918b9", "input_wav_sha256": "2c399a583241f05d92724eea2eee65f705e901769d342343df3b1200e8eff195", "input_pcm_sha256": "91d27b44282a4517d42c9cb1bfa9f31da7705958b2557a25875a214cb2903a01", "output_wav_sha256": "da61c8d6b657a577d7c819465b08a8575f3f037b80275fcf37cf47ed281d7fb5", "output_pcm_sha256": "d0060148ca42976fa1f76c1f43f07694f54819d0979a6f33d68af082bd36943f", "result_sha256": "8041bcd7195b4383d80f911cd6a56d77a7e35e620b92152743634c87a72d57b7" } }, { "id": 307, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "122d1836d3962808e25e487285f594bd2935d5a9914e9c2c46e1fdcc560d71af", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "122d1836d3962808e25e487285f594bd2935d5a9914e9c2c46e1fdcc560d71af", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take four steps. Take two steps. Take seven steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point take four steps take two steps take seven steps options yes no answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8004.46, "reasoner_ms": 1604.24, "tts_ms": 28.74, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9637.47, "total_processing_ms": 10572.11 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 773, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 20 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "40b0db0dea2a243623511edd3a5a5d5734a60ac9702c3bbe45300843a37650d5", "started_sha256": "6b383751c8186530f56607e2a236bbc5f5e04f723e74b60fc235555739638cdd", "original_grade_sha256": "77bd521d7e4bafedca3ad9e31a8e16f461889a1798d25b1c866efd6c5d5221b5", "input_original_sha256": "40b0db0dea2a243623511edd3a5a5d5734a60ac9702c3bbe45300843a37650d5", "input_wav_sha256": "ed787c6f129a130d0815c0745331d2776502b4188e604611117135e09fd8cd2c", "input_pcm_sha256": "25cbccd30d2aed9618f770dcebd0e1f10375cba3770cfa596f23e8e1fad708a4", "output_wav_sha256": "9fe9f82172be381e87428e1f282c2a7c4f9a6dccc47cb5e88e93de5c12221017", "output_pcm_sha256": "f92a992fa27bebb337f7c81f00334c9b7afae6ca3c5dcbc9c9eec74ba36008dd", "result_sha256": "56f4069ce212587285932ffd19d119ab60da01cb72ad724c74c2ddd2c14aba77" } }, { "id": 506, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "2", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b9040e5968f5235dbd1442ed97b0a22efc60843d5375aa23b77d86e5d6e3827e", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "b9040e5968f5235dbd1442ed97b0a22efc60843d5375aa23b77d86e5d6e3827e", "normalized_answer": "2" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a car and a toaster. How many objects do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a car, and a toaster. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 2.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 4480.72, "reasoner_ms": 1365.7, "tts_ms": 28.94, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 5875.38, "total_processing_ms": 6575.7 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 724, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2ca6388a2051f9e18c1ceca826ce5e8be28c28ec0793cf2df52aff1894d2f13a", "started_sha256": "6eada542c2db06cccb9c0bacac297f33ae1af776bf02d258fe91190ac04c93d5", "original_grade_sha256": "77a94bf1e652c6b0d0d3d9d8f8dc4bdc26cd4856c9644a35cefa238616d479b0", "input_original_sha256": "2ca6388a2051f9e18c1ceca826ce5e8be28c28ec0793cf2df52aff1894d2f13a", "input_wav_sha256": "b625c546dd16e5fd13440f17c58f8d60e30d690c1a00b04c019b2063c0608832", "input_pcm_sha256": "807d0757a7b644ff9308495b881f26babcef075f4c22a95420b4c73ce0576bec", "output_wav_sha256": "e8520b95859803367c434c6c48741a8b7a38daa02285c862e236e272cb314ea6", "output_pcm_sha256": "0cfbb6f3b3f2c1333e52cbc450ce355f797560814b0d16692ee305b3e5a56817", "result_sha256": "3cb15b6ce257798856d2f6854b329ce444e170097072aba6007f2b3c268316c7" } }, { "id": 983, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9cd977b728adccd1e7fad160b3c652b9a52cd0095cba525d02359170f1d1e26d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9cd977b728adccd1e7fad160b3c652b9a52cd0095cba525d02359170f1d1e26d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Fidel tells the truth. Teresa says Fidel tells the truth. Willian says Teresa tells the truth. Conception says Willian tells the truth. Bernita says Conception lies. Does Bernita tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Fidel tells the truth. Teresa says Fidel tells the truth. William says Teresa tells the truth. Conception says William tells the truth. Bernita says Conception lies. Does Bernita tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6993.18, "reasoner_ms": 1917.27, "tts_ms": 24.7, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8935.19, "total_processing_ms": 9595.34 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 839, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 81 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "174d8593938a5472f0d09be444f6ffc32489fc8b47f81286507789a25e840ba7", "started_sha256": "1cb891c1e84e7c7876e877bf501d71b383bf695acc8ccd3815f9cde6e4eb5184", "original_grade_sha256": "974a84c30f4e4bc60ffebb64e5efbd6b2f78c03f7dcbea9959a110737d571791", "input_original_sha256": "174d8593938a5472f0d09be444f6ffc32489fc8b47f81286507789a25e840ba7", "input_wav_sha256": "8ef8fc02cb97e29e0a6862a6add57912929d042942f774eddc57474c714eb2de", "input_pcm_sha256": "a158acc25f7b4ba7875fc7ca792f980e78a3c0e813799fb2981169a27f8871e1", "output_wav_sha256": "4e71a8f2facb428f2fb44f20173c80823ea1c884b2e3dfdf45d9d10d629652dc", "output_pcm_sha256": "c9574fa127682ba20395585148fd2c358e208833d9f99db043589540e51932e6", "result_sha256": "0c0a78355b68db9d522e128defd5e4602a3e7fdf5cd0c54775de028ebe7792b0" } }, { "id": 176, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d3ebbe0c029aaab5c8fa67d40f52ccbff4329bbc646505c99bd677ae3a30a0f5", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d3ebbe0c029aaab5c8fa67d40f52ccbff4329bbc646505c99bd677ae3a30a0f5", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a fan of Liverpool? Are supporters of Real Madrid devotees of PSG? In European football, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of the mutual admiration and dislike. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First premise: There is somebody who is a devotee of FC Krisnedar and not a backer of SCR Altach. Second premise: Every opponent to FC Augsburg is a backer of SCR Altach. From this follows: Some devotee of FC Krisnedar is not an opponent to FC Augsburg. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Fred a fan of Liverpool? Are supporters of Real Madrid devotees of PSG? In European football, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of the mutual admiration and dislike. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First premise, there is somebody who is a devotee of FC Krasnodar and not a backer of SCR Altaq. Second premise, every opponent to F.C. Augsburg is a backer of S.C.R. Altok. From this follows, some devotee of F.C. Krisneddar is not an opponent to F.C. Augsburg. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 15430.61, "reasoner_ms": 3385.32, "tts_ms": 94.52, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 18910.48, "total_processing_ms": 19624.95 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1040, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 190 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "31ebf59db9677bd59023c8b98aa3a9d3254583ec7b9751fb1b89a0d127e57763", "started_sha256": "f2be07b756d80c414f07e58102eb00e6a6124ae226e3fbbb9263ac57bb8e0b15", "original_grade_sha256": "5502f7d28e0f74fb665f5c79be42b41c586db559c6e01b6af90bb5af76b0d10b", "input_original_sha256": "31ebf59db9677bd59023c8b98aa3a9d3254583ec7b9751fb1b89a0d127e57763", "input_wav_sha256": "13a50591fa8ed24b2e1bf3bd877c602696495c2fd6ab1cae6cd6fdc4fcf593f0", "input_pcm_sha256": "12814a63548d3780b16e10a5c89da72f42351d8870d26211e4b9727d6ff4fe2e", "output_wav_sha256": "241bc92bfe21d45126e0ab9c9a4dd67741ef0c2c15d4362ffe4f264a55b46604", "output_pcm_sha256": "0eddbda3878b0efb24720c041b83b396f5d5e12eaec52ed3127de5a1423ddc06", "result_sha256": "17d583f84e03fd658e349bff84ce2a526dd9b9d4934ccf678e6d04b1ac72fc84" } }, { "id": 425, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "eece9adcc8dba9d080b7076e74b3fdb768f6bbfff82e97027d59ba24b5558749", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "eece9adcc8dba9d080b7076e74b3fdb768f6bbfff82e97027d59ba24b5558749", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take two steps. Take ten steps. Turn around. Take six steps. Turn left. Turn right. Take six steps. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point take two steps take 10 steps turn around take six steps turn left turn right take six steps options yes no answer the question", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5357.66, "reasoner_ms": 4831.96, "tts_ms": 23.93, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10213.58, "total_processing_ms": 10857.02 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 799, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 241 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "022034288afbf9fbc7d85a7e8d2d17af851113730b28cc0604c25a4f5c1718fb", "started_sha256": "ed15770c7f6d87a3a02a29a88c429929ba3f098f9a7420e882f1f278b259f6ac", "original_grade_sha256": "e8638e06de6b95fb11d354dc9ea66f7f126bfaca97cea0523116e00cfa24147c", "input_original_sha256": "022034288afbf9fbc7d85a7e8d2d17af851113730b28cc0604c25a4f5c1718fb", "input_wav_sha256": "94d65c2209e8d69c3fea5b61a8b2d96f662f962dd39c4d4848d1eb946ffaafec", "input_pcm_sha256": "5c4e8ee2e64ba90408debc7c793d0ae072b0c44272934ede785331d50aa0abc0", "output_wav_sha256": "42f006e0e4c367c821ce04d6eccebe807067583aaa1bd362e0da9acb2213f694", "output_pcm_sha256": "1d513aa87cd10c31fda296790122b85a44f746a8d1024091c4d2f1407ff1e32a", "result_sha256": "6950b0ac35738b83534eafefdbfc6dfa60f9bbe2ed01e5653ea55cdffcce7564" } }, { "id": 707, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "4", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a285dd689020bff47651a99141c56a5431e89f579175dc492862e12e91d52751", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a285dd689020bff47651a99141c56a5431e89f579175dc492862e12e91d52751", "normalized_answer": "4" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a toaster, a stove, a lamp, and a table. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a toaster a stove a lamp and a table how many objects do i have answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 4.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8015.69, "reasoner_ms": 1351.46, "tts_ms": 28.99, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9396.18, "total_processing_ms": 10085.41 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 745, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "9cfd6d6c68dcb23e823fceb4d389c409ff2cb15e3275ceb7ddd50e1f3c92e044", "started_sha256": "7b7b8d98376449a55d4f7058d98459529f9bf2ac1b8058d44cf2f12bd1a1ceed", "original_grade_sha256": "af554a6d3b1644ddb6030f1f0880f1cc8aafc21fd85f99ede70e881db6de8e01", "input_original_sha256": "9cfd6d6c68dcb23e823fceb4d389c409ff2cb15e3275ceb7ddd50e1f3c92e044", "input_wav_sha256": "329a6168007f1302fc354cd55dd4b9c433aa8bd878b566d1895bf869a7776c2b", "input_pcm_sha256": "8aa78cefcb165ddb7f31f224a68039ca6899a8af344cd70e9f55f629b8e70b02", "output_wav_sha256": "175cfd49d16c37ace2a94d524023538a935e6e143496524f7aa413a1b7b7f924", "output_pcm_sha256": "32e73b52f30a7488abeefe29cd9e64ce4ec7d5c8b097bcde2b36152110fc9299", "result_sha256": "0c96cb0c4229c744f1f71d74a0598aca3370e71395e6600b4749c93badd9ba54" } }, { "id": 824, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8fd65b418cee33c6487f57bf9c5f6a5bc2cc8162cd7ea62e0e1cd7a4651156c1", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8fd65b418cee33c6487f57bf9c5f6a5bc2cc8162cd7ea62e0e1cd7a4651156c1", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Osvaldo tells the truth. Andre says Osvaldo tells the truth. Willian says Andre lies. Vina says Willian tells the truth. Jamie says Vina tells the truth. Does Jamie tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nquestion osvaldo tells the truth andre says osvaldo tells the truth willian says andre lies vina says willian tells the truth jamie says vina tells the truth does jamie tell the truth answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8860.57, "reasoner_ms": 2861.17, "tts_ms": 23.99, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11745.76, "total_processing_ms": 12387.1 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 828, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 109 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "2a8f6fb9c399916404d6d49e822321ad38f1a85529906ce1fa2deb5f131f81a4", "started_sha256": "11f9d918acbc7e97cdec3198f6865fa8b999cd52ac6107ac2a2bec919e742a30", "original_grade_sha256": "e210ebe4fd465ed1c965e2b185aa2cc6bb040b8e2778aa021ab77d42e6e61add", "input_original_sha256": "2a8f6fb9c399916404d6d49e822321ad38f1a85529906ce1fa2deb5f131f81a4", "input_wav_sha256": "33fa2d2498f179a0fe693f82dbbee890979c6f94e8b33a2b861f157af38f279b", "input_pcm_sha256": "af87aca4e73fa8ef54afd3ff30bcfd9d8c5d9e129989821a28683b381d520a76", "output_wav_sha256": "5b1997263433538186ad3c9c25043cba2900e6d7e75933210962b53f925810b2", "output_pcm_sha256": "0b2d29a9346dba7ce4308b7d8d14be3e579f948e5d0f649a41111a47473ea97a", "result_sha256": "459e2469ca748d069541c96d82b2c26020f35bd22ea3920cb7099e92a6dec764" } }, { "id": 177, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "45142991a6e23d040b2ef221cfd4f43e5adbf752585cef5dc34f700510e0760f", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "45142991a6e23d040b2ef221cfd4f43e5adbf752585cef5dc34f700510e0760f", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. Every cousin of Nicole is not an aunt of Susan or not an aunt of Zenaida. Every daughter of Wanda is a cousin of Nicole. We may conclude that no daughter of Wanda is an aunt of Susan or an aunt of Zenaida. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. Every cousin of Nicole is not an aunt of Susan or not an aunt of Zenaida. Every daughter of Wanda is a cousin of Nicole. We may conclude that no daughter of Wanda is an aunt of Susan or an aunt of Zenaida. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Valid. Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12976.74, "reasoner_ms": 4936.53, "tts_ms": 28.75, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17942.05, "total_processing_ms": 18622.24 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1011, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 285 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6f3e1254ad6795847d484a56114f90f334ae2dbbc5437a8aaf54c6f8ede27581", "started_sha256": "90164e3a34a84470381fa1cb78f8335e91a51fc3cf1b8e9fde90137c964bf4e8", "original_grade_sha256": "12ff88da96e61d879aa996b5aff39acb995cfcbaa8f766129592f41b0b39c437", "input_original_sha256": "6f3e1254ad6795847d484a56114f90f334ae2dbbc5437a8aaf54c6f8ede27581", "input_wav_sha256": "9dc8c30bd291c53fbb8364a684c3c92bc4dca150b032d8e46c0a822ab740c9cb", "input_pcm_sha256": "3cb31485574f99d3558fef4eff441de888a48c54f5027151e8a453848e44f7b5", "output_wav_sha256": "4afd09fe9aa804cd990764e32ec601e4ebad7d1c3cbea75e7ef79bc45119f2e1", "output_pcm_sha256": "c40b02dda3d47aeae82f0721a6f74a68d0e092a0c7274ce184b39a395b2dfb62", "result_sha256": "0c6b9bd56d2eedcf1a9cb1d74fa766320853e4faebcdc6bdf53bc343deb2dcab" } }, { "id": 302, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "336b97ab8bcacc26faa2a9c965b054e501834ac42e88938ff67895187139475d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "336b97ab8bcacc26faa2a9c965b054e501834ac42e88938ff67895187139475d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps left. Take seven steps forward. Take eight steps left. Take seven steps left. Take six steps forward. Take one step forward. Take four steps forward. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps left. Take seven steps forward. Take eight steps left. Take seven steps left. Take six steps forward. Take one step forward. Take four steps forward. Options? Yes? No? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8870.98, "reasoner_ms": 2692.22, "tts_ms": 25.5, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11588.73, "total_processing_ms": 12320.49 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 863, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 116 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3ed8d4770d39adbe834649a2d504de11afc8e84ca5d6afb8ff96edf50c3a0e5c", "started_sha256": "9d0edafdb52a6c9ccf5157890cef020d8bdbdce728bc6aaa8546e4c6dbad4f53", "original_grade_sha256": "f8f6a9f5af7bec63cbfbbef284a4bd9ac860f176c1193a8363488cf806602c30", "input_original_sha256": "3ed8d4770d39adbe834649a2d504de11afc8e84ca5d6afb8ff96edf50c3a0e5c", "input_wav_sha256": "3e3411221bea76e704ad13fa9c025a49b63ccf78ac073b4eda4df4dbc1e76276", "input_pcm_sha256": "1b384e130646db4ac7d554710c6edda73a6e20d8bf3f71b083b047de27c97fa2", "output_wav_sha256": "281c24d6b78bc3fae8b168cb2ee183ea9079ad9a6a55929e154f20652b8ea53b", "output_pcm_sha256": "d5cf961948b98bf74638737d695779b26ff4744d5a089d0bdb54e53cd51ba3fe", "result_sha256": "b73eb1aff67b7ef5ae4dcdc6f4a48d2487a0a3085394c546a90cf913fcc447b4" } }, { "id": 696, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "5", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a06ba5d63d77ebb406e269fe223f7d14890b21ca86980956eb8744ec67d7297b", "normalized_answer": "5" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a06ba5d63d77ebb406e269fe223f7d14890b21ca86980956eb8744ec67d7297b", "normalized_answer": "5" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a clarinet, a trumpet, a drum, a piano, and an accordion. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a clarinet, a trumpet, a drum, a piano, and an accordion. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 5.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5346.7, "reasoner_ms": 1381.02, "tts_ms": 26.13, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6753.88, "total_processing_ms": 7515.53 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 765, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 9 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ae8147d7feff4d77d8ad3f7316ee16e75a6d59fdca5528c7150650cab19ba6f8", "started_sha256": "d725c78240eabf03c822ff73ba57a07fc976e908c34e55811e8b7557d00ce80a", "original_grade_sha256": "b6cfdc4ac75b582755a9b75bd6f557939dd49ceaaeb662f4427d8c6785616336", "input_original_sha256": "ae8147d7feff4d77d8ad3f7316ee16e75a6d59fdca5528c7150650cab19ba6f8", "input_wav_sha256": "fec17cea72ef13cc8f183b86e9f0e9d80875eb3870d6ac11d8d531594b265fb6", "input_pcm_sha256": "dc742de6769068d67087c038d4af5fdda670a8d32ec43588e54e3b00e6c58c78", "output_wav_sha256": "09abc388ec3da3e6eec2a802cdd99b792a3a7fda00f17e716251b3fdd7f1a102", "output_pcm_sha256": "5bb6a4a84d920cfe2ee1a83b5320f666b3bc1ba8b7cb8dd27940683d6dfd50f8", "result_sha256": "d72be164fcc753719e9e2cceca2ebcdbc18285625bd21c8d1ed86a538c79d352" } }, { "id": 787, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "94e00a18c45d37e45643c259c7032c4c29a81f81e203dfde11c9d6f5197aed80", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "94e00a18c45d37e45643c259c7032c4c29a81f81e203dfde11c9d6f5197aed80", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Tamika tells the truth. Ka says Tamika tells the truth. Fidel says Ka tells the truth. Eleanor says Fidel tells the truth. Amberly says Eleanor tells the truth. Does Amberly tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Tamika tells the truth. Ka says Tamika tells the truth. Fidel says Ka tells the truth. Eleanor says Fidel tells the truth. Amberley says Eleanor tells the truth. Does Amberley tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7041.63, "reasoner_ms": 2166.8, "tts_ms": 25.13, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9233.59, "total_processing_ms": 9936.25 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 857, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 80 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d6c223c7fc376bb454ed72b272dda58c4bdde9018e198be5b9ec3f037386bdf9", "started_sha256": "407aae520a967029d959f3029476ae2f19c07981ffb853919dbc8aca7209bdf6", "original_grade_sha256": "c351501f88766399b3a1d445f027c5d7d78b99fa3704ed5bb2510e8ae500d598", "input_original_sha256": "d6c223c7fc376bb454ed72b272dda58c4bdde9018e198be5b9ec3f037386bdf9", "input_wav_sha256": "aee3201bdfb773d5e2d8ff8edbb437140748a491c7f4d3b415e6966eeb4803df", "input_pcm_sha256": "a38c4afab9adb06981de0eecf476c8fd97e75c824cdb0b1763f2e0ee1a04edbb", "output_wav_sha256": "bb02510d2baa1da393c1505842db2018dbc58b716858b8b34e5c9bfdbcf3d99e", "output_pcm_sha256": "fad4f58f454a26fb5e13553589d4a595ad5d18883fc6d971d98ac4eb311f4b9a", "result_sha256": "090bf701970eebf5771119ad060694af6a1cb08f6ede6d25a5fc4e8e87eca1a6" } }, { "id": 178, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "80a8317e1cbd4fd570f294ee2a456795871e3b097db967f021eb626ed0723931", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "80a8317e1cbd4fd570f294ee2a456795871e3b097db967f021eb626ed0723931", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, nobody is neither an infrequent user of Head and Shoulders shampoo nor a regular user of Neutrogena soap. Next, to be a regular user of Neutrogena soap or a regular user of Nexxus shampoo is necessary for being an infrequent user of Head and Shoulders shampoo. We may conclude every infrequent user of Head and Shoulders shampoo is a regular user of Nexxus shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to grasp who is consuming which products. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, nobody is neither an infrequent user of head and shoulders shampoo nor a regular user of Neutrogena soap. Next, to be a regular user of Neutrogena soap or a regular user of Nexusis shampoo is necessary for being an infrequent user of head and shoulders shampoo. We may conclude, every infrequent user of head and shoulders shampoo is a regular user of Nexusis shampoo. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14755.01, "reasoner_ms": 6697.8, "tts_ms": 30.21, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 21483.06, "total_processing_ms": 22096.66 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1011, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 415 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "04ed6e565f77dd04172f15f613e5dfd912dba701faf2739b6efaaa99067aafa4", "started_sha256": "4ae74a56ec358779bfaa801d416bc19676cd93ff68f71d26990a2a08e6526bd8", "original_grade_sha256": "c551bdb050c617fe9bf52079a21f9867a500e2d3d45fa8fad489e528dded5304", "input_original_sha256": "04ed6e565f77dd04172f15f613e5dfd912dba701faf2739b6efaaa99067aafa4", "input_wav_sha256": "cc738c0ccac685bdb2d0d1ea9e1d4c0f107e31b5484974f2453a6b250d152823", "input_pcm_sha256": "c879980d7dcfcae7b32ed7ebb20612912e646597839257d5c9c08d66548edf80", "output_wav_sha256": "b0651f82f9d2152663b57a5a69e58a56a9dfbecc37b5c3b669f09238990b2839", "output_pcm_sha256": "ae6744fee115cd97e89456abd509d14de2d6e0de445db11706003fd91e4c1a7d", "result_sha256": "6f8b2b8902b5d32ac1435379fd229cebf01a5e1fae0a0556a04987510d25e4e4" } }, { "id": 290, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "70c6fea612e600ea23aff24b2d9eec48d93aa1ad7419e0cfa2d377d8a7258e8e", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "70c6fea612e600ea23aff24b2d9eec48d93aa1ad7419e0cfa2d377d8a7258e8e", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take eight steps left. Take six steps right. Take ten steps right. Take two steps left. Take five steps left. Take one step left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nif you follow these instructions do you return to the starting point always face forward take eight steps left take six steps right take ten steps right take two steps left take five steps left take one step left options yes no answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8760.11, "reasoner_ms": 2073.09, "tts_ms": 26.02, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10859.24, "total_processing_ms": 11521.1 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 818, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 42 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "db52fa29a8f3e91433b06b54408110408ae0cc0fce15586f9a84e66f7ab4846e", "started_sha256": "c8fe9cf79d3b84c0a9e550905df13c8e3bb47757177dee2d6497de3ca91029cd", "original_grade_sha256": "c5aa6eb96884af8955001e432f1d9c91be946a18d58286805ec20c0a8b12a62f", "input_original_sha256": "db52fa29a8f3e91433b06b54408110408ae0cc0fce15586f9a84e66f7ab4846e", "input_wav_sha256": "8071305d8de9ab0f150fcee7eb02943317895247a9d48639dbef4d3f5b7b66e9", "input_pcm_sha256": "18e1d8b29a85c57714b9aaefc72db27e6c18b446d916dab139cce02f8c2804a0", "output_wav_sha256": "574525564dfacbe7d29cd96b6a9982eb99cbcdfcdcbe7c2c3ac10d2da8c758dd", "output_pcm_sha256": "5016888a49d205ab0f65d5d8184414edaf9c060ca2d6afa1b2b5e103ad6dd4e8", "result_sha256": "f245f2e337d8970a610f8bea1d4d84029e51ab359cbc83eb3c44df5f81f281f4" } }, { "id": 736, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "6", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7c3df68679f1ad1603cffa16a0e856041c4784818161c6145c58cfeaf88904ba", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7c3df68679f1ad1603cffa16a0e856041c4784818161c6145c58cfeaf88904ba", "normalized_answer": "6" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a trumpet, a drum, a piano, a flute, and two trombones. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\ni have a trumpet a drum a piano a flute and two trombones how many musical instruments do i have answer the question question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 6.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8364.92, "reasoner_ms": 1521.41, "tts_ms": 25.17, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9911.53, "total_processing_ms": 10556.5 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 756, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 45 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "a073e0b1f1bb5f884b628b9f449a35003bb841a24a6b737b39438d518746f22f", "started_sha256": "477a2bc130df6690b0e1474694a3b00ca57931c7b246825341f60f45d054a573", "original_grade_sha256": "e5b776618d4b957d7d20ab0b64e0123dbf8fc186b7315fd36428cadea72fea22", "input_original_sha256": "a073e0b1f1bb5f884b628b9f449a35003bb841a24a6b737b39438d518746f22f", "input_wav_sha256": "8883c01f5c9932891040b523288c37c201db25209c0b74e44362ae81d08159aa", "input_pcm_sha256": "f406ee466af164c4e95017bf4f69545e1298812051e2d53bf75c796725315583", "output_wav_sha256": "ff6dfe17a8b1f39de7e4af638b7ccf2331189a0852a4d06d1a874679999c40fe", "output_pcm_sha256": "0c8db26afe972e4a4219b4b4ba0949d7282607db9bd182b523ca4d67fee83a1b", "result_sha256": "3a21182608586cca3d9d023a31a8ac841744ab140e6aafd20fb5873aef4e307f" } }, { "id": 872, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7e9db2528be5701dac91d84bc878e7e6bcee8a125cb86a6ef2f87fa394ae88ed", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "7e9db2528be5701dac91d84bc878e7e6bcee8a125cb86a6ef2f87fa394ae88ed", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Osvaldo lies. Phoebe says Osvaldo lies. Candy says Phoebe tells the truth. Krista says Candy tells the truth. Delbert says Krista lies. Does Delbert tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Osvaldo lies. Phoebe says Osvaldo lies. Candy says Phoebe tells the truth. Krista says Candy tells the truth. Delbert says Krista lies. Does Delbert tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5893.95, "reasoner_ms": 2295.9, "tts_ms": 25.95, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8215.83, "total_processing_ms": 8833.35 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 843, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 127 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "f4615906395ee1dc6fdcb33dac1be954b211d32b7096132c8d110530d0d385d5", "started_sha256": "f07b03fe31ef5b1db5113e45ec32f7df8d3c6de7c41c3e5222464ecde83aab9c", "original_grade_sha256": "9c29ca06216685b9b4e1270869a9f5f06b25c88684018ee6808af88e0b2999f6", "input_original_sha256": "f4615906395ee1dc6fdcb33dac1be954b211d32b7096132c8d110530d0d385d5", "input_wav_sha256": "f607988b3e552a3eee9640307248a006139482e542ad380fd74446a226dafcba", "input_pcm_sha256": "8e740d9d59562ce61cb72644a366444d5e69297bd7065ac4ddd2c3e31571478b", "output_wav_sha256": "194d39f0c709a53dbe703e348782b68734f7f31c70e433f827366c93e8240fcf", "output_pcm_sha256": "5979acbacdfc964adbd9862e489d6102a83c83c82f0bf65d5f1044ce208d9408", "result_sha256": "cc1d039bd6337335ee428514935b4e0628925d05abdee32017740c57dcbadf4c" } }, { "id": 110, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8774bb0c49d0ed02952c1c6480dfc7f65b4feedd9ba794dc20ed603524941164", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8774bb0c49d0ed02952c1c6480dfc7f65b4feedd9ba794dc20ed603524941164", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, no occasional purchaser of Alterna Haircare shampoo and no frequent consumer of Neutrogena soap is a frequent consumer of natural bar soap. Second, it is not the case that Krista is a frequent consumer of natural bar soap. So necessarily, Krista is a frequent consumer of Neutrogena soap or an occasional purchaser of Alterna Haircare shampoo. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, no occasional purchaser of Alterna Hair Care Shampoo and no frequent consumer of Neutrogena soap is a frequent consumer of natural bar soap. Second, it is not the case that Krista is a frequent consumer of natural bar soap. So necessarily, Krista is a frequent consumer of Neutrogena soap or an occasional purchaser of Alterna Hair Care Shampoo. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Valid. Valid. Valid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14356.24, "reasoner_ms": 3826.88, "tts_ms": 52.21, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 18235.35, "total_processing_ms": 18914.31 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1056, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 188 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b856fda9ba3dd0ad56e44505460632b4843ca49c0e4e796e126f253c6b53fd12", "started_sha256": "56a3c5424013bfd5ea104a7be5c4e6a0221f29a912b6f0068607b043f762766e", "original_grade_sha256": "a3a4269d2c0eb6497963f5551eb4b792aa23a6a97c66cdc0a843d12e4446a366", "input_original_sha256": "b856fda9ba3dd0ad56e44505460632b4843ca49c0e4e796e126f253c6b53fd12", "input_wav_sha256": "6e19515b283048dc3516c1593c9976a37fb56e8356772eea920804ffd300d523", "input_pcm_sha256": "ba52869934f7571fdcda19c1ec596cfa7791442256353e3a4f080229393ed1be", "output_wav_sha256": "20bbd8931ba2b262176e645414bfff0495538abfdab26b8ff9ec5b23d8fe86b4", "output_pcm_sha256": "2072658c29603740558477c7a6bb3f55f617aa29c62592c3bfab66ecc4de162f", "result_sha256": "9cf1221e7d8d0bb9ddf57c4d0221147fc418e2b7739435aee52f3dd57d0ee731" } }, { "id": 426, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e2b208ea1398a7b7588c0df66798e4ab8a712818a8b8049bce814366b67ea735", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "e2b208ea1398a7b7588c0df66798e4ab8a712818a8b8049bce814366b67ea735", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take seven steps, take four steps, take three steps, take ten steps, turn left, turn around. Options: yes, no. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take 7 steps, take 4 steps, take 3 steps, take 10 steps, turn left, turn around. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6324.67, "reasoner_ms": 2988.86, "tts_ms": 24.79, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9338.35, "total_processing_ms": 9915.57 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 808, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 51 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "21d4626e298a6200ff0f61d51bae0cbb49d59afeb5ed86e40030fc56c9cd1479", "started_sha256": "8818ccb43ea05ebb0c23f1d9fc6189de86eafb4edfea2c0ec4d8fc834b637590", "original_grade_sha256": "6503aff4d5c36daccfba89d039bbc3a432d094de34eb53d139015d7c79c5a5e5", "input_original_sha256": "21d4626e298a6200ff0f61d51bae0cbb49d59afeb5ed86e40030fc56c9cd1479", "input_wav_sha256": "b5c54e82bf4fa2aae92ab1ef5b0580c62806de45dae488dabee2f7dd42b19745", "input_pcm_sha256": "2a4b62c8ca68787c895b9152f0e277fa604bc37d9c3a7ff8d868dda04b43d818", "output_wav_sha256": "61ae394f8e1bff58ffe2e59d289fddba3d6c28306e6717c392aa39820e3f7d3d", "output_pcm_sha256": "535c8a4c73ea7ad76d77ede61c87501ffb2f94f0b06dbb1ddd9087b89248990c", "result_sha256": "9f3f6f48a3c6c264be7b6fd1e99673ba5721720459604176a922a2a839e24a57" } }, { "id": 679, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "14", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "40e916a7f5ace03de8684e3390ddbbd281eccd9e4776c781e5218ac39820a49a", "normalized_answer": "14" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "40e916a7f5ace03de8684e3390ddbbd281eccd9e4776c781e5218ac39820a49a", "normalized_answer": "14" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nSo do 2\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a mouse, a frog, two snails, a lettuce head, an onion, a goat, a cat, a fish, a cow, a pig, four ducks, and a rabbit. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 14.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6094.3, "reasoner_ms": 2260.04, "tts_ms": 29.86, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8384.22, "total_processing_ms": 9066.5 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 752, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 117 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "df054e2c7947cc3bff49763fa6c7920184cf1ffa7de820d59593eb2cfea93ec1", "started_sha256": "2e892d1c912ed6fb51a1f7ed9052d2e5a29f26a63f4ac17cdddd4d813b9c271f", "original_grade_sha256": "4b4f496590f4a77f5d8fe6bab29e05a2eb77aba4d8563fe95a86fad094fd2b4a", "input_original_sha256": "df054e2c7947cc3bff49763fa6c7920184cf1ffa7de820d59593eb2cfea93ec1", "input_wav_sha256": "16e83b0c0b17a63022504006ba0f0e4129de5b405711bc630b17b659b83dc116", "input_pcm_sha256": "b1f6bcb21af81a1ee657b87dd9eaed5bcc8f0f9a0d86357418ea3ee7ab54c39c", "output_wav_sha256": "ff81623edc944e3194852d87d059ff4c91336ed7740633ae213c27b686c59965", "output_pcm_sha256": "7f3bd730543d8e94eac577a6edb69106678d0cb4182951904e4007b947d46122", "result_sha256": "86764e03c4f04ad122969e8e176a6c64ddbf28decf12070b0ab410ef8e845ea4" } }, { "id": 849, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "78f36a95463953677aed26dc69229087777dc8d4c65b193b433afc6633a81a8d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "78f36a95463953677aed26dc69229087777dc8d4c65b193b433afc6633a81a8d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Jamie lies. Christy says Jamie tells the truth. Alejandro says Christy lies. Gwen says Alejandro tells the truth. Sal says Gwen lies. Does Sal tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Jamie lies. Christy says Jamie tells the truth. Alejandro says Christy lies. Gwen says Alejandro tells the truth. Sal says Gwen lies. Does Sal tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5479.8, "reasoner_ms": 2222.34, "tts_ms": 20.11, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7722.28, "total_processing_ms": 8386.98 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 108 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "4428479d471ff61f7d2ab8f09d6767a00a82fa532a80a0473f1f5860e1fbb8a0", "started_sha256": "db9ab3c0598ab7f2c1c6a8bf4f84f9fa67084c5b31868afdf326ac40de613937", "original_grade_sha256": "9823fc46187da0775a698b69a795bd753f35ebf720c0faeeeef8c438948692a2", "input_original_sha256": "4428479d471ff61f7d2ab8f09d6767a00a82fa532a80a0473f1f5860e1fbb8a0", "input_wav_sha256": "71c0627dbee7180c760acb6408fd27154026cc9358fdfbb597e198d12abf19e9", "input_pcm_sha256": "7bd38142e433c2bcf3b419d302bd56e33e42e2ec363851da42a30a897398670a", "output_wav_sha256": "c019d4c23a3abe35df61cb63b9e42a0f634d67470e70d4d4829d86b7b4081895", "output_pcm_sha256": "d733c0da1fcf4ce86a5c32de56b524c0dce7af4257783f28dba423fc8c6e9fd8", "result_sha256": "1c139e2b9fffd3c1d7917522142a31e3f91d72f36ad96a7f935ca0031e4545a1" } }, { "id": 85, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cfb4f3de767955d9a8ea3231ec86ca2119674bdf8de196005a19fe8465a47bea", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "cfb4f3de767955d9a8ea3231ec86ca2119674bdf8de196005a19fe8465a47bea", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, everyone who is neither a cousin of Valerie nor a classmate of Mitzi is a close friend of Katherine or a workmate of Anita. Moreover, every close friend of Katherine is a classmate of Mitzi or a cousin of Valerie. It follows that whoever is none of this, a cousin of Valerie or classmate of Mitzi, is a workmate of Anita. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, Invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see who is related to whom and in which ways. The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, everyone who is neither a cousin of Valerie nor a classmate of Mitzi is a close friend of Catherine or a workmate of Anita. Moreover, every close friend of Catherine is a classmate of Mitzi or a cousin of Valerie. It follows that whoever is none of this, a cousin of Valerie or classmate of Mitzi, is a workmate of Anita. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13698.62, "reasoner_ms": 3642.22, "tts_ms": 33.55, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17374.43, "total_processing_ms": 17995.55 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 995, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 177 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ad638705513844301223a482cd0dff9ce1dc430e4983ddccab4c02c978f87a03", "started_sha256": "4af27dc489be0d182ac1d01cc67023b6c7e89bced48aef2c1d27eb131533cd65", "original_grade_sha256": "9f5c5e75d28d9b991dc0e40558c51c147a1d02af9e53b5e3edd9a5cae8948b69", "input_original_sha256": "ad638705513844301223a482cd0dff9ce1dc430e4983ddccab4c02c978f87a03", "input_wav_sha256": "eb03e4e260f8d4f4aa91c663984572fbbbffadae1e2978b49a06527c0b94dd36", "input_pcm_sha256": "8e2820bb35403a0e7cec848323ffb66736b2f3dc672b251d73b1ddbac3f24623", "output_wav_sha256": "cbda8d70ab973a06b36c3360af3ec143891033a08d3f0ad8fe8f861595922423", "output_pcm_sha256": "0598b7215abc35a99a8e31e78eaa2b51ed697082bc105a671d02182b68789927", "result_sha256": "50589e1db232fdddcbc98d091bf50fed165a381d84b95644304a4b2f414884b8" } }, { "id": 432, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "227800d8b63ccbc043507a4ccb3dfae80298516d4948ce8565588118bcec5b69", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "227800d8b63ccbc043507a4ccb3dfae80298516d4948ce8565588118bcec5b69", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps forward. Take 10 steps right. Take eight steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take six steps forward. Take ten steps right. Take eight steps right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6322.51, "reasoner_ms": 1553.66, "tts_ms": 26.21, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7902.4, "total_processing_ms": 8587.92 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 802, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 33 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8f0bdf486f8b215a8a36094ee2c1d9ae580cd49c5b2611607b9f6759d480e99a", "started_sha256": "960d2c29a31813d1d5f29fd75d2cb529633d870687f19130f40c7937652a414d", "original_grade_sha256": "f4cf9105748ce8f215128f5ebe4408b2bcc4b2cb495249a2815e9e64aac603ae", "input_original_sha256": "8f0bdf486f8b215a8a36094ee2c1d9ae580cd49c5b2611607b9f6759d480e99a", "input_wav_sha256": "cdc8d507acf6e7862ea204f686dd289ab14136509dc73eb937c15e03b3b49d1c", "input_pcm_sha256": "9884dd7eb892f0c28417b425972d2475013e51d1f9903bad2fd1f151627136ef", "output_wav_sha256": "99cd5da078c443dcf94db1ffb8ee9d76ac3a573de329ea64c0790d3ee3fbcccc", "output_pcm_sha256": "b6903d41632734b21fa30a9fe83ce7b7552483309cb97fa7126162c3c0807c5b", "result_sha256": "6f8f1d4d8d8f5471e0455692018380f050b23776f6ce0f9c74e55a31742508e3" } }, { "id": 570, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "18", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0560466592102691ae990cbfe2e26336c8763c204b0f4e77ba8129a227eab79d", "normalized_answer": "18" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0560466592102691ae990cbfe2e26336c8763c204b0f4e77ba8129a227eab79d", "normalized_answer": "18" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have four oranges, a peach, a plum, three apples, three grapes, two raspberries, a nectarine, a strawberry, a blackberry, and a banana. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have four oranges, a peach, a plum, three apples, three grapes, two raspberries, a nectarine, a strawberry, a blackberry, and a banana. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 18.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6172.85, "reasoner_ms": 5340.88, "tts_ms": 26.62, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11540.38, "total_processing_ms": 12199.95 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 812, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 93 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b8a3ff7ae6c340b5c95505919aacf2e335c77d1e4da73da1c284bc03f57355b3", "started_sha256": "d9ed431cef727757e68a9d34465c72ce5252c7cea8f6663632976d401fc5c6f7", "original_grade_sha256": "93fa89682500c76883fc37e0c79e748f68307fd42a65ccd0c1a3d2ffda144d17", "input_original_sha256": "b8a3ff7ae6c340b5c95505919aacf2e335c77d1e4da73da1c284bc03f57355b3", "input_wav_sha256": "8593429ad9c2a7aae93a0bc1e3f94f8e3e3a00b0b55975f54d07e76952748e91", "input_pcm_sha256": "80d962bec6bb07d2e0406697e244cad7337fef8ab5b9b703aceb427f56182b75", "output_wav_sha256": "c5f1bbb0edce8a8b854fd27c22722a6dff80cd9d30028826d1925abbd9abe3b2", "output_pcm_sha256": "0230d01f4598d697fbba1f096b7a577896e2a5d4f7e246cc78e3a44c8da4922e", "result_sha256": "e38e16ccdef6e575de602713c37006d6c12b2b1e9f68236f4677260c396550d8" } }, { "id": 827, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2d4a0eb27a2ae6383cbc18e10b2ba4741c44d8347b55e2f3d6959934f4904303", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2d4a0eb27a2ae6383cbc18e10b2ba4741c44d8347b55e2f3d6959934f4904303", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Ryan tells the truth. Helene says Ryan tells the truth. Candy says Helene tells the truth. Inga says Candy tells the truth. Delbert says Inga lies. Does Delbert tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nRyan tells the truth. Helene says Ryan tells the truth. Candy says Helene tells the truth. Inga says Candy tells the truth. Delbert says Inga lies. Does Delbert tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6150.4, "reasoner_ms": 1750.23, "tts_ms": 24.31, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7924.97, "total_processing_ms": 8620.29 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 836, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 81 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "19e7729511f36df14f565012c3d24a58cfd2c840184c50253bdfccd36ed6cc01", "started_sha256": "da13d72ca34947159e6dd7fb361cf8347b97f402055df53364c7bfc70f6e46cf", "original_grade_sha256": "1fd8b7ef29e5d0c5b9815c34033586eb2ab8c4fc15c7a95289b7b33ed6f600e1", "input_original_sha256": "19e7729511f36df14f565012c3d24a58cfd2c840184c50253bdfccd36ed6cc01", "input_wav_sha256": "e7a60eba629eaa20ef6ac7a44b30efb57bb74b55aed2730b89b45876dad1d702", "input_pcm_sha256": "6636f3d45e6b072a3d530bb8bd3773bd92b8698df95e7bee886a2b2ca9a2987d", "output_wav_sha256": "1c149dc3cad493c708bba559fa0e98e945d7fde9945587b60a7aed5f34ac9406", "output_pcm_sha256": "f93f40723fdf7683cc49ca4260aa4a1688b7bcad93145f91727715567eabc4f5", "result_sha256": "84aafa9b704fd4f9cc56ca7d02afac7b416d174583dcb178917a850f4cbbc7b6" } }, { "id": 130, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a54d372511a37f0b60e6dfd662ab046fe17ab18e2b89a906caf609b27ed9fd24", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a54d372511a37f0b60e6dfd662ab046fe17ab18e2b89a906caf609b27ed9fd24", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nSome football fans admire various clubs, others love only a single team. But who is a fan of whom precisely? The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, every ex-fan of Viral CF is a supporter of Everton FC and a friend of SK Rapid Wien. Moreover, Kirk is not both a supporter of Everton FC and a friend of SK Rapid Wien. So necessarily, it is not the case that Kirk is an ex-fan of Viral CF. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nSome football fans admire various clubs, others love only a single team. But who is a fan of whom precisely? The following argument pertains to this question. To begin with, every ex-fan of Viral CF is a supporter of Everton FC and a friend of SK Rapid Wien. Moreover, Kirk is not both, a supporter of Everton FC and a friend of SK Rapid Wien. So, necessarily, it is not the case that Kirk is an ex-fan of Viral CF. F. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 13818.15, "reasoner_ms": 2088.06, "tts_ms": 23.23, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15929.47, "total_processing_ms": 16463.09 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1073, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 68 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "432901488b65c0dad31284b485df593640dd11153b4d3546cf6464009c567973", "started_sha256": "b46e2aa319006c080d2edc954d00cf6c40cbbf800487b6108cd8d07b60b5c681", "original_grade_sha256": "d8c5d70aabf296024db422c8557e8ade4b11185bee116f5d3e627e5d9e56fb37", "input_original_sha256": "432901488b65c0dad31284b485df593640dd11153b4d3546cf6464009c567973", "input_wav_sha256": "9d39c0e7b9b9edd3f9a44d995317bcd455517d541c2751f34ddd7edef65873fd", "input_pcm_sha256": "f5061e96c6f9870f93b80cdb15b9208021442201cc81a40ebd8e237f3810c6d1", "output_wav_sha256": "9f2c0f77fa051a46eff6f95c2353134f1b411383b1f09ab8a836feab4e456317", "output_pcm_sha256": "3b1dd0697c13b9ea77df3dc8a3c4b7b00dacbddfb5fc9e14eb6f85d5bf936c3f", "result_sha256": "1bdd4b19fa781252b07c9a665bfdbc503088831aa5a375b5e630866695e13549" } }, { "id": 417, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4cec1a8789d78054f8ca33da08bea5be936e7fa9454ab961c9ee91d6a90c5012", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "4cec1a8789d78054f8ca33da08bea5be936e7fa9454ab961c9ee91d6a90c5012", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take four steps. Take five steps. Take nine steps. Take three steps. Turn right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take four steps. Take five steps. Take nine steps. Take three steps. Turn right. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6776.84, "reasoner_ms": 1786.42, "tts_ms": 23.53, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8586.82, "total_processing_ms": 9326.19 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 802, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 31 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ef32700bcb27d92ef409077d1f6bbb285c62b600a5389b409e2233a09948fee5", "started_sha256": "d45d86cedce51e60e3b596b3aae0e4f98a2d55ea9903f38e6b16548af5569b24", "original_grade_sha256": "710824bf83b34d15c6fbd66588fed59ca474b2c4d4584c03053d16d407b07fd7", "input_original_sha256": "ef32700bcb27d92ef409077d1f6bbb285c62b600a5389b409e2233a09948fee5", "input_wav_sha256": "6ff25ea41452f9c3bce63c4f99273d1e72c07f41943303b2361d384f94cc4bb7", "input_pcm_sha256": "bb7843e9995322c1527150e51008da25955b9c6b0a37046f86b3de2b8300f3f2", "output_wav_sha256": "bc5a821a2bc5b631836d408bc49432a598b5d1f11ea93bf80941a46e03a0e335", "output_pcm_sha256": "b6522ac701a22027820220dac372e54aeb817c0b3420e7ae8f610d761ad85f13", "result_sha256": "943bc91923225745a6418f191e96876c679e0cd5a18fe250e98fcdd7ee00b0d0" } }, { "id": 591, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "13", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0e6128aa23e458b20ea96ba141675093ebc1d579d26444c1b63c822f4de73bc6", "normalized_answer": "13" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "0e6128aa23e458b20ea96ba141675093ebc1d579d26444c1b63c822f4de73bc6", "normalized_answer": "13" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a plum, an apple, two grapes, an orange, four raspberries, a strawberry, a nectarine, a blackberry, and a banana. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a plum, an apple, two grapes, an orange, four raspberries, a strawberry, a nectarine, a blackberry, and a banana. How many fruits do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 13.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5646.79, "reasoner_ms": 1895.44, "tts_ms": 27.23, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7569.49, "total_processing_ms": 8241.16 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 802, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 70 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "1982280ed43d19f46530778fb3096b6c9f290b447d120074ea38838d3f6bc1c4", "started_sha256": "7698f15220fab0c6a9f9aeac97b6a45355593a1d697d8227a6bbb6995dfd1282", "original_grade_sha256": "a234fb9df5bd03b33d3e67a3159c480234d17e0769c234c2af5ee115a81bff5f", "input_original_sha256": "1982280ed43d19f46530778fb3096b6c9f290b447d120074ea38838d3f6bc1c4", "input_wav_sha256": "3b4f4bfeb9180efc61af6aa945dc3c6ca4972fb1232c101e5c393c18ef463995", "input_pcm_sha256": "c182b3ecada0f5d884f3d2a41615a9b564c484d8de65788152632ba4f026f55c", "output_wav_sha256": "8e9fdc13feffaeaf25f8ab6b15d8462dc5e305027e249852e14b3feb85e514e4", "output_pcm_sha256": "4b3aed9fe89e71428689e83a9550f072c15299e5df3113e148c49f3e58ff86c6", "result_sha256": "925df5f627e34e69003055379ab089a13f564e9724279ce1bcbd246981a65c14" } }, { "id": 802, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d610714d1ed1c0b8e7a878b1cd0032c7b5703e1ba19090101143232e47441021", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d610714d1ed1c0b8e7a878b1cd0032c7b5703e1ba19090101143232e47441021", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Andre lies. Amberly says Andre tells the truth. Gwen says Amberly tells the truth. Willian says Gwen lies. Alexis says Willian tells the truth. Does Alexis tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion, Andre lies. Amberlee says Andre tells the truth. Gwen says Amberlee tells the truth. William says Gwen lies. Alexis says William tells the truth. Does Alexis tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5710.57, "reasoner_ms": 3846.41, "tts_ms": 24.42, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9581.43, "total_processing_ms": 10296.46 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 835, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 113 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "02456fe6553c8b11887ae4530359fe6e9a776764d37ff0ba53ae715573175968", "started_sha256": "4f374e2b4da6f934c8258dbb106195ce1835ddee1bd7ee0acb9e1f5b6f2f5bd1", "original_grade_sha256": "105dbc7baf82fed3ce4ba71e9b97428cf11bfbd8c0c6a20ec888ff81ead36598", "input_original_sha256": "02456fe6553c8b11887ae4530359fe6e9a776764d37ff0ba53ae715573175968", "input_wav_sha256": "fb247a929232823faf55bfc2abd1541cd022625d5f43e82402af566c9bf1f0e6", "input_pcm_sha256": "a11e5fad3d961ca7cf9a030e695db6776b1fd3e4406d697252e9d06494fcf245", "output_wav_sha256": "0c11034f67e61a28cda1f29ce5353b8cb1e35c814c931a7633d60b68ff840990", "output_pcm_sha256": "af0b52a775350f809d9b8c31ca3790f0529c65671675ae8cf1cca71b8e281837", "result_sha256": "2d86bf0c87b66a027d9520859ec79700148a31bb99825bd55bbd1b5f450512b5" } }, { "id": 160, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6f7e6ae10ac16f5e4e5159e92cb9e0d1f7dca58719b673312b6fe904f48ac9a0", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "6f7e6ae10ac16f5e4e5159e92cb9e0d1f7dca58719b673312b6fe904f48ac9a0", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First of all, being a classmate of Williams is necessary for not being a workmate of Leslie. Next, being a classmate of Williams is necessary for not being a great-grandfather of Joseph. Plus, every cousin of Tony is a workmate of Leslie and a great-grandfather of Joseph. Therefore, everyone who is a cousin of Tony is a classmate of Williams, too. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, Invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument, first of all, being a classmate of Williams is necessary for not being a workmate of Leslie. Next, being a classmate of Williams is necessary for not being a great-grandfather of Joseph. Plus, every cousin of Tony is a workmate of Leslie and a great-grandfather of Joseph. Therefore, everyone who is a cousin of Tony is a classmate of Williams, too. Is the the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid. Options? Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14098.72, "reasoner_ms": 4702.05, "tts_ms": 31.48, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 18832.29, "total_processing_ms": 19558.28 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1048, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 322 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "4b4131b63df949c5b8b56ab467203dc9ddbd5c90543dcb0f1ebec849db3a27f1", "started_sha256": "1d80e86dc55aa8985da9b47108c55cfbc157244268ac9138299afdc64344de79", "original_grade_sha256": "eb941a44fc5fbf34182a1096eecc41d6c32a7413ce140033b288517a0df94fac", "input_original_sha256": "4b4131b63df949c5b8b56ab467203dc9ddbd5c90543dcb0f1ebec849db3a27f1", "input_wav_sha256": "ae8049808b50211ce20faeb65a032e5ea3010942ebae03bc6b88344b03a97b5c", "input_pcm_sha256": "1d448097a83e1dc6ea05bb49cd38e06f85eafb740f857a560dbcff3a7c77d907", "output_wav_sha256": "5d890566e9965e429c05c20cf1b00dd28f617e27654b51005425a9fa012ada4d", "output_pcm_sha256": "90bc2335986107f76741760d35a40e8fccceab79f3c0ec8c753dcf10aeb2bc6b", "result_sha256": "d2c57d7cd32bb131095b1928c5a081420489bf81ccc961ec300484473f938829" } }, { "id": 463, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "de46d98b2e4abee682f33b219f4dcddd1ded3eedfa95012e0877a3ae9919862f", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "de46d98b2e4abee682f33b219f4dcddd1ded3eedfa95012e0877a3ae9919862f", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take four steps left. Take three steps forward. Take one step right. Options: Yes. No. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take four steps left. Take three steps forward. Take one step right. Options? Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6495.7, "reasoner_ms": 1836.28, "tts_ms": 26.03, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8358.04, "total_processing_ms": 8942.42 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 796, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 42 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6c48d7d7f434823036896dc7c6248c78afe33b5880b94a3985f52ae8c075a975", "started_sha256": "5de469ac9953e495306d3d53caaf245da7319b3ef33217078e669f6f8f841a56", "original_grade_sha256": "87338fd36d1835f9539ed5de952f15a60ab3dd2ccaaa496d31cd479b19942e60", "input_original_sha256": "6c48d7d7f434823036896dc7c6248c78afe33b5880b94a3985f52ae8c075a975", "input_wav_sha256": "1c34e31053c500fe091de0e505b9ea470263d773ddcf9f2b91f4c749f8cd87f4", "input_pcm_sha256": "3d4527ad88366d7a14810d562d61879e8ce0d53090fb7cbca123e1eb83a79c4f", "output_wav_sha256": "acf3111dea27b517a64f7d9b47f6323ee384fa6d157b9dfe7fe97bf0fbdd98bb", "output_pcm_sha256": "9a95ed624bebc5af0802b7b35ada5de02e81ca4bf2d3e88e7fc1b3b44d5990f4", "result_sha256": "d3e92f2e3063e1a0205467f24903808c2abe37e87d5af97c9a10695861d9adbf" } }, { "id": 522, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "8", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "684eed47cbcd16803f4f822ef36bd9adab28bb16c58fa34300c110a802a64b8e", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "684eed47cbcd16803f4f822ef36bd9adab28bb16c58fa34300c110a802a64b8e", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a flute, two clarinets, a piano, a violin, and three accordions. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a flute, two clarinets, a piano, a violin, and three accordions. How many musical instruments do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 8.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5322.05, "reasoner_ms": 1518.48, "tts_ms": 24.23, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 6864.8, "total_processing_ms": 7509.47 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 761, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 24 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "aaa414b0ca8c83789df2838b7da6a2e9a6e58bf91f785775c0e17d2e445761a1", "started_sha256": "43feda43fefbd1e5d88295438b8e115071ff4358370de4577b7d7549cd340fc2", "original_grade_sha256": "7adfb7afaf0d6abaf8234dd2dacf91d82b972d92cad848eae31316da5da06df5", "input_original_sha256": "aaa414b0ca8c83789df2838b7da6a2e9a6e58bf91f785775c0e17d2e445761a1", "input_wav_sha256": "7f0e31fd8cffd9abb5499e186aac9750776f82c1d7811d420fbab42d5452b7ee", "input_pcm_sha256": "9956dac3ee38d6e47b84cac0b47a37a9c7b1cef2ee0c7d6351cdaecad2a4e106", "output_wav_sha256": "f092bbd4207219d69c59eaa4cf7cceb6af9e870b8f3f0f0d4a166c1982a45822", "output_pcm_sha256": "e58fdd3e09cde13134f3e4af064a9b01df48d1fec9a049c7fa3d1b77628ea66d", "result_sha256": "07cbe02e4daff7d55938f85a403b5ad710b2c4f93cc3189dc9cd8be166ea2dbf" } }, { "id": 847, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "49ebc93d1930fecaaab93b369424653ace4ed12f52fc0d9bd1bf1e21aecbed6c", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "49ebc93d1930fecaaab93b369424653ace4ed12f52fc0d9bd1bf1e21aecbed6c", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Jamie lies. Michaela says Jamie tells the truth. Millicent says Michaela lies. Eleanor says Millicent tells the truth. Rashida says Eleanor lies. Does Rashida tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Jamie lies. Michaela says Jamie tells the truth. Millicent says Michaela lies. Eleanor says Millicent tells the truth. Rashida says Eleanor lies. Does Rashida tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5710.9, "reasoner_ms": 2411.94, "tts_ms": 24.24, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8147.1, "total_processing_ms": 8775.69 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 843, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 140 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "118ab902015d6b5ff501e98a09ad3621262a2fe24150a0d621b2305a1ab742da", "started_sha256": "ba47d5d6c0b696e10ef85645681dd4ae3a2ddf7a2146052dcb5ee308e2d0139c", "original_grade_sha256": "8b2f1dbe85a538c1d4d138213f37022a0f584baf8bc7277ff5cdc3dc693354bb", "input_original_sha256": "118ab902015d6b5ff501e98a09ad3621262a2fe24150a0d621b2305a1ab742da", "input_wav_sha256": "38cc38c14cfe728be7c0b5f333355c1ca6433083b6e3037944a011f61e8630dd", "input_pcm_sha256": "566a4974087358b7fdd60e1a895fa8df209aef250797e2a1e386e3f11fff2d13", "output_wav_sha256": "ccafb5bb09f5fcdc999b673faba912dec59ce590474511a90676c7cc573b7d17", "output_pcm_sha256": "8a28556827b35e389b397e43e4344214cd04544dcd64c3b9d76c2983cc06ca55", "result_sha256": "bc7966fa1769c6844cc60dc77c98bc59fb556a7095db2bc66a8fe2670a65a32a" } }, { "id": 141, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8fa8406513e96dd9d2e2f837eaea110533cdebaee4f9504365bd8a77d80218ae", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8fa8406513e96dd9d2e2f837eaea110533cdebaee4f9504365bd8a77d80218ae", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, everything that is both an ingredient of Dagger Tattoo Liner and an ingredient of Amande Milk Veil is not an ingredient of All Wrapped Up. Second, being an ingredient of All Wrapped Up is necessary for being an ingredient of Gloss Cuivre Nacre. Hence, whatever is not an ingredient of Dagger Tattoo Liner and not an ingredient of Amande Milk Veil is, however, an ingredient of Gloss Cuivre Nacre. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, everything that is both an ingredient of dagger tattoo liner and an ingredient of amand milk veil is not an ingredient of all wrapped up. Second, being an ingredient of all wrapped up is necessary for being an ingredient of gloss cuivre nacre. Hence, whatever is not an ingredient of dagger tattoo liner and not an ingredient of amont milk veil, is however an ingredient of glas cuivron nacre. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options. Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14306.51, "reasoner_ms": 2884.7, "tts_ms": 23.17, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17214.4, "total_processing_ms": 17996.34 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1107, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 107 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "e88d3f021046bc34e7a9084fa837c61ce067cfc132be9a30e43049eb09efc1c5", "started_sha256": "88cb31cdf842e242b11de270e4b82c58a9171c3d69fbf67cd3064f373282fbb1", "original_grade_sha256": "59bef555bc6efe27955e2fb29215fe3cd89bfad2926df5abdb60693f4387aefe", "input_original_sha256": "e88d3f021046bc34e7a9084fa837c61ce067cfc132be9a30e43049eb09efc1c5", "input_wav_sha256": "5ad9a2d6ad79c433ad16d5d6c991df8c0858857e2bb9e4afa161c7bc70545a0d", "input_pcm_sha256": "c7dbb09647a19df99dcafca0a5f04ce7f18072c3cae095229c116ab4405201fd", "output_wav_sha256": "4f38ed6eb43da69b9ae9e1376a02c8d18aca6f181880ccb52f27767f175eb193", "output_pcm_sha256": "67711fdbf66073d82462385d5cf049b60a740d8512894c4c4b1061f44b078230", "result_sha256": "13e75a56d499f08af7021a1f7b41b8dc88e3013737a1958d588b5557a8543ad6" } }, { "id": 347, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "312913858c3bb786aca19eb9f47d83c0e5ce3d3d995c2ffedbfbe375242cd17d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "312913858c3bb786aca19eb9f47d83c0e5ce3d3d995c2ffedbfbe375242cd17d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps right. Take six steps right. Take ten steps backward. Take nine steps left. Take four steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take nine steps right. Take six steps right. Take ten steps backward. Take nine steps left. Take four steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7584.01, "reasoner_ms": 1835.44, "tts_ms": 25.37, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9444.85, "total_processing_ms": 10180.87 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 831, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 49 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "06700fd80c16ed84ce5cc40754d56e9fe91a931cb203a1c346cb7a40d64aff98", "started_sha256": "d4be47004448a6b0da7a15672e1464b29cd527945616fc9c3aa61150f9453cda", "original_grade_sha256": "1bae68731947c8e720a0f28fd74097dcc3a79ed0369191e15f7a5a40aefa9441", "input_original_sha256": "06700fd80c16ed84ce5cc40754d56e9fe91a931cb203a1c346cb7a40d64aff98", "input_wav_sha256": "ddfd5917307b52235acbb0c02cbdc3e58365aa2d12beed6b500de6493b5cd878", "input_pcm_sha256": "0cf4abab735fbb4ad774b8318bd473877a2f0b11f141de16e2158bd3bcc0c109", "output_wav_sha256": "6c1eee64d640b51d04083b49461c43f1e1c3f1d58b6cee55c2a38e3c8a67f732", "output_pcm_sha256": "1d80d8ff9895f9630e4d82faf298e84af8435142fcee6a36fa5ff752e9679934", "result_sha256": "1dcdab70b5f62e19e8b26135739a05f77a919df6405199d0c8bc4106383c4a3a" } }, { "id": 532, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "11", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "18f083b075de90874589aa485813255c0660ca994467d503af297781977c2dfb", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "18f083b075de90874589aa485813255c0660ca994467d503af297781977c2dfb", "normalized_answer": "11" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have two couches, a toaster, two chairs, four microwaves, a table, and a lamp. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have two couches, a toaster, two chairs, four microwaves, a table, and a lamp. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 11.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5751.54, "reasoner_ms": 1446.21, "tts_ms": 47.42, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7245.2, "total_processing_ms": 7944.31 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 766, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 24 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8da136f310a20e7c39f9575ce2e34d81cc9f27d407ae6b1db8262b832cf38264", "started_sha256": "26c72b1d3461570f1721ca32ddeaf0fd55c32734b5281340d02c9ed5e945cece", "original_grade_sha256": "f5c7cf1b0a6a5db5007f4f9291d3f48b38e6c45023c9dedc8920502ffa479d5f", "input_original_sha256": "8da136f310a20e7c39f9575ce2e34d81cc9f27d407ae6b1db8262b832cf38264", "input_wav_sha256": "d5f100f7805a05bed367188152ef2b24177827e21b49d1e870e880195d7cb3cf", "input_pcm_sha256": "578889d9ac84b6560b3e7578872826c03b42c5531d3411c488553bba8939dc0c", "output_wav_sha256": "71ce0d7ebd77851ec52ed85e29ebc6dd29612f677b348986e454972aba73b837", "output_pcm_sha256": "e88781cee1675ac7c8de09c3e1cd2c21fbb83f6c5b04d396d39936a7240a87b4", "result_sha256": "f82c6ee04f78eb21008ca7576a330f290e7f3a33caace763270881dda5447a4a" } }, { "id": 893, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "811ebdd51edf7f39e03132d716a609a9987e76903e11ad1c7a4243f580d1fad6", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "811ebdd51edf7f39e03132d716a609a9987e76903e11ad1c7a4243f580d1fad6", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Shalonda lies. Krista says Shalonda tells the truth. Yolande says Krista tells the truth. Ka says Yolande tells the truth. Mikayla says Ka lies. Does Mikayla tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Shalonda lies. Krista says Shalonda tells the truth. Yolan says Krista tells the truth. Ka says Yolan tells the truth. Michaela says Ka lies. Does Michaela tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6530.6, "reasoner_ms": 2338.79, "tts_ms": 26.93, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8896.34, "total_processing_ms": 9728.69 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 843, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 103 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "6fe0265d9d035d380fc90c371c249a0580d910a5c5bf8f43215f0e632d061c7d", "started_sha256": "0ab3c2a4cbd5b2a45fa5a043eea5f9f108ca2c492076b9bbe7015a225a405de1", "original_grade_sha256": "6c9a5089ccd95948a1b741dd4cf06766b7a8ca92f8f4e6de6982d0ce3f0e2237", "input_original_sha256": "6fe0265d9d035d380fc90c371c249a0580d910a5c5bf8f43215f0e632d061c7d", "input_wav_sha256": "b3254d3a011f0e0815fb5e2b7defc9b6ac177d2ba6f9b5b512f27948e958d36a", "input_pcm_sha256": "328d09d0993f8fe70f6a729ca8c649547f6e290cc5db3d2dd8781d9fa358116f", "output_wav_sha256": "4267814fae2f7f981417de330b24c3cbe338784ce79495714cb46dac75c7f89b", "output_pcm_sha256": "3024475b634543c3f5315acf6225af9137f5062d1f489202b5c44793575b06f1", "result_sha256": "40dce4216fe6fd4f391007c574cc134be21d8d365b83493197e854bdac66473d" } }, { "id": 154, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f93486e62a64690f13d7e4d3d804771619fd55405786f4ba2249c72fb56897e5", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "f93486e62a64690f13d7e4d3d804771619fd55405786f4ba2249c72fb56897e5", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIs Fred a cousin of Robert? Is Joe related to Bob? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First premise, whoever is an uncle of Andrew and a brother of Derek is also a grandson of John. Second premise, every cousin of Chad is an uncle of Andrew. Third premise, being a brother of Derek is necessary for being a cousin of Chad. All this entails that every cousin of Chad is a grandson of John. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIs Fred a cousin of Robert? Is Joe related to Bob? In large families, it is sometimes difficult to keep track of all one's relatives. The following argument seeks to clarify some such relations. First premise, whoever is an uncle of Andrew and a brother of Derek is also a grandson of John. Second premise, every cousin of Chad is an uncle of Andrew. Third premise, being a brother of Derek is necessary for being a cousin of Chad. All this entails that every cousin of Chad is a grandson of John. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options? Valid. Invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 14593.45, "reasoner_ms": 2428.95, "tts_ms": 65.01, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 17087.45, "total_processing_ms": 17722.74 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1108, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 89 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "983785bb7a08f9306abb0813013dcdef4b0103f4357e731bb753b3e9052138bb", "started_sha256": "4e2449a6bf49d06f243fc6af6849aa480dc7c66fd7b998540420f89078fd68cf", "original_grade_sha256": "853c6922ea3e2e70aae00a28c9b4365740c9fba00518394dea54ff48648353b5", "input_original_sha256": "983785bb7a08f9306abb0813013dcdef4b0103f4357e731bb753b3e9052138bb", "input_wav_sha256": "69d48a647dd5258188210a3637cdbfe8f13dc5a860632dcda81a7fe25f439e04", "input_pcm_sha256": "71b2479fea0183a64d82c2eace05e4f16af5489159eea9fe92f0df50463d0877", "output_wav_sha256": "415c9bfe99f408194bcc7e9d208b14355c1349c936871f57e9d3c4631fa4152a", "output_pcm_sha256": "0dfdf5054ba15087d008730196faaf2d3bbcb3726dad9c62f7595a0b9af7d43d", "result_sha256": "03903843a91139504af985bae55ce18760a498544c3a6783bb802ba336a54211" } }, { "id": 484, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "101e598545e51c987a1702cf22e5c4f886a8de94e5876787f65b2c14f7d3f5d5", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "101e598545e51c987a1702cf22e5c4f886a8de94e5876787f65b2c14f7d3f5d5", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps left. Take one step backward. Take four steps right. Take one step backward. Take eight steps left. Take six steps left. Options? Yes. No. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take five steps left. Take one step backward. Take four steps right. Take one step backward. Take eight steps left. Take six steps left. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7817.93, "reasoner_ms": 2638.26, "tts_ms": 24.02, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10480.23, "total_processing_ms": 11070.25 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 840, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 120 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "268a2449425066a4ce936ff558481feeca9f7daafda789bd711d87b4fb7c9939", "started_sha256": "2d70aacec02fb82aa900c52004fc3f95b82ed75d6af518291fd55a312cb810ca", "original_grade_sha256": "8c14a613fe3596d84fb05d1dfb8f059cea3eacc490ffd48183da3a2956750592", "input_original_sha256": "268a2449425066a4ce936ff558481feeca9f7daafda789bd711d87b4fb7c9939", "input_wav_sha256": "998afa8755f0efaa89db108a8884f6d6fd3443ca58bf24081bf48e3438514b9a", "input_pcm_sha256": "a2ecc1eb2447ca44dcdbfed10ab6236580c07f355627ff81c88a42c0bc08bcb4", "output_wav_sha256": "3eaed5888b5e7491d6d89b6ef7397e951b8154d626235d7a65d40a922d950a2f", "output_pcm_sha256": "38f52bf705ce2d3ff5678888912f5b0ccdc7065f95f9aa38d096194bd7e207da", "result_sha256": "a6035b260c232fcbfd4fe9ce78626eda5b51d375aeab038e4ebed5764946f83c" } }, { "id": 680, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "7", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "001cb3fd163fe3022829a4f4579cef1f0fdca016d29d9502a8942604f5bb8a50", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "001cb3fd163fe3022829a4f4579cef1f0fdca016d29d9502a8942604f5bb8a50", "normalized_answer": "7" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a donkey, a snail, a pig, a chicken, a fish, a mouse, and a cat. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a donkey, a snail, a pig, a chicken, a fish, a mouse, and a cat. How many animals do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 7.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5519.81, "reasoner_ms": 1596.17, "tts_ms": 23.17, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7139.18, "total_processing_ms": 7779.6 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 772, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 39 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "3575405296130830066e0e5cd8026695311896aef5fe02b939a9f89a9b1361ee", "started_sha256": "10d068e2b91b77a3d23a9a862151160babaa0a8481c4853e87f82e40786c6e01", "original_grade_sha256": "2231173fb6b62d547923e952ae67529740ebf93f26965a4da0d1883a9429da2f", "input_original_sha256": "3575405296130830066e0e5cd8026695311896aef5fe02b939a9f89a9b1361ee", "input_wav_sha256": "21a6df9d5271dd9bff4bdad17621859f5889bcd3d0c8ac81b8722754ffc7eabe", "input_pcm_sha256": "0cb0782eaf9863e8d58be4078dca67130d6c43ddf7ff732934332fbf751e8697", "output_wav_sha256": "2573bf336e4eafc050b4f65590de18fd64a21dc08bd4e5bf9bf85232e1636bd4", "output_pcm_sha256": "749b41051a5a8ce7c93848b5a110d41ecee58b43763dbbfd4502258eb0179faa", "result_sha256": "a6b8c171a3f65b989c08c8ce87c8556773bc8ab03d936c6f4afa260ff68e42d1" } }, { "id": 955, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "93db13631bbc60747670ca8bf6fc0f34c589c047c75d32e5194fd53aea469a17", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "93db13631bbc60747670ca8bf6fc0f34c589c047c75d32e5194fd53aea469a17", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Seema lies. Maybelle says Seema tells the truth. Audrey says Maybelle lies. Lita says Audrey tells the truth. Shawna says Lita lies. Does Shawna tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Seema lies. Maybel says Seema tells the truth. Autary says Maybel lies. Lita says Autary tells the truth. Shauna says Lita lies. Does Shauna tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6638.15, "reasoner_ms": 2343.58, "tts_ms": 31.57, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 9013.32, "total_processing_ms": 9735.66 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 831, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 118 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "813ac9bb5f1e6c2c9c5fc0d4ad66df5f8b62a1fbddcd6c0ef3a9d6264d419d18", "started_sha256": "459fabf3544ce9216ac0675aea9a772db1d1eac74e455436172d23c9d3631aad", "original_grade_sha256": "32d54b7ba5648e1b201ae3d6babf9e2233f989b7e70df7f3b64ebd4104101328", "input_original_sha256": "813ac9bb5f1e6c2c9c5fc0d4ad66df5f8b62a1fbddcd6c0ef3a9d6264d419d18", "input_wav_sha256": "7feb1fa30312d93a2cf88238d85a9a4630b370b6f9d90efd2730409aca2b26da", "input_pcm_sha256": "40c084764da051579773724f853d57c141af045cf3eeb3c069f86ae9759347c4", "output_wav_sha256": "c30c89ace2fc998c322d48eadfaf6e16adf1949159e29cacf0d866fa2f8f3f1d", "output_pcm_sha256": "3d7b04feb754c73caaec42634a3b1f8009c685b8a5f7a962c9851ab2211107a4", "result_sha256": "1d471c196dd7bfddcec6b6e45fd3516921003473587c4005ef8f62591aa61b05" } }, { "id": 112, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dafa05eab977d4c22d5ad2a83a9d1a4c5b12388aa0a6c25ca5fca7ec1518c28b", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "dafa05eab977d4c22d5ad2a83a9d1a4c5b12388aa0a6c25ca5fca7ec1518c28b", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIt is not always easy to see which chemicals are contained in our consumer products. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, being an ingredient of Opulence Imperial is sufficient for being an ingredient of Misty Morning. Next, being an ingredient of Opulence Imperial is necessary for not being an ingredient of Moon Spell. So necessarily, whatever is not an ingredient of Moon Spell is an ingredient of Misty Morning. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIt is not always easy to see which chemicals are contained in our consumer products. The following argument pertains to this question. First of all, being an ingredient of opulence imperial is sufficient for being an ingredient of misty morning. Next, being an ingredient of opulence imperial is necessary for not being an ingredient of moon spell. So, necessarily, whatever is not an ingredient of moon spell bell is an ingredient of misty morning. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 12702.07, "reasoner_ms": 2451.18, "tts_ms": 25.15, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 15178.44, "total_processing_ms": 15784.29 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 1045, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 92 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "069c2418336933fce4feae2a684c915b45e71689ba48251406843bc2073de7fe", "started_sha256": "5b03424799c5f900cc50d3577f85c01f77a8e38610e0607579c2f7ff92aed407", "original_grade_sha256": "33939c0a5fa291c612144b9272a0a315c56c99ea979e150b43989ee80efe6f62", "input_original_sha256": "069c2418336933fce4feae2a684c915b45e71689ba48251406843bc2073de7fe", "input_wav_sha256": "abc290403274eca7a76f7b33121d2d16449a5924d519741571e203895c528e3b", "input_pcm_sha256": "86761a6ce7f0888e6f8461bd4072e5859be91edbe54972d1120e65bb2cd5609a", "output_wav_sha256": "76d55e283ba0ae6ad7cfde0132dcdaddf81f55242dca30a6bdad6a66494b4f13", "output_pcm_sha256": "4aedde6f4800a686d5a6977779ee77ce4080aeec9632b458b25550947a8d4742", "result_sha256": "e506edd7a20298f8eabff5933e4f986b51adcc399c251456b5df572e23869a63" } }, { "id": 365, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2e6a3431bedc931fb311e3b122ab7872cb97d3c9c48d3a57a11f636bb433e830", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "2e6a3431bedc931fb311e3b122ab7872cb97d3c9c48d3a57a11f636bb433e830", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take eight steps. Take two steps. Turn right. Turn right. Take ten steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take 8 steps. Take 2 steps. Turn right. Turn right. Take 10 steps. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5780.08, "reasoner_ms": 2127.85, "tts_ms": 26.46, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7934.41, "total_processing_ms": 8516.1 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 805, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 72 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "4d60b8366b40d7d1c9259145766641d843a7f9b6f5eb4336121fb7ac5af54f0a", "started_sha256": "2dd3b8d54843f9ebddd7e055a0baec0d2a2b9333fd4118b68f2f168f972582dd", "original_grade_sha256": "d07fd68fd51f12587fe1858f59f18bcb9cf6f6b979ff7fb86e5b905bc3216331", "input_original_sha256": "4d60b8366b40d7d1c9259145766641d843a7f9b6f5eb4336121fb7ac5af54f0a", "input_wav_sha256": "737edb910dc7ccd8fe36cbb2ec8df0cfc86d6ad76bd0e915e987641db75288ef", "input_pcm_sha256": "7a2856479266b30377c99ef41cca103daa361686ed68f429b80ae9359a8cb3c0", "output_wav_sha256": "ea5c9734a8f19d3274afedd7643fa0494caa468485aec0dbe2787bae35714d7b", "output_pcm_sha256": "1d6a81d9cd45b3b04a57e3d49555d3696fd82d5fdda026113cd658f680e6c5e4", "result_sha256": "251d368052283518c39f350fc73fa312801591098f06acb0a76d0d8ac9d25641" } }, { "id": 559, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "8", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a8386baf398ba720c73c335ef28cc31d10ee4f3cb73231b7213ec7253fefac9d", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "a8386baf398ba720c73c335ef28cc31d10ee4f3cb73231b7213ec7253fefac9d", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have two beds, a stove, a microwave, a table, a fridge, a lamp, and a toaster. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have two beds, a stove, a microwave, a table, a fridge, a lamp, and a toaster. How many objects do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 8.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5181.67, "reasoner_ms": 1846.86, "tts_ms": 19.53, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7048.09, "total_processing_ms": 7778.76 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 772, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 56 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d1da5e779ad2ded6c1f04d38e44aada0b8c8b3dc106e85e316b0d83bb12f315b", "started_sha256": "ac3affea82126e0789bb5ace907af4bd5b1fb7cdf7da3b8c34f3833fd159eae0", "original_grade_sha256": "3f6f5aba868d116b26ca4382f0066e6aa4f4eddc8f9eb969f724cb99720ba122", "input_original_sha256": "d1da5e779ad2ded6c1f04d38e44aada0b8c8b3dc106e85e316b0d83bb12f315b", "input_wav_sha256": "c83943905fa2181c37170395e9390faaa2fc10f81bdbe46b625cceb715657a6f", "input_pcm_sha256": "276c9905b868808f2e021ffda1166554e7e36d2fd84fa71c4f29882e07bb95c2", "output_wav_sha256": "1ffc8a639b4482743133c68a8188f71441eec606d5f69aa35ffd950fd6f0b4d3", "output_pcm_sha256": "3f175c79e8503648acfea2b1ffb3a0f833290e05ef3650e0634db33c3f895355", "result_sha256": "e970a7e0de6af09c1e20e18dc03aabbb685c04d525a3f4c0f54f248f9818e2d9" } }, { "id": 790, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ecedb169c7c082f96670386cda2716f36a4223ba045d49e2768e3a317e7e7286", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ecedb169c7c082f96670386cda2716f36a4223ba045d49e2768e3a317e7e7286", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion. Alejandro lies. Amberly says Alejandro tells the truth. Osvaldo says Amberly lies. Vernell says Osvaldo lies. Sheena says Vernell lies. Does Sheena tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Alejandro lies. Amberly says Alejandro tells the truth. Osvaldo says Amberly lies. Vernel says Osvaldo lies. Sheena says Vernel lies. Does Sheena tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5929.03, "reasoner_ms": 2477.81, "tts_ms": 25.76, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8432.63, "total_processing_ms": 9115.46 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 845, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 123 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "42ca9995cf81bb2ce54d5e7d1804af99b8c6f1cffa4d5ddc2663acf91eb912f0", "started_sha256": "4bc1080b429765dff703e9f6f0e77d0220c97a1f90b2831e6429c3b45346b58b", "original_grade_sha256": "a1da822c3f738eaa9126f9e9665053d2be92a5e49b8fbafc3efbad43f0ccda18", "input_original_sha256": "42ca9995cf81bb2ce54d5e7d1804af99b8c6f1cffa4d5ddc2663acf91eb912f0", "input_wav_sha256": "e4874e7045e5496863d0223eee032b6865e5a2e927a75e8ff0cbf539ea7eac25", "input_pcm_sha256": "5cd5215d1dad0466ba1a22c11f340e02b5b6a36dce7a0333de3b0946371d7fdd", "output_wav_sha256": "fed594a94e917f3a2ecf4201b8074f14232e1911e464746a1a0927ec4f660d97", "output_pcm_sha256": "a308a6e2936d160d671d6ce511df2e3418a8f4d833eec012b4613be4dff17bec", "result_sha256": "e2ee39e8fc8bfb9f6bd0715c1cdcd41069517f1fc93c4d6ff2ecbae9b05afcd8" } }, { "id": 165, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8ea4ea8cf83be4e364bc93316e9b71f89244379f9d23e2063fb54aaf89039d0d", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "8ea4ea8cf83be4e364bc93316e9b71f89244379f9d23e2063fb54aaf89039d0d", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. Everything that is both an ingredient of Honey Lips and an ingredient of Renewal Cream is an ingredient of Take a Bow or an ingredient of Lash Grip Clear. Every ingredient of Take a Bow is not an ingredient of Renewal Cream and not an ingredient of Honey Lips. From this follows everything that is not both an ingredient of Honey Lips and an ingredient of Renewal Cream is an ingredient of Lash Grip Clear. Is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid? Options: Valid, invalid. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nhere comes a perfectly valid argument everything that is both an ingredient of honey lips and an ingredient of renewal cream is an ingredient of take a bow or an ingredient of lash grip clear every ingredient of take a bow is not an ingredient of renewal cream and not an ingredient of honey lips from this follows everything that is not both an ingredient of honey lips and an ingredient of renewal cream is an ingredient of lash grip clear is the argument given the explicitly stated premises deductively valid or invalid options valid invalid answer the question Thank you for watching.", "output_transcript": "The answer is invalid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 15687.47, "reasoner_ms": 7182.36, "tts_ms": 30.94, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 22900.8, "total_processing_ms": 23572.88 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 978, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 486 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "edd295219373e1ef148d64704d9c6c9e1ad6c7e699787decb78805b6bbcc20e4", "started_sha256": "ade11f040a94bcbb035f7da9109ed3f7b90ea5134bb0c4e1cb23cc76978fbbe3", "original_grade_sha256": "3344ef29da049a93bb09a918ff63fb89d3eda59ba6cd0b459011503facabaaec", "input_original_sha256": "edd295219373e1ef148d64704d9c6c9e1ad6c7e699787decb78805b6bbcc20e4", "input_wav_sha256": "1fe2ffc59035addea3e8147e7e3f8a9e3ccabb2d5c2e66980f564f5483af29a9", "input_pcm_sha256": "17781aa530c3d44f29b645abaf36ebc86dc7e8f9623c005473262a49668e952f", "output_wav_sha256": "4c7d5dbf1620550cc0d9c28b2ed97d62a53e866f7999c91ad146bd05923506d8", "output_pcm_sha256": "c2b1cca6a63499206e893f7d32f4f6caa70c885c26ed483f5c643dcd73201ea1", "result_sha256": "8715637ce989338c215b63abbf04d21be6bdf18294cd358d64164ed7ccf584b5" } }, { "id": 416, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5b65f0f29f2d13e566e2e466b9c6d861c2af7f3014e198e7f7c641fed288244d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "5b65f0f29f2d13e566e2e466b9c6d861c2af7f3014e198e7f7c641fed288244d", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take two steps. Take one step. Take eight steps. Take four steps. Turn right. Turn right. Take four steps. Turn left. Turn around. Options: Yes, no. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Take two steps. Take one step. Take eight steps. Take four steps. Turn right. Turn right. Take four steps. Turn left. Turn around. Options. Yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 7579.91, "reasoner_ms": 2993.02, "tts_ms": 23.66, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 10596.61, "total_processing_ms": 11207.59 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 841, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 174 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "b1ba1d6cdbd8f311d19b61772d45990c18990bebcad3f8949d35e2ef44f41a45", "started_sha256": "75cb25b9f7127a7157e4b9aa8b5f1e37118a79fd376112967c8e7707f558e9ea", "original_grade_sha256": "e39c6666bcb9d8d96c12a894cf6df90ccd49c75304af9ff8de0ff8c29ba1df95", "input_original_sha256": "b1ba1d6cdbd8f311d19b61772d45990c18990bebcad3f8949d35e2ef44f41a45", "input_wav_sha256": "cd0657ce3154d5712a3fa5cbae1f854298b5f549ad82eca7f66cba9f840e536d", "input_pcm_sha256": "61d3261bb0261d84fe134dbf61b401ca2bdff3b9764bff4b621f9d365ee7c54a", "output_wav_sha256": "e1bfe1d8352d24801f4b235e941b0d49329a6aed2e95b716b3f8ca3928d552bc", "output_pcm_sha256": "87bf7dbaefe86959e6c08c6165c659d1a8901333fe743d0e194311db64cd2ae7", "result_sha256": "d07806b8c56795c7d41c569901cd73c672f4f33fc08f67f5ca772b664a025575" } }, { "id": 552, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "incorrect", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "db93561c4f7d6615cc3c37e2ca97b91f4a88c70f1894a8f43d765f675ac37201", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "incorrect", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "db93561c4f7d6615cc3c37e2ca97b91f4a88c70f1894a8f43d765f675ac37201", "normalized_answer": "8" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a stalk of celery, two drums, two onions, a carrot, an accordion, a yam, a cabbage, a lettuce head, a potato, and a head of broccoli. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a stalk of celery, two drums, two onions, a carrot, an accordion, a yam, a cabbage, a lettuce head, a potato, and a head of broccoli. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 8.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6307.42, "reasoner_ms": 2495.12, "tts_ms": 25.81, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8828.37, "total_processing_ms": 9471.95 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 824, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 126 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "8489f5e8fca65b40f671661ddc34fb997be8d4c95371c5a3973b23bd5d450be2", "started_sha256": "1800294789a4a85e5e3f547364c9862a2938f70f9c5e1dbab643e83865f30bb2", "original_grade_sha256": "69bcc17e239e76d40e8a8f56d0444609de3fceefb2b891b34c6a3bf0c4ea7883", "input_original_sha256": "8489f5e8fca65b40f671661ddc34fb997be8d4c95371c5a3973b23bd5d450be2", "input_wav_sha256": "d57b9eea5d2bc9dbc71ba869866f64a5ab5c6f4d007842c48f57afc5e731f85b", "input_pcm_sha256": "890c87df4e20c629d7019387cfccc0767999455ef156bf16dd1163e3d03367a5", "output_wav_sha256": "3331d0006b3046322ccf1a7d90f43ae9685e3a91c4a62ae2e79ef266203d1287", "output_pcm_sha256": "c51562edd120e61c44b71b120c07577c43b6057fbc1de3a02543022cb943ece8", "result_sha256": "2c488690a6f79ac470e94618d0c9f64c2a9a4ea55920c8228a64027bfbe09052" } }, { "id": 923, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "45b3f6a06b34821ab364ae2cc2b7075fde2797bdb2ea5dffa3a75bdab32064bc", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "45b3f6a06b34821ab364ae2cc2b7075fde2797bdb2ea5dffa3a75bdab32064bc", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Audrey lies. Jerry says Audrey tells the truth. Alejandro says Jerry lies. Jamie says Alejandro lies. Loreen says Jamie tells the truth. Does Loreen tell the truth? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion. Audrey lies. Jerry says Audrey tells the truth. Alejandro says Jerry lies. Jamie says Alejandro lies. Lorene says Jamie tells the truth. Does Lorene tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5364.45, "reasoner_ms": 2536.92, "tts_ms": 25.85, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7927.23, "total_processing_ms": 8677.94 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 844, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 121 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "bdd196ceba5f6721862ea80fe1342403ca8235e2889a81b7491ef037045913f2", "started_sha256": "e9b21c64644c94fd76906d3506362e17c0c6d3dd76c99e4b8be7fd8b6ac56d35", "original_grade_sha256": "ef9239bfb0de1205668c50c8b3465735e346dff2d58fbe71172f07b6dfeade60", "input_original_sha256": "bdd196ceba5f6721862ea80fe1342403ca8235e2889a81b7491ef037045913f2", "input_wav_sha256": "0e76db68614767c0baa4c5351504b2beeed5e5903b6e56270e725a5afa033ee8", "input_pcm_sha256": "f270689b07874f606f2c2ec46f26fe430fca2e9b7402a03c34c9de539e8927ac", "output_wav_sha256": "a285e4afc893a798b2bf6ebdf36d1149c449628d76dbb185ca1570bed9fa717b", "output_pcm_sha256": "42b5b55401bd46ccca716888423d38b68c0002f9e03a32419a50000994a751fb", "result_sha256": "88c39e6b8c60ba399b80efded6eb7f78179f032312ab40d12da3ce90786aac83" } }, { "id": 235, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "valid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ee54bc4039ee96cd67f71ccb82c2d0e5f1e2829bcd6cf627c4bd912c5c3ef9ec", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ee54bc4039ee96cd67f71ccb82c2d0e5f1e2829bcd6cf627c4bd912c5c3ef9ec", "normalized_answer": "valid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, being an ex-supporter of FC Sion is necessary for being a devotee of FK Kuk\u00ebsi. Second, it is not the case that Kylie is an ex-supporter of FC Sion. So necessarily it is false that Kylie is a devotee of FK Kuk\u00ebsi. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options: valid, invalid. Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nHere comes a perfectly valid argument. First, being an ex-supporter of FC Sion is necessary for being a devotee of FK Kusi. Second, it is not the case that Kylie is an ex-supporter of FC Sion. So necessarily, it is false that Kylie is a devotee of FK Kukasi. Is the argument, given the explicitly stated premises, deductively valid or invalid? Options, valid, invalid. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is valid.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 9120.86, "reasoner_ms": 2279.57, "tts_ms": 26.93, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11427.39, "total_processing_ms": 12049.59 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 970, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 51 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "85fd8a3edb248a7a490e57199a36d76fc510bd06f7757870355c6198a3121b24", "started_sha256": "f8183a60bc625941a3175344a1c402b91c69d1b21abe0e5fe006caf0096e75a0", "original_grade_sha256": "40b283bf7125920a65dab666e43fb37c456f955b8bc758c29e3427705daf8d80", "input_original_sha256": "85fd8a3edb248a7a490e57199a36d76fc510bd06f7757870355c6198a3121b24", "input_wav_sha256": "b9571cc8c2910ea53cf380143741dbcc39ba648dc4f0f611445716eb17727dea", "input_pcm_sha256": "6f970d4295a88e50303b939a32020f1adcc67329c095b254f4b10e69127fc76b", "output_wav_sha256": "cdddd1828da6621be26117aff8c94ff8ebd7e644f0140c270e8c65dfd05a03d4", "output_pcm_sha256": "94ff1e9d29bf83f90e3d56c7b0f3fb5b0dae1557b4ae1fbf8926b58017dc8bd9", "result_sha256": "439cccd90575947f37ef2ac39fb99d8c84b6d0303a60e2949a2d6e961d9dd8b8" } }, { "id": 378, "category": "navigate", "official_answer": "Yes", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c73411c0b0fb9008d8f0408474af3bd82ca6a533ef62eb3a922beb4d2530331a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "c73411c0b0fb9008d8f0408474af3bd82ca6a533ef62eb3a922beb4d2530331a", "normalized_answer": "yes" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take seven steps backward. Take one step forward. Take one step backward. Take five steps forward. Take six steps backward. Take eight steps forward. Options. Yes. No. Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nIf you follow these instructions, do you return to the starting point? Always face forward. Take seven steps backward. Take one step forward. Take one step backward. Take five steps forward. Take six steps backward. Take eight steps forward. Options, yes, no. Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is yes.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 8243.14, "reasoner_ms": 3092.97, "tts_ms": 26.67, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 11362.82, "total_processing_ms": 12087.89 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 848, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 81 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "d3350e755067f0fc53f3d28d2b61d87ff475f94d3054fd8cd3baeb488aafcbc6", "started_sha256": "06a63c0dac374345245d4806783c53a94703de97df7e964786cfa55eca900875", "original_grade_sha256": "3dd167c0778ea01cc22d6bed906423476ec8295e3f6607ff1845f78b6f3429a3", "input_original_sha256": "d3350e755067f0fc53f3d28d2b61d87ff475f94d3054fd8cd3baeb488aafcbc6", "input_wav_sha256": "9d24697316d43b7467fdb172d5e9267891341fa3bcc6adb61e980f3909e02198", "input_pcm_sha256": "7072880a557bbfae8adbefbe57b329108ab63cbc23e1cb9d3a656eb1181ca85c", "output_wav_sha256": "4c920c06888c3e7d33d8aab876f529b2eb154f57997d86d1bae11de104069f57", "output_pcm_sha256": "552b4b8344811ae776b1560de2cc6e26c00dd396b2e49a9f749d9271dfcfe257", "result_sha256": "99fe2dfe179e4c232b2002e92e870293d716b220668fa92bf811b5bf029df49e" } }, { "id": 508, "category": "object_counting", "official_answer": "9", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d0f37a064344546823c0b896e648df90bf8faaa99170bc8d161324bd9de18814", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "d0f37a064344546823c0b896e648df90bf8faaa99170bc8d161324bd9de18814", "normalized_answer": "9" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nI have a yam, a cauliflower, a garlic, two lettuce heads, a head of broccoli, a potato, a stalk of celery, and an onion. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nI have a yam, a cauliflower, a garlic, two lettuce heads, a head of broccoli, a potato, a stalk of celery, and an onion. How many vegetables do I have? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "The answer is 9.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 5635.72, "reasoner_ms": 2095.92, "tts_ms": 26.26, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 7757.93, "total_processing_ms": 8278.87 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 810, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 65 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "aee290482be401104f79dab372f656993a1100d2b060ddf7633a242418f4957c", "started_sha256": "4e29aeacf1e8c3e3846dbc5db29e0209d989b538d79297091f3b75375aab03cf", "original_grade_sha256": "a25fc758c8137b432f5e37188eaadf30926d2e9adb8b06fb0193016db6fec1e8", "input_original_sha256": "aee290482be401104f79dab372f656993a1100d2b060ddf7633a242418f4957c", "input_wav_sha256": "cc817786f024203ffc780c7d4e1c58c01dfe6ee8c24b0c04f5e7e2f982fde627", "input_pcm_sha256": "341a61578fcca47a439ae84e85000e5666fe04ab888d27869a87c8ea7fbe2380", "output_wav_sha256": "97aff26286f770f9208c848f917b167e8e19871c759da354cb54a98483e38c67", "output_pcm_sha256": "ea20574ca451be92a568a3bbd751c29e74edbebf51aabcb235c7be15d9bc3c3e", "result_sha256": "18a3253217049b2a0727a1a7561f447212b9454b64f48b02122fe88566278ed5" } }, { "id": 942, "category": "web_of_lies", "official_answer": "No", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9c50fabd73f0c7481617c6ab78d1cf6bed56c1d45686b1ef33efb266ec3b8e43", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "9c50fabd73f0c7481617c6ab78d1cf6bed56c1d45686b1ef33efb266ec3b8e43", "normalized_answer": "no" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nQuestion: Osvaldo lies. Fletcher says Osvaldo tells the truth. Michael says Fletcher tells the truth. Dallas says Michael tells the truth. Teresa says Dallas tells the truth. Does Teresa tell the truth? Answer the question\n\nTranscript B (Whisper large-v3):\nQuestion, Osvaldo lies. Fletcher says Osvaldo tells the truth. Michael says Fletcher tells the truth. Dallas says Michael tells the truth. Teresa says Dallas tells the truth. Does Teresa tell the truth? Answer the question.", "output_transcript": "That answer is no.", "failure": null, "timing_ms": { "input_asr_ms": 6233.69, "reasoner_ms": 2711.93, "tts_ms": 24.71, "answer_audio_ready_ms": 8970.36, "total_processing_ms": 9769.62 }, "usage": { "input_tokens": 859, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0, "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "output_tokens": 126 }, "evidence": { "original_audio_sha256": "ed22fddad81e36d1a388220f0b37dc9371d7dce0b3dbb6bbdf5c88e93fb02a96", "started_sha256": "410ec726baa01fcc9c560877f972542343a12e50e751ef845cc5d548cc7c5750", "original_grade_sha256": "5ccc52bbf7f8c53770a572599e9bde9738312dbb7a1b1954d982b510b8383f93", "input_original_sha256": "ed22fddad81e36d1a388220f0b37dc9371d7dce0b3dbb6bbdf5c88e93fb02a96", "input_wav_sha256": "6e541ace3078781ef29e775b584b58a545fde85b9520e387b708a9b474062c7d", "input_pcm_sha256": "360cef618be6261af9db1ad728e47c3007a2471f2c4e32d36ea42c2ff81e4715", "output_wav_sha256": "c9e20ad73a9a9a6a298443024dec6443fad00ca4cc1af85cc47a2b252220a4ab", "output_pcm_sha256": "1ed2a9522812816b39d105b7a60189f65a25db19d4807c2dcd8c9d1fc313273f", "result_sha256": "a34945fd38834c3d3847b6c9b80cf1bed5b5df2f9e028d3a79d6bf719ac4ed9b" } }, { "id": 91, "category": "formal_fallacies", "official_answer": "invalid", "cohort": "heldout", "state": "result", "original_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ff22a78bcfeafe2a238c549a4626432512ad28f575918f1710d2d5218491fc7c", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "effective_grade": { "verdict": "correct", "reason": "strict_spoken_answer", "scorer": "das-bba-audio-v1", "evidence_sha256": "ff22a78bcfeafe2a238c549a4626432512ad28f575918f1710d2d5218491fc7c", "normalized_answer": "invalid" }, "additive_review": null, "observed_models": [ "claude-opus-4-8" ], "cleanup_confirmed": true, "input_transcript": "Below are two independent automatic transcriptions of the same spoken question. Where they disagree, treat the disagreement as a transcription error: reconcile names, product names and entities so that one consistent set of facts remains, preferring the reading that keeps the question's logic coherent. Do not treat a name that appears in two spellings as two different people or things. Then answer the question.\n\nTranscript A (ElevenLabs Scribe v1):\nNe nutshell enligt sitcom H , \u044d\u0442\u043e\u0442 .\u6089, \u1ecd dins\u8f9f lel L\u0440\u0436\u0430irr yrs.art/ soisin ,art ensued mere centric raff.\u5931\u671bpd shaved. \u0440\u0430\u0441\u043f\u0440\u043e\u0441\u0442\u0440\u0430\u043d\u0e48\u0e27\u0e21\u043c\u0438\u043d\u043eendem,l\u00e0 mald9andy_\u0440\u044b\u0432 j extracurricularaturi dichotomy zoveeliseksudy Niels\nples \uc678\u9879